Your Retirement Planning Simplified

Episode 220 explains sequence of returns risk and mitigation strategies for retirement withdrawals

15 min Listen to the original Episode page
Retirement PlanningSequence of Returns RiskAsset AllocationRisk ManagementWithdrawal Strategies

Summary

Joe Curry defines sequence of returns risk as the primary danger for retirees, occurring when market downturns coincide with the withdrawal phase. He illustrates how selling assets during a decline locks in losses, requiring more units to be sold to generate the same income. Using a numerical example, he shows that identical average returns can lead to vastly different final portfolio values depending on the timing of gains and losses. To mitigate this, he recommends an income floor for essential expenses and a defense bucket of short-term safe assets to avoid forced selling. He also discusses flexible withdrawal plans but warns against hiding entirely in cash due to inflation and longevity risks.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    Sequence of returns risk is located in the 'retirement danger zone,' defined as the years just before and just after stopping work.

    Joe Curry · 1:24

  2. 2
    A defense bucket is described as 'flexibility insurance,' allowing investors to spend from safe money while markets recover, avoiding forced sales at the worst time.

    Joe Curry · 8:47

Episode sections

  1. 0:30 – 2:43

    Introduction and Sequence of Returns Risk

    Joe Curry introduces the fear of market downturns occurring at retirement and defines sequence of returns risk as the primary danger in the years surrounding retirement. He notes that while return order matters little during accumulation, it becomes critical during withdrawal.

  2. 2:43 – 4:01

    Working Years vs. Retirement Withdrawals

    The speaker explains that during working years, market drops allow buying at lower prices with time to recover. In retirement, selling during a downturn locks in losses because more units must be sold to generate the same income.

  3. 4:01 – 8:05

    Numerical Example of Sequence Risk

    Joe presents a four-year example of two investors with $500,000 starting capital and $25,000 annual withdrawals. Despite identical average returns, the investor facing negative returns early ends with significantly less capital than the one facing negative returns later.

  4. 8:05 – 9:34

    Mitigation Strategies: Income Floor and Defense Bucket

    The speaker recommends an income floor for essential expenses and a defense bucket of short-term safe money to avoid forced selling during market downturns. He suggests using tools like bond ladders or CPP bridges to cover the first five years of retirement.

  5. 9:34 – 14:30

    Flexible Withdrawal Plans and Risk Trade-offs

    Joe discusses flexible withdrawal plans that pre-define spending cuts during rough patches. He warns against hiding in cash, as that trades sequence risk for inflation, longevity, and interest rate risks.

Claims worth verifying

Retiring in late 2021 or 2022 meant stocks and bonds fell together.

Joe Curry ·2:03

How to verify: Check S&P 500 and Bloomberg Aggregate Bond Index performance data for 2026-2026; verify retirement age demographics for those years. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Two people with $500,000 starting capital and $25,000 annual withdrawals, earning the same average return over four years, end up with different balances if the order of returns differs.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·4:40

How to verify: Recreate the arithmetic: Person A (-20%, -10%, +10%, +20%) vs Person B (+20%, +10%, -10%, -20%) with $25k withdrawals; compare final balances. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The first person in the example finished year four with $357,500.

Joe Curry ·6:37

How to verify: Verify the calculation: Start $500k -> -20% = $400k -> -$25k = $375k -> -10% = $337.5k -> -$25k = $312.5k -> +10% = $343.75k -> -$25k = $318.75k -> +20% = $382.5k -> -$25k = $357.5k. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The second person in the example finished year four with $392,400.

Joe Curry ·6:37

How to verify: Verify the calculation: Start $500k -> +20% = $600k -> -$25k = $575k -> +10% = $632.5k -> -$25k = $607.5k -> -10% = $546.75k -> -$25k = $521.75k -> -20% = $417.4k -> -$25k = $392.4k. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The retirement danger zone consists of the years just before and just after you stop working.

Joe Curry ·1:24

How to verify: This is a definition provided by the speaker; verify by checking the transcript text at 1:24. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Hiding everything in cash trades sequence of returns risk for longevity risk, inflation risk, and interest rate risk.

Joe Curry ·10:42

How to verify: This is a financial theory claim; verify against standard retirement planning literature (e.g., Trinity Study) regarding real returns of cash vs. equities. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify the numerical example by calculating the compound annual growth rate and withdrawal impact for a $500k portfolio with $25k annual withdrawals under different return sequences.
  • Review historical market data for the late 2021-2022 period to confirm simultaneous declines in stocks and bonds as cited.
  • Research bond ladder construction and CPP bridge strategies to evaluate their suitability for covering the first five years of retirement.
  • Analyze the inflation-adjusted real returns of cash holdings versus equities over long time horizons to assess the risk of hiding in cash.
  • Check personal asset allocation for a defined 'defense bucket' of short-term safe assets to ensure it covers essential expenses without forced selling.
  • Review flexible withdrawal plan guidelines to understand how spending cuts are pre-defined during market downturns.
Full transcriptexpand

0:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Welcome to the only show that simplifies the complicated world of retirement planning while embracing life beyond the numbers.

0:10Joe Curry: Expect clear insights,

0:11Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): accessible tools,

0:12Joe Curry: expert interviews,

0:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and

0:13Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): actionable advice.

0:15Joe Curry: Empowering you to use your values as a roadmap to your ideal retirement.

0:19Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): No MBA required.

0:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hey guys,

0:31Joe Curry: it's Joe Curry and welcome back to the show. So there's one fear I hear more than almost any other from people who are right on the edge of retirement. And it's this. What if I finally pull the trigger, I hand in my notice, I start this whole new chapter, and then the market drops right out from under me.

0:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): If

0:49Joe Curry: that worry has ever crossed your mind. this episode's for you because by the end of it, you're going to understand why the timing of a market downturn can matter even more than how big it is, and more importantly, what you can actually do about it. Now, I think it

1:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): was

1:03Joe Curry: two episodes ago, we talked about sorting your uh retirement risks into two piles, the ones you can control and the ones you can't control. And the big idea that there's no risk-free option. options, you only ever move risk around. Well, today we're zooming in on one specific risk that you can't control. And it's a big one. It's called sequence of returns risk. And it lives right in the middle of what I call the retirement danger zone, those years just before and just after you stop working. You've probably heard me mention this on the show before, and we definitely talked about. the retirement danger zone. And so here's the thing that makes it so sneaky. For your entire working life, it barely mattered what order your returns came in. That's not to say that you liked seeing your portfolio drop, but at least you knew that you had time, right? And then the day you start drawing income, that order becomes one of the most important things in your whole plan. And if you happen to retire in late 2021 or 22, you got a front row seat to that because stocks and bonds fell together as the whole wave of people, which continues today, are stepping into retirement. So I wanna do three things today. First, I'll explain why the order of your returns matters now when it never used to. Second, I'll put a simple example on it so you can

2:23actually see it and not just hear me say the words. And third, we'll get into what to do about it. Because remember, you don't get a vote on what the market does the year you retire. Okay, so let's dive in here. So first, your whole working life, the order of your returns barely mattered, right? And the day you retire, it flips into one of the most important things in your plan. So let me explain why that is. When you're still working and saving, think about what a rough market actually does. You're adding money every paycheck. And so when the price drops, again, you might not like it, but at least you're buying your investments cheap, right? You're buying shares cheaper than before it dropped. So a bad year earlier in your career can actually help you now because you've got 20 or 30 years for it to recover. and you were just buying all the way down. So timing is doing some heavy lifting for you in that case. Now flip it. You've entered retirement

3:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and

3:26Joe Curry: instead of adding money, you're taking it out. And all of a sudden, a down year is completely different because to fund your income, you have to sell. And when the market's down, you're selling more units to pull out the same number of dollars.

3:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

3:39Joe Curry: now you're taking money off the table at exactly the wrong time.

3:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

3:43Joe Curry: that's money that you never get a chance to let climb back, right? So the selling is now locking in the loss.

3:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

3:50Joe Curry: here's the takeaway for this part. And I want you to really sit with this. So in your working years, time is on your side. In retirement, timing is the risk.

4:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now

4:01Joe Curry: this sounds a bit abstract. until you actually visualize it because I'm talking on a podcast. But if I put some numbers on it, and I want to be clear up front here, these are just some simple numbers to show the idea. This isn't a recommendation on what to have or what to take out. But let's just picture two people. Same starting nest egg, let's call it $500,000. They both take out the same income each year. We'll say that's $25,000. a year. And here's the key part. Over the whole stretch of years, they earn the exact same average return. Same average. Okay. The only difference between them is the order those returns come in.

4:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

4:40Joe Curry: one of them hits a rough patch early, while the other one hits the same rough patch, but later on.

4:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

4:45Joe Curry: let's watch. Here's the first one. The one who gets the bad year right at the gate, they start at $500. $500,000. The market falls 20%,

4:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and

4:54Joe Curry: they're down to $400,000, but they still need to live. So in this case, we're just saying at the end of the year they pull out their $25,000, and now they're sitting at $375,000. Now person two in year one gets a 20% positive return, takes out their $25,000 at the end of the year, and now they're beginning. year two at $575,000. Year two, let's say person one had a negative 10% rate of return. So the market wasn't finished going down yet. They got to take out their $25,000 again at the end of the year. And now they're finishing that year with a portfolio of $312,500. Let's say person two, they get a 10% positive return. in the next year, and they take out their $25,000 again at the end of the year, and they're left with $607,500.

5:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now

5:47Joe Curry: in year three, the first person, now they got a positive return. Market's coming back. So they get a positive 10% rate of return in year three.

5:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

5:56Joe Curry: after taking out their withdrawal, they're left with $318,750.

6:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now

6:02Joe Curry: person two. gets a negative 10% rate of return in year three. So now they're starting to get a rough patch here, and they finish the year after taking their withdrawal

6:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): with

6:13Joe Curry: $521,750.

6:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

6:17Joe Curry: for this example, we're going to say year four is the final year of the example. The first person, now they get their 20% rate of return. And after their withdrawal, they finish. year three, sorry, year four with three hundred fifty-seven thousand five hundred dollars. And person two, now they get their negative twenty percent rate of return, ending with a portfolio value of three hundred ninety-two thousand four hundred dollars at the end of year four. So

6:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that

6:45Joe Curry: was a lot of numbers, a lot of talking. Let me break it down a bit. After four years

6:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): with the

6:50Joe Curry: same simple average return, person two is starting year five with 35, approximately $35,000 more than person one.

7:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now

7:01Joe Curry: that might not seem like a big amount in the grand scheme of things, but it's more than a year's worth of withdrawals. And we're just four years into retirement.

7:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

7:11Joe Curry: for the rest of retirement, person one is taking the same amount of money. for their living expenses out of a smaller portfolio, which means they're more likely to run out of money than person number two. Now, these examples could be a lot more extreme if we were entering a scenario like the global financial crisis or the dot-com crash.

7:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

7:29Joe Curry: the takeaway here is a big one. Okay. The average return almost lies to you in retirement. Two plants, the exact same average, can end up in completely different. places. And the thing that separates them is timing. And this is why when you're doing your planning, it's so important that you're not just working off a straight line projection. Someone saying, hey, if you get X percent per year in retirement, everything's gonna work out. Because it doesn't really tell you anything about how the timing affects those outcomes.

7:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now,

7:58Joe Curry: here's the good news. And it ties straight back to the uh the risk episode where we did a couple episodes ago.

8:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

8:05Joe Curry: it is you can't control whether the bad years show up first.

8:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But

8:09Joe Curry: you're not helpless here, right? And there are some tools for this. So one place to start is with an income floor. So what I mean by that is making sure your basic non-negotiable expenses, like uh the roof over your head, your groceries, heat and hydro are all covered by dependable income.

8:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that

8:27Joe Curry: you're not pulling out of the market. Because once the essentials are safe or taken care of, now you've got room to be flexible with everything else, right? The muffs, the must-haves aren't riding on what the market did last week. Then there's the defense bucket, short-term money that you can keep out of the market on purpose so that your income doesn't depend on selling your stocks at the worst possible moment. You spend from safe. money while the markets do their thing. So that's your flexibility insurance, the cushion you hope you don't need, and you're really glad to have when you do.

8:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

9:00Joe Curry: you can lean on that defensive side extra hard right at the start of retirement. So this is where something like a bond ladder or what we call a CPP bridge can come in, right? Where you deliberately overload the safe money to carry you through the front. first five years, that retirement danger zone. And the reason you focus on those first five years is that those are the riskiest years for sequence of returns risk, right? And why we call it the retirement danger zone. So you get through that early window in good shape,

9:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): then

9:31Joe Curry: honestly, a lot of the danger is already behind you.

9:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

9:34Joe Curry: then here's one last idea or strategy for today uh a flexible. withdrawal plan, right? A real plan, like retirement income guardrails we've talked about, or dynamic distribution strategies.

9:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

9:46Joe Curry: I want to be clear about what I mean here because this is not a vague, oh, hey, we'll tighten our belt if things get bad. It's an actual plan set up ahead of time that tells you when to ease off your spending and by how much, so that when a rough patch hits, you're trimming on purpose calmly instead of

10:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the same.

10:03Joe Curry: panicking. And that's exactly where this series is headed in a few episodes. Right? We'll talk more about that. Now here's the important part. And this is really the main thing. These are tools, not a prescription, right? You don't necessarily need every one of them. And this is not an all-encompassing episode on every way to deal with sequence of returns risk. And the right mix depends entirely on your situation and your comfort level. The balance we talked about in that episode a couple episodes ago. So because the answer is never just to hide everything in cash, that basically doing that only trades sequence of return risk for other risks like longevity risk, inflation risk, and interest rate risk. Right. So there's always going to be some kind of risk there. It's how are we going to manage that risk? So the real goal is a plan that carries you through the bad. early years if you get them without blowing up the rest of your retirement.

10:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

10:55Joe Curry: the takeaway, you don't beat sequence of returns risk by predicting the market. You beat it with a plan built for your situation so that the order your returns happen in aren't going to sync retirement for you.

11:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All right.

11:09Joe Curry: So if I bring this home,

11:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the

11:11Joe Curry: order your returns barely mattered while you're saving. And it matters in a big way once you start spending. So two plans with the very same average can lead to totally different places just because of timing. And since you can't control the timing, you prepare for it instead, right? An income floor so your essentials are covered. A defense bucket, so you're never a forced seller. Leaning on that safe money heavier through those first five years, the retirement danger. zone,

11:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and

11:40Joe Curry: a flexible withdrawal plan for when you need to dial things back.

11:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The

11:44Joe Curry: one idea I want you to keep is this: in retirement, timing is the risk and the fix is structure, not a forecast.

11:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

11:53Joe Curry: here's something to think about as you go on with your week. If the market had a rough couple of years right as you retired, do you actually know what your plan would do?

12:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Are

12:03Joe Curry: your essentials covered by income? So you're not selling investments? Or would you be forced to sell at the worst possible time? And if you ever stress test your plan by assuming the bad years come first instead of quietly hoping they come later or hoping they don't come at all. Right?

12:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

12:20Joe Curry: if you're listening to this and thinking, yeah, this sounds a bit like me,

12:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you

12:24Joe Curry: can watch a short overview of our true. wealth roadmap at Matthews and Associates.ca forward slash roadmap. And it'll walk you through who we help and how our 60-minute retirement review works and what you get in the simple one or two page retirement blueprint that follows.

12:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

12:41Joe Curry: when you picture your own retirement, don't just ask how big the next downturn might be. B, Ask, do you have a plan in place to get through those tough years if they show up early? and keep going? All right.

12:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

12:53Joe Curry: appreciate you guys tuning in as always. Thanks for listening. And uh I will chat with you guys again next week. Take

13:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): care.

13:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Investment services are provided through Matthews and Associates Investments of Aligned Capital Partners Incorporated and approved trade name of Aligned Capital Partners Incorporated ACPI. Only investment related products and services are offered through ACPI, Matthews and Associates Investments of ACPI, and covered by the Canadian Investor Protection Fund. Tax plan. planning, financial planning, and insurance services are provided through Matthews and Associates. Matthews and Associates is an independent company separate and distinct from ACPI, Matthews and Associates Investments of ACPI. Matthews and Associates are not licensed tax professionals, and you should consult with your tax advisor before acting on any recommendations.

13:55Joe Curry: Visit retirement planning simplified.ca

13:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and join the Retirement Planning Simplified community

14:00Joe Curry: where we explore the complicated world of retirement. planning while embracing life beyond the numbers.

14:05Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): As a member of our community, you'll receive insights,

14:08Joe Curry: tips, and

14:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the latest retirement planning tools

14:11Joe Curry: straight from us to you.

This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights