Ex-SIG Trader Alex Monahan on Sports Betting Arbitrage and Prediction Markets
Summary
Alex Monahan, a former trader at Susquehanna International Group (SIG), discusses his transition from trading index derivatives during the March 2020 crash to exploiting inefficiencies in the US sports betting market. He explains how SIG's market-making techniques, such as managing inventory risk through leaning quotes, parallel strategies used by sportsbooks to manage risk and limit sharp bettors. Monahan highlights that early sports betting edges were driven by aggressive customer acquisition promos and arbitrage opportunities, which have since diminished as books became more restrictive. He notes that prediction markets like Kalshi and Polymarket currently offer similar opportunities for ex-traders, though competition is increasing. Finally, he contrasts SIG's risk-focused culture with the customer-centric approach required to build a consumer-facing sports betting tool like Odds Jam.
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 2:01
SIG Trading During March 2020 Volatility
Alex Monahan describes trading index derivatives at Susquehanna (SIG) during the March 2020 market crash, specifically noting a long position in airline ETFs like JETS due to heavy retail shorting flow from WallStreetBets and Robinhood.
- 2:01 – 8:15
Market Making Risk Management and Flow Analysis
Monahan explains how SIG manages inventory risk by widening spreads or leaning quotes to avoid taking toxic institutional flow while capturing benign retail flow, distinguishing between informed hedge fund orders and uninformed retail orders.
- 8:15 – 17:25
SIG Training and Decision-Making Culture
The speaker details SIG's training program, which emphasizes expected value (EV), poker-based decision making, and tail risk management over outcome-based evaluation, preparing traders for high-volatility environments through mock trading and simulator exercises.
- 17:25 – 23:49
Transition to Sports Betting Arbitrage and Promos
Monahan recounts how SIG colleagues treated sports betting as a gambling opportunity after legalization, leading him to exploit market inefficiencies through arbitrage, middle betting, and sign-up bonuses during the 'Wild West' phase of US sportsbooks.
- 23:49 – 30:39
Sports Betting Strategies and Market Evolution
He outlines specific betting strategies including arbitrage, middle betting on player props, and EV betting against consensus lines, noting that early edges were high due to bookmaker growth mode but have since diminished as books limit sharp bettors.
- 30:39 – 31:31
Prediction Markets and Future Opportunities
Monahan compares traditional sportsbooks, prediction markets like Kalshi and Polymarket, and financial markets, suggesting prediction markets offer a middle-ground opportunity for ex-traders as traditional sportsbooks become more restrictive.
- 31:31 – 33:30
Market Making on Prediction Markets
Alex Monahan notes that ex-traders are making significant profits market making on prediction markets like Kalshi and Polymarket. He warns that this opportunity is becoming more competitive as large firms like Susquehanna (SIG) enter the space, potentially with preferential treatment.
- 33:30 – 40:04
Sportsbook Pricing Disparities and Business Models
Monahan explains that sportsbooks maintain different prices across platforms because they manage risk internally and seek competitive advantages, such as being the first to offer correlated same-game parlays. He argues that books often prefer to limit or cut off winning bettors rather than invest in perfect pricing, especially given the complexity of thousands of live lines.
- 40:04 – 44:08
Odds Jam Product Strategy and SIG Influence
Monahan contrasts SIG's risk-focused trading mindset with the scrappy, customer-focused approach needed for Odds Jam. He highlights that Odds Jam's value proposition relied on two key factors learned from trading: extreme data speed (avoiding 25-second delays) and broad market coverage (including soccer and tennis, not just NFL).
- 44:08 – 46:33
Unlearning SIG and Building a Consumer Business
Monahan states that while SIG taught him financial concepts, it did not teach him essential business skills like hiring, marketing, A/B testing, or customer acquisition. He also notes he had to unlearn SIG's secrecy, as sports betting tools require transparency to help users beat limited books.
- 46:33 – 59:43
Long Degeneracy and Regulatory Risks
Monahan questions the sustainability of the
Assets discussed
| Asset | Kind | Stance | Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| TeslaTSLA | equity | neutral | for people who had been trading index derivatives or specific names, Tesla, whatever, for like five, ten 10 years, it's different. |
| AppleAAPL | equity | neutral | Being able to buy Apple at a hundred here and then sell it for a hundred and one, you know, somewhere else. Like that's |
| Meta PlatformsMETA | equity | neutral | or whatever, like buy by my advice, buy by my stock trades basically. I'm long Facebook. Um, you know, I I I I bet the Lakers. |
| S&P 500 | index | neutral | and put your money in the S And P P500 500 because, no offense, you're not the guy who's like gonna have some crazy market-making market making strategy that's always gonna be able to beat out others and make millions of dollars. |
“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.
Claims worth verifying
Alex Monahan made approximately $260,000 in his first year of sports betting.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·20:40
How to verify: Tax records or personal financial disclosures if publicly available; otherwise, verify via cross-reference with his LinkedIn profile or public interviews confirming the timeframe and amount. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Sports betting was legalized in the United States in 2018 following a Supreme Court ruling.
Alex Monahan ·17:54
How to verify: US Supreme Court case Murphy v. National Collegiate Athletic Association (2026). For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
SIG (Susquehanna) is famous for using poker to train traders and emphasize expected value decision-making.
Alex Monahan ·13:05
How to verify: SIG corporate history pages, employee testimonials on Glassdoor/Blind, or industry publications detailing SIG's trading culture. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Tesla is an example where market makers were 'run out of the water' due to tail risk.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·8:45
How to verify: Historical price data for TSLA showing extreme volatility events (e.g., 2026 short squeeze) and market maker inventory reports if available. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Sports Illustrated Sportsbook offered a $7,500 risk-free bet and has since shut down.
Alex Monahan ·30:51
How to verify: Archive.org snapshots of Sports Illustrated Sportsbook terms and conditions; news articles confirming the shutdown of the SI sportsbook. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
DraftKings offered VIP referrals paying $5,000 per friend, capped at five referrals.
Alex Monahan ·29:34
How to verify: DraftKings promotional terms from the relevant period (2026-2026) archived online or in press releases. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourcePatrick Mahomes' passing yards follow a normal distribution.
Alex Monahan ·26:13
How to verify: Statistical analysis of NFL player performance data (e.g., from Pro Football Reference) to check for normal distribution of passing yards. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Kalshi and Polymarket are prediction markets where market making is an opportunity for ex-traders.
Alex Monahan ·31:13
How to verify: Kalshi and Polymarket websites describing their market making programs or liquidity provider incentives. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
SIG traders made more money sports betting than in their jobs during the early US legalization period.
Alex Monahan ·0:47
How to verify: Anecdotal verification via industry forums (e.g., Reddit r/sportsbook, Blind) or SIG employee anecdotes; difficult to verify precisely without internal data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Most retail options trading is negative expected value (EV) long-term.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·17:11
How to verify: Academic studies on retail options profitability (e.g., from Journal of Finance) or broker-reported data on retail trader P&L. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify the current regulatory status and licensing requirements for sports betting arbitrage tools in your jurisdiction.
- Check Kalshi and Polymarket's current liquidity and spread data to assess if market-making opportunities still exist for retail traders.
- Review Susquehanna International Group's (SIG) public filings or press releases regarding their involvement in prediction markets or sports betting technology.
- Analyze Odds Jam's pricing model and data latency claims against independent user reviews or technical audits.
- Research the historical performance of middle betting strategies on player props to understand the impact of bookmaker limits and rule changes.
- Compare the efficiency of traditional sportsbooks versus prediction markets using historical odds accuracy data from sources like Odds Shark or BetMGM.
- Investigate the conflict of interest if Odds Jam or similar tools have partnerships with specific sportsbooks that may influence their recommendations.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00Ethan Kho: March 2020, you're a quant trader at SIG. The markets are going haywire. Give me one example of a trade you guys put on.
0:07Alex Monahan: We ended up getting long airlines because so much retail flow wanted to be short. It was like every single morning you would look at Wall Street bets. You're not expecting one to two percent moves, you're expecting some days like five, six higher moves. So it was an absolutely insane time. It was just wild. SIG was a group of gamblers. right? So when sportsbooks legalized, it kind of became the talk of the office. And when sportsbooks first launched in the US, the market's super inefficient. They're only in a few states. All these companies are trying to launch. They're not really limiting sharper customers. So it was like the Wild West. I remember looking back after a few months and just being like, I made more money sports betting batting than I did in my job. How
0:49Ethan Kho: much were you making, if you don't mind me asking? I
0:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): think
0:50Alex Monahan: my first year of sports batting, I probably made like
0:58Ethan Kho: Alex, thank you so much for coming on the pod.
1:01Alex Monahan: Thanks for having me. I'm pumped.
1:03Ethan Kho: It's March 2020. You're a quant trader at SIG. The markets are going haywire. Give me one example of a trade you guys put on.
1:11Alex Monahan: Yeah, we ended up getting long airlines because so. much retail flow wanted to be short. It was like every single morning you would look at Wall Street bets. I was trading Jets, which was an airline ETF, index derivatives, so calls and puts on ETFs. And there was a lot of madness because I'd block, I had the crypto ETF, but Jets was a particularly crazy one because a lot of clients, as well as a lot of retail traders. wanted to put on big positions in airlines. And it's obviously very stressful at that time because the market can move a lot more. You're not expecting one to two percent moves. You're expecting some days like five, six higher moves. So it was an absolutely insane time, especially around like earnings and you know as news came out about COVID. it it was just wild.
2:01Ethan Kho: What are the ways in which you guys manage? risk when you have all this flow? Everyone wants to buy puts on jets on airline stocks, right? Um, you guys have a long position. How do you actually navigate that on your balance sheet?
2:14Alex Monahan: Yeah, so a lot of what I thought about as a trader is I mean, we tried to stay flat, right? SIG is overall a market maker. So you don't want to be super long or super short. in general. Of course,
2:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
2:30Alex Monahan: know, we are relying on research, and sometimes we do want to be a little long, so we'll put on what I would say are called liens. So maybe instead of quoting something, you know, 99 at 101, we'll widen out on the bid a bit, like have a less aggressive bid so we can sell a bit more.
2:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
2:49Alex Monahan: that's how we thought a lot. and also just what percentage of the trades do we want to take from Robinhood and retail traders? So, how wide do we want to be or how competitive do we want to be? Because naturally, if everyone's trying to, you know, sell puts and you're very competitive on pricing, you're gonna get long pretty quickly. So a lot of it was also trying to figure out vol levels, how wide do we want to be, how competitive do we want to be? Um yeah. so SIG was interesting because I ended up trading as an index derivatives trader. You know, you trade a lot against retail, so I'm following Wall Street Bets and Discords and communities to try to get a sense of like what trades are people putting on, how informed are they, and why. And you're also trading with institutional players, you know, who sometimes want to put on big trades in airlines and they must be and they may be more informed, right? You're trading against hedge funds. Um Yeah, so a lot of SIG is kind of I felt like you're reacting to trades coming in and trying to assign
3:55risk of just like how much information is in this order. Cause Because if I go to, you know, if Citadel comes in or a hedge fund and wants to make a big trade against us, toxic flow is a word that's thrown around a lot, is that may affect your fair value. Maybe I thought something was worth a dollar. If they want to buy a lot, maybe now I'm updating after the order to like 105. Whereas if it's a bunch of Robin Hood, you know, whatever degenerates on Wall Street bets, you may just. take that trade and be happy to take, you know, ninety percent or whatever of the allocation and just continue to sit on the bid and the offer.
4:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): For
4:35Ethan Kho: retail specifically, how do you identify or screen for whether the flow is toxic or benign? And I'll I'll go more specific into that. You know, let's think about GameStop, right? You know, let's say, I mean, I think it's very easy to say these guys have no edge. that you know overall and you know and and you know overall it doesn't matter too much, but look at the way the stock moved, right? It's just it's just insane. Right. How did you think how would you how did you think about something like that?
5:03Alex Monahan: Yeah, and it's the same with crypto, right? Like it's really hard to know. Um and also some of it is trying to get a sense of what could the magnitude be. So we're looking at, you know, how big
5:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like
5:18Alex Monahan: how bad could things get, right? Because maybe you think, okay, these retail traders, you know, or after Jim Kramer says something on CNBC and he talks about airlines and jets and now there's and he's recommending putts, there's a lot of order flow coming in. But if it just keeps coming in and keeps dropping the price. more and more, you just keep losing, right? Um, so if you're the initial person selling,
5:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
5:46Alex Monahan: know, sometimes you'd want to hold off on taking many of the initial orders. And then when it seems like things are slowing down, you want to get more aggressive because you're getting a better price where you're buying.
5:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
5:57Alex Monahan: there's like a little game theory there. I would say, you know, obviously SIG has amazing technology. just in terms of like even helping identify what counterparties you're trading against. Um yeah.
6:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
6:12Alex Monahan: it's not easy.
6:14Ethan Kho: At SIG, were there ever moments where there There is strong reason to take a directional punt and a big direction? directional punt on a particular name, on a particular product, because you're able to, you know, you have such a good understanding of what essentially all the players in the market are doing. And so it's basically a high-level poker game, and you can decide to bet big at various moments.
6:43Alex Monahan: At points, but also just, you know, I don't want to talk about what I don't know. I was a pretty low-level trader at Suscraft. Susquehanna when I left. Um, I just finished being an assistant trader and got promoted and started working on a desk, and then I ended up leaving to start my company. So I definitely think as people get more experience, you know, for people who had been trading index derivatives or specific names, Tesla, whatever, for like five, ten 10 years, it's different. For me, I most of the time, especially because I started trading. at a crazy time, right? It was the Trump-Biden election. It was also COVID. So I was much more risk neutral, which maybe means I wasn't, you know, as great of a trader, but I think it's obviously a crazy first time to start market making when volatility is that high, um, when retail flow is exploding and when the market is just insane. Um so for me personally, not really. I was trying to stay flat overall and be very smart about that. Um because crypto was moving a lot at that time and we had some big losses and big wins on some of the ETFs I was trading, airlines as well. Um so but again, there obviously are traders at SIG, at Citadel. Um even some
8:03of my friends who still work at these companies who now are taking much more directional bets. Me, when I started, not as much. No, and I'm not going to claim uh that that I was or that I'm that smart, you know.
8:15Ethan Kho: You joined SIG uh at a very volatile time, right? What did your colleagues say
8:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to you?
8:27Ethan Kho: Are there any things your colleagues said to you about the way the market had changed during that point in time? 2020, meaning?
8:37Alex Monahan: I mean, not specifically, like I feel like especially
8:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): at
8:46Alex Monahan: SIG, they talk a lot about tail risk, right? Like we spent time on Tesla. Like Tesla's a prime example of where market makers got run out of the water. And you like just not getting too confident in your ideology of what fair value is or how much it could change. So they really stress that as a whole. When you join, when you're an intern, when you're an assistant quantitative trader, and when you're a quantitative trader. I don't think like for specific, wow, this is the craziest market I've ever seen. I don't necessarily think so, because for the guy trading maybe Tesla initially, there have been way crazier times. So I think for some of the experienced traders, or you think about the founders of Susquehanna, who are absolutely amazing, right? It's a crazy company to work at, is they've been through crazy markets. many times. Um
9:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
9:43Alex Monahan: don't think so. Like I do think Susquehanna did a good job, maybe at not freaking me out as a new trader. Like I felt prepared by the education. And Susquehanna's a great company, I thought, like when I was debating offers, because they spend a year trading you. You don't get thrown into the fire. You spend a year learning a lot, doing mock trading, trading simulators, you know, with really high-up traders, doing projects, whatever. So I personally felt like decently prepared as long as I stayed relatively wide and tried to stay relatively flat.
10:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
10:21Alex Monahan: it was just busy. I mean, there's a difference. Like,
10:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
10:25Alex Monahan: remember traders talking about B. being busier than ever. Like you couldn't leave the desk. And that's a good thing in many ways. Volatility is amazing for market makers. Like if you look at the amount of money Jane Street Citadel, like they make, they made during like COVID versus a boring summer. You want a lot of trading volume, wider bid ass spreads. So remember I people talking about that. It's just there have been summers where like, you know, you kind of sit at your desk, you look at sports, people. are talking. When the market's slow, you don't want to force things.
10:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
10:55Alex Monahan: then COVID just being like in early, out early, you're not leaving your desk, and like phones are going off the hooks.
11:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): No, when you're talking about it. But most
11:04Alex Monahan: people were excited, like, not obviously excited for COVID, but most people were excited for the trading environment. Nobody obviously was excited about COVID. Um,
11:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
11:14Alex Monahan: people were excited because there's a ton of business. Everyone is trying to trade, put on positions, retail, hedge funds, boom. And that's amazing for market makers.
11:24Ethan Kho: Most oil ETFs don't actually track the price of oil. They hold futures contracts, and many of them track oil for delivery up to four months from now. So when you buy an oil ETF, you're not betting on today's oil prices. You're betting on where the market thinks oil will be next season. That's not the kind of trade you meant to make. Which brings me to today's sponsor, Onyx. They're the world's biggest market maker in oil derivatives, and they built the solution to this problem: the Onyx Spot Return Crude Oil ETC.
11:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It
11:55Ethan Kho: tracks dated Brent, the price 78% of the world's oil deals are based on. And it reflects barrels just shipping in the next two to three weeks. That exposure used to be reserved for oil majors and trading houses. Now you can buy it on interactive brokers. The ticker is OIL. You mentioned the training program at SIG that you went through, and that they invest a lot of resources into training you
12:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): up
12:22Ethan Kho: and and and giving you a very good understanding of what it is they do and how. they take risk or and and manage it. What are some of the most important lessons you learned from that year?
12:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
12:37Ethan Kho: and how did it shape the way you think about taking risk in general?
12:41Alex Monahan: Yeah. I think it like if we go back, I was in, SIG, say, you know, this was probably seven years ago at this point, but think. thinking about everything in terms of bets and decision making and expected value, it seems so simple, but it's a very new concept for people. I mean, even most traders, I would say, retail traders, like so in terms of SIG, you play a lot of poker. SIG is famous for that. And really grilling you on why did you make this decision? Quant you know, quantify this mathematically. So in mock trading, when you're doing trading simulators, and sometimes it's just like here's the price of a stock, the stock is now higher. What do you quote this call at? Here, this order comes in. What are you quoting at? They really grill you on why, why, why did you do this? Like it's good decision making, given everything you know, and also can. considering what you don't
13:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
13:41Alex Monahan: in less focused on outcomes, which isn't how most people think. So, like we had a guest speaker, you know, Annie Duke, who wrote a book like Thinking and Bets, he was a professional poker player.
13:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
13:54Alex Monahan: SIG spends a lot of time on that, thinking about how wide you want to be, how much flow you think is going to come in, um, how tight. you want to quote, why. And they really stress that, and then they stress that also with like historical, you know, things that happened in markets and trying to get a sense of what you would have done, and then kind of allowing you to see what ended up happening.
14:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
14:23Alex Monahan: Yeah. Also just like how to talk to clients. I think there's part of it too. There's a fine line between being fast and quoting a horrible price. Right? So like when a client calls, you there's a lot of things to consider because you don't want to offer a market, that's a joke. Because then they're not going to call you back. But you also don't want to quote way too tight and maybe get blown out of the water. So I feel like there's a lot of things um
14:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): at
14:57Alex Monahan: SIG as I kind of think back, because again, this was a while ago that they weren't intuitive to me, even as like until you go through SIG or become a trader and really start getting into markets, um, that makes sense. Even just like understanding an option, like I heard the word option when I was in in college and high school and kind of understand understood them, but like really getting deep. We we had test sessing. Like you're going through Vega, gamma, all these complex things, and um they really wanted you to understand every detail of the product you were trading. Because there's also different products, right? Um Yeah.
15:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
15:34Ethan Kho: traded you traded uh index options.
15:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Is it
15:38Ethan Kho: correct? Yeah.
15:39Alex Monahan: I traded index options for I mean, maybe three to six months and then I ended up leaving to start my company and this was like prime covid. Maybe a little longer. Um yeah, so I went through the assistant quantitative trader program. I thought that was amazing. I still tell anyone who wants to be a trader, I think it's the best company to join. You learn so much. And then I started trading. It was already COVID. During COVID, I kind of got thrown into it. And then I ended up leaving maybe like, I don't know, four or five, something like that months later.
16:11Ethan Kho: Is there an intricacy to index equity options that you learned at SIG that you think would be valuable for anyone who wants to speculate on that product?
16:27Alex Monahan: Anything I learned that may be valuable. I mean, not particularly if I'm being completely honest. Like again, uh I I know I told you this, but I worked as a market maker and I think the things I learned at SIG, I don't trade now, right? I I invest for the long haul, but I don't trade because I feel like now I understand how smart and how good the tech is in and how difficult it can be to make money trading derivatives as an individual, as a retail trader. And don't get me wrong, I'm not gonna put a blanket statement. It's not possible. Obviously, it is, and there's people who carve out edges and more liquid markets, as well as maybe more liquid markets. But me personally, like
17:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
17:11Alex Monahan: don't do it, right? Like I understand why people buy, you know, covered calls, but I also understand why it's almost certainly negative EV long term. So yeah.
17:25Ethan Kho: Talk to me about how you got into sports betting. You know, on the
17:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): back
17:29Ethan Kho: of that.
17:30Alex Monahan: Yeah. It's it's it's interesting because like I'm hopefully it hasn't been completely useless. This part will be more interesting because I remember more. Um but say SIG was, you know, Sig was a group of gamblers, right? So sports betting legalized in the United States in 2018. That's when the Supreme Court ruling was, and it was state by state. This was pre-production markets. And
17:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): at
17:56Alex Monahan: SIG, I spent a lot of weekends going to play poker at a casino with my. coworkers. Um, and just like gambling. So when sportsbooks legalized, it kind of became the talk of the office. And some people like absolutely loved it. And when the market was slow, um so even when I was an assistant trader, we would talk about new sports books that launched, all the promos, their odds boosts. So, like, okay, if you know this team was gonna be minus 110 and now they're plus one ten, is that a good bet? How do you quantify that mathematically? And er what if there's this like par light profit boost? What's the best way to mathematically do it? So there were a lot of people at SIG who ended up really enjoying this. I ended up getting in some group chats, and I would say I probably became one of the most obsessed with sports betting to the point where like I would go into SIG, I would trade, and I would go home and I would research sports betting or bet until like midnight. And then I would wake up early and like look at lines and look for bets and arbitrage bets and I would be blowing up the
19:05group chat with like all my bets and stuff like that. So I would say there were some people at SIG, you
19:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
19:11Alex Monahan: there's some people at SIG who are making millions of dollars and they're like, Yeah, sports betting, like it's cool, you know. And then there's some people who were like, It's Philadelphia, it's a huge sports city, were huge on it and going through all the books, all the promos, how to maximize them. And I kind of ended up learning a lot from those people, as well as just like getting really deep into sports betting and enjoying it. Um, because I felt like for me personally as SIG, we're the market maker. You're kind of the house, right? You're setting the lines, um,
19:45Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you're
19:45Alex Monahan: setting the bid ass spread. Whereas a sports better, you're trying to exploit sports books. And when sportsbooks first launched in the US, the market's super inefficient. They're only in a few states. All these companies are trying to launch, they're all trying to set prices independently, odds independently. They're not really limiting. sharper customers. So it was like the Wild West. And I I remember looking back after a few months and just being like, I made more money sports vetting than I did in my job. Like that seems crazy, but I was also putting in a lot of time to be clear. Like weekends, I was waking up, I was looking at sports lines, I was going through all the promos, I was driving to different states to take advantage of sign-up bonuses, you know. New Jersey, I would drive across the bridge and take advantage of those promos. So I was hustling. But
20:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
20:33Alex Monahan: then I just started to fall in love with it.
20:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): How
20:37Ethan Kho: much were you making, if you don't mind me asking?
20:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
20:40Alex Monahan: think my first year of sports botting, I probably made like $260,000,000. Um crazy. But also there were a lot of promos. I flew to Colorado. Colorado legalized online sports wedding. They had a sports book that had a seventy five hundred dollar risk free bet. So if you lose your bet, you get your money back. That's like the gist of it. If you figure out the expected value, it's like five grand. So like and this is one sports book of the hundreds they had in Cal Califor or in Colorado. Maybe not hundreds, but I mean they there were Sports Illustrated, there were all these books, probably at least 30. So I went for a long weekend. You know, I think I took a day off SIG, and like I get there and I have all my spreadsheets and I did it. And so a lot of it is not this is not complicated modeling. I'm setting up some scrapers, I'm doing obvious promos that are super lucrative. These books are in pure growth mode, customer acquisition. mode. And that's kind of how I started to get really turned on to sports betting. Um, but I've always like liked gambling. Um I thought poker at SIG was fun. I don't play poker anymore, but I always enjoyed it and kind of thinking through the math. I enjoyed being a market maker and thinking about these things, and I
21:59think sports betting, I felt more agency in some ways. because you don't have to
22:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): work
22:06Alex Monahan: at a company. You also don't have to go anywhere physically, right? Like you can just sit on your computer and have forty different sportsbook tabs pulled up and be kind of ripping and running.
22:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
22:19Alex Monahan: it felt new. Like I think poker and trading have been around much longer and there's a ton of information on poker. Like sports betting budding, at least in the US, was very new. And
22:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
22:32Alex Monahan: felt like there was a ton of opportunity.
22:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
22:35Alex Monahan: then, like, okay, now I made all this money in Colorado. Now I'm gonna, you know, get my friend and I'm gonna take him and show him how to do this. So it it it also was like It's a fun thing to just like do and talk about socially, especially because most of my friends like sports. and like making money. So
22:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
22:55Ethan Kho: know, you're you're speaking to someone who doesn't sports bet much. The most I'll do is whenever I'm at a bar, um, and this is not something I do anymore, but whenever I was I'm at a bar and I'm a huge UFC fan, um I'd check the favorite for all the fighters and then find someone who likes the other fighter and then bet fifty 50 fifty. 50 odds and then just run that over and over again every single time I'm at a I'm at a bar. That was that's fun. It's it's fun, right? It's a it's a very simple, clear edge. You know, it's like it's it's at least it's in general, it it would be, you know, t 20 cents of edge per dollar, right? That's
23:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): great
23:32Alex Monahan: it's the type of trace you want to make.
23:34Ethan Kho: Exactly. Very good stuff. But walk me through um, you know, how does edge come about in sports trading? You know, what are what are the things you're looking at? How has a edge how has edge evolved since it got legalized? I'd love to hear your thoughts.
23:49Alex Monahan: So I guess like to summarize what I think SIG did a really good job at is just teaching me to think
23:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): s
23:56Alex Monahan: like numbers, expected value, whatever. Cause Because obviously when you're a market maker, you have days where you get destroyed, smoked, like you're I'm I'm looking at the screen, I'm like, great, negative three mil. Um, and then you have days up a lot and just kind of not letting that bother you. And also, like when you work at a firm, it's not your money.
24:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
24:15Alex Monahan: but as a trader, it kind of started on a much smaller scale. And basically, how I started is I started setting up just you know, my own little bottle. bots to get data from these different sports books and just look for inefficiencies. So I'll give you a simple example, it's called arbitrage, right? Maybe some stupid new sports book like Wind Creek, which is a sports book in in Pennsylvania, maybe they have the Chiefs at plus 110, and FanDuel has the Eagles at plus 110. You're betting 100 to win an 110. So you put 100 bucks on both sides, $1. one bet wins, one bet loses, you're gonna end up ten dollars. That's called arbitrage. Um that's kind of like you're literally just the most simple. Like I wish this existed in financial markets. It's basically like you're buying a stock on e-trade for 10 bucks, you're selling it on Robinhood for 11 instantaneously, you're just making a buck.
25:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
25:13Alex Monahan: that was nice. because also at this time I just left college, right? So I mean, making $20, $50 an arbitrage bet, and I'm sitting at home, you know, eating chipotle, like it's like it's real money to me at the time, and it was a lot of fun to have that edge. And from there, I started to get into other strategies, right? So there's middle betting, which is okay, maybe buck. books don't even have the same line, but maybe they're pricing a player at way different levels. Maybe FanDuel has Patrick Mahomes' passing yards line at 200. You know, DraftKings is at 249 half. Let's bet the over on FanDuel, uh the under on DraftKings, and then if he ends up in the middle, you know, between 200 and 249, I'm gonna win both bets. Like that's a great deal. And then it's things. thinking about well, how good does a middle have to be to put it on? Because you're paying the VIG, maybe minus 110, minus 110. What's the probability? And you know, players largely follow a normal distribution for like their points and rebounds. Patrick Mahomes isn't going to throw 800 yards. He's also not going to throw zero. So he's going to end up like the probability he ends up kind of around. where his line is centered is pretty high. It roughly follows a normal distribution. So you can kind of like start to quantify
26:33this stuff mathematically, which I found really interesting and fun and profitable. Because there were days, you know, where I'd have a middle on, let's say, on a point spread where I need Patriots minus two and a half, jets plus three and a half. So I want the Patriots to win by three. And if the Patriots win by exactly three, I make thirty-five thousand dollars. And if any other outcome happens, I lose, you know, two thousand. So like it it also was a lot of fun because it's kind of like having your own little crazy stock portfolio where I felt like I had an edge. Um or not felt like I had an edge, which is much harder to do, again, in my opinion, in derivatives like stock options. and in index options or trading stocks.
27:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
27:18Alex Monahan: it was like a thrill because I'd have a lot of money bet and you're kind of running your own little hedge fund. That's how I thought about it. So from there you can kind of go into like other strategies. There's expected value betting, which is if you have hundreds of sports books setting lines, how do you determine what's the fair price? Kind of like if I have a bunch of different trading firms quoting bid ass spreads,
27:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
27:43Alex Monahan: can kind of look at them and be like, okay, it's kind of average like 98 cents at 102, fair value is a dollar. If I can get this for like,
27:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
27:52Alex Monahan: know, if I can buy this for like 95 cents, seems like a good trade where I'm getting five cents Sense of edge. It Seems very simple. Obviously, it's not how derivatives markets work. But in sports market, betting, that is how it works. You have all these independent parties setting prices. Some are smarter than others, sharper than others for some markets, some are stupider. For some markets, others are sharper, they get more flow, they get more player prop bets.
28:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
28:18Alex Monahan: there's all these things you can think about. Like let's say I think FanDuel is the fifth sharpest sports book. So I'm gonna put 20% weight in what FanDuel's pricing something is. at. I think Pinnacle is XYZ. I think Circa's XYZ for money lines, but less for player props. Like you can kind of create your own little model for calculating what you think the fair probability a team wins is. Um or a player goes over or under their given stat line, because everything's obviously about probability. And then you can look. So if I think the fair value. of the Chiefs winning is 50%, that means plus 100 is fair. We're betting 100 to win 100. Because if I win 50% of my bets at plus 100, I'm breaking even. So if I can get anything above plus 100, I'm profitable. So then maybe there's like four books offering the Chiefs above plus 100. one hundred. You hammer them all for the max you can get down to spoil. Cause sports books, they are casinos. They tell you your max bet size, and as you win more, they cut you down more. And I think that's been one of the biggest changes. Is initially it was the Wild West. Books were in growth mode. So they just
29:28want customers. Um
29:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so
29:30Alex Monahan: like I remember DraftKings had
29:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like
29:34Alex Monahan: I was a VIP at DraftKings. Even though I was up a $100,000 hundred thousand dollars at on this book. at this point, I'm a VIP. So you would get things like, you know, bring over your other whale friends and we'll give you $5,000. So I referred five SIG traders. I made $25,000. I could only refer five five friends max. Make $25,000, referring them the worst customers they could ever have, right? Like the last customers you guys ever want. Um but because they were very simple. They were just launching a sports book. It's probably the more money people bet, the more money we're gonna make, and their pricing wasn't optimal and all these things. I think now books have gotten much more focused, especially with the rise of prediction markets and DFS apps and sweepstakes apps. DraftKings is not losing a billion dollars a quarter anymore on marketing and promos and accepting, you know, large bet sizes from winning customers, is they've gotten much, much, much more aggressive at cutting people off, limiting sharp players, um,
30:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): as
30:39Alex Monahan: well as reducing the value of some of these signup promos. So I'll give you an example: Sports Illustrated, $7,500 Dollar risk-free bet. Sports Illustrated sports folks books are out of business, right? They shut it down. Um yeah, so you can still, there's still a lot of edges in sports betting, but I think the magnitude of the money you can make is lower. Um, at least using very basic strategies on retail sports books like a DraftKings or an MGM. There's a lot of opportunity on prediction markets, but prediction markets obviously. I would put in between like making money on a sports book, where you will start to get limited as you win, and making money in financial markets like the stock market.
31:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
31:27Alex Monahan: prediction markets are kind of in the middle where
31:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
31:31Alex Monahan: have a lot of friends or ex X traders I know, or just people who I met through the sports market. batting industry who make a killing trading on prediction markets, especially last year when they were earlier. Um, market making prediction markets, quoting parlays on Calci
31:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
31:49Alex Monahan: Polymarket, like offering the bid and the ask, market making. So there's real opportunity, and that's scalable, but it's also getting more competitive. You know, the more active a market becomes, then the big players, like a Susquehanna has an incentive to start to trade on it. And they may get, you know, trading firms may get preferential treatment or maybe not. I don't know. Um but then you start to get more competition. And like now Sig has a sports trader role. That's like a job they have. So yeah.
32:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): What
32:26Ethan Kho: you said there about ex-traders trading prediction markets and making swaths of money, I can attest. I've met a bunch of people who are printing amounts that I'm just in disbelief of how much they're making, market making some of these contracts.
32:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
32:44Ethan Kho: I I have a question about sports betting in general. Um because
32:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): when
32:51Ethan Kho: you're a trader, right, when you're making a bet, um the one of the most important questions one has to ask themselves is themselves, uh people have to ask themselves is, you know, wh why is it that there is edge in this thing? What what am I what am I actually exploiting? Um with sports betting, something I don't fully understand is how can there be a different price across exchanges? You know, across different sports books. That doesn't make sense to me because you know, as an exchange, like surely you have to move your lines if DraftKings is quoting something different, right? That that's something I don't fully understand. Can you explain that to me?
33:30Alex Monahan: Yeah. So why do sports sportsbooks books have different prices is
33:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
33:37Alex Monahan: common question. It's kind of always been that way. Because if you think about it, a casino,
33:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like
33:44Alex Monahan: if you think about the old days of sports betting, you go to Vegas, you go to Circa, Circa's getting their own bets and they're managing their risk, and as they get more money on the Chiefs, they may change the price. I think also a lot of sports books, they want their pricing to be in in-house. house. Um and also they want the ability to add new markets. So, like FanDuel, I think, was the first company to add a same-game parlay, right? When you can bet a parlay on the same game, and that's when correlation is involved, it's harder to price. So if you bet Mahomes to throw two touchdowns and the Chiefs to win, there's obviously correlation, so the price is going to be. different than a regular parlay.
34:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
34:29Alex Monahan: if FanDuel is the only sports book offering same-game parlays, they have a huge competitive advantage because people love to bet parlays on the same game. A game they're going to, a game they're watching, whatever.
34:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
34:41Alex Monahan: a lot of it is books want to do it themselves because it's a competitive advantage. And again,
34:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
34:49Alex Monahan: general thought is even if we have missed pricings as a casino, you can just cut off the winners, which you see predicts talk about consistently for why they're the better alternative for consumers, which we can debate and that's very debatable. But there is no house, right? So it's a fair market in that way. If you offer the best price, you will get filled. Um and
35:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
35:19Alex Monahan: guess so why do sportsbooks have them is if you're BetMGM and you can just, you know, limit people once they make fifteen thousand dollars and you know only three percent of Americans are smart enough to figure out what arbitrage is, it's like eh, whatever, why even invest in better? pricing and all these things if we can just cut off the winners? Like who cares? Right? It's like being a buffet if you can just kick out all the people who eat too much. It's like there's no reason to restrict. There's no reason to cut off people entering. Um in some ways, because it's very hard. You have to remember for a sports book, they have lines sometimes
36:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): at
36:05Alex Monahan: the minimum, hundreds of thousands of lines up, right? On FanDuel. For one NBA game, there's thousands of lines. All these props, all these different markets, first quarter, all these different totals. It's very hard to price. And things are always moving. Players are getting injured live, especially when a game is going on. It's very hard to keep things perfect. So it's a much easier business. model to just say we can take the winners and cut them off, which is why prediction markets have been such a thorn in their spine. Because yeah, and then you know, why do prediction markets have different prices? I assume some market makers, you know, get better incentives. Like, I don't know. what would make SIG decide, or Citadel, or a Jump decide which book do we want to market make on, or do we want to market make on them all? I'm not specifically sure.
37:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
37:04Alex Monahan: it's much eh,
37:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it's
37:06Alex Monahan: you it's it's not even that rare to see arbitrage between prediction markets. It's usually just like smaller amounts. Um small. smaller liquidity, longer time horizons. So there's been arbitrage on like elections and stuff. But if something's six months, a year out, and you can make a guaranteed 2% return, it's like that's not a good deal. But the reason sports books have different odds is it's just kind of that's their business model, is we keep things very simple. We have a simple odds feed, whatever. And we make five percent the vague, and if anyone's beating us, we just cut them off. And most people are very degenerate and square, so it's okay. Um yeah.
37:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
37:52Alex Monahan: can't
37:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): do that
37:53Alex Monahan: in financial markets.
37:55Ethan Kho: Yeah. No, your your
37:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): two
37:59Ethan Kho: thoughts. Um first I'm just thinking about sports betting and in general and being able to trade a different price on different sports books in equities markets, in the financial markets. That isn't her unheard of. Being able to buy Apple at a hundred here and then sell it for a hundred and one, you know, somewhere else. Like that's that's crazy. I mean, that's how FTX was making money initially, right? With Alameda. Um
38:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
38:25Ethan Kho: then the second thing is. you touch on a on something that
38:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
38:29Ethan Kho: think about a lot. I'm sure a lot of other people think about a lot, which is the rise of degeneracy. And how that is leading to this explosion in new business lines around gambling, around, you know, um weather around trading. Um right. And y I just want wanna to talk a little bit about that and sort of tying everything together. Um, because I think it is a regime shift in the way the economy works and understanding these shifts as traders do, I think is extremely important for someone building a business and thinking around sort of the conditions that we're in right now and how to win in those conditions. And so, real quick, before we go into that, I'd love to hear a bit about how your trading and the ways in which you thought about trading and were taught through poker, through EV, through thinking about things,
39:31you know, almost in a zero-sum Was some way. Um, How did those learnings map onto building odds gem, building a great business uh and selling it for lots of money?
39:42Alex Monahan: Yeah, so
39:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
39:44Alex Monahan: would say SIG taught me a ton about sports betting, which is the same. It's a zero-sum game, you make money or the book makes money. And I have a lot of thoughts on long degeneracy as well. But in terms of running a business, I think SIG's very very different mindset. Because at SIG, you're constantly thinking about risk. Because if you just get equal buy and sell orders, right? You're just making the bid ass spread and you're happy as can be. SIG is you're thinking about risk. Is volatility increasing? What's happening in other products? Um, what does this order mean if this hedge fund is trying to put on this? trade? And you know, how how should that uh impact what I think about vol or fair value? Why did they buy a straddle, not a strangle? Like you're thinking about all these things. Whereas I feel like when running a business, maybe not always, it depends on the type of business, but we
40:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): were
40:44Alex Monahan: very like scrappy, we were bootstrapped. So it was very much like figure out what works,
40:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what
40:50Alex Monahan: customers care. about. And from SIG, I kind of knew what will sports betters, traders, sports traders, prediction markets, and what does a regular trader care about? It's speed of data, which is obvious, but a lot of people didn't get it. Like they don't nobody understood. So odds jam initially, we tried to be the fastest possible, right? Because there were a lot of companies that would have, you know, 25 second a minute refresh speeds. Is that's not useful. Or maybe it's slightly useful,
41:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
41:27Alex Monahan: like people will pay 10 times more for something that's faster, um, because speed is everything. And in trading, it's obviously worthless if you have a price feed that's 25 seconds delayed. So at OddSham, we st we wanted that. We also cared about breadth of markets. Like at SIG, you know, SIG wants to offer every market possible, ideally, and quote them optimally. You're a customer facing uh business, right? Like if you don't have index derivatives and you only have you know stock options, someone's gonna go to another market maker. for their index derivatives. So SIG has natural gas, they have bonds, they have fixed right, they have all these different things. Um and I think in the case of Odds Jam, we try to have every market possible. Some people, sometimes there's great arbitrage bets in soccer. Most websites and whatever, like our early competitors. like did not
42:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they
42:29Alex Monahan: focused on NFL money lines and maybe the main player props, but not tackles plus assists or tennis or these other things. So breath of markets was very important to us from the start, too. We want to have a million odds updating every second as quickly as possible. Um
42:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so
42:48Alex Monahan: I think both of those things maybe like they have had SIG inspiration, data, data's everything, data driven tools, expected value, arbitrage, all these basic things I kind of learned as a a junior trader. I mean, we're not talking about crazy things thinking about edge, but most sports betting products were just like buy picks or whatever, like buy by my advice, buy by my stock trades basically. I'm long Facebook. Um, you know, I I I I bet the Lakers. Like that was kind of the level of tools that that at least at the time were available. So we took the opposite approach. We want to cut all that BS and just focus on fast data, a huge amount of markets, and um actually building valuable tools that are like based in
43:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): things that.
43:39Alex Monahan: are clearly valuable, like arbitrage, like middle betting, like EV betting. And the value prop was like hard to argue with. Um,
43:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so
43:48Alex Monahan: I guess like Sig's financial training obviously taught me a ton in terms of what would be valuable for a sports trader and sports better. And I was the first customer myself, right? I built the product for myself because I was sports betting spending a lot and I was making. money. So I was a great first use case. Um I think in terms of building a business, I actually had to learn
44:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
44:11Alex Monahan: ton of things that you don't learn at SIG, how to hire people, how to manage people, how to do social media, how to, you know, market, how to do email marketing, like all these things. Um
44:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): how
44:25Alex Monahan: to A B test things. like y you know, s the the subscribe page and the cancellation flow. Like, it was very different in that way. So I kind of felt like
44:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
44:36Alex Monahan: don't learn that, right? Like I didn't. When I was in college, like I studied math and computer science and then I became a SIG trader. I didn't know shit about marketing a product or closing a deal or negotiating and maximizing or A B testing or yeah I don't know, like I just didn't l learn those things or how to do UGC on TikTok to acquire customers for your business at like a low CAC. Like that was not a Stanford math class, right? So um and you SIG obviously doesn't care about it. So
45:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
45:06Alex Monahan: terms of like running a business, I don't think a ton at SIG applied.
45:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Are
45:10Ethan Kho: there any things you had to unlearn from Sig?
45:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah
45:14Alex Monahan: maybe like being cautious and secretive. Like Sig was very secretive, right? Like I I you probably would have gotten fired if you talked to the media, if they're like outside the building. Maybe not actually, but you know, it's very like SIG is,
45:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
45:28Alex Monahan: know, in Balakinwood, and it's an amazing place. I think everyone would learn a ton working there. I always was tell people, but it's not like it's very, you know, you're doing your own thing and you want your own PL and you obviously don't want to share the trading strategies working with you with the rest of the world. In sports spending it's different because
45:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
45:52Alex Monahan: start to get limited. So
45:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
45:54Alex Monahan: don't really care, right? Like if I already made X amount of dollars and have a bet BetMGM MGM account that's nuked and I'm limited. to like $5, $10 a bet.
46:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm
46:05Alex Monahan: not going to use the book anymore. So the only business model left is help other people learn how to make money or provide tools to them that help them make money on BetMGM because this book is now worthless to
46:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): me.
46:18Alex Monahan: So maybe a little bit of that. I mean, I never
46:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): thought
46:25Alex Monahan: I'd have like a consumer business. Um not really. So yeah.
46:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
46:34Alex Monahan: then in terms of long degeneracy, which I know you talked about, that's definitely something I think about the space. Like, it's pretty crazy if you think about
46:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): how
46:43Alex Monahan: many DFS apps, um,
46:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): how
46:47Alex Monahan: many prediction predics, markets, like how many card ripping companies. are valued at billions of dollars? Like
46:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): how
46:55Alex Monahan: sustainable is it? I don't know. Um it's it's crazy. And obviously, it's like as a whole, is gambling good for society? I mean, like probably not, but it's probably here to stay and people were. doing it illegally, which I think is something you can argue. Like, it's like, is legal marijuana? It's like, I don't know, if marijuana were gone forever, would that be good for the world? I don't know. But maybe cocaine is an obvious yes or an alcohol. If we never discovered this compound called alcohol, would the world be a better place? So I think a little bit about sports betting is I understand the argument,
47:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but now
47:38Alex Monahan: there's just gambling everywhere, right? Like I understand, okay, people are doing it on these sketchy websites. That's probably not good. We should probably legalize sports betting. And then you kind of understand prediction markets. Well, it's not really fair if you're betting against the house. What's much more fair is peer-to-peer.
47:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
47:55Alex Monahan: now it's like, you know, you can't even turn on a TV anywhere without seeing 45 gambling ads. And it's like, at what point does that become bad for society? Um, I don't know. But I think it is valuable in trading and in sports betting to at least that's what I tell myself. Like, you still want to have people who like try to produce good content. There's a lot of scams in sports betting, trading, prediction Production markets. Um, but it's still, you know, I overall felt fulfilled. running a sports betting business because I felt like we were doing a lot more to try to educate people.
48:37Ethan Kho: On the long degeneracy trade, what are your thoughts on the way it's running? Do you think we hit the top of that trade, say, a year from now, two years from now? Is it here to stay? You know, how would you not even give me a a straight up answer to w how you think it's gonna play out? What do you think it depends on?
48:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
48:57Alex Monahan: mean, probably regulation. Like I even remember at SIG during COVID, I'm like, who are all these people on Robinhood and e trade? Like, do they not have jobs? Like, who are these people commenting on all these Wall Street bet threads?
49:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
49:13Alex Monahan: I think it's interesting because you see this growing divide of the haves and the have nots in casinos and prediction markets and DFS companies are making a ton of money and card ripping companies and people, you know, that means people are losing a ton of money, right? Like the less educated, the less whatever. So like and that leads to only more income disparity, which I think is something our country talks so much about. And we're American, I definitely believe overall in freedom of choice and things like that. But it's hard. It it's crazy compared to like 2018, you watch a TV game, you look at an athlete's social media, you watch a sports game, like how much gambling are you seeing versus now? And I mean, how much more can we take before people are like, this is just too much, and this clearly isn't good for like 18 year olds and and kids in college and stuff like that.
50:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
50:17Alex Monahan: don't know. I'm not a policy guy. Um I'm I'm not a policy expert in that way, but you know, I think
50:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
50:29Alex Monahan: think there's pros and cons. And I see it with prediction markets because I see a lot of people gambling who got incentivized to now gamble who are never gonna make money gambling. Like they're not quantitative and maybe they'll have some highs and lows. Then I also see people who are really smart and sharp who now can make a ton of money market making and things like that. And obviously I'm happy for them. It's like it's weird because you don't want the less educated to like lose a bunch of money. But at the same time, like it's it's been a cool side hustle. Like it was fun for me to exploit sports books. And maybe at some point I will start, you know, taking market making on prediction markets seriously or more seriously. Like I've done a bit of it, but you know, I don't know. It's like I like the opportunity, but also I'm aware. of the ramifications.
51:17Ethan Kho: One thing I love thinking about is um
51:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
51:23Ethan Kho: current regime, call it business regime, uh regulatory environment, you know, AI, all the different tailwinds. And then how does one bet with a business to win in the current regime? And
51:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
51:36Ethan Kho: lot of say a lot of a lot my friends,
51:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
51:41Ethan Kho: the people I know who are doing the best are able to ride these insane trends of being able to raise lots of capital right now, right? Being able to go along a trend like degeneracy, like many friends with perps exchanges who are absolutely printing, right? Um, or a friend um who's printing trading prediction. markets, right, taking advantage of weaker players.
52:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
52:07Ethan Kho: and really I want to ask about the advice you would give framed like that to the median talent. And I ask that question because I think it's very easy to say what you should do if you're in the top percentile, right? Very, very easy. You can ride the hottest trend, you will, and you will be more than just rewarded. It will be your your your gains will be so disproportionate to anything you could have made before. But when I look at the median person, like truly median, not median smart, not median at Ivy League, you know, truly median. I don't know what the optimal way is to make money
52:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
52:55Ethan Kho: this current regime. It just seems so hard. Do you have any thoughts around that?
53:00Alex Monahan: Yeah. I mean, I think everyone is median at some things. Right? So I think part of it is you need to acknowledge and that maybe a career isn't for you. Like, I'm technical enough. I did math and computer science, but like I don't really care that much about like I would have hated my life as trying to become get a PhD in AI and be an AI researcher. And I wouldn't have been the top guy. And I'm, you know, I'm aware like I don't like it that much, and I'm not that. smart or that good at it. I would have been a horrible math PhD or something. So why would I compete in that field? Um
53:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
53:49Alex Monahan: I think everyone is good at some things. So I've met people who
53:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so
53:55Alex Monahan: I think it's like an honest conversation with yourself about like what are you good at? And this means maybe you shouldn't be a trader, period, right? Or you shouldn't be or or simply do the easy money on sportsbooks, prediction markets, the sign-up bonuses, some arbitrage, and then once you get limited, call it a day, and put your time somewhere else. Um, and put your money in the S And P P500 500 because, no offense, you're not the guy who's like gonna have some crazy market-making market making strategy that's always gonna be able to beat out others and make millions of dollars. You're not that guy. So make money, put it in the market, make some easy money off sportsbook, sign up bonuses, put it in the market, call it a day. Obviously, as you said, for the top technical people, um maybe they just should be market makers. For the median people, it's well, maybe you're median in terms of technical. and quantitative abilities, and you don't like what are you really good
54:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): at? Because
55:00Alex Monahan: everyone's good at something. Like, I don't think I'm top percentile technical, top percentile social media creator, but like you kind of combine them, and it ended up being a huge business in a very short amount of time, often off no really. raised capital. So like I think for everyone it's just kind of like find your spot. I don't know if that's helpful, but like
55:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
55:26Alex Monahan: do think there are some people who my advice to them
55:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if
55:30Alex Monahan: they're like, hey I've made money with arbitrage on odds jam and like it was a lot of fun but now I'm limited and whatever whatever should I try market making prediction markets like I've never used clawed code or like haven't done any computer science and have no experience in trading or math or probability. I just like did arbitrage and it's like your best bet is probably don't spend the time and you'll probably lose money. If I were you I wouldn't but you know you can take my advice with a grain of salt or you're gonna have to learn a lot and pick up a a lot of skills and you still have a high probability of failing.
56:07Ethan Kho: Yeah, 100%. Like
56:11Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
56:11Ethan Kho: I I I love thinking in terms of understanding one's own competitive advantage very deeply and and squeezing the juice out of that. And then also on top of that, I agree with you in saying that true competitive advantage is found in the intersection. um, I would argue, uh, between two inversely correlated things. Right? This social media thing, and then you being, you know, not AI researcher level, not math PhD level, but being still top percentile uh math and CS. I mean you were a trader at SIG, that at least at the very minimum means something. right? Uh it's it's it's it's incredibly powerful.
56:55Alex Monahan: And you can't you can like you couldn't it's hard to outwork someone again who likes it. Like for me, I I loved sports betting. I was doing it all the time. I I enjoyed trading. But when people are like you were an expert trader, it's like, I mean, I traded at SIG
57:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): for
57:09Alex Monahan: like five months, then I quit. It's like I was not a top, top trader, and these are super complex stories. I'd be putting up YouTube videos at midnight on a Friday. It's like whatever, like we got college football tomorrow. I mean, for me it was fun. For a lot of people, it was horribly boring in work. So I think the intersection, exactly as you said, it's like you have to figure out your competitive advantage. What do you like? What do you care about? And um
57:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what
57:37Alex Monahan: are you at least somewhat good at? Like you know, Mom Dani or whatever the New York, your your probably favorite mayor. Um, like he'd probably be a terrible quant trader, maybe not, but you know, like he's really good at speaking, so I think he picked the right lane. Um
57:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
57:54Alex Monahan: just kind of figuring that out, I think, is very important. And I spend a lot of time still thinking about.
58:00Ethan Kho: Real quick. Uh
58:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is
58:04Ethan Kho: there any one trait that your most successful friends have in common? Other than they're hardworking, etc. Because that everyone knows you ought to work hard. Is there any understanding that they have? Anything they figured out? You know, just to give you a bit more flavor for the sort of stuff that I'd love to hear.
58:22Alex Monahan: I mean, I don't know if these are specific enough, but I'd say like scrappiness. and willingness to do anything to make their their project or or whatever they're trying to do succeed. Because at this point from Stanford, from kids I know at MIT, a lot of very successful people and just scrappiness I think is very important. I think also it's just like willing to do whatever it takes. So I think in the case of Odds Jam, there were a lot of things I probably wasn't comfortable with. My co-founder didn't know how to do. And there's some people I think who like box themselves in so much, especially in the realm of business, like, oh, I'm not good at sales. It's like, well, you're starting a company. So you're gonna have to figure out sales. You're gonna have to figure out marketing. Um that's like a kind of high level one, is you're just like I'll figure it out.
59:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): No,
59:19Ethan Kho: no, that that makes perfect sense. Um and I think what you've encapsulated there is just
59:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
59:26Ethan Kho: is that simple. You just have to figure something out, figure out your competitive advantage, figure out what it is you can do with that competitive advantage, and then just keep just keep running, don't stop, and keep moving. Thank you so much for Alex, coming on Odds on Open. This was wonderful, man.
59:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Thank
59:42Alex Monahan: you, Ethan.