David Tinsley discusses K-shaped economy dynamics, consumer spending by income cohort, and recession indicators.
Summary
Host Will Compernolle and David Tinsley analyze the current state of the US economy, debating the validity of the 'K-shaped' narrative. Tinsley argues that wage growth has converged across income cohorts, effectively closing the gap for most Americans, though the top 5% still exhibit distinct spending behaviors. He highlights that the top 10% drive 36% of discretionary spending, making the economy sensitive to equity market corrections. Tinsley identifies middle-income households as most vulnerable to interest rate hikes due to mortgage exposures, while lower-income groups are more sensitive to essential goods prices. The discussion concludes with specific indicators for potential recession, including payroll declines and labor market drying.
Key takeaways
- 1 Energy, groceries, housing, and healthcare make up over 60% of the budget for the bottom 10% of households, compared to only 30% for the top 10%, making lower-income groups more sensitive to price spikes in these categories.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) · 12:10
Episode sections
- 1:14 – 3:13
Market Update: Elections, CPI, and Fed Policy
Host Will Compernolle reports that Democrats won majority control of both the House and Senate in recent midterm elections, initially boosting markets before tech stocks fell on regulation fears. He notes October CPI rose 0.4% headline and 0.3% core, leading traders to price in a December Fed rate hike. Yields rose 10-20 basis points, with 10-year yields near 5% and long bonds near 5.35%, while October payrolls grew by 165,000 and unemployment fell to 4.1%.
- 3:13 – 11:34
Defining the K-Shaped Economy and Income Growth Trends
David Tinsley explains that the K-shaped economy refers to a gap in spending and wage growth between high and low-income households. He notes that Bank of America data shows all income cohorts have seen rising spending growth, with the gap being one of growth rates rather than levels. He describes three phases: post-pandemic favoring lower incomes, mid-2024 to 2025 favoring higher incomes, and a current normalization where wage growth is similar across cohorts.
- 11:34 – 22:00
Wealth Effects and Consumption Concentration
Tinsley states that the top 10% of households contribute about 36% of discretionary spending. He argues that the wealth effect is strongest for directly held equities among the top 5%, while housing and retirement accounts have weaker effects due to illiquidity and lack of awareness. He warns that a significant equity market correction could disproportionately impact top earners' spending.
- 22:00 – 25:09
Interest Rate Sensitivity and Labor Market Risks
Tinsley identifies middle-income households as most sensitive to interest rate hikes due to mortgage exposures and rental costs, whereas lower-income households are less levered and higher-income households are insulated by fixed rates and asset positions. He suggests that a labor market slowdown in AI-related sectors could spill over to lower and middle-income spending, while a stock market correction would primarily hit the top 5%.
- 25:09 – 31:19
Demographic Shifts and Consumer Resilience Indicators
Tinsley notes that retirees spend more on groceries and travel but less on restaurants due to having more time to cook. He identifies two potential recession indicators: a consistent decline in payrolls or a broadening labor market drying up, and a large correction in the S&P 500 affecting the top 5% of consumers.
Claims worth verifying
Democrats won majority control of both the House and Senate in last week's midterm elections.
Will Compernolle ·1:14
How to verify: Check official results from the Federal Election Commission (FEC) or major news outlets for the most recent midterm election cycle prior to the podcast release date. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
October CPI rose 0.4% headline and 0.3% core.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·1:50
How to verify: Consult the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) Consumer Price Index report for October 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Traders are fully pricing in a December rate hike with another 25 basis points of tightening by the end of the first quarter.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·1:50
How to verify: Check CME FedWatch Tool or CME futures prices for December 2026 and Q1 2026 Fed funds rates. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
10-year treasury yields are anchored close to 5%, while the long bond is back trading near 5.35%.
Will Compernolle ·2:30
How to verify: Check US Treasury yield data from the Federal Reserve Economic Data (FRED) or Bloomberg for the relevant date. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
October Jobs report showed payrolls grew by an unexpectedly strong 165,000, while the unemployment rate ticked down a tenth to 4.1%.
Will Compernolle ·2:30
How to verify: Consult the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) Employment Situation Summary for October 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Bank of America Institute looks at data upwards of seventy million consumer and small business accounts.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·4:45
How to verify: Review Bank of America Institute publications or press releases detailing their data coverage scope. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Lower income wage growth after tax was growing around five percent year over year in 2023 and into 2024.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·6:27
How to verify: Cross-reference Bank of America Institute wage data with BLS Current Employment Statistics or Census Bureau data for post-pandemic wage trends. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Lower income wage growth was about one percent throughout 2025, and higher income wage growth reached about four percent by the end of 2025.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·7:08
How to verify: Check Bank of America Institute reports or BLS data for wage growth by income quintile/decile for 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The top ten percent of households contribute about thirty six percent of overall discretionary spending.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·15:27
How to verify: Verify against Bank of America Institute spending data or Census Bureau Consumer Expenditure Survey breakdowns by income decile. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The One Big Beautiful Bill Act delivered roughly around a hundred billion of stimulus into the accounts mainly via higher tax refunds.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·13:10
How to verify: Review the text of the 'One Big Beautiful Bill Act' (or the actual legislation name if this is a misnomer) and Congressional Budget Office (CBO) cost estimates for tax refund impacts. For recent events, verify 2026-08-13 through 2026-11-13. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify Bank of America's consumer spending data methodology and sample size (70M+ accounts) via their official research reports.
- Check the latest Gini coefficient data from the US Census Bureau to confirm if inequality has stabilized or reversed recent trends.
- Review Q1 2026 GDP reports to validate claims of strong consumer performance and absolute spending run rates.
- Analyze S&P 500 valuation metrics and historical correlation with discretionary spending from the top 5% of households.
- Examine current mortgage rates and refinancing activity among middle-income households to assess interest rate sensitivity.
- Monitor construction and manufacturing payroll data to confirm if lower-income wage growth is indeed picking up as claimed.
- Review the text of the 'One Big Beautiful Bill Act' to verify the $100 billion stimulus amount and distribution method (tax refunds).
- Compare current CPI components (energy, groceries, housing) against historical budget shares for the bottom 10% to assess inflation sensitivity.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:14
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You're
- 0:14
- Will Compernolle: listening to Simply Put, a podcast from FHN Financial. I'm your host, Will Comprel. The term K-shaped Shaped economy has been used to explain the curious disconnect between resilient consumer spending and widespread equation. economic pessimism.
- 0:28
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): This
- 0:28
- Will Compernolle: framework suggests strong consumption growth is being sustained by an increasingly narrow share of households at the top of the income distribution. This would imply not only a particularly fragile consumer, but also a very specific kind of interest rate sensitivity, as the Fed adjusts policy to bring the economy into better balance.
- 0:47
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): On
- 0:47
- Will Compernolle: today's episode, we talk with David Tinsley, managing director and senior. economist at the Bank of America Institute, about the variation in spending growth across income groups, how changes in wealth affect consumption patterns, and which consumers will feel the biggest bite from tighter fed policy. Stay tuned.
- 1:14
- Will Compernolle: Coming up soon our interview with David Tinsley, but first a quick market update.
- 1:27
- Will Compernolle: Democrats won majority control of both the House and Senate in last week's midterm elections. Although financial markets initially rallied, the prospect of tighter regulation on AI and data center construction eventually weighed on tech stocks. The dust is far from settled and investors hope to receive some clarity about Democrats' policy goals over the next two months before the
- 1:47
- Will Compernolle: new representatives are sworn in in January.
- 1:50
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
- 1:50
- Will Compernolle: October CPI rose 0.4% headline and 0.3% core, both surprising to the upside by a tenth of a percentage point. After Fed Governor Chris Waller gave a decidedly hawkish speech earlier that day, traders are now fully pricing in a December hike with another 25 basis points of tightening happening by the end of the first quarter.
- 2:10
- Will Compernolle: Subsequent Fed officials reiterated Waller's belief that the Fed could not be overly patient in its commitment to restoring price stability. Yields are up 10 to 20 basis points on balance over the last two weeks, primarily from this week's hot October CPI. Intermediate treasuries had rallied initially after the tech. sell-off on the premise that a slower pace of AI investment would
- 2:30
- Will Compernolle: cool the economy and necessitate a less aggressive path for Fed policy. 10-year treasury yields are anchored close to 5%, while the long bond is back trading near 5.35%. Last week, the October Jobs report showed payrolls grew by an unexpectedly strong 165,000, while the unemployment rate ticked down a tenth to 4.1%.
- 2:50
- Will Compernolle: Investors and FOMC participants were largely unfazed by the report, maintaining confidence in the labor market without worrying about overheating. That's all for the market update this time. Now our interview with David Tinsley.
- 3:13
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Our
- 3:13
- Will Compernolle: guest today is David Tinsley, Managing Director and Senior Economist at the Bank of America Institute. David, thanks for coming on the podcast.
- 3:21
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Of course, thanks for having me.
- 3:23
- Will Compernolle: Our topic today is the K-shaped economy: the extent to which the post-pandemic recovery has affected groups differently, and what it could mean for the future economic trajectory. David, to start things off, tell us more about this term K-shaped economy. When people say the economy is K-shaped, what sorts of economic conditions or
- 3:43
- Will Compernolle: patterns are they trying to illustrate?
- 3:46
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Well, usually they're talking about both spending and wage growth, and they're normally implying a large and growing, potentially growing anyway, gap between household buy income. So in other words, over the course of this K-shaped
- 4:05
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): debate, it's been widely put that higher income households have been doing better in some sense. You know, they've been spending faster, their wage growth has also been better. That's the kind of basics of it.
- 4:19
- Will Compernolle: So I want to dig into that a little bit more because the letter K, the downward slope suggests that yes, there is not only widening. inequality, but also those lower groups are worse off, right? If their standard of living was saying the same, it would be a horizontal line. So at least in the use of the letter K,
- 4:39
- Will Compernolle: that is the implication, right? That the lower income groups are doing worse than they were before.
- 4:45
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 4:45
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): guess that's right. I mean, I would caveat that. One of the virtues of uh the Bank of America. Institute is, you know, we're looking at data upwards of seventy million consumer and small business accounts in Bank of America's customer base. And when we split our data by income, so top third, bottom middle
- 5:05
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): third, bottom third, what we have seen is all of those cohorts have seen rising spending growth. It's not as if the lowest cohort has seen uh decline, negative rates of growth. So I think in that sense, the gap is a gap in growth rate, not really in
- 5:25
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): levels, I'd say.
- 5:26
- Will Compernolle: I do want to get to uh consumption trends in just a bit, but let's talk about income growth. So looking at the US by population, over the past few years, how has income growth differed across the US? Is it really widening inequality, or is this narrative a bit overstated?
- 5:46
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
- 5:47
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): you know, what's quite interesting is you can split this kind of post pandemic phases into kind of like three distinct phases. You have the period immediately after the pandemic, which was a period where people were going out, they were spending some of the accumulated uh stimulus checks and doing things we hadn't
- 6:06
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): done when they were under the kind of auspices of social distancing, etc. And that was actually quite a favorable environment for the labor market for the lower income households. There you saw rapid jobs growth in and kind of high touch services, retail distribution, etc. And in our
- 6:27
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): data you saw lower income wage growth after tax wage growth, sort of growing around five percent year over year in twenty twenty three and into twenty twenty four. And really there wasn't such a growth at that time in the higher income households. So at that period of time, this was quite a favorable period
- 6:46
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): for lower income households. But then when you get to about the middle of
- 6:51
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): 2024 into 2025, you get to a period where really, to some extent, that post pandemic wave has run its course, and then things go into reverse, and then you get a period where
- 7:08
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): lower income wage growth is softer, about one percent throughout twenty twenty five in our data, and a high higher income wage growth as that part of the labour market firms up and they reach about four percent by the end of twenty twenty five. So in other words, over those two phases you see uh lower income do
- 7:27
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): better at the start and then the baton switch to higher income. And then kind of what's interesting right now in our data is that the K has shut.
- 7:37
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 7:38
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): as you go in into the middle of twenty twenty six as of the September data, what you see is as of the October data, what you actually see is the fact the wage growth is more or less the same actually across cohorts now. And I think one of the reasons for that is parts
- 7:58
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): of the lower income labour market have picked up some, in all honesty, again. So when you think of the jobs growth we have seen, although the overall picture has been cooler, you know there's been more of a broadening in labour market growth in construction and manufacturing, etc. So I think that's part of the story. So kind of three distinct phases and then looking
- 8:18
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): across all of them, I don't think you'd necessarily say that inequality has widened across the whole period. For example you look at popular measures like the genie coefficient of inequality, income inequality, what you've tended to see for decades is rising inequality.
- 8:38
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): And then the pandemic really saw a kind of stalling out of that and then some narrowing inequality over that first phase, then some rewidening and now kind of flat. So I think that's the overall pitch picture. In some sense, the focus on the last couple of years does exaggerate the importance of decay.
- 8:58
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I think that's a fair point.
- 8:59
- Will Compernolle: I think putting that into three separate chapters, so to speak, is so helpful because there are so many big shocks during the pandemic, and you can really m tell a different story based on where your starting point is. But if we look at the most recent chapter. that you described, if we were to extend those trends and
- 9:19
- Will Compernolle: kind of assume that we're in, you know, the dust has settled and this is the new normal, is this pretty comparable to what we saw before the pandemic? And I guess what I'm getting at is if we want to try to explain consumption patterns, income patterns right now, is this unique narrative of the case? K-shaped
- 9:39
- Will Compernolle: economy helpful, or are we really just going back to what was the normal for the decade before 2020?
- 9:47
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Well, I think as of now, the K-shaper's narrative has run its course. I think right now we're in a period where there are small discrepancies across the income cohorts. In actual fact, for example, in the uh wage age. data that we look at from our own customers, lower income households
- 10:07
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): are seeing slightly faster wage growth. But these are small differences. If you look back decades, by and large, the discrepancies across these income cohorts has not been so huge. And I think we are probably back into that kind of period actually. Yeah. A period of you could call it normalization. I've got two
- 10:27
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): caveats though. One is the current run rate of spending growth and potentially wage growth in our data is high. We've had a very good middle of 2026 in terms of the kind of macro data for the consumer. You saw it in the first quarter GDP
- 10:47
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): figure, too. While, in a sense, the discrepancies of normalized. have normalized, the actual growth rates we're seeing right now are probably a little bit above normal in all honesty. And then the other second caveat I'd make is that when we split our own data, look at just the top five percent of households by income. So
- 11:07
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): these are the guys that have really very high compared to the rest of the population anyway, high income levels and are probably the households where a lot of the equities reside, a lot of the financial wealth resides. Their spending growth is still stronger than the rest of the pack. There is a sense of the K from the five
- 11:26
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): percent downwards does more or less converge, but the very highest earners are still outspending the You're rest. right.
- 11:34
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 11:34
- Will Compernolle: do want to talk a little bit more about the wealth effect uh in a bit, but let's shift to consumption patterns, specifically for food and gas. So the consumption profile across the population obviously differs. Some people dine out more than others, use more medical services, have to pay for lots of childcare or none at all. And the
- 11:54
- Will Compernolle: CPI is meant to be representative of this average, but very few people actually live as that average. So when we think about the spike in prices, this year for food and energy specifically, how has that experience varied across different income groups?
- 12:10
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): You know, that's a great point. I mean, these averages can feel a lot of variation. And you know, uh, one household's dollar is not the same as another household's dollar. Um, and just simply uh, in you know, some of the categories you were discussing there. energy, groceries, housing, healthcare, for the bottom ten
- 12:31
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): percent of households by income, they make up in excessive sixty percent of their wallet. Whereas for the top ten percent of households by income, they're only making up about thirty percent of their wallet. So any percentage change you're seeing in something like the oil price, speeding being through fruited, to gasoline prices, you know, it hits hit the low.
- 12:50
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): lower income consumers considerably harder. There's no doubt about that. Now this year, one of the offsetting factors, well there are two really, one of the offsetting factors has been the OBBA, the One Big Beautiful Bill Act. You know, that did deliver I think roughly around a
- 13:10
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): hundred billion of stimulus into the accounts mainly via higher tax refunds of consumers, and that was pretty well spread across the income distribution. So that was one factor that allowed households to weather the higher gas prices, most obviously, over the spring.
- 13:30
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): And then I guess the other point to make is just this pickup Pick up in the wage growth data we've seen, where we've seen some genuine pick pickup up at the lower end, which has also, I think, helped the lower income consumers weather the gas shock. It certainly has a discontinuous impact across the income distribution.
- 13:50
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): To be completely frank, if you'd have told me at the start of this year we were going to see uh gas prices where they were over the you know the last six months, I would have been amazed to expect the strength of consumer spending and discretionary consumer spending we've seen nonetheless
- 14:10
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): over that period. So by and large, households and obviously again, you know, averages do hide different stress in the distributions. By and large, households have weathered this gas shock pretty amazingly well.
- 14:24
- Will Compernolle: Past food and gas, let's talk more about that. Let's talk about overall consumption. This K-shaped framework has been brought up a lot recently to explain that curious contradiction where so many people are reporting economic hardship and yet the economy is growing close to or above potential. And the thinking is: if there's enough spending from the top of
- 14:44
- Will Compernolle: the income distribution that can sustain aggregate demand in the economy, so there's not a recession, even if a sizable chunk of the population is experiencing significant challenges. What do the data say? Has the concentration of spending changed over the past few years to the point where
- 15:04
- Will Compernolle: it would support this argument?
- 15:07
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): In terms of the share that higher income households contribute to overall consumer spending, it's definitely the case. they make outsized contributions. So if you just look at discretionary spending, so you strip out the kind of must haves, utilities, healthcare, gas, housing, etc., then the
- 15:27
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): top ten percent of households, they're contributing about thirty six percent, I think, of overall discretionary spending, so more than a third, even though they're only ten percent by number. And so they do punch above their weight. As I was saying, the top five percent of
- 15:47
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): households we do see in our credit and debit card data, their spending growth is running ahead of overall spending growth. So the economy is still getting an outsized booth boost from the wealth effect hitting the higher income consumers. Because I was saying
- 16:07
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): really, the normalization and the closing of the K means that this argument can be overdone a little bit right now. Actually, one of the striking things in our data is the breadth of spending growth. You know, as I was saying, the K UK is shut, lower income spending growth is has picked up, and even when you look across retail and services.
- 16:27
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): spending categories, you see a very broad growth. Around 70% of retail spending on discretionary goods in our data is rising by volume. So, in other words, there's a very broad floating of all boats in terms of consumer spending. But at the end of the day,
- 16:46
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if
- 16:46
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): you were to see an equity market retrenchment, for example,
- 16:51
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): and a pullback of that top five, ten percent of household, they would make an outsized contribution on the downside as well. You know, we do have to keep watching those guys, those higher income folks, but it is quite a broad story right now.
- 17:07
- Will Compernolle: Let's talk more about the wealth effect. And the thinking here is that um even if people's paychecks are not keeping up with their growth and expenses to the extent that we might think, if they see that their retirement accounts and their house value is going up, they'll feel more comfortable spending. Does the
- 17:27
- Will Compernolle: data prove that? I mean, it it sounds intuitive, but I'm not even sure how often people are checking their there 401ks were
- 17:34
- Will Compernolle: or checking what price houses are selling for around them. How much weight do you put on this idea of the wealth effect?
- 17:41
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): When you think about the wealth effect, I think you r you you make a good point. You've got to break that down by the form of wealth and the liquidity of that wealth. So housing as an example is one of the more broadly distributed forms of wealth. By no means everybody, but sort of sixty sixty-five five percent or so of the population are homeowners, even
- 18:01
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): many of them have a mortgage. where may well have some equity. But like you would say, the ability to sell your property right now uh in a very flat market is limited. For those guys, I'm not sure the wealth effect is particularly strong, even if the house prices were rising fast, which of course they're not.
- 18:21
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): And I think similar argument would apply to, you know, your retirement accounts too. As you say, many people aren't really aware of the value in their account. And even if they were, they wouldn't feel particularly inclined to tap those savings. I mean they're there to support them in old age. I think
- 18:41
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): one area though where the wealth effect seems to have most traction is really directly held equities ultimately. So households that actually hold the S and P, you know, or companies within it, when we've looked at how variations in the
- 19:01
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): S and P translate into changes in discretionary spending by the very top earners compared to the rest, we do see a relatively decent correlation between the two. So in other words, when the S P is rising or when equity is more broadly a rising, that does seem to boost
- 19:21
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): the top earners' spending. But I do think you'll make a good point that the broader wealth effect is probably fairly weak.
- 19:31
- Will Compernolle: So does that mean can uh given the concentration of spending in and that top five percent, how they represent a large larger share of the overall economic spending, and they're also sensitive to rising stock prices, if we do see a pullback in equities, let's say from, oh, I don't know, this whole
- 19:51
- Will Compernolle: AI thing doesn't fully live up to the hype, do you suspect then that there could be a sharp downturn in consumer spending because those equity holders are the ones that are checking their accounts.
- 20:05
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I think that's quite plausible. I mean the question is how big the league correction would need to be. And because the market has ramped so much over two or three years, we've seen very large gains in people's positions. So I think yes, if there was a sell sell-off off large enough, and we may be
- 20:25
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): talking ten, twenty percent sorry hard to put a precise number on it, but a large sell-off that also impacts confidence, that would most likely have a dent on the very highest income spenders. And given, you know, what we were talking about, our outsized contribution to spending, that would
- 20:45
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): certainly knock not the macro data. The outstanding question then would be what about everybody else? Now, if that correction was occurring because these very large numbers in terms of uh CapEx in a AI were not proving profitable
- 21:05
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): and there was a pullback there, then I guess a plausible scenario would be also a slowdown in the labour market in those parts of the economy closely allied with the AI grid build out, boom. And then you probably would get a follow through from lower and middle income
- 21:25
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): households also seeing a slowdown in spending as a result of that labour market correction. But you know, there's obviously a lot of ifs and buts in that. It's very much dependent on how this AI story in the broadest sense plays out.
- 21:40
- Will Compernolle: Another example of how the path of AI seems to determine the path of the overall economy. Um the Fed raises interest rates to bring demand into better balance with supply, and part of this is by slowing down investment. But on the consumer side, higher rates could affect asset prices, so it affects the wealth effect, but they also make it more expensive to
- 22:00
- Will Compernolle: borrow using things like credit cards. Where do you think we see consumption being most sensitive to Fed hikes? Where on the income distribution will consumption go down the most?
- 22:11
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): In terms of the income distribution, this is really a middle income story. So when you think of lower income households, we're making general characterizations here, but a lot of their spending is on necessities and they have limited room and probably limited capacity to borrow in any case. So
- 22:32
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): almost by dint of that financial situation, they're probably less levered uh and less exposed to interest rates. When you think about the top end, see the top end tends to be where the assets sit to. I think you're making the reasonable point about the wealth effect after hitting hitting their bottom line.
- 22:52
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): But aside from that, the kind of cash flow effects of higher rates are probably not so important for them. But then you kind of got the guys in the middle who are kind of like a mixture of homeowners with uh mortgages. Potentially some of those guys are on fixed rates, taken out a number of years ago, and for a good
- 23:12
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): time they were are insulated from fed time. tightening. Uh but then you've got this almost kind of like this post pandemic cohort of prospectives and new buyers who come through who are either tied to higher rates or in currently in rental and are not able to contemplate the
- 23:32
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): higher rates that are coming through. So it's kind of mixed picture. I think interest rate sensitivity net net is probably
- 23:39
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): relative to history is probably a bit low, to be honest, because of these fixed rates and then these solid asset positions on higher income households books. But where the
- 23:51
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): most bang for the buck from the Fed rate hiking cycle occurs, I think is probably in the middle of the income pack.
- 23:59
- Will Compernolle: Given how concentrated overall consumer spending is at the top, and because interest rates are this blunt instrument that pinches all of the population, you know, the Fed can't target it specifically at one sector or one region, does that mean that for consumer spending to slow down enough to bring supply
- 24:19
- Will Compernolle: and demand into better balance, the middle part of the distribution is going to get pinched more until that higher income? slows down its spending enough or is it a little bit more complicated than that?
- 24:31
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
- 24:31
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I think it'll come back back to what happens on in the equity space, won't it? I mean, if we have a you know a stock market that's relatively resilient to higher yields, then that's probably a plausible story that we'll have to keep bearing down, if you like, in terms of monetary policy terms, in terms of kind of like the middle income
- 24:51
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): perhaps the sort of generationally middle of the pack too, you know, the kind of millennials and the Gen X, they'll feel that pressure most. But if the stock market were to correct, the equity market were to correct, then I think it could be a slightly different story where the top of the pack has the higher delta.
- 25:09
- Will Compernolle: Another thing you've published work on recently is the impact of an aging consumer. So we talk a lot about how baby boomer retirements mean slower labor force growth, bigger government transfers, or what it means for home sales. But I haven't heard people focus as much on how this demographic shift also changes the spending profile of consumers. What are
- 25:29
- Will Compernolle: the main differences in spending between those 60 Sixteen and over and everyone else?
- 25:35
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): In some respects, this is a sort of obvious point. But people with retirement who retire have more time and they don't work. So what you find in the data is that they have about two hours extra leisure time a day. And how do they spend that? I mean, one slightly counterfactual thing is you might think they're going out to dine more, but in our spending data,
- 25:55
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): when we slice it across these age groups, we find actually spend less on restaurants and the rest of the age ranges. And I think that partly speaks to the fact that when you have more time on your hands, you've got more time to prepare food. And so their grocery bill tends to be bigger actually than uh than the rest of the age groups, uh while
- 26:15
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): their restaurant bill as a share of total spending is less. But they do spend more as you might expect on travel. And not forgetting of course, there's a huge chunk of this accumulated wealth people talk about in the economy, both housing equity and of course the e uh the rising equity prices that sits on this older
- 26:35
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): consumers balance sheet. So they'll spend that in what I would think of as mainly kind of sir discretionary services space, travel, tourism. There may be an opportunity for restaurants that to, you know to tap more of those dollars uh if they focus on those consumers some more. To some extent quite obvious
- 26:55
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): uh trends.
- 26:56
- Will Compernolle: So to close things out, we know there's been this surprising resilience of the US consumer these past few years, but where do you think the signs of eventual cracks will emerge? Is there a particular group that you think could be the proverbial canary in the coal mine that signals a pending recession?
- 27:15
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Well I think I would look to the labour market data most obviously there. If the broadening in uh the labour market uh dries up, or indeed if payrolls start to decline consistently, I would begin to be concerned about the resilience of the
- 27:34
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): overall consumer picture. And then in a very kind of high frequency sense, if there's a large correction in the S P in the stock market at some point, and I think it needs to be large, then I would be concerned for that higher end consumer. So there's kind of two legs to it really.
- 27:54
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): One a slightly lower frequency one, which is the labour labor market, and then the higher frequency one is definitely uh asset market.
- 28:04
- Will Compernolle: David Tinsley, thanks for coming on the podcast.
- 28:07
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Thanks so much.
- 28:19
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That
- 28:20
- Will Compernolle: was David Tinsley, managing director and senior economist with the Bank of America Institute.
- 28:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 28:25
- Will Compernolle: think the biggest takeaway for me from that conversation is David's sense that a downturn in the labor market is the most likely catalyst for a slowdown in consumer spending.
- 28:33
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): A
- 28:34
- Will Compernolle: decline in equity prices would have an impact on the consumption of the top 5% of households, but it would have to be a truly significant correction to cause the kind of fall in consumer spending that leads to a recession.
- 28:45
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): As
- 28:45
- Will Compernolle: he said, the K-shaped narrative has largely run its course at this point, and the breadth of spending growth across the populations suggests the consumer is in quite good shape despite all the headwinds of the past few years. October retail sales next Tuesday will give a first glimpse of the strength of fourth quarter consumer spending. The following week, consumer confidence and SP's
- 29:05
- Will Compernolle: preliminary PMIs will add to the existing survey data for November. The day before Thanksgiving, the October core PCE deflator is expected to rise 0.3%. which we believe will further affirm expectations for a December rate hike.
- 29:19
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
- 29:19
- Will Compernolle: FOMC minutes for the October meeting will be published next Wednesday, although recent commentary from Fed officials strongly suggests a 25 basis point rate increase is in the cards next month. Traders will be looking for more information regarding the committee's decision to leave rates unchanged last month. There are also a handful of additional Fed appearances over the
- 29:39
- Will Compernolle: next two weeks before the pre-meeting communications blackout begins the day after Thanksgiving. Chairman Warsh is scheduled to give opening remarks on November 16th at a conference in San Francisco, hosted by the Fed's Productivity and Jobs Task Force. That's all for today's episode. Thanks again for listening. I'm Will Compernal, macro strategist with FHN Financial.
- 29:59
- Will Compernolle: This episode was edited by Bill Stanfield. Don't forget to like and subscribe. to Simply Put wherever you get your podcasts. Email Simply Put at FHN Financial.com with any questions or comments.
- 30:23
- Will Compernolle: This podcast is presented for informational purposes only and is not intended as an offer or solicitation with respect to the purchase or sale of any security. Views expressed herein accurately reflect the speaker's personal views about the data, news, trends, events, etc., discussed herein or any subject securities or issuers. No part of their compensation was,
- 30:43
- Will Compernolle: is, or will be, directly or indirectly, related to any specific recommendations or views expressed. FHN Financial through First Horizon. Bank or its affiliates offers investment products and services. Investment products are not FDIC insured, have no bank guarantee, and may lose value