Macro & Volatility™

Purvis and Silva discuss AI's 'awkward adolescence', regulatory headwinds, and inflation impacts on markets.

30 min Listen to the original Episode page
Artificial IntelligenceFederal ReserveMacroeconomicsMarket VolatilityTech SectorCredit Markets

Summary

Michael Purvis characterizes the current AI sector as being in an 'awkward adolescence' where high input costs and potential regulatory pressures from a 'blue wave' election outcome may slow data center build-outs, favoring large scale players over smaller firms. Josh Silva notes that trading has become more difficult since 2019 due to the end of the zero-interest-rate era, with rising credit spreads hindering short-term AI infrastructure growth. Purvis contrasts the current boom with the 1990s tech bubble, citing today's sponsors as unregulated monopolies with strong balance sheets, though he questions the long-term economics of trillions in AI CapEx. Silva warns that unprofitable tech companies face existential risk if build-out timelines extend, potentially leading to bankruptcies. The speakers also discuss how AI spending has boosted GDP but driven up inflation, limiting the Fed's ability to control prices via rates.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    generate trillions of dollars of revenue at a at a nice high margin. And so it's not clear of these hyperscalers, do all four four of them win?

    Michael Purvis · 8:05

Episode sections

  1. 0:00 – 1:09

    Intro and AI Inflection Point

    Eric Bender introduces the episode, noting recent market disruptions and the upcoming Anthropic IPO. He frames the discussion around AI's current stage, asking Michael Purvis for his assessment of the sector's trajectory following the initial optimism of 2024 and 2025.

  2. 1:09 – 3:26

    AI's 'Awkward Adolescence' and Regulatory Pressures

    Michael Purvis describes the current AI phase as an 'awkward adolescence' where high input costs and potential regulatory pressures from a 'blue wave' election outcome may slow data center build-outs. He argues this environment favors large, well-capitalized 'scale players' while threatening smaller, capital-constrained firms.

  3. 3:26 – 5:53

    Trading Difficulty and Credit Market Signals

    Josh Silva notes that trading has become difficult since 2019 due to the end of the zero-interest-rate era. He highlights that rising credit spreads and higher capital costs will hinder short-term AI infrastructure growth, though he expects long-term winners to emerge among hyperscalers.

  4. 5:53 – 9:06

    Comparison to 1990s Tech Boom

    Purvis contrasts the current AI boom with the late 1990s tech/telecom bubble, noting that today's sponsors (Google, Microsoft) are unregulated monopolies with strong balance sheets, unlike the startups and regulated utilities of the 90s. However, he questions the long-term business economics and TAM for trillions in AI CapEx.

  5. 9:06 – 11:39

    Winners, Losers, and Capital Constraints

    Silva argues that while large tech firms are financially robust, unprofitable tech companies face a tough path as funding costs rise. He warns that companies assuming rapid two-year build-outs may fail if timelines extend to five years, potentially leading to bankruptcies that larger firms could acquire.

  6. 11:39 – 20:07

    Fed Policy and Market Volatility

    Silva expresses concern over potential Fed rate hikes, citing hawkish signals from governors. He observes that the VIX EQ versus VIX index ratio is rising, similar to late-dot-com levels, indicating increasing macro risk and decreasing micro risk as investors sell calls and buy puts.

  7. 20:07 – 24:54

    AI's Impact on Inflation and GDP

    Purvis estimates AI spending boosted GDP by 60-80 basis points but also drove up PPIs and consumer inflation through supply chain crowding. He argues that demand from hyperscalers is interest-rate insensitive, but broader inflation is supply-driven, limiting the Fed's ability to control it via rates.

  8. 24:54 – 29:39

    Recession Risks and Fixed Asset Booms

    Silva suggests the Fed risks causing a recession if it hikes rates aggressively, arguing they are behind the curve on inflation data. Purvis counters that rate hikes may be necessary to create room for future cuts if a recession follows a fixed-asset boom, noting historical precedents where fixed assets exceeded 20% of GDP.

Assets discussed

AssetKindStanceContext
AlphabetGOOGLequityneutralToday it's different because the big companies are companies like Google and Microsoft, right, which are basically to a degree. sort of incredibly successful, unregulated monopolies, right?
MicrosoftMSFTequityneutralToday it's different because the big companies are companies like Google and Microsoft, right, which are basically to a degree. sort of incredibly successful, unregulated monopolies, right?
NVIDIANVDAequityneutralAnd so to me, the it's not about earnings faltering for NVIDIA in 2027 or probably even 2028.
S&P 500indexneutralI think there's another point I want to make here, which is let's just talk about the SP 500, the market cap SP 500.
AppleAAPLequityneutralSo I think the overall sort of sharp ratio, if you will, the volatility adjusted returns for the S P 500, we're going into a new place because we just, you know, okay, Apple can maybe still be Apple in a way.
Crude oilcommoditybearishnow as we've seen things like oil drop substantially, like we're seeing things like copper drop substantially today.
Coppercommoditybearishnow as we've seen things like oil drop substantially, like we're seeing things like copper drop substantially today.

“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.

Claims worth verifying

Anthropic has an upcoming IPO.

Eric Bender ·0:51

How to verify: Check financial news archives for November 2026 for announcements regarding Anthropic's IPO filing or listing date. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

AI entered a period of 'awkward adolescence' after optimism in 2024, 2025, and early 2026.

Michael Purvis ·1:29

How to verify: This is a subjective characterization; verify by checking if subsequent market analysis from late 2026/early 2026 uses similar terminology to describe AI sector performance. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

A 'blue wave' election outcome implies higher regulatory pressures and longer data center build times.

Michael Purvis ·2:09

How to verify: Review US election results from November 2026 and subsequent legislative/regulatory proposals affecting tech infrastructure and AI. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Hyperscalers (Google, Microsoft) are unregulated monopolies with strong balance sheets, unlike 1990s telecom sponsors.

Michael Purvis ·7:04

How to verify: Review SEC filings (10-K) for Google and Microsoft to confirm balance sheet strength and regulatory status; compare with historical regulatory filings for Verizon and AT&T. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

AI spending boosted GDP by 60-80 basis points.

Michael Purvis ·20:13

How to verify: Compare US GDP growth data from BEA with estimates of AI-related capital expenditure from Microsoft and Google filings to assess the correlation. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

The Fed is expected to hike rates by 50 basis points in December.

Josh Silva ·11:59

How to verify: Check Federal Reserve meeting minutes and CME FedWatch Tool data for November/December 2026 for rate hike expectations. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The VIX EQ versus VIX index ratio is at levels similar to the end of the dot-com bubble.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_3) ·19:15

How to verify: Retrieve historical VIX EQ and VIX index data from Bloomberg or CME Group and compare the ratio from November 2026 to late 2026/early 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Fixed asset investment as a percent of GDP reaching 20% has historically been followed by a recession.

Michael Purvis ·25:54

How to verify: Analyze historical US GDP data (BEA) and fixed asset investment data (Census Bureau) to identify periods where fixed assets exceeded 20% of GDP and check subsequent recession dates. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Oil prices dropped substantially below $80.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·24:40

How to verify: Check historical oil price data (WTI/Brent) from Bloomberg or Reuters for late 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Microsoft and Google CapEx estimates match the 60-80 basis point GDP boost estimate.

Michael Purvis ·20:32

How to verify: Review Microsoft and Google (Alphabet) quarterly earnings reports and capital expenditure disclosures for 2026-2026 and compare with US GDP growth figures. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Do your own research

  • Verify the 'blue wave' election outcome and its specific legislative implications for tech regulation and data center zoning.
  • Check current credit spreads for unprofitable tech companies and compare them to historical levels during the 2000-2002 dot-com bust.
  • Review the latest VIX EQ vs. VIX index ratio data to confirm if it is indeed at levels similar to late 1999/early 2000.
  • Analyze recent GDP and PPI reports to quantify the estimated 60-80 basis point contribution of AI spending to GDP and its impact on supply chain inflation.
  • Examine the balance sheets and cash flow statements of major hyperscalers (Google, Microsoft, etc.) to assess their ability to sustain multi-year CapEx cycles.
  • Look for evidence of data center construction delays or cost overruns reported by major construction firms or real estate investment trusts (REITs) focused on data centers.
  • Review Federal Reserve meeting minutes and governor speeches for hawkish signals regarding future rate hikes.
  • Compare current AI CapEx levels and revenue generation metrics to the telecom infrastructure build-out of the late 1990s to assess economic sustainability.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00
Eric Bender: Welcome to the 35th Macro and Volatility Podcast. Today is Wednesday, November 18th, 2026. My name is Eric Bender. I am joined by our two experts, Michael Purvis, CEO of Talbach and Capital Advisors, a cross-asset macro research firm, and Josh Silva, CIO of Pasaiic Partners, a derivative specialist and
0:20
Eric Bender: manager of institutional advisory assets. Before we dive into today's topics, we ask that if you like what you hear, please subscribe to Macro and Volatility on your
0:31
Eric Bender: podcast platform of choice, Bloomberg and LinkedIn. As always, Michael is available to discuss his institutional research offering and Josh is available to discuss his derivative solutions. All right, let's get into it. A lot has happened over the last uh few weeks since our last podcast. We've had elections, ground
0:51
Eric Bender: stops, outages, rumors of dirty bombs. And today we're looking forward to anthropics IPO. So we're gonna try and hone that down a little bit and really focus just on AI. Um, Michael, where are we at with AI and where are we going?
1:09
Michael Purvis: Well, it's been a uh pretty fascinating and and somewhat bizarre um series of developments here. But look, at the end of the day, AI, after all the AI optimism from 2024, 25, and the first part of this year, you know, we're going from that period into really sort of
1:29
Michael Purvis: what I would call a protracted um awkward adolescence. I think it's important to recognize that with this awkward adolescence, you know, the ultimate sponsor. sponsors, the parents, if you will, of this AI boom have been the biggest companies in the world, right? There that have had
1:49
Michael Purvis: historically fantastic balance sheets and fantastic free cash flow. Obviously, those two items are evolving here. But they're very strong sponsors. But I think, in spite of that, there's obviously an enormous series of unanswered questions. And I don't think we're going to get answers on a lot of them anytime soon. Um, I do think,
2:09
Michael Purvis: though, that I think the way things are setting up here is what are we all learning? We're learning, A, we had a blue wave, that probably means higher regulatory um pressures, um, which means ultimately things get more expensive, uh, uh, and it probably takes a lot longer to build out a lot of the data centers. Um We're also learning that
2:29
Michael Purvis: input cost continued to be very, very high. We continue to see that reflected in the economic data there. And I think what that probably means is
2:39
Michael Purvis: that whether you call it regulatory capture, whether you call it
2:45
Michael Purvis: you know, the an extended um duration of of build for this transformation. is that it's gonna favor the scale players. And anyone who's the the more vulnerable you are to access to capital to make your business plan work, uh the the the higher the chance that you're gonna get washed out ultimately
3:05
Michael Purvis: in this. Um uh there. And I think that's where where the markets are really dealing with right now is that that sort of stage here. But um there's there's still a s a series of other questions that I don't think we'll get answers to, but they're they're being asked by the markets every
3:21
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): day.
3:22
Eric Bender: Thanks, Michael. Uh Josh, what are you thinking on those lines?
3:26
Josh Silva: I mean, with my trading hat on, that's you know where I uh you know spend some of my career, I think. Am I investing half of which is my second part of my career? Um, I think investing and trading are are just not. gonna be easy. I think we've had a pretty easy environment since 2019, um, quite frankly, from a tr more from a trading perspective, in terms of themes,
3:46
Josh Silva: in terms of um uh uh momentum, in terms of like how you can buy time, you know, you know, buy breakouts and stuff like that. Um and I think 2026 has proven that to be very difficult. And you can see it in the numbers. And I think that's gonna going to continue to be difficult. I mean, as I like to say, trading is. a very hard way to make a living. And a lot of people are about to find
4:06
Josh Silva: out. I continue to believe there'll be clear winners and losers in the AI space. And with this current market environment being what it is, you know, I think it's important to recognize those. I I go back to sort of my old adjective, which is fixed income is sort of sometimes drives the bust. And I think credit markets are key to watch as credit um widens.
4:27
Josh Silva: out as capital markets get more difficult, I think it's going to be harder and harder for the AI trade to play out in the short term. In the long term, it's a different conversation, but in the short term, I think it's where it is. I think, you know, people forget like zero interest rates or zero made technical technology investing pretty easy and it
4:46
Josh Silva: pushed forward a lot of investments because the access to capital is so cheap. You can make large investments pretty cheaply for growth. That's gone away. And so you could sort of say we've this rapid pace of tech growth that we've seen is going to slow down. And so I'm not saying that it's over. I'm not saying AI isn't going to work. I'm just going to say
5:06
Josh Silva: this the pace of this is going to slow down. The higher cost of capital is going to impact future growth and again, future speed of the infrastructure build out. And therefore, like it's just going to take longer. And I think the market's reflecting that. I think the market's reflecting that in the stock prices. I think the market has gotten to that point. The
5:26
Josh Silva: question is, what's next? And I think the big thing is I think unprofitable tech is it's It's it's it's gonna it's gonna have a tough path. And large you know scale tech leaders, hyperscales. will will experience short-term pressures, but in the long term, like like Michael said, I think they're fine. I think they're they'll continue to do what they do, they might cut cap acts, which will help their
5:46
Josh Silva: stocks, quite frankly. Um, so that's kind of how I how I see it right now with the with with where we are currently.
5:53
Eric Bender: Thank you. So stay with me on this. We we touched on this a little bit in our last podcast, but I think it's worth revisiting. How does it compare with the tech telecom booth? boom in the late 1990s?
6:06
Michael Purvis: Yeah, I mean, uh Josh and I both have some scar tissue back from uh those days there. I think it's important to recognize that the sponsors
6:15
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of
6:15
Michael Purvis: the tech telecom boom back in the 90s,
6:19
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
6:20
Michael Purvis: certainly on the telecom side, were very much um sort of from the startup realm, and they were really you know, IPOing and high-yield bonds. And you saw companies like Global Crossings sort of come out of nowhere and ultimately merge with MCI and all that. And then on the other side of the spectrum, you had uh you know
6:39
Michael Purvis: highly regulated companies like Verizon and ATT, these giant um slower-moving A slower moving monoliths, they're there, and so much of the s the shareholder value creation story. was really
6:52
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): get
6:53
Michael Purvis: bought by one of those companies, right? Um there was sort of like a, you know, like in the company, the big company could say, hey, well, I could buy this company and get speed to time to market there. Um
7:04
Michael Purvis: and that was sort of part of the dynamic back then, right? Today it's different because the big companies are companies like Google and Microsoft, right, which are basically to a degree. sort of incredibly successful, unregulated monopolies, right? That have these skills in-house that move very, very quickly. And they've had
7:24
Michael Purvis: enormous balance sheets, right? So they're it's they're very different than the ATTs and Verizons of the late 1990s. Um
7:31
Michael Purvis: there. So the sponsorship here is is really fundamentally different. Um and I think that doesn't make it dramatically bigger. better. There's a lot of issues. I think that today's um AI boom
7:45
Michael Purvis: is considering that the tech boom didn't really have to. And part of it is simply gets down to what are the the you know, the the long-term business economics, what really is the TAM for all of this um AI spend? And you know, since we're now measuring it all in trillions of dollars of CapEx spend, well that basically that spend has to basically
8:05
Michael Purvis: generate trillions of dollars of revenue at a at a nice high margin. And so it's not clear of these hyperscalers, do all four four of them win? What is SpaceX's role with its terrestrial uh build out and potentially its space build out? There, like there's just a in a way, it's a there's a
8:25
Michael Purvis: lot more questions about the business. model. Back then in the 90s, it was like, oh, here's fiber and we can do wireless and we can shove a lot of bits through, people pay us a lot of money for it. Right. And obviously there was a litany of bankruptcies that all fell out of that uh out of that period there. But at least sort of like he sort of knew what the markers here. Here, we're I think we're uh the the
8:44
Michael Purvis: world's still sort of scraping together. What does this really look like four or five years from now? And so to me, the it's not about earnings faltering for NVIDIA in 2027 or probably even 2028. It's sort of what does the end game look like? And that cloud is haunting the ecosystem in a very different way than it
9:04
Michael Purvis: was in the late 90s.
9:06
Josh Silva: Yeah, I'm I'm I'm not gonna touch in the video right now until we have a clearer picture of like what is happening there. I just I've learned in my old days of just leave that alone until you there's more clarity. Um, you know, I I I just you know, my my general feeling is the AI picture started to change three months ago. Um, you know, and that then generally
9:26
Josh Silva: I believe, like, you know, I'm not saying that this isn't going to play out in five or six years. What I'm saying is the market is having it playing out in two years or a year and a half. And and I think that's off the table, quite frankly. I think this that that's sort of rapid growth, AI investment, the type of investment that happened, I think that's off the table. And I think
9:46
Josh Silva: that again, the landscape is getting more complex. So you're going to start seeing winners and losers.
9:53
Josh Silva: No, but no stretch of the imagination. The Cisco's today are the, you know, the Microsoft's and the Google, and they're in much, much better shape and much, much better PEs. much, much better balance sheets, and much, much better revenue growth. And so it's hard to see sort of the big guys really having a big bear market drawdown. We is I think Michael and I talked about
10:13
Josh Silva: it, you might see a PE drawdown, but like we don't necessarily see a growth thing. That being said, there are a lot of global crossings out there. And I think it's imperative to pay attention to that. Um, and the reason is because funding costs is cost gonna
10:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be.
10:26
Josh Silva: getting higher. I mean, one of the big issues I still go back to with dot com is as funding got more and more expensive, you know, people couldn't raise the capital that they needed to build things out that they needed to bill out, and they were eventually ran out of money. So the risk here is if there's companies that cash flows are assuming a build out of two years, and that becomes
10:46
Josh Silva: five, they're not going to make it. And so that's the risk. Again, this isn't going to impact Google and in Microsoft. In fact, it might actually help them,
10:56
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
10:56
Josh Silva: know, where they have the ability to acquire a company that's out of, let's say, bankruptcy or a company that runs out of cash flow that's built a very, very good business. And they'll be able to bring that in. Again, that's sort of like the five, six-year Year um build out. And as as I said before, I think this um this this this
11:16
Josh Silva: cost of capital is real, whether it's through credit markets or whether it's through the Fed, which we haven't really really got into. And so I continue to go with the broader market may avoid a bear market altogether, in fact. Um it doesn't mean that some of these names are not going to see a significant
11:36
Josh Silva: continued correction as they just run out of capital.
11:39
Josh Silva: Um, you know, and the last bit I want to talk about is you know, we talked about credit in credits reset, right? Credits reset higher, and that's just where it is, which is a good thing in the long term. But if the Fed you know comes in with the 50 basis points hike in December, which a lot of people are talking about, I don't I just don't see that being a good thing for equities.
11:59
Josh Silva: I think that's not gonna help equities, and I think the market in the last. and sort of bit of the sell-off is is saying that to a degree.
12:06
Eric Bender: Yeah, I think that's right, Josh. I think you're and this is leads to my next question here, Michael. Are we are we at an inflection point? Because it certainly feels like the markets are telling us that we're at an inflection point. There's a bit of uncertainty, there's you know various different dynamics going on. So are we at an inflection point as it relates to the markets and then markets?
12:26
Eric Bender: market volatility.
12:28
Michael Purvis: Well I think I think uh you guys are right. I think I think look we've gone from glass super half full to pretty half empty. And I don't think the half empty part of that is going to be turned around by earnings uh upgrades or analyst price target upgrades or what have you um
12:48
Michael Purvis: uh there I think I think it's just because ultimately this question ultimately, the whole ecosystem really comes back to this one core question, which is okay, if you if a bunch of companies spend X trillions of dollars, what are the recurring revenues and margins from that business, right? And I
13:08
Michael Purvis: don't think anyone really understands that. And until we get clarity on that, then NVIDIA will be the best buy ever, right? Like it'll probably be fantastic. And a lot of these other names that are levered to the um levered to the infrastructure build will be will be will be fantastic, right? But I just don't see that
13:28
Michael Purvis: answer to that question materializing decisively anytime time soon. And until it does, I think, I think it's a it's a it's a big sort of cloud host hope hovering over it. I think there's another point I want to make here, which is let's just talk about the SP 500, the market cap SP 500. For 15 years, that rally has been a
13:48
Michael Purvis: wonderful rally and it's really been underwritten by the core four, five, six giant tech companies, right? Which produce produced fantastic quantity of earnings growth and an incredible quality of earnings growth with fantastic moats motes and fantastic balance sheets, right?
14:03
Michael Purvis: All of a sudden, prospectively, well, what are the moats on this CapEx spend there? Now they may have their existing businesses still moted, but the new spend, which is a very big part of their business prospective business, what do the moats look like?
14:21
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
14:22
Michael Purvis: and what are the economics on that, right? Um, and then I think the other the other thing. we got to just uh keep in mind is that is that their ability to do things like, oh, you know, earnings are going to be a little soft and search if you're Google and let's just roll out a bunch of buybacks, right? I mean, that buyback machine is not what it is. So I think the overall sort of sharp ratio, if you will,
14:42
Michael Purvis: the volatility adjusted returns for the S P 500, we're going into a new place because we just, you know, okay, Apple can maybe still be Apple in a way. and and all that, but we just don't have those other companies anchoring the market um the um the way they do. So I think it's gonna be actually probably very good for stock
15:01
Michael Purvis: pickers to not have those guys pushing the market up so much for so long. But I do think it also So it makes the SP market cap index it's a little bit,
15:13
Michael Purvis: you know, it basically. it's gotta go into a lower PE um uh range.
15:18
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): And and and you know, part of that is that with with lower PEs happen in a higher rate environment, like kind of using old school 1970s technology. So, like this higher interest rate environment or the higher cost of capital, generally, if you look at the old theories, it should lower PEs to a certain degree. And I and I just keep going to the cost of capital. Like I I agree with with Michael in the
15:38
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): sense that. there's a lot of these big hyposcalers can take earnings and invest, but you also need the capital markets and the amount of capital markets that Facebook has asked for, or SpaceX has asked for, or you know, you pick your stock that's gone into the bond market to try to raise and the biggest bond issuance that we've ever seen Seeing over the last few
15:58
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): months, you know, is widen these credit markets out. And you know, that that means the cost. of capital is more expensive. Now, if your view is that, hey, it doesn't matter the cost of capital because we're going to build this wonderful thing, great. But if your view is, hey, you know, as the cost of capital gets more expensive, it hurts people. Again, I don't think the cost of capital hurt hyperscalers. I do think
16:18
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): it'll hurt the smaller players. And that's what I'm sticking to. And again, that's why I'm not uberly bearish. Like I'm just saying there's certain stocks that are going to do, you know, not so good going forward. You know, and then I go into like the biggest cloud for me is still the Federal Reserve. And the Federal Reserve has come out incredibly hawkish in the last week, in you know, like various governors asking for
16:38
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): 50 basis points in December. And I just think this move into the inter higher interest rates is going to put a cap on the market. I just think that that runaway sort of one-directional growth that we've seen is going to be much, much. harder at a higher credit ratio, a higher credit spread, and a higher general, you know, you know, um,
16:58
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): you know, interest rate environment. Um so so I would say like the period of easy, as Mike said, stock picking might be the best way to go forward. The easy general broad market will get higher. I do think the SP will fix itself if that's the case, but that's another question for another day. Um, again, I continue to believe the technology sector.
17:15
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): benefited so substantially from this low growth and low cost of capital to grow itself. And so this is part of that whole picture. At the end, you know, going to the Fed, I think the Fed is making a mistake here. I know this is different than Michael's opinion to a degree. Um, I don't think the inflation picture is what it was. I think the Fed got the
17:35
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): inflation picture wrong in 2021. Um, I think they're getting it wrong. now as we've seen things like oil drop substantially, like we're seeing things like copper drop substantially today. Um I think you know the market is is about the Fed is probably about six to eight weeks behind where I think things have and things have significantly reset since the election. And so I think
17:54
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): that's important to keep in mind. I also think that the concept of loading low lowering affordability by raising rates is an old concept. And I think it's going to be hard to get housing prices lower with higher rates. In fact, I think it actually might drive housing prices higher for a variety of different reasons. There just won't be any supply. And I think the only way
18:14
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): to get housing prices lower
18:17
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): pretty much is that we need more supply. And so while these microeconomic conditions are changing rapidly right now, and I would agree Eric with you, you said that we're at this in front. inflection point with rapid changing views. The election changed things because it was such a big win for blues that it becomes a different conversation with data centers. It
18:37
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): gets a bigger conversation with housing, it becomes a different conversation, you know, with rates, all these different things. And I think like taking a step back, breathing, and not adding leverage, which was a big driver of the move up in July. is what you're going to see. And you're going to see
18:52
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a more
18:54
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): leverage in equity markets.
18:55
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Like
18:55
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): the situational awarenesses of the world are not going to go in and buy calls on every single name. And your last question, what you got to in you know, talking about on vol, we're seeing that. So I look at this VIX EQ versus VIX index. And yesterday it it'd had been the lowest it had printed in a long time, which is basically saying that the macro
19:15
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): risk dynamics are inching up and the micro risk dynamics are inching down. The macro risk is usually driven by put buying. The micro is usually driven by call selling. And what we're seeing is that ratio coming in is similar to what we saw at the end of dot-com. It's just a start. It's got a long way ways to go, quite frankly. But the fact
19:35
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): that that's starting to happen is starting to tell me, hey, the Wallmark. wall market's saying this picture might be changing. And therefore we need to listen to it a little bit more.
19:44
Eric Bender: So if if okay, if if all I mean, that's a lot to chew on, but if all that is true, so do we from the macro perspective, is it a little bit AI is wagging the dog here? So does does it mean that you know AI, a cool off will, you know. make interest rates uh
20:05
Eric Bender: and inflation will drive that?
20:07
Michael Purvis: I I think, you know, look, in in my in the work I've done, um
20:13
Michael Purvis: I I think you can you can make a rough estimate that had A this AI ramp never happened, GDP probably be sixty to eighty basis points lower than it was. I mean, there's a range there and these are the this is these are guesstimates there, but just looking at historical growth rates and in in in tech spend and and and adjusting for that.
20:32
Michael Purvis: Although I will say they kind of match up very nicely those estimates with what the actual CapEx was coming out of Microsoft and Google and so forth. But so I think there was a couple of things happening there. One, it pushed inflation, it pushed PPIs to very high levels, which is I think filtering into
20:52
Michael Purvis: various facets of the consumer economy. It certainly means like getting a plumber or a roofing guy or uh uh someone who knows how to deploy concrete, uh, let alone buying an iPad or uh or a PC. A lot of those prices have been inflated up, and those do somehow either directly or indirectly come into the consumer inflation story. Um uh there.
21:12
Michael Purvis: We've obviously got higher oil prices that are zero. sort of sort of occurring a bit at the same time here. So if the if the there's probably been some crowding out on the housing supply, housing building a house is harder when Mark Zuckerberg is building, you know,
21:29
Michael Purvis: the way he is, and he's got his um colleagues doing the same thing. It does crowd out
21:36
Michael Purvis: a a variety of needed input. inputs to create some of the other fixed asset stuff like housing there. And also I think it's part of the inflation story and why the Fed has gotten
21:48
Michael Purvis: more hawkish. And you're seeing, you know, one series after another of hotter than expected PPI and CPI, PCE prints all coming in, right? So the Fed's wanting wanted to get on that. I think Josh raises a really good question, though, which is that. if we've seen sort of seen peak acceleration in AI spend,
22:08
Michael Purvis: um, certainly what's estimated, and now things start falling um into place a little bit more orderly. Do we start seeing some deflation, some of those things reverse um and and all that? My own view is that like the broader condition, what we're dealing with on the inflation story, is that there is some. demand, and but that
22:28
Michael Purvis: demand is very much driven by Microsoft, right? It's not Mr. Smith, it's it's Microsoft and Google. And that demand is largely interest rate insensitive. I don't think their decision to, you know, is spend hundreds of millions of dollars is predicated on whether they're ten years at five percent or four percent or six percent, or that's or that there's spreadbacks up to under basis points, because they're
22:48
Michael Purvis: solving for a much higher return on invested capital.
22:51
Michael Purvis: But I do think that the um uh you know there's a there's a basic situation here that we're all going to be looking at where some of the stuff will stop, the acceleration will stop, start modifying there. And and the and the Fed, um my guess is the Fed ends up doing one to
23:11
Michael Purvis: two more hikes and probably not the three that's priced or the four or five. that other people expect. I think it's gonna be uh um a bit more modest there because let's face it, a lot of this inflation, you go back to the last couple of years, it's it's vol they're volatile numbers there. And I think the Fed's also gonna be faced with, well, okay, what are we really doing here if we
23:31
Michael Purvis: jack up rates by another 50 basis points? Okay, we're gonna hit autos, but autos has not been part of the inflation story. It's gonna make it more expensive to get a mortgage, to Josh's point. So I I think it's gonna be it's gonna be tricky. Like a lot of the inflation, aside from Microsoft and Google, is driven by supply shot supply shocks, which the Fed is, of
23:51
Michael Purvis: course, their toolkit is not really there to make more copper or more oil. Um
23:57
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): it's it's I think the Fed has one major tool to use.
24:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
24:01
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): I don't necessarily know if that tool is the best. tool to use with the current inflation environment we have. Yeah. And I think that they think it is. And I think that's the approach that they're taking. Because it's it's been, you
24:11
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
24:11
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): as I'm a monetarist, I'm a new Chicago guy, right? I believe in the ability of the Fed to manage money supply. But I think that changed in a way. And so I think it's a little bit different of a story. And therefore, it's like, you know, when you look at it and you say, well, this is the tool that we have, but it might not be the tool that. that's needed. And so markets change, dynamics change. And I think it's harder and harder
24:31
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): for the Fed to deal with because I just don't think that they have the tool that they really need to break this inflation cycle. And the only way that they can do it, quite frankly, is
24:40
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): if
24:40
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): they go to 50, I think there's a chance they're going to put us into a recession. And I think that's what I mean with them being behind the curve. I think all the numbers are what they are. And I think that they're playing a little bit with fundamental. fire at this point when they don't need to with oil down to below 80.
24:54
Michael Purvis: I I I would I gotta jump into you. I would vigorously disagree with that. 50 basis points is going to put us into a recession. Look, since the 10 years been floating up for
25:05
Michael Purvis: some time now, I don't know if there's a magic number that, oh, the average rate is 5.x Point X percent versus 4.x 4. percent, whether that's really going to put us into a recession. Economic growth has been a accelerating
25:17
Michael Purvis: here, you know, within the within the economy. But I do think there's something that I'll tell you,
25:24
Michael Purvis: my sort of view is that the reason to raise rates here is not that they're going to really beat up inflation, because that comes back to other factors.
25:34
Michael Purvis: Really on the supply side and again on the AI spend and and oil prices and tariffs, things like that. But I think if you go back to the history of fixed asset booms, right, and there's been a bunch of them, right? Many of the times they're followed by a recession, right? In other words, there's a budget capital deployed. Fixed asset is a percent of
25:54
Michael Purvis: GDP goes from like 15% up to 20%. Every time it goes to 20%, historically, there's been a recession thereafter, right? And so if we end up, and again, this fixed asset boom is very unique in so many ways. It's very different than other fixed asset booms we've had. But nonetheless, there is that history where
26:14
Michael Purvis: companies are committing into this. And if to have those a higher um Fed Fund Fed funds rate gives you a lot more room to move down if and when you do see a recession. coming out of this
26:28
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
26:28
Michael Purvis: other side
26:28
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of it. That's that's right.
26:29
Josh Silva: That's the
26:30
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): old though.
26:30
Michael Purvis: It's the rainy day argument.
26:32
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I mean that's
26:32
Michael Purvis: you're like, oh let's get inflation back to two percent in 2008.
26:36
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): In my
26:36
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): view like a lot of this changed three weeks ago. Like this is not an opinion about the possibility the Fed pushing a recession by raising three you know 50 basic loans is an opinion I had three weeks ago. It was nowhere near. What I'm doing is I'm opening up the conversations to that possibility now. Because I don't think it was a possibility three weeks ago. I mean
26:54
Michael Purvis: talking about the the blue wave.
26:55
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Yeah. So I think it changed things a lot. And I do think it's not even just the blue wave, it's just the way that the the energy of the markets feel. The energy of the markets is telling me, hey, we
27:07
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): need
27:07
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): to start looking at this. Because once this became a thing, when the sofa rate in March went up 30 basis points, which was like last week, Monday, I
27:14
Josh Silva: think it was.
27:14
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): or Tuesday, which is like November 10th or November 11th, I think was the date. Um the market changed. And so when I look at the energy of the market, the energy of the market is telling me, hey, this is now arrested, which I didn't think it was. So, anywho, that's that's kind of where I am. I think that's, you know, I think it's worth starting a
27:34
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): conversation
27:36
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): about this at this time. I'm not saying it's going to gonna happen, I just think it's worth opening up a conversation. Well,
27:41
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that's a the
27:42
Michael Purvis: blue wave definitely raises lots of questions. Uh, I think it's but it's it's a it's such a broad spectrum of of of uh people that are part of this blue wave, you know. So it's it's and it you know, again, I I I think what I think Josh, what you're sort of getting at a little bit is 28 twenty eight sort of
28:02
Michael Purvis: feels a little bit more locked for a Democrat. And so then if you have, you know,
28:07
Michael Purvis: you know
28:07
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): that's that's not what I'm saying at all. What I'm actually saying is that it just changed the energy. And the
28:11
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): energy,
28:12
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): the energy changed, and the market's telling me that. I'm not taking that out. I mean, the market dropped a lot.
28:18
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
28:18
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): you know, it could be anthropics IPO, everyone's selling to get in front of. It could be because of the move in interest rates, it
28:24
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): could be the
28:24
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): abundant inflation, it could be a Jensen, it could be whatever you. wanted to do. The energy of the market isn't like what it was. And therefore, you got to listen. And that's why I'm bringing it up as a conversation. I'm not saying it's going to happen, but it's a conversation that needs to be had.
28:39
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
28:39
Eric Bender: no doubt there's uh a lot of uncertainty uh as we think about this stuff. Listen, great conversation. Uh guys, thank you so much uh for doing this. Uh thank you, Michael, thank you, Josh. Uh you could find them on Bloomberg LinkedIn and their respective websites, uh www.talbokandcapital.com and
28:58
Eric Bender: www.bessingpartners.com. Um thank you again for joining us. And remember, we'll keep an eye on what matters in the markets.
29:08
Michael Purvis: This podcast is for informational purposes only and is not investment advice.
29:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
29:14
Michael Purvis: information opinions, and views expressed on this podcast are for informational purposes only and are not intended as investment advice.
29:23
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
29:23
Michael Purvis: opinions expressed may not align with Passaic Partners' views or its client strategies. Market forecasts are speculative and should not be the sole basis for investment decisions. Consult your financial and tax advisors before making any investments.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights