Deal Flow

Q3 2026 Public Markets Read: Sunbelt REITs Face Pricing Pressure as Coastal Markets Grow

29 min Listen to the original Episode page
Real Estate Investment TrustsApartment REITsSunbelt MarketsCoastal MarketsSupply and DemandNOI AnalysisRental Market TrendsCredit Quality

Summary

Michael Puglio presents the Q3 2026 Public Markets Read, analyzing 22 companies including 7 apartment REITs, homebuilders, SFRs, retailers, and software firms. He argues the Sunbelt is at the bottom of the revenue cycle with dwindling supply, while coastal markets benefit from past supply gluts. Public REITs report results weeks before private owners, offering early indicators of occupancy, revenue, and NOI trends. The analysis highlights that renewal rates, not new lease growth, are driving revenue, with significant pricing gaps emerging between new and renewing tenants. Credit quality remains strong with delinquencies below 1%, though insurance costs are decreasing while utilities are rising.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    Public REITs report results weeks before private owners see data, providing the earliest market read on key metrics.

    Michael Puglio · 1:06

  2. 2
    Renewals drove revenue growth of 3-5% while new leases fell at six of seven REITs, creating an 11% pricing gap at MAA.

    Michael Puglio · 5:56

Episode sections

  1. 0:05 – 1:06

    Introduction and Market Thesis

    Michael Puglio introduces the Q3 2026 Public Markets Read, stating the Sunbelt is at the bottom of the revenue cycle with dwindling supply. He argues operators will win by retaining renters through high renewal rates and cost control rather than generating new lease rent growth.

  2. 1:06 – 3:05

    Public REITs as Early Indicators

    Puglio explains that public REITs report results weeks before private owners see their data, providing the earliest market read. He notes the analysis covers 22 companies, including 7 apartment REITs (4 Sunbelt, 3 coastal), homebuilders, SFRs, retailers, and software companies.

  3. 3:05 – 4:04

    Q3 Scorecard: NOI and Occupancy

    Coastal NOI grew while Sunbelt NOI fell at three of four Sunbelt comparables. Occupancy is stable (93-97%), indicating the issue is pricing and costs, not demand. NXRT is identified as an outlier with significant NOI decline.

  4. 4:04 – 4:48

    Revenue, Occupancy, and Supply Dynamics

    Sunbelt revenue is flat while coastal revenue grew 2.4%, driven by a past supply glut. Occupancy is slightly lower in the Sunbelt (94.7%) than coasts (96.2%). Supply is starting to dwindle, with MAA reporting absorption beat deliveries and VMRK forecasting low 2027 supply.

  5. 4:48 – 7:03

    Rents: New Leases vs. Renewals

    Renewals drove revenue growth (up 3-5%) while new leases fell at six of seven REITs. This created an 11% gap at MAA where new residents pay significantly less than renewing ones, highlighting that retention is the key revenue driver.

  6. 7:03 – 8:53

    Occupancy, Turnover, and Supply Details

    Occupancy held steady year-over-year, with turnover around 40-53%. Supply data shows MAA's absorption beat deliveries, VMRK has 2027 supply at 1.2% of stock, and UDF's CFO called 2027 supply favorable. Charlotte is noted as an exception with high recent delivery rates.

  7. 8:53 – 10:13

    Concessions and Bad Debt

    Credit quality is clean with delinquency below 1%. Concessions are limited except in high-supply markets like Charlotte, where MAA offers 10-12 weeks free. Collections remain strong, indicating renters are holding jobs and paying rent.

  8. 10:13 – 29:25

    Expenses and 2027 Budgets

    Insurance costs decreased across all seven REITs (2-18%), while utilities increased (3-12%). NXRT saw significant expense growth in taxes and repairs, driving its NOI down 8%. Personnel costs fell at MAA, CPT, and IRT due to scale and technology.

Claims worth verifying

Michael Puglio is co-founder and CIO of Carbon, which owns and operates workforce housing across the Sunbelt.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·0:05

How to verify: Carbon Capital Management website or SEC Form ADV filing for Carbon Capital Management, LLC. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

VMRK is the result of EQR and AVB consolidating starting this quarter.

Michael Puglio ·1:45

How to verify: VMRK (Equity LifeStyle Properties) Q3 2026 10-Q filing or press release regarding the merger with EQR and AVB. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Occupancy is between 93% and 97%, with a median of 95.5% across the 22 companies.

Michael Puglio ·3:22

How to verify: Q3 2026 earnings releases for the 22 companies listed. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Sunbelt revenue was flat (+0.2%) while coastal revenue was +2.4%.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·4:04

How to verify: Q3 2026 earnings releases for Sunbelt (MAA, CPT, IRT, NXRT) and Coastal (ESS, UDR, VMRK) REITs. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

MAA reported absorption beat new deliveries in its markets.

Michael Puglio ·7:55

How to verify: MAA Q3 2026 earnings call transcript or 10-K/10-Q filing. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

VMRK has 2027 supply at about 1.2% of existing stock with deliveries down about 20%.

Michael Puglio ·7:55

How to verify: VMRK Q3 2026 earnings call transcript or investor presentation. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

UDR's CFO called 2027 supply incrementally favorable.

Michael Puglio ·8:15

How to verify: UDR Q3 2026 earnings call transcript. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

MAA offers 10 to 12 weeks of free rent on certain floor plans at two leaseups in Charlotte.

Michael Puglio ·9:16

How to verify: MAA Q3 2026 earnings call transcript or investor presentation. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Arbor CEO said multifamily values are down another 5 to 15% this year.

Michael Puglio ·15:19

How to verify: Arbor Realty Trust Q3 2026 earnings call transcript. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Review Q3 2026 earnings reports for MAA, VMRK, UDR, NXRT, CPT, and IRT to verify NOI, occupancy, and revenue trends.
  • Check public filings for MAA and VMRK regarding 2027 supply forecasts and absorption data.
  • Analyze insurance and utility expense trends in Q3 2026 reports to assess cost control effectiveness.
  • Verify delinquency rates and bad debt percentages across the 7 apartment REITs mentioned.
  • Compare new lease vs. renewal rent growth rates for MAA to understand the 11% pricing gap.
  • Research supply delivery data for Charlotte to assess if it remains an exception with high delivery rates.
  • Look for counter-arguments regarding the sustainability of renewal-driven revenue growth.
  • Check for any conflicts of interest or sponsorships related to the REITs discussed.
Full transcriptexpand

0:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All

0:06Michael Puglio: right, everyone. Thanks so much for joining us for our third quarter 2026 Public Markets Read. So thank you so much for joining us. I am Michael Puglio, co founder and CIO of Carbon. We own and operate workforce housing across the Sunbelt. So this is the the data that we look at every single day on our own properties. A quick note before we start the views today are my own, not carbon. carbons. Nothing here is investment advice or an offer to buy or sell anything. And past performance does not predict future results. If I had to give you the whole thing up front, I'd say this the sunbelt is at the bottom of the revenue cycle. Supply is starting to dwindle, which is good news for owners. And operators win this year by keeping renters in place. So that means higher renewal rates, high customers. customer satisfaction, and controlling costs, not by generating significant rent growth. So that's the story. It's most of what we're going to be talking about today, and most of what's been reported by the REITs, the home builders, and all the adjacent industries. So, first, why do we care about the REITs? And the reason why is because they typically report first. So, as a private owner, you see your own quarter, maybe a few comps from your broker, maybe some information. from your deal desk. But that's about it. The public REITs report the whole market on the same measures just a few weeks after the quarter ends. So it's really the earliest read we get on what's happening. This quarter we looked at

1:2622 companies. We're going to make a couple expansions next quarter, but this is our first time doing this. So certainly if you have feedback, you think we should be looking at additional companies or additional insights, please provide feedback. We want this to be useful and valuable to not only us for our internal processes and understanding what's going to be happening in the future and what's happening today, but also to make sure that we're providing value to our audience. Please give us feedback. Those 22 companies are made up of seven apartment reads, four in the Sunbelt, three on the coast. So we can get a good look at what's happening in our markets and as a comparison to the coastal markets. And just so you know, VMRK is EQ. EQR and AVB combined, starting that this quarter. So they they consolidated. Then we've got 15 companies that are around us. We have the home builders, we have the single family rental companies, the home improvement space, the resale brokers, and software as it relates to real estate. MAA, CPT, I R T and NXRT XRT operate in our core markets. Those are the Sunbelt Reads. REITs. So that's going to be our main read for this quarter. And then the coastal REITs give us a sense of where the Sunbelt might be in a year or two, just based on those supply waves. And I'm not going to walk through every single company. What we are going to do is just pull out what matters for us as operators as best as possible. So these there's a lot of data that gets released by all of these folks. So I just want to make sure you guys are aware of that because there's going to be a lot of data coming

2:45at us. I'm going gonna to try to distill that to the most important parts, but there'll be a lot of extra data on the screens. If you're listening to this on a podcast, you can always get the slides or the video from our team if you'd like to have that as a companion to the audio file.

3:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

3:02Michael Puglio: if you're watching live, then you're seeing what I'm seeing. So here's the scorecard. Coastal NOI grew, Sunbelt NOI fell at three of the four comps. So that's really the headline for the quarter. ESS led at plus three. 3.1% on N NOI. NXRT was at the bottom at minus 8.2%, which was an outlier. And everyone else landed somewhere between negative two and positive two. Occupancy is basically fine across the board from 93 to 97%. I'm rounding a bit here. Median is 95.5, 85 and a half give or take. So people are living in these buildings. This is not a demand problem, it's a pricing problem and a cost problem. And that's the important difference. So we're not going to see distress from some of this headline numbers. The distress is going to be under the hood. So we're going to take a look at that. Keep NXRT in the back of your mind. Revenue is down less than a point. And NOI was down by 8%. We'll get to why in just a few slides. And I'm going to come back to this page later and go through the four Sunbelt REITs one by one because they're the ones that look most like us.

4:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All

4:04Michael Puglio: right, here Sunbelt revenue was basically flat plus 0.2%. Close to coastal was plus 2.4%. And that gap really was the supply wave. If you guys watched our webinar from a few weeks ago where we talked about general market data, we talked about the macro picture all the way down to the supply and demand and the migration picture all out at the Sunbelt and the coastal markets. You'll know. that supply, there was a supply glut, and that came on the back of a really strong migration trends in the Sunbelt. And we're seeing some of the hangover effects of that in this rent growth. So a lot of apartments got built in the Sunbelt from 23 to 25, and we are still working through it. Now, to be fair to the Sunbelt, these are simple averages for the four companies. NXRT pulls them down quite a bit. If you take NXRT out, some Sunbelt NOI was about flat. So an expense growth is about 1.5%, not 3.9% again. If you take away NXRT, which was kind of the outlier. So this the big Sunbelt reads are holding flat. They're not falling apart. The stress is really at the smaller value added name, like I just said. Occupancy is 94.7 in the sunbelt versus 96.2 on the coasts. And that's moved

5:160.3% from a year ago. So residents are there. The pricing power just isn't there quite yet. And this is what we've been saying for a while. Supply moves first and rents follow. What's different is the timing. We thought 2026 was going to be the year it turned. And for the sunbelt reads, the third quarter just isn't, we're not quite there yet. Area. We are starting to see the change and change improve. So we are seeing it become less negative and the direction. is right. It's just taking a little bit longer than we expected at this point for the Sunbelt to recover from all of that occupancy or excuse me, all that supply. Now, rents. If you only look at one slide today, I would say this is the one. Renewals carried the whole quarter across the board. New leases were down at six of the seven REITs. MAA was minus six. NXRT minus 4.5 four point five, and VM. VMRK was the only one positive at 0.4. Renewals, on their hand, were up at all seven between around 3% to 5%. So think about what that means at MMA. A new resident is paying about 6% less than the last resident in that unit. And the resident who stays is paying 5.3% more. That's an 11% gap. And that certainly can't sit there forever. So either new lease pricing is going to come back up. or residents who are renewing are going to start to notice that they're paying more than new leases and they're going to start shopping. So right now, this business is really about

6:35keeping people. How fast a work order gets closed, whether someone actually calls the resident before the lease is up, and where that is where revenue is this year. It's not in the marketing budget. It is in making sure that people are happy in their units, they are getting good customer service, good. physical work order completion times, good community events, good culture at the properties. That's what gets people sticky and staying, not necessarily any fancy new lease concession. Occupancy and turnover is our next slide here. Occupancy held within 0.7% of a year ago at every single REIT. CPT and ESS went up a little and the other five, other five slipped a little. Turnover is sitting between forty and fifty-three percent a year. And I won't line up and rank them because everyone counts that number a little bit different. But the point is roughly half of your residents still move every year. That's significantly down, obviously, from the COVID era, but but otherwise is an important number to know because it's not like you're keeping these people for eight years. You're basically turning

7:35over everyone every two years or half your residents residence a year as I said. So next we have our supply. So this is where the good news is. And there's three things that I'd write down here. First, MAA says absorption beat new deliveries this year across its markets. That means fewer buildings and lease up and less pressure on concessions. Second, VMRK has 2027 supply at about 1.2% of existing stock with deliveries down about 20%. Again, another great piece of information for us. And third, the CFO of UDR called 2027 supply incrementally favorable and said owning a home is still expensive enough that people are staying put. Now, it's not even everywhere. MAA said 19% of Charlotte's inventory was delivered in the last three years. So again, not every market is exactly the same, but that is a headline number that you want to keep in mind. an eye out for. We typically want to make sure that we're not in any markets or we're not buying in any markets where annual supply of deliveries is more than 5%.

8:36So when you see Charlotte inventory of 19% was delivered in the last three years, that's a pretty incredible number. So just be aware that if you're investing in or involved in Charlotte anyway, you may have a little bit longer of a recovery. versus some of these other markets. Next, we've got concessions and bad debt.

8:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So,

8:56Michael Puglio: not everyone gives great information here. So we're just doing our best. But generally speaking, from the information we can see, credit is basically clean. Delinquency and bad debt are below 1%. UDR is down 50 basis points from a year ago, and they give credit to their screening process. Only two REITs actually. put a number on concessions. And the only one that really matters is MAA. They're doing up to 10 to 12 weeks on free on certain floor plans at two leases ops in Charlotte. So same theme as before. You've got a lot of deliveries in Charlotte. And so you've got to compete for those tenants. And so be aware of that. That's going to mean less pricing power in the near term in Charlotte, but maybe a good time to break ground. because probably a lot of other developers aren't going to be willing to break ground today. At the stabilized properties, we're really not seeing that anymore. So that's good news as well. There is a question in the marketplace as to whether or not concessions will be the new normal, or if that's something that's going to go away as we get to higher and higher occupancy. For workforce housing, collections is the first number we look at. And that's what the public REITs are telling us is that the rental. renter is holding up. It's the same thing we said in October when we had our last webinar. People have jobs, and people with jobs generally are paying the rent.

10:12Expenses. So for those we're at the end of the budget season for sure, most people have finalized their budgets for 2027. But if you haven't yet, or you haven't considered some of these factors, you should definitely reopen the books and consider some changes to your seven. 2027 budget process. Insurance for the first time, which is great, has gone down at all seven REITs. So that's good. That's happening across the board. Utilities went up at all seven, and that's pretty much your 2027 budget right there. Insurance was down anywhere from 2% to 18%. CPT was down 18% and IRT down 17. A few years ago, we were getting insurance quotes that would kill deals at the closing. table. So this is real relief. If your renewal as an owner didn't come in lower, I would go back out and bid it or find a new insurance broker. In utilities, we're up 3% to 12%. So plan for that. Again, this is on a 12-month basis. So just be aware of that. This is through the third quarter. And now going back to NXRT, RT expenses were up twelve 11%, eleven percent, taxes were up 15%, and repairs and maintenance were up 20%. That's how you go from a revenue number down just a percent, but NOI down 8%. So when revenue is flat, the expense line is the whole game. One more thing here personnel costs went down at MAA, CPT, and IRT. That's scale and it's

11:31technology, and it's taking cost out of on-site staffing. We'll see that again in a couple slides.

11:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay,

11:38Michael Puglio: next we have guidance. What do these guys think is going to happen next? And what are they saying? And what are they saying relative to what they said before? So three of the six cut their 2026 NOI guidance and all three of them are in the sunbelt. MAA was down 0.35%, CPT down 0.4%, and NXRT down 3.3%. UDR, ESS, both coastal raised their guidance. We are seeing, as you saw, some rent growth in the coastal market. So probably a lot of these players were thinking flat on revenue and they're seeing actually upside to their budgets, but we're still seeing lagging in the Sunbelt markets. And so probably that's what we're looking at here. Some upward guidance for these coastal guys and then for the Sunbelt operators there. they're still dealing with the overhang of supply, and it's just taking a little bit longer than we all expected. The Sunbelt operators are not calling for a bottom for 2026. They're telling us that 2027 supply looks better, but their own numbers say that this year isn't there yet. If you're putting together 2027 budgets, that's the tension that you're budgeting into. For us, the lesson is the same as in October. Underrate the market as it is today and treat any recovery as upside.

12:55The transactions and balance sheets. So the reads sold a lot more than they bought, about 2.2 billion out of out and just 0.66 billion in. CPT alone sold 1.6 billion. So that's a pretty sizable percentage of the sales. The number I like the most in this page is UDR sold at about a mid mid-5 five cap. and bought back its own stock at about a mid-six implied cap rate. So simply put, a private buyer will pay more for an apartment building than the stock market will pay for the same building. So private values are holding up basically. Well, another way of looking at that is that perhaps the private market is overvaluing the real estate and the public market, given it's liquid and has more players, is actually truly valuing the asset. So I wouldn't say one market. is better than the other, just to say that there is a delta between those two markets. And the REITs are taking advantage of that by selling where it's where it's expensive and buying where it's cheap, or vice versa. So now look at their debt. 3.45 to 4.75, mostly fixed, four to

13:55four to six times leverage. A lot of private owners who bought in 21 and 22 with floating bridge debt don't have anything like that. Some of them extended. in 2024, hoping rates would come down. And we know how that's gone. So rates are way higher than that since 2024. It's the debt, not the market, that's going to force some of these sales in the private market. That's not necessarily as applicable to the REITs because their leverage point, even though it's four to six times leverage, the way that is calculated means that's somewhere between 25 to 40 percent loan to value. In the private market, you you've got much higher leverage rates. Most of the private operators are levering between 60 to even 80 or 85% of cost. And so way different risk profile when you're dealing with that type of leverage.

14:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

14:40Michael Puglio: that's going to be, I think, where the opportunity is over the next 18 months. Like we said back in October, it's not going to be a clean opportunity. It's going to take operators who can do the work on the ground, do workouts, and deal with lenders and take over properties through special servicing or otherwise. Next, there's no slide for this part. So just the one thing we're going to add for next for next quarter is going to be the mortgage reads. I think there's some interesting information to pull out of the mortgage REITs. Streets, But while I can all stay, the sources and the Q3 calls were released by Arbor. Starwood, ReadyCap, and Blackstone Moorgridge Trust, as well as KKR. And the numbers aren't in the deck. But just to give you some quick color here, what they're saying about values, just to give some from their releases, Arbor CEO said multifamily values are down another 5 to 15% this year after the 10-year moved up about 140 to 160 basis points in nine months. He also said deal volume basically dried up. So if you're carrying a 2021 or 2022 deal at the value you bought it, you're probably a little high. Second, and this is where this is the line I would underline. Starwood said the stress and the cost of refinancing, not in property operations, which is very consistent with everything that we just talked about. Multifamily is the most rate sensitive part of their book, and we're talking Starwood here because it trades at the

15:58lowest cap rate. Every downgrade they made this year or this quarter was a loan from before twenty twenty three and more than half are apartments. So the buildings are fine. It's the capital structure that isn't and that's what we've been saying for a while. And now the lenders are saying it too. Third, the pace. Arbor had four hundred and fifty million of new delinquencies in one quarter and they slowed down their REO sales sales. Starwood is selling for closed apartments at about seventy 72 two cents on the dollar on the original loan. in cash, and sponsors are still writing checks. Starwood said that borrowers put in another 710 million of new equity on the stressed loans. And so this doesn't all come back to the market at once. It comes out slowly as runner as owners run out of equity. Arbor wants to call cut its legacy book from 4.5 billion to about 1 billion by the end of 2027. So these deals are going to happen. And this is the window. Starwood thinks the special servicing peaks in late 2027 to early 2028. So the these mortgage reads who are the biggest players in the 2021-2022 frenzy are going are starting to offload their books and it's going to happen now. They're going to do it at distress pricing. It's going to happen between now and the middle of 2028. So that's the window, the next 12 to 24 months and that's valid. validated based on everything else that we're seeing from the private market. And fourth, the

17:18lenders have pulled back. Arbor is basically not making any new loans, and the agency volume fell by more than half. It's agency volume, excuse me, fell by more than half from August to September when rates jumped. And less leverage for buyers means less competition for whoever has the cash and the patients. ReadyCap Ready Cap said something that I think every operator should be should be should listen to. They've stopped selling back. bad loads at a discount. They're going to hold their 28 problem loans, almost all apartments at about 70% occupied for the next couple of years and fix the buildings first. They said they're looking at joint ventures with operators to do so. So the lenders don't just want buyers, they want operators. And that's a different kind of opportunity than a fire sale. It's one that rewards people who can actually run their property. Now, to be fair, Blackstone is the counterpoint. They sold about a billion. dollars of loans at 93 cents in the dollar. And their problem is an office, not apartments. Their good family, their good multifamily loans are getting paid off about $1.1 billion this year. And they said they feel pretty good about multifamily and the new loans they're making are in apartments and industrial. So good apartment loans still refinance. The problem is the 21 and the 22 bridge loans on deals that never hit their plan. And KKR is the same story. 1.2 billion of loans paid off this quarter. So good loans still refinance. This is a vintage problem, not a market wide freeze. One more thing on Arbor's call that I would watch is they said occupancy dropped at some of their properties

18:38in Jacksonville, Orlando, San Antonio, Houston, and Atlanta, tied to ICE activity. These are workforce housing markets. So that's a demand risk. We definitely need to keep an eye on going forward. But we didn't get this into the deck in time, but next quarter, the mortgage REITs will get their own slides so we can start tracking this quarter for quarter.

18:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

18:57Michael Puglio: now back to page three, if I may. Hopefully, the four Sunbelt REITs. So just a quick, a quick minute on this. So IRT is the one that is actually growing. So you could see that here, line three: revenue up is two 2%. percent. NO. up NOI was up 1.6. The only Sunbelt REIT with positive NOI. New leases were basically flat while everyone else was giving up a couple points. Renewals were up 4.6 and they held guidance. So that's not that the Sunbelt can't grow. It depends a lot where you are and what you charge. The one thing I would watch is leverage. IRT has the highest leverage in the group of 6.2 times EBIDA, EBITDA, but that

19:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is

19:37Michael Puglio: again still low at private. standards, well under a 50% LTV. MAA is a retention story. So new leases were down 6% and renewals were up 5%. That's an 11-point gap that we talked about. They're holding the rent roll together with the residents who stay. Collections are the best in the group with just 0.3% of delinquency, but NOI was still down 1.8 and they cut their guidance. The They're other ones telling you that Charlotte had 19% nineteen percent of its inventory. delivered in three years with 10 to 12 per weeks of free free at those two leaseups. So they've got some more development risk in their portfolio. So even the best operator in the Sunbelt is still working through supply in some markets. CPT is the cost control story. Revenue is flat, expenses were flat too. And how do they do it? They did it because insurance was down almost twenty 20%, percent, personnel was down three 3%. percent, and that's why NOI only slipped. 0.2%. They also sold about $1.6 billion in assets, and they have the lowest leverage of the four, about four times EBITDA, which is something like 20 to 25% low into value. So they're cleaning out the balance sheet while it's quiet. NXRT is the one I would pay the most attention to because it looks the most like a value add class B operator. Revenue is down about a point, which isn't terrible, but expenses were up 11. Taxes were up 15%. Repairs and maintenance were up 20%. Utilities up 12%. So NOI was down 8%.

20:57Guidance went from minus 1 to minus 4. And core FFO, which is free cash flow from operations, is down almost 26%. Occupancy is also the lowest of the four. That likely means they're reinvesting their cap Cat into CapEx and capital improvements or just maintenance capex. That's why your free cash flow is down. And also occupancy is the lowest of the four at just 93%. They have almost 11,000 units forecasted to deliver in 2026 within three miles of their properties. They, I think, are expecting some more stress on that occupancy number, and they're going to need to protect the renewals and they're going to have to be sensitive to their pricing rates if they want to maintain or increase that occupancy. And I think that's the whole lesson of the quarter in one company. When rents are flat, you can't afford to be loose on expenses. Taxes and repairs will really hurt you. So going back through to slide 12 where we were before, we're going to go to the adjacent scorecards. So these are all the other companies that are that impact our business. We have the home builders, we have single family rentals, we've got remodeling, we've got brokerage, and we have operating software. Obviously, we can only look at public comps. And like I said, we're also going to be adding the mortgage REITs to this list for next quarter. One thing to note: Home Depot and Lowe's are the fiscal Q2 May through July. Unfortunately, their quarter doesn't come out yet, or not as of today, when

22:16we recorded this. So, first we have our home builders. We talk about demand here. So orders and margins were down at all five builders, and prices were down at four. Net orders were down between six to fifteen percent. Lenar's incentives were 12% of revenue. That is pretty significant. So they're giving up price and they're paying incentives to move homes, and volume still went down. If you have a renter that makes enough to buy, a 10% incentive is real money. And so that's the threat at the top of your renter base, but orders still fell. So people are not exactly rushing to buy. Home builders on the supply side. backlogs were up at only two of the five, DR Horton and Pulti. The line we look at here is built to rent. D.R. Horton took $91 million of impairments on the nine multifamily rental projects. Lenar's multifamily revenue went from 228 million last year to only 338 million. And the builders are backing out of rental. That may have a little bit to do with the legislative agenda. And that may that also helps the supply picture over the next few years, but not so great for the builders. Next we have our SFR folks. So the single family rents were up about 3%, definitely ahead of the apartment median of 2%. Occupancy is over 96. So families who can't

23:30buy are renting houses and they're not leaving the rental market. So this is still a strong place to be an owner. It just may be harder and harder to break into this market which may continue to support rent growth in this area. Next, we have the remodeling space. So what we're seeing is bigger tickets, fewer transactions. Home Depot comps were up 1.7% and Lowe's was up 0.2% with transactions down at both. They said that existing home turnover is bouncing along at troth level, excuse me, levels. So people are just not moving. So you're seeing large. larger projects being done for people to re-renovate their homes. So this is not a news story, but I would expect that Home Depot and Lowe's should continue to perform well as long as the economy generally continues to hold up. Next, we have the resale market. And I think the long story short here is the resale market is basically frozen. Compass organic transactions were down 0.3. point three. Zillow's industry transaction value is up one. AGNT grew eight percent, but that's from them taking share, not by the market growing. Why does that matter to us? Is if nobody's selling their house, your renters aren't buying one. And that's one of the big reasons why renewals are holding up.

24:41Last but not least, here we have App Folio. App folio revenue is up almost 20%, and units were up eight 8%. percent. So owners are spending money on software. UDR says. AI and data help bring its delinquency down. VMRK says its tech and AI advantages are compounding. And remember, personnel costs went down at the big sunbelt REITs on the expense side. So it's showing up in the PL now. And this I thought was a really fun chart on everything that was said in the transcripts of the public results. releases. The most used phrases on these 22 calls, the top or gross margin, new lease rates, interest rates. Gross margin is all the builders and retailers. New lease is in the REITs, and that's the same story as the rent slide. The coastal REITs talked about rent growth. The Sunbelt REITs talked about core FFO being down, and everyone else is talking about rates. Interest rates and mortgage rates are both are in the top five. mostly from the builders. And the quick five takeaways for everyone, just as quick snapshot, and I went through this relatively quickly today.

25:48Hopefully you guys got some good value here, but just a quick snapshot of what we talked about. Five things. One, some belt revenue is flat. If you're doing a 2027 budget, I would start at flat. Two, renewals are carrying the rent roll. Rent growth right now is really about keeping. the residents that you have. Three, the relief is an insurance, not utilities. Take your insurance renewal and hold it up against these numbers. Four, the builders gave up price and volume. These incentives are making buying cheaper for some of your renters, but probably only those at the very very high end of your rental pool. And five, three of the six REITs cut guidance and all three of them are in the Sunbelt. So my take the supply that's been holding rents down is going away, and you can see it in the public numbers. The turn is coming later than we thought, but it's coming. Until it does, you win by keeping residence and controlling costs, and the deals over the next 18 months are going to be the ones where the debt forces the sale, not the market.

26:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

26:44Michael Puglio: with that, that's all I have. We'll send the recording and the recap to everyone who registered. If you want to go deeper on your market or any of these companies, the link is on the screen. I'm happy to set up a call. Let's see. I have a couple of questions here in the chat, actually. Let's see. What should owners be putting in their budgets for 2027? We talked about that. Really, we want to be thinking about getting your growth from a renewals, not new leases. And really going through your expenses line by line. Insurance is going It's down at all the REITs as much as 18% at CPT. CPTs. If your renewal didn't come in lower, you should bid that again. Utilities are up. So make sure you're budgeting for that. Do not expect utilities to be flat year over year. And taxes are one to watch property by property. That was all over the place. And then one other question while I have it, let's see where is the distress and when does it actually show up? This one, not at the REITs. So I would because their debt is largely fixed and it's in that three and a half to five percent. range and they're relatively low levered. The stress is more with private owners who bought in 21 and 22 with floating rate bridge debt, and then they extended in 24 or 25 because everyone thought rates were coming down. That didn't really happen. So when these extensions run out, the lenders are gonna want a pay down or a new rate cap, and some of the owners are just not gonna going have to it, or their equity groups are just gonna going to not want to continue to participate. I think that a lot of that. comes to the market over the

28:03next 18 months. And the thing to watch is the debt, not the building. So pull the maturities over the next 24 months if you're interested in that kind of thing and start making phone calls. A lot of these properties are fine, they're well occupied, they're well maintained. They just don't have the capital structure to support a hold past 2027 or 2028. And then last question I see when does some Sunbelt rent growth come back? I would say it's later than we thought. The supply side is turning. MMA said absorption beat deliveries this year. VMRK has 2027 supply at about 1.2% of stock. That's great news. And builders are backing out of rentals. So that part is doing what we expected. But all the three guidance cuts were at Sunbelt some belt REITs, reads and new lease rent rents are still negative at most of them. Basically, if you're asking me what would you put into 2027 budgets, I would still expect flat and just hope that it comes back faster. And that's upside, but I would not underrate a rent growth so far as new leases for your 2027 budget. So with that,

29:04thanks so much for spending the time with us today. Again, if you want to reach out, everything is on screen. And if you want to get these slides or any additional information, please reach out. It and would we'd be happy to provide it. Thank you. and have a great rest of your day. We'll see you next

29:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): time.

This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights