N4EA CEO Sadie Frank on how co-occurring weather and geopolitical shocks disrupt global supply chains
Summary
Sadie Frank, CEO of N4EA, explains how the firm quantifies logistics disruption risk by modeling scenario analyses for events like Panama Canal droughts or Strait of Taiwan disruptions. She argues that supply chain operators view all disruptions as equivalent in impact, focusing on operational consequences rather than causes. Frank highlights compounding risks from El Niño, such as typhoons in Asia followed by Panama Canal restrictions, which create spatial-temporal cost spikes. She also notes that insurers are seeing rising wind damage claims, indicating a structural shift in climate risk exposure for port infrastructure.
Key takeaways
- 1 N4EA quantifies logistics disruption risk by modeling scenario analyses for events like Panama Canal droughts or Strait of Taiwan disruptions, focusing on the 'when, where, and by how much' of global movement failures.
Sadie Frank · 2:16
- 2 Hurricane Helene and Milton disrupted a core saline bag distribution facility, forcing hospitals in Oregon to alter patient hydration protocols, demonstrating how industrial logistics failures directly impact healthcare delivery.
Sadie Frank · 9:31
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 1:39
Sponsor Read and Introduction
Vanguard promotes its institutional quality bond funds for stability and income. The host introduces the episode topic of supply chain shocks from severe weather and El Niño, welcoming guest Sadie Frank, CEO of N4EA.
- 1:39 – 5:05
Company Overview and Risk Scope
Sadie Frank explains that N4EA quantifies logistics disruption risk, analyzing how weather and geopolitical events impact global movement of goods. She notes that while clients focus on various risks, the operational impact is what matters most to supply chain operators.
- 5:05 – 8:32
El Niño and Global Supply Chain Interconnectivity
Frank discusses how El Niño causes co-occurring disruptions, such as typhoons in Asia and droughts in Panama, which cumulatively drive up costs. She emphasizes that localized disruptions have massive downstream impacts due to the global nature of modern supply chains.
- 8:32 – 10:31
Case Studies: Hurricane Helene, Milton, and Medical Supplies
Frank illustrates supply chain fragility with a personal anecdote about delayed medical hydration supplies in Oregon caused by Hurricane Helene disrupting a saline bag distribution facility. She also mentions the impact on rail profits and chip manufacturing logistics.
- 10:31 – 17:07
Critical Infrastructure and Barge Transport Risks
The discussion covers the transport of massive data center components via barge on rivers like the Mississippi and Ohio. Frank highlights risks associated with weather affecting these specialized transport routes, which are often overlooked in infrastructure risk assessments.
- 17:07 – 22:10
Seasonality and Panama Canal Adaptation
Stevenson and Frank discuss the Panama Canal's proactive water management in response to El Niño, noting shifts in cargo types from holiday goods to agricultural products. Frank stresses that risk is a function of both time and space, requiring awareness of seasonal planting and harvest windows.
- 22:10 – 28:06
West Coast Wind and Fog Risks
Frank identifies wind and fog as major risks for West Coast ports, particularly the Columbia River Bar, which can shut down ship traffic. She notes that insurers are seeing rising wind damage claims, highlighting a growing but underappreciated climate risk for port operations.
- 28:06 – 30:25
Co-occurring Risks and Future Outlook
Frank expresses concern over co-occurring disruptions, such as a conflict in the Taiwan Strait combined with a Gulf hurricane, which could severely impact oil and fertilizer markets. She warns that stacked risks in a constrained global system pose significant threats to stability and prices.
- 30:25 – 31:12
Federal Support and Risk Stacking
Andrew Stevenson notes that federal support from agencies like FEMA may decrease due to budget constraints, creating a risk for economic recovery. Sadie Frank adds that risks have geographic and temporal components, and when they stack globally and over time, resilience requires a deeper bench of options to function in a constrained world.
- 31:12 – 32:48
Resilience and Supply Chain Complexity
Sadie Frank defines resilience as identifying effective solutions and deploying them when needed. Andrew Stevenson concludes by emphasizing that extreme weather affects everyday consumer goods, using the iPhone as an example of global supply chain complexity where final assembly occurs in China despite global component sourcing.
Claims worth verifying
Vanguard builds institutional quality bond funds designed to help portfolios remain steady when markets don't.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·0:00
How to verify: Vanguard marketing materials and prospectus for institutional bond funds; check vanguard.com for fund descriptions and risk disclosures. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
N4EA is a family company started by Sadie Frank and her brother, with Sadie as CEO/co-founder and her brother handling technical skills.
Sadie Frank ·2:36
How to verify: N4EA corporate website 'About Us' section or LinkedIn profiles of Sadie Frank and her brother. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
El Niño caused massive typhoons in the Asia Pacific region, clogging ports like Shanghai, and subsequently caused drought in Panama restricting waterways.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·6:25
How to verify: National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) El Niño reports; port authority announcements from Shanghai and Panama Canal Authority regarding closures and water levels in 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Hurricane Helene and Milton washed out railways, taking a couple hundred million dollars off one major rail company's operating profit for the year.
Sadie Frank ·8:52
How to verify: SEC 10-K or 10-Q filings of major US railroads (e.g., Norfolk Southern, CSX) for the fiscal year 2026; news reports on hurricane damage costs. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceHurricane Helene and Milton knocked out a core saline bag distribution facility, forcing hospitals to adjust patient hydration procedures.
Sadie Frank ·9:12
How to verify: Hospital press releases or operational reports from facilities in Oregon; news coverage of medical supply chain disruptions post-Hurricane Helene. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
80% of goods are transported on the water.
Sadie Frank ·11:43
How to verify: United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) Review of Maritime Transport; World Bank logistics data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Panama Canal Authority implemented proactive water management this year to reserve water for future El Niño impacts.
Andrew Stevenson ·17:27
How to verify: Panama Canal Authority official statements or press releases regarding water conservation measures and toll/cargo adjustments in 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Columbia River Bar was completely shut to traffic for a couple of days last weekend due to wind and storms.
Sadie Frank ·25:10
How to verify: US Coast Guard notices to mariners; local news reports from the Pacific Northwest regarding Columbia River Bar closures in late 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Insurers are seeing wind damage as a sneaking, year-over-year increasing loss category in their claims over the past ten years.
Sadie Frank ·25:54
How to verify: Insurance industry reports (e.g., from Swiss Re, Munich Re) or specific insurer claims data summaries published in 2026-2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Hormuz knocked out some 30% or something of fertilizer supply.
Sadie Frank ·29:20
How to verify: International Fertilizer Association reports; news articles detailing fertilizer supply chain disruptions linked to Strait of Hormuz events in 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify N4EA's methodology for quantifying logistics disruption risk by reviewing their whitepapers or client case studies.
- Check recent Panama Canal Authority reports on water management strategies and cargo mix shifts during El Niño events.
- Review insurer claims data for wind damage trends at major US West Coast ports like the Columbia River Bar.
- Analyze historical data on co-occurring disruptions, such as Asian typhoons and Panama Canal droughts, to assess compounding cost impacts.
- Examine federal budget proposals for FEMA to evaluate potential changes in disaster relief funding.
- Research the logistics of transporting large data center components via barge on the Mississippi and Ohio rivers.
- Look for reports on the impact of Hurricane Helene and Milton on medical supply chains in Oregon.
- Assess the risk of stacked geopolitical and climate events, such as a Taiwan Strait conflict combined with a Gulf hurricane, on oil and fertilizer markets.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Today's show is brought to you by Vanguard. Advisors, your clients count on bonds for income and stability, not unwanted surprises. That's why Vanguard builds institutional quality bond funds. They're designed to help portfolios remain steady when markets don't. Whether index or active, Vanguard aims for consistent bond performance with a low cost edge, which helps. clients earn returns that compound over time. A rigorous approach to risk management holds it all together. The goal? Keeping income instability in and unwelcome surprises out. Because fixed income shouldn't feel like a roller coaster. Explore institutional quality bond funds from Vanguard. Learn more at vanguard.com. slash audio. That's vanguard.com slash audio. While investing is subject to risk. Vanguard Marketing Corporation distributor.
1:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Financial markets can no longer ignore the impacts of climate change, shifting consumer expectations, and increasing regulatory scrutiny. These forces are reshaping industries, redefining risk, and creating new opportunities. for long-term value creation. Through conversations with industry leaders, investors, and subject matter experts, we explore where sustainability is translating into measurable financial outcomes. Welcome to Sustainability Currents, brought to you by Bloomberg Intelligence.
1:39Andrew Stevenson: Welcome to Sustainability Currents. I'm your host today, Andy Stevenson, senior climate analyst for Bloomberg Intelligence. And today we're going to talk about all things supply chains, especially in the context of El Nino, which has a a habit of making some a mess. I'm joined today by Sadie Frank. She is the CEO and co-founder of N4EA.
2:01Sadie Frank: Awesome. Thanks so much. Glad to be here. Andrew.
2:03Andrew Stevenson: Thank you. Uh could you please tell us a little bit about your company? I d obviously you're the supply chains business, or we wouldn't have you on today, but can you kind of uh break down what your uh company does and and the role you play?
2:16Sadie Frank: Yeah, so uh supply chain is a complex space. There's a lot of moving parts. My company focuses squarely on quantifying logistics disruption risk, which sounds wonky, but is basically trying to understand when things move around the world, where, when, and by how much uh things can get messed up. So that can be anything from building out scenario analysis models to see what happens to the Panama Canal if there's a disruption in the Strait of Taiwan, to looking at where and when uh weather risks will disrupt global supply chains. Um it's a family company, I always like to say, started by myself and my brother. Uh I'm the CEO and co-founder, so I talk to people and he's the technical skill that actually makes the thing go. Um, so yeah, so that's that's who we are. My background is in climate. So I'm a climate-related financial risk person. Um, spent a lot of time in this space and really love thinking about complex risks and how they impact people.
3:13Andrew Stevenson: I gotcha. And I just as you brought that up, I was thinking how much of your work now is related to kind of non-climate risks? Because obviously we have a lot of disruptive disruption, maybe not that much, but I'm just curious, is that something you're you mentioned Taiwan, Taiwan and places like that. Those are clearly more like what if scenarios. So this is a lot of what you're doing is around in the context of some kind of dramatic change, how does, you know, a company or a business respond, especially in the context of needing something tomorrow. You know, we're gonna spend a lot of time uh today talking about why that is a is a is a pretty expensive part of the equation.
3:54Sadie Frank: Yeah. It's a good question. You know, if you talk to an operator, so basically somebody who works in supply chain at like on at a dock, um or you know, is uh at Nike or something like that, they'll tell you that any disruption is a disruption. So it really actually doesn't matter if it's war or climate or tariffs. Um, what matters is the impact. And so, you know, for a lot of our clients, and doesn't really matter what the underlying thing is,
4:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it just matters what
4:22Sadie Frank: the impact is.
4:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I wouldn't think it does.
4:24Sadie Frank: Um yeah, you know, and so so we do look broadly. Uh, I will say, however, it kind of tends to move cyclically. So this year, you know, with Hormuz, everybody was highly attuned to geopolitical risk. Um, I will say with El Nino, however, we're starting to circle back to clients, you know, across insurance, commodities, and logistics, waking up to the fact that El Nino is a huge risk and it's already starting to impact their bottom line. So, you know, I'd say it's kind of a bit of a moving target, but the nice thing about supply chains is that when the impacts are visible, the entire economy feels them. So again, there's like this nice way that it doesn't really matter what the underlying risk is, it matters where and when it occurs and who it impacts. Oh,
5:05Andrew Stevenson: that makes sense. All right, well let's like kick into El Nino here. I mean obviously the Panama Canal might be a good a good example for people as well because that was pretty pretty impactful. and it and it was uh rather unexpected, at least at the time. Can you talk about some of the what your clients are asking you about about El Nino? I mean, obviously it affects
5:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
5:25Andrew Stevenson: whole world. So it has uh has a quite a bit of breadth to how wide they could be asking the question. But
5:31Sadie Frank: yeah. So as you mentioned, El Nino is global and I think one of the things that tends to get underappreciated about supply chain risk. is that, you know, based because of the way that we've built out these global supply chains over the past 50 to 100 years, you really have companies that are truly global in the sense that they source from one location, ship it to another location, maybe build a product at one location, ship it all the way back around the world, send it to a distribution center, and then, you know, it reaches the end customer. What that means is that clients can say, oh, well, uh, Panama might experience drought, doesn't really impact me. That turns out to not be true because you get these localized disruptions that can cause massive downstream impacts. And what you get within something like El Niño is you get co-occurring disruptions in different places that all kind of drive costs up in specific ways. Um,
6:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): so
6:25Sadie Frank: just to kind of make that concrete. you know, what we're seeing this year is that there were massive typhoons in the sort of Asia Pacific region, which is a very expected pattern that happens with El Nino. That clogged up some of the major ports like uh Shenza and some of the big ports in Asia that provide a lot of manufacturing and a lot of the sort of core inputs and finished goods to the East Coast. of the US. And then you also saw, you know, like just about a month later, drought in Panama restricting waterways. So that caused another disruption. And now we're sort of tracking that risk across space and time into, you know, winter season here. And you're starting to see, I mean, I'm in Portland, Oregon right now and it's pouring rain and you're seeing massive wind risks start to pile up in places like California, which can impact ports. So the risk isn't static. And I think what we hear from clients mostly is where am I going to be impacted? How long is it going to last? And then fundamentally, you know, like what can I do about it? And what are my options for responding to this risk? But I always just come back to the fact that it truly is global and it truly drives risk. You know, doesn't really matter where you are in the world in place and time, like it will it eventually. hit you in some way.
7:40Andrew Stevenson: Gotcha. Yeah. I mean, you think about what happened this year with all the storms, basically, as you say, heading out of the Atlantic into the Pacific.
7:46Sadie Frank: Yep.
7:46Andrew Stevenson: Bashing around the Pacific quite a bit. Hawaii got hit a couple of times this year. Um, wasn't as bad as
7:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
7:53Andrew Stevenson: Cat Five or anything, but it was still pretty dramatic in terms of what they do. And, you know, they're very dependent on the rest of the world in terms of how they get their how they get everything in uh in. into the country or into the into the states state and city rather. Um, can you maybe follow a chain for us just so we understand what you're kind of driving at? Like how are these ricochet bullets, you know, hitting the target, missing the target effectively? Like how how you Yeah, you can pick any example you want, but just just to give it of an example of like something starts here in the and the butterfly flapped its wings and all of a sudden, you know, we're feeling it over here somewhere else.
8:32Sadie Frank: Yeah, absolutely. I'll start with sort of the the charismatic megafauna of examples, which is very personal to me, which is that a couple of years ago, um, you know, this was uh everyone's probably remembers Hurricane Helene in Milton, And which hit the coast of the US, eastern coast of the US, and Florida. And so, you know, that was a big storm. It washed out a bunch of railways that, you know, took, I think, a couple hundred million dollars off of one major rail company's operating profit for the year. So core risk happened, okay, big risk. A year later, I was in, I was getting a procedure done here at a hospital in Oregon. And I was delighted, I couldn't get in for weeks. I was like, what's going on? And finally they hooked. me up to the thing and they don't give me water when I need water, right? I don't know if you've had sort of an inpatient procedure, but they tend to be very strict about when you can drink. And I was like, what's going on? Last time I was here, you know, I could drink water. And, you know, what they told me was that because Hurricane Helene and Milton had knocked out a core saline bag distribution facility, that they had had to adjust their entire optimal. operating procedures for when patients could stay hydrated and look when and how to hydrate patients, because they weren't able to have the stock that they needed to actually like they had to adhere to their typical procedures for hydration for patients.
9:51And so I think that that is a core example, you know, in terms of the real impact that this can have on people's lives, where if a supplier is disrupted, right? So there's like one or two places in the world that manufacture a specific thing, if that's the case and one of those goes down, you know, the entire downstream supply chain is impacted. And again, that sounds wonky, but what it comes down to is me getting my inpatient procedure in Oregon. And so that's kind of, I think, a really grounded example. You know, one of the other ones that we think about when we just sort of think at a high level, I can talk for a little bit about. data centers and critical infrastructure build-outs, you know, that we're seeing globally. You know, as I mentioned, a lot of those start in Asia. So you get a lot of the kind of like core fabrication for chips um going on. Those chips trans are transported on specific supply chains because they're very high value and they need to be packed very precisely and they need to get flown. So once you get a sh uh chip manufactured. it then has to get flown by air to very specific distribution points around the world. If there's weather, for instance, you know, we've all been on airplanes where there's turbulence where it's like too hot to take off, that's a risk to the chips themselves, right? So not only do you have concentration of chip manufacturing, I think it's Taiwan that is the largest
11:11chip manufacturer along with South Korea. So if you have disruptions to the suppliers that build the chips, that's a risk. If you have disruptions to the airports that transport the chips, that's a risk.
11:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
11:23Sadie Frank: then likewise, once you actually get the chips to their final destinations, you have to put them in in data centers and server racks that also have to get shipped around the world. And those are shipped on boats. And so these are, you know, I think maybe folks have heard about this 80% statistic that says. that like 80% of goods are transported on the water. That's true. But what that actually means is that if you're shipping big stuff or you're shipping highly perishable stuff, that all has to go on specific boats that are intricately designed within an inch of their life to get there on time and to get there safely. And so just kind of lock this into people's minds, you know, when you're transporting a massive piece of equipment, so like a turbine or, you know, like a co a cooling station or whatever, that often gets shipped up the Mississippi, which I don't think people really like. I was shocked to learn this, but barge transport. So you get into mobile deep water port like mobile or New Orleans, and then you get uh will get put on a barge, shipped up the Mississippi, shipped even further down local U.S. rivers. So the, I think like the Alley. Allegheny and the Ohio River. And then if you can't get to your location by barge, you have to use specialized road transport that can take like f you know, days and days and days because you're carrying something so big that it has to move like 10 miles an hour on tiny little local
12:42roads. So when we think about critical infrastructure like the these massive data center projects in Ohio, those are all of those components are getting moved along like the rivers in your backyard. And so I I don't think that that's like what people tend to think of when they think of data center or like critical infrastructure risk, anything, electricity build out, but that's how it happens, you know, and it's like all going on in the background of our daily lives. But it's it's those when we talk about physical constraints to building, that's exactly what we're talking about.
13:12Andrew Stevenson: Right. I mean, I you you've you right maybe think. made me of also another risk that's that's uh related to the wildfires, which is completely uh yeah counterintuitive. But you know, people's procedures in Ohio were canceled because they can't get the air, the air filtered from the outside is not clean. You know, like
13:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they
13:32Andrew Stevenson: they it would they need special purification equipment. So I thought people just canceled their appointments because they didn't want to go outside, but no. it's the ER that cancels those appointments because they have to have pure air inside of those operating rooms and they can't start with junk. You know, like as it comes, I mean
13:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): there can be
13:50Andrew Stevenson: doesn't have to be perfect, but it it has to be a long way from, you know, uh h heavy PM, whatever particle matter in the air and things like that for you to actually be able to use it. So um some of these things you're talking about like you know, just the trusting that the river is flowing, you know, like trusting that the air is clean. You know, like these are these these are what we take for granted every day, right? In the Rhine, for example, the summer in Germany, I mean it was you could have a p a picnic in the middle of the Rhine in a lot of places this summer. You know, like people were the barges that are the uh the transport things for like Viking cruiser cruises, for example, they had to drop people off because it just wasn't enough water, right? So that those kind of uh you know, there's lessons to be learned from how to do it next time, right? Almost every one of these things, and I assume that's a lot of kind of the the work that you're doing is drawing on history. Um I was a little curious about I mean, obviously COVID was look got kind of the mother of all supply chain disaster. disasters, right? I what in terms of things being closed down and just not having access to different things. Um is it I mean, are these climate events in a in a way similar to that? Or is that was that just a completely it's very hard to use as a proxy for what's going on today because it was just such an
15:09absolute, you know, shutdown.
15:11Sadie Frank: Great question. So I think COVID was abnormal in the sense that, you know, we had not had a global pandemic occur on the scale that it did in industrialized 21st century society, right? So, you know, I think that that was kind of a wake-up call for everybody about how the about the fragility in the system that we built, because it hadn't been really tested on a scale. So my brother likes to say that uh people mistook supply chains for transparent because nothing had bad enough had ever happened. But in fact, what it really is is like a Rube Goldberg machine where, you know, like it's just a complete mess. And so COVID kind of like woke everybody up to how fragile this system was. Because again, it hadn't been tested
15:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
15:56Sadie Frank: modern in modern history. I think climate is a little bit different in the sense that. it's predictable, which I think people underestimate, right? I mean, and this goes to your work, which is that we can quantify it and we can get a sense of, you know, there's obviously a ton of work that needs to be done, but you know, El Nino is a predictable phenomenon. We know when it's going to happen. We generally know where and how the impacts occur. Um, so you can actually prepare for it and measure it and understand. it. You know, pandemics and geopolitical risks, I always say to people, are a little bit different because they're, I mean,
16:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what
16:34Sadie Frank: are what is, you know, what is an exogenous of event? But it is exogenous in the fact that it can come out of nowhere kind of and shut down large swaths of the of the planet. Um, so I think COVID was a little bit different, but I think that the lessons that we take from that is the same, which is that, you know, we live on a I always say we live on a bounded planet with finite infrastructure and only certain ways to get from point A to point B. And we all rely on that shared infrastructure. So we have to understand what the risks are. And it again, it doesn't really matter what the what the underlying driver of the risk is, it can really just be about the impact.
17:07Andrew Stevenson: Makes sense. I I wanted to kind of go back to your comment earlier about the Panama Canal because this year we saw prices go through the roof. for shipping. It was actually preventative this year. Like they this was trying to make sure that they had enough water reserved for next year because people talk about El Niño, like, oh, it didn't happen or whatever, but it's it's happening this month is when it starts officially, right? So it's this is the next sort of four to six months, is really the the kind of meat of it from uh and and I think it's interesting because it
17:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
17:41Andrew Stevenson: is predictable, but what isn't what is unusual is sometimes the window is different. So the the window of like you look at what happened with the Panama Canal the last time around, it was sort of Christmas season, shall we say. But this this time around it's more agricultural products that go through there. So that's another thing that I think maybe might be helpful for people that get a better understanding of is just like why this stuff is it's not just a cookie cutter answer. It's a it's very much a seasonally driven response function, right?
18:12Sadie Frank: Yeah, absolutely. I mean, and I think that that's one of the core things to communicate to anybody who's interested in trying to mitigate this risk. Again, whether or not you're your sort of pricing it if you're an insurer or you're trading off of it if you are in commodities or financial markets, or you're actually like shipping something, which is that risk here is a function of time and space. It has it has geographic components and it has temporal components. And understanding both of those and how they interact is key. Of, you know, seasonality and cyclicality means something very specific. So, you know, obviously if you're shipping everything. agricultural products, you need to be highly aware of when your planting season is going to be, what the harvest looks like. You know, all of those have a seasonal element that shifts, right? Depending on kind of what the weather is.
19:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
19:02Sadie Frank: then also if you're transporting and loading those grains, you need to be able to have ships in place to pick up those grains within a window so that they don't spoil and they're
19:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): not
19:09Sadie Frank: like sitting out on a dock exposed to moisture, which is a huge risk. So, you know, everybody. at each step in the supply chain needs to be aware of those shifting temporal factors when they're thinking about risk. Um
19:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
19:23Sadie Frank: I think that that's that's a core thing that, you know, as we think about subseasonal forecasting, as we think about some of, you know, the better weather modeling, um, that can happen. But going going back to your Panama point, I also think one of the interesting things is that the Panama Canal Authority is reacting. There's sort of this sort of adaptive function in all of this, right? Where like last year or last time around, um, huge impacts because, you know, the Panama Canal Authority, I think, kind of got caught a little flat footed by the impact there. And now you're seeing proactive, a lot more sort of more proactive water management built into the system. And I know that the Canal Authority is taking, you know, is paying extremely exquisite attention to this to be able to manage their their asset long into the future. So, you know, I do think in a just to not to overly make complex the question of temporality, but then you also have this adaptive response that needs to come into play here when we
20:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): think about the systemic actors.
20:17Andrew Stevenson: They get paid by things going through, right? So they uh saw a big drop in their pay and they wanted to make sure that doesn't happen again. So I mean that's the continuous contingency factors. Uh obviously I mean there's a cost to that, of course, but but usually it's it's weighed against the cost of something else happening again to kind of mess things up. I was going to say any anything in the US that you're particularly focused on, just to bring it back a little home uh in terms of supply chains and and uh
20:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
20:48Andrew Stevenson: the context of El Nino, I mean one of the things that I've been watching is for example, the corn harvest in Brazil and how it's kind of soybeans are getting pushed back and they use the same fields. And so you end up this sort of pushing the corn season into the middle of next summer, which is a little scary from a, you know, corn is very perishable at certain temperatures. It just kind of dies, right? So that has a knock on effect to
21:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
21:15Andrew Stevenson: other parts of the world that don't have that problem, right? So the US is one of those places where we expect enough rain to make it a pretty reasonable season and give them kind of an advantage. Do you even do you look at things like that? Do you kind of I mean obviously there's sort of the way I always look at it's just like there's winners and losers in this often, right? It's not it's not always like you think about, okay, well, you know, we had a wildfire or something like that. People didn't go outside and do stuff that nobody wins, right? You know, like but you usually when there's a cost pressure to rebuild from a hurricane or whatever, the guy that, you know, in Oregon, for example, your local timber guy may jack up prices because the prices in in in Florida are higher, right? And that's not because uh he's trying to take advantage of that. He's not getting as much timber because they basically bypass him and send it all down to rebuild. So
22:10Sadie Frank: well I mean the direct uh analogy there in terms of what we've seen this year is Hormuz, which is that it has been a banner year if you own a tanker, right? Because we you know freight prices are through the roof because you know like everybody needs to scramble to get ships. So, you know, if you I think m I was just looking at Maersk's op, you know, those shipping companies have are raking in the dough. So, you know, disruption always has winners and losers, and it depends on what side of the the risk you're what side of the trade you're you're on. Sure. Um I would say in terms of things that we're watching that are sneakers, um, wind. So wind and fog. So, you know, obviously. I'm on the Pacific Coast and the Columbia is like a massive grain exporter. You know, it's if we think about sort of like major global grain um and agricultural corridors, you know, the West Coast ships an immense amount of stuff. What will happen when you high I was just talking um to a subseasonal forecaster um about this, which is
23:10that, you know, you get high wind speeds at ports and you can't load because the cranes don't operate. And that's a safety risk for crew, but it's also a risk of damage. So if you have a crane swinging around, your cargo can get damaged. Um, it can knock into another crane and then your crane can get damaged. So, you know, when we think about logistics risk, one of the things that worth keeping an eye on is things that can stop loading for grains, where and which means that if you have stopped stop loading from you can't load in fog. you can't load in wind, you can't load in rain, um, that's a cargo risk because again, if you have these highly perishable things, as you just mentioned, sitting around unable to get loaded in time, that's a potential both quality risk and delivery risk. So that's something that we're keeping an eye on when we're thinking about where these occurs.
23:55Andrew Stevenson: And and in the context of overseeing we're seeing in the West Coast, you you're obviously physically closer and probably intellectually closer than I am. But uh but uh there's been a lot of you know I can't remember what they're what they're calling it these sort of something waves in the in up the west on the west coast where they just keep you know putting a lot of pressure on the coastline in ways that has never happened before. Is that the wind you're describing the the do you remember I'm what talking about the whatever they call it Calvin Calvin waves waves.
24:24Sadie Frank: I'm a big I'm a big surfer actually and I was just on the coast this weekend,
24:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): not
24:28Sadie Frank: to surf, but just to like look at the waves because
24:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they were
24:30Sadie Frank: nuts. Um, but I will give you a specific example that's grounded in our data and the kind of thing we do. So we did research on soybeans globally to see which soybean trade routes were the most at risk of delay. What we actually found was that it was the Columbia River ports and the Columbia River routes that were that, you know, statistically. have the highest likelihood of delay. And the reason for that is, we suspect, because of the Columbia River Bar and because of the fact that you have to utilize the river system to get out to port and then out to the export markets. And so just to give you a specific example of this, on the coast last weekend the Columbia River Bar was completely shut to traffic. So you literally could not get ships in and out of that. waterway for I think
25:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
25:17Sadie Frank: couple of days. That obviously has a huge impact on whether or not you're shipping. And so I'm
25:22Andrew Stevenson: sorry, and why was it shed? It was shut because
25:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of wind
25:24Sadie Frank: and because of the storms.
25:26Andrew Stevenson: Because
25:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of the wind,
25:26Andrew Stevenson: yeah,
25:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I guess.
25:28Sadie Frank: Vessels can only operate in a certain amount of wave and wind speed, um, wave height and wind speed. And so that's a huge risk.
25:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
25:34Sadie Frank: that's kind of an example of how you know these things can really stack up over time. And actually I was talking to an insurer the other day, and they were saying that when they were looking back at their claims over the past ten years, it was actually wind damages that were sneaking up year over year in terms of the things that they weren't necessarily having on their radar when it came to climate risks. But that was actually where it was showing up in their claims was that over the years, wind damage was becoming one of the main losses, which is pretty interesting.
26:03Andrew Stevenson: On the West Coast too, not this is not a East Coast thing.
26:07Sadie Frank: They're a global thing, but it was, you know, about the specific issue of wind speed and damages to port infrastructure that they were ensuring.
26:15Andrew Stevenson: Sure. And and the obviously with we we have this year with El Nino, we had kind of a calm Atlantic this year and kind of a more feisty Pacific, shall we say. How did that affect? or not affect trade routes? Was that a was that a factor? Or was because we had a record number of cat five storms and I mean it's in the ocean. So there's a lot of ocean. So maybe you can always get
26:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): around
26:36Andrew Stevenson: it. But is that something that also is a consideration or is there just sort of like longer roads that take a little more fuel?
26:43Sadie Frank: It depends kind of on the time of year and what what's going on locally. But I will say, so obviously without the massive East Coast um damages and what you saw in the Gulf, like that there was no disruption there, which was great. You know, like we had a much more
26:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): stable
26:59Sadie Frank: trade environment for everything, commit both going into and coming out of the Gulf and the East Coast. Um
27:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what
27:05Sadie Frank: I will say about that Atlantic season, though, or sorry, the Pacific season, was as I mentioned, these dis delays stacking up at these Asian ports. So, you know, Shanghai, I think. the port of Shanghai was closed for a couple of days and that caused like massive backlogs in terms of container shipping. Yeah. And that was because the port again had
27:24Andrew Stevenson: And that was wind?
27:25Sadie Frank: That was yeah, typhoon. You can't load. And so I think it was Shanghai and another major port. And these stack up. So you get like a single disruption. Okay, it's a couple of days, but actually what that throws off is the entire shipping. like entire liner services. So that was a huge impact from El Niña that we saw.
27:43Andrew Stevenson: There are pictures of these guys on the East Coast or what on the West Coast. This is during kind of the COVID era, where they just sit in their trucks waiting and waiting and waiting and waiting days, right? Because they don't get paid until they deliver and they're not delivering because they can't get their stuff to the port.
27:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
27:58Sadie Frank: And it's all it's all a chain, it's a supply chain, you know? So it's like one one link.
28:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
28:03Sadie Frank: the chain gets disrupted and then the whole thing has to adjust.
28:06Andrew Stevenson: All right. So I'm going to put you on the hot seat since we're getting near to the end of the time here. Um 2027, 2028, I just may take more than a year to kind of play out. But what are the things that you're really looking at or kind of on your radar for things that people should be aware of?
28:21Sadie Frank: You know, I think where we're what really keeps me up at night is co-occurring co occurring risks because of as I mentioned, you know, we live there's only so many ways to get from A to B. There's only so many producing regions. You know, you you used your core an example, but you know, think about key commodities like cocoa or even pharmaceutical supply chains where they're highly concentrated in India and China. There's only certain places in the world that produce our key goods. Um, if you get risk in one place. that stacks on top of risk in another, that's a s that's a massive systemic disruption. And so what keeps me up at night is again thinking about Taiwan, you know, if there is sort of like a conflict, a major conflict over the next couple of years. Um that Taiwan Strait is massive global choke point. Okay. So if we get that, and then we also get, you know, some a category five hurricane in, you know, the Gulf, uh, what's what does that do to oil markets? You know, and so what does that do to all of the key inputs? You know, we saw I think Hormuz like knocked out some 30% or something of fertilizer, and nobody was really paying attention to fertilizer. Turns out that, you know, fertilizer supply chains are highly concentrated. So that keeps me up at night. Is like, what if we get sort of like stacked co-occurring disruptions from an overall more riskier operating? environment. Um,
29:40what does that do to global prices and and really global stability? I mean, not to like zoom all the way out, but
29:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
29:46Sadie Frank: we saw what happened um in COVID and sort of, you know, like what what these massive shocks can do to the global environment. So that's my that my sunny outlook. There's
29:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): your
29:56Andrew Stevenson: sunny outlook. Yeah, like Well I mean to bring it back to you you're were talking about Hurricane Ian and Helene, those were or Milton and Helene, excuse me. those happen kind of at the same
30:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): time,
30:05Andrew Stevenson: right? Within a couple of weeks of each other. And what normally happens is, you know, crews come down from the northeast and repair the power grid and they go back up, but then you have two of them, right? So you're you're both of them got slower. You know, so like that's that's you know, I mean that for the concerns that very similar concerns, but in a more of a federal construct is that, you know, we may have less support and it from FEMA and places like that going forward because the budgets are seem to be going south as opposed to the north. And it the none of that's free, you know. Like we have to we actually that's that's sort of an insulator for a lot of activity, right? You want these economies to get back on track as soon as we put quickly as soon as possible, right? That's the
30:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
30:53Andrew Stevenson: thing that you give up with that.
30:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
30:55Sadie Frank: I mean, and I think that just goes back to what we've been talking about throughout this whole conversation about risk having both a geographic and a temporal component, you know, right? If you get risk stacked globally and then you also get them stacked in time, um, which I think just points overall to having a more
31:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
31:12Sadie Frank: deeper bench of options. and sort of like thinking through a constrained world and then what does that world look like and how do you develop solutions that allow you to still function, right? And I mean I think that that's like the ultimate goal of resilience is sort of thinking through all the options, identifying what works, and then figuring out how to deploy them when you need them.
31:34Andrew Stevenson: Great. Well thank you so much for your time. I certainly appreciate that it, Thadie. That was great. I I hope uh listeners were as entertained as I am, because I'm I I know this is gets a little wonky, but at the end of the day, this affects your pocketbook, it affects my pocketbook, and it is it is like what drives a lot of the economy, is every little piece that goes into everything that you did you build. You know, you think about an iPhone, the last thing it gets done is it's assembled in China, like the rest of
32:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
32:03Andrew Stevenson: it's not built in China, but like the last piece is there, right? So thank you so much, Sadie, and uh I appreciate your time.
32:17Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Here are
32:17Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): five
32:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): reasons
32:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): to subscribe to
32:19Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Bloomberg News Now. Number five, you get the latest news from around the world instantly. Number
32:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): four, it
32:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): saves you time.
32:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Your
32:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): day's busy.
32:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Catching up takes just a few
32:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): minutes.
32:29Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Three, it's available 24 hours a day whenever you need it. Two, it's convenient.
32:34Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Listen on your smartphone
32:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): or
32:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): smart
32:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): speaker.
32:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And number one, it's easy to find. Subscribe on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or anywhere you listen. Five reasons: one simple way to stay on top of the news. Bloomberg News Now.