Analysis of Alberta separatism claims, fiscal impacts, and economic risks compared to Brexit
Summary
Host Richard examines the Alberta Prosperity Project's push for independence, citing political tensions and alleged foreign interference. He critiques a LifeWorks report on CPP contributions, arguing it ignores costs like OAS and uses unrealistic oil price assumptions. The episode highlights trade risks, potential capital flight similar to Quebec's sovereignty movement, and the volatility of an oil-dependent economy. Finally, it compares the situation to Brexit, suggesting the movement may be a bargaining chip rather than a genuine path to independence.
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 2:25
Introduction and Sponsor Reads
The episode begins with sponsor advertisements for IG Private Wealth, BetMGM Sportsbook, Sephora, and PlayOjo, followed by host Richard introducing the topic of Alberta separatism.
- 2:25 – 5:31
Context of Alberta Separatism
Richard explains that the Alberta Prosperity Project is collecting signatures for a referendum on independence, citing political tensions, Western alienation, and alleged foreign interference involving US officials and a $500 billion loan offer.
- 5:31 – 10:00
Alberta's Economic Profile
The host provides a primer on Alberta, noting its status as a prairie province with a strong oil and gas sector (80% of Canada's oil production in 2024) and high GDP per capita, despite representing only 15% of Canada's GDP.
- 10:00 – 14:37
Fiscal Arguments for Independence
The segment details the fiscal grievances driving separatism, including equalization payments where Alberta is a net contributor, and the Canada Pension Plan (CPP), with claims that Alberta contributes disproportionately to the pension fund.
- 14:37 – 20:56
Critique of the LifeWorks Report
The host critiques a LifeWorks report estimating Alberta's CPP share at $334 billion, citing Dr. Trevor Toomb's analysis that the report ignores costs for OAS and child benefits, underestimates military spending, and uses unrealistic oil price assumptions.
- 20:56 – 22:56
Trade and Capital Flight Risks
Risks of secession include becoming landlocked, losing access to the Canadian Free Trade Agreement, and facing increased trade costs similar to Brexit. The host also cites historical data from Quebec showing significant business and capital flight during separatist periods.
- 22:56 – 25:23
Currency and Structural Challenges
The host discusses the logistical challenges of creating a new currency, potential federal debt allocation, indigenous rights renegotiations, and the volatility of basing an economy on oil and gas, which fluctuates significantly.
- 25:23 – 28:55
Conclusion and Brexit Comparison
The episode concludes by comparing the situation to Brexit, noting that misinformation played a role in the UK vote, and suggesting that Alberta's separatist movement may be used as a bargaining chip by the provincial government rather than a genuine path to independence.
Assets discussed
| Asset | Kind | Stance | Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gold | commodity | neutral | The Alberta Prosperity Project proposes that the province adopt the US dollar for some reason and then eventually transition to its own Alberta backed by gold, Bitcoin, and oil, but doesn't account for the cost of setting up those reserves, nor the risk of a province that's a fraction of the country size launching a new currency from scratch. |
| BitcoinBTC | crypto | neutral | The Alberta Prosperity Project proposes that the province adopt the US dollar for some reason and then eventually transition to its own Alberta backed by gold, Bitcoin, and oil, but doesn't account for the cost of setting up those reserves, nor the risk of a province that's a fraction of the country size launching a new currency from scratch. |
| Crude oil | commodity | neutral | The Alberta Prosperity Project proposes that the province adopt the US dollar for some reason and then eventually transition to its own Alberta backed by gold, Bitcoin, and oil, but doesn't account for the cost of setting up those reserves, nor the risk of a province that's a fraction of the country size launching a new currency from scratch. |
“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.
Claims worth verifying
Separatists met with US officials to discuss a $500 billion loan to help Alberta transition to independence.
Unidentified speaker ·
How to verify: Search news archives for reports on meetings between Alberta separatist groups and US officials regarding loans, or check statements from BC Premier David Eby.
Between 19 and 29% of Albertans support independence to varying degrees.
Unidentified speaker ·
How to verify: Review recent polling data from reputable Canadian pollsters (e.g., Nanos, Abacus Data) on Alberta separatism sentiment.
Alberta made up over 80% of Canada's total oil production in 2024.
Unidentified speaker ·
How to verify: Check Natural Resources Canada or the Alberta Energy Regulator's 2024 production statistics.
The oil sands account for 98% of Canada's proven oil reserves.
Unidentified speaker ·
How to verify: Consult the Alberta Energy Regulator or the Canadian Association of Petroleum Producers' latest reserves report.
Alberta represents about 15% of Canada's gross domestic product.
Unidentified speaker ·
How to verify: Review Statistics Canada data on provincial GDP contributions for the relevant year.
Alberta Premier Danielle Smith argues the province sends out over $20 billion more annually than it receives.
Unidentified speaker ·
How to verify: Search for official statements or speeches by Premier Danielle Smith regarding federal transfer payments and equalization.
A 2023 LifeWorks report estimated Alberta's share of the CPP at $334 billion.
Unidentified speaker ·
How to verify: Locate and review the full text of the LifeWorks report titled 'The Economic Case for Alberta Independence' or similar publications from 2023.
NATO's target of 2% of GDP would put annual military spending at $10 billion, rising to $25 billion under a 5% target.
Unidentified speaker ·
How to verify: Calculate based on Alberta's GDP and compare with NATO spending guidelines; verify the specific claims made by Dr. Trevor Toomb in his critique.
From 1976 to 1979, an estimated 368 businesses moved their headquarters out of Quebec.
Unidentified speaker ·
How to verify: Search historical economic records or academic papers on the economic impact of the Quebec sovereignty movement for business relocation statistics.
Non-tariff barriers increased by 3 to 8% for the UK after Brexit, with GDP impacts ranging from 2 to 5%.
Unidentified speaker ·
How to verify: Review economic studies on Brexit's impact, such as those from the UK National Institute of Economic and Social Research or the Bank of England.
Do your own research
- Verify Alberta's 2024 oil production share and proven reserve percentages via Natural Resources Canada or Alberta Energy Regulator reports.
- Review the full LifeWorks report and Dr. Trevor Toomb's critique to assess assumptions on oil prices and cost allocations.
- Analyze Canada's equalization payment history and Alberta's net contribution status using Government of Canada fiscal data.
- Research post-Brexit trade barrier impacts and GDP effects using UK Office for National Statistics or academic studies.
- Examine historical capital flight data from Quebec's 1976-1979 sovereignty period via provincial business records or economic studies.
- Check current Canadian constitutional law regarding unilateral secession and the requirements for federal negotiation.
- Assess Alberta's government revenue composition over the last decade to evaluate reliance on volatile oil and gas sectors.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:00
- Unidentified speaker: Okay.
- 0:00
- Unidentified speaker: When I sell my business, I want the best tax and investment advice.
- 0:04
- Unidentified speaker: I want to help my kids, and I want to give back to the community.
- 0:07
- Unidentified speaker: Ooh, then it's the vacation of a lifetime.
- 0:12
- Unidentified speaker: I wonder if my head of office has a forever setter.
- 0:15
- Unidentified speaker: An IG Private Wealth Advisor creates the clarity you need with plans that harmonize your business, your family, and your dreams.
- 0:23
- Unidentified speaker: Get financial advice that puts you at the center.
- 0:26
- Unidentified speaker: Find your advisor at IGPrivatewealth.com.
- 0:31
- Unidentified speaker: Legendary has arrived at Alberta with BetMGM Sportsbook.
- 0:35
- Unidentified speaker: Sign up to unlock access to hundreds of pregame and live betting options for all your favorite sports, including hockey, baseball, soccer, and much more.
- 0:44
- Unidentified speaker: Have a hunt your favorite player is gonna have a great game?
- 0:47
- Unidentified speaker: Lock in your picks and watch the action unfold.
- 0:50
- Unidentified speaker: You can make your picks on your favorite team, too.
- 0:53
- Unidentified speaker: And every time you play, you can enjoy instant deposit options and fast withdrawals.
- 0:58
- Unidentified speaker: BetMGM Sportsbook is available in Alberta.
- 1:01
- Unidentified speaker: Download the app and experience Vegas thrills in the palm of your hand.
- 1:05
- Unidentified speaker: See BetMGM.com for terms.
- 1:07
- Unidentified speaker: 18 Plus Alberta only, please play responsibly, subject to eligibility requirements.
- 1:12
- Unidentified speaker: If gambling is affecting your mental health or well-being, 211 Alberta is here to help.
- 1:17
- Unidentified speaker: Call or text 211 or visit ab.211.ca.
- 1:21
- Unidentified speaker: BetMGM operates pursuant to an operating agreement with the Alberta Eye Gaming Corporation.
- 1:25
- Unidentified speaker: Standard message and data rates may apply.
- 1:30
- Unidentified speaker: This is big.
- 1:32
- Unidentified speaker: The Sephora Savings Event is back.
- 1:35
- Unidentified speaker: And now through November 9th, everything's on sale.
- 1:38
- Unidentified speaker: Everything you really want.
- 1:40
- Unidentified speaker: Like one size, Patrick Ta, Carastas, Kayali, Lane, and yeah, you're gonna need a bigger bag.
- 1:47
- Unidentified speaker: Shop at Sephora.
- 1:48
- Unidentified speaker: Limitations apply.
- 1:49
- Unidentified speaker: Must be a beauty insider.
- 1:50
- Unidentified speaker: See terms at Sephora.ca for complete details.
- 1:55
- Unidentified speaker: So your decaf oat milk extra but not piping hot, four pumps of caramel, no sugar, small latte, and a large cup.
- 2:01
- Unidentified speaker: That will be 10 minutes.
- 2:02
- Unidentified speaker: No worries.
- 2:03
- Unidentified speaker: I'm having fun on PlayOjo.
- 2:05
- Unidentified speaker: And I keep it fun with all the latest slot and live casino games.
- 2:08
- Unidentified speaker: Plus, I get instant payouts with no minimum withdrawals.
- 2:11
- Unidentified speaker: Oh, and no wagering requirements ever.
- 2:14
- Unidentified speaker: Here's your decaf oat milk extra but not piping hot.
- 2:16
- Unidentified speaker: Ah, thanks.
- 2:17
- Unidentified speaker: Playtime's over.
- 2:18
- Unidentified speaker: Mmm, lovely.
- 2:20
- Unidentified speaker: Feel the fun, playoff.
- 2:22
- Unidentified speaker: 18 plus Alberta only.
- 2:23
- Unidentified speaker: Please play responsibly.
- 2:24
- Unidentified speaker: Full term supply.
- 2:25
- Unidentified speaker: Hey everyone, it's Richard.
- 2:26
- Unidentified speaker: You're watching The Plain Bagel.
- 2:27
- Unidentified speaker: There's been a lot of talk about Alberta separatism lately.
- 2:31
- Unidentified speaker: Started off as a fringe movement that slowly picked up steam, and thanks to changes made at the provincial level to make a referendum easier to have, the Alberta Prosperity Project, a nonprofit pushing for independence, has started collecting signatures to put the question to voters as to whether Alberta should leave the rest of Canada.
- 2:49
- Unidentified speaker: And as you can imagine, in the current environment, the whole thing has been pretty controversial.
- 2:54
- Unidentified speaker: Canada is already facing a trade war from the United States and threats from Trump to turn the country into the 51st state via economic pressure.
- 3:02
- Unidentified speaker: And news broke last month of separatists meeting with US officials to discuss a $500 billion loan to help the province transition to independence.
- 3:11
- Unidentified speaker: Something BC Premier David Eby likened to treason.
- 3:14
- Unidentified speaker: Now, right from the get-go, it's worth highlighting these aren't elected officials, and only a minority of Albertans, between 19 and 29% according to recent polls, actually support independence to varying degrees, which while High for Canada is actually on par with some US states like California, and actually less than demand for independence from states like Texas and Alaska.
- 3:34
- Unidentified speaker: And the Alberta Prosperity Project behind the referendum, the most vocal group in pushing for independence here, is very much a p questionable organization, we'll call it.
- 3:44
- Unidentified speaker: In their own marketing material, which starts with a quote of the US Declaration of Independence, the group laments about Alberta's quote, downhill spiral into the vortex of the WEF UN Marxist agenda, they'll be exacerbated by the proposed digital ID, programmable digital currency, and the ESG credit score to control every aspect of your life.
- 4:03
- Unidentified speaker: And there are plenty of other examples of the group's co-founder Jeffrey Rath and CEO Mitch Sylvester saying pretty outlandish stuff.
- 4:10
- Unidentified speaker: Yet this fringe group has been given quite the megaphone, especially among some within the mega crowd.
- 4:16
- Unidentified speaker: Personalities on Twitter would have you believe that Albertans are dead set on separating or even joining the US, sharing videos of long lines and filled venues for referendum events, and Treasury Secretary Scott Bessant has even recently commented on working with Alberta as an independent country, all of which obviously raises anxieties about foreign interference from an administration that would actively benefit from a divided Canada.
- 4:38
- Unidentified speaker: Now, ultimately, Albertans have every right to self-advocate in discussing their relationship with the federal government.
- 4:44
- Unidentified speaker: But the current campaign being run by the Alberta Prosperity Project is built on misconceptions and misinformation.
- 4:51
- Unidentified speaker: With a group making some pretty tall promises, saying they'll eliminate income taxes, sales taxes, save families tens of thousands of dollars a year, all with no grounding in reality and no consideration for the substantial risks and costs of secession.
- 5:08
- Unidentified speaker: Which is why I wanted to cover the topic.
- 5:09
- Unidentified speaker: I know this is a political issue and I don't usually like to cover the messy stuff, but I wanted to discuss the economic aspects that are often used to justify the idea of Albertan independence and really put them to some scrutiny, especially given the likelihood that we might face a vote here, and the risk of misinformation from either Wrath or Trump influencing people's decision.
- 5:31
- Unidentified speaker: But before hopping into the messy stuff, let's start with a bit of a primer about Berta.
- 5:35
- Unidentified speaker: At the risk of signing like a third-grade Canadian geography teacher, Alberta is one of Canada's three prairie provinces, known for its agriculture, with the province making up nearly half of livestock and crop market receipts, and its landscapes, with the province hosting a range of the Rocky Mountains and Banff National Park, the first and top-rated Canadian National Park.
- 5:53
- Unidentified speaker: It's also home to the world's largest outdoor rodeo, the Calgary Stampede, and the world's largest statue of a dinosaur, named Tyra.
- 6:00
- Unidentified speaker: Now, economically speaking, Alberta is most known for its oil and gas industry, with the province alone making up over 80% of the country's total oil production in 2024, thanks largely to its oil sands, which alone account for 98% of Canada's proven oil reserves.
- 6:18
- Unidentified speaker: Now, the province isn't the biggest economy in the country.
- 6:21
- Unidentified speaker: It represents about 15% of gross domestic product compared to Ontario.
- 6:25
- Unidentified speaker: Okay.
- 6:26
- Unidentified speaker: When I sell my business, I want the best tax and investment advice.
- 6:30
- Unidentified speaker: I want to help my kids, and I want to give back to the community.
- 6:33
- Unidentified speaker: Ooh, then it's the vacation of a lifetime.
- 6:37
- Unidentified speaker: I wonder if my head of office has a forever setter.
- 6:40
- Unidentified speaker: An IG Private Wealth Advisor creates the clarity you need with plans that harmonize your business, your family, and your dreams.
- 6:48
- Unidentified speaker: Get financial advice that puts you at the center.
- 6:51
- Unidentified speaker: Find your advisor at IGPrivatewealth.com.
- 6:55
- Unidentified speaker: The sports calendar is on fire, and the Score Bet has you covered with breaking news and betting seamlessly connected.
- 7:00
- Unidentified speaker: Every play, every stat, every score, giving you the tools you need to bet confidently.
- 7:05
- Unidentified speaker: Born in the North, built for you.
- 7:07
- Unidentified speaker: The Score Bet, Canada Sportsbook.
- 7:09
- Unidentified speaker: Please play responsibly, 18 years or older.
- 7:11
- Unidentified speaker: If gambling is affecting your mental health or well-being, help is available.
- 7:14
- Unidentified speaker: In Alberta, call or text 211 or visit ab.211.ca.
- 7:19
- Unidentified speaker: Standard message and data rates may apply.
- 7:26
- Unidentified speaker: This is big.
- 7:28
- Unidentified speaker: The Sephora Savings event is back.
- 7:31
- Unidentified speaker: And now through November 9th, everything's on sale.
- 7:34
- Unidentified speaker: Everything you really want.
- 7:36
- Unidentified speaker: Like one size, Patrick Ta, Karas Toss, Kayali, Lanege, and yeah, you're gonna need a bigger bag.
- 7:43
- Unidentified speaker: Shop at Sephora.
- 7:44
- Unidentified speaker: Limitations apply.
- 7:45
- Unidentified speaker: Must be a beauty insider.
- 7:46
- Unidentified speaker: See terms at Sephora.ca for complete details.
- 7:51
- Unidentified speaker: So your decaf oat milk extra but not piping hot, four pumps of caramel, no sugar, small latte, and a large cup.
- 7:57
- Unidentified speaker: That will be 10 minutes.
- 7:58
- Unidentified speaker: No worries.
- 7:59
- Unidentified speaker: I'm having fun on Playo.
- 8:01
- Unidentified speaker: And I keep it fun with all the latest slot and live casino games.
- 8:04
- Unidentified speaker: Plus, I get instant panels with no minimum withdrawals.
- 8:08
- Unidentified speaker: Oh, and no wagering requirements ever.
- 8:10
- Unidentified speaker: Here's your decaf oat milk extra but not piping hot.
- 8:12
- Unidentified speaker: Ah, thanks.
- 8:13
- Unidentified speaker: Playtime's over.
- 8:14
- Unidentified speaker: Mmm, lovely.
- 8:16
- Unidentified speaker: Feel the fun, playoff!
- 8:18
- Unidentified speaker: 18 plus Alberta only.
- 8:19
- Unidentified speaker: Please play responsibly, full term supply.
- 8:21
- Unidentified speaker: At 39% and Quebec at 20%.
- 8:24
- Unidentified speaker: But the province's natural resources have helped the province consistently achieve the highest GDP per capita and average income among provinces.
- 8:31
- Unidentified speaker: Now, as you might expect from a province that's sometimes called the Texas of the North, Alberta is fairly right-leaning when it comes to its politics.
- 8:39
- Unidentified speaker: And with Canada having been run by liberals since 2015, this has been the source of some tension over the past decade.
- 8:45
- Unidentified speaker: Environmental policies like the carbon tax and burdensome approval processes for oil projects, and a general lack of support for pipeline development from neighboring provinces has held back growth and investment for Alberta's oil and gas sector.
- 8:57
- Unidentified speaker: And with the majority of Canadians living in Ontario and Quebec alone, some have argued that Canada is experiencing Western alienation, this idea that eastern provinces are largely dominating politics for the country, something that has contributed to this growing separatist sentiment.
- 9:12
- Unidentified speaker: Now, Canada is no stranger to separatist movements.
- 9:14
- Unidentified speaker: In fact, the country's predominantly French province of Quebec has already had two referendums on independence, the latter of which just barely saw the province remain as a part of Canada in 1995, with the remain vote winning by a sliver at 50.6% of the vote.
- 9:32
- Unidentified speaker: But compared to Quebec, Alberta doesn't have the same deep roots or cultural concerns around things like language and the like.
- 9:38
- Unidentified speaker: In fact, in all of its history, Alberta has only ever elected one separatist to its legislative assembly.
- 9:45
- Unidentified speaker: Whereas the Bloc Québécois, a national party dedicated to Quebec's sovereignty that's previously pushed heavily for separatism, was actually the official opposition from 1993 to 1997, and even today holds a good number of seats in the country's House of Commons.
- 10:00
- Unidentified speaker: So then what's driving the desire to separate now?
- 10:03
- Unidentified speaker: Well, aside from the political grievance from a largely conservative province around a liberal party remaining in power after a long Justin Trudeau term, the arguments made are largely fiscal in nature, with one of the main points being around transfer payments.
- 10:18
- Unidentified speaker: As mentioned, Albertan households have a higher average income, which, thanks to Canada's progressive tax system, also means they tend to pay higher taxes.
- 10:26
- Unidentified speaker: A good chunk of this taxes goes towards transfer payments, which are distributed among the provinces to cover things like education, health care, and social services.
- 10:35
- Unidentified speaker: But one of these transfers, known as equalization payments, is specifically designed to redistribute revenue from wealthier provinces to those with lower income, to quote, ensure that all Canadians have access to broadly comparable levels of public services.
- 10:48
- Unidentified speaker: And these equalization transfers have been a point of frustration for the provincial government.
- 10:53
- Unidentified speaker: While the amounts don't represent an explicit fee charged to Alberta since all Canadians again face the same progressive tax rates, the province doesn't receive any amount from the transfers, making it a net contributor.
- 11:04
- Unidentified speaker: And Alberta Premier Danielle Smith argues that when you consider all transfers beyond just equalization, Alberta sends out over $20 billion more annually to the rest of Canada than it receives back in benefits.
- 11:17
- Unidentified speaker: An amount that represents an average of around $4,000 per capita.
- 11:21
- Unidentified speaker: So there's this view that Alberta is subsidizing other provinces in the country.
- 11:25
- Unidentified speaker: And there is some truth to that, with this view also extending to Alberta's contribution to the Canada Pension Plan.
- 11:31
- Unidentified speaker: Much like how Social Security works in the US, every employee in Canada pays a portion of their paycheck towards the CPP.
- 11:37
- Unidentified speaker: That amount gets matched by their employer and invested to help grow the pot.
- 11:41
- Unidentified speaker: And when the employee retires, they're able to receive payments from the program depending on their age, contribution period, and their average earnings while they worked.
- 11:49
- Unidentified speaker: Now, Alberta has a younger than average population, meaning that Albertans tend to make more contributions to the program than they see benefits redeemed.
- 11:57
- Unidentified speaker: And because of the higher average income, some believe the province has made a disproportionate contribution to the country's pension plan.
- 12:05
- Unidentified speaker: In fact, one 2023 LifeWorks report estimated that based on contributions, withdrawals, and historical performance, the province's share of CPP sat around $334 billion, representing roughly half of the entire country's plan.
- 12:21
- Unidentified speaker: Okay.
- 12:22
- Unidentified speaker: When I sell my business, I want the best tax and investment advice.
- 12:26
- Unidentified speaker: I want to help my kids, and I want to give back to the community.
- 12:29
- Unidentified speaker: Ooh, then it's the vacation of a lifetime.
- 12:33
- Unidentified speaker: I wonder if my head of office has a forever setter.
- 12:37
- Unidentified speaker: An IG Private Wealth Advisor creates the clarity you need with plans that harmonize your business, your family, and your dreams.
- 12:44
- Unidentified speaker: Get financial advice that puts you at the center.
- 12:47
- Unidentified speaker: Find your advisor at IGPrivateWealth.com.
- 12:51
- Unidentified speaker: The sports calendar is on fire and the score bet has you covered with breaking news and betting seamlessly connected.
- 12:57
- Unidentified speaker: Every play, every stat, every score, giving you the tools you need to bet confidently.
- 13:01
- Unidentified speaker: Born in the North, built for you.
- 13:03
- Unidentified speaker: The Score Bet, Canada Sportsbook.
- 13:05
- Unidentified speaker: Please play responsibly, 18 years or older.
- 13:07
- Unidentified speaker: If gambling is affecting your mental health or well-being, health is available.
- 13:10
- Unidentified speaker: In Alberta, call or text 211 or visit ab.211.ca.
- 13:15
- Unidentified speaker: Standard mental community rates may apply.
- 13:22
- Unidentified speaker: This is big.
- 13:24
- Unidentified speaker: The Sephora Savings event is back.
- 13:27
- Unidentified speaker: And now through November 9th, everything's on sale.
- 13:30
- Unidentified speaker: Everything you really want.
- 13:32
- Unidentified speaker: Like one size, Patrick Ta, Carastas, Kay Ali, Laneige, and yeah, you're gonna need a bigger bag.
- 13:39
- Unidentified speaker: Shop at Sephora.
- 13:40
- Unidentified speaker: Limitations apply.
- 13:41
- Unidentified speaker: Must be a beauty insider.
- 13:42
- Unidentified speaker: See terms at Sephora.ca for complete details.
- 13:47
- Unidentified speaker: So your decaf oat milk extra but not piping hot, four pumps of caramel, no sugar, small latte, and a large cup.
- 13:53
- Unidentified speaker: That will be 10 minutes.
- 13:54
- Unidentified speaker: No worries.
- 13:55
- Unidentified speaker: I'm having fun on Playo.
- 13:57
- Unidentified speaker: And I keep it fun with all the latest slot and live casino games.
- 14:01
- Unidentified speaker: Plus, I get instant payouts with no minimum withdrawals.
- 14:04
- Unidentified speaker: Oh, and no wagering requirements ever.
- 14:06
- Unidentified speaker: Here's your decaf oat milk extra but not piping hot.
- 14:08
- Unidentified speaker: Ah, thanks.
- 14:09
- Unidentified speaker: Playtime's over.
- 14:10
- Unidentified speaker: Mmm, lovely.
- 14:12
- Unidentified speaker: Feel the fun, playoff.
- 14:14
- Unidentified speaker: 18 plus Alberta only.
- 14:15
- Unidentified speaker: Please play responsibly, full term supply.
- 14:17
- Unidentified speaker: Now, the federal act that created the CPP actually allows provinces to leave with their share of the pot to start their own provincial pension plan.
- 14:25
- Unidentified speaker: Quebec itself has been running an independent pension plan since the beginning.
- 14:29
- Unidentified speaker: So, as you can expect, there's been a lot of demand to take this money and run.
- 14:32
- Unidentified speaker: Now we need to highlight that this calculation is very widely contested for reasons that we'll touch on.
- 14:37
- Unidentified speaker: But the Alberta Prosperity Project estimates that even if the province ended up with just half of this amount, the province could achieve a fiscal surplus of $23.6 billion to $45.5 billion by cutting off ties with Canada's federal government, even after accounting for the upfront costs and the ongoing expenses of replacing federal functions, which compares to the forecasted multi-billion dollar deficits that the province is expecting over the next few years.
- 15:06
- Unidentified speaker: So you can see the appeal.
- 15:07
- Unidentified speaker: It's argued that Albertan independence would both decrease taxes and increase the province's budgetary surplus, and eliminating the overhang of federal regulations could bolster investment and economic growth for the province.
- 15:20
- Unidentified speaker: All of which sounds pretty compelling.
- 15:23
- Unidentified speaker: Except for the fact that it's completely unfounded.
- 15:25
- Unidentified speaker: Yes, progressive taxes do lead to Albertans paying higher taxes since they earn, again, higher average incomes, and that is being used to help support other provinces in the country.
- 15:34
- Unidentified speaker: New Brunswick, for example, sees nearly a quarter of its revenue paid for by other provinces via equalization transfers.
- 15:42
- Unidentified speaker: But there's a whole slew of problems with the estimates being used by the Alberta Prosperity Project here.
- 15:47
- Unidentified speaker: Dr.
- 15:47
- Unidentified speaker: Trevor Toomb, a professor of economics and director of fiscal and economic policy at the University of Calgary, for example, nice last name by the way, has himself pointed out a few issues with the report.
- 15:58
- Unidentified speaker: Namely, the cost and revenue assumptions used to calculate these generous figures just don't make any sense.
- 16:03
- Unidentified speaker: There are a number of oversights in the calculations.
- 16:05
- Unidentified speaker: The group completely forgets about old age security and the Canada child benefit, essentially arguing that Albertans will continue to receive these payments without explaining where the $10 billion to fund these programs will ultimately come from.
- 16:17
- Unidentified speaker: The group also assumes that Alberta could build an entire military presence for just a few billion dollars, even though the NATO target of 2% of GDP would put the annual spending alone at $10 billion a year, an amount that would eventually rise to $25 billion under the new phasing in of the 5% target.
- 16:36
- Unidentified speaker: Meanwhile, on the revenue side, the group bases oil royalty estimates on an oil price of $85 Canadian dollars a barrel, which at the time of the draft was closer to accurate, given that oil prices spiked in the month the report was released.
- 16:49
- Unidentified speaker: But today, the Western Canadian Select benchmark, what most Albert receive for their oil, is sitting at just 69 Canadian dollars a barrel.
- 16:58
- Unidentified speaker: But the most bizarre issue is that 16% of the Albertan government's revenue under this plan, about $23 billion, or essentially the entire fiscal surplus on the low end, appears to come from the returns and contributions by Albertans to the Canada pension plan.
- 17:15
- Unidentified speaker: So I guess Alberta will just commandeer pensioner income to fund its independence.
- 17:20
- Unidentified speaker: It also brings us to the issues with that calculation of Alberta's share of the CPP, because even with just using half of that estimate, the assumptions being used here just aren't realistic.
- 17:29
- Unidentified speaker: In fact, if other provinces used the same assumptions that were used in the LifeWorks report, there wouldn't be enough money to go around.
- 17:35
- Unidentified speaker: Ontario and Alberta alone would take up the entire pot of money.
- 17:40
- Unidentified speaker: Reason being that the LifeWorks calculation is oversimplified and doesn't account for the full impact of withdrawals on investment returns, nor the influence of worker mobility.
- 17:50
- Unidentified speaker: You see, it's very common for Canadians from other provinces to move and work in Alberta when they're young, especially in the oil and gas sector, and then retire and receive their government benefits in a different province, which has contributed to Alberta having the lowest age demographic among the provinces.
- 18:05
- Unidentified speaker: But this can skew the numbers, making it look like Albertans are paying for the retirement of other Canadians, even if that isn't really the case.
- 18:12
- Unidentified speaker: So even the Prosperity Project's 25% assumption is an aggressive estimate when you consider Alberta Okay.
- 18:18
- Unidentified speaker: When I sell my business, I want the best tax and investment advice.
- 18:22
- Unidentified speaker: I want to help my kids, and I want to give back to the community.
- 18:25
- Unidentified speaker: Ooh, then it's the vacation of a lifetime.
- 18:29
- Unidentified speaker: I wonder if my out of office has a forever setter.
- 18:33
- Unidentified speaker: An IG Private Wealth Advisor creates the clarity you need with plans that harmonize your business, your family, and your dreams.
- 18:40
- Unidentified speaker: Get financial advice that puts you at the center.
- 18:43
- Unidentified speaker: Find your advisor at IGPrivatewealth.com.
- 18:48
- Unidentified speaker: Legendary has arrived in Alberta with BetMGM Casino.
- 18:52
- Unidentified speaker: Sign up to unlock access to over 4,000 casino games, including exclusive spots you can't spin anywhere else.
- 18:59
- Unidentified speaker: Survivors Ready?
- 19:00
- Unidentified speaker: The iconic TV show is now an online casino game where you can tap into Island Fun.
- 19:04
- Unidentified speaker: BetMGM has also brought the prices right, Game of Thrones, Family Food, MGM Millions, and so many more exclusive casino games to Alberta.
- 19:12
- Unidentified speaker: Get Las Vegas right from your phone with live dealer games streaming from real tables.
- 19:17
- Unidentified speaker: And every time you play, you can enjoy instant deposit options and fast withdrawals.
- 19:21
- Unidentified speaker: BetMGM Casino and its legendary library of games are available.
- 19:25
- Unidentified speaker: Download the BetMGM app.
- 19:27
- Unidentified speaker: See BetMGM.com for terms.
- 19:29
- Unidentified speaker: 18 plus Alberta only.
- 19:31
- Unidentified speaker: Please play responsibly, subject to eligibility requirements.
- 19:34
- Unidentified speaker: If gambling is affecting your mental health or well-being, 211 Alberta is here to help.
- 19:38
- Unidentified speaker: Call or text 211 or visit ab.211.ca.
- 19:41
- Unidentified speaker: BetMGM operates pursuant to an operating agreement with the Alberta iGaming Corporation.
- 19:44
- Unidentified speaker: Standard message and data rates may apply.
- 19:48
- Unidentified speaker: This is big.
- 19:50
- Unidentified speaker: The Sephora Savings Event is back.
- 19:53
- Unidentified speaker: And now through November 9th, everything's on sale.
- 19:56
- Unidentified speaker: Everything you really want.
- 19:58
- Unidentified speaker: Like one size, Patrick Ta, Caristas, Kay Ali, Laneige, and yeah, you're gonna need a bigger bag.
- 20:05
- Unidentified speaker: Shop at Sephora.
- 20:06
- Unidentified speaker: Limitations apply.
- 20:07
- Unidentified speaker: Must be a beauty insider.
- 20:08
- Unidentified speaker: See terms at Sephora.ca for complete details.
- 20:13
- Unidentified speaker: So your decaf oat milk extra but not piping hot, four pumps of caramel, no sugar, small latte, and a large cup.
- 20:19
- Unidentified speaker: That will be 10 minutes.
- 20:20
- Unidentified speaker: No worries.
- 20:21
- Unidentified speaker: I'm having fun on Play Ojo.
- 20:23
- Unidentified speaker: And I keep it fun with all the latest slot and live casino games.
- 20:26
- Unidentified speaker: Plus, I get instant payouts with no minimum withdrawals.
- 20:30
- Unidentified speaker: Oh, and no wagering requirements ever.
- 20:32
- Unidentified speaker: Here's your decaf oat milk extra but not piping hot.
- 20:34
- Unidentified speaker: Ah, thanks.
- 20:35
- Unidentified speaker: Playtime's over.
- 20:36
- Unidentified speaker: Mmm, lovely.
- 20:38
- Unidentified speaker: Feel the fun, play Ojo!
- 20:40
- Unidentified speaker: 18 Plus Alberta only.
- 20:41
- Unidentified speaker: Please play responsibly, full-term supply.
- 20:43
- Unidentified speaker: Represents just 12% of the country's population and 16% of the CPP's contributions.
- 20:49
- Unidentified speaker: So right away, there are some pretty glaring issues with the fiscal utopia that's being promised for Alberta's separation.
- 20:56
- Unidentified speaker: Then there's the risks, downsides, and costs that haven't been covered here.
- 21:02
- Unidentified speaker: For one, there's the pretty obvious issue of Alberta becoming a landlocked nation between Canada and the US, which, aside from the military and border implications, also presents a pretty big issue for trade.
- 21:13
- Unidentified speaker: Alberta is already the most US trade-dependent province in Canada, sending the vast majority of its oil down south.
- 21:20
- Unidentified speaker: And any access to Canada's West Coast, where the province currently sells its oil to China, would have to go through British Columbia.
- 21:26
- Unidentified speaker: So not only would Alberta immediately lose access to Kuzma and the Canadian Free Trade Agreement with other provinces, but it would also have to renegotiate these trade relations from a pretty disadvantaged position.
- 21:37
- Unidentified speaker: And even without implementing explicit tariffs, it's likely that trade costs would increase.
- 21:42
- Unidentified speaker: As highlighted by Dr.
- 21:43
- Unidentified speaker: Toom, research on Brexit has found that non-tariff barriers increased by 3 to 8% for the UK after it left the EU, with estimates for the impact on GDP ranging from 2 to 5%.
- 21:56
- Unidentified speaker: For Alberta, a 5% increase in trade costs alone could cause its economy to lose out on an estimated $20 billion annually.
- 22:06
- Unidentified speaker: Secondly, there's a risk of capital and human capital flight here.
- 22:09
- Unidentified speaker: But the truth is that companies and investors don't like political instability, nor the risk of losing access to nearly 90% of Canada's population.
- 22:20
- Unidentified speaker: So there's a good chance that we see companies and employees leave the province, thereby shrinking the tax base and hurting economic activity, even just on the threat of secession.
- 22:29
- Unidentified speaker: Something we actually saw firsthand with Quebec.
- 22:32
- Unidentified speaker: From 1976 to 1979, while the Separatist Party Quebecois was in power, an estimated 368 businesses moved their headquarters out of the province, with even the Bank of Montreal moving to Toronto, Ontario.
- 22:45
- Unidentified speaker: This is also an issue given Alberta's dependence on labor from other provinces, especially for its oil, gas, and construction industries.
- 22:52
- Unidentified speaker: So any barrier on labor mobility is going to be a meaningful headwind here.
- 22:56
- Unidentified speaker: Then there's the question of money.
- 22:59
- Unidentified speaker: Like actual money.
- 23:00
- Unidentified speaker: What would Alberta use as its currency if it were to separate?
- 23:04
- Unidentified speaker: The Alberta Prosperity Project proposes that the province adopt the US dollar for some reason and then eventually transition to its own Alberta backed by gold, Bitcoin, and oil, but doesn't account for the cost of setting up those reserves, nor the risk of a province that's a fraction of the country size launching a new currency from scratch.
- 23:25
- Unidentified speaker: And truly, these are just some of the issues of the countless list of risks and costs that just aren't being considered here.
- 23:32
- Unidentified speaker: Replacing infrastructure for healthcare, education, employment insurance, and pension funding.
- 23:36
- Unidentified speaker: Establishing border patrol for a border that's now over 10 times larger than before.
- 23:40
- Unidentified speaker: The development of a new legal and court system, the re-establishment of international relations without access to Canada's reputation and G7 status.
- 23:48
- Unidentified speaker: Less favorable lending terms given the uncertainty.
- 23:50
- Unidentified speaker: Alberta's share of federal debt that the Canada government might hitch on the province on the way out.
- 23:55
- Unidentified speaker: The issue of federally owned land.
- 23:57
- Unidentified speaker: You could kiss BAMF goodbye because that's run federally, not provincially.
- 24:00
- Unidentified speaker: The question of indigenous rights in areas and the need to renegotiate there.
- 24:04
- Unidentified speaker: The fact that since Quebec, Canadian law has been updated so that it no longer allows unilateral secession, meaning a yes referendum vote may not even lead to independence.
- 24:13
- Unidentified speaker: And of course, the issue of 25% of the province's GDP coming from oil and gas, an incredibly volatile industry to base your economy off of.
- 24:22
- Unidentified speaker: A big selling point for independence here is the idea that Alberta could deregulate and double down on its oil and gas sector to bolster economic activity.
- 24:30
- Unidentified speaker: But oil can be pretty unreliable.
- 24:32
- Unidentified speaker: The Albertan government's revenues from oil and gas have fluctuated from as low as 6.5% of their total income to as high as 33.2% in just the past decade alone.
- 24:42
- Unidentified speaker: In fact, the Alberta government is currently bracing for higher deficits due to currently low oil prices.
- 24:49
- Unidentified speaker: And we've seen the province struggle during oil gluts in the past.
- 24:52
- Unidentified speaker: So while oil has historically been a great boon for the Albert government, that might not always be the case.
- 24:57
- Unidentified speaker: And one of the benefits of remaining as part of Canada is the industrial diversification it provides should things turn sour.
- 25:05
- Unidentified speaker: Ontario, for example, has fluctuated between being a net contributor and a net recipient of equalization payments.
- 25:12
- Unidentified speaker: And while it's true that Alberta has not received an equalization transfer since the 1960s, it may not always be able to rely on its above-average GDP per capita and young demographics.
- 25:23
- Unidentified speaker: Now there are certainly valid criticisms of federal policies and how they are impacting Alberta.
- 25:28
- Unidentified speaker: I mean, this is Canada we're talking about.
- 25:31
- Unidentified speaker: We have a reputation of holding back our industries with red tape.
- 25:34
- Unidentified speaker: But Alberta doesn't operate in a closed system, so it's actually quite difficult to accurately estimate many of these figures, to quantify its relationship with the rest of Canada when you consider things like labor mobility, military spending, and the federal tax credits and supports given to oil and gas companies that pay for Alberta's royalties.
- 25:54
- Unidentified speaker: But what is almost certain is that secession would prove incredibly challenging for the province of Alberta.
- 26:01
- Unidentified speaker: And it's very likely that it would cost more than it would save.
- 26:05
- Unidentified speaker: Canada itself, of course, would suffer as well.
- 26:07
- Unidentified speaker: Alberta is a very important economy and should be recognized for its contribution to the country.
- 26:13
- Unidentified speaker: But independence could prove fiscally devastating for Alberta.
- 26:16
- Unidentified speaker: Some may believe it's so worth it.
- 26:18
- Unidentified speaker: We're really just talking about the economic considerations here.
- 26:21
- Unidentified speaker: But a vote shouldn't be held under false pretenses.
- 26:24
- Unidentified speaker: In 2016, there was a lot of misinformation and confusion about Brexit when just over 50% of voters chose to leave the European Union.
- 26:32
- Unidentified speaker: In 2025, five years after officially leaving, the poll suggests that the majority of respondents ultimately believe it was the wrong decision.
- 26:39
- Unidentified speaker: Now, as mentioned, Albertan separatists do currently remain a minority in the province, and there is a good chance that the provincial government is using the movement as a bargaining chip in its relations with the federal government.
- 26:51
- Unidentified speaker: Premier Daniel Smith has done things like reducing the number of signatures needed to put the referendum to a vote while also talking about a united Canada.
- 26:58
- Unidentified speaker: But with the onslaught of misinformation coming our way and likely to come our way in the future, especially if we approach an actual referendum vote, hopefully this video helped to clear the air.
- 27:15
- Unidentified speaker: Let me know your thoughts on Alberta separatism.
- 27:16
- Unidentified speaker: Whether there are any points that you think were missed, is this something you're strongly supportive of?
- 27:20
- Unidentified speaker: Are you vehemently against it?
- 27:22
- Unidentified speaker: Any and all thoughts, welcome in the comments down below.
- 27:25
- Unidentified speaker: Thanks again for joining me, and as always, be safe out there.
- 27:34
- Unidentified speaker: Well, there's more to it than that, Sean.
- 27:37
- Unidentified speaker: Like with Bet365, I get paid the second my team goes at big with early payout and can cash out at any time before the game ends.
- 27:44
- Unidentified speaker: Sean's getting his steps, but I'm getting paid.
- 27:47
- Unidentified speaker: Bet365, the home of winning early.
- 27:50
- Unidentified speaker: 18 plus, please play responsibly.
- 27:51
- Unidentified speaker: Upper to only terms, conditions apply.
- 27:52
- Unidentified speaker: If gambling is affecting your mental health or well-being, 211 Alberta is here to help.
- 27:55
- Unidentified speaker: Call or text 211 or visit ab.211.ca.
- 27:58
- Unidentified speaker: Standard message and data rates may apply.
- 28:00
- Unidentified speaker: This is big.
- 28:02
- Unidentified speaker: The Sephora savings event is back.
- 28:05
- Unidentified speaker: And now through November 9th, everything's on sale.
- 28:08
- Unidentified speaker: Everything you really want.
- 28:09
- Unidentified speaker: Like one size, Patrick Ta, Carastas, Kali, Lanege, and yeah, you're gonna need a bigger bag.
- 28:16
- Unidentified speaker: Shop at Sephora.
- 28:18
- Unidentified speaker: Limitations apply.
- 28:19
- Unidentified speaker: Must be a beauty insider.
- 28:20
- Unidentified speaker: See terms at Sephora.ca for complete details.
- 28:25
- Unidentified speaker: So your decaf oat milk extra but not piping hot, four pumps of caramel, no sugar, small latte, and a large cup.
- 28:31
- Unidentified speaker: That will be 10 minutes.
- 28:32
- Unidentified speaker: No worries.
- 28:32
- Unidentified speaker: I'm having fun on Playo!
- 28:34
- Unidentified speaker: And I keep it fun with all the latest slot and live casino games.
- 28:38
- Unidentified speaker: Plus, I get instant pans with no minimum withdrawals.
- 28:41
- Unidentified speaker: Ugh, and no wagering requirements ever.
- 28:44
- Unidentified speaker: Here's your decaf oat milk extra but not piping hot.
- 28:46
- Unidentified speaker: Ha ha thanks.
- 28:47
- Unidentified speaker: Playtime's over.
- 28:48
- Unidentified speaker: Mmm, lovely.
- 28:51
- Unidentified speaker: Playoff.
- 28:52
- Unidentified speaker: 18 plus Alberta only.
- 28:53
- Unidentified speaker: Please play responsibly.
- 28:54
- Unidentified speaker: Full term supply.
More from The Plain Bagel
Dealing With Investment FOMO
Episode discussion: The Plain Bagel episode on Dealing With Investment FOMO argues that behavioral biases and social media distortions drive irrational investment decisions.
Speakers’ claims: Speaker 2 introduces Fear Of Missing Out (FOMO) as a behavioral bias where the pain of missing gains outweighs rational risk assessment. The speaker explains that social media amplifies this by showcasing polished success stories while omitting failures, creating a distorted view of investing probabilities. Regret aversion causes investors to focus on short-term price volatility rather than long-term fundamentals, leading to purchases based on hype rather than due diligence. The episode warns that buying after a price surge often means entering an overvalued position, which is akin to gambling if the investor does not understand the asset's fundamentals. To counter FOMO, the speaker proposes a four-question check: verify source reliability, understand fundamentals, assess risk tolerance, and determine if the opportunity is truly time-sensitive. Finally, the speaker notes that most investments are not time-sensitive, and the urgency created by FOMO is often artificial.
The Ridiculous Rise and Fall of WeWork
Episode discussion: WeWork Files Chapter 11 Bankruptcy After Years of Losses and Failed IPO
Speakers’ claims: Host Richard Coffin discusses WeWork's Chapter 11 bankruptcy filing, noting the company missed interest payments and raised doubts about its ability to continue as a going concern. WeWork was valued at $47 billion in 2019 with $22 billion invested but never recorded a year of profit. SoftBank invested $18.5 billion based on a 'space as a service' pitch, despite poor unit economics and a failed 2019 IPO. By Q2 2023, WeWork had $19 billion in liabilities against $15 billion in assets. The host attributes the rise and fall to prolonged low interest rates encouraging risky venture capital investment.