Stock Market Shenanigans

Retiree stress test shows reinvesting dividends extends portfolio longevity during market crashes

16 min Listen to the original Episode page
Retirement PlanningPortfolio ConstructionMarket RiskDividend ReinvestmentMonte Carlo Simulation

Summary

The speaker conducts a retirement stress test on a $100,000 portfolio composed of six ETFs, assuming a $26,000 annual withdrawal and 15% historical returns. A Monte Carlo simulation reveals that withdrawing 100% of income leads to significant depletion when a 30% market drop occurs in the first year. By modifying the strategy to withdraw only 88% ($23,000) and reinvesting the remaining 12% ($3,000), the portfolio's resilience improves significantly. This reinvestment strategy extends the portfolio's longevity to age 83-84 even in worst-case scenarios. The speaker concludes that maintaining flexibility by reinvesting a portion of income helps accumulate shares at lower prices during bear markets.

Episode sections

  1. 0:01 – 1:51

    Introduction to Retirement Paycheck Stress Test

    Speaker outlines a scenario where a retiree spends their full $26,000 annual income from a $100,000 portfolio, then tests how a 20-30% market drop affects sustainability. The speaker introduces a comparison between spending all income versus reinvesting 10%.

  2. 1:51 – 4:50

    Portfolio Composition and Baseline Assumptions

    The speaker details a $100,000 portfolio of six ETFs: SPY (20%), QQQI (20%), JEPQ (15%), GPIQ (10%), ChIPE (20%), and AMDW (15%). Historical data shows a 26% yield and 15% appreciation, though the speaker notes these are optimistic assumptions for newer funds.

  3. 4:50 – 8:27

    Stress Test Methodology and Monte Carlo Simulation

    Using a retirement stress test tool, the speaker sets assumptions: $100k start, $26k annual withdrawal, 15% return, 3.5% inflation, and 30-year horizon. A Monte Carlo simulation of 5,000 random scenarios is run to establish a baseline retirement confidence score.

  4. 8:27 – 11:25

    Bad First Year Sequence of Returns Analysis

    The speaker forces a -30% market drop in the first year across all simulations. Results show that spending the full $26k leads to significant portfolio depletion and potential ruin, highlighting the danger of sequence of returns risk when withdrawing all income.

  5. 11:25 – 13:05

    Reinvestment Strategy and Improved Longevity

    The speaker modifies the test to withdraw only 88% ($23,000) and reinvest the remaining 12% ($3,000). This strategy significantly improves portfolio resilience, extending the portfolio's longevity to age 83-84 even in the 10th percentile worst-case scenarios.

  6. 13:05 – 15:58

    Conclusion on Flexibility and Portfolio Construction

    The speaker concludes that reinvesting a portion of income provides flexibility during bear markets by accumulating more shares at lower prices. They emphasize that while this income-focused test is useful, a full retirement portfolio should include multiple 'teams' (foundation, future, growth, etc.).

Assets discussed

AssetKindStanceContext
SPDR S&P 500 ETF TrustSPYetfneutralWe have SPY at about 20%, so that's $20,000. In its this job, it's broad income and growth.

“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.

Do your own research

  • Verify the historical yield and appreciation data for the specific ETFs mentioned (SPY, QQQI, JEPQ, GPIQ, ChIPE, AMDW) using their respective prospectuses or fact sheets.
  • Review the methodology of the retirement stress test tool used to ensure the Monte Carlo simulation parameters match the speaker's assumptions.
  • Analyze the impact of sequence of returns risk on different portfolio allocations using historical market data from sources like Yardeni Research or Morningstar.
  • Compare the speaker's 15% return assumption against long-term historical averages for equity portfolios to assess the optimism of the baseline.
  • Check the current expense ratios and dividend yields of the listed ETFs to confirm the 26% yield claim is realistic for the current market environment.
Full transcriptexpand
0:01
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): That's your retirement paycheck, so you spend all $26,000. Then the market drops 20%, maybe 30%. Your portfolio value falls, your distributions start changing, and suddenly that $26,000 paycheck may not be nearly as sustainable as you thought. So what do you do? Take a major
0:21
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): pay Your cut, sell, hold, keep spending every dollar the portfolio produces, or could something as simple as reinvesting 10% of the income from day one completely change what happens when the bear market arrives? Today we're going to find out. I'm taking a hundred thousand dollars covered call portfolio, including some
0:41
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): pretty aggressive high-income ETFs, and we're going to break it.
0:45
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Then
0:45
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): we're gonna see what happens if we spend all the income versus spending ninety 90% percent and reinvesting. the other 10%. And finally, if the market does crash, I'll show you exactly what I'm looking at to decide. Do I buy, do I hold, or is it actually time to sell? So stay tuned.
1:10
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Paycheck. So today I don't want to ask whether covered call ETFs are good or bad. I want to ask a much more useful question. How much of the income can we actually afford to spend? We're gonna start by spending it all. Then we're gonna stress the market and see what happens to that paycheck. After that, we're going to make one tiny change. We're only gonna spend about 90%
1:30
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and reinvest 10%. We're gonna see whether that little bit of reinvestment gives you this portfolio enough breathing room to handle a bear market. Then we're gonna talk about the question everybody eventually faces when markets start falling. Do I buy, sell, or hold? And that's where Simply Money Principle Number 7 comes in. Don't guess, test.
1:51
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Let me outline the portfolio we're gonna look at. We're gonna have six ETFs. We have SPY at about 20%, so that's $20,000. In its this job, it's broad income and growth. Then we have QQQI. at 20% or about $20,000. That's the NASDAQ income and growth. We have JEPQ at 15%,
2:11
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): about $15,000. That's NASDAQ oriented income. We have GPIQ at 10%, $10,000. That's NASDAQ income and growth. Growth Then we have ChIPE Chippy at 20%, $20,000, which is high income semiconductor. exposure, and we have AMDW at 15% or
2:30
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): $15,000, which is aggressive AMD high income exposure. I intentionally made part of this portfolio aggressive. I don't want to build a portfolio that looks great in a stress test because I removed everything that's actually stressful. To begin with, we're going to go ahead and plug this into the Simply Money Portfolio Planner. I'm only using
2:51
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): this on this video to get our baseline. So what I've done is I've plugged in those tickers we just discussed. I put it in here at the different allocations and it pulls up the historical yield and appreciation and down here it gives us our cumulative. I'm only using this on this video to pull this up because we're going to put it into our
3:11
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): retirement stress test to see how it actually holds up So we have about 26% average yield and about a 15% appreciation. Now, this is historical, and as you know, some of these funds are very new, like Chippy's just barely over a year old. So we don't have a lot of data, and this is probably not going to hold.
3:31
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I'm going to go ahead and use this optimistic outlook and let you see how it upholds in the stress test, even with it being so optimistic. This is what we're gonna base it on. You can see starting out, you'd produce we're gonna call this $26,000 of income. That's what we're gonna use, these figures right here. That is the Simply Money portfolio planner.
3:51
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): If you've never seen this, this is available down below in the Buy Me a Coffee. This is great for comparing different tickers and seeing how different allocations would perform. You can do deposit rules, withdrawal rules, and forecast it out and see how it would hold, whether you're building, whether you're reinvesting, whether you're reallocating to other
4:10
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): funds, or if you're in retirement and using that income. And we've set this up at $100,000. You can see that equals right here each of those funds. And we're accumulating for zero years. We're not accumulating at all. We're spending it from the beginning. That is where we're starting. out with this. And remember, this is the paycheck we're going to
4:30
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): start retirement with. And that's important because you're not going to let spending automatically decline just because the portfolio declines. You're testing whether that original paycheck is sustainable. Now we have our income, we have our baseline that we're gonna going use. to We're gonna going to go over to the Simply Money retirement stress test, and we'll go over here to
4:50
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that. and see our starting portfolio. And we're only doing this income portion. Now, if I was retiring, I would have my foundation team, I'd have my future team, I'd have my dividend and growth team along with this other fund that we have here. But we're looking, I'm going to skip down here, the team allocation,
5:10
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and we have 65% in the growth and income team. That's your spy eye, your QQQI, your JEPQ, and your GPIQ. Then we have 35% in the retirement paycheck team, and that's Chipie and AMDW. We're only testing that to see how that portion of the income holds up. We have this set
5:30
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): instead of at manual, we have it set on team allocation. Coming back up here to the top, we have the $100,000 hundred thousand dollars starting balance. We're gonna say we need all of that income. so we're gonna use the full $26,000 it produces. The annual return rate we said was 15%. Extremely optimistic. We're putting inflation at 3.5%.
5:50
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Number of years we're projecting out 30 years. We have inflation adjusted, yes. The dividend yield 26%. Again, very optimistic, but these high yields are there, and we're gonna see. going to how they do in the stress. And then the dividend growth we're putting at two percent because these funds don't produce like an SCHD
6:10
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): or a Devo or DGRO, that dividend growth factor, especially if you're using it all. You can build your own dividend growth by reinvesting a portion of it, but we'll get into that in another video. Those are the assumptions we're making, and we have it set at aggressive because this would be an extremely aggressive portfolio if all you had was the growth and
6:30
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): income team and the retirement paycheck team. We don't have any other sources of income. Come over here to the static chart. You can see that income needed $26,000, dividend payment $26,000. But it's basically a wash that first year. We're gonna see what happens. We're not gonna run right here. Market stress test is off. We're not running any.
6:51
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): different scenario. This is gonna take 5,000 different scenarios and run them randomly and see what the returns over the 30 years would be, and then score that to see how you did. And then we will turn it on and we'll do the bad first-year sequence of returns and then a bad first three-year Year sequence of returns to see how
7:11
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): this portfolio does in stress testing. Now we run this just come. over to the retirement competence dashboard, hit this run new stress test, and it will run 5,000 different scenarios. While that's running, I'm going to take you over here so you can see. Here's your simulations. You can scroll down and go down 5,000 lines,
7:31
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and it shows you year one what the return is, year two what the return is, and it does that for 5,000 different scenarios.
7:39
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Let you see this is a Monte Carlo simulation. It's running different scenarios. So if 5,000 people had the same exact portfolio and they retired, but different sequences happened, how would this portfolio hold up? The stress test runs. Come back over here. You can see your portfolio will go down with the expected Inspective value. This is the 50th
7:59
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): percentile. You can see our portfolio does go up, it holds up. well in just sequences that are random. You get a strong stress test status, you get retirement confidence score of 93.9. There's very good outcomes with this. This is showing if the market just randomly takes place and you
8:19
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): don't have any sequence of returns early on. That's a good sign. But we want to come back over here and say what happens if we retire.
8:27
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and then our first year is bad. And doing that, you run this again, and the first year on all 5,000 simulations is going to be exactly the same. It's going to be bad. You can come over here, you can see the first year we have a negative 30%. Then from there on it is just random. So you have 5,000 different
8:46
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): scenarios from year two on, and you'll have years that it's negative. 30 and then positive. Other years it's negative 30 and then another negative year because that's how the market can work. For example, here you have negative 30 and then the next year negative 27. But this scenario right above it, you have negative 30, then positive 56.
9:07
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Very different outcomes on those two simulations. When you come over here, when we look at this, you can see how significantly that. 30% drop is. Your portfolio is down. You don't have to sell shares because you have that income producing, but you're going to produce less income because your portfolio is much
9:27
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): lower. And again, this is just random and it is not cut and dry. This is not a guarantee. And remember, this is not financial advice, this is for informational and educational purposes only. The purpose of these stress tests is we don't know what the future holds. So we put in different scenarios and we stress our
9:46
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): portfolio. We have different situations where we can say, what would it do if this happened? And when I'm doing this, I'm looking at my portfolio and I'm saying, what happens if we have a bad first year? What happens if we have a bad three years? What happens if I don't get the year? yield I expect? I could go back over here and say maybe I'm not going
10:06
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): to get that twenty-six percent right here. And I could put that down to fifteen percent. And what would happen if that was the case? And I can run all these different scenarios. And my goal when I do my own portfolio or I'm coaching someone is I'm stress testing as many different scenarios as I can to see does it hold
10:26
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): up? or how much would I have to change? How flexible would I need to be under these different circumstances? And that's important to me because when I go to retire, I'm gonna be flexible. I know my plan's not gonna be cut and dry. I get X number of dollars forever and ever, and the market's gonna do different things, inflation's
10:46
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): not always gonna be exactly three or three and a half percent, life's gonna happen. I need to stress test that. What if I need thirty thousand dollars? What if I only need twenty thousand? What happens if inflation's five percent? All those different things you can run those different scenarios. So that is showing that you're going to have some
11:05
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): struggles. If the market, you can look right here, if the market does bad, you're looking at you could be running out of money, at least in this portion of the portfolio. if you're taking that full amount out early on. I'm not even going to run the three-year bad because we see that we're already having struggles with it. What I want to do now is
11:25
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): instead of saying, okay, we're gonna take the entire twenty-six thousand dollars, we're gonna say we're gonna take about ninety percent. It's actually eighty-eight percent. We're only gonna going to take twenty-three thousand dollars. That means three thousand dollars. the first year is being reinvested, approximately about twelve percent, is being reinvested
11:45
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): back into the portfolio and building those shares up so even though the price is going down, your share count's going up, and when you're in a bear market, the good thing is if you're reinvesting, Investing, you're getting more shares. And how would this hold up in this first bad year? We'll come back and run this one more time and see
12:05
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): what happens. And you need to remember that maybe you have to reinvest 20%. So you're looking and saying, okay, I will generate $26,000 my first year. If I take all of it, there's a chance I might have to take my income the next year is going to be lower, and I don't have any extra bill to reinvest.
12:25
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Whereas I could plan. it saying, okay, I need $26,000. I can't retire until this earns $30,000. So I can reinvest $4,000. It allows you to play around with that. You can see as this is run that now you're producing this amount of income, but you're not burning it down as quick. And you can see how the
12:45
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): portfolio holds up much better, even in the worst case scenarios over here, the 10th. percentile, you're not running out of money until you're 83, 84, and that's starting retirement at 58. Again, it lasts 25 years there, it's a nice longevity, and you can see the difference by saying, I'm not going
13:05
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): to take the full amount, I'm only going to take 90% or 80%. And you can plan that to give yourself flexibility, and that's one of the positive. positives people forget about with covered calls and income-producing retirement strategies, is it gives you more flexibility versus okay, I have to have a cash
13:25
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): bucket, and then if the market's down, I'm gonna live out of my cash bucket because I can't sell shares when they're down 30%, because I'd have to sell 30% more shares, and then when it recovers, I have 30% fewer shares. to get that recovery. Where in this scenario, okay, I'm taking a little bit less cash, but
13:45
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I'm buying more shares, and when the market does recover, I have more shares to capture more of that upside. Can have some very positive impacts. Now I would not build my team like this. This is only showing the income side of things because we're stress testing that. That's why we build the foundation team, the future team,
14:05
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the dividend growth team, the growth and income team, which we do have represented here, and the retirement paycheck team. A portfolio for me for retirement would have all five of these teams represented in some form or fashion. Now we want to go ahead and do the bad first three years with the same approach of taking 12% and
14:25
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): reinvesting it. Now this is going to be a pretty hefty stress test because if you look over here, you see that every simulation you have 30% down, 15% down, 10% down, and then it goes random, and you'll have some years even in the fourth year, and possibly even the fifth year, where
14:45
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): it's negative. So it can be a really tough scenario, and this is truly stress testing if. your sequence of returns is like that, you better be flexible in retirement because five negative years in a row is extremely, extremely unlikely, but you never know. And that's why I like stress testing. Again,
15:05
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): in this method, this holds up as well as using the full amount did, but this is with three years sequence of returns being negative at the beginning. This really shows you that this can handle a lot, and that's on the tenth percentile. There's a chance, even in this sequence of returns, that you could have this portfolio last until you're
15:24
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): 82, 83 years old. That gives you flexibility. I wouldn't say that I'd be comfortable with this, but if I only had a hundred thousand dollars and only needed twenty-three $23,000 thousand dollars to live on to maybe supplement my social security and other things. and I could be flexible. This would be something I would look at. We could run this instead of saying, okay, I'm gonna take the full
15:44
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): twenty-three thousand, maybe I only take twenty-one thousand and see how that would do. And so a lot of different ways you can run this and run those scenarios. Again, why I like running all the various options and
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.

More from Stock Market Shenanigans

Stock Market Shenanigans

Uber Vs Hertz

Episode discussion: Speaker critiques Robinhood's Hertz trading limits and proposes Uber acquire Lucid and Hertz to compete with Tesla.

Speakers’ claims: The speaker criticizes Robinhood for restricting Hertz call options, arguing this signals fear of a short squeeze despite Hertz's declining stock price. They argue Tesla will dominate autonomous vehicles due to vertical integration, whereas Uber relies on third parties. To compete, the speaker proposes Uber acquire Lucid Motors for manufacturing and Hertz for $8/share to gain maintenance infrastructure. Hertz's $18.7B debt is analyzed, with $11.5B being vehicle-backed and potentially offloadable. The speaker also discusses MP Materials, noting recent trades and catalysts like GM qualification.

Autonomous VehiclesRobinhoodHertz
19 min3 assets10 claims to verify
Stock Market Shenanigans

Yieldmax launches SKHY ETF

Episode discussion: YieldMax launches SKHY ETF tied to SK Hynix; speaker details dip-buying strategies for EGGY and HOOW

Speakers’ claims: The speaker discusses the launch of YieldMax's SKHY ETF, which employs an option income strategy linked to SK Hynix, a key supplier of AI memory chips. He details his strategy of buying the dip on the EGGY ETF during periods of extreme fear, citing conviction in its holdings of photonics and AI chips. The speaker also analyzes the market reaction to Robinhood's earnings miss, viewing the drop in the HOOW ETF as a buy-the-dip opportunity. Additionally, he reviews opportunity scores for single-stock ETFs, highlighting significant upside potential for Alibaba (BABW) and Uber (UBU) based on analyst forecasts.

YieldMax ETFsSK HynixAI Infrastructure
16 min6 assets10 claims to verify
All insights