CNBC Property Play

Bain Capital's Ryan Cotton argues for shifting real estate capital from traditional office and retail to alternative assets like data centers and senior housing.

31 min Listen to the original Episode page
Real EstatePrivate EquityAlternative AssetsData CentersSenior HousingInterest RatesMarket VolatilityBain Capital

Summary

Ryan Cotton of Bain Capital Real Estate identifies a structural shift in real estate investment away from traditional office and retail toward alternative assets such as data centers, senior housing, and private aviation infrastructure. He attributes this migration to secular demand drivers including AI, remote work, and growing wealth concentration, which have disrupted traditional valuation models. Cotton advises investors to ignore short-term volatility and focus on long-term operational excellence and income growth, citing historical precedents like the 1970s where real estate outperformed most assets. He emphasizes that niche sectors require specialized expertise and offer supply constraints that support premium valuations, contrasting them with commodity assets like office space.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    He claims that 10 years ago, 93% of real estate assets were in four traditional sectors, a figure that has dropped to 82% today as capital migrates to alternatives.

    Ryan Cotton · 6:34

Episode sections

  1. 0:01 – 1:07

    Introduction to Alternative Real Estate

    Ryan Cotton identifies a structural shift in real estate investment away from traditional office and retail toward alternative assets like private airplane hangars and marinas. He notes that as wealth concentrates, demand for luxury leisure infrastructure grows, creating new investment opportunities.

  2. 1:07 – 2:59

    Market Volatility and Valuation Challenges

    Cotton describes the current real estate environment as disrupted by higher interest rates, post-pandemic overbuilding, and shifting demand patterns driven by AI. He highlights that frequent macro shocks prevent the market from finding a stable equilibrium, leading to deal re-trades and slowing volume.

  3. 2:59 – 4:10

    Investment Philosophy and 'Mr. Market'

    Adopting a Warren Buffett analogy, Cotton advises ignoring daily valuation fluctuations ('Mr. Market') and focusing on long-term fundamentals and income growth. He emphasizes that while values may reset, operational excellence and strong leases will eventually restore market optimism.

  4. 4:10 – 6:05

    Thematic Investing vs. Traditional Classes

    Bain Capital Real Estate focuses on long-term secular demand drivers rather than traditional asset classes. Cotton argues that office and retail lack positive 10-year demand themes due to remote work and AI, whereas alternative sectors like senior housing and data centers offer structural growth.

  5. 6:05 – 8:01

    Capital Migration to Alternatives

    Cotton notes that capital has shifted away from the traditional 'four food groups' (multifamily, office, retail, industrial), with the top 10 global REITs now dominated by alternative sectors like data centers and senior housing. He distinguishes data centers from industrial due to unique power and zoning requirements.

  6. 8:01 – 9:15

    Operational Complexity in Niche Assets

    Unlike commodity office leasing, niche assets like senior housing and data centers require specialized operational expertise and talent. Cotton cites Welltower trading at a premium to net asset value as evidence of the value created through operational capability in these sectors.

  7. 9:15 – 11:20

    Supply Constraints and Ultra-High-Net-Worth Demand

    Private aviation and marina assets benefit from the K-shaped economy and growing ultra-high-net-worth populations. Supply barriers are significant in developed markets like New York and Boston, leading to convex rental growth and scarcity value for these niche assets.

  8. 11:20 – 26:55

    Interest Rates and Historical Precedents

    Cotton explains that while higher rates increase required yields, they can also mute cap rate expansion by accelerating rent growth and slowing new supply. He cites the 1970s Volcker era, where real estate outperformed all assets except gold in the latter half of the decade, as a historical parallel.

  9. 26:55 – 27:59

    Market Volatility and Long-Term Strategy

    Ryan Cotton discusses navigating market disorientation by focusing on long-term fundamentals rather than short-term volatility. He advises investors to maintain focus on their core objectives to succeed through market cycles.

  10. 27:59 – 28:47

    Respect for Competitors and Industry Leaders

    Cotton expresses high regard for macro and thematic investors, specifically citing Blackstone as the largest real estate investor manager. He highlights the importance of understanding industry dynamics to achieve significant success.

  11. 28:47 – 29:11

    Prologis and Strategic Niche Expertise

    The speaker points to Hamid Moini, founder of Prologis, as an example of an investor who generated extraordinary returns by identifying the value of infill industrial assets and logistics before the broader market did.

  12. 29:11 – 30:34

    Strategic Scale vs. Asset Growth

    Cotton explains that Bain Capital Real Estate prioritizes generating returns over increasing assets under management. He rejects non-strategic mandates, such as trading office distress, to maintain a competitive edge and avoid distractions.

  13. 30:34 – 31:11

    Commitment to the Real Estate Cycle

    Cotton affirms his long-term commitment to real estate, stating he intends to stay through the current cycle to capitalize on the eventual market recovery. He emphasizes the importance of being present to benefit from the work done during difficult periods.

Assets discussed

AssetKindStanceContext
GoldcommodityneutralThe next eight years uh that followed from 74 to 82, real estate was the second best performing asset class in the world after gold.

“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.

Claims worth verifying

Bain Capital Real Estate manages $18 billion in assets.

Diana Olick ·0:23

How to verify: Check Bain Capital’s official website or press releases for AUM figures. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Ryan Cotton is the head of Bain Capital Real Estate.

Diana Olick ·0:23

How to verify: Check Bain Capital’s leadership page or SEC filings for Bain Capital Real Estate principals. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

The war in Iran and blowout of the long end of the treasury curve are macro shocks affecting real estate.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·2:11

How to verify: Verify geopolitical news archives for Iran tensions and Treasury yield data for the specified period. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Treasury rates are pushing five to five and a half percent.

Ryan Cotton ·2:31

How to verify: Check US Treasury yield data for the 10-year note around the transcript date. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

93% of real estate assets were invested in four food groups (multifamily, office, retail, industrial) 10 years ago, down to 82% today.

Ryan Cotton ·6:34

How to verify: Analyze historical NCREIF or CoStar data on asset class allocation percentages. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Seven of the 10 largest public REITs in the world are alternative sectors like data centers and senior housing.

Ryan Cotton ·7:14

How to verify: Review the latest S&P 500 or FTSE NAREIT index constituents by market cap. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Welltower trades at 130% of net asset value.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·8:37

How to verify: Check Welltower (WELL) latest quarterly report for NAV per share and stock price. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Atlantic Aviation traded to Apollo at a fairly high multiple.

Ryan Cotton ·10:45

How to verify: Search SEC filings or press releases for Apollo’s acquisition of Atlantic Aviation and the deal multiple. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Safe Harbor Marinas traded to Blackstone.

Ryan Cotton ·10:45

How to verify: Search SEC filings or press releases for Blackstone’s acquisition of Safe Harbor Marinas. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

From 1974 to 1982, real estate was the second-best performing asset class after gold.

Ryan Cotton ·13:22

How to verify: Verify against Ibbotson/Morningstar or NCREIF historical performance data for the 1970s and 1980s. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Bain Capital Real Estate manages $18 billion in assets under management.

Ryan Cotton ·29:11

How to verify: Check Bain Capital's official website or press releases regarding Ryan Cotton's appointment or fund size disclosures. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Bain Capital has $230 billion in total assets under management.

Ryan Cotton ·29:11

How to verify: Check Bain Capital's official website or recent annual reports for total AUM figures. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Blackstone is the largest real estate investor manager.

Ryan Cotton ·28:19

How to verify: Consult industry rankings from sources like Preqin or Blackstone's investor presentations regarding real estate AUM. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Prologis is one of the five most valuable REITs in the world.

Ryan Cotton ·28:47

How to verify: Check current market capitalization rankings for REITs on financial data platforms like Bloomberg or Yahoo Finance. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Hamid Moini built Prologis by understanding the value of infill industrial assets and logistics capabilities.

Ryan Cotton ·28:47

How to verify: Review Prologis corporate history or Hamid Moini's biographical information on Prologis's investor relations page. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Bain Capital Real Estate is not a public asset manager.

Ryan Cotton ·29:11

How to verify: Check the corporate structure of Bain Capital Real Estate and its regulatory filings (or lack thereof) with the SEC. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Ryan Cotton rejected a $10 billion mandate to trade office distress.

Ryan Cotton ·30:10

How to verify: This is a hypothetical example provided by the speaker; verify by checking if Bain Capital Real Estate has publicly disclosed any such large office distress mandates during the relevant period. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify NCREIF or CoStar historical asset allocation reports to confirm the shift from traditional to alternative real estate sectors.
  • Check the latest S&P 500 or FTSE NAREIT index constituents by market capitalization to validate the claim that top REITs are now alternative-focused.
  • Review Federal Reserve Economic Data (FRED) on commercial real estate vacancy rates and tech sector employment trends to assess AI and remote work impacts.
  • Look up Welltower (WELL) stock price and latest quarterly earnings report to verify the 130% NAV premium claim.
  • Verify Ibbotson/Morningstar or NCREIF historical performance data for the 1970s and 1980s to confirm real estate's performance relative to gold.
  • Check US Census Bureau wealth distribution data and private aviation/marina industry growth reports to assess demand drivers for luxury leisure infrastructure.
Full transcriptexpand
0:01
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It
0:01
Ryan Cotton: leads you away from the office. It leads you away from the mall.
0:04
Diana Olick: Forget office towers and shopping malls. The next big real estate play could be something you never expected.
0:11
Ryan Cotton: Private airplane hangers, marinas for boats and yachts.
0:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
0:14
Diana Olick: when you talk to your investors and you say, Well, I'm interested in marinas and airplane hangers, how do they respond?
0:21
Ryan Cotton: As people get richer, they buy more toys.
0:23
Diana Olick: And they need places for their yachts. With $18 billion in assets under many management, Bain Capital's Ryan Cotton is betting on a dramatic shift in where money is moving and which properties could deliver the biggest returns.
0:36
Ryan Cotton: There is a structural change coming in the type of assets that real estate investors want to own.
0:41
Diana Olick: On this episode of Property Play, the big money behind CRE's next transformation.
0:48
Diana Olick: Ryan Cotton, head of Bain Capital Real Estate. Welcome to the Property Play.
0:52
Ryan Cotton: Thanks for having me.
0:53
Diana Olick: So you are in charge of $18 billion in assets under management on the real estate side, but as we were just joking before, that changes every day because of what we're seeing in interest rates. How are you operating in this environment?
1:07
Ryan Cotton: Sure. It's definitely a confusing Using and complicated time to be a real estate investor. Uh, you have a few con factors coming together at the same time, higher interest. rates, as you mentioned, quite a lot of supply that's still working its way through the system as a bit of an overhang from the zero interest rate period when
1:22
Diana Olick: Which was overbuilding.
1:23
Ryan Cotton: Just overbuilding, exactly. And a lot of shifting demand patterns. AI changing the way logistics and supply chains work, changing the way offices work and and people you know congregate, uh evolutions in and consumer economy and and where the wealth is being created and being spent in the economy. All those things. put together are creating this cocktail of disruption in real estate that's made things
1:43
Ryan Cotton: disruptive for the industry as a whole. I think both in terms of understanding the value of what people own today in this new paradigm, but also thinking about where do you go from here and how do you allocate capital against those dynamic shifts.
1:55
Diana Olick: Well the value is the most interesting part because as we said, it's shifting every single day. I'm hearing things like you can't value a property anymore or do deals are falling through and having to be revalued. So you're on the ground. What are is it hyperbolic or are you really seeing the deals fall through, the values change day to day?
2:11
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): No,
2:11
Ryan Cotton: I think it's very real. Um, you know, if you think back over the last few years, we've sort of had a macro shock every six months. Uh, whether that's the war in Iran, whether that's uh now the the blowout of the long end into of the treasury curve, whether that was tariffs, uh, every time the market started to get back on its feet, find its balance, find its level, and start to clear itself again, a new shock came around and there's another
2:31
Ryan Cotton: digestion period that has to happen. Um, we're clearly now working through the implications of a higher tenure, you know, pushing, you know, five, one to five, three, depending on the day right now. That's that's an environment the industry wasn't necessarily geared for. Uh, not a surprise to us at Bain Bane Capital. I think we'd had that call for a while, but I think it is disorienting as people try. to rebase
2:51
Ryan Cotton: values. And in the midst of transactions, you're seeing value retrades at the 11th hour, deals getting pulled and volume slowing down yet again in the market.
2:59
Diana Olick: So what do you do? I mean, on the ground, how do you operate in that type of environment day to day? Give me an example.
3:06
Ryan Cotton: Yeah, for sure. Well, I the good news is, you know, we're long-term investors and we're not spot traders of these assets. And so, you know, we don't have to have an opinion on value every single day. I think often about Warren Buffett's analog of Mr. Market being your business partner who's a paranoid schizophrenic who comes in and quotes you values and, you know, when he's a bullion, you can sell. And when he's depressed, you can just tell him to get out of your office. You know,
3:26
Ryan Cotton: that's a little bit how I think about the market. What I think matters is focusing on fundamentals and driving income growth, really trying to optimize the value of the assets, deliver the best product you can for your customer and build the strong strongest lease roles that you can. And if you put your head down and work hard on creating value, I'm certain that eventually the market finds its level, finds its
3:46
Ryan Cotton: balance and Mr. Market finds his optimism again. And then you can get back into transacting.
3:50
Diana Olick: And Bain operates across all asset classes, right? So you, you know, you but you have office, you have apartments, which are all multifamily Family different industrial data centers. Some are doing incredibly well, some are in recovery, some are not doing so well. As you said, we did see this overbuilding because of those record low interest rates that came out of the pandemic.
4:10
Diana Olick: Um, we see that inventory working through in multifamily. We see office kind of in recovery now. We're in at least, you know, New York and San Francisco. What else do we care about? Um so what is the strategy? Because you have kind of a different outlook than some of the other folks we've talked about.
4:26
Ryan Cotton: Yeah, for sure. I think the three through line in what we do in real estate is is deep thematics. And really a thematic is a long term secular demand driver, some change in the way we live, work, shop, play that creates growing demand for a certain type of real estate and preferably growing demand outside of supply. Um and and if you take that lens to to investing in the asset
4:45
Ryan Cotton: class, it leads to some unique curations in your portfolio. Uh, you know, office is a great example. It's very tough to come up with a national long-term demand thematic for office. Uh, if anything, the thematics are negative. You know, AI and productivity enhancements, um, you know, remote work uh that we all learn through COVID. These things are not bringing more
5:05
Ryan Cotton: people into an office.
5:07
Diana Olick: But I thought AI was because I was told that, you know, while well, tech coder workers can be remote, AI wants everybody in the office, and that's what's fueling San Francisco.
5:15
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
5:15
Ryan Cotton: although I think you need a lot less people to do that coding. And so, yes, they may be coming back, and San Francisco is surely having a moment. But if you look at Denver, if you look at Atlanta, if you look at secondary, tertiary clusters, you
5:27
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
5:27
Ryan Cotton: that demand is falling apart pretty rapidly. And so we really start the conversation with what is that 10-year secular demand driver that creates the need for more of this real estate? And if you take that lens, you know, it leads you away from the office, it leads you away from the mall, it leads you candidly away from some multifamily markets where you have out migration or
5:46
Ryan Cotton: oversupply of that product. And instead, it leaves you into more of what I would call alternative or immersion classes of real estate.
5:53
Diana Olick: Such as
5:54
Ryan Cotton: things like senior housing, self-storage, student housing. Uh Even now, the most bleeding frontiers of that are private airplane hangers, marine. marinas for for boats and yachts.
6:05
Diana Olick: This does not sound sexy.
6:12
Diana Olick: Net operating income for those of you, yes.
6:14
Ryan Cotton: Fair. Uh and there's real scarcity of those assets and and supply barriers that means that even though demand continues to grow, supply may not have an adequate response to it. You know, something very different than what you have in the office space or in the the multifamily space or even the large industrial warehouse world. Um, and as that's evolving, what you're seeing is a bit of a tectonic shift in capital. Uh, if
6:34
Ryan Cotton: you go back, you know, 10 years ago, something like 93% of all the real estate assets in the world were invested in four food groups: multi-office, retail, uh, and industrial. Uh, today, um, that's down to sort of 82% as more and more capital is is moving out. of those sectors because of the lack of structural demand drivers
6:54
Ryan Cotton: and moving into these more peripheral asset classes. You know, a test I would fail that I find fascinating is if you look at the 10 largest public REITs in the world today. Most liquid markets, you know, have a daily referendum on value. The 10 largest in the world, uh, seven of them are alternative sectors of real estate, be that data centers, be that senior housing. You know, these are not traditional
7:14
Ryan Cotton: four food. group asset classes. And that's where the most liquid markets have migrated.
7:18
Diana Olick: So you don't put uh data centers under industrial with some people do.
7:22
Ryan Cotton: No, I think it's a very different product. Um, you know, industrial for me is sort of large vacant warehouses that have trucks coming and going every day. And you're thinking about coverage ratios and ingress and egress and those sort of things. Data centers is a unique asset class that that relies much more on power generation, your access and capacity for power, cooling technology, and has
7:42
Ryan Cotton: a very different sort of zoning and permitting overlay to it. And so I just think both the regulatory as well as the structural requirements of the asset class are just fundamentally different.
7:50
Diana Olick: So I'm just while you were saying that, I'm hearing the investors watching this saying, okay, which REITs, which REITs, which REITs do I buy? As you said at senior loan, And we
7:57
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know
7:57
Diana Olick: there's names like Ventas. What are some of the names that you're talking about in that alternative?
8:01
Ryan Cotton: Yeah, sure. I mean it you you could look can them up. I and I'm definitely not a stock picker. So I I'm not here to make uh buy recommendations for anybody, but you know, DLR digital realty is a great example of that. And in that top 10, um, Welltower is a great example on the senior side. And in that top 10, um, you know, you have a bunch of people who are sort of trying to play in these nichier ecosystems. Um, and
8:21
Ryan Cotton: as you get further out the frontier, I mean, this is a continually evolving thing. If you think back 20 twenty years ago, people didn't. did not think senior housing was real estate at all. It was an operating business that that happened to own some real estate. Today, it's some of the most valuable real estate in the world as well tower trades at 130% of net asset.
8:37
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
8:37
Diana Olick: that's demographics though, right?
8:38
Ryan Cotton: It's demography, it's operational constraints. It's hard to operate that real estate. You know, think about the difference between some of these alternative asset classes and in traditional. In an office building, I can call C CBRE BRE and say lease the building for me. And if they don't do a good job, well, I'll replace them with JLL and we move on. When you're operating a senior housing facility, this isn't a commodity product. You have to have
8:58
Ryan Cotton: capability, you have to have team, you have to have talent, you have to know how to deliver a service every day to your customer. Same thing's true in data center land, you know, power permitting and staying on the good side of the city and the county you operate in. That's a real expertise that's required. Uh, that's not just an outsourceable commodity.
9:15
Diana Olick: So when you talk to your investors and you say, Well, I'm interested in marinas and airplane hangers, how do they respond?
9:22
Ryan Cotton: Yeah, I'd say you you you have two conversations. The first is what is the structural demand driver that makes you interested in that? Uh both of those happen to share one structural demand driver, which is the K-shaped economy and the growth of the ultra-high Ultra high net worth in the United States. Um
9:35
Diana Olick: rich people like airplane hangers. hangars.
9:37
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
9:37
Ryan Cotton: know, wealth is concentrating. And as people get richer, they buy more toys.
9:40
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
9:40
Diana Olick: they need places for their yachts.
9:41
Ryan Cotton: And they have to park their yacht somewhere because once it's in the water, it's got to go somewhere. No
9:45
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): problem.
9:46
Ryan Cotton: The airplane has to be stored in a hangar because you don't want hail damage or weather damage, and your insurance company will require that. And yet there are real structural supply barriers around that. You know, you think about a market like New York or Boston, you're not adding new marinas to Boston Harbor. It's a fully developed, you know, no more supply available market. And so you've you got some real convexity and rental rate growth there. So that's the first
10:05
Ryan Cotton: topic is sort of where does that demand generator come? The second is where is the capital coming from? You know, is there sufficient liquidity in these markets? Is there an exit that's coming from these markets? And what I think you see a pattern of, and it dates back to senior housing 20 years ago before Ventos House and Welltower, um, is emerging capital market demand for these higher
10:25
Ryan Cotton: growth asset classes. Now you have large public REITs in those legacy sectors like self storage and senior housing that 20 years ago were not in vogue. Today you're seeing some of the largest investment firms in the world make big bets in these asset classes. Atlantic Aviation, second largest private airplane hangar platform in the country, traded this year to Apollo at a
10:45
Ryan Cotton: fairly high multiple. Um, Safe Harbor Marinas, you know, largest marina platform in the world traded to Black. Blackstone this year.
10:51
Diana Olick: These are just not names we talk about.
10:53
Ryan Cotton: They're not. They will be.
10:54
Diana Olick: But we should be.
10:55
Ryan Cotton: They will be for sure. And I think one of the jobs of an investor today is to try and stay in front of those capital migrations and and take advantage of the re rate. When we started buying marinas, you know, we were able to buy those assets somewhere between a seven and a nine cap rate. Uh today, those assets trade between a five and a six cap rate, just because so much capital has come into that subsector. uh
11:15
Ryan Cotton: with a desire to accumulate assets that it's driven a fundamental re-rating in the way the market values those assets.
11:20
Diana Olick: And interest rates affect on these?
11:22
Ryan Cotton: Interest rates, of course, have an effect on cap rates across the board. You have to be thoughtful about that. Um
11:27
Diana Olick: dumb that down for us. How do interest rate? And I don't want to do like, you know, econ 101, but just for for the lay people out there listening, what does that mean?
11:35
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
11:36
Ryan Cotton: I mean, think about real estate. You're effectively buying a total return. algorithm, right? You're buying a yield that you go in at. Think about that as your cap rate. You're buying growth. How much can you grow that NOI and grow that yield over time? And then there's a bit of a drag for reinvestment, capex requirements and that sort of thing. And so if I'm buying a mariner at a five cap and I think I can grow NOI
11:56
Ryan Cotton: at 9% a year, I'm getting a 14% unlevered return on that asset before me. meeting.
12:01
Diana Olick: You're very mathy.
12:02
Ryan Cotton: You know, data. data driven. That's a part of our DNA, I'd suppose. And so of course, as the risk-free rate goes up, as treasury rates go up, the required yield that I want to own for a particular piece of risk goes up along with it. What's interesting is there is not a perfectly linear relationship. You know, one point in treasuries does not mean every cap
12:22
Ryan Cotton: rate goes up one point, because there are offsetting factors to that. Most notably your ability to grow increases in high interest rate environments because inflation is higher. You can take rent faster. You can grow your income a little bit faster. And so that's a bit of a muting effect to that translation. Also, as we talked about a little bit earlier, development starts to slow down. Supply growth slows down in those
12:42
Ryan Cotton: higher interest rate environments, meaning you get into a tighter absorption environment, again, allowing you to grow your income a little bit faster. And so if you look over history, uh interestingly, the very best periods for real estate returns typically are in higher interest rate environments or rising interest rate environments. Not necessarily true of existing assets, those reset
13:02
Ryan Cotton: in value, but the go forward returns from attaching yourself at this moment in time to that asset class tend to be really good. Take the 1970s as an example. Clearly, super high interest rates, the Volcker era, hyperinflation. Um, the first four years of that decade were really bad for real estate. You sort of saw a 30% value destruction in the asset class as you reset the
13:22
Ryan Cotton: base rates and and you got into that higher interest rate environment. The next eight years uh that followed from 74 to 82, real estate was the second best performing asset class in the world after gold.
13:32
Diana Olick: So where are we in that? Are we still in the first four years? Yes.
13:35
Ryan Cotton: I think we are ending the first four years.
13:37
Diana Olick: Okay.
13:37
Ryan Cotton: Um, you know, we are back into a higher rate environment. Real estate is trading in the third quartile of long-term valuation ranges. And so you're attaching yourself at a pretty good entry price on an absolute price per pound basis. You're buying below the 50-year trend line of real estate values today. So you're attaching yourself at a really interesting moment in time.
13:57
Diana Olick: So why are the deals falling through now?
13:59
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
13:59
Ryan Cotton: I think the deals are falling through because buyers and sellers can't agree on value. Uh Um
14:03
Diana Olick: we're back to value.
14:04
Ryan Cotton: Yeah. It's the reset of that existing portfolio where people are still wrestling with the multifamily asset you bought in 2021 is not worth what you bought it for in 2021. Um, sellers are holding out hope, rates will will roll over, you know, we'll go back to the good old days and value will recover in my portfolio. And buyers are saying
14:23
Ryan Cotton: there's a new normal here. And until those two sides can agree. you know, you've got too wide of a bidass spread in the market.
14:29
Diana Olick: So it's kind of the same thing that's happening in the housing market, right?
14:32
Ryan Cotton: Exactly. Exactly.
14:33
Diana Olick: Sellers think their house is worth X, buyers think it's worth Y. Yeah,
14:36
Ryan Cotton: despite mortgage rates going up, you haven't seen real value compression in housing because I know what I paid for it. I know what it was worth two years ago. I'm holding on to that vision. Uh and until there's some reset in expectations, you really won't see liquidity returns.
14:49
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
14:50
Diana Olick: Funny how that works. Um, so you talk about value, of course, and you have a different when going back to the four major asset classes, which you still are in. I know you like the the other stuff, but um
15:01
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
15:01
Diana Olick: lot of investors say it's a rough time, but if you hang on to the trophy assets, if you look for the trophy assets, then you're in a good place because they'll never lose value. The value will, you know, the deal's not gonna going to fall through because we know what those are, but you don't like trophies trophy so much. I'm told.
15:15
Ryan Cotton: Yeah, I I'd say uh it depends on how you define trophy. You know, I think there are some The
15:20
Diana Olick: Empire State Building, let's say.
15:21
Ryan Cotton: That's a fairly trophy that's fairly a trophy. I definitely agree with that. Uh though I would say that demand patterns in New York for office space are changing and the neighborhoods people want to work in have evolved. And 42nd Street is not exactly, you know, ground zero for where people want to be going to work anymore. Uh instead Park Avenue is now, you know, the new uh top of the heap in New York City. Uh, one
15:41
Ryan Cotton: Vanderbilt next to Grand Central Station is, you know, top market rents in New York City. Uh, because trophy is really about demand. It's about why people want to be in those assets. And I think there are some bad heuristics and bad patterns in real estate where people just reflexively go back to what's worked before, you know, buy the dip, buy the trophy
16:01
Ryan Cotton: asset, because that never loses. its value without asking the next why question, which is what makes that have enduring value? What is it about the neighborhood? What is it about the physical characteristics of the asset? Was it about the customer needs that means that those needs will never change, that this asset will always work to serve that asset class? Um, and I do think some of that
16:21
Ryan Cotton: is changing a little bit faster than the market is absorbing that change at the moment.
16:25
Diana Olick: So you stay out of trophy entirely?
16:27
Ryan Cotton: No, I'd say we we are happy to buy super high quality assets where the demand fundamentals and the why make sense to us. You know, I think as an investor
16:36
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
16:36
Diana Olick: not just trophy on trophy.
16:37
Ryan Cotton: Not just trophy because the market says that's trophy. Um, you know, to me, the most important question you can ask as an investor is why. You know, it's our job as investors to ask why until we can't ask the question anymore. And then we've arrived at a fundamental belief of the that investment. You know, why is the Empire State Building a trophy asset? Well, because everybody knows its name. Well, why does everybody know its name?
16:57
Ryan Cotton: Well, because everybody wants to go there. Okay, that's my bet. Does everybody still want to go there to go to work? And you have to have a point of view on that before you attach yourself to that asset.
17:07
Diana Olick: Um, it there's so much
17:09
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
17:09
Diana Olick: know, happening now in the market as you talk about whether it's the trophy, whether it's the interest rates, whether it's the different types of assets. that are changing and their values are changing. You said something to me earlier
17:20
Diana Olick: that when you talk to real estate investors in general, they're quote, reeling.
17:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
17:27
Ryan Cotton: we've heard this from a bunch of people. Um, you know, uh, a few people do surveys of real estate managers uh every year. Ask them about sentiment and and where their heads at and what they see for the year ahead. And what we heard from this year's surveys was that. a huge number of managers expressed being in a fog, being confused about what's happening.
17:44
Diana Olick: Which is not what you want your asset manager to say with
17:46
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): billions of dollars.
17:47
Ryan Cotton: Your asset manager telling people
17:50
Ryan Cotton: happening and I think that fog is because the rate environment has shifted so radically. If you really think about uh the journey we've been on, for 15 years we've been in a structurally declining interest rate environment ever since the global financial crisis. And that creates a lot of pattern recognition, that creates a lot of embedded sort of reflex about how you invest.
18:08
Diana Olick: Again, which is what we see in the housing market. People think 7%
18:12
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is
18:12
Diana Olick: abnormal on a mortgage rate. It's really not.
18:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's not.
18:14
Diana Olick: It's just abnormal compared to 10 years ago.
18:17
Ryan Cotton: Long-term average for US 10-year treasuries is 5.2%. That's where we sit today. So we are at normal today, even though for the last 15 years that has not felt normal. And I think when you're going through a paradigmatic shift that's that large from 15 years of patterns that work for you, of a tailwind that you just could take for granted every day, and you're
18:37
Ryan Cotton: now moving into an environment where that's not a given, you know, where it's highly likely rates will stay higher and elevated at this level for some period of time, your whole philosophy has to shift. Your whole style of investing has to shift. What you buy. has to shift. How you operate has to shift. And that's a like turning a super tanker. You know, you can't do that in
18:57
Ryan Cotton: a day. And the average investor well, I think we had a little bit of of foresight here. And I won't take credit for it. I'm the beneficiary of an enormous platform that has quite a lot of capability. One of those capabilities is a centralized macro function that for the last four years has been saying inflation would be persistent. and therefore we would be in a higher
19:16
Ryan Cotton: interest rate environment for longer. Um, you know, we we did a lot of hedging activity in 2021 when rates were near zero because of that view and it it paid off fairly well for us.
19:27
Diana Olick: So you saw it coming.
19:28
Ryan Cotton: Uh you know, it's a risk. Okay,
19:30
Diana Olick: you could say
19:30
Ryan Cotton: I I think in investing you can never claim to see something coming. I think what you're really doing is pricing fans of outcomes and probability distributions, but it felt to us at that moment and really felt to us for the last four years like higher interest rates were more likely than not. Um, and so that led us to start wrestling with this faster, to start asking what it means, to start thinking about where do you
19:50
Ryan Cotton: want to go in this environment. Um, and what we were hearing, frankly, from a lot of the market around us was it's gonna roll over. The Fed's gonna relent, you know, they're gonna start cutting. When they start cutting, it's gonna go back to the way it was. Um, you saw them express that in capital in 2021-22, 40% of all the real estate capital that was invested in the US was put in market
20:10
Ryan Cotton: rate multifamily assets that were bought around a four and a half cap rate. If you thought interest rates were going to five point two percent, you know, buying at a four and a half cap at that moment in time was not a good idea.
20:23
Ryan Cotton: Um, but that's not what the market thought. Uh and so now as this reality is becoming understood, as it's becoming obvious that the Fed is not going to be in a cutting cycle anytime soon. And surely the long end of the curve, which the Fed doesn't control, has its own point of view about where we're headed, uh people are now having to go through that that journey of figuring
20:42
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): out
20:42
Ryan Cotton: what it means.
20:42
Diana Olick: Hence the fog. Hence
20:43
Ryan Cotton: the fog.
20:44
Diana Olick: And the reeling, which you do not have and it's okay to give yourself a pat on the back. That's why you're here. Um so operating in this environment of foggy colleagues and reeling temperaments over what's going on, how do you stay the course? Just personally, like as what you do for a living.
21:03
Ryan Cotton: Yeah, well, sure. I think there's there's an investment dimension and a psychological dimension to that question. I think that the psychological dimension Mention is, you know, you you have to remind yourself that, you know, it's never as good as it feels or as bad as it seems. Uh and that you really need to take a long-term orientation and just work through it one step at a time.
21:19
Diana Olick: You must meditate.
21:20
Ryan Cotton: Uh yeah, a little bit of that. Um, and a lot of really smart people around me that I get to have incredibly dynamic conversations with. I don't think any one person can figure these things out and it takes it takes a team. I think the investment side of it is you you really need to pivot your capabilities and your aperture, and you need to start focusing on higher growth because that's what generates income and the in these environments. You
21:40
Ryan Cotton: need to focus on operating capability, your ability to add alpha to create net operating income growth, not just buy it and then wait for it to re rate as the cost of capital re-rates around you. And so you have to become a much more hands on, much more proactive, you know, much more value added manager in this environment than just somebody who's trading beta.
21:58
Diana Olick: So let's talk about capabilities and aperture because you, as you said, are late to the real estate game. You haven't been doing this very long, but you have been doing other things. Tell me the evolution of Ryan Cotton and how he got into real estate. Yeah,
22:11
Ryan Cotton: an unusual journey for a real estate manager. I spent the first 20 years of my career in the private equity business of Baying Capital.
22:16
Diana Olick: So still money.
22:17
Ryan Cotton: Still managing money, still building operating platforms, uh, and thinking about that why question a lot, trying to understand, you know, what's happening to the companies we invest in and how to position them well. against those shifting thematic dynamics that are out there. But really what it taught me was two things. One was how to understand those thematics, how to see that bigger picture, to invest with a wider
22:37
Ryan Cotton: aperture and with a sense of 10 year direction of travel and not just two year momentum. And then secondly, how to build advantaged operating platforms. You know, in in private equity, I think one of the most qu important questions you can ask is why is this a winning business? What what is its source of competitive edge, competitive advantage? Um, that's a key diagnostic.
22:57
Ryan Cotton: If you're going to attach yourself for five to seven years to a company, you better believe they have a right to win. Um and so as I migrated to real estate, you know, those are the two lenses I tried to bring, along with a bunch of humility and recognition that I had a lot to learn, uh, was really let's be focused on those thematics. Let's curate a portfolio that is exposed to 10 year shifts and how we live, work,
23:17
Ryan Cotton: and play. And let's go build advantaged operating platforms that have a reason that they can generate better results in the assets themselves. You
23:25
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
23:26
Diana Olick: why real estate for you?
23:27
Ryan Cotton: Um, because I think this moment in time is super interesting. I think there is a really big opportunity to build through this cycle, uh, to create the next generation of a real estate investment platform that is. um that is purpose built for this moment, that's not uh have 15 years of bad patterns and trading beta, but really is focused on
23:47
Ryan Cotton: creating edge and operational advantage and investing in the right sectors. And I think for for people who can make that pivot faster and who can build those platforms, you know, there's there's a big shift coming in the world. And And my my desire, my job is to get ahead of that and make sure we're one of the winners through that cycle.
24:03
Diana Olick: Which you seem to be doing right now. But in talking about all of the macros and everything going on in the real estate world and the greater economy in general globally, I got to get down to what is your big play?
24:15
Ryan Cotton: Yeah. Well look, I think our our big play is uh it to go back to where we started the conversation, this belief that there is a structural change coming in the type of assets that real estate investors want to own. Um, we talk about as the pivot to alternatives. Um, if you survey investment managers, uh, they would tell you they own half as many alternative real estate assets as they
24:35
Ryan Cotton: want to. Uh, if you survey uh, you know, institutional investors, capital allocators, the people that I work for, they would tell you that by 2030, they expect to own 30 own thirty to to 40 forty percent of their portfolios in alternative real estate relative to the 12 twelve to 15. fifteen percent they own today. And so if you can make yourself an expert in those emerging
24:55
Ryan Cotton: niche alternative segments of real estate, if you can build and own the operating axis of competitive advantage that lets you deliver better results in those segments of real estate, you can really take advantage of that structural shift in capital. Um we're not spending a lot of time trying to become great office investors. Um there are people who do that really well. I have a lot of respect for those people. And if you want to
25:15
Ryan Cotton: play that cycle, there are people I would highly recommend you play that cycle with. We're not it. Um, if you want to take advantage of what I think is a 40 year shift in the kind of real estate we we want to own, you know, that's what we're trying to be, is the is the platform of choice for that.
25:29
Diana Olick: So you come in, you're the new guy, you haven't done real estate and you're pitching alternatives. How hard is that to sell to the people that you work with? Because they're saying, all right, well, he doesn't know real. estate. Yes, he knows money, he knows investing, but we've been doing this forever. You are now leading a group. You are now raising funds. I see you've got two different multi-billion dollar funds. So for
25:49
Diana Olick: within Bain Capital and then for the investors, how did you convince everybody of this play?
25:55
Ryan Cotton: Yeah, well, I I think I'm lucky that a lot of smart minds got there with me. You know, I this was not a unique insight. Uh, and the team I joined at Bain Capital had sort of been prosecuting the strategy for a while. Um, they they joined us from the Harvard Management Company where they they managed the endowment of Harvard University in real estate. And that was really the philosophy they had built themselves on there was, you know, focusing
26:15
Ryan Cotton: more on emerging demand fundamental, thematic real estate um that that led them to alternatives. And so there was a a meeting of in the minds already when I joined them. And then for investors, you know, they see the empirical data. I mean, we talked about the public market data point earlier, but but I'll share one more. If you look over the last 10 years, alternative real estate's generated roughly double the return of
26:35
Ryan Cotton: traditional real estate in both the public and private markets. And it's done it with lower volatility. So three times the sharp ratio. It doesn't take a lot of convincing to an allocator Or to sort of explain, you know, this is a three times sharp ratio double return way to invest. They want more. of that. And they they see that, they see it in their own portfolios, they understand it.
26:55
Ryan Cotton: I think their biggest question is, how do I get more of it? And who are the right partners who have edge and advantage in pursuing?
27:02
Diana Olick: And they now especially want real assets over the capital markets because everything is so volatile. But I assume, given everything going on globally and oil prices and all of these other macro factors, that can come back. to haunt real estate as well.
27:16
Ryan Cotton: For sure. As we said, it's a disorienting time. Uh and and you do
27:20
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
27:20
Diana Olick: you're not feeling
27:21
Ryan Cotton: you have to hang on through the cycle. I mean there are surely scary days in real estate. There are surely volatile days. There are days when, you know, the market, Mr. Market, uh to use Warren Buffett's phrase is a paranoid schizophrenic. Uh and you, you know, you sort of have to recognize it for what it is. Um but I think the the long term story remains fundamentally intact. And so if you just keep your eyes focused on what you're headed toward and what
27:41
Ryan Cotton: you're building, you could migrate your way through the cycle and you'll come out a winner on the other side.
27:45
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
27:45
Diana Olick: you've mentioned Warren Buffett a couple of times. Is there anyone specifically in real estate though who coming into this as the newbie, you looked at and said, okay, I'm not necessarily following everything this person does, but was a guidepost for you?
27:59
Ryan Cotton: Yeah, I I spent a lot of time actually as we built a business plan for real estate at Bing Capital, um, looking at all the folks that are operating in the world today. And there are some of my competitors that I have extreme respect for, people who I think are extraordinary macro investors, extraordinarily thematic investors who understand the dynamics that are at play in the industry.
28:19
Ryan Cotton: Um, and you know, those tend to be the folks who've been big winners, honestly. Um, there's a reason Blackstone is the largest real estate investor. manager.
28:26
Diana Olick: I was gonna say Blackstock. Blackstone, right?
28:27
Ryan Cotton: They're very good at what they do. And I have an extraordinary amount of respect for them and their platform uh and their ability to invest at scale in the asset class. Um and I think there's been a lot of esoteric people through history who've who've made expertise in small niche segments where they've generated extraordinary returns. If you look at uh Hamid who built Prologis, you know, he understood the value of infill
28:47
Ryan Cotton: industrial assets and the value of large scale logistical capabilities. capability long before the real estate market did. And as a result, built one of the five most valuable REITs in the world thinking about that.
28:57
Diana Olick: So you are an $18 billion slice of $230 billion Bain capital assets under management. Do you expect to grow that significantly or in your time or keep it as that small niche sector for Bain?
29:11
Ryan Cotton: Yeah, our goal is surely to grow, but not for the sake of growth. You know, we're not a public asset manager at Bain Capital. We're not valued based on our assets under management, and there's no reward for just putting a bigger number on the board. Um, what I want to do is generate extraordinary returns for my investors. That's my number one day job. Um, and I do think that there are certain advantages that come with scale in
29:30
Ryan Cotton: real estate, your relevance to the market, the data capability you have, the insights you have, your ability to attract talent and world-class investment talent to that. platform, the scale you can build in operating platforms to reinforce that competitive edge and advantage that that you have. And so what I talk to our team about, what I talk to my investors about is strategic
29:50
Ryan Cotton: scale. Uh it's it's growing and building in ways that create and reinforce competitive advantage that produce superior returns. Um, You know, somebody offers us a $10 billion mandate to go trade office distress, you know, we're not going to take that capital because that's not strategic. That doesn't build a capability for me. That doesn't reinforce an access of competitive advantage for me.
30:10
Ryan Cotton: That's just managing money. Um, and I'm sure your ego feels good. Um a
30:15
Diana Olick: lot of people are doing that though.
30:16
Ryan Cotton: But it's a distraction. Um, and I think if you're really focused on generating superior returns, you need to focus on what you're great at and reinforcing that competitive edge every day. So
30:26
Diana Olick: from what you've learned so far and being in this, you know, bunch of years now, do you expect to stay in real estate or is this another stepping stone?
30:34
Ryan Cotton: Um, well, I I'm gonna be here for a while for sure. Um, you know, I think there is an enormous opportunity here, like I said. Uh, and I think this cycle will take some real time to play out. And I obviously want to uh see the other side of this cycle. Uh, as I remind our team every day, you know, when you're in the bottom like this, it's hard to remember what the top. feels like. Uh, but it does come back. Um and I want to be
30:54
Ryan Cotton: here when that comes back. And I wanna, I wanna ride that wave and and take advantage of all the hard work we've done through these tough yards and tough years uh to be winners on the other side of that. And so I I'm no tourist here. I'm I'm here to stay.
31:05
Diana Olick: Ryan Cotton, head of Bane Capital Real Estate. Thank you so much.
31:08
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Thank
31:09
Ryan Cotton: you for having me. It was a pleasure.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights