Keith Dykes and Brian Roper argue for income-based retirement planning over savings targets
Summary
Keith Dykes and Brian Roper argue that most people make the mistake of focusing on arbitrary savings numbers rather than their actual annual spending requirements. They claim that 95 to 98% of individuals ignore the expense side of their retirement equation, leading to inadequate preparation. The speakers identify healthcare costs and market volatility as primary risks, noting that healthcare expenses often force individuals to work until age 65 for Medicare eligibility. They introduce a 'financial house' model to balance growth, income, and preservation, and mention the Rule of 55 as a specific withdrawal strategy.
Key takeaways
- 1 Keith Dykes cites a commercial by an unnamed investment bank featuring people with 'number bubbles' above their heads to illustrate the media's focus on arbitrary savings targets rather than actual lifestyle spending needs.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) · 1:23
Episode sections
- 0:23 – 3:07
Planning Mistakes and the Focus on Savings Numbers
Brian Roper and Keith Dykes identify failing to create a plan and focusing solely on a savings target as major retirement mistakes. They argue that individuals should instead focus on annual spending requirements and start planning as early as possible to leverage compounding.
- 3:07 – 6:05
Determining Retirement Readiness Through Income Planning
The speakers discuss how to assess if one has enough money to retire by shifting focus from accumulated savings to income planning. They note that many people underestimate their income needs or overestimate their ability to spend down assets without a strategic plan.
- 6:05 – 10:07
Key Financial Risks: Volatility and Healthcare Costs
Brian Roper and Keith Dykes identify market volatility and healthcare expenses as primary concerns for retirees. They highlight that healthcare costs are a significant barrier to early retirement due to the gap before Medicare eligibility at age 65.
- 10:07 – 14:30
Balancing Growth and Protection in Retirement Portfolios
The hosts discuss the trade-off between growing wealth and preserving capital in retirement. They introduce the 'financial house' model, suggesting a diversified approach with portions of the portfolio dedicated to the roof (growth), walls (income), and foundation (preservation).
- 14:30 – 18:42
The Rule of 55 and the Importance of Actionable Planning
Keith Dykes explains the 'Rule of 55,' which allows penalty-free withdrawals from 401(k)s if retirement occurs in the year one turns 55. Both speakers emphasize that having a concrete, adaptable financial plan is more critical than any single rule or number.
Claims worth verifying
Keith Dykes references a commercial by an investment bank showing people with number bubbles above their heads.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·1:23
How to verify: Search video archives for investment bank advertisements featuring 'number bubbles' or similar visual metaphors for savings goals; identify the specific bank if possible. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
95 to 98% of people ignore the expense side of their retirement equation.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·3:38
How to verify: This is an internal anecdote from JL Perkins Wealth Management; verify by checking client engagement data or surveys from the firm if publicly disclosed, or treat as unverified anecdotal claim. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Healthcare expenses are the biggest barrier to early retirement because individuals must wait until age 65 for Medicare.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·7:33
How to verify: Verify Medicare eligibility age (65) via the official Medicare.gov website or CMS.gov; review healthcare cost studies (e.g., Fidelity Annual Study) for data on pre-Medicare healthcare costs. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The 'Rule of 55' allows penalty-free withdrawals from 401(k) or employer-sponsored plans if retirement occurs in the year one turns 55.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·14:52
How to verify: Verify against IRS Publication 590-A or IRS Code Section 72(t)(1)(A)(ii) regarding exceptions to the 10% early withdrawal penalty for distributions after separation from service at age 55 or older. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The standard age for penalty-free withdrawals from IRAs and 401(k)s is 59.5.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·15:12
How to verify: Verify against IRS Publication 590-B or IRS Code Section 72(t) regarding the standard 59.5 age threshold for qualified distributions. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify the '95-98% ignore expenses' statistic by searching for Keith Dykes' published articles or My Retirement Clarity research papers on expense tracking.
- Confirm the specific terms of the 'Rule of 55' by reviewing IRS Publication 590-B or the specific plan documents of your employer's 401(k) plan.
- Research current healthcare cost projections for pre-Medicare retirees using data from the Employee Benefit Research Institute (EBRI) or the Health Care Financial Management Association (HCFMA).
- Check the definition of 'Sequence of Returns Risk' in academic finance literature to verify the claim that early retirement market declines have a disproportionate impact on portfolio longevity.
- Review the 'Financial House' model in Keith Dykes' book 'Retirement Clarity' or My Retirement Clarity website to understand the specific asset allocation recommendations for each component.
- Identify the unnamed investment bank in the cited commercial to assess potential conflicts of interest or bias in the critique of savings-target marketing.
- Compare your actual annual spending history against your projected retirement income sources (Social Security, pensions) using a tool like the Social Security Administration's myaccount or a pension estimator.
- Look for counter-arguments to the 'income-first' approach by reviewing traditional 'sequence of returns' studies that suggest different withdrawal strategies for volatile markets.
Full transcriptexpand
0:02Lee Perkins: Welcome to the My Retirement Clarity Podcast, where our goal is simple: to help you close the gap between what you know and what you implement. The team at JL Perkins Wealth Management does this by helping good people make great decisions so they can enjoy an amazing retirement. And now here's your host and financial advisor, Lee Perkins.
0:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
0:24Brian Roper: hello, Brian Roper here from JL Perkins Wealth Management Back. in the podcast studio. Filling in for Lee today. With me is Keith Dykes. Keith, how are you? I'm
0:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): doing great, Brian.
0:32Brian Roper: Yeah, good. Good to see you again. And we got uh five questions every retiree should consider today. That's that's gonna be our topic. We're gonna go through some common questions that we see uh just about every day when we meet with our clients that bring in,
0:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
0:46Brian Roper: know, concerns and uh just want to talk to us about, you know, things and things. that they should consider in retirement. So we're going to go through some of these today. I think you'll find benefit from hearing a little bit of each of these questions. Key, start this first one. Now, what's the biggest financial mistake you you see people make when they're prepping for retirement?
1:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Man, that's that's an interesting crest question. I would say it's sort of depending down to one, right? It it just kind kinda of depends. But I'll point out two things that I think are big mistakes and they're they're kind of kinda connected. a little bit. And the first one is just failing to make a plan. What we see so often is and I think I think the propaganda out there in the media really has people focused on it is a number, right? They're just focused on I need to get to a number, whether that's a a million dollars. I think for most people that's the big number in their head, or two or three million. Whatever that number is for everybody. In fact I remember a commercial a few years ago. uh for an investment bank, I don't remember which one, that it was it was all about what's your number. And it showed people walking around with a with a number, uh look up that number bubble above their head. Um they're focused on a number and I think what they should be focused on is they need to be focused on how much are they going gonna to need to spend every year in retirement to maintain the the kind of lifestyle that they want. So I think that's really the starting point. And the second thing that's kind of connected is just waiting too long to come up with a plan. Um they avoid looking at looking at things and and trying to to make a plan earlier is always better in my mind. So there you go. Well said. I mean what we've heard before, you know, people don't plan to fail, they
2:23fail to plan. Uh having that plan and starting,
2:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know,
2:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): as soon as you can in the waiting game seems to be one of the most critical mistakes. Uh, we try to teach young people in our next generation of workshops that we do about compounding wealth and even just starting soon when you're younger and investing. Uh, that's key. But also, as you get older, starting sooner in retirement planning is is is better. So
2:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): well
2:47Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): said, all right. So, question number two today, talking about five questions every retirement retiree plan. should consider. How do you how do you know when you actually have enough money? So you just talked about that commercial with the number and everybody's trying to get to a number, but how do you know that that number's right? Or how do you know when you actually have enough money to say, hey, I I'm going to stop taking a pH. What are your thoughts? Yeah, I mean, the thing here is there's there's always the danger that every time you start getting to get close to a goal in your mind you kind of move the goalpost. I would say it's one of the top two questions that we get is do I have enough money to retire? Right. And um it's an individual question, you know. Again, uh I kind of alluded to it or talked briefly about it in the answer answering in the last question, but it's you know, how much are you spending? I mean, and and I would just say in general, when we're talking to people and planning for people's retirement, this is the half of the equation that I mean, virtually everybody, I'd say 95 to 98% of people just they ignore the expense side of the equation completely. You know, they're so focused on the number and how much they've
3:58accumulated that they're not even thinking about how much money do I spend. And often oftentimes, you know, we're meeting with people that they're, you know, they're not huge spenders. They're they're living, you know, normal lifestyle and they're not they're not really spending a ton, a ton of money. And they actually with Social Security and and those sorts of things, and especially if they um have a pension of some sort fork from the government or from you know a teacher's pension or something like that, they they generally have more income coming in than what they realize. So again, it's back to coming up with a plan and um really looking, doing some income planning and figuring out what the picture looks like. I mean that that's kind of what I think.
4:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
4:41Brian Roper: I mean it's the difference between being financially able to retire and then feeling comfortable about retiring. It's you know we we we get emotional sometimes with some of these conversations and it's really good to share that, hey, you might be doing better than you think as long as you don't change your spending habits. You know, all of a sudden if you retire, you know, you go crazy spending money thinking, oh, I have a retirement account that I can access. Well, that has to be strategically panned out for, you know, twenty, thirty years potentially. So I i it's an emotional uh time when we s we say, Hey, you you actually have enough money, you know, to retire and you're good. as long as we plan and stick to that plan. So
5:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, I think
5:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): a I think a lot of people, yeah, they're just number focused and they're not even really thinking about the fact that that money should continue to be invested and continue to grow. So if you income pr plan properly, you know, you're never taking enough from your um retirement accounts to begin to degrade it. If you have enough uh investable assets to be used. begin with. And for the people that are gonna have to tap into that, then income planning becomes that much more important so that they can comforta comfortably and with confidence pull from their retirement funds, knowing that it's gonna begin to go down, but do it in a way where it should last throughout the rest of your lifetime. So again, yeah, you know, I hate to be a broken record, but plan, plan and income
6:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): plan.
6:03Brian Roper: That's yeah, well said. So
6:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): all
6:05Brian Roper: right. Question number three. If you were retiring tomorrow, what would you worry most about today's financial environment? And I I I think, you know, right off the bat, market volatility, which we see right now, and certainly inflation has affected all of us. Uh are the w how much our money can buy these days with cost of goods increasing. I mean, those are those are certainly front and you know center of today's financial environment. Uh, you know, other things that change but can can kind of throw a wrinkle into your taxes and your tax cuts and tax laws. I mean, that if we're not on top of that, uh, you know, that could be certainly, you know, a worrisome situation. But again, with the strategic tax plan, you know, if you're getting out in front of that, you know. But
7:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
7:01Brian Roper: from today's financial environment, that those are those are certainly some of the top things that we see and some of the questions that our clients bring to us. What am I what do I miss? What else are we hearing out there and that would be worrisome about today's financial?
7:13Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Well, I think for most people their biggest concerns would be market volatility, depending on their perspective on things. And, you know, I think the biggest problem might even be health care expenses. So, you know, as we all know, cost of health care um continues to go up. And I think it's the biggest barrier for most people to retire early. Um I think most people work longer than what they were. would like to because right now it's hard to answer that health care question until they till they get the sixty five and can start taking start taking Medicare. So you know the to me, even though the market volatility is most people focus, there are ways to structure uh an investment plan that can reduce the volatility and and layer it in a way where you can mitigate some of the potential early declines. You know, we we talk about those that sometimes that it it's real that if you know you retire and um the timing was off and let's say the market had two or three years of declines, the first two or three years you're retired, that's gonna make your retirement have a dramatic um it's gonna be dramatically different than it would
8:23be if you retired and you had three Bayer banger years uh in the market. So but again, that's why it's so vitally important to work with a financial advisor that could help you limit the volatility of your plan. And then, you know, we've got um people that we help our clients um who are experts in the healthcare field that could help them not only bridge that gap between retirement and um uh Medicare, um, but also help them when it's time for Medicare to select what what parts are important for them and whether or not they need to do one of those supplemental plans or not. Because as we know, we can you can spend as much on the insurance as you want to. Uh it's not always necessary to uh buy every insurance out there available. So
9:08Brian Roper: yeah, no for sure. I mean we we've we've said before could you know we are all right now the youngest and healthiest we'll ever be. So healthcare expenses uh and planning for that um is critical too. So
9:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): hey
9:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): folks, Lee Perkins here. I wanted to tell you about our brand new book called Next Phase: How to Retire in a Year or Less Without Regrets. It's all about helping you prepare for the next phase of your life, whatever that looks like for you. So if you're ready to make the most of your next phase, or if you're already retired and aren't sure you're doing all you can to get the most out of your retirement, then you'll want a copy of this book. All you have to do is text next phase to 478-475-2050, and we'll send you a copy right away. You can also access additional resources and register for one of our upcoming workshops at our website, www.myretirementclarity.com. Thanks for listening. Now back to the show.
10:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All
10:07Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): right. Question number four. Is it more important in retirement to grow your money or protect what you've already accumulated? So do you think about from a, you know, an accumulation phase of life when we're maybe younger and working and and we're starting to save and invest and you know accumulate that money uh and grow it, um, you know, but as we get towards retirement, uh, some of our pre-retirees have a decision to make. Is it do I need to keep growing my money or is it time to just start holding on tight and protecting and and you know what I've already kind of got there. What do you what do you think, Pete? Yeah, I mean, people usually fall into one of one of two camps. Um yeah, you got some people when they retire, they've always been focused on accumulation and um and the returns and and that's all they care about is they're they're just focused on getting large returns on their on their investments. And then, you know, the the other camp um is people that are just terrified of the market and they want to be as conservative as possible. Um I would say in general, to answer the question directly, um the losses in retirement are gonna per hurt you and affect your um potential retirement far more than the gains. Now, the caveat in that is obviously the gains are important. You you need to have gains in your financial plan so
11:27that you can outrun uh inflation um and buying power erosion a hundred percent. But that's why your your investments need to be diversified, where you know we talk a lot of with up our clients about the financial house. And there are three levels of the financial house. There's the roof, the walls, and the foundation. And we think that that people should have a portion of their money, invested money and portfolio in all three levels of the financial house. Every level has a different purpose. You know, the roof, money in the roof is to help outpacing inflation. It needs to grow, right? If you're a 30-year-old and you got 30 more years to work, then you probably need to have the bulk of your money in the roof. If you're retired, probably not. You know, you probably need to maybe have 10, 20, maybe even 30% in the roof if you're really don't mind taking a little bit of risk. Um the foundation is more that money that goes there is to preserve the money, right? It's it's um you're taking
12:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
12:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): less risk. You there are investments that aren't in the market, so you can't lose your principal. But you're probably not gonna get a high return um in general on those. However, there are products and investments out there that can't potentially get you a little bit higher return than say um a fixed, a fixed account or something like that. But anyway.
12:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
12:47Brian Roper: I think uh you've you've kind of nailed it. The answer's not gonna going to be the same for everybody. I th I think I was with a brother client last week and we were talking about what percentage of their kind of retirement accounts do they want to set aside to continue to invest versus what they wanted to actually protect. And you know it we s we actually took the percentages off and put the dollar amounts on there.
13:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): And then there were their
13:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): their kind
13:10Brian Roper: of emotions changed. We're like, wait a minute.
13:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
13:12Brian Roper: was thinking twenty 20%
13:13Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): percent of my
13:14Brian Roper: portfolio
13:14Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): and you know,
13:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
13:15Brian Roper: that's that
13:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): might
13:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): be $250,000.
13:17Brian Roper: That that's a different than a percent, right? Because that's m every dollar that I earned in life. Yeah,
13:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that's
13:21Brian Roper: my money that I that I work hard. And so,
13:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
13:24Brian Roper: know, just looking at it differently um yeah can change what how people respond.
13:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, I I would say the thing about that is being you know, I'm in addition to a financial advisor. I've been a small business owner for a lot of years. And one of the things that being a business owner taught me is um it's better to focus on percentages. And uh sometimes that can seem a little counterintuitive, but I tell you, as a business owner, sometimes we have to write some big checks. Big checks to the government and taxes, big checks for expenses. And what you learn in business if is if you're constantly focused on the dollar amount, things can get real emotional. real quick. And so by focusing on the percentages, it helps take out the emotion a little bit and help me um helps me to make some wise decisions without being so focused on the dollar amount.
14:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And I think
14:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): that's the way to do it. That's
14:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): true.
14:16Brian Roper: You can look at it either way and get get a different reaction based on how that goes. But um okay, good stuff. So question number five, last one today. Keep what's one piece of retirement advice you wish everyone over? fifty five understood? What's what's one piece of
14:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): advice
14:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that
14:31Brian Roper: you kind of wish everybody knew?
14:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Okay. So I might be going a little bit different route with this one, but I'm going to mention uh this because I don't think that many people know about it out there. So there's this thing called the rule of fifty five, right? Which basically says that if you retire in the year that you turn fifty five, not even once you're fifty five, but let's say you turn fifty-five in October, um, in January of that ye same year while you're still fifty-four, if you retire, um, you can have access to your deferred retirement funds without paying a penalty to the government. So, you know, normally you can't you don't have access to your money until you're fifty-nine fifty nine and a half and you're in your
15:15Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in
15:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): your deferred IRA uh or your four one K. Um but this rule allows you um to pull money out of your four one K or employ your sponsored plan penalty free. And that that's gonna save you at least ten percent. So one of the main reasons people work until at least fifty nine and a half, or maybe even sixty sixty-two two due to Social Security, is because they don't have access to their money penalty free to be able to kind of bridge the gap uh between retirement and when they can start getting um access to their retirement funds and social security. So uh if you again, by using the rule of fifty five, if you retire in the year that you turn fifty five or later, in between fifty 55 five and fifty 59 nine and a half, you've got penalty penalty-free free access to your money. Yeah, that's good. And I not too many people are familiar with that. It's very good to bring that to their attention. I'm going to go in a different direction. What I would tell you the most important thing is not having a plan. Not having a plan or just waiting too long to
16:17Brian Roper: implement that plan because there's
16:19Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): so many things to consider when it comes to health care expenses, asset management, you know, planning for income when you stop getting the paycheck. Just trying to hope that it works out is not a plan. And so, you know, I would tell I would tell people, anyone over 55, look, let's sit down, let's plan it out. Let's ask some questions, get some tough answers if we have to, so that we can build a financial plan so you can sleep well at night and have retirement clarity. And that's um that is really kind of a good piece to that if you have that. It starts with with creating an a plan that can also always change, right? It doesn't have to be the same plan to 55 that you are at 60 or 65 or even older. Um but waiting and not planning, uh man, that's that's what we want everybody to hear. But hey, listen, great uh great time today with you, Keith. Um I'll tell you what, we got a beautiful weekend in store and looks like weather wise. I hope our listeners out there can enjoy, get out and enjoy uh what we have. Um
17:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
17:13Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): know, to be thankful for uh again, it's Brian and Keith from JL Perkins Wells Management. We can help you or anyone you know reach out to us and connect, and uh we will see you back next time on the podcast. And I think Lee's coming back next time.
17:25Brian Roper: Yep, Lee should be back. We're looking forward to that, and uh we'll see you next time.
17:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Thanks. Hey there,
17:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Lee Perkins here. If you're like a lot of folks, you've been listening to this podcast for a long time now. But I've got an important question for you. Have you implemented any of the ideas that we've discussed on the show? If you haven't, what are you waiting on? You know you're not getting any younger. So here's my challenge: don't just consume the content. Our number one goal for this podcast is to help you close the gap between what you know. and what you implement. So if you're ready to implement, take that first step today and visit www.talkwithjlp.com and schedule a 15-minute phone call with one of our advisors, and we'll help you close the gap between what you know and what you implement so you can enjoy the next phase of your life. Now is your time. Don't procrastinate any longer.
18:24Brian Roper: Investment advisory services are offered. by JL Perkins Wealth Management, a registered investment advisor and insurance agency. Information is for illustrative purposes only and does not constitute tax, legal, or investment advice. Always consult with a qualified tax, legal, or investment professional before taking any action.