Vishal Khandelwal argues investing is 99% behavior, advocating for simplicity, long-term horizons, and stress-testing plans against zero returns.
Summary
Vishal Khandelwal discusses the psychological aspects of investing, asserting that behavior accounts for 99% of success while intellect plays a minor role. He advises investors to stress-test financial plans against scenarios where stocks yield zero returns for a decade, rather than assuming high compound growth. Khandelwal outlines a framework for evaluating businesses based on simplicity, management integrity over a 10-year period, and durable moats, while warning against related-party transactions and high leverage. He recommends a barbell portfolio strategy, annual portfolio reviews to avoid behavioral biases, and a personal philosophy of valuing time and experiences over accumulating arbitrary net worth figures.
Key takeaways
- 1 But there are 60% which I've given out to say a PMS and a couple of mutual funds to manage.
Vishal Khandelwal · 24:13
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 0:44
Market Uncertainty and Retirement Planning
Vishal Khandelwal and host Ivan discuss the unpredictability of markets over any time horizon. They introduce the concept that investors should plan for a scenario where stocks do not rise for a decade, emphasizing that financial plans must survive zero-return periods rather than relying on assumed high compound returns.
- 0:44 – 3:42
Investing Philosophy and Management Track Records
Khandelwal references Peter Lynch's advice to buy businesses an 'idiot can run,' advocating for simplicity. He outlines his checklist for evaluating management, which involves comparing what they said versus what they did over the last 10 years to assess integrity and execution.
- 3:42 – 12:35
Career Journey and the 2008 Financial Crisis
Khandelwal recounts his entry into the stock market in 2003 and his experience on Wall Street during the Lehman Brothers collapse in September 2008. He describes the crisis as a turning point that led him to leave stock recommendation roles to focus on teaching and long-term investing principles.
- 12:35 – 20:44
Behavioral Finance and the Role of AI
The discussion shifts to the psychological aspects of investing, with Khandelwal asserting that investing is 99% behavior and 1% intellect. He argues that AI cannot provide an edge on temperament or fear/greed, and that the only sustainable edge is behavioral discipline and time horizon.
- 20:44 – 23:33
Time Horizons and Asset Allocation
Khandelwal distinguishes between short-term market voting (under 5 years) and long-term weighing (5+ years). He advises that asset allocation must be personalized to the investor's specific financial goals and life stage, rather than following generic rules like '100 minus age'.
- 23:33 – 25:25
Personal Evolution and Delegating Investments
Khandelwal explains his shift towards a more passive approach, managing only 40-45% of his equity portfolio personally while delegating 60% to PMS and mutual funds. He attributes this to changing life priorities and the realization that investing is a personal game that evolves with age.
- 25:25 – 28:15
The Psychology of Money Across Decades
The speakers discuss how the perception of money changes with age: from status and scarcity in one's 20s, to security and freedom in one's 30s, to becoming 'invisible' in one's 40s. Khandelwal critiques the modern fear-mongering around retirement corpus numbers, noting that previous generations lived well with less.
- 28:15 – 35:20
Defining Business Simplicity and Analysis Framework
Vishal Khandelwal argues that while businesses may appear simple (e.g., known brands like Colgate or Nestlé), true understanding requires analyzing the quality of the business, the quality of management, and the valuation. He emphasizes that simplicity means the business does not leave the investor with difficult, unanswerable questions regarding its profit chain and sustainability.
- 35:20 – 39:05
Analyzing Business Quality and Management via Annual Reports
Khandelwal outlines a checklist for analyzing a business by reading at least 10 years of annual reports to assess management's track record, capital allocation efficiency (Return on Incremental Capital), and cash flow sustainability. He stresses comparing the company with its closest competitors to understand opportunity costs and avoiding businesses with high leverage or poor capital allocation.
- 39:05 – 45:19
Red Flags and the Circle of Competence
The speaker identifies related-party transactions, repeated dilution, and bad ethics as 'dark red flags' that warrant immediate avoidance, citing Warren Buffett's principle that anything multiplied by zero is zero. He advises investors to stay within their circle of competence and avoid sectors they do not understand, such as banking or regulated industries, if they cannot answer key questions about them.
- 45:19 – 49:30
Moats, Competition, and Sustainability
Khandelwal defines a moat as a durable competitive advantage, illustrated by Apple's ecosystem, which makes it difficult for customers to leave. He notes that high margins and returns on capital attract competitors (the 'open jar of honey' analogy), causing moats to shrink as returns converge to the cost of capital. Investors must assess the sustainability of this advantage over a 10-year period.
- 49:30 – 51:28
Valuation by Inversion and Reverse DCF
Instead of predicting future target prices, Khandelwal uses a mental model of inversion and a reverse Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) analysis. This method calculates the growth rate in cash flows that the current market capitalization implies. If the implied growth rate is unreasonable based on business analysis, the valuation is deemed unfair, regardless of future price movements.
- 51:28 – 54:46
Position Sizing and the Sleep Test
Position sizing is determined by the 'sleep test' and the investor's conviction. Khandelwal practices equal sizing (e.g., ~6-7% for a 15-stock portfolio) to manage risk, arguing that a smaller position in a steady business may be preferable to a large position in a volatile one. He rejects active position sizing based on perceived risk, favoring a disciplined, equal-weight approach for individual investors.
- 54:46 – 1:22:55
Barbell Portfolio Construction
Vishal Khandelwal describes a barbell strategy allocating 5-10% to high-risk assets and 90-95% to safe, understandable assets like debt or gold. The goal is to beat inflation with the safe portion while accepting potential total loss on the risky portion, adjusted for age and life stage.
Assets discussed
| Asset | Kind | Stance | Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| AppleAAPL | equity | neutral | In today's world, when a company creates such deep water bodies around it, whether by way of building a strong brand name or a strong distribution channel or a very nice product, a great product, like for example, Apple. |
| AmazonAMZN | equity | neutral | I earn as Amazon 0% margin so that a competitor can never enter. |
| Gold | commodity | neutral | it could be a mix of debt and whatever it is, the gold and your total portfolio, but you understand what you are buying, right? |
“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.
Claims worth verifying
The Sensex multiplied by around seven times during the bull market before the 2008 crisis.
Vishal Khandelwal ·0:24
How to verify: Check historical Sensex index data from 2026 to 2026/2026 via NSE India or Bloomberg. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
There were 3 crore DMAT accounts before COVID and 26 crore DMAT accounts currently.
Vishal Khandelwal ·10:58
How to verify: Check NSDL and CDSL annual reports or press releases for account opening statistics for the relevant pre-COVID and current years. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Sensex gave almost zero returns in the last two years.
Vishal Khandelwal ·10:25
How to verify: Calculate the total return index performance of the Nifty 50 or Sensex over the two-year period preceding the podcast release date. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Khalil Gibran wrote a poem stating 'the self is a sea, boundless and measureless'.
Vishal Khandelwal ·7:50
How to verify: Search Khalil Gibran's published works, such as 'The Prophet' or 'Sand and Foam', for the specific quote. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Investing is 99% behavioral and 1% intellectual.
Vishal Khandelwal ·15:10
How to verify: This is a subjective assertion/claim by the speaker; it cannot be factually verified as a universal law but can be tracked as a stated philosophy. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
AI tools are always overconfident and trained on existing models.
Vishal Khandelwal ·17:15
How to verify: Review technical documentation of major LLMs regarding their training data (existing text) and known tendencies for hallucination or overconfidence in outputs. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Khandelwal manages 40-45% of his own equity portfolio personally and delegates 60% to PMS and mutual funds.
Vishal Khandelwal ·1:25
How to verify: This is a personal financial disclosure claim; verification would require access to his personal financial statements or public disclosures if he is a regulated entity. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Benjamin Graham said the market is a voting machine in the short term and a weighing machine in the long run.
Vishal Khandelwal ·21:04
How to verify: Check Benjamin Graham's book 'The Intelligent Investor' for the exact phrasing of this analogy. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Retirement corpus requirements like 10 crore or 40 crore are a modern phenomenon not seen 30 years ago.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·27:44
How to verify: Compare historical inflation data, average income levels, and cost of living indices from 30 years ago versus today to contextualize retirement savings goals. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Lehman Brothers collapse occurred in mid-September, around September 17th.
Vishal Khandelwal ·6:20
How to verify: Check historical financial news archives or SEC filings for the exact date of Lehman Brothers' bankruptcy filing. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourcePeter Lynch said you should buy things you can draw with a crayon and businesses an idiot can run.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·28:42
How to verify: Check Peter Lynch's book 'One Up on Wall Street' for the specific quotes regarding 'crayon' and 'idiot'. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
In India, sectors like farming, banking, and regulated industries are difficult to understand due to terminologies and regulation.
Vishal Khandelwal ·31:33
How to verify: General knowledge of Indian financial sectors; verify complexity by reviewing regulatory frameworks for banking (RBI) and pharma (CDSCO). For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Buffett said anything multiplied by zero is zero.
Ivan ·39:33
How to verify: Check Warren Buffett's shareholder letters for the quote 'anything multiplied by zero is zero'. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Simon Sinek says 'hell yes or no'.
Vishal Khandelwal ·40:19
How to verify: Check Simon Sinek's books or articles for the 'Hell Yes or No' decision-making framework. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Jeff Bezos said 'your margin is my opportunity'.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·47:51
How to verify: Check Amazon's historical shareholder letters or interviews with Jeff Bezos for this quote. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Philip Fisher said a high margin is like an open jar of honey inviting bees.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·48:16
How to verify: Check Philip Fisher's book 'Common Stocks and Uncommon Profits' for the 'open jar of honey' analogy. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Nassim Nicholas Taleb talks about the barbell approach of investing.
Vishal Khandelwal ·54:40
How to verify: Check Nassim Nicholas Taleb's book 'Antifragile' or 'The Black Swan' for the 'barbell strategy'. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Apple is a consumer company, not just a technology company, which contributes to its moat.
Vishal Khandelwal ·46:15
How to verify: Check Apple's business model analysis and investor presentations which emphasize consumer ecosystem and services. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceReturns on capital converge to the cost of capital over time for all companies.
Ivan ·46:51
How to verify: Check economic theory on mean reversion of returns and competitive advantage decay in academic finance literature. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Khandelwal states he sold companies simply because they gave him a 100% return (alpha), remaining anchored to purchase price only in terms of understanding, not holding on for more.
Ivan ·55:49
How to verify: Cross-reference with Vishal Khandelwal's published investment letters or articles on Safal Niveshak's website discussing past sales and performance. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
He claims the only reasons to sell are a broken thesis, management changes, or shrinking moat, explicitly rejecting selling based on stock price or purchase price anchors.
Vishal Khandelwal ·56:14
How to verify: Verify against his published 'Selling Checklist' or educational materials on Safal Niveshak's platform. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
He asserts that risk is measurable (probabilistic) while uncertainty is not, using the analogy of colored balls in a bag.
Vishal Khandelwal ·1:00:37
How to verify: This is a conceptual definition; verify consistency with his published writings on risk vs. uncertainty on his blog or books. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
He mentions the saying 'Haveli Ki Umra Sat Sal' (Palace lifespan is 60 years) regarding wealth destruction across three generations.
Vishal Khandelwal ·1:05:51
How to verify: Verify this is a known Marwari/Gujarati business saying through cultural dictionaries or historical business literature. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
He states Charlie Munger passed away three years prior to the interview (2023).
Vishal Khandelwal ·1:17:53
How to verify: Verify Charlie Munger's death date via public records (he died Nov 28, 2026). Note: The transcript says 'three years' relative to the 2026 interview date, which aligns with 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Vishal Khandelwal has learned to say no to most things in life over the last 15-20 years.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·1:19:49
How to verify: Cross-reference with biographical details on Safal Niveshak website or interviews from 2026-2026 to confirm timeline of behavioral shifts. For recent events, verify 2026-08-10 through 2026-11-10. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify Peter Lynch's quote about buying businesses 'an idiot can run' in his book 'One Up on Wall Street'.
- Cross-reference Vishal Khandelwal's published articles or books on Safal Niveshak for his specific triad of business analysis questions.
- Calculate Return on Incremental Capital (ROIC) for companies mentioned using their annual reports to verify claims about capital allocation efficiency.
- Check Warren Buffett's shareholder letters for the 'zero multiplier' concept regarding related-party transactions.
- Review economic theory on mean reversion of returns to assess the claim that all companies' returns on capital converge to their cost of capital.
- Analyze Apple's business model and ecosystem to verify the claim that its moat stems from consumer lock-in rather than just technology.
- Compare annual reports of competitors to understand opportunity costs, as recommended for assessing if a target company is the best in its sector.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:00
- Vishal Khandelwal: Every past market crisis looks like an opportunity and every future market crisis looks like a risk. Nobody has any idea what's going to happen with markets or anything in the next 10 years. Forget next 10 years, next five years, next one month, next one day.
- 0:12
- Ivan: What if stocks simply don't go up for a decade?
- 0:14
- Vishal Khandelwal: Your life depends on you earning a 20% compound return for the next 10 years. They need to rethink.
- 0:20
- Ivan: What was happening? Uh exactly, what were your emotions like? The
- 0:24
- Vishal Khandelwal: Sensex multiplied by around seven times when they and were stock. there were stocks which had multiplied by much bigger numbers, much higher numbers. People with the highest IQ working on Wall Street are the guys who actually lay the seeds of the future crash or future market crisis. People are throwing numbers like 10 crore to retire or 15 crore to retire or 40 crore to retire. It never happened 30 years back. Your kids are not going to be worried whether you have a 5
- 0:44
- Vishal Khandelwal: BHK or a 6 BHK when you are 60 years of age. You're saying India is a micro cap. Of course it's a micro cap. But do you have the competency to go and understand global investing? If not, stay here. Peter Lynch said that you should buy things that you can draw with a crayon. Buy businesses that an idiot can run because in the future an idiot is going to probably run it.
- 1:03
- Ivan: Can you take us from the stage of deciding whether this business deserves your money and what is your checklist?
- 1:10
- Vishal Khandelwal: Every person, every management leads leaves footsteps. What they said versus what they did was over last the 10. years is very important for me to understand.
- 1:17
- Ivan: What is the selling checklist?
- 1:20
- Vishal Khandelwal: It's always the case.
- 1:21
- Ivan: One thing you would never do with your money.
- 1:24
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 1:25
- Vishal Khandelwal: still manage around 40-45% of my own equity portfolio on my own in terms of stocks. But there are 60% which I've given out to say a PMS and a couple of mutual funds to manage. The day you make investing your job.
- 1:42
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): When
- 1:42
- Ivan: Vishhal Khanderwal was young, he watched his father lose money in the stock market and decided that the market was a place where wealth goes to die, not where it gets built. So, how does someone go from that to spending the next 20 years teaching hundreds and thousands of investors how to build wealth in that very same market? His answer has almost
- 2:03
- Ivan: nothing to do with intelligence. It's about what he calls the long game. The idea that how you respond to your mistakes matters more than the mistakes themselves. But most crashes are not just a market problem, they are a mirror. They show you exactly where your humility runs out. And there's an idea, Oh and there's an old idea that he
- 2:23
- Ivan: keeps coming back to: fall seven times, rise eight. Not just recovering to where you were, but coming back stronger than before. So in this conversation, we talk about fear, patience, the marshmallow test for money, why a business that is boring enough for an idiot to run might just be the smartest bet you'll ever
- 2:42
- Ivan: make. Let's get straight to it. Thank you so much, Vishhal, Vishal, for coming here and being with us for this podcast. I'm really looking forward to this episode. And I know that you're very conscious about media engagement. So I really appreciate you coming by for this recording.
- 2:57
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Thanks,
- 2:57
- Vishal Khandelwal: Ivan. Uh and I think uh I've seen uh a f a few episodes of your podcast. You're doing a great job. And I've seen a lot of esteemed guests on your podcast as well. So thank you for this honor of inviting me on this session. Thank you.
- 3:09
- Ivan: Oh my god, you know, this one endeavor that we have is to empower investors, and I couldn't think of a more fitting guest to actually do that. And I hope that we're going to glean out as much uh gyn from you uh as we can. And it's interesting because we were just talking a while ago about uh how your sort of the your journey in
- 3:29
- Ivan: the markets, it's been very serendipitous. Can you tell us a little bit more about that? Because you experienced your father losing money. What kind of an impact did that have on you? And what was your initial assessment of the stock market and how has that changed?
- 3:42
- Vishal Khandelwal: So I think uh when my father was losing money, I only have vague uh uh memories of that. I was too young at that point. In 1991, I was just thirteen years of age. And uh 2000, of course, I was a bit grown up, but I had n no idea about where I wanted to go in life. Like all teenagers, all young adults, they have no idea. Only in hindsight, as I think Steve Jobs said, that you can connect your
- 4:02
- Vishal Khandelwal: dots. In foresight, there's no way. So when I look back at my 18, uh, 16-year-old self, I had no way of knowing where my future was going to take me. And coming from a small town, uh, except knowing the stock market was like a casino where you go to lose your money. It was like a trading den where big people make money. This is what I had heard uh in my house
- 4:22
- Vishal Khandelwal: and people around me, the grown-ups grown ups who were trading in stock markets at that point of time. I had no really interest or no idea about that I wanted to get into the career of stock market. I came to Bombay to do my MBA and MBA in finance, and I wanted to get into the foreign exchange market, and I actually studied on my own the nuances of foreign exchange, all those kinds
- 4:42
- Vishal Khandelwal: of things. We were in 2003 when I was passing out of my MBA and the only job, the single job that came my way,
- 4:52
- Vishal Khandelwal: and India was recovering from the aftermath of the dot-com uh bubble that had burst in 2000. And uh uh the Sensex was at at a almost a low at that point of time. So there were not really much jobs available uh for finance students at that point of time. And the only job that came my way was that of being a stock market analyst.
- 5:12
- Vishal Khandelwal: I had no clue what that job entailed. I took it because I'd promised my 2B wife that we would get married only after I got a job. There's no way. So again, there was a lot of serendipity, and I thank her to this day that uh it was that promise that really led me to take up the first job. And the first job that was of being a research analyst, which
- 5:32
- Vishal Khandelwal: led me to so many wonderful things in life for the last 20, twenty, 21, twenty-one, 23 twenty-three years. So s complete serendipity, I would
- 5:40
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): say.
- 5:40
- Ivan: You
- 5:40
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
- 5:40
- Ivan: it's interesting that sometimes doing something makes you realize what you don't want to do in life, and I
- 5:45
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): guess
- 5:45
- Ivan: you had that moment. Can you tell me a little bit more about the day of 2008? We were just talking about that where you were actually in the States and you were close to the the Lehman building and you're saying the fear was palpable. What was happening? Uh exactly, what were your emotions like?
- 6:00
- Vishal Khandelwal: So I uh 2003 I joined. Uh 2008, first five years, India saw one of the best bull markets that we've ever seen. The Sensex multiplied by around seven times, and there were stocks which had multiplied by much bigger numbers, much higher numbers. So I I had gone to the US on a on a office work, on an office project. Uh uh and uh
- 6:20
- Vishal Khandelwal: on the day Lehman bent burst, uh, I think it was mid-September, 17 17th September, something like that, I I was right. on Wall Street, very close to Lehman's building. And I could see the panic in the news, and they had giant screens that some at some places, and we could hear of things actually crashing. Though the crisis had already started, being in the industry, I knew that there were some issues
- 6:40
- Vishal Khandelwal: which were bubbling up, right? But seeing the panic upfront, up close, I think gives you a different sense of how the actual things are happening on ground.
- 6:52
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 6:53
- Vishal Khandelwal: as I mentioned the crisis already started a few months back, and uh I was sort of disillusioned by what was happening around me. Again, it was not true for everyone who was working in the financial market, but the kind of person I was and I am, um, I thought this is not where I want to make my career or or I want to work long term,
- 7:12
- Vishal Khandelwal: right? Uh I was recommending stocks for a living. Uh again, uh working for an independent research company, we were recommending stocks for the long term. So I had got a good grounding, right? So I would not say I started with a trading mindset and a speculative
- 7:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): mindset and
- 7:26
- Vishal Khandelwal: that moved to investing. No, I was lucky that I got into the investing mindset, got into Buffett and Munger even before the crisis came in. But uh that crisis uh actually led me to believe that this is not something which I wanted to do for the rest of my life. And that was actually a turning point for me. So the world was
- 7:45
- Vishal Khandelwal: going underground, and I think it was also a lot of my aspirations
- 7:50
- Vishal Khandelwal: where I was changing a lot inside. So I still remember there's this beautiful poem on self by a famous author called Khalil Gibran, where he says the self is a sea, boundless and measureless. Right. And I came across that poem. I did not really understand much of that. I understand probably slightly better at this point of
- 8:10
- Vishal Khandelwal: time. But
- 8:12
- Vishal Khandelwal: life happens, right? And if you it's very important for us to accept things that are happening around us and inside of us, and to take a call which really tells us that this is what we want to do in life. Of course, as I said, there's a lot of serendipity.
- 8:27
- Vishal Khandelwal: But the point is that I find myself lucky that I took that call of leaving the financial industry as far as writing about stocks and recommending stocks is concerned, because that is not where I was getting joy. And more about teaching people than trying to tell them that this is how you avoid losing money. So
- 8:47
- Vishal Khandelwal: and again, uh investing is just the front. I want to teach the world how to live a good life and not really trying to be as a role model, but in terms of whatever I've learned, little learned in life, I see my 20 year old struggling with all those questions, existential questions, and that is all I am trying to solve for the past 15 years for
- 9:07
- Vishal Khandelwal: myself and in a way for anyone who's willing to listen to me.
- 9:12
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 9:12
- Ivan: as you said on record as well that you know being a teacher teaches you so much about your own behavior and it's such a big learning for yourself. Speaking of learnings, uh, you know, you've been talking about the uh the way of investing, telling investors to think long term. But you know, you put out a c uncomfortable piece just a short while ago saying,
- 9:32
- Ivan: what if stocks simply don't go up for a decade?
- 9:35
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now
- 9:35
- Ivan: on an average investor reading, that that is uh, you know. sort of very panic-inducing. So I just want to understand a little bit about what exactly that piece means.
- 9:45
- Vishal Khandelwal: So if you look at what has happened in the last four years, or I not just four years, ever since 2008, we've never we've not had a major crisis, crisis, which which really leads a lot of people to question what they are doing in the stock markets. We have situations we have from the 2008. financial bust, right, where the markets
- 10:05
- Vishal Khandelwal: corrected by what 50-60% and things were looking bleak for almost 15 months. We have had short crises and short crashes, right? But not a major, major crisis where people start questioning the very act of being in the stock market. If you look at the last two years, when nothing has moved and the Sensex probably has given almost zero returns, and a lot of stocks have not given
- 10:25
- Vishal Khandelwal: returns. Of course, there have been pockets which have given returns. I'm sure you see a lot of people even questioning now when nothing bad really has happened.
- 10:34
- Vishal Khandelwal: You're
- 10:35
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): saying since
- 10:35
- Ivan: COVID? No,
- 10:36
- Vishal Khandelwal: no, I'm talking about the last two years where the markets
- 10:37
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): have not really moved, the
- 10:38
- Vishal Khandelwal: broader markets have not really moved. But if you look at the last five years, where most of the people who are investing in stock markets have come in, uh I I I if I have the numbers right, before COVID, we had three crore D max. DMAT accounts, now we have 26 crore DMAT accounts. Now see so many young people who've come to the markets, we've not seen what a
- 10:58
- Vishal Khandelwal: bad market can look like. And we've had long periods of, I would not say zero return, but frustrating periods. Like if you look at people buying at the heights of uh hardship Hardshare meta crisis for the next 10 years was zero return for the markets. Of course, a lot of people made a lot of money. A lot of different countries have gone through long phases. So,
- 11:18
- Vishal Khandelwal: my intent with that episode of video on my podcast was not to really create panic, but to tell to every investor to think in terms of what-ifs. Right? If you have seen only good returns, it's very important to understand that even if the market does not crash, but if your life depends on you
- 11:38
- Vishal Khandelwal: earning a 20%.
- 11:39
- Vishal Khandelwal: compounded return for the next 10 years, then you need to rethink. Because I again I don't want to predict a period of low returns in the future. But for an from an individual investor's point of view, if your financial life depends on you earning 10% return, your financial goals depend on you earning 20% for the next 10 years, like it has happened for the past few years, I think you need to
- 11:59
- Vishal Khandelwal: make a rethink. So when I say expect 0% return, I'm saying you expect 0% return, you put that in your Excel sheet and say if your life will still be sorted 10 years down the line. If that is the case, you're fine. Otherwise, you need to rethink.
- 12:12
- Ivan: Okay, that's very important. And you know, part of the other principles that you've advocated
- 12:18
- Ivan: in the long game, congratulations on the book as well, is that how you react to your mistakes matters more than the mistakes themselves. Give me some examples, maybe, if you can, in real life as to when you know how you reacted to the mistake made so much more of a difference.
- 12:35
- Vishal Khandelwal: I think uh that reaction is completely in I think uh as I as we were talking earlier as well, there's something called as dichotomy of control. There's so many things in life that we don't control, and there are very few things in life that we control. And one of the things that we control in our lives is how we react to situations, right? So it's very easy on paper to teach someone or for someone to understand: okay, when the
- 12:55
- Vishal Khandelwal: market crashes 50%, this is how you react, you buy
- 12:57
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): more
- 12:58
- Vishal Khandelwal: because things are getting cheaper. But when you actually see that with your money, it's so difficult to do that. 2020, a lot of people uh uh luckily for me, that was not the first major crash. 2008 happened, and I had learned a lot of lessons, only to repeat some of them in 2020. But for 2020, when if it's your first major crash, right, uh, and you're seeing your
- 13:18
- Vishal Khandelwal: money disappearing 50%, 60% overnight, it's very difficult to practice what you have learned all this while. As I think someone said that every past market crisis looks like an opportunity, and every future market crisis looks like a risk.
- 13:33
- Ivan: Yeah.
- 13:34
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): How
- 13:34
- Vishal Khandelwal: can that be possible? Because in the past we all have a 2020 perfect vision. I I knew market. was going to crash. I wish I could have bought stocks. But when that thing actually happens,
- 13:44
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 13:44
- Vishal Khandelwal: think it's your reaction that really matters. So for me, 2020 was again a major lesson. I had deployed almost 50% of my available surplus. But again, as you as I said, you still need to relearn a lot of lessons. I still was waiting for the markets to fall further. Even when
- 14:01
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): they had already
- 14:02
- Vishal Khandelwal: corrected 50%. that was a
- 14:03
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): good
- 14:03
- Vishal Khandelwal: time for me to put 100% on my surplus money. But I waited 50% and waited and waited and waited.
- 14:09
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Did
- 14:10
- Vishal Khandelwal: not happen.
- 14:10
- Ivan: Okay. Yeah. So that's an important lesson with the way you actually reacted to.
- 14:15
- Vishal Khandelwal: Yes, yes. I think uh uh uh this uh there's this wonderful book called uh uh Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance by Robert Persig. And he says, How do you learn to become a how do you make how do you make a perfect painting? And he says, it's simple. You become perfect and then paint naturally.
- 14:35
- Vishal Khandelwal: Right? So the markets,
- 14:38
- Vishal Khandelwal: the tools, AI, for example, these are all like canvases and brushes that we have. And now we have more brushes and more paints and everything. Oh
- 14:47
- Ivan: boy, don't we?
- 14:48
- Vishal Khandelwal: But you, as an investor, are the painter.
- 14:49
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay.
- 14:50
- Ivan: The
- 14:50
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): brushes
- 14:50
- Vishal Khandelwal: are only going to help you if you are sane, if you are sound, if you know what to paint, if you know how to paint. Right? So you have to take care of that inner being much more than worrying about the tools in front of you. And as I was as we were also discussing, investing is a 99% behavioral
- 15:10
- Vishal Khandelwal: business and only 1% intellectual business, right? And all people may say, okay, on the in the comments, I'm sure that this is not the case. Uh you're saying that everything is behavior. No, it doesn't happen that way. But if you look at the history of stock markets, it's the same behavior or misbehavior repeating again and again and again. People have been skillful, right? People with the highest
- 15:30
- Vishal Khandelwal: IQ working on Wall Street, people with the highest IQ who are working, or those people are the guys who actually lay the seeds of the future crash or future market crisis. So it's behavior. and you need to mind your own behavior and you to behave well. I think that's a that's a thing that takes a lifetime.
- 15:45
- Ivan: It absolutely does. So when you say behave well, can you just tell us a little bit more? Do you have certain principles in mind that you adopt that you think would make the checklist if someone who's watching right now wants to learn?
- 15:57
- Vishal Khandelwal: The thing about behavior is that you have to go through bad behavior yourself
- 16:00
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
- 16:00
- Vishal Khandelwal: understand what not to do. To
- 16:01
- Ivan: actually accept explain. it.
- 16:02
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): As I
- 16:02
- Vishal Khandelwal: said, it's very difficult to handle, hand someone a checklist
- 16:05
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of this
- 16:05
- Vishal Khandelwal: is something that and this is something which I have also changed my mind over the last few years. If you would had asked me this question ten years back, I would say if I know the bad behaviors, I will become a good investor
- 16:15
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): because
- 16:16
- Vishal Khandelwal: I know what not to do. But seeing market cycles, seeing the behavior of other people, seeing my own behavior uh and still learning, I understand that you have to go through those bad market periods which are probably the training grounds for you to behave better. I will not say perfectly, but better in the future. So in terms of I think some bad behaviors
- 16:35
- Vishal Khandelwal: that have shown up in my own investing and also I see across around, I think one of the most uh probably one of the worst behaviors that people uh display in markets is that of overconfidence. Right? And that has just magnified over a period of time. right? Now, overconfidence, if you look at today's world and people talk about AI
- 16:55
- Vishal Khandelwal: and technology tools, which are going to help us become better investors and do all the analysis at the click of a button, this is just added to the overconfidence of people because AI is always overconfident. If you just ask a few questions to artificial intelligence tools that are around, you are going to get perfect answers, right? So your skill in
- 17:15
- Vishal Khandelwal: today's world is not to train your brain to become a better collector of information because everyone can do that, or a better user of AI, because everyone can do that. Your skill in today's world is to ask better questions. Right? Because everyone is
- 17:35
- Vishal Khandelwal: asking the first 20 questions. Can you ask the 21st? question?
- 17:39
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right?
- 17:40
- Vishal Khandelwal: And what kind of questions that you are fine living with without searching for answers? Because as I mentioned, the answers, the best answers, come when they have to come. And AI is trained on existing models. They are trained on what someone else has already thought. Now, if you are living your life and making your a decision based on what the
- 18:00
- Vishal Khandelwal: answers which are ready made in front of you, you stop. thinking. First, people stop reading, then they stop thinking, and they're dedicating everything to technology and everything. I'm not really sure whether it's going to help you become a better investor.
- 18:14
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 18:15
- Ivan: paint the picture for us then for someone who is living in in the world of AI who is asking those questions on a daily basis, perhaps not asking maybe the better question, but asking those questions. not reading that much, what what does it uh look like for the investor? Is I are you foreseeing a bleak?
- 18:33
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): No, I think
- 18:34
- Vishal Khandelwal: I I am I am an eternal optimist, and that's the reason I am investing in stock markets. You have to be an optimist over there. I would say realist. Okay. Right? So uh uh to each a zone, I have always looking I've always looked at investing from a survival point of view. Right? So uh even when I'm I am looking at AI I have maintained that
- 18:54
- Vishal Khandelwal: always right uh uh you in today's world you cannot have
- 18:59
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): any
- 18:59
- Vishal Khandelwal: edge on the information side everyone has the same information right you cannot have any edge on the analysis side tools can analyze better than you I'm talking about most investors right the only edge is your time horizon
- 19:13
- Ivan: okay right
- 19:14
- Vishal Khandelwal: the only edge is how do you behave when others are misbehaving.
- 19:19
- Vishal Khandelwal: Now AI cannot tell you the amount of fear that you feel when the markets are crashing, right? Or the amount of greed that you feel when the markets are surging. Those answers need to come from you. So behavior is the only edge. So I don't see a bleak future. I see people have uh humanity. has seen an increase
- 19:39
- Vishal Khandelwal: in IQ, and I'm also seeing very smart younger generation which is coming up.
- 19:44
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
- 19:45
- Vishal Khandelwal: they only need to be guided well. The problem that we have in today's world is a lot of
- 19:51
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): not
- 19:51
- Vishal Khandelwal: the right kind of guidance, I would say a lot of noise all
- 19:54
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): around. A
- 19:55
- Vishal Khandelwal: lot of what is called as FOMO, fear of missing out. Right? Most of the mistakes that we made in life and investing is is guided by the fear of missing out on things. Whether it's investing or living a good life or choosing the right kind of career, it's all FOMO. If you can handle that well, and I as I said, being human, you cannot really eliminate that. If
- 20:15
- Vishal Khandelwal: you can handle
- 20:15
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that
- 20:16
- Vishal Khandelwal: fear well, I think you'll have you'll you'll live a good life and become a good investor.
- 20:22
- Ivan: And that is so critical, especially in the times that we live in. But um let's understand a little bit more about the uh the the time frame that you've spoken about, because a lot of market gurus preach investing long term, but you've been quite specific about it in terms of the definition, five years being the absolute minimum, et cetera. Can you tell us why
- 20:42
- Ivan: those numbers are important?
- 20:44
- Vishal Khandelwal: Long time back when I was starting to invest and reading more about Buffett and Mungar, Munger, I also read about a person called Benjamin Graham. And Benjamin Graham, he's called the father of value investing. He said, in the short term, the market is a voting machine, and we all vote through our emotions, right? In the long run, it's a weighing machine. Now, if you stand on a weighing scale, you cannot say,
- 21:04
- Vishal Khandelwal: show me five kg is less. It'll show you exactly what is the weight, right? In the same way, when I say in the long term the market is a weighing machine, in that case, the market
- 21:14
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): gives
- 21:15
- Vishal Khandelwal: the weight to a company's business or valuations or the wealth that someone can create out of that business, depending on how the business, the underlying business is. In the short term, which is five years or less, nothing happens. It's largely, I would say, a fancy trust competition where the best-looking person or the best-looking
- 21:33
- Vishal Khandelwal: stock in the sense or the most talked-about stock really wins, right? Of course, there are winners otherwise as well. But the longer you play this game, and to each, again, as I said, for someone whose financial goal is coming up in the next five years, I would not say in think about 20 years. You need to think about five years. But then your asset allocation has to be in
- 21:53
- Vishal Khandelwal: line with what those five years are going to happen, right? It i in in terms of five years asset allocation. For someone who has a long-term horizon, which is 20 years, your asset allocation will be much more different. And I would rather say you'll have much more equities in your portfolio, or you should have much more equities in your portfolio because the probability of making returns to meet your financial goals, the longer the horizon, the better it
- 22:13
- Vishal Khandelwal: is. Right? So investing is a very personal game, right? There's no, there are written checklists, written rules, written rules of asset allocation. People talk about 80, 80-20, 20, depending on your age, 100 minus age, all this, all this is fine. right? But if you remove the personal out of finance, nothing remains. What we are seeing in the world of YouTube
- 22:33
- Vishal Khandelwal: and in the world of uh media and and all around now, even if I make all the so-called expert, though I detest calling myself a guru, so we'll remove that word guru. There's no guru out here. We all students of markets and students of life. So I think uh it's very important to play that investing game as a very personal game.
- 22:53
- Vishal Khandelwal: And that's the reason I
- 22:56
- Vishal Khandelwal: though I teach investing, I also tell people that you
- 23:01
- Vishal Khandelwal: my job is not to teach 100 people out there. Maybe one or two are going to relate to what I teach. And if they are able to make a better decision, because they're able to relate that, because for them, this is the exact life stage that they are, and in, this is how they view money.
- 23:15
- Vishal Khandelwal: right? That is where my job is done.
- 23:19
- Ivan: Yeah.
- 23:19
- Vishal Khandelwal: Right? So
- 23:21
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah.
- 23:21
- Ivan: Okay, so it's not for everyone, and you're saying that it's a very personal game, and there are select people who will relate to your investment philosophy. And if that one person changes their mind or adopts your philosophy, then that's it.
- 23:33
- Vishal Khandelwal: That is true.
- 23:33
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And I
- 23:34
- Vishal Khandelwal: and not just from me as a giver of information and ideas, but also from someone me as a taker. of information and ideas. Now I cannot blindly copy, say, what Warren Buffett did and Charlie Munger did or Howard Marks did or Monish Pabra did or Manish Yokani did, and I need to copy that. Right? I have to listen to them. I have to suit their investing principles
- 23:54
- Vishal Khandelwal: and see if that works for me or not. Now I have talked about, I think, in a previous podcast and also on my platform as well, that over a period of time I've I have gotten more and more. passive as far as my investing is concerned. And passive does not here mean index funds, but more and more towards delegating investing to people whom I think are much more
- 24:13
- Vishal Khandelwal: better suited to manage a part of my money. It doesn't mean that I have moved towards 100% non-equities. I still manage around 40-45% of my own uh uh equity portfolio on my own in terms of stocks. But there are 60% which I've given out to say a PMS and a couple of mutual funds to manage. Again, how?
- 24:33
- Vishal Khandelwal: Why? Because my life stage has changed. My way of looking at markets have changed. My priorities in life have changed. What brings me greater joy has changed over a period of time. And you need to just move in life again towards things that give you the greatest amount of joy. 20 Twenty years back, it was picking stocks. Twenty years later, it is not picking
- 24:53
- Vishal Khandelwal: stocks. It's very personal. Right? So the thing about giving general idea of the general checklist, and this is something which I have also come to believe over years, is that I do not want to give a general checklist or a general way of behavior because uh we can always lay down the principles, but it's very
- 25:13
- Vishal Khandelwal: important for the investor. the listener, to take as per their own life situation. Just to give one more example of, and it's a very critical thing, uh the idea of money.
- 25:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
- 25:25
- Vishal Khandelwal: We all talk about money as financial freedom and how do you look at money? And as a 40, 45-year-old, I want to give advice to a 20-year-old while that person has is a different life situation altogether.
- 25:36
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): When
- 25:36
- Vishal Khandelwal: I was twenty, or when someone is twenty. how do you look at money? You look at money from the point of view of scarcity and status.
- 25:43
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 25:43
- Vishal Khandelwal: I go back and look at my own twenties and I think that way. When I was in my twenties, money meant status and security. Yeah. I wanted to, I was just starting out in my life and all those kind of things. Moving into my 30s, I have to build a certain kind of investments, right? S certain kind of skills around money and had having some money in my bank account and investment. investments,
- 26:03
- Vishal Khandelwal: right? It moves from status to security and freedom. Because now there that is the phase where money starts working for me. Right? Maybe meet meeting some of my financial goals in my 30s, or for for me, for example, the idea of quitting my job to start something on my own happened in my 30s.
- 26:22
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): When
- 26:23
- Vishal Khandelwal: you move to your thirty third forties, 40s,
- 26:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 26:25
- Vishal Khandelwal: should reach a phase where money becomes invisible in your
- 26:28
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): life. Where
- 26:29
- Vishal Khandelwal: you stop worrying about money.
- 26:31
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 26:31
- Vishal Khandelwal: save as much as possible, invest as much as possible. Do it diligently, whether do it on your own or you hire someone else, but take very good care of your money when you're 20s and 30s. Don't say I am too young, 80-20, I will play with risk and play with fire. It's very important to say I can take risk and actually, as I say,
- 26:51
- Vishal Khandelwal: as we were discussing, right? Knowing something versus understanding something
- 26:58
- Ivan: are
- 26:58
- Vishal Khandelwal: completely different.
- 26:59
- Ivan: Completely different.
- 27:00
- Vishal Khandelwal: We are living in a world which is full of vocabulary. Everyone knows the words of things.
- 27:05
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
- 27:06
- Vishal Khandelwal: the question is, how many people actually take the time to think, reflect, and understand things? thing.
- 27:11
- Ivan: Yeah.
- 27:13
- Ivan: Especially at this time. of information overload. I'm entering my era where now money has to become invisible to me. So fingers crossed, I can do that. And
- 27:22
- Vishal Khandelwal: when I say invisible, you still need money to live
- 27:23
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in the world.
- 27:25
- Vishal Khandelwal: But it's you you reach a stage where you stop worrying about your money.
- 27:28
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 27:28
- Vishal Khandelwal: it doesn't it it it happens at any any kind of network that you have.
- 27:32
- Ivan: Yeah.
- 27:32
- Vishal Khandelwal: Right? Again, uh the point that we're we are seeing uh uh again a lot of uh noise and news all around where people are throwing numbers like 10 crore to retire or 15 crore to retire or 40 crore to retire. It never happened 30 years back.
- 27:44
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 27:45
- Vishal Khandelwal: our parents and grandparents still gave us a good life.
- 27:48
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So,
- 27:48
- Vishal Khandelwal: why is there so much scare fear-mongering, so much scare which is spread around in today's world? What has changed? The life life of an individual, an average individual, has become better.
- 27:59
- Ivan: Yes,
- 27:59
- Vishal Khandelwal: but the fear has also increased.
- 28:01
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Why is
- 28:02
- Vishal Khandelwal: there so much fear in
- 28:02
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the world?
- 28:02
- Vishal Khandelwal: and insecurity all around? Who's talking about that? We need to talk about that. But the problem, the more you talk about that, people want to bring it back to you and say, no, tell me how to make get rich fast.
- 28:15
- Ivan: Yeah, especially in this world where we're comparing ourselves every second of every minute to the person who's doing something better than us, and that's something I'll come down to as well. But let's talk about how you know analyzing a bit. business, and you've stressed multiple times on the factor of simplicity, uh, which comes down to three things. Can you elaborate those three
- 28:35
- Ivan: things for us and give us an example, maybe, of a business that looks incredibly simple but maybe is not well understood?
- 28:42
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 28:42
- Vishal Khandelwal: I think, yeah, so this is the lesson Listen again, uh uh how views have changed as you gain experience. Uh Peter Lynch, the final fund manager in the US legendary money manager, he said that you should buy things that you can draw with a crayon.
- 28:57
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 28:57
- Vishal Khandelwal: it should be as simple. And he also said that buy businesses that an idiot can run because in the future an idiot is going to probably run it. It has to be so simple that nobody can come and disturb the business. So the idea of simplicity. And even Warren Buffett has said multiple times that you need to buy businesses in your circle of competence. Things that you understand, they are very simple, and he's given through his own examples of buying very, very simple
- 29:17
- Vishal Khandelwal: businesses as per his own understanding. And we've taken that idea literally to say, instead of buying simple businesses, we say buy businesses whose brands name, brand names you know, for example, in India. So by Colgate, by HVL, by Nestlé, by ITC, by Asian Pain, Spiddlite, all those kind
- 29:32
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of
- 29:32
- Vishal Khandelwal: things, which is a good idea, perfectly fine. But the point is thinking a business is simple and actually understanding.
- 29:40
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what
- 29:40
- Vishal Khandelwal: the business is all about are two different things. When I talk about understanding a business, the broader three things which I need to understand as an investor is the quality of the business, the most important thing. The quality of the management, the second most important thing. And only after these first two are tick ticked mark, yes, then
- 30:00
- Vishal Khandelwal: the quality of valuation or the valuation at which I am buying or I'm looking to buy this business at. So three things have to fit, have to be ticked mark yes for me to actually bring that stock or a business in my portfolio. I'll talk about the first, which is the quality of the business. Now for that, knowing what products they sell, knowing the
- 30:20
- Vishal Khandelwal: brand name is not enough. Right? As I say, investing is simple but not easy. Simple is knowing the brand name and knowing that the business has survived for the past 20, 30 years. Okay, perfectly fine. But we are investing today for the next 20 years. So you need to answer where do the cash flows of the business. Can you answer if you want to say that I understand the business?
- 30:40
- Vishal Khandelwal: The first thing, where does the profit and cash flows of the business come in? Can you draw the entire chain of how the profits actually come in, cash flows of the business come in?
- 30:51
- Vishal Khandelwal: Second thing is how sustainable are those cash flows? Can you I'm not asking you to predict the future, but can you visualize based on your understanding of the business or economics of the business or the industry landscape, how sustainable are the cash flows in the future and whether a competitor can come and disrupt Disrupted. it?
- 31:10
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 31:10
- Vishal Khandelwal: the third most important thing is what can break it.
- 31:13
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): What
- 31:13
- Vishal Khandelwal: are the other factors that can break? the chain of cash flows and profits for the company? Now, if you ask, and I do all my sessions when I do my sessions, when I ask these kind of questions, and everyone owns stocks, everyone who owns businesses across sectors. There are certain sectors which are specifically difficult to understand. In India, for example, if you've
- 31:33
- Vishal Khandelwal: looked at the farmer sector or the banking and financial sector or the regulated sector, which is slightly difficult to understand. because of terminologies and regulation,
- 31:41
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): all those kind of things.
- 31:42
- Vishal Khandelwal: But everyone owns these kinds of stocks in their portfolio.
- 31:45
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The next
- 31:46
- Vishal Khandelwal: question, when you ask, do you understand the profit chain, the profit pool, the industry analysis, the competition, the risks to the business? A lot of hands go down because people don't move to the second round. Right? So a lot of business that looks simple on the face of it
- 32:01
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): may
- 32:01
- Vishal Khandelwal: look difficult when you start. to ask questions. Right? And that goes to the same idea in today's world, the differentiating advantages can you ask better questions?
- 32:11
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 32:11
- Vishal Khandelwal: when I say simple business, those are the business I'll call simple, which don't leave you with a lot of difficult questions to answer.
- 32:19
- Vishal Khandelwal: Promoters are pledging what will happen, the company is taking on a lot of debt, what is going to happen, right? The company's working capital situation is the a bit tricky. What is going to happen? The company is spending a lot of money to keep on building capacities, but the profits are not coming. What is going to happen? Right? The company is in a regulated market. What is going to happen? The company's raw materials are sourced internationally.
- 32:39
- Vishal Khandelwal: It depends on one supply of raw material. What's going to happen? Now, for again, if for an individual investor like me, these are very difficult questions to answer.
- 32:48
- Ivan: Yeah.
- 32:48
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 32:48
- Vishal Khandelwal: I'll rather instantly close the annual report and move to something where I don't need to answer a lot of these questions, maybe different questions, but not a lot of these questions. And those are the kind of business I would want to bring in my portfolio. Now, for someone who understands pharmaceutical value chain, for someone who understands banking finance, entire value chain, how the business is run, the regulations, the regulatory
- 33:08
- Vishal Khandelwal: requirements, It's perfectly fine, go and invest. But the first step of being a good investor is the idea of human. humility. And from humility comes the idea of circle of competence, which means you need to remain inside your competence. Right? Like we do in life. Right? Now, as Buffett has also said, the size of the
- 33:28
- Vishal Khandelwal: circle does not matter. What matters is that you do not cross the edges.
- 33:33
- Ivan: Yeah.
- 33:33
- Vishal Khandelwal: Over a period of time, you learn more and you enhance the size of the circle, you understand about more industries, you understand. about more businesses, you understand how to analyze a business better. Right? But before you do that, don't go and invest just because someone else is making money over there. Comparison.
- 33:50
- Ivan: Yeah.
- 33:51
- Vishal Khandelwal: Right? So a lot of these problems are going to get sorted when we actually stop to think about what exactly investing is all about.
- 33:59
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right?
- 33:59
- Vishal Khandelwal: So the first step of doing anything is to understand the definition of the key terms. We can throw out long term. What do you mean by long term? You can throw about investing. What do you mean by long-term investing? We we talked about investing is not about buying stocks, but about owning businesses. Now, two things. What is ownership?
- 34:19
- Vishal Khandelwal: What do you mean by businesses?
- 34:21
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right?
- 34:22
- Vishal Khandelwal: A lot of people don't think in terms of ownership. A lot of people, most people don't think in terms of businesses. they think in terms of stock tickers.
- 34:28
- Ivan: Yes.
- 34:29
- Vishal Khandelwal: People want to get rich because the stock is going to multiply. And this is how the language, the vocabulary is there in across, all around us. Amidst this, how do we actually slow down to think about businesses and ownership?
- 34:43
- Ivan: Yes. That
- 34:43
- Vishal Khandelwal: is what real investing is all about. Not everyone should do that, not everyone would do that, but that is how I do that.
- 34:49
- Ivan: Yeah.
- 34:51
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 34:51
- Ivan: think the the line that really stuck with me right now is that a simple business doesn't leave any difficult questions to answer. Doesn't
- 34:58
- Vishal Khandelwal: leave many difficult questions
- 34:59
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
- 35:00
- Vishal Khandelwal: answer. Yes.
- 35:00
- Ivan: Yeah. Okay. Um so if we were to do this practically, Vishal, if I were to say, give you an annual report of a company, if let's say that's the first uh you know parameter we'd look at, can you take us from the stage of deciding whether this business deserves your money and what goes what is your checklist?
- 35:20
- Vishal Khandelwal: Okay. So we'll keep aside the idea of valuation for now because valuation is
- 35:23
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): not
- 35:24
- Vishal Khandelwal: there in the annual report
- 35:24
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): at this point of view. Business and management.
- 35:26
- Vishal Khandelwal: Business and management. So, like I mentioned, I need to, since I'm buying a stock, I'm opening an annual report, which a lot of investors don't actually do, right? I am going to first understand what the business
- 35:38
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is.
- 35:39
- Vishal Khandelwal: all about, what products and this I'm assuming this is a company which is very new in front of me, and I've not known anything about the business. I'm not coming with any notions of what this business is all about. I'll read the last at least 10 years of annual reports of the business or where they've come from, in any order which I like, maybe starting to end or ending to start. Right. So I'll read about the business
- 35:59
- Vishal Khandelwal: overview, what the management has said over the past many years, and whether they have delayed. delivered it or not. That tells me a lot about management quality as well. Right? They every every every person, every management leaves footsteps. So
- 36:12
- Vishal Khandelwal: what they said versus what they did over the last 10 years is very important for me to understand, to even have some sense of credibility about around them. What's been their capital allocation track record? Very important, right? Revenue growth is perfectly fine. You can easily calculate the sales growth for the past 10 years, you can easily calculate the profit growth for the past 10 years. But
- 36:32
- Vishal Khandelwal: whether that growth happened at the cost of capital efficiency or inefficiency, right? For every hundred rupees that they invested in the last 10 years, every year, were they able to earn higher and higher profit or not?
- 36:46
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right?
- 36:46
- Vishal Khandelwal: That's such an important return on incremental capital or investor, return on capital. employed. These are simple ratios that everyone needs to calculate and these are easily available in today's world. But the hard thing is to actually go and do that calculation and do that analysis, right? Yeah. And it tells you a lot about the business and not just about the business,
- 37:06
- Vishal Khandelwal: you also, if you were to it's very important to go to the next step, which is to pick up maybe one or two closest competitors and also read their ten 10 years' annual reports. to know whether the company that you are starting with is a better business or the competitors are a better business, right? Also to understand investing is also about opportunity cost. You may
- 37:26
- Vishal Khandelwal: have started with a company, and someone said, Oh, it's a great company, you read about it. But when you're reading about the competitor, which is company B, you realize, no, I think I found greater value in company B. How do you find that only when you take the effort of reading a competitor's annual report? So read the same thing, 10 years annual report, understand the business, understand unit economics if you can,
- 37:46
- Vishal Khandelwal: understand the margin profile, understand return ratios, understand how much leverage is on the balance sheet. Are they playing with fire? Have they have their return? A lot of people look at long-term long term growth rates, average compounded annual growth rate. But compounded annual growth rate hides the pain in between and the risks that the business has taken to
- 38:06
- Vishal Khandelwal: reach that compounded annual growth rate. Someone can take a lot of leverage, a lot of debt on the balance sheet to grow at a CAGR of 30%. And someone has taken no debt but has grown at 15-20%. For me as an investor, I would prefer the second business over the first business. Business. Right? You can make more money probably in the sec second in the first business because someone has taken a
- 38:26
- Vishal Khandelwal: leverage. but the probability of losing it all also increases.
- 38:30
- Vishal Khandelwal: We all focus on the on the probability of success. We
- 38:34
- Vishal Khandelwal: forget the consequences of failure.
- 38:37
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 38:37
- Vishal Khandelwal: a lot of businesses in today's world are dying faster than they used to die maybe 20 years back. So for me, starts with understanding business, understanding management, understanding capital allocation, reading through the cash flows. More important than reading through the income statement, right? Cash flows, balance sheet, income statement in terms of priority of how much
- 38:57
- Vishal Khandelwal: weightage do I give to each of these. Understanding whether they have done something which is not in
- 39:04
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): favor
- 39:05
- Vishal Khandelwal: of minority investors, maybe repeated dilution of shares. Are there significant related party transactions which they have indulged in over the past few years? Right? Nobody would have noticed, or people in bull markets will just leave that aside of things are fine, companies growing, why are you so worried about that? Right? But again, it entirely depends on the kind of investor you are.
- 39:25
- Vishal Khandelwal: If you're focusing on survival apart from growth, you're going to focus on all those things because I think Buffett said that anything multiplied by zero is zero.
- 39:33
- Ivan: Yeah.
- 39:33
- Vishal Khandelwal: Right? So you need to find those zeros which can which when multiplied with a lot of growth. right? And those zeros are bad capital allocation, bad quality management, some lack of ethics, right? All those things. If you see even a hint of that, right?
- 39:51
- Ivan: It's a red flag.
- 39:51
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): For
- 39:52
- Vishal Khandelwal: me it's a red flag. Red r red, red, dark red flag.
- 39:54
- Ivan: Yeah.
- 39:55
- Vishal Khandelwal: I'll just not invest. And that's the reason that may l reduce your circle of competence. That may reduce the universe for you.
- 40:00
- Ivan: But
- 40:01
- Vishal Khandelwal: perfectly fine playing in your universe.
- 40:02
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 40:03
- Vishal Khandelwal: there are so many companies which are listed in India which are coming out. You have a lot of universe which is going to build up over the next few years as well. Okay.
- 40:10
- Ivan: Yeah. I like that you said that deep red flag. You're not going to compromise on any of the factors
- 40:14
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that you spoke about. It's
- 40:16
- Vishal Khandelwal: more negotiable.
- 40:16
- Ivan: It has to meet that criteria. I
- 40:18
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): think
- 40:19
- Vishal Khandelwal: I remember this this this this term that Simon Simon Sinek, who's an author, he says hell yes or no.
- 40:25
- Ivan: Yeah. It
- 40:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): has
- 40:25
- Vishal Khandelwal: to be hell yes.
- 40:27
- Ivan: If
- 40:27
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
- 40:27
- Vishal Khandelwal: is yes or no, then it is no.
- 40:29
- Ivan: He used another expletive, but you said hell
- 40:31
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yes. I love it.
- 40:32
- Ivan: Okay. I agree. Um okay. If I I may sound, I mean, I feel you're gonna judge me for this question, but say someone who's watching you is saying, But that's so much work. Ten years annual report, I don't have the time, I don't even have the ability to do that. What is their next best option, or is this diagram? direct investing not your game and
- 40:52
- Ivan: still?
- 40:52
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Direct
- 40:53
- Vishal Khandelwal: investing is not your game. Don't do
- 40:54
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.
- 40:55
- Vishal Khandelwal: Buying stocks or not having stocks in your portfolio is not a shame.
- 41:00
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right?
- 41:00
- Vishal Khandelwal: We all want to buy stocks because we all are entertainment seeking people. Right? And if post twenty twenty everything is legalized now, legalized gambling, online betting, everything, right? And attention spans have come down.
- 41:14
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
- 41:15
- Vishal Khandelwal: Everything is on social media.
- 41:17
- Vishal Khandelwal: Twenty years back, my world was my neighborhood. Now, what is happening in Nepal or Syria or Somalia or Israel? I have a view on everything.
- 41:28
- Ivan: Yeah.
- 41:28
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 41:28
- Vishal Khandelwal: it's going to impact me every day. We see videos of people dying, accidents Students on a daily basis. We also see videos or snapshots of people making multi-core multi-crow rupees showing their PL on social media on a daily basis.
- 41:40
- Ivan: And living the fancy life.
- 41:41
- Vishal Khandelwal: Living a fancy life. And we think, what am I doing with my own life?
- 41:46
- Ivan: Yeah.
- 41:46
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We
- 41:46
- Vishal Khandelwal: start to question our own lives.
- 41:48
- Ivan: Yeah.
- 41:49
- Vishal Khandelwal: Right? But we ignore the rule of luck. We ignore that probably
- 41:54
- Vishal Khandelwal: they were much more skillful sometimes, right?
- 41:58
- Vishal Khandelwal: We also uh uh bring all those things into our living room, into a mindset. right? Which leads us to a lot of negative thinking about the world around us. And mind has a limited capacity in that way, right? I remember this famous explanation from Sherlock Holmes to his accomplice Watson,
- 42:18
- Vishal Khandelwal: and he says, Sherlock Holmes says the mind is like the brain is like an empty attic.
- 42:23
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 42:24
- Vishal Khandelwal: you can stock so much furniture into that empty attic.
- 42:27
- Vishal Khandelwal: But for every new furniture that you bring into that attic, you have to throw out something else.
- 42:32
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Which
- 42:32
- Vishal Khandelwal: means for every junk and news and noise that you want to store in your brain, all the wisdom that you stored over years has to move
- 42:38
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): out. And
- 42:39
- Vishal Khandelwal: this is what is exactly happening in today's world when we are consuming, consuming, consuming because of fear of missing out. Whether it's more stocks, more news, more podcasts, more noise, everything we want to consume more and more and more.
- 42:52
- Vishal Khandelwal: Right? So we have to question all that. We've stopped questioning, and that was my question. And I said, what if the next 10 years give you zero returns?
- 43:00
- Ivan: Yeah.
- 43:00
- Vishal Khandelwal: It's the idea of leading someone to question and not to tell that, oh, next 10 years zero returns. My point is to not tell you what is going to happen. I have no idea. Nobody has any idea what's going to happen with markets or anything in the next 10 years. Forget next 10. years, next five years, next one month, next one day. But what we are surrounded with are predictions. And
- 43:20
- Vishal Khandelwal: predictions garbed as expert opinions.
- 43:23
- Ivan: Yeah.
- 43:23
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 43:23
- Vishal Khandelwal: just don't take it. After twenty years in the markets, I can see through all that thing. It's very important for us to see through all that thing, what is which is noise. Even expert opinion about a market's future is noise.
- 43:36
- Ivan: Yeah.
- 43:37
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 43:37
- Vishal Khandelwal: now if you look at the financial I ca I was a part of the financial service industry, and we are sitting doing this podcast in the financial service industry's room. Right? The very fact that more and more financial products are being launched and given to investors is also creating fear of missing
- 43:52
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): out. Yeah.
- 43:53
- Ivan: Mutual
- 43:53
- Vishal Khandelwal: fund?
- 43:54
- Vishal Khandelwal: Dosalbad mutual fund sain. SIP SAIT Saiti two years back, but SIP Saiyan. sain Because you have a new product.
- 44:01
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): People
- 44:01
- Vishal Khandelwal: talking about global. Five years back, they said India is where the world is coming at. Now we're saying India is a micro cap.
- 44:08
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Of
- 44:09
- Vishal Khandelwal: course, it's a micro cap. But do you have the competency to go and understand global investing? If not, stay here. You have a lot of options.
- 44:18
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Or
- 44:18
- Vishal Khandelwal: give it to some money manager. But don't spread yourself too thin and look everywhere just because you are fearful of missing out. I always maintain this philosophy that most investors are perfectly fine having no stocks in their portfolio.
- 44:33
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 44:33
- Vishal Khandelwal: if yes, maybe 10 stocks in their portfolio, something that they understand well. Maybe two or three different mutual fund schemes. One health insurance policy, one life insurance policy, a few money for some amount of money in emergency fund. That's
- 44:46
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.
- 44:47
- Vishal Khandelwal: That's your like a half half-page page financial plan. You don't need more. than that. Everything else is just adding complexity to your life. Why do you want to
- 44:55
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): add
- 44:56
- Vishal Khandelwal: complexity to your life? We need to make life simple.
- 44:59
- Ivan: Yeah, I I absolutely agree. You know, just having it with the basics. And like you said, if you don't have the competency, then just there's absolutely no need to do it. Um, let's uh talk a little bit more about a lot of companies talking about their moths, motes, especially these new age companies. that are coming about. How when is it that you say this is a red flag, I'm not falling for
- 45:19
- Ivan: it? Or when do you say that yes, this actually makes sense? This is the company's moat.
- 45:24
- Vishal Khandelwal: See, I think a moat is not just a theoretical concept, it's also shown up in numbers and the company's performance the past few years. And when I say past few years, at least 10 years of numbers. Right? So uh knowing a company by its brand name
- 45:37
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
- 45:38
- Vishal Khandelwal: understanding whether the it let me first define what a moat is, right? A lot of people are confused what a moat is. So if you see in historical times when when kings used to build castles, right, they used to surround that castle with a deep water body or huge mountains, and they used to so that the enemy could not enter. That deep water body with alligators and crocodiles
- 45:58
- Vishal Khandelwal: was the moat.
- 45:58
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It
- 45:59
- Vishal Khandelwal: was called the moat. In today's world, when a company creates such deep water bodies around it, whether by way of building a strong brand name or a strong distribution channel or a very nice product, a great product, like for example, Apple.
- 46:15
- Vishal Khandelwal: The kind of mode that that company has, like Buffett bought or Buffett's team bought, was not because it was a technology company, but because it was a consumer company. Now, not many many people would have looked at Apple by way of being it being a consumer company. Right? You enter the Apple's platform and it's so difficult to leave it. And there's so many companies which are doing that, not just Apple. Right? So that is
- 46:35
- Vishal Khandelwal: a moat.
- 46:37
- Vishal Khandelwal: The first thing is to identify moat. Why? Because as as I mentioned, in today's world, the age of an average company is coming down. So all companies over a period of time will see their return on capital converge to their cost of capital.
- 46:51
- Ivan: Yeah.
- 46:51
- Vishal Khandelwal: Right?
- 46:52
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): A
- 46:52
- Vishal Khandelwal: company which has no advantage over competitors is going to see that very soon. Which means for an investor, the compounding period is very small. And we understand that compounding works over a long period of time, 10 years, 15 years, 20 years.
- 47:05
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
- 47:05
- Vishal Khandelwal: if the moat has shrunk in five years or there's no moat, you don't have a period to compound your wealth. But for another company which has advantage over competitors, that return on capital is going to converge to the cost of capital over a longer period of time. Till the time it happens, you already have that compounding period long enough for you to compound your
- 47:25
- Vishal Khandelwal: wealth. Right? So that is point number one around mode. It's very important to find that advantage in the business, and that's the reason
- 47:33
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I say
- 47:33
- Vishal Khandelwal: investing is not simple. Because how do you find that? Of course, you look at return. on capital, you look at the cross margins of the business, you look at the debt on the balance sheet compared to a competitor. When you talk about moat,
- 47:45
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 47:45
- Vishal Khandelwal: always compare it into a competitor. There's no isolation.
- 47:48
- Vishal Khandelwal: The second thing is the sustainability of that moat,
- 47:51
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): which
- 47:51
- Vishal Khandelwal: is very difficult in today's world because either people with deep pockets are entering new industries, and that's the reason Jab Bizos Bezos said many years back that your margin is my opportunity. Right? I earn as Amazon 0% margin so that a competitor can never enter. A competitor is never going to find it lucrative.
- 48:08
- Ivan: Yeah.
- 48:09
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): For
- 48:09
- Vishal Khandelwal: a company which earns a great margin, a great return on capital, I think Philip Fisher said, it's like an open jar of honey,
- 48:16
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): which
- 48:16
- Vishal Khandelwal: is going to invite a lot of bees.
- 48:19
- Vishal Khandelwal: So, like you and me are getting enticed by saying, Oh wow, this company has great return on capital and great margin, let me go and invest in this business because it has huge moat. A potential competitor is also looking at the same thing.
- 48:32
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Which
- 48:32
- Vishal Khandelwal: means the future that moat is going to shrink. The moment it starts shrinking, and you are a diligent investor who's reading the annual reports and the balance sheet, and the company is changing around, you're going
- 48:42
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
- 48:42
- Vishal Khandelwal: have to take a relook at your thesis. And that goes to the same idea that buy and hold does not mean buy and forget. And you have to be an owner of businesses and not a holder of stocks. Holding is very passive. Ownership is where you understand all these nuances of investing.
- 49:00
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 49:01
- Vishal Khandelwal: that leads to the idea that it's not simple. We've made it simple in today's world because we have tools, we have the vocabulary, we have the terms, we have the technology to analyze. But the question is:
- 49:12
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): are
- 49:12
- Vishal Khandelwal: you asking the right questions?
- 49:15
- Ivan: It definitely comes down to that. And you know, while we touched greatly upon uh the business and the management, can we talk about fair valuation and how you know you're buying at the right price and what your um what your understanding and explanation of that would be? I
- 49:30
- Vishal Khandelwal: think when it comes to valuation, I use a mental model called inversion. Inversion simply means the other side of
- 49:38
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
- 49:38
- Vishal Khandelwal: question. Instead of asking what can how can I create wealth, you ask how can I ruin myself. And you don't do those things. So when it comes to valuation, instead of asking, is this valuation fair? I would rather ask, is this valuation unfair?
- 49:51
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 49:52
- Vishal Khandelwal: do something called as a reverse DCF. Reverse DCF simply means in discounted cash flows, you take the cash flow, you predict the cash flows for the next 10 years, in simple words, right? You predict the cash flows for the next 10 years. and discount them to the present value. This is a mathematical concept, but you can get calculators and tools to do that. It's a simple mental model how to do that. In
- 50:12
- Vishal Khandelwal: reverse DCF, you try to find out what is the expected return that the market is expecting for the company's cash flow to grow at. What's the rate of return that than the market is expecting? And then your job as investors to only challenge that, whether that's reasonable or not reasonable. Using a mathematical formula, when you find out that for the current market cap to get justified,
- 50:32
- Vishal Khandelwal: the market expects a company's cash flows to grow at 30%.
- 50:36
- Vishal Khandelwal: And your analysis of the business says no, 30% is not reasonable. It's unfair, which means the valuation is unfair.
- 50:42
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 50:42
- Vishal Khandelwal: you're not worried about target prices, you're not worried about where the valuation is going to go in the future. Your only worry is whether this is a good price to buy the business or not with a reasonable margin of safety. So if the valuation is unfair, I'm not going to buy. If the valuation based on expected cash flows is fair, I'll take a look and probably
- 51:02
- Vishal Khandelwal: buy the stock. Not worrying about any target prices in the future. There's no target prices. You're thinking like an owner and not as an analyst.
- 51:08
- Ivan: Yeah. Okay. So, like you said, it's inversion. That's the principle you're using when it comes to valuation. Now you've gone on record to say that a 10% position is capable of terrifying you into selling at the bottom, which may be worse than a 3% position that you can calmly hold through the storm. So how does a retail investor decide whether a stock merits two, five,
- 51:28
- Ivan: or ten percent in their portfolio?
- 51:30
- Vishal Khandelwal: I think so
- 51:31
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
- 51:31
- Vishal Khandelwal: way to do is a sleep test. Right? Are you able to sleep peacefully at night owning a stock, as I said, 10% holding in your portfolio?
- 51:39
- Vishal Khandelwal: But the very moment the market crashes and the stock also falls down, and you are doubtful whether you should be owning that stock, you should not be owning that stock. Forget 10%, not even 1%. But a 3% holding, which is a very small holding, but it's a business, of course, which is much more steadier, right? And uh it may not have a lot of growth in it, but it's much more
- 51:59
- Vishal Khandelwal: steadier. Uh it has, it has the management is much more credible. Me as an individual investor, I'm going to own that business with much, much, much more promise and much more, in the sense, uh comfort than the second business. Now it's very difficult for us without and if you don't understand the business. And that's the reason the idea of understanding the business thoroughly, even if
- 52:19
- Vishal Khandelwal: you think it's a simple business, comes into play. If you understand a business thoroughly,
- 52:24
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 52:24
- Vishal Khandelwal: can assign probability of things going. right or wrong. Investing is all about probabilities, it is not about certainties. Even
- 52:33
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): for
- 52:34
- Vishal Khandelwal: me as an investor, I don't practice active position sizing. There's something called position sizing, how much of what stocks to own in your portfolio? I do equal sizing. When I try to buy a stock in my portfolio, right, assuming I want to have 10 stocks, maybe to give a better number, assuming I want to have 15 stocks in my portfolio.
- 52:53
- Vishal Khandelwal: 100% divided by 15 is around 6-6.5%. Which means when I say equal sizing, on the day I want to buy a new stock in my portfolio, the 15th stock, that should not be more than 6%, 7% of my portfolio. It can go and rise and go up to 10%, 15%, but at cost, I practice equal sizing.
- 53:11
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 53:11
- Vishal Khandelwal: that is perfectly fine for me. It has worked really well for me over the years. You have to be even more diligent to find out how much 2%, 10%, 5%. It's entirely dependent on your conviction on the business, the durability of the mode, your understanding of the durability, the risks. Do you understand that? Entirely depend on your conviction. So
- 53:31
- Vishal Khandelwal: to give a simple answer,
- 53:34
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
- 53:34
- Vishal Khandelwal: need to understand the business thoroughly well. To even assign 2%, 10%. 5%.
- 53:40
- Ivan: Okay. Yeah. It boils down to understanding the business and of course then deciding what the probability could be. Now you've argued that no two investors can own exactly the same company or the same stock and you know require, they would require different margins of safety. Can you tell us a little bit more about what you mean by that?
- 53:59
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Life stage.
- 54:00
- Vishal Khandelwal: I think it's a matter of life stage. If someone who's living on
- 54:03
- Vishal Khandelwal: their investments and probably sixty years of age or sixty five years of age, who has nothing, there's no active source of income, right? They need to and they're buying a given stock some compared to someone who's at thirty or twenty-five years of age. Do the age does not matter. Someone who's at sixty-five with all liabilities taken care of can play on the front foot and invest in
- 54:23
- Vishal Khandelwal: extremely risky businesses and play for that
- 54:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): twenty
- 54:25
- Vishal Khandelwal: 20% percent CAG. CAGR and all those kinds, do all those kinds of things in the world. But I'm talking about in very general terms. Yes.
- 54:31
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Someone
- 54:31
- Vishal Khandelwal: who's 30-year-long runway of growth and active source of income, right? Yeah. Can look at the same stock and have a higher allocation to that
- 54:37
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): stock
- 54:37
- Vishal Khandelwal: compared to someone who's at a different stage
- 54:39
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of
- 54:40
- Vishal Khandelwal: life. There's something called the barbell approach of investing, which Nasim Talib talks about, where he says:
- 54:45
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): when
- 54:46
- Vishal Khandelwal: you imagine a barbell, bar value, you imagine two sites sides with the same weight. But he says on one side you have 5% weights to extremely risky investment propositions where there's a chance of losing your money 100%. On the other side, 95% of your money should be in extremely safe. And he says, safe for you. You understand the business, it could be a mix of debt
- 55:06
- Vishal Khandelwal: and whatever it is, the gold and your total portfolio, but you understand what you are buying, right? You're not playing for a multi-bagger, multi bagger, you're playing for a reasonable rate of return to beat the inflation. Now, for a 30 year old, it could be 10% and 90%. For a 60 year old, it could be 1% and 99%.
- 55:23
- Ivan: Okay.
- 55:23
- Vishal Khandelwal: Right? So you have to take it accordingly based on where you are in your life stage
- 55:28
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and your money
- 55:28
- Vishal Khandelwal: requirements.
- 55:29
- Ivan: Okay. Your life stage and your money requirements. And you know, in this era Uh of all of these stock tips and things, uh what is the selling checklist? I know you don't like giving this checklist, but I just want to understand because you have admitted in your career that you've often sold companies simply because they have given you that alpha, that kind of a hundred percent return, et
- 55:49
- Ivan: cetera. Um, but you've remained anchored when it comes to your purchase price. What does an investor need to mentally set themselves up for for selling?
- 55:57
- Vishal Khandelwal: So I think uh based on when someone asks me when do you sell the stock, my answer is I sell the stock at the wrong time. It's always the case. When you sell a stock, it starts rising, right? It happens all the way. But uh on a serious note, uh my reason for selling a stock is never the stock price.
- 56:13
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay.
- 56:14
- Vishal Khandelwal: Right? Uh and I think that's one of the bias that investors it's very difficult to get over that bias because people are anchored to their purchase price, right? Oh, or the stock has become a five-bagger.
- 56:24
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
- 56:24
- Vishal Khandelwal: let me sell before it before. I lose my paper profits. Or oh, the stock has fallen by 50%, I'll sell only when I get my money back. Now looking at your purchase price is irrelevant to your selling decision. For me, the only reasons to sell the stock is when the thesis breaks, or when
- 56:44
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
- 56:44
- Vishal Khandelwal: business where I've I have invested in, or the management where I invested in, my view on those things have changed because probably the business is. worsening, the moat is shrinking, the management has taken a decision which is not to my liking. I may be proven wrong perfectly fine, but at this point of time, that is my reason to sell. That is one reason where the thesis changes or worsens. Right? The second thing
- 57:04
- Vishal Khandelwal: is where I made a mistake. The thesis was wrong from the very first day. Yeah, my My view on the business was wrong from the very first day, and maybe someone, a new view. has come up, new view in the sense when I relook at the business, and it has happened with me in the past as well, where I when I look at the business with a
- 57:22
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): much
- 57:22
- Vishal Khandelwal: more deeper sense, after I have started investing in, I realize, oh, this is a mistake from the
- 57:27
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): very
- 57:27
- Vishal Khandelwal: beginning.
- 57:27
- Ivan: Okay. So
- 57:28
- Vishal Khandelwal: rather than hanging on, say, oh no, I've committed capital, right? We all suffer from commitment bias. Once we've we have committed, we stay to the commitment. Yeah. Which is good in life, but not true in investing a lot of times. right? So that is where I try to sell stocks and move out, that specific stock. The third is opportunity cost. If I find a better opportunity, I have no excess cash to
- 57:48
- Vishal Khandelwal: invest in, which has rarely been the case. It's not that I always have excess cash, but I try to find those opportunities within my existing circle of competence and existing portfolio. right? So that is another reason for me to sell a stock where I have the least conviction to invest in a stock where I have more conviction. right? But that's it's a very tricky thing. And the fourth thing which I have really sold
- 58:08
- Vishal Khandelwal: the stocks most of the time in my life is when I wanted to use that money to meet a financial goal.
- 58:13
- Ivan: Okay.
- 58:14
- Vishal Khandelwal: So maybe buy a house or spend some money on some financial goal or something like that. Where I don't have extra cash. So what do I do? I sell my stocks. They don't need to worry about, oh, I'm going to miss out on compounding and everything. everything. The money is there to serve you. So you rather use it till the time you can use it.
- 58:30
- Ivan: Okay. So from what I got, sell when the thesis is breaking, when the motor is shrinking, or if you have to meet a financial goal
- 58:38
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): primarily.
- 58:39
- Ivan: Um now your recent letter says that the intellectual understanding of risk and what the nervous A system can actually tolerate can be completely different.
- 58:49
- Vishal Khandelwal: Yes.
- 58:49
- Ivan: What do you mean
- 58:50
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): by that?
- 58:50
- Vishal Khandelwal: I I already mentioned about that on paper we understand a lot of things. Knowing, as I said, knowing the name of something versus knowing something are two different things.
- 58:59
- Ivan: Okay. Okay.
- 58:59
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 58:59
- Vishal Khandelwal: that's exactly what I'm saying. When your nervous system reacts to the actual risk on the ground,
- 59:05
- Ivan: it
- 59:05
- Vishal Khandelwal: could be completely
- 59:05
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): different.
- 59:09
- Vishal Khandelwal: You have to know yourself, and how do you know yourself? Not not by someone telling you the kind of person or the kind of investor you are, but by actually practicing going through those bad periods of time.
- 59:18
- Ivan: Okay. Um so uh let's just understand a little bit more about this uh information overload that we're so accustomed to in today's day and age. Um what should be the real edge? What should be that smart question that investors should ask at a time when we have all of the information at our fingertips?
- 59:36
- Vishal Khandelwal: I think uh uh it could be a very cliched answer, right? But but the first thing is to know yourself. Know your capacity to take risks, know what can cause you sleepless nights, and it it would be completely different from what others are uh what the answer would be for others. Right? So knowing yourself I think is is the most important that that you can I think practice here.
- 59:56
- Vishal Khandelwal: I think understanding business, I repeat that again and again. Understanding business is is one of the m again, one of the most important things over here as well. Understanding what you are getting into. Right? We are living in a world where stock tips are easy, finding out stocks to buy multi-baggers, all those things are created by someone else, and we lap onto them because they're easily available,
- 1:00:16
- Vishal Khandelwal: right? But the point is that do I understand what I am getting into? The third thing is we use since you use the word risk, I always come to this idea that a lot of us in investing don't really understand. the difference between risk and uncertainty. Randomly confused between the two, and we make a lot of mistakes in our investing life. Risk is measurable, right? If I
- 1:00:36
- Vishal Khandelwal: were to give you
- 1:00:37
- Vishal Khandelwal: a bag full of say red color balls and white color balls, and I tell you 70% of balls are red in color and 30% are white in color, and I ask you to pick out one ball and tell me the color in advance. You can with probability tell because there are more red color balls than white clap balls. Right? That's uncertain, that's risk because you can measure, right,
- 1:00:57
- Vishal Khandelwal: with some probability. But if I give you a bag, an opaque bag, and I don't tell you whether there are balls or there are bats or there are something else in the thing, but I ask you to pick out something, right? Now you have no idea what's going to happen, what's inside this bag, right? That's uncertainty. A lot of people, when the markets are uncertain, nobody knows
- 1:01:17
- Vishal Khandelwal: anything, they'll talk about probabilities.
- 1:01:21
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We
- 1:01:21
- Vishal Khandelwal: are dealing with uncertainty, but you're talking about risk. Right? And you are going to make an investment which is going to lose you a lot of capital going forward.
- 1:01:30
- Vishal Khandelwal: On the other hand, a lot of times when
- 1:01:33
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): people
- 1:01:34
- Vishal Khandelwal: are looking at risky stuff, where they are looking at a business which is making a decision where a lot of people think that this can go wrong and backfire. Someone else is looking at that from a risk point of view. You're looking at it from an uncertainty point of view that I don't know about the future. Nobody knows about the future of businesses. But why do some people create wealth from the same businesses where others lose money?
- 1:01:54
- Vishal Khandelwal: Because they are looking at that business from a risk point of view and not an uncertainty point of view. So it's very important for us to differentiate.
- 1:02:00
- Ivan: Distinguish between the two.
- 1:02:03
- Ivan: It's not about having enough money in your bank account, you said. Instead, ask yourself what is the purpose of having enough money in your bank account. At this time, when we're looking at the sort of hedonic treadmill that everyone is on, and financial freedom and all of that, can you tell me about how your journey or your relationship with money has evolved and what does it mean to you?
- 1:02:24
- Vishal Khandelwal: So I think uh uh
- 1:02:26
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): f
- 1:02:27
- Vishal Khandelwal: like like any individual, my journey has evolved over time, as far as my relationship with money is concerned. Uh uh when I look back at my twenties, right, money was about
- 1:02:38
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 1:02:39
- Vishal Khandelwal: scarcity and status. Right? Uh you want to acquire things, you want to acquire money, you c You acqu acquire name and everything.
- 1:02:47
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That was
- 1:02:47
- Ivan: specifically for you, yours. yourself.
- 1:02:48
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, for
- 1:02:49
- Vishal Khandelwal: for for me myself,
- 1:02:50
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): right? And
- 1:02:51
- Vishal Khandelwal: I'm sure for a lot of people, when you look at your 20s, you want to earn more money because there's scarce money.
- 1:02:57
- Ivan: Yeah.
- 1:02:57
- Vishal Khandelwal: So scarcity and status. When you move, when you earn money and invest money, it moves from scarcity status to uh money is is equated with uh security. You are looking at that money to invest so that it secures your financial futures from scarcity to security because already built up certain certain kind of network. net worth.
- 1:03:15
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): When
- 1:03:15
- Vishal Khandelwal: you move to your 40s, right, you reach a stage where money should become invisible. If you are in your 40s and you're still running after money and you're still worried about building a 40 crore or 50 crore or 60 crore net worth because someone on television or media told you that this is the bare minimum that you need to earn, then
- 1:03:35
- Vishal Khandelwal: I'm not sure that's worth even practicing. And I think I also mentioned it somewhere else that that idea of financial freedom itself has become a cage for
- 1:03:44
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): us.
- 1:03:44
- Vishal Khandelwal: We all chasing that rain the golden pot at the end of the rainbow running after something which is nobody knows what happens, right? So I don't work with a number. Of course, uh there are numbers like 35 times your annual household expenditure at the time of your retirement multiply, and that is the enough number. But who decides that number?
- 1:04:05
- Vishal Khandelwal: You save, you invest. I am not been a goal-based person.
- 1:04:09
- Ivan: Okay.
- 1:04:10
- Vishal Khandelwal: We all talk about goal-based investing. I have never been a goal-based person. I try to live my life as it comes, trying to avoid disaster, as Manga said, inversion. If you're trying to avoid disaster on a daily basis, life should be fine after, not after, life should be fine on a daily basis. And 20 years, 30 years down the line,
- 1:04:29
- Vishal Khandelwal: you'll reach a stage where you never imagined that you're going to reach 20 years prior to that. So my 50-year version will never imagine the kind of life I am going to live when I compare to what my 20-year-old was imagining.
- 1:04:41
- Ivan: Yeah.
- 1:04:42
- Vishal Khandelwal: We have to stop doing all that kind of things because we are imagining too much into the future. We are trying to control a lot of those outcomes, which is ruining our. present lives. Is life is not worth chasing a lot of money, right? The question is how much how what would you do with that money? There's this concept. There's a very nice book called Die with Zero. Right?
- 1:05:03
- Vishal Khandelwal: The basic idea is that uh your idea when you pass away, right, should not be to have a large net worth. You need to spend that money, give your children, do charity, whatever it is, so that by the time you are dead or you die. you're dying, you have you have no money.
- 1:05:17
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 1:05:17
- Vishal Khandelwal: people are talking about generation wealth.
- 1:05:19
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
- 1:05:19
- Ivan: Yeah,
- 1:05:19
- Vishal Khandelwal: we're talking about generation
- 1:05:21
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): wealth,
- 1:05:21
- Vishal Khandelwal: right? Because it's also it's also what's sowing the seeds of fear in our minds. Everyone is creating generation wealth, and I am not creating wealth for myself, which means I am behind. No, you're not behind. You're perfectly fine.
- 1:05:33
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): People
- 1:05:34
- Vishal Khandelwal: who are all, and I'm not saying people who are chasing generation wealth or creating generation wealth are not fine, perfectly fine. To each his own, their own journey. They have been lucky, they have been skillful to create that kind of wealth perfectly fine. In in in Marwadis and Gujarati's business families, we have a saying called Haveli Ki Umra Sat Sal.
- 1:05:51
- Vishal Khandelwal: Every palace or has a sixty year life lifespan. The first generation creates, the second preserves, and the third destroys.
- 1:05:58
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 1:05:58
- Vishal Khandelwal: kiskele karriophone. kar.
- 1:06:00
- Vishal Khandelwal: And when you give your a lot of money to your children, you're actually not preparing them for the real road that they should be walking upon. Give them ample enough so that they don't fall in life. But the upside is for them to take care
- 1:06:11
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of.
- 1:06:12
- Vishal Khandelwal: Why are we worried about creating wealth for the next few generations? You as well better live your life, spend money, don't splurge money, don't be wasteful of money. Give it to someone who needs it, but at least enjoy. So I don't agree completely with that marshmallow. experiment. I used to, but not 100% now. If you have one
- 1:06:32
- Vishal Khandelwal: marshmallow and if someone promises you another marshmallow, perfectly fine. You can resist, resist. But if you want to eat it, eat half of it and keep half for the rainy day. Right? So spend money, enjoy your life, take your kids to places where where you they you are going to build memories.
- 1:06:49
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Your
- 1:06:49
- Vishal Khandelwal: kids are not going to work. be worried whether you have a 5 BHK or 6 BHK when they are when you are 60 years of age. I see so many people creating net worth, building net worth, compromising their present life just because they want to have a bigger number to tell a story to the world. See how I created this net worth.
- 1:07:07
- Ivan: Yeah.
- 1:07:07
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It
- 1:07:07
- Vishal Khandelwal: doesn't happen that way. Nobody, I think nobody is happy that way. Except when they are talking about their numbers.
- 1:07:14
- Ivan: Yeah, you're right. And uh you know, I think like you spoke about just move towards what brings you more joy in the
- 1:07:20
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It
- 1:07:20
- Vishal Khandelwal: is all about that.
- 1:07:21
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's all about that. So
- 1:07:22
- Vishal Khandelwal: I th there's
- 1:07:23
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): this
- 1:07:23
- Vishal Khandelwal: uh beautiful s uh letter that uh there's this story of uh some high school some school students who sent a letter to Kurt Vonnegut, the author. They sent a letter to all the authors inviting them to come to their school. Nobody came, even Kurt Vonnegut did not come up, but he sent them a letter. and he asked them
- 1:07:40
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
- 1:07:41
- Vishal Khandelwal: practice whatever brings them the greatest joy. He says, write a poem, paint a picture. Not to paint a picture or write a poem, but to practice becoming. Right? And then you tear it off. You don't show it to anyone, you tear it off and throw it in the world. But the process of painting that picture, a process of creating that poem, if
- 1:08:01
- Vishal Khandelwal: that makes your soul grow.
- 1:08:03
- Vishal Khandelwal: you've achieved whatever you wanted to achieve in life. You don't need to show it to someone else. The PL is not for the world. You are not answerable to anyone. Whether you earn a 10 crore or a 20 crore, where you earn a 20% C AGR or 10% C AGR or 15% C AGR, you are not answerable to anyone. It's your one single life. You live it the way you want
- 1:08:23
- Vishal Khandelwal: to, without being irresponsible.
- 1:08:26
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That
- 1:08:26
- Vishal Khandelwal: is all. we need to do in today's world to be on that same ground. Everyone is going insane.
- 1:08:33
- Ivan: Yeah.
- 1:08:34
- Vishal Khandelwal: And in that insanity, I when I compare myself, I say, Oh, I am leaving, I'm I'm left behind, which means I am doing something wrong. You're always questioning ourselves.
- 1:08:42
- Ivan: And comparing ourselves.
- 1:08:43
- Vishal Khandelwal: Which was not the case 30 years back. Of course, there was, but now it's on a global scale. It's right here in front of me in my mobile phone.
- 1:08:51
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 1:08:51
- Vishal Khandelwal: open a mobile phone and I start comparing.
- 1:08:53
- Ivan: Yeah.
- 1:08:53
- Vishal Khandelwal: I drew a chart sometime back where I drew a chart of a person's life and I say a happy man because things are growing.
- 1:09:00
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 1:09:00
- Vishal Khandelwal: suddenly, when the happy man's friend is even happier, the happy man becomes an unhappy
- 1:09:04
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): man.
- 1:09:05
- Vishal Khandelwal: Because the friend is happier.
- 1:09:07
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
- 1:09:08
- Ivan: So
- 1:09:08
- Vishal Khandelwal: there's no end to
- 1:09:09
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.
- 1:09:09
- Vishal Khandelwal: You have to s stop it yourself.
- 1:09:12
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 1:09:12
- Ivan: how much time do you spend on social media? Is it at all doing that?
- 1:09:15
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): No, I spend
- 1:09:17
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that much
- 1:09:17
- Vishal Khandelwal: time where I go and maybe get some ideas of maybe I would say maybe half an hour, forty five minutes actively.
- 1:09:23
- Ivan: Okay. I
- 1:09:23
- Vishal Khandelwal: also indulge you to do scrolling sometimes. Perfectly fine. Right?
- 1:09:28
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But there has
- 1:09:29
- Vishal Khandelwal: to be a useless part of a day.
- 1:09:30
- Ivan: Yeah.
- 1:09:31
- Vishal Khandelwal: Everything needs does not need to be hustled.
- 1:09:33
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But no useful but now, part of it. Bashal,
- 1:09:34
- Ivan: it's happening all the time. The useless part of your day is extending to three hours and four hours.
- 1:09:38
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and seven hours. You can
- 1:09:40
- Vishal Khandelwal: only control that. Yeah.
- 1:09:41
- Ivan: It's
- 1:09:41
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): very
- 1:09:41
- Vishal Khandelwal: because algorithms, so now look at the algorithms. We are all driven by algorithms.
- 1:09:44
- Ivan: Yeah. So
- 1:09:45
- Vishal Khandelwal: the earlier you understand that, the better off your in terms of writing, in terms of creating content, everything, right? People are using artificial intelligence to do that. Perfectly fine, do that. I I uh use uh AI to edit my to proofread. Freed. And
- 1:09:57
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 1:09:58
- Vishal Khandelwal: I can do it faster, right? Perfectly fine. But the ideas have to come from you. Yeah. You have to know where to start. and where to stop.
- 1:10:03
- Ivan: Yeah.
- 1:10:04
- Vishal Khandelwal: You cannot delegate everything to algorithm.
- 1:10:05
- Ivan: Yes. Let it make your life more efficient, but
- 1:10:08
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): let the
- 1:10:08
- Ivan: thinking come from the
- 1:10:09
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): world. Perfectly fine. Perfectly
- 1:10:10
- Ivan: fine.
- 1:10:11
- Ivan: I want to talk so much more about this, but you you all there's this other thing that you said when it comes to investing that you review your portfolio only once a year because it deliberately avoids uh uh you know that constant action which people are in. Why shouldn't they constantly look at that? their portfolios?
- 1:10:28
- Vishal Khandelwal: I think we talked about the chemical called dopamine. Right? We're all dopamine-seeking creatures, right? And those short burst of like algorithm or the doom scrolling. You're actually, when you're reviewing your portfolio daily, you're actually doom scrolling on your portfolio. It's the same as doom scrolling. Right? And the more you review, the more is the chance that you're going to act again and again. Because
- 1:10:48
- Vishal Khandelwal: every time your portfolio is looking going to look imperfect compared to someone else's. Right? So if you can keep looking at your portfolio on a daily basis and not act, which is very rare to do, perfectly fine, go and do it. I'm not advising, I'm not teaching anyone to do that, to not do that. But the point is that the human brain is not evolved to an
- 1:11:08
- Vishal Khandelwal: extent where we look at everyone making money, things moving on a daily basis, and we are not doing anything. We have to do something. Right? So to avoid invert, to avoid all that kind of problems that I can create with my own mind and my own portfolio by acting a lot of time, I avoid looking at that portfolio. And that's the reason. And
- 1:11:28
- Vishal Khandelwal: when I say when I want to avoid looking at a portfolio on a regular basis, I also first So first, I need to have those kind of investments which I need to avoid looking.
- 1:11:37
- Ivan: If
- 1:11:37
- Vishal Khandelwal: I invest in businesses which I don't have. understand just because someone else is investing, or if I invest in startups or things where things change very fast, where suddenly you have profits and cash flows and suddenly everything disappears, right? I am not going to review only once a year.
- 1:11:52
- Ivan: Yeah.
- 1:11:53
- Vishal Khandelwal: Right. Right. So have that kind of a portfolio for your retirement, for your future financial goals, which you don't need to look. Then I say don't look need to look again. It's not about forgetting. It's about spending less. The lesser time you spend on your investments, I think the better would be your long-term returns. Investing is not a full-time activity if
- 1:12:13
- Vishal Khandelwal: you are not a full-time money manager. Because then you are working on a job. The day you make investing your job, I think you're in You are wrong hands.
- 1:12:22
- Ivan: Say that again: the lesser time you spend on
- 1:12:24
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
- 1:12:24
- Vishal Khandelwal: lesser time you spend on investing, the greater is the chance. that you're uh going to do better, much better than others for the long term.
- 1:12:31
- Ivan: Okay. Now, Safar Niveshak, I believe, turned 15 this July. So, what does that mean for you? What keeps you motivated to keep teaching?
- 1:12:40
- Vishal Khandelwal: Means a lot to me because I see uh even most marriages in today's world don't last 15 years. Right? So uh having this one person thing uh running for the past fifteen 15 years.
- 1:12:51
- Vishal Khandelwal: uh I think the only thing which has helped me continue is that I even now, after 15 years, I don't see it as work. Right? Uh I talked about things that make your soul grow.
- 1:13:01
- Ivan: Yeah.
- 1:13:01
- Vishal Khandelwal: This is something that makes my soul grow on a daily basis. And when you do that, when you are lucky enough to find that kind of work for yourself, right? You 15 fifteen years passed, past, 20 twenty years passed, past, right, till the time you want to do it and you can do it, you completely are into it. So for me I'm thankful that I've been lucky to be here talking to you after fifteen years of completing Safal Nibeshak. I
- 1:13:21
- Vishal Khandelwal: enjoy doing what I'm doing.
- 1:13:23
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
- 1:13:24
- Vishal Khandelwal: twenty years back, as I mentioned, I enjoyed more of stock picking and researching stocks. Now I enjoy more of writing and reading and teaching. Right. So my investments have become much more passive, passive in the sense I delegate it to someone else apart from myself. Now I focus more on teaching and writing and
- 1:13:39
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 1:13:39
- Vishal Khandelwal: finding, I don't know, as you're
- 1:13:41
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): saying.
- 1:13:42
- Vishal Khandelwal: The meaning of my own life. So I don't know.
- 1:13:45
- Ivan: How profound. I would have said you're getting older and wiser, but I think you've been imparting wisdom for the last many years now. So clearly that's not going to hold true. But you've you emphasize a lot on reading. You're an avid reader, and not just about finance, philosophy, history, psychology. Uh, you know, people like Krishna Mud. Muriti to Kabir. What is there, maybe if you
- 1:14:05
- Ivan: had to narrow down, I know this is very difficult for you to maybe one idea or one philosophy uh completely outside of finance, but that made you dramatically better at investing.
- 1:14:16
- Vishal Khandelwal: I I thought talked about that.
- 1:14:18
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Because you do
- 1:14:18
- Ivan: that all the time.
- 1:14:19
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, that's it.
- 1:14:19
- Vishal Khandelwal: I talked about that uh just some time Sometime back. It's called the dichotomy of control.
- 1:14:23
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay. Right?
- 1:14:23
- Vishal Khandelwal: Uh
- 1:14:24
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that would be most
- 1:14:24
- Ivan: effective.
- 1:14:25
- Vishal Khandelwal: It is, it it uh is very important. for to for us to understand what we control and what we don't. Right? Uh and accept. Right? The acceptance does not come. We all
- 1:14:34
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): want
- 1:14:34
- Vishal Khandelwal: to control everything, right? And uh that also happens when it comes to business analysis. When we're talking about annual reports, I I see that problem happening because we try to get as much information on a business, as much analysis, because we think that the more we know, the more we are going to control the outcomes, which does not happen. Right? So it I only can control my reaction, my uh behavior to a
- 1:14:54
- Vishal Khandelwal: certain extent. Yeah. The cost that I spend, the time which I spend on investing, that is in my control. The returns are not in my control. It's all about probabilistic outcomes in the future. So why would I even worry about that?
- 1:15:05
- Ivan: Okay.
- 1:15:05
- Vishal Khandelwal: Right? So uh knowing what you control and what you don't control, I think is one of the most non-investing lessons which has helped me as an investor in life.
- 1:15:12
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 1:15:13
- Ivan: you describe described the long game as going beyond. the what of investing to the who and the kind of person that is actually capable of surviving decades in the market. So, um, what kind of a person, what kind of a person does one need to become to really be a true long-term investor?
- 1:15:30
- Vishal Khandelwal: Oh, that person, yeah, I I I I I see the gravity of that situation. I know that I can never become that kind of a person ever in my life because then you are beyond he hu being. human.
- 1:15:39
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay.
- 1:15:39
- Vishal Khandelwal: Because you need to,
- 1:15:41
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 1:15:41
- Vishal Khandelwal: would say, eliminate ego because the market is the great greatest humiliator out there, it's going to humiliate you.
- 1:15:46
- Ivan: Yeah.
- 1:15:47
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 1:15:47
- Vishal Khandelwal: if you live with ego, you're not going to be a successful investor. So now eliminating ego is a very difficult thing, right? You have to be humble enough to accept all the outcomes which come to you. Even if you are the best of investor, you are going to have some outcomes where you're going to lose a lot of money, right? You're going to be proven a uh fool, maybe, right? So you have to understand that
- 1:16:07
- Vishal Khandelwal: market is the place where you have to be extremely humble to accept all the outcomes which come your way. Third thing is you have to be independent-minded-minded, right? Uh the world is going to tell you a lot of things. Listen to everyone, as I think my grandmother uh uh elder said, right? Suno subki Sabki karu monkey Manke. right. You listen to everyone else, perfectly fine if you have time, but do what
- 1:16:27
- Vishal Khandelwal: you think is right for you. You are going to play, and long game is the more important, most important thing about the long game is it's that your game
- 1:16:36
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is
- 1:16:36
- Vishal Khandelwal: not someone else, because if it's someone else's game, it's not going to be long.
- 1:16:40
- Ivan: Yeah.
- 1:16:40
- Vishal Khandelwal: Right? It has to be your own game without any scorecard. Right? So, how do we live in a world of comparisons without any scorecard? Because
- 1:16:48
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we
- 1:16:48
- Vishal Khandelwal: are all looking left and right here, Uska portfolio, merit.
- 1:16:52
- Vishal Khandelwal: they are earning much more better, faster returns than me. If you can stop doing that and only live with your own scorecard, which means I am happy doing this kind of investing. I'm happy spending my time on non-investing, being an investor, picking stocks and now not picking stocks. Whatever the world says, as I say, not in uh easy words, but Charlie Manga Munger told tell me, told me, right,
- 1:17:12
- Vishal Khandelwal: in indirectly, says, if the world disagrees, you say to hell with
- 1:17:16
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you.
- 1:17:18
- Ivan: And he
- 1:17:19
- Vishal Khandelwal: talked about worldly wisdom
- 1:17:20
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): because when
- 1:17:20
- Vishal Khandelwal: you're trying to acquire worldly wisdom, right, people are not going to agree with you. People say, Oh, this world is you have one short life, you try to get rich and live by live a big life and high-flying Flying life, right? And what is Charlie Munger doing acquiring worldly wisdom and is not trying to get as rich as Warren Buffett? He said nobody's going to agree with
- 1:17:40
- Vishal Khandelwal: you.
- 1:17:40
- Ivan: Yeah. And
- 1:17:41
- Vishal Khandelwal: if they don't agree with you, then say it will help with them.
- 1:17:44
- Ivan: Yeah, I mean, I've I've heard about how even with all the wealth he's accumulated, lives very simplistically. So it's it's so he's he's true to what he actually preaches.
- 1:17:53
- Vishal Khandelwal: He passed away three years.
- 1:17:55
- Ivan: Um Vishal, this is something that is an antithesis to what you believe in, but let's do a rapid file. So this would
- 1:18:02
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be just
- 1:18:03
- Ivan: quick answers that
- 1:18:04
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): come to
- 1:18:04
- Ivan: mind. A book that you have gifted someone the most number of times or you're ready to reread a million times over.
- 1:18:13
- Ivan: Yes. I love that book. Okay. Um what teaches you more about yourself? Is it a bull market or a bear market cycle?
- 1:18:20
- Vishal Khandelwal: Bear market, because it tells you the true yourself, true you that you are.
- 1:18:24
- Ivan: The most overrated piece of advice.
- 1:18:26
- Vishal Khandelwal: Book your profits.
- 1:18:28
- Ivan: Okay. Someone maybe that you enjoy or you like reading their tweets on Twitter or X?
- 1:18:36
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
- 1:18:37
- Vishal Khandelwal: not on Twitter.
- 1:18:39
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay.
- 1:18:39
- Vishal Khandelwal: On Twitter a lot of people, but uh
- 1:18:41
- Ivan: But tell me like three people you find super interesting on Twitter.
- 1:18:45
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
- 1:18:45
- Vishal Khandelwal: I um I think uh Barry Rit Holz Halls is one of them, right? He he runs Rit Ritholz Halls wealth. Management.
- 1:18:52
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
- 1:18:52
- Vishal Khandelwal: then um
- 1:18:53
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
- 1:18:54
- Vishal Khandelwal: Professor Sanjay Bakshi. He's very rare appearance on Twitter, but I really like when he talks about he gives actually case studies on Twitter for people to solve. So that's very something which is very interesting. And yeah, I think these two people Ian Castle is one or more. Ian Castle is I think uh he he he is much more regular on Twitter and he writes really wise stuff on
- 1:19:13
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Twitter.
- 1:19:14
- Vishal Khandelwal: So I think these three come on top. There of course many people, but these three on the investing side come on top.
- 1:19:20
- Ivan: Okay. Um do you have a daily practice that keeps you grounded or something that you do for yourself?
- 1:19:24
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh I
- 1:19:25
- Vishal Khandelwal: think writing.
- 1:19:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay.
- 1:19:26
- Vishal Khandelwal: Writing uh coming appearing in front of that blank screen on a daily basis which tells you that you have to start from zero every day.
- 1:19:35
- Ivan: Yeah.
- 1:19:36
- Vishal Khandelwal: I think that's something which keeps me grounded and that's something which I enjoy a lot. Yeah.
- 1:19:40
- Ivan: Something that you value now that you did not earlier in life?
- 1:19:47
- Vishal Khandelwal: My time.
- 1:19:49
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 1:19:49
- Vishal Khandelwal: think uh I've learned to say no to most things in life now which take up a lot of time compared to what it was twenty maybe fifteen, twenty years back.
- 1:19:57
- Ivan: One thing you would never do with your money?
- 1:20:00
- Vishal Khandelwal: Leverage. I'll never borrow. And it's not my money, of course, but in my investing, I'll I'm going to never borrow money to invest. And that's the reason I also avoid companies which borrow a lot of money.
- 1:20:12
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's my
- 1:20:12
- Vishal Khandelwal: nature.
- 1:20:14
- Ivan: If you weren't uh an investor or a writer or teaching things about investing, what do you think you'd be doing?
- 1:20:20
- Vishal Khandelwal: I would have said, okay, I teacher. Teacher in a primary school, maybe.
- 1:20:24
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Okay.
- 1:20:25
- Vishal Khandelwal: But uh uh since I love mountains. maybe a mountain tour guide, something someone who actually shows people and goes to the same place on mountains again and again.
- 1:20:33
- Ivan: Do you do that in your free time now?
- 1:20:34
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I don't do that. I love mountains.
- 1:20:36
- Vishal Khandelwal: I I am my own tour guide in sense. Uh if there's an option of choosing between an ocean and mountain, I love mountains. My wife loves seas. Okay. Right. But yeah, being a mountain tour guide would be a great option of not doing anything of this sort.
- 1:20:48
- Ivan: Okay, so you have the next decade to maybe cultivate.
- 1:20:51
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that
- 1:20:51
- Ivan: passion. Vishal, once again, thank you so very much for taking the time out. I could have written a copious number of pages of all the advice that you gave. So thank you so very much for enlightening our audience.
- 1:21:09
- Vishal Khandelwal: So I think that's the most important thing and that's the reason I said that I say no to most podcasts.
- 1:21:13
- Ivan: Yeah.
- 1:21:14
- Vishal Khandelwal: Right. Uh I I I don't know, I I feel uh uh uh scared in the company of people I've never met in life. Oh but you've uh it was comfortable. This was
- 1:21:23
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a good thing. I'm so glad because
- 1:21:24
- Ivan: I I actually Googled an ET Now video where I used to work and I found it pop-up from 2008 when I started my career. So clearly you're not doing a lot of those interviews. Thank you.
- 1:21:34
- Ivan: That was Vishhal Khandelwal Kandelwal giving us his entire view on the markets, and while of course he talks so in-depth about everything, I would be doing a disservice by summing up his uh his explanations, but I'm gonna give you a quick synopsis of what we've learned and discussed today. That investing is about 99% behavior and one percent
- 1:21:53
- Ivan: intellect. You need to actually go through the pain yourself to understand, and that will be your training ground for investing. Buy things that you can draw with a crayon. Look at the quality of a business, the quality of the management, and of course, look at the valuations. That is very critical while assessing a business. Play uh the investing as a
- 1:22:13
- Ivan: personal game. It's very important to cater it to your personal behaviors. Don't overload your mind with junk information. Do not have FOMO Former while investing. Be uh an owner of a business and not just a holder of stocks. And remember that knowing yourself and understanding yourself better is what and
- 1:22:33
- Ivan: understanding your overall risk assessment is what is going to make you a good investor. And at the end of the day, do what makes your soul grow. I really hope you enjoyed watching this episode. Do remember to like, share, comment, and of course to subscribe to the channel. Thanks so much for watching.
- 1:22:49
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Investment in Security securities is my market are subject to market risks. Read all the related documents carefully before investing.