Julia Zhou on Market Maker Ethics, Tokenized Commodities, and Regulatory Fragmentation
Summary
Julia Zhou, President of Caladan, defines responsible market making as providing liquidity without manipulating prices, contrasting this with unethical practices where makers are incentivized by issuers. She argues that blockchain technology does not eliminate human-driven financial crises, citing historical precedents like Tulip Mania. Zhou highlights the operational challenges of 24/7 crypto trading and the regulatory fragmentation hindering global institutional adoption. She distinguishes between speculative crypto assets and genuine financial products like tokenized commodities, noting Caladan's focus on the latter.
Key takeaways
- 1 A responsible market maker tightens spreads and provides depth without influencing price direction.
Julia Zhou · 0:00
- 2 In the crypto industry, there have been instances of market makers who did not behave well. They were economically incentivized, maybe by the token issuer, to uh push prices in a certain direction.
Julia Zhou · 0:19
- 3 24/7 trading disrupts traditional middle-office reconciliation and technology upgrade schedules.
Julia Zhou · 14:27
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 1:27
Market Maker Role and Ethics
Julia Zhou defines a responsible market maker as an entity that provides liquidity by tightening spreads and reducing trading costs without impacting price. She notes that some crypto market makers have been incentivized by token issuers to manipulate prices, which is unethical.
- 1:27 – 5:18
Speaker Background and Career Path
Tony Edward introduces Julia Zhou, President and Co-Founder of Caladan. Zhou recounts her background in economics at Columbia University during the 2007 housing crash, her transition to tech in the late 2000s, and her eventual entry into crypto market making in 2017.
- 5:18 – 7:36
Blockchain and Financial Crises
Zhou argues that blockchain cannot prevent future financial crashes because human drivers of fear and greed are constant. She cites historical examples like Tulip Mania and the 1929 crash to illustrate that technology does not change human behavior.
- 7:36 – 9:25
Market Structure and Fragmentation
Zhou describes market makers as the 'plumbing' of the market, aggregating liquidity across fragmented crypto exchanges and products. She emphasizes their role in enforcing the law of one price and providing depth for large orders.
- 9:25 – 12:30
Market Manipulation and Regulation
Zhou distinguishes legitimate market making from manipulation, stating that responsible makers do not impact price. She notes that enforcement actions have occurred against makers incentivized to push prices, drawing parallels to historical regulatory responses in traditional finance.
- 12:30 – 19:25
Price Formation and Volatility
Zhou identifies a key retail misconception: confusing marginal transactions with fair value. She explains that crypto's 24/7 nature and thinner liquidity lead to more frequent price dislocations compared to traditional markets.
- 19:25 – 23:20
Tokenized Assets and Regulation
Zhou discusses the controversy surrounding tokenized securities, noting that issuers are concerned about losing control. She highlights the lack of regulatory guidance and the ongoing debate between different tokenization models, such as SPV vs. securitized approaches.
- 23:20 – 32:04
Tokenized Commodities vs. Securities
Zhou states that Caladan provides liquidity for tokenized commodities like gold, silver, and oil, but not tokenized equities. She argues commodities are simpler to tokenize because they lack corporate actions like dividends and voting rights.
- 32:04 – 33:27
Regulatory Fragmentation and Classification Debates
Julia Zhou identifies regulatory alignment as a major roadblock for global institutional crypto markets, citing differing classifications of digital assets across jurisdictions. She notes that Singapore classifies assets under the Payment Services Act, Japan recently reclassified crypto as a financial product, and the US debates whether perpetuals are swaps or futures.
- 33:27 – 34:38
US Regulatory Stance and Future Clarity
Zhou argues that while the US lacks clarity, it is positive that key questions regarding perpetuals, prediction markets, and tokenized securities are on the regulatory agenda. She contrasts this with other regions, suggesting the US is actively debating these definitions rather than ignoring them.
- 34:38 – 37:07
Crypto as Entertainment vs. Financial Products
Zhou advises investors to distinguish between crypto as an entertainment industry (meme coins, NFTs) and genuine financial products (futures, perpetuals). She compares meme coins to trading collectibles like Pokemon cards and warns against conflating tokenized gold with speculative assets.
- 37:07 – 39:52
Caladan's Roadmap and Expansion
Julia Zhou outlines Caladan's roadmap, which includes expanding into tokenized commodities, adding more fiat currencies for settlement (recently adding the euro), and growing institutional partnerships. She highlights receiving a derivatives license (SIBA) from the Cayman Islands regulator.
Assets discussed
| Asset | Kind | Stance | Context |
|---|---|---|---|
| BitcoinBTC | crypto | neutral | Is the interest still concentrated Traded with Bitcoin and Ethereum or is it broadening to XRP salon and other altcoins? |
| XRPXRP | crypto | neutral | Is the interest still concentrated Traded with Bitcoin and Ethereum or is it broadening to XRP salon and other altcoins? |
| EthereumETH | crypto | neutral | you're uh the large asset managers, I would say, are still primarily uh seeing interest in BTC and ETH, but um family offices or brokerages, they will go, you know, towards the five, the top five, top ten. |
| Gold | commodity | neutral | we do on tokenized commodities, and we are seeing a lot of demand for tokenized gold, silver, oil. Um on gold, particularly, there's a lot of demand for tokenized gold. |
| Silver | commodity | neutral | we do on tokenized commodities, and we are seeing a lot of demand for tokenized gold, silver, oil. Um on gold, particularly, there's a lot of demand for tokenized gold. |
| Crude oil | commodity | neutral | we do on tokenized commodities, and we are seeing a lot of demand for tokenized gold, silver, oil. Um on gold, particularly, there's a lot of demand for tokenized gold. |
“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.
Claims worth verifying
A responsible market maker should not have any impact on the price, period.
Julia Zhou ·0:00
How to verify: Review Caladan's public documentation or client agreements defining their service scope as liquidity provision without directional influence. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
There have been instances of market makers in crypto who did not behave well and were economically incentivized by token issuers to push prices.
Julia Zhou ·0:19
How to verify: Search for SEC or CFTC enforcement actions against crypto market makers for price manipulation, such as cases involving specific token issuers. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceJulia Zhou grew up in New York City and has lived in Singapore for thirteen years.
Julia Zhou ·2:03
How to verify: Check Julia Zhou's LinkedIn profile or Caladan's official team page for biographical details. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Julia Zhou was an economics research assistant at Columbia University in 2007.
Julia Zhou ·2:03
How to verify: Review Julia Zhou's LinkedIn profile or Caladan's official team page for biographical details. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Julia Zhou's husband worked in quantitative/HFT trading at Citadel and Tower.
Julia Zhou ·3:35
How to verify: Review Julia Zhou's LinkedIn profile or Caladan's official team page for biographical details. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Caladan is connected to 60-something different exchanges.
Julia Zhou ·8:55
How to verify: Review Caladan's public documentation or client presentations listing their exchange integrations. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Julia Zhou has been trading 24-7 for nine years.
Tony Edward ·13:55
How to verify: Calculate the duration since Caladan's founding (2026) to 2026, or verify Caladan's operational history. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Caladan does not provide liquidity on tokenized equities but does on tokenized commodities.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·23:20
How to verify: Review Caladan's public documentation or client presentations listing their supported asset classes. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The SEC has provided a tokenization exemption.
Tony Edward ·21:45
How to verify: Search for SEC announcements or no-action letters regarding tokenized securities exemptions. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceThe Clarity Act did not pass.
Tony Edward ·21:45
How to verify: Check the status of US legislative bills named 'Clarity Act' or similar crypto legislation in the US Congress. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Digital assets in Singapore are classified under the Payment Services Act.
Julia Zhou ·32:04
How to verify: Check the Monetary Authority of Singapore (MAS) website or the Payment Services Act text for definitions of digital payment tokens. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Japan recently reclassified crypto as a financial product.
Julia Zhou ·32:23
How to verify: Review Japanese Financial Services Agency (FSA) announcements or news reports from late 2026/early 2026 regarding crypto reclassification. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The US is debating whether perpetuals are swaps or futures.
Julia Zhou ·32:23
How to verify: Search US Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) or Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) statements, court cases, or legislative proposals from 2026-08-19 to 2026-11-19. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceCaladan received approval from the Cayman Islands regulator for SIBA (derivatives license).
Julia Zhou ·37:07
How to verify: Check the Cayman Islands Monetary Authority (CIMA) public register or Caladan's official press releases for SIBA license announcements. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Caladan recently added the euro to its settlement capabilities.
Julia Zhou ·37:27
How to verify: Check Caladan's official announcements, press releases, or website updates from 2026-08-19 to 2026-11-19 regarding fiat currency support. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Julia Zhou is President and Co-Founder of Caladan.
Julia Zhou ·37:07
How to verify: Verify via Caladan's official website, LinkedIn profile, or company press releases. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Meme coins are entertainment products, not financial products.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·34:44
How to verify: This is a subjective classification; verify by noting Zhou's explicit statement in the transcript. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Tokenized gold is a genuine financial product and real innovation.
Julia Zhou ·35:21
How to verify: Verify by noting Zhou's explicit statement in the transcript. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Julia Zhou prefers email for communication.
Julia Zhou ·38:22
How to verify: Verify by noting Zhou's explicit statement in the transcript. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Julia Zhou admires Patagonia for being profitable, principled, and caring about the environment.
Julia Zhou ·38:29
How to verify: Verify by noting Zhou's explicit statement in the transcript. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Review SEC or CFTC enforcement actions against crypto market makers for price manipulation.
- Analyze liquidity depth reports from Messari or CoinMetrics to assess fragmentation across venues.
- Compare order book depth charts with trade history on major exchanges to identify price outliers.
- Review operational disclosures from traditional banks regarding challenges of continuous trading.
- Check historical price charts for WTI futures on CME versus perpetual contracts on Hyper Liquid during weekends.
- Compare minimum trade sizes and trading hours for COMEX gold futures versus tokenized gold products.
- Verify Caladan's public mission statements or client service agreements regarding their role as liquidity providers.
- Investigate regulatory classifications of digital assets in Singapore, Japan, and the US for consistency.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00Julia Zhou: A responsible market maker should not have any impact on the price, period. Market makers are there to provide liquidity. That means they're there to tighten the spreads and reduce the cost of trading, and they're there to provide depth so that if you want to trade beyond what's on top of book, you can trade a larger order size. The price is supposed to be set by the market. In the crypto industry, there have been instances of market makers who did not behave well. They were economically incentivized, maybe by the token issuer, to uh push prices in a certain direction. That is at odds with how ethical trading in any market should be done.
0:43Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): This episode is brought to you by CalShi. Calci. You probably know Calci for prediction markets, but now you can also trade crypto perps. with a free $25 bonus. You can trade on crypto up or down with up to 6x leverage, meaning you can put down $100 and control a $600 position. And the big one for us in the United States, it's the first CFTC regulated perps exchange in the country, which means no VPN and no offshore nonsense to deal with. To claim your $25 bonus, all you have to do is make your first $50 trade through the special Thinking Crypto link, which is calci.com slash P slash thinking crypto. Link will be in the description.
1:27Tony Edward: Hey folks, welcome into the Thinking Crypto Podcast. I'm your host, Tony Edward, and we are recording at station three in New York's financial district. And joining me is Julia Zoe, who is the co-founder and president of at Caladan, which is one of the oldest and largest digital asset market makers. Julia, great to have you.
1:45Julia Zhou: Thanks for having me.
1:46Tony Edward: So the incredible story is that we bumped into each other yesterday at Ripple Swell.
1:51Julia Zhou: Yes.
1:51Tony Edward: And before you're heading back home to Singapore, like let's let's do this interview. So really happy to have you.
1:57Julia Zhou: Yep, we crammed it in the schedule.
1:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So,
1:59Tony Edward: Julia, tell us a bit about yourself. You know, where do you hail from and what's your professional background?
2:03Julia Zhou: Yeah, um I grew up in New York City, been living out in Singapore for thirteen years. I started my career in economics. I was an economics research assistant at Columbia University, and the professor who I was supporting specialized in real estate. And this was 2007, which meant that three months into my first job, I'm helping my boss make a PowerPoint presentation to go in front of the Fed and explain why housing prices are crashing.
2:29Tony Edward: Wow.
2:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
2:30Julia Zhou: So um, you know, I think from there it developed a little bit of a taste for being in somewhat chaotic environments. Um and then I transitioned into tech. So around 2008, 2009, a lot of innovation was happening in tech. That was when mobile apps were launching, the social media platforms like Twitter and Instagram were taking off, e-commerce and SaaS business models were exploding. And I found it really fun to work in that industry where the playbooks weren't written. Like everybody was figuring out what does it mean to run a SaaS company? Like how do you do that? How does digital marketing work? Right? How do you grow an audience online? And it was fun just to be in the mix of that. So the last role that I had in tech was with a Boston-based ad tech company that was expanding into Asia. I was one of their first hires in Asia, and I ran around China, India, Korea, Australia, you know, growing that business. It was a ton of fun. Um That was what I when I moved m first
3:35moved out to Singapore. And then in 2017. twenty seventeen, um my husband, who has a background in quantitative trading, HFT trading at Citadel and Tower, and then my other uh good friend from university who has a background in in product and tech, they were looking at the crypto markets together. And again, you know, same story, crypto markets in 2017 of if you remember were a little bit crazy, right? There's a lot going on, a lot of price. dislocations, a lot of volatility. Um, so they started trading in those markets. And initially, I didn't think that I had very much to contribute to this project because I didn't have a trading background. So I was like, you know, I still have my job, you guys go and do this, you know, cool. Over the course of the first year, uh they kept asking me to help out. And I was, you know, sure, I'll help find an office, set up a legal entity, hire some people. And over the course of that first year, uh I think what we all realize is that when you run a crate trading firm, there are a lot of things that need to be done that are not trading. Um so today I look after HR, legal, compliance, finance, uh, and the brand.
4:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You know,
4:49Tony Edward: I want to go back to 2020. twenty seven uh two thousand seven, excuse me, because I have a story related to that. I was at a mortgage bank and we were doing a lot of loans and
5:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
5:00Tony Edward: felt the same fire and pressure when the you know the housing market collapsed. But you know, with your knowledge now of blockchain and crypto and with a lot of assets going on chain, do you do you think that blockchain could maybe help prevent a future 2008-type crash?
5:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hmm.
5:18Julia Zhou: Um the short answer is no.
5:22Tony Edward: Because humans will be humans, maybe.
5:24Julia Zhou: Because humans will be humans. You know, there's this amazing book called Uh Boom and Bust, which is about the history of financial markets. And really, this goes back to Venice in the 1300s, it goes back to Tulip Mania, Netherlands, it goes back to the rain. railroad mania
5:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of
5:40Julia Zhou: the 1800s. Humans will be humans. I think blockchain can uh n make trading more capital efficient, it can make payments faster, you know, it can make trading 24-7, um it can increase global market access to assets, can do all of those things. But I don't think it's gonna fundamentally change the human drivers of fear and greed, unfortunately.
6:07Tony Edward: Yeah. It's a bug and a feature that, you know, we're speculative beings, but we also get over speculative and then a a a bus happens, unfortunately. Um so tell us and for the folks who may not know about market making and Cowland, Calan, uh, you know, tell us about what what does a market maker do and what what value you guys bring to the market and things like that.
6:30Julia Zhou: Absolutely. Um the way that I describe it is we're like the plumbing in the walls. So when you turn on the water at your sink, right, you can touch and see your faucet, you turn it, water comes out. But there's this whole network of plumbing inside the walls that you don't see, uh, which is how the water gets to you. And similarly, when you pull up your app, whether it's your, you know, Robinhood app or what have you, and you trade, that's the part that you can touch and see. But how where's that liquidity coming from? Like where's that pricing coming from? What actually happens after you trade? How does the tokens actually arrive in your wallet? But That's all the plumbing in the walls that you don't see and that's what a market maker provides.
7:13Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Pardon the interruption Hi, I'm Tony. I'm the host of the Thinking Crypto Podcast. I wanted to ask you if you can please support the podcast by hitting the like button, subscribing if you haven't as yet. You can leave a comment below as well. And if you're listening on a podcast platform such as Spotify, Apple, or wherever you get your podcasts, please be sure to follow and hit the five star store rating. I'll let you get back to the content. Thank you so much.
7:36Tony Edward: So you guys are pretty much the core infrastructure. of the market because exchanges can't function without you. W where do we get the the pricing, the ability to buy and sell? You're a kind of the foundation of the house, so to speak.
7:49Julia Zhou: Yes, correct. Um in n in normal times when markets are functioning well, you never see us, you never think about us, right? It's only when liquidity evaporates from the markets and there's extreme volatility that the market makers are still there providing structure. The other thing I will say is that crypto markets are extremely fragmented. You've got liquidity distributed across, you know, not only different products like spot and perpetuals and options, but across centralized exchanges, decentralized exchanges, you know, exchanges in regulated in different regions, like every country has its own. set of regulations. And now across prediction markets and ETFs and digital asset treasuries as well. So the liquidity is really very fragmented. And our job is to aggregate it, to enforce the law of one price across the markets, right? So people get the At same uh pricing and they're able to trade at size across the market.
8:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
8:51Tony Edward: which markets do you guys service?
8:53Julia Zhou: A lot of them. We're connected to 60-something different uh exchanges, and then we also have a lot of bilateral counterparties. Uh so we serve markets both globally, um, across spot and perpetuals.
9:10Tony Edward: Now, market makers sometimes get blamed for manipulating token prices. This is we see it sometimes on social media, people complaining and so forth. What separates legitimate market making from manipulation and what should investors expect from a responsible firm?
9:24Julia Zhou: Yeah.
9:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): A
9:26Julia Zhou: responsible market maker should not have any impact on the price, period. Right. So market makers are there to provide liquidity. That means they're there to tighten the spreads and reduce the cost of trading, and they're there to provide depth so that, you know, if you want to trade beyond what's on top of book, you can trade a larger order size, right? Without too much slippage, which means the price moving against you. Right. That's what a market maker is supposed to do. The price is supposed to be set by the market, by the demand for buyers and sellers. In an ideal world, market makers should not have any impact on that. Now, in the crypto, industry, there have been instances of market makers who did not behave well. There was enforcement action against a few of them for manipulating prices. And I think that they were economically incentivized maybe by the token issuer or something like that to push prices in a certain direction. That is at odds with how ethical trading in any market should be done, right?
10:30And it certainly applies to both crypto and TradFy markets. Aaron
10:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Ross Powell Oh,
10:34Tony Edward: absolutely. And do you feel some of that happened because crypto was this new nascent asset class, no one was really paying attention to it? The regulators were like, uh, it's a baby. We don't really care right now. But it's grown up since. Aaron
10:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Ross Powell
10:47Julia Zhou: Absolutely. Absolut. I think you see that happening in general whenever there's innovation, there's this period where people are kind of figuring it out. And you know, oftentimes there will be an unfortunate incident or two that causes the regulators to wake up and say, Oh, this is something that you know we need to take action on. So for example,
11:08Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um,
11:08Julia Zhou: if you go back to the nineteen 1910s tens and nineteen 1920s, twenties, the stock market in the United States was a little bit of a free-for-all. Right. And then we had the 1929 crash, and then the Glass-Steagall Act, and a you know, regulation around how you have to report to investors and who can trade. All of that came as a response to that, right? Similarly, after 2008 financial crisis, we had regulation stepping in about what banks can and cannot do and how who you can give a mortgage. to and who you can't, right? Um so unfortunately that's the way of the world. Yeah.
11:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
11:45Julia Zhou: and I don't know that there's a way that uh we can perfectly anticipate everything that needs to be regulated before there's some kind of market incident, unfortunately.
11:55Tony Edward: Yeah, I often give the examples of Bernie Madoff,
11:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the
11:59Tony Edward: the famous movie The Wolf of Wall Street with penny
12:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): socks, stocks,
12:01Tony Edward: boiler rooms. not to mention uh you had the movies like Wall Street with Gordon Gecko and all that, right? These stories have been told by I think people forget and they're just like, this only happens in crypto. And it's like, no, it's happened throughout a different market, so especially the stock market, if you just look at the history.
12:17Julia Zhou: Fear and greed. Yeah.
12:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right?
12:18Julia Zhou: That's what it all comes back down to. Yeah.
12:21Tony Edward: Exactly. So what is the biggest misconception you think uh retail investors have about crypto prices and how they move?
12:30Julia Zhou: I think it's confusing the marginal transaction with the fair value price. So when we see large market dislocations, whether it's a fat finger trade or you know for whatever reason, right? There are incidents in all markets where you will see, for example, let's say the price has been of an asset has been 100, and then all of a sudden somebody does a transaction at 150, right? Or even 110, and it's way off of where the price was. That does not mean, that marginal transaction does not mean that that is actually the fair value price. So in crypto, because the markets are much more volatile than traditional assets historically. and also because um you know liquidity in crypto is much thinner than in markets like uh commodities or or securities,
13:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): there
13:24Julia Zhou: are a lot a lot uh it is much more common in crypto to have instances where you see some marginal transaction that is far off from where the actual fair value price is.
13:37Tony Edward: And then it's an
13:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): add
13:38Tony Edward: added a layer complication. It's 24-7 global, right? I I can imagine versus the stock market opening and closing bell. So it's much harder, I would assume, to manage?
13:49Julia Zhou: Um yes. We have been trading twenty-four-seven for nine years.
13:55Tony Edward: Wow.
13:55Julia Zhou: No downtime.
13:57Tony Edward: I can't imagine what that's like. And then now, Julia, it looks like all markets are heading to 24-7 or at least 24-5 because they're looking to put assets on chain.
14:08Julia Zhou: That is correct. And a lot of people are uh not super happy about it because you know, traditional finance trading, they're used to a certain workflow and a certain cadence, you know. 7:45, 45, you get to your desk, nine o'clock, the market's open, eleven AM, London closes, and then we start s reconciling and settling, and 4 p.m. the markets close, and you go out and take your clients out to drinks. That's the the cadence, right? And for the technology teams and for the middle office teams, you know, after the market close, that's when they start their middle office operations, reconciliation, settlement, clearing. Uh that's when the technology teams do their upgrades and fixes to the technology. because you know it's gone offline. Right. 24 7 is gonna shake all of that up.
14:55Tony Edward: Wow.
14:56Julia Zhou: Yeah. It's
14:56Tony Edward: Brave New World.
14:57Julia Zhou: Yes.
14:58Tony Edward: Um and I uh I mean, we're a couple blocks from the New York Stock Exchange. Eventually, they're gonna have to retire the opening and closing bell is not gonna be a thing anymore. They're gonna put it in a display case.
15:09Julia Zhou: Correct. Yes. That's actually something that at our company, when we've hired people um who came from TradFar. TradFi, it was actually
15:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like
15:17Julia Zhou: a transition for them in their working patterns because they were so used to this there's an open, there's a close, there's certain activities that I do every morning and every afternoon, and they're so used to that workflow and then they come into crypto and it's not that anymore. We don't have a market open or market close.
15:34Tony Edward: Wow. So
15:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
15:36Tony Edward: don't know if you can answer this, but do you guys use AI to assist with the 24-7 nature of the crypto markets?
15:42Julia Zhou: We use AI in many ways, yes. Yeah.
15:44Tony Edward: Yeah, because uh obviously humans need to sleep and all that take rest.
15:48Julia Zhou: Correct.
15:49Tony Edward: Okay, so without revealing confidential client information, what changes are you seeing in institutional demand? Is the interest still concentrated Traded with Bitcoin and Ethereum or is it broadening to XRP salon and other altcoins?
16:01Julia Zhou: Yeah. Generally institutional capital are invested in, I would say, typically they talk about like the top five, maybe top ten. Um it depends on what segment of the institutional market. So
16:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh, you
16:17Julia Zhou: know, you're uh the large asset managers, I would say, are still primarily uh seeing interest in BTC and ETH, but um family offices or brokerages, they will go, you know, towards the five, the top five, top ten. Uh and then the retail brokerages obviously will offer a lot more.
16:39Tony Edward: Yeah.
16:40Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
16:41Tony Edward: what is that like? You know, with some of the brokerages that you work with and they're like, here's this new altcoin. Maybe it just got started a month ago. They just did their token launch. How do you make do the market making for something like that and provide the liquidity?
16:55Julia Zhou: Yeah. Um, so in market making, there's this concept of price formation. And this goes back to what we were saying about the 24-7 markets. And now we have tokenized RWAs, tokenized commodities, tokenized securities, right? In the markets, there's a concept of where the price formation happens. So in equities, the price formation obviously happens on New York Stock Exchange and NASDAQ. And if you have a tokenized representation of those stocks, you know, anything the Magnificent 7, for example, the or a perpetual on that, that pricing is going to follow the pricing that's happening on the traditional exchange. Now, nights and weeks. weekends, where the price formation happens shifts. So right now, um the US stock exchanges close overnight, but there are these alternative trading systems or ATSs, there's three three major ones that operate in US overnight hours.
17:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
17:56Julia Zhou: from they start at 8 p.m. Eastern and they go until uh what is it 4 a.m. or 5 a.m.? And during those hours, that's where the price formation happens, right? So right now, um so I'll give you an example of this. Earlier in the year when the Iran war broke out, Hyper Liquid was one of the few places in the world that you could trade WTI.
18:19Tony Edward: Right.
18:19Julia Zhou: It was on a like a Saturday, right? Um and so that's where we saw price formation happening for that asset. So it shifts. If we move towards a world where the traditional exchanges like the New York Stock Exchange and Nasdaq are truly 24-7, then I think that will continue to be the price the source of price formation all the time. But right now we're living in again a fragmented world where where the dominant source of pricing is coming from changes throughout the day.
18:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): How
18:53Tony Edward: does that get resolved
18:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): where
18:55Tony Edward: it's not as fragmented?
18:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Part
18:57Julia Zhou: of that's our job.
18:59Tony Edward: Okay.
18:59Julia Zhou: And part of that is about, you know, if we move towards a world where everybody is twenty four seven, then that will be resolved. But obviously there's gonna be a transition phase in between.
19:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
19:10Julia Zhou: I think market makers will have a large role to play there.
19:14Tony Edward: Are institutions who are issuers of tokenized stocks or equities or whatever it may be approaching you to provide market making for those assets?
19:25Julia Zhou: The issuers of tokenized securities are, I I would say rightly so, somewhat concerned about their assets being tokenized in a way that you know they might lose control of. So there's been quite a bit of controversy and resistance, I would say, to some of the approaches to tokenization. Right now, there are different approaches to tokenization that are happening in the industry. There's the approach where you take the assets, you put it in a SPV, like the alpaca model. There's the approach where you uh work with the security issuer to ensure that the token has. all of the same shareholder rights as the security. So that's the securitized model. We have not yet, as an industry, um, you know, agreed on how exactly this is going to work. The regulators have not given uh guidance on how that will work. So it's still a little bit up in the air.
20:23Tony Edward: Yeah, obviously AMC AMC's CEO can. kicked off the revolt. Yes. Yes. Going after Robin Hood. But then a a slew of other companies follow suit saying, wait a minute, we don't like what's happening here. Uh it feels like someone needs to bridge the gap to as you alluded I mentioned, there are different ways to tokenize these assets and educate them about these different ways and what works well, what carries over voter rights, uh and all the rights that come with owning a stock versus an SPV and things like that.
20:55Julia Zhou: I think this will be a mix, this decision will be made by a mix of commercial and regulatory input. Right? Obviously, all of the security issuers have something to say about it. The exchanges probably have something to say about it, the clearers right, have something to say about it, and you know, it's the job of the regulator. regulators to take all of that input and make the ultimate decision.
21:19Tony Edward: Hopefully they can get it resolved by early 2027. If not.
21:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That
21:24Julia Zhou: may be ambitious.
21:26Tony Edward: Just because I feel like we have this momentum going, and yet now these companies are coming out, publicly traded companies, saying, nope, not gonna happen. And that does that's not a good look, and especially if you're trying to innovate. Um and obviously here in the United States specifically, we didn't get the Clarity Act pass, even though the SEC has provided the tokenization exemption. So it just feels a little messy right now.
21:46Julia Zhou: Absolutely it is. Yes. That being said, I do think the United States, compared to other countries, is now pushing the envelope with regards to regulation because these things are at least on the agenda. They're being talked about, right? In other countries, um the concept of tokenizing their securities, most other countries, it uh hasn't been broached.
22:09Tony Edward: Wow.
22:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You know,
22:11Tony Edward: there there because there's been a lot of talk about the US has been falling behind, especially since the Claret Acting passed, even though the agencies have been putting forth guidance. But it sounds like we are back in a driver's seat, maybe, that's to your point.
22:23Julia Zhou: I think there's a lot of commercial um openness to the industry right now in the United States. Um, you know, things like these tokenized securities venues, it's a bit of up in the air, you know, how well they do, but at least they're being allowed, right? So the SEC is creating these exemptions to allow people to play in the sandbox and innovate. Whether or not it will be a commercial success remains to be seen. Similarly, with tokenizing securities, right, the fact that the security tokenizers and the security issuers are talking about this and they're having a very public debate about it, and they're, you know, that arm wrestling is happening, I think is progress.
23:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Aaron Powell
23:10Tony Edward: Now you mentioned folks are not really approaching you about providing marketing market making. for tokenized assets. But are you and the folks at Calman behind the scenes?
23:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So sorry,
23:20Julia Zhou: just to be clear, we are absolutely seeing so right now we do not provide liquidity on tokenized equities,
23:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
23:27Julia Zhou: we do on tokenized commodities, and we are seeing a lot of demand for tokenized gold, silver, oil. Um on gold, particularly, there's a lot of demand for tokenized gold. because you can trade it in far smaller sizes than is on avail on, you know, venues like CME. And you can trade it 247, right? Um so that absolutely there's there there's a lot of that happening.
23:52Tony Edward: Interesting. So a lot of folks are kind of hyper focused on the equity side of things, but the commodities sounds like that could be the winner uh because it's less complication. Oil, gold.
24:04Julia Zhou: There's absolutely
24:05Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): less
24:05Julia Zhou: complication.
24:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
24:06Julia Zhou: um when you tokenize a security, you have to take into account corporate actions, dividends, share splits, votes, like that doesn't exist uh with commodities. And so it is a simpler product to tokenize.
24:21Tony Edward: So do you foresee that tokenized commodities outpace tokenized securities over time? Because less complications. It can get off the line faster.
24:32Julia Zhou: In terms of the overall industry adoption of the tokenized version of that products, possibly. Yeah.
24:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Because
24:40Tony Edward: gold is pretty huge.
24:41Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
24:42Tony Edward: and it's worldwide asset that I don't need to think about, even if I don't know about Tesla Slock stock or Apple Slock, stock, I know gold.
24:48Julia Zhou: Yeah.
24:49Tony Edward: Because in different parts of the world. and different walks of life.
24:52Julia Zhou: The global appetite is also different, right? In the United States, um, a lot of you know middle class people, just everybody invests in equities. It's a cornerstone of most people's portfolios. In other countries, like in Asia, for example, many people avoid equities markets. They don't quite trust it. Um, I mean, I'm talking about their own. local equities markets, right? And it's much more common to see people investing in real estate and gold and increasingly crypto.
25:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hmm.
25:24Tony Edward: Very interesting. So with the tokenized commodities,
25:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
25:29Tony Edward: this may be a dumb question, you probably addressed it already. How do you provide liquidity on a Sunday?
25:34Julia Zhou: Hmm. Mmm, Yeah. So again, it comes back to that question of where are the sources of price formation. So just to get a little bit technical, right? The way that our market making and trading works is we take data from all of the venues that we're connected to, our own trading, our own fills, and we combine that and we calculate a fair value price. And the fair value price is quite a bit more. complicated than just, you know, the average of the price on Binance and Coinbase, right? There's a lot that goes into creating that price. And it's a predictive price. It's not what the price is right now, it's what do I think the price will be, you know, one second, one minute, ten minutes from now, right?
26:20Tony Edward: Right.
26:21Julia Zhou: Um, so there's a lot that goes into calculating that, and that's really what our quant research team is. uh responsible for. So what goes into calculating that price depends on what data is available. On nights and weekends, the data that's available is different from what's available when the market is open. And it also depends a lot on you know where we see the trading activity and and the volumes happening. That is also different depending on times of day.
26:54Tony Edward: Not to mention geopolitical macro factors. So if a war starts right away, things start uh fluctuating.
27:01Julia Zhou: Yeah, exactly. So I think the short answer to your question to be a little bit more specific, right? Um during market open hours, the traditional venues like CME, for example, uh their price from for gold would have a very large weighting and a very large impact to how we think about fair value price. Nights and weekends, when it's closed, it will could actually shift to some of the more crypto native or DeFi venues, because that's the only pricing that's available.
27:32Tony Edward: Until everyone gets on the same page with this, do you see a bifurcation of the markets and uh price? issues, arbitrage, liquidity problems? And again, these this could just be the version 1.0, but 2.0 is better and 3.0 is better, and so on and so forth. But there could be the problems of the two separate markets.
27:51Julia Zhou: Yes. I I think absolutely. I mean, already what we're seeing is that liquidity is much thinner on you know nights and weekends than it is during market open. Right now we move towards a world where there is no market. more market open, that could shift.
28:05Tony Edward: Right.
28:06Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And I
28:06Tony Edward: guess that's where the regulators have to step in to maybe control some of the potential issues.
28:11Julia Zhou: Yeah. Um
28:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I think just on
28:13Julia Zhou: a very practical level, the hours where we will continue to see the thinnest liquidity is gonna be US afternoon into evening, right? Because Asia wakes up at nine 9 PM, US markets close at four. Europe, it's the middle of the night for them. Um, there's not a whole lot of people who live in the middle of the Pacific. So those hours between like u US Eastern 4 p.m. and 9 p.m., that's gonna be, I think, where we're gonna see the least activity.
28:42Tony Edward: Very interesting. Where do stable coins play a role in market making? And are you using it and also providing stablecoin liquidity to exchange? exchanges and folks that you work with?
28:53Julia Zhou: Yeah. Stable coins are fantastic. They're fantastic for settlement. You can do settlement anytime instantly, right? You don't have to wait for the banks to open on Monday morning. So, you know, that's the primary use case. Now I think there's more stable coins being launched, which also provide yield, which is absolutely great. I think from the trading perspective, we're moving, or I would like to see us move towards a world where the assets that we hold as collateral for trading can earn some yield while they're sitting there. So almost every trading firm in the world they trade with a prime, right? They don't put their assets on exchange directly. They trade through a prime. Like in the crypto world, you've got Ripple Prime, College. Copper, et cetera. In the traditional world, you've got your Goldman's and ABM and ROWs and you know Stone X's, et cetera. Right now, the capital that you put with your prime is cash. It earns nothing unless you're putting it to work. In the future, if we are a if if prime brokerages in general are able to support either tokenized money. market funds or yield bearing stable coins, that's an additional source of yield.
30:08Similarly, um when stable coins are used for payments. Right now, you know, payments across the world, the capital doesn't earn anything while it's in transit. With yield bearing stable Stablecoins coins or you know tokenized uh
30:24Tony Edward: deposits
30:24Julia Zhou: yeah, deposits, that could change.
30:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): A
30:27Tony Edward: question that uh just came to mind. I know a lot of folks monitor what Tether's doing as far as stable coin uh dominance and and then the correlation to the market. Are institutions or whales that you may have countered still using stable coins as a way to move their money in and out of the exchanges and to make purchases of assets and then liquidate those assets and and so forth?
30:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
30:51Julia Zhou: are in so the question is, are institutions using stable coins to trade their assets?
30:56Tony Edward: Yeah.
30:57Julia Zhou: Yes, absolutely. Yeah.
30:59Tony Edward: Cause I I I I've always wondered, because I I track some of that on my own. Like, you know, it's seeing what the stable coin supply is, um, with the volume that's on exchanges, and that could be an indicator as to how some of these whales who move markets are operating. So I just always I asked that because I'm I'm just curious about that.
31:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
31:19Tony Edward: but do you deal with just specifically exchanges and brokers or do you deal with like high net worth individuals as well?
31:27Julia Zhou: We are uh exclusively institutional. So we deal with exchanges, uh brokerages, Bridges, uh ECPs, right? We do not trade with any uh individuals.
31:39Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um Yeah, because
31:41Tony Edward: I know there's like OTC markets out there, so I was curious if that's something you guys offer, but no, obviously not. Um as you expand your regulatory footprint around the globe, what still needs to change for institutional crypto markets to operate on a global scale? Um, you know, obviously you guys are trying to be as global as possible to grow the business, but what are some roadblocks that you see that still need to be? removed?
32:04Julia Zhou: Yeah. Um regulatory alignment would be fantastic, right? So uh in Singapore, for example, digital assets are still classified under the Payment Services Act. Um in the US, there is currently there's this debate over whether perpetuals are swaps or futures, no. you know, that seems to be an open question. Um, Japan just recently reclassified crypto as a financial product, right? So what exactly crypto is? Is it payments? Is it capital markets product? Is it a you know future? Is it a swap? Like that is still governments don't agree on that.
32:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): That
32:50Julia Zhou: makes it challenge. challenging.
32:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Oh
32:52Tony Edward: yeah, it's so fragmented.
32:54Julia Zhou: Exactly. Yes.
32:55Tony Edward: Yeah. So I wonder who's the global institution that's gonna help the deal. Is the IMF, the Bank of International Settlement? Aaron
33:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Powell
33:02Julia Zhou: I mean, I think the regulators do talk to each other. Sure. Right. And they do have kind of working groups and consortiums. Um but then, you know, I think they also go back to their home countries and there's political pressure one way or another. So
33:15Tony Edward: Yeah.
33:15Julia Zhou: Yeah.
33:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
33:17Tony Edward: I think you alluded to this earlier. Uh
33:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): which
33:20Tony Edward: market has the most clarity, would you say? And that might be a tough question to answer.
33:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hmm. Um I'm not
33:30Julia Zhou: quite sure how to answer that one.
33:33Tony Edward: I know it's it's still fra fragmented, but I'm curious who's who's on the leaderboard, so to speak. Is it the US maybe, You know, that uh has because of their w what their agencies are doing?
33:42Julia Zhou: I don't think the US has clarity, no. But the US is asking the questions.
33:46Tony Edward: Okay.
33:47Julia Zhou: Right? So these topics the some of the topics that are up for debate in the United States right now, like what is a perpetual? Is it a swap or is it a future? What is prediction markets? Is it sports betting or is it events contracts? Right? How do we want to handle tokenized securities? Um none of these questions have been answered, but they're on the agenda.
34:06Tony Edward: Sure.
34:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hmm. A
34:08Tony Edward: lot to be uh determined.
34:11Julia Zhou: Right. I think it's a again, I think it's a positive thing that it's on the agenda. I think it's a positive thing that we're debating these questions. Um and you know, it I look forward to a future state where we do have clarity in answers, not clarity of the act, but clarity on these questions.
34:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): If
34:27Tony Edward: you could give our audience one lesson about how crypto markets really work, something they won't learn by just looking at the price charts, what would it be?
34:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Hmm.
34:38Julia Zhou: One of the things that I have learned during my time in the crypto markets is that there's
34:44Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a
34:44Julia Zhou: part of it which is the financial markets, and there's a part of it which is an entertainment industry. So things like meme coins, you know, NFTs, that is entertainment. It is no different than trading Pokemon cards or beanie babies for those of us who are old enough to remember that. Right. Um but then there very much is a side of the industry which are genuine financial products, you know, futures,
35:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): um
35:13Julia Zhou: perpetuals right? Whether it's for long-term investing or for trading. And I think the most important thing that I would like people to understand about the crypto industry is not to confuse the two. Just because there is, it's all being grouped under the crypto umbrella, right? Um Don't discount, you know, tokenized gold as a real innovation. just because it's being grouped in with meme coins. I don't think it should
35:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be I
35:44Tony Edward: 100% agree with you. And this is something I try to tell a lot of people, especially who are like, hey, isn't this that scam coin a part of crypto and all of crypto is a scam? Like, no, you have to segment it. The there in every market there's bad actors and there's good actors, of course.
35:59Julia Zhou: Yeah. And and I wouldn't
36:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): even call
36:00Julia Zhou: meme coins bad actors. They're not. They're just an entertainment product like Pokemon cards.
36:06Tony Edward: Yes, I I I I agree with you in principle, but like unfortunately right now the bad actors are rug pulling a lot of people.
36:14Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And the e the easiest thing to do
36:16Tony Edward: is do is with a meme coin, right?
36:17Julia Zhou: Sure.
36:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): 100%.
36:18Julia Zhou: Yeah.
36:19Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
36:19Tony Edward: but that that could change over time as the market matures and there's more education and uh you know the agencies can say hey if you're looking to invest here's what you to expect, here's what to look at for
36:29Julia Zhou: there are one hundred percent scams happening that people should avoid, right? Then there are entertainment products.
36:36Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yes,
36:37Tony Edward: true.
36:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right?
36:37Julia Zhou: Like I would argue that you know your board apes, those are an entertainment products.
36:42Tony Edward: Yeah.
36:42Julia Zhou: Um and then there are financial products.
36:45Tony Edward: Yeah.
36:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
36:47Tony Edward: I think it's the education that uh uh aspect. I think the public, the mass. masses, don't fully see the full picture, I should say. The three sixty view of it. And uh hopefully with education, hopefully with podcasts like this and interviewing folks like yourself, we get the message out there
37:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
37:02Tony Edward: delineate between all those things. Uh so Julia, what's on your roadmap? What can we expect from Caladan?
37:07Julia Zhou: Yeah. Um so we are gonna be pushing forward into tokenized commodities. We're gonna be continuing to expand. the number of institutional partnerships that we have. Um, you know, we just recently uh received the approval from the Cayman Islands regulator for SIBA, which is our derivatives license. We look forward to adding more fiat currencies um to our settlement capabilities. We just recently added euro and we've got a few other currencies in the mix. Um So essentially providing the best liquidity that we can across digital assets.
37:45Tony Edward: That's exciting. And I would love to have you back on as uh maybe in 2027 as the markets
37:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): continue
37:52Tony Edward: to grow and uh you know to talk more about it. Because I'm very fascinated by the market making side of the business, which, you know, like you said earlier, it's behind the wall. You don't see it, but it's so critical to the function. of the market.
38:03Julia Zhou: Yeah.
38:04Tony Edward: Julie, got some wrap-up questions here for you.
38:06Julia Zhou: All right, let's do them.
38:07Tony Edward: First, are you an early bird or a night owl?
38:10Julia Zhou: Early bird. My brain doesn't function after 10 p.m.
38:13Tony Edward: Do you prefer a window seat or aisle?
38:15Julia Zhou: Isle. I need to get up and go go pee.
38:20Tony Edward: Do you prefer a text, email, or a call?
38:22Julia Zhou: I am old-fashioned. I'm gonna go with email.
38:25Tony Edward: And what's one
38:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of the things that you're gonna
38:27Tony Edward: company outside of crypto you admire?
38:29Julia Zhou: Ooh. Um Patagonia.
38:31Tony Edward: Oh yeah.
38:32Julia Zhou: You know, they're very profitable, but they're also very principled. And I think that uh, you know, the amount that they care about the environment is, you know, they're doing good things for the world.
38:43Tony Edward: Yeah, one of my favorites too. If you could have dinner with any person living or dead, who would it
38:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be?
38:49Julia Zhou: My husband. I spend a lot of time with my co-founder and business partner. I spend a lot of time with my co-parent, but I would love a little bit more time with my husband.
39:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): They
39:00Julia Zhou: all happen to be the same person.
39:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Same person,
39:02Tony Edward: yeah. Uh best advice you've ever gotten.
39:06Julia Zhou: Ooh. Um pessimists sound smart, optimists make money.
39:12Tony Edward: Mmm, I like that. I'm gonna steal that. You should. Julia, pleasure. Thank you for the insights. And like I said, we'll love to do round two and uh talk in 2027. But thank you so much for uh joining me.
39:24Julia Zhou: Thanks for having me on. This was fun.
39:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Thank you so much for tuning in. Please hit the like button, subscribe if you haven't as yet. If you're listening on a podcast platform such as Spotify or Apple, please follow and leave a five-star five star rating. Thank you so much.