Money Girl

Laura Adams outlines strategies to reduce auto insurance premiums without sacrificing coverage.

22 min Listen to the original Episode page
Auto InsurancePersonal FinanceRisk ManagementInsurance DiscountsCredit Scores

Summary

Laura Adams discusses the current landscape of auto insurance costs, noting a modest 1% increase in 2026 following previous spikes. She advises consumers to perform apples-to-apples comparisons by matching exact policy details when shopping for quotes. Adams recommends higher liability limits than state minimums and suggests umbrella policies for asset protection. She introduces the 10% rule for dropping physical damage coverage on older vehicles and highlights the importance of credit scores and discounts. Finally, she contrasts captive versus independent agents and warns against coverage lapses during switching.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    Nationally, full coverage auto insurance now averages about $2,240 a year, about $187 a month. That's only about a 1% Percent increase for 2026.

    Laura Adams · 0:50

  2. 2
    A captive agent represents a single insurance carrier, and some are state farm, allstate, and farmers. They basically know their company's products inside and out, but that's all they sell. There are also So independent agents or brokers. They represent dozens of different regional and national. carriers.

    Laura Adams · 15:37

  3. 3
    Canceling old coverage before the new policy starts can cause fines, registration suspension, and high-risk flags for 3-5 years.

    Laura Adams · 17:55

Episode sections

  1. 0:44 – 3:15

    Introduction and Auto Insurance Cost Context

    Laura Adams introduces the topic of reviewing auto insurance policies, noting that full coverage averages $2,240 annually. She highlights that while the 2026 increase is modest at 1%, previous years saw massive spikes due to vehicle costs, repair expenses, and medical/legal costs.

  2. 3:15 – 4:34

    The Importance of Apples-to-Apples Comparison

    Adams advises downloading the current policy's declarations page to match exact liability limits, deductibles, and endorsements when requesting new quotes. She warns that lower quotes may result from reduced coverage rather than better rates.

  3. 4:34 – 8:25

    Understanding Auto Insurance Coverages

    The host explains liability coverage (bodily injury and property damage), Personal Injury Protection (PIP) in no-fault states, and uninsured/underinsured motorist coverage. She also distinguishes between collision and comprehensive coverage, noting requirements for leased/financed vehicles.

  4. 8:25 – 10:05

    Recommended Coverage Levels and Umbrella Policies

    Adams argues that state minimums are often too low, leaving personal assets exposed. She recommends at least 100/300/100 liability coverage and suggests an umbrella policy for those with significant assets to protect against lawsuits exceeding auto limits.

  5. 10:05 – 12:00

    The 10% Rule for Dropping Physical Damage Coverage

    For vehicles owned outright, Adams suggests dropping collision and comprehensive coverage if their combined annual cost exceeds 10% of the car's market value minus the deductible. She illustrates this with a $5,000 car example, recommending self-insurance via an emergency fund instead.

  6. 12:00 – 15:37

    Discounts and Credit Scores

    Ways to reduce premiums include raising deductibles, bundling policies, and maintaining good credit. Adams notes that most states use credit-based insurance scores to assess claim likelihood, with exceptions in California, Hawaii, Massachusetts, and Michigan.

  7. 15:37 – 17:16

    Types of Agents and Shopping Strategies

    Adams contrasts captive agents (representing one carrier like State Farm) with independent brokers (representing multiple carriers). She recommends using independent brokers for broad comparisons and obtaining direct quotes from carriers like GEICO or USAA that brokers may not represent.

  8. 17:16 – 21:45

    Switching Policies and Avoiding Lapses

    The host clarifies that policyholders can switch carriers before renewal, with insurers prorating refunds. She identifies the most common mistake as canceling old coverage before the new policy starts, which can cause fines, registration suspension, and high-risk flags for 3-5 years.

Claims worth verifying

Full coverage auto insurance averages about $2,240 a year, or $187 a month, with a 1% increase for 2026.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·0:50

How to verify: Check industry reports from the Insurance Information Institute (III) or the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) for 2026 average premium data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

State auto insurance minimums are often too low, with some states like Florida not requiring bodily injury liability for registration.

Laura Adams ·8:46

How to verify: Review Florida Statutes Chapter 324 and other state Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) or Insurance Department websites for minimum liability requirements. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Laura Adams holds a $1 million umbrella liability policy.

Laura Adams ·9:45

How to verify: This is a personal financial disclosure; verification is not possible via public records unless disclosed in a specific legal filing or interview transcript. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Raising a collision deductible from $500 to $1,000 could save 10% or more on premiums.

Laura Adams ·12:40

How to verify: Request quotes from multiple insurers with different deductible levels to calculate the percentage savings. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Most states allow credit-based insurance scores to influence auto rates, with exceptions in California, Hawaii, Massachusetts, and Michigan.

Laura Adams ·13:39

How to verify: Check state insurance department regulations or the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) model laws regarding credit-based insurance scores. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

GEICO and USAA are direct-to-consumer insurers that independent brokers may not represent.

Laura Adams ·16:37

How to verify: Review GEICO and USAA's distribution channels on their official websites or contact their customer service to confirm if they work exclusively with independent agents. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

A lapse in coverage can flag a driver as high risk, spiking premiums for 3 to 5 years.

Laura Adams ·17:55

How to verify: Consult insurance industry literature on underwriting practices or the Insurance Information Institute (III) regarding the impact of coverage lapses on future premiums. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify the current average annual cost of full coverage auto insurance using data from the Insurance Information Institute or similar industry reports.
  • Check your state's specific minimum liability requirements and compare them to the recommended 100/300/100 limits.
  • Review your current policy's declarations page to identify exact deductibles and endorsements for accurate quote comparison.
  • Calculate the market value of your vehicle using sources like Kelley Blue Book or Edmunds to apply the 10% rule for dropping physical damage coverage.
  • Confirm whether your state uses credit-based insurance scores by checking your state's department of insurance regulations.
  • Identify whether your current agent is captive or independent to understand the breadth of carrier options available.
  • Check for potential high-risk flags on your driving record that might affect future insurability if a lapse occurs.
Full transcriptexpand

0:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Some mornings you want a quick coffee. Other days, a proper cafe moment. With the Ninja Auto Barista Pro, you get both. Pick from 13 drink presets, then save your favorites the way you like them. Hot or iced, it makes silky microfoam hands-free, with dairy or plant-based milk. From busy mornings to slow weekends, Cafe Quality Espresso at home is now part of your routine. Ninja Auto Barista. We take coffee seriously so you don't have to. Discover Ninja Auto Barista and bring cafe quality coffee home. Now serving cafe quality drinks from your countertop. Shop now at sharkninja.ca.

0:44Laura Adams: When was the last time you reviewed your auto insurance or shopped around for a better rate? If

0:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you're

0:50Laura Adams: like most people, you probably set your policy on auto pay and haven't touched it ever since. Nationally, full coverage auto insurance now averages about $2,240 a year, about $187 a month. That's only about a 1% Percent increase for 2026. However, most states had massive spikes in previous years. Auto rates have increased for various reasons, and what you pay also depends on where you live, literally, down to your zip code. One reason is that vehicles cost more, and getting repairs is more expensive as well. Some areas have experienced higher rates of car theft or damage from natural disasters. Plus, medical and legal costs are higher over. overall. So carriers have a lot to consider when setting rates, including adhering to laws set by each state's Department of Insurance. They try to predict the number and the severity of future claims and then set premiums that will cover them and maintain

1:55their profitability. So in today's show, I'm going to focus exclusively on how to shop, compare, and save sales. serious money on auto insurance without sacrificing protection and leaving yourself dangerously exposed. You'll learn which essential coverages you actually need, the highest impact discounts to ask for, and the exact steps to switch carriers. Plus, stick around to the very end because I'll share the single most common mistake people make when changing their auto. insurance. Hey everyone, welcome back. This is episode 1067 of Money Girl. I'm Laura Adams, an award-winning author. I'm also a media spokesperson, a money speaker, and host of this show with over 44 million downloads. Do you have a money question or maybe you want to reach me about a speaking event? You can leave me a voicemail at 302-364-0300. 302-364-0308, or send me an email through my contact page at LauraDadams.com. And in the show notes, you can find links to learn more about me and sign up for my free newsletter, The Money Stack. All right. Once you get an auto insurance policy, I think it's very easy just to forget about it, you know, to forget about periodically shopping and comparing your rate. I'm definitely

3:15guilty of this. And I actually plan to shop my rate this week because I just haven't done it in a while. The last time I shopped my coverage, I was pleased to find that my current insurer was actually giving me the best rate. However, insurers quietly raise rates over time, and your life and your financial circumstances can change, and that might cause you to overpay. or even to be incredibly underinsured. The most important rule to remember when you start shopping auto insurance is to make an apples to apples comparison. So let's say a carrier quotes you an auto insurance rate that's $50 a month cheaper than your current policy. Wow, that sounds amazing, right? Well, the trick is to carefully review. new auto quotes and compare them to your current coverage. A low quote might sound great, but it could be for coverage with a lower liability limit or a higher deductible. So before you start shopping, you want to log into your current provider's website or app and download your policy's declarations page. That's where you're going to see all your coverage information, like deductible. deductibles and endorsements. They should be listed there. You want to use those exact same coverages and numbers on a new quote. So that

4:34ensures you're comparing the same thing. On your declarations page, you'll see that auto insurance isn't one coverage, it's actually a package of coverages. And the types and amounts that you must have depend on where you live because insurance is regulated. by states. To be sure you understand what you're paying for and what you need and maybe don't need, I'm gonna review what you might see on your auto policy. Liability coverage. You're gonna definitely see this. This is the most important part of auto insurance because it protects you from lawsuits if you injure people and their property. For instance, let's say you cause a crash and you hurt another driver or their passengers. There is a bodily injury liability component of your policy that would pay for their medical bills, lost wages, and any legal bills, up to a limit. You also have property damage coverage that pays to repair or replace something

5:35you damage in a crash, like another car or a street sign or a fence. Now, states have different minimum liability limits, and it's usually written as three numbers like 25 slash 50 slash 25. Here's how to read them: that first number is bodily injury per person. So that would be $25,000 per person. The second number is the total per accident. In this case, my example is $50,000. And then the third number in my example is $25,000. That would be for property damage. Now you may also see personal injury protection or PIP. This is another component of auto insurance in some states. It pays for your medical expenses, your lost wages, and perhaps any childcare needed after. a crash. Now, PIP is only required in what are called no-fault states, like my home state, Florida, where each driver must file medical claims with their own insurer first, regardless of who caused a crash. In no-fault states, you can only sue the other driver if your injuries and medical costs exceed a limit. However, most states are at fault, meaning the person who

6:53caused a car accident is financially responsible for damages and can be sued. Some states require you to purchase uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage, and others make it optional. This coverage protects you in an accident with someone who has no insurance or maybe not enough insurance to pay your medical bills or to repair your vehicle. Unfortunately, many people drive without insurance, especially when premiums become unaffordable. So I definitely recommend keeping uninsured and underinsured coverage, even if your state doesn't require it. It's relatively inexpensive. And like I said, it's going to protect you from other people's bad financial decisions. Auto insurance also includes collision coverage. That pays to repair or replace your vehicle if you get into an accident. Now, if you have an auto loan or a vehicle lease, it's required. You've got to have collision. However,

7:54you can opt not to buy collision coverage if you own a vehicle in full. But, you know, again, you want to be financially prepared for the worst if you don't have collision. There's also comprehensive coverage that pays for almost everything else that isn't a collision, like theft of your car or damage from hail, floods, falling branches, vandalism, or even hitting an animal like a deer. Again, if you own your vehicle outright, Right, you can opt out of comprehensive, but otherwise, it's required.

8:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All right,

8:26Laura Adams: so when you're trying to save money, I think it can be tempting to carry only the bare minimum in auto insurance. The problem is that state minimums can be dangerously low, like $25,000 or less in bodily injury liability per person. In fact, my home state of Florida doesn't even require most drivers to have bodily injury. liability to register a car. If you cause an accident that results in someone's hospital stay, a surgery, or involves multiple vehicles, having no or a low liability leaves you very financially vulnerable. That's because the injured party or parties can sue you directly for amounts that exceed your insurance coverage. So, regardless of your state's auto liability requirement, consider getting more to protect your assets. You know, unless you have a very low net worth, I recommend having at least 100, 300,000, 100. That's 100,000 in bodily injury per person, 300,000 $100,000 per accident, and 100,000 for property damage. Again, that's 100. slash $300 slash $100. If you need protection above those amounts, consider

9:45getting an umbrella liability policy. It can be more affordable than just significantly boosting your auto insurance liability. For instance, I have a $1 million umbrella liability policy that would kick in if I exceed my auto insurance liability. limits. However, for risks that don't involve other people, like repairing or replacing an older vehicle or one you own in full, consider a 10% rule for collision and comprehensive coverages. Here's how it works: if the annual cost of your collision and comprehensive coverage combined is more than 10% of your car's. actual market value, less your deductible, it might be time to drop them. Let me give you an example. Let's say your car is worth $5,000. Like, you know, that's probably the most you could get for it. And you have a $500 auto insurance deductible. The difference is $4,500. So take 10% of that. That's $450.

10:51So if you're paying more than $450 annually for collision and comprehensive combined, it likely isn't worth it. Especially if you have funds in a savings account to pay for potential damages. Plus, if you put your savings, you know, if you stop paying collision and comprehensive and you put that savings into an emergency fund. it helps you self-insure.

11:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Some mornings you want a quick coffee. Other days a proper cafe moment. With the Ninja Auto Barista Pro, you get both. Pick from 13 drink presets, then save your favorites the way you like them. Hot or iced, it makes silky microfoam hands-free with dairy or plant-based milk. From busy mornings to slow even. weekends, Cafe Quality Espresso at home is now part of your routine. Ninja Auto Barista. We take coffee seriously, so you don't have to. Discover Ninja Auto Barista and bring cafe quality coffee home. Now serving cafe quality drinks from your countertop. Shop now at sharkninja.ca.

12:00Laura Adams: Okay, now that you know what coverage. coverages are mandatory and optional, let's talk about other ways to save money. If you can't or you shouldn't drop protections or lower them, discounts can be the key to cutting premiums. While your auto deductible isn't technically a discount, raising it is an easy way to lower your rate. There is a deductible on both collision and comprehensive. that you can change. The higher your deductible, the lower your premium. For instance, if your collision deductible is 500, you might bump it to 1,000. That could save you 10% or more, just depending on your home state and your carrier. Yes, a higher deductible means you've got to pay more out of pocket before your coverage begins. But remember, insurance is designed to protect you from disasters, not to cover your small inconveniences. So get quotes on different deductibles to see how they would change your premium. Another significant way to save on insurance is bundling policies, which is called a multi-policy Policy discount. Basically, carriers want more of your business, so they might give you a 10 or 20%. discount if you purchase auto insurance and home or renters,

13:19life, or umbrella policies with them. But there's no guarantee about that. So you want to shop a bundle and price individual policies separately. Also, most states are going to look at your credit. Now, there is an exception in California, Hawaii, Massachusetts, and Michigan. Most states will allow a credit-based insurance score to influence your auto insurance rate. That's a special credit score that basically estimates how likely you are to file an insurance claim. And in general, having a higher regular credit score boosts your credit-based insurance score and will cut your insurance premiums. Now you can't raise your credit overnight, but it is good to know that achieving and maintaining good credit can pay off with your insurance. Auto insurance discounts do vary by insurance companies, but they typically include savings for these eight things. One is telematics. This is using some kind of a mobile app or even a plug-in device inside your vehicle that tracks various. safe driving habits, and then you get a discount if you are a safe driver. If you insure multiple vehicles, if you maintain a clean driving record with no moving violations or

14:38accidents, even being a student driver who's under 25 with good grades, such as keeping at least a B Be average, driving low annual miles, like less than 7,500 or 10,000. miles a year, can get you a discount. And completing a safe driver course, such as Aceable's defensive driving course, you can learn more at Aceable.com and belonging to certain organizations like a university, a professional association, or a credit union, you know, in some cases, can offer an affinity discount. And even setting up paperless statements and automatic premium payments can lower your rate. And you can check your policy to see what discounts are currently in place. And if you believe you're missing any, be sure to ask your agent for ways to save. Okay, when you're actually ready to shop auto insurance, what's the easiest way to do it? Well, the main types of insurance agents that you might consider are cash. captive agents and independent brokers. Let me explain the difference. A captive agent represents a single insurance carrier, and some are state farm, allstate, and farmers. They basically know their company's products inside and out, but that's all they sell. There are also So

15:57independent agents or brokers. They represent dozens of different regional and national. carriers. So basically, you can hand them your declarations page, and then they can shop it across their entire network to find you the best option for your situation. They get paid a commission from the insurer, not you. So if you want a thorough comparison, my recommendation is to contact a reputable independent broker who can give you quotes for multiple carriers. Then you might get direct quotes from any major direct to consumer insurers like GEICO or USAA if you're eligible for them, that the agent, the independent agent can't provide you. That should give you plenty of options to consider. You can also get quotes from various online quote aggregator sites. The problem is many aren't actually. actual comparison tools. They simply sell your information to carriers who will then start contacting you. And that can be a fine way to go if you understand the process. So once you've done the best apples to apples comparison possible for your auto insurance, you may decide you want to switch carriers. Many people mistakenly believe that they have to wait until their auto policy. renewal

17:16date to switch. If your auto policy renews in six months, you can switch today, even if you prepaid your premiums. Your insurer must prorate your coverage by refunding any unearned paid premiums if you switch. And a few carriers might charge you a small administrative fee, like $25 or $50. bucks to switch. So there's basically no downside to switching before your auto policy's renewal date. Now, here's the single most common mistake people make when changing their auto insurance: it's canceling your old policy before your new policy takes effect. Even a 24-hour lapse can trigger state fines, suspension of vehicles. vehicle registration, and worst of all, flag you as a high risk driver. That can instantly spike your premiums for the next three to five years. So, as I mentioned, your first step is going to be pulling out your current declarations page so you've got a baseline on the coverages and the rate you're paying right now. That's essential for getting a true comparison, and it's really easy just to send that to a broker. or a carrier. Second, is to contact one or more reputable independent insurance brokers who represent dozens of regional and

18:35national insurance companies. They can shop your current coverages across many insurers. Again, it's no cost to you. Now, you may want to ask AI about how to find the best contacts. Here's an AI prompt you can copy and paste from the show notes. You might say, I live in this city, state, or zip code and am looking for the top five reputable independent insurance agencies or brokers in my area that handle personal auto insurance and optionally home renters and umbrella liability bundling. Prioritize established local agencies that represent multiple national. and regional auto insurers, have good client reviews, and no consumer facing broker fees for personal auto policies. Okay, so I know that's long, but basically the more specific that you can be with AI prompts, the better. Remember to ask brokers for auto quotes with higher deductibles. You know, if that's something you're considering, especially if your emergency fund can handle

19:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.

19:39Laura Adams: And make sure they include every possible discount you're eligible for. Third, get direct quotes from any major direct to consumer insurers, again, like GICO or USAA, that brokers didn't provide you. And finally, make a switch without letting your old coverage lap, laps, even for an hour. If you're planning to shop your car insurance, this week, like me, let me know how much you save. And again, go to the show notes to get that AI prompt if you're interested in using AI to find some local reputable brokers. If you enjoyed today's show, take a few seconds to subscribe to the Money Girl Podcast newsletter. That's in addition to the money stack I mentioned earlier. The Money Girl Podcast newsletter focuses primarily on the podcast. and you can find a link in the show notes or at quickandirtytips.com. That's all for now. I'll talk to you soon. Until then, here's to living a richer life. Money Girl is a quick and dirty tips podcast. We've got a great team. I want to thank Steve Rickyberg, our audio engineer. Holly Hutchins is our director of podcast. Morgan Christensen is our manager of creative partnerships and business development. Rebecca Sebastian is our marketing and publicity manager. Nathaniel Hoops is our marketing contractor. And Maram El Nagib is our

20:59podcast associate.

21:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Some mornings you want a quick coffee. Other days, a proper cafe moment. With the Ninja Auto Barista Pro, you get both. Pick from 13 drink presets, then save your favorites the way you like them. Hot or iced, it makes silky microfoam hands-free, with dairy or plant-based milk. From busy mornings to slow weekends, Cafe Quality Espresso at home is now part of your routine. Ninja Auto Barista. We take coffee seriously, so you don't have to. Discover Ninja Auto Barista and bring Cafe Quality Coffee home. Now serving, cafe quality drinks from your countertop. Shop now at sharkninja.ca

This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights