Money of Mine

Jeremy Raper on AI-Driven Activism, Regulatory Loopholes, and Capital Sizing in Australian Microcaps

57 min Listen to the original Episode page
Shareholder ActivismAustralian MiningRegulatory ComplianceCorporate GovernanceSmall-Cap ValueAI in Finance

Summary

Jeremy Raper argues that AI has reduced the cost of shareholder activism by approximately 99%, enabling investors to pursue value in small-cap companies with smaller positions. He details specific cases in the Australian mining sector, including a successful challenge against illegal control acquisition at DGR Resources and an ongoing activist campaign against governance failures at Terracom. Raper also highlights Alara Resources as an undervalued copper producer and discusses the strategic importance of capital sizing, citing the 'Hum situation' as a lesson in why larger stakes are necessary to bypass bureaucratic proxy advisors and force quicker resolutions.

Episode sections

  1. 0:00 – 6:42

    AI and the Deflation of Activism Costs

    Jeremy Raper explains that AI has drastically reduced the frictional and legal costs of shareholder activism, making it viable to pursue value in small-cap companies. He contrasts his recent legal spend of $3,000 with a previous campaign costing nearly $500,000, attributing the difference to AI-assisted document review and drafting.

  2. 6:42 – 10:48

    The Takeovers Panel and Regulatory Lag

    Raper discusses the Australian Takeovers Panel, describing it as a referee for market integrity that is currently struggling to cope with the increased volume of AI-enabled filings. He notes an imbalance where practitioners can process thousands of pages quickly while regulators may still rely on manual processes.

  3. 10:48 – 20:42

    DGR Case Study: Identifying Illegal Control

    Raper details his investigation into DGR Resources, focusing on a suspicious transaction involving the Mather Group and an offshore entity, 10 Star Trading. He argues that a coordinated off-market share purchase was structured to keep the Mather Group below the 20% control threshold, violating the Corporations Act.

  4. 20:42 – 26:28

    Regulatory Outcome and Minority Protection

    The Takeovers Panel ruled that the Mather Group had illegally acquired control, requiring them to unwind their stake to 20%. This results in the sale of 25% of their shares, which will be held by ASIC. Raper highlights that the orders include protections requiring minority shareholder approval for any future takeover bids.

  5. 26:28 – 33:26

    Terracom: Distressed Coal Asset and Governance Concerns

    Jeremy Raper discusses Terracom, a semi-distressed coal company that underwent a rights issue allowing an Indonesian group (Orbit Marketing) to acquire control. Raper details suspicious elements, including undisclosed funding sources, a change in Orbit's ownership to a Balinese hotel operator, and a massive, late-disclosed asset impairment.

  6. 33:26 – 41:33

    Terracom: Impairment Analysis and Activist Strategy

    Raper argues that Terracom's impairment used unusually conservative assumptions (20% discount rate vs. industry 10-12%) to write down assets, potentially masking cash flow generation. He outlines his activist approach, involving regulatory complaints and public pressure to address governance failures and minority shareholder treatment.

  7. 41:33 – 47:28

    Alara Resources: Copper Producer Valuation

    The discussion shifts to Alara Resources, a copper producer in Oman. Raper views it as an attractive bet due to its low valuation (2x free cash flow), improving unit economics as strip ratios decrease, and the potential for debt reduction as shipments resume. He notes the complexity of its 51% ownership structure.

  8. 47:28 – 50:29

    Canyon Resources: Underbid and Control Dispute

    Raper briefly touches on Canyon Resources, noting the unusual nature of a controlling shareholder making a bid at 40% below the existing stock price. He suggests this may involve regulatory scrutiny regarding the treatment of minority shareholders, similar to other cases he has analyzed.

  9. 50:29 – 51:15

    Reflections on the Hum Situation and Capital Sizing

    Jeremy Raper discusses a 'bad year' and identifies the 'Hum situation' as a key learning experience regarding capital sizing. He argues that having insufficient capital (a 'water pistol') prevented him from effectively challenging a dominant shareholder who was destroying company value.

  10. 51:15 – 54:42

    The Hum Case: Governance Failures and Proxy Advisor Challenges

    Raper details a conflict where a 30% shareholder (the Chairman) attempted to expropriate value from minority shareholders. Despite the stock trading at half book value and the Chairman rejecting a third-party bid at a 30% premium, proxy advisors were slow to support Raper’s campaign to remove the board.

  11. 54:42 – 57:03

    Strategic Shift: From Persuasion to Leverage

    Raper explains that with larger capital positions (15-20%), activists can force negotiations without relying on proxy advisors. He emphasizes that 'time kills all deals' in distressed or stagnant microcaps, so having a 'bazooka' allows activists to resolve issues faster before opportunities expire.

Claims worth verifying

Raper's legal costs for a recent Takeovers Panel case were $3,000, compared to nearly $500,000 for a previous campaign involving Hum Group.

Unidentified speaker ·

How to verify: Review public filings and cost disclosures from the Hum Group campaign and the DGR Resources Takeovers Panel proceedings.

AI reduced the cost of legal work for Raper by 99% compared to traditional legal billing rates of $800-$1,000 per hour.

Unidentified speaker ·

How to verify: Compare the total legal bills from the Hum Group case with the DGR case, and check standard Australian legal hourly rates.

In Australia, the control threshold for mandatory bid requirements is 20%, which is lower than the 30% threshold in the UK.

Unidentified speaker ·

How to verify: Check the Australian Corporations Act Chapter 6 and UK City Code on Takeovers and Mergers.

DGR Resources was trading at a discount to its net asset value of approximately 6-7 cents per share, while the stock price was 2.5-3 cents.

Unidentified speaker ·

How to verify: Review DGR Resources' financial reports and share price history during the period of the Mather Group transaction.

The Mather Group increased its stake from 15-16% to 19.9% through a coordinated transaction with 10 Star Trading to avoid crossing the 20% threshold.

Unidentified speaker ·

How to verify: Examine the Takeovers Panel decision and filings regarding the May transaction involving DGR Resources.

10 Star Trading is an offshore entity with no natural persons listed on documents, linked to the Mather Group through historical investment patterns.

Unidentified speaker ·

How to verify: Conduct corporate registry searches in the British Virgin Islands and Hong Kong, and review historical shareholding disclosures of DGR Resources.

The Takeovers Panel ordered the Mather Group to sell 25% of its stake to return to the 20% control limit.

Unidentified speaker ·

How to verify: Read the official orders issued by the Australian Takeovers Panel in the DGR Resources matter.

The Takeovers Panel orders require a majority of minority shareholders to approve any future takeover bid for DGR Resources.

Unidentified speaker ·

How to verify: Review the specific conditions laid out in the Takeovers Panel's decision orders for DGR Resources.

Raper lost a previous Takeovers Panel case against GWR Group regarding association, but the company later paid special dividends.

Unidentified speaker ·

How to verify: Check the published reasons for decision from the Takeovers Panel regarding GWR Group and subsequent dividend announcements.

The 'creep provision' in Australia allows shareholders to increase their stake by 3% every six months without triggering a full bid.

Unidentified speaker ·

How to verify: Review the Corporations Act provisions regarding 'creep' acquisitions in Chapter 6.

Terracom took a $50 million EBIT loss last year and wrote down the book value of its assets almost to zero.

Jeremy Raper ·27:54

How to verify: Check Terracom's annual financial report for the fiscal year prior to the impairment announcement for EBIT figures and asset write-downs.

Orbit Marketing owned just under 20% (19%) of Terracom before the rights issue.

Jeremy Raper ·29:03

How to verify: Review Terracom's ASX announcements or shareholder registers from before the rights issue to confirm Orbit Marketing's stake percentage.

Orbit Marketing's acquisition of its initial 20% stake in Terracom was funded with only $10,000-$15,000 SGD in equity capital, with the rest coming from undisclosed sources.

Jeremy Raper ·30:45

How to verify: Check the paid-in capital of Orbit Marketing (a Singapore-domiciled company) via Singapore corporate registry filings.

Terracom used a 20% pre-tax discount rate for its asset impairment, while other coal companies use 10-12%.

Jeremy Raper ·34:22

How to verify: Review Terracom's impairment note in its financial statements and compare with impairment notes of peer coal companies.

Alara Resources trades at approximately 2x free cash flow.

Jeremy Raper ·46:09

How to verify: Calculate Alara's market capitalization divided by its trailing or forward free cash flow as reported in its financial statements.

Alara's current strip ratio is 6-7:1, with a long-term mine plan of 3.5-4:1.

Jeremy Raper ·45:41

How to verify: Check Alara Resources' technical reports or operational updates for current and planned strip ratios.

Canyon Resources' controlling shareholder made a bid at 40% below the existing stock price.

Jeremy Raper ·48:16

How to verify: Review Canyon Resources' takeover bid announcement and compare the offer price to the stock price on the day prior to the bid.

Terracom's independent director Mark Chadwick left the board due to disagreements over strategic direction and risk management.

Jeremy Raper ·32:25

How to verify: Check Terracom's ASX announcements regarding board changes and Mark Chadwick's resignation statement.

Orbit Marketing changed hands during the rights offer period, with the entity being sold to a Balinese hotelier.

Jeremy Raper ·31:49

How to verify: Review Orbit Marketing's corporate filings or news reports from the relevant period to confirm ownership changes.

Alara Resources owns 51% of its primary asset.

Jeremy Raper ·44:52

How to verify: Check Alara Resources' corporate structure disclosures or annual report to confirm the ownership percentage of its main asset.

Raper personally owned 5-6% of Hum, and his co-conveners owned 3-3.5%, totaling approximately 10% ownership.

Unidentified speaker ·51:46

How to verify: Check Hum's shareholder register or proxy filings (e.g., Schedule 13D or equivalent) from the relevant period to confirm Raper's and his partners' disclosed ownership percentages.

The dominant shareholder in Hum owned 30% of the company.

Unidentified speaker ·51:50

How to verify: Check Hum's shareholder register or proxy filings from the relevant period to confirm the largest shareholder's stake.

Hum's stock price had declined 90% over the last 10 years prior to the campaign.

Unidentified speaker ·52:03

How to verify: Calculate the total return of Hum's stock over the 10-year period preceding the activist campaign using historical price data.

Hum was trading at half of its book value at the time of the campaign.

Unidentified speaker ·52:15

How to verify: Compare Hum's market capitalization to its total shareholders' equity (book value) from its financial statements during the campaign period.

The Chairman of Hum cycled through six or seven CEOs during his tenure.

Unidentified speaker ·52:03

How to verify: Review Hum's corporate history or annual reports to count the number of CEO changes during the Chairman's tenure.

Do your own research

  • Verify the current shareholding structure and beneficial ownership of DGR Resources, Orbit Marketing (Terracom), and Alara Resources via ASIC filings and company announcements.
  • Review the specific discount rates used in Terracom’s impairment tests compared to peer group averages to assess the validity of the asset write-down.
  • Check the latest rulings and orders from the Australian Takeovers Panel regarding the DGR Resources case to confirm minority shareholder protections.
  • Analyze Alara Resources’ strip ratio trends and debt reduction schedules to validate the projected improvement in unit economics and free cash flow.
  • Examine the voting records and statements of major proxy advisors regarding the Hum situation to understand the delay in board removal support.
  • Investigate the 'creep provision' rules under the Australian Corporations Act to understand the legal limits on gradual control acquisition.
  • Review Canyon Resources’ bid documents to assess the rationale behind the 40% discount to the existing stock price and any regulatory scrutiny involved.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00
Unidentified speaker: Now, with the massive deflation in costs that AI has largely provided, it's just opened up a whole world of opportunity.
0:06
Unidentified speaker: Traditional activism encompasses a huge number of technical communications.
0:10
Unidentified speaker: Like legal filings.
0:11
Unidentified speaker: $800 an hour always would slave over and get right.
0:14
Unidentified speaker: You know, for 90% of your work, it's probably good enough.
0:17
Unidentified speaker: Certainly at 99% cheaper.
0:21
Unidentified speaker: Jeremy Rafer, absolutely wonderful to um to speak with you in the flesh.
0:25
Unidentified speaker: It's been here.
0:26
Unidentified speaker: It's been a few years.
0:27
Unidentified speaker: I think you you uh you stood me up in Perth six months ago, mate.
0:31
Unidentified speaker: I was there.
0:32
Unidentified speaker: I yeah, I did do that.
0:33
Unidentified speaker: I did do that.
0:34
Unidentified speaker: But it was late.
0:35
Unidentified speaker: It was like we've got to get a beer in.
0:36
Unidentified speaker: It was late.
0:36
Unidentified speaker: I didn't give you much notice.
0:37
Unidentified speaker: So fair enough.
0:38
Unidentified speaker: I'll I'll take half the blame for that for sure.
0:39
Unidentified speaker: Thank thankfully we scheduled this one a bit further in advance.
0:42
Unidentified speaker: Um I think everyone has to be paying attention to what you're doing in the market, especially in the our market lately.
0:48
Unidentified speaker: You you you're proli you're prolific.
0:50
Unidentified speaker: You're um you're more active than you ever have.
0:53
Unidentified speaker: If people don't know, you know, you've got a reputation as an activist shareholder, you agitate, you have an influence, and very recently you've you've taken an exceptionally keen interest in a bunch of busted up mining microcaps that are latent cash boxes, um, which I've looked at with a lens for a long time of thinking these are value traps, and you've seemingly figured out a way to unlock value where I thought there were value traps.
1:19
Unidentified speaker: What's changed?
1:19
Unidentified speaker: Like why is this sector so interesting right now?
1:22
Unidentified speaker: What's changed?
1:23
Unidentified speaker: Um so so look at AI.
1:28
Unidentified speaker: Okay, so so AI is obviously a very, very powerful tool.
1:30
Unidentified speaker: If you look at why a cash box has been trapped and has nothing's happened there for a long time, um there I guess there's two main reasons that fund managers will typically give.
1:41
Unidentified speaker: One is reputation.
1:43
Unidentified speaker: We don't want to be seen as a guy who goes in there and you know throws their kid out the pram and causes a lot of trouble and it makes it hard to raise assets, etc.
1:49
Unidentified speaker: So that hasn't changed.
1:50
Unidentified speaker: The other thing is friction.
1:52
Unidentified speaker: Friction is basically like cost, right?
1:54
Unidentified speaker: So, you know, a lot of these situations are pretty small companies, right?
1:57
Unidentified speaker: They're $50 million cash boxes, $100 million cash boxes.
2:00
Unidentified speaker: You know, even if you're a small cap fund manager, it's just not worth your while to go after that.
2:05
Unidentified speaker: It's not, or maybe it is here and there, but it's not scalable.
2:07
Unidentified speaker: Okay, but oftentimes there's a lot of discrete high fixed costs to attacking what could be a small amount of money in that box, right?
2:14
Unidentified speaker: So what's changed with AI is all of a sudden the frictional cost of pursuing some of these alternate angles to get the money out has come way down.
2:24
Unidentified speaker: So, for example, if you take the it's not a resources stock, but it's relevant to what to what I'm about to say.
2:28
Unidentified speaker: So I I led a campaign to reconstitute the board of a company called Hum Group Limited, H-U-M, that was, I mean, still ongoing in many ways, but let's call it not successful on its face.
2:40
Unidentified speaker: Um, and it was a very elongated process, consumed a huge amount of time, energy, and money.
2:44
Unidentified speaker: Um, and in that lead up to an EGM, so that's an extraordinary general meeting, uh, you know, uh notice of meeting, paperwork, legals, all that must have spent close to half a million bucks.
2:56
Unidentified speaker: Not solely myself, but the the convening shareholders spent close to half a million bucks, of which legal was probably three to four hundred grand, let's say.
3:02
Unidentified speaker: Um, you know, that was a that sorry, that that included a takeovers panel, a very long and complicated takeovers panel case that went through a couple of appeals.
3:08
Unidentified speaker: So there was a large discrete legal component to that cost.
3:12
Unidentified speaker: I just went through a similarly long and tortured takeovers panel case that did not have an EGM attached to it, uh, but nevertheless was a very long takeovers panel case that had thousands of submissions, whatever it was, and my grand total spend was $3,000.
3:26
Unidentified speaker: So my legal bill went down not 50%, not 80%, not 90%, not 95%.
3:32
Unidentified speaker: It went down 99%.
3:34
Unidentified speaker: Okay, so you know, every case is slightly different.
3:38
Unidentified speaker: That's not to say it's a pure apples-apples comparison, but the frictional cost of attacking these opportunities using the regulatory apparatus that we have has come down massively, massively.
3:49
Unidentified speaker: So what does that mean?
3:50
Unidentified speaker: Like in harm, I had a lot of eggs in that basket, sizing wise.
3:53
Unidentified speaker: So I was almost committed to spend, you know, with the benefit of hindsight, it was a terrible, terrible uh uh way to construction investment and to pursue an investment.
4:02
Unidentified speaker: But you know, I almost had to spend that money on legals because I had so much money in the stock.
4:06
Unidentified speaker: Now, if you if you're gonna mention something like DGR, it's a very small investment for me.
4:11
Unidentified speaker: But it's still very worthwhile because my legal cost is zero.
4:15
Unidentified speaker: Zero.
4:16
Unidentified speaker: So I can actually pursue things when I only have six figures, well in this case, seven figures in the stock.
4:21
Unidentified speaker: I mean, no even a small fund man is not gonna pursue a legal strategy to get value out with seven figures in a stock.
4:28
Unidentified speaker: Even eight figures is not gonna be enough to cut it.
4:31
Unidentified speaker: But now with the massive deflation in costs that AI has largely provided, um it's just opened up a whole world of opportunity.
4:39
Unidentified speaker: A whole world of opportunity.
4:40
Unidentified speaker: Like think about all the like traditional activism, what is it, encompass?
4:44
Unidentified speaker: Okay, it encompasses a huge number of technical communications, sending letters to boards, um, making presentations, um, sending missives to shareholders, communicating with shareholders, uh, filing EGM documents, paperworks, like legal filings, right?
5:01
Unidentified speaker: That lawyers would spend, you know, $1,000 an hour lawyers, $800 an hour lawyers would slave over and get right.
5:06
Unidentified speaker: Now, and that's not to say AI is as good as your top legals at Minters or whatever, uh, but you know, for for 90% of your work, it's probably good enough.
5:15
Unidentified speaker: Certainly at 99% cheaper, it's definitely good enough, right?
5:18
Unidentified speaker: It's like the old your it's the exact same phenomenon as like a LCD screen in TV.
5:22
Unidentified speaker: You know, in 2005, everyone had a flat screen T well, excuse me, a flat screen TV cost 2,500 bucks, 3,000 bucks.
5:31
Unidentified speaker: In 1995, they cost 10,000 bucks.
5:33
Unidentified speaker: You know what a flat screen, a 16-inch flat screen costs today?
5:35
Unidentified speaker: 500 bucks.
5:36
Unidentified speaker: You don't have to get Sony, Sony's out of business, Toshiba's out of business.
5:39
Unidentified speaker: You can just get any one of 20 not unknown Chinese brands, and they're all you know, they're 95% as good as Sony, or 98% as good as Sony.
5:47
Unidentified speaker: It's the exact same age-old uh uh pattern we see in technology advancement.
5:51
Unidentified speaker: That is, cost deflation goes to the benefit of the consumer.
5:54
Unidentified speaker: In this case, the consumer being me, the consumer of the legal services.
5:58
Unidentified speaker: So that's that's a very key part of why now.
6:01
Unidentified speaker: But on the on the other side of that, there are humans that have to digest it, take it as a panel, whatever it might be.
6:06
Unidentified speaker: They have to go through all the the filings on all the work.
6:09
Unidentified speaker: And if everyone just jumps on board and starts doing this, you know, at kind of nauseam for them, either the process slows down or there's got to be some sort of give there, or maybe the the barrier becomes a bit higher.
6:20
Unidentified speaker: Governance gets better, like or guys.
6:24
Unidentified speaker: I've never known you'd be so hopeful.
6:26
Unidentified speaker: So so things definitely slow down.
6:30
Unidentified speaker: There's certainly an adoption curve, and some consumers of and adopters are at the forefront of the curve, and others at the end of the curve, and oftentimes the regulatory apparatus is at the end of the curve.
6:42
Unidentified speaker: So you've probably noticed.
6:43
Unidentified speaker: I mean, you're you're an active follower of things like the takeovers panel.
6:45
Unidentified speaker: You just had Ben on the show, right?
6:47
Unidentified speaker: From from Harvest Lane.
6:48
Unidentified speaker: So, like you know, I'm happy the takeovers panel exists, don't get me wrong, and they're an important function in the parts of the market that I look at and operate in.
6:57
Unidentified speaker: But clearly, they took an inordinate amount of time to decide various cases, and they're obviously I mean, they obviously cannot uh uh cope or having trouble coping with the new pace of AI enablement, right?
7:09
Unidentified speaker: Like, you know, my ability to wade through thousands of pages of court documents and filings has gone up 10,000%, and they're probably still doing most all of it manually, right?
7:19
Unidentified speaker: There's obviously a massive imbalance there.
7:20
Unidentified speaker: You alone are probably responsible for like 60% of the work at the moment.
7:23
Unidentified speaker: Mate, I'm banning three for four of the panel this year.
7:26
Unidentified speaker: So I bet they love you.
7:27
Unidentified speaker: But the panel, the panel's become like the latest arsenal in your talk, it feels like you're like Yeah.
7:33
Unidentified speaker: I mean, yeah, look, the panel, uh how much background do you have to go into the panel?
7:38
Unidentified speaker: I mean, it's it's I think Ben on the last show you had made an interesting analogy.
7:43
Unidentified speaker: He said they're the referee for takeovers in the country.
7:45
Unidentified speaker: I thought that was interesting in in a number of ways.
7:48
Unidentified speaker: Uh, particularly the the the the concluding thing that he said where you know they're the referee, sometimes they say a yellow, sometimes they say a red, and sometimes you really disagree with their decision.
7:57
Unidentified speaker: It's a good way to put it.
7:59
Unidentified speaker: So you can play the game on the field, um, you appeal for the foul, and sometimes they call the foul, and they say it's a foul, and you keep playing the game.
8:11
Unidentified speaker: So it's but for me, I'm more like, well, you called the foul, like, should I get a penalty?
8:14
Unidentified speaker: Doesn't always work that way.
8:16
Unidentified speaker: But look, yes, they're they're doing an important function.
8:18
Unidentified speaker: Um, I have my, you know, obviously my pick I pick a few bones with them here and there, but all in all, they're definitely positive for the markets.
8:25
Unidentified speaker: But equally, I think the advent of technology that enables, you know, people to make better use of the apparatus that we have, that look, it's in the Corporations Act, right?
8:35
Unidentified speaker: Like they're there to maintain the integrity of the markets.
8:37
Unidentified speaker: I mean, there's nothing more fundamental than the integrity of the markets when there's a change of control.
8:41
Unidentified speaker: That's not quite the be-all and the end all, but it's one of the most important uh uh facets of free market, right?
8:48
Unidentified speaker: Um, and so to the extent that it becomes easier for practitioners like myself to shine a light upon conduct that they themselves have called extremely serious or the most serious breaches, whatever it is they said in the in the filing on DGR recently, to the extent that I'm able to leverage technology to bring those kinds of um cases, you know, in a very kind of uh what's the word for it?
9:09
Unidentified speaker: Altruistic sense, not a profit motivated sense.
9:11
Unidentified speaker: In an altruistic sense, it should be good for the market.
9:14
Unidentified speaker: Like I think Ben said a similar thing on his pod, uh on your pod with him the other day.
9:18
Unidentified speaker: Like, we're there's not a charity, you know.
9:21
Unidentified speaker: I I'm a I'm a raging capitalist, right?
9:23
Unidentified speaker: I want I'm here to make money, but so is the biotech company that's finding the new cancer drug.
9:28
Unidentified speaker: They're not in it for love of the game.
9:30
Unidentified speaker: Well, of course they are in a in a in a you know, their employees believe in helping people, etc.
9:35
Unidentified speaker: And you know, I I want to you know uphold the standards of the markets and and think it's um it's obviously to everyone's benefit to have a better functioning market, but also you still want to make money.
9:45
Unidentified speaker: You wouldn't you wouldn't you wouldn't be doing this if you weren't making money.
9:47
Unidentified speaker: Well, uh but no one no one would be doing anything worth doing if they weren't having it for money, right?
9:52
Unidentified speaker: So let's talk about DGR because this is an instance where a foul was called and and and you got a penalty.
9:58
Unidentified speaker: Um and the the the the rhetoric out of or the the the wording out of the panel was was extraordinary.
10:04
Unidentified speaker: Like um and now 25% of um of of stock will will vest with a with ASIC and it needs to be sold.
10:12
Unidentified speaker: But I want I want you to talk me through like from identification of this all the way through to like the playbook that you employed and how like your your actual strategy for getting this outcome, which many people have looked at the discount to nav the DGR has traded over a long period of time.
10:25
Unidentified speaker: Shareholders have been aggravated when when that company's embarked on financing of various various um uh iterations, and no one until now has been able to kind of get an outcome.
10:36
Unidentified speaker: So look, it's uh it's a long and tortured history, but but I'll try to stick to what's in the public domain and what's been you know uh disclosed in the panel findings because otherwise it might get a bit messy and hard to follow.
10:48
Unidentified speaker: But there's various categories of panel cases, okay?
10:51
Unidentified speaker: So some of them have to do with uh change of control in the context of an attempt to buy the company or a substantial share of the company or a per perceived change of control of the company.
11:02
Unidentified speaker: So it doesn't have to be necessarily have to be 100% of the company's changing hands, it just turns on this phrase change of control or affecting control.
11:09
Unidentified speaker: So it could be a very small percent of the company around a key control threshold.
11:13
Unidentified speaker: In Australia, one of the key control gateways, not the only one, but probably the most important one is the 20% threshold.
11:19
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
11:19
Unidentified speaker: Okay.
11:20
Unidentified speaker: Why is that important?
11:21
Unidentified speaker: Okay, so so with without giving too much other uh uh backstory, in many MA markets around the world, okay, you have a mandatory bid regime.
11:29
Unidentified speaker: That means if you go above a certain threshold, the regulators determine that you need to bid for all the minority shares because control has effectively passed.
11:36
Unidentified speaker: And if you pass that threshold and the minorities are stuck, subordinated, dominated vehicle for it could be in perpetuity, and there's just a huge risk of disenfranchisement over time.
11:45
Unidentified speaker: Okay.
11:45
Unidentified speaker: If you think about if you own 30, 40% of a company, chances are you have a majority of the directors or you control the directors, you might have related party transactions.
11:55
Unidentified speaker: You but there's mining and non-controlling interest in a JV is horrible.
11:58
Unidentified speaker: Exactly.
11:58
Unidentified speaker: You can go down a rabbit hole very quickly.
12:00
Unidentified speaker: So in order to defray the likelihood that minorities get, by the way, what's the swearing policy these days?
12:06
Unidentified speaker: Say whatever you want.
12:06
Unidentified speaker: Minorities get fucked over.
12:08
Unidentified speaker: Maybe the only way to put it.
12:09
Unidentified speaker: Um the the regime, uh the rules are often like, okay, if you go above 30% in the UK, you have to bid.
12:15
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
12:16
Unidentified speaker: You have to bid for everyone.
12:17
Unidentified speaker: And then if you're going to bid, there has to be a price that's at least the similar level you've paid for any shares in the last four months or six months or whatever it is.
12:23
Unidentified speaker: And if you don't bid now, you can't bid for another 12 months, so it's a cooling off period.
12:27
Unidentified speaker: So you have these strict rules.
12:28
Unidentified speaker: Australia's quite unique, it does not have that.
12:30
Unidentified speaker: Australia does not have a mandatory bid regime.
12:33
Unidentified speaker: Kind of as a compensatory for that, the perceived control level is actually much lower than many other markets.
12:38
Unidentified speaker: In Australia, it's set at 20%.
12:40
Unidentified speaker: You can buy it up to 19.95 or whatever it is percent.
12:43
Unidentified speaker: After that, there's only two or three gateways by which you can increase the control.
12:46
Unidentified speaker: One is a formal bid or a scheme, on or off market.
12:49
Unidentified speaker: There are various structures.
12:50
Unidentified speaker: One is the creep provisions, as you know, you can buy 3% every six months.
12:54
Unidentified speaker: Uh, another is with shareholder approval.
12:56
Unidentified speaker: So company might be in distress, need new money, the main shareholders at 19%, they do a rights issue, they underwrite it.
13:03
Unidentified speaker: This is actually quite common, as you know, in mining, and then they go from 20 to 40, 40, they can just gobble up that way, often in semi-distress, probably also a mechanism often used to acquire control in dodgy circumstances.
13:15
Unidentified speaker: Um, and then I think there might be one other gateway that's slipping my mind.
13:19
Unidentified speaker: But but essentially, if you go up to 20%, it's very tightly controlled how you then move through 20%.
13:25
Unidentified speaker: So if you come across a situation where, for whatever reason, you see someone owns 40% of the company or 30 to 45, 50, it doesn't really matter what it is, and you think and can prove that they acquired that stake through a gateway not permitted uh by uh by the exceptions to to the to the 20% threshold regime in the in the in the in the corporations act, in chapter six of the act, um, then essentially what you've had is control changed illegally against the law.
13:54
Unidentified speaker: Uh and look, there's there's various ways that that that could happen.
13:58
Unidentified speaker: I kind of highlighted a few of them.
13:59
Unidentified speaker: But in this particular case, what happened was you had one shareholder, uh the Math Mather Group, or the Mather entities, Nick Mather being the guy that runs the company, the CEO, uh, were about 15% of the company.
14:12
Unidentified speaker: I want to say 15 or 16% ownership.
14:14
Unidentified speaker: There was another entity called 10 Star Trading that was essentially essentially a corporate black box.
14:21
Unidentified speaker: Like just name on a paper, no people attached to it, no nat what we call no natural people, no natural persons.
14:27
Unidentified speaker: Like, you know, a registry in Cayman Islands signed some, or British Virginia Islands actually signed some docs, and then when you follow the paper trail, again, thanks AI.
14:34
Unidentified speaker: Uh when you when you follow the paper trail, it's it's a box above a box above a box.
14:38
Unidentified speaker: So you go from a uh British Virginia Islands holding company to a Hong Kong, to an Isle of Man Trust, to a Hong Kong entity with you know, no people on any bits of paper.
14:48
Unidentified speaker: I mean it's key.
14:49
Unidentified speaker: So I mean, when you find something like so so that other entity owned 20%.
14:53
Unidentified speaker: So you had so you had this starting situation where that entity owns 20%, you don't know anything about who's behind it.
14:58
Unidentified speaker: May there owns 15-16%.
15:01
Unidentified speaker: And then in May there was a very curious transaction where about 7% of the company was sold at a price divorced from the market price, the market price at the time being 2.5, 3 cents, 7% of the company traded hands at 4.5 cents.
15:13
Unidentified speaker: Don't quote me on the numbers, it's all in the filings, you can look up the exact numbers.
15:17
Unidentified speaker: But it was a it was a non-economic price relative to where the stock was trading in the market.
15:21
Unidentified speaker: It was in a coordinated transaction, and it was split 50-50 between these two parties.
15:26
Unidentified speaker: So you can pull up the takeover panel guidance notes if you want, but one of the inditia in what's called the indicia or indications of association is transactions in concert.
15:36
Unidentified speaker: A coordinated transaction done at a similar price in an off-market level at the same time is not proof of association, but potentially indicative of association and demand, you know, it's questionable, let's say.
15:49
Unidentified speaker: So that was happened in May, and so you pull on a couple of threads at the same time.
15:54
Unidentified speaker: Either I found or that transaction got pointed out to me in the context of a company that was already trading at less than half of a net cash.
15:59
Unidentified speaker: Okay.
16:00
Unidentified speaker: So none of this would have been pursued if there wasn't gold at the end of the rainbow.
16:03
Unidentified speaker: Okay.
16:04
Unidentified speaker: So because of the sole gold transaction, so DGR was a large investor in a company called Sold Gold.
16:08
Unidentified speaker: Sold gold got sold to the Chinese.
16:12
Unidentified speaker: They I mean there's so many things to pull on here, but at the end of the day, they had seven six to seven cents net of value against uh, or at least net cash of about six cents a share and a few other things, uh, largely derived from the sole gold proceeds before sale proceeds.
16:27
Unidentified speaker: Before that, there was you know a bunch of shares and a bunch of other stuff, but not much hard cash.
16:33
Unidentified speaker: So there wasn't much to f there wasn't much to fight over.
16:35
Unidentified speaker: Um, all of a sudden, you see this weird transaction in the context of the company that's been massively become massively net cash.
16:42
Unidentified speaker: Uh and look, it just it looked strange on the face of it.
16:45
Unidentified speaker: So, you know, I did some work, I did some reading, understood that 10 star trading, one of these entities, um it just didn't look right, didn't smell right, it'd never been in human sign any of the documents for years and years.
16:58
Unidentified speaker: Um you had a you had uh the Panama papers were linked in the uh some of the signatories on 10-star documents had been disclosed in the Panama Papers as specific offshore tax structuring entities.
17:12
Unidentified speaker: You know, this is a tiny Queensland shit co cash box with you know one asset that just got liquidated and a history of broken promises and broken hearts, right?
17:23
Unidentified speaker: So no idea what this 10-star trading is doing.
17:25
Unidentified speaker: Um very quickly you could figure out that 10 stars only made public investments in other Mether related entities and going on for you know decades, decades.
17:33
Unidentified speaker: Literally never never made another public investment other than a 10 than than a Mether entity.
17:37
Unidentified speaker: I mean, that is it's all just in the in the eth, you know, in the you can find that all by a quick Google search.
17:43
Unidentified speaker: Okay, so I'm thinking, okay, there's this weird transaction, cash box, 10 stars, obviously uh offshore entity, Queensland mining company with an offshore, random offshore entity, it's a main shareholder.
17:54
Unidentified speaker: The transaction that they did in May was specifically structured such that Mether did not go over 20%.
17:58
Unidentified speaker: Okay, so he went from 16% to 19.9%.
18:01
Unidentified speaker: The residual shares got stuffed with another associate on a loan, but he lent the money to a third party to hold the shares so he couldn't go over 19.9%.
18:08
Unidentified speaker: Looking pretty uh uh uh alarm bells are ringing, Willie.
18:12
Unidentified speaker: Associated.
18:12
Unidentified speaker: What's that?
18:13
Unidentified speaker: It looks associated.
18:14
Unidentified speaker: It looks associated, it looks associated.
18:15
Unidentified speaker: So so of course, you know, this is just suspicion at my point, and you know, the it's you the the bar to prove association is is very, very high, as it as it probably should be, right?
18:25
Unidentified speaker: As you know from the the CZR example, the creasy annual situation, they specifically disclosed in that situation that the wife and the husband, despite the fact that they were married, were not a relative.
18:38
Unidentified speaker: And in fact, that actually is the legal policy.
18:40
Unidentified speaker: Just because there's a family relationship, so oftentimes not mother, oftentimes not wife and husband, oftentimes it's like son and father.
18:48
Unidentified speaker: Just because they're in the same family, you doesn't mean they're associated, which I think is kind of bullshit, frankly, but that's that's actually the law.
18:54
Unidentified speaker: That's not enough.
18:55
Unidentified speaker: In and of itself, that's not enough.
18:56
Unidentified speaker: You need an overwhelming body of evidence to prove association.
18:59
Unidentified speaker: Anyway, I go to the chairman of the company, this is chairman of DGR, and I present all these concerns in a formal letter.
19:05
Unidentified speaker: And I just say, look, these appear to be high, this is highly susp you know transaction is strange, okay?
19:12
Unidentified speaker: The May transaction.
19:13
Unidentified speaker: It appears coordinated, um, it appears designed to hide change of control, uh, it's at off-market price, you know, or basically six or seven laundry lists of stuff that I'd found.
19:23
Unidentified speaker: And then I also said, look, there's a huge discount in the stock.
19:26
Unidentified speaker: And I don't think as a shareholder, and I'd bought some shares, as a shareholder, I don't think you should be doing what you're doing.
19:31
Unidentified speaker: You should pay it all back in dividends or you know, whatever it is.
19:33
Unidentified speaker: Like there basically there's a governance discount.
19:35
Unidentified speaker: There's a huge amount of opacity.
19:37
Unidentified speaker: The reason the stock trades at such a cheap level is because there's a massive governance problem here and there's a capital allocation problem.
19:43
Unidentified speaker: No one trusts they'll get the money back.
19:44
Unidentified speaker: And if you actually do something with cash that's accredited for shareholders, like paying a big dividend, buyback, whatever, um, then the stock will go up.
19:52
Unidentified speaker: So, you know, this is all just kind of common sense stuff, right?
19:57
Unidentified speaker: And you know, that the chairman I said on the phone, mate, the fact you're calling me to have this reaction from New York, it was late night New York or something, the fact you're calling me to give me this feedback is ev is suggestive to me that actually I'm barking up precisely the right tree, not the wrong tree.
20:15
Unidentified speaker: Right?
20:15
Unidentified speaker: So, and yeah, and as you can see in the filings, like this is this is all being litigated, right?
20:20
Unidentified speaker: So you you can read the takeovers panel of filings and you can look through the statements the company made uh and also the statements uh Mr.
20:27
Unidentified speaker: Mather made.
20:28
Unidentified speaker: And look, there is look to be clear, there is some distinction between statements made by the company and statements made by Mr.
20:32
Unidentified speaker: Mather.
20:33
Unidentified speaker: Uh, but at the end of the day, the panels made their decision, and the consequences of that decision are you have to unwind the illegal control that was acquired.
20:42
Unidentified speaker: And in this case, because 20% is the key threshold, they'd gone to 45% illegally, therefore, the remedy is not to buy out everyone, the remedy is actually to go back to 20%.
20:51
Unidentified speaker: So therefore you have to sell 25%.
20:53
Unidentified speaker: Now, there's a whole process around how they're going to do that, but that's kind of what the orders tried to that must be pretty standard first reply.
20:59
Unidentified speaker: I mean, have you ever had a company that responded to your your inquiries straight up and said, no, you're right, Jeremy?
21:05
Unidentified speaker: I mean, not not in so much as those terms like you're right, you got me.
21:10
Unidentified speaker: Not like that, but there's ways and means of doing it, right?
21:13
Unidentified speaker: Like, on the one hand, you can maybe try to protect yourself legally whilst also giving a little.
21:21
Unidentified speaker: So so for example, at that stage, you know, I'm I'm a shelled, I want the stock to go up, I want to make money, you know.
21:25
Unidentified speaker: So so in my mind also, they should know there is a calculus.
21:28
Unidentified speaker: You know, there's a huge, in this case, not so much money, but a lot of time, effort, and attention devolved to running this down, right?
21:35
Unidentified speaker: And pinning their hide to a wall, so to speak.
21:38
Unidentified speaker: And if they'd put a little meat on the bone, who's to say?
21:41
Unidentified speaker: Like if they'd turned around and said, you know what, you're wrong.
21:43
Unidentified speaker: Um, you've got the wrong idea, you know, it looks like a duck, it cracks like a duck, but it's a horse.
21:49
Unidentified speaker: Um but here's 20 cents per share.
21:51
Unidentified speaker: You know what I mean?
21:52
Unidentified speaker: If here's a dividend, you know, like then I have to think hard about the cost of enforcement and the time and effort and attention and move on to the next thing.
21:59
Unidentified speaker: So there was a case, uh GWR Group, which was a little similar to that, which one I actually did take to the panel and lost.
22:05
Unidentified speaker: Um, and the reasons have been published, and I've essentially I couldn't meet the definition of association, even though they did refer the conduct to ASIC, and ASIC might still be looking at it because frankly, it's completely and utterly inexplicable how they got to 45% of the company.
22:19
Unidentified speaker: Anyway, we won't go into that too much.
22:21
Unidentified speaker: The point is I lost the case, but in the proceedings of you know, interacting with the the company, um, the lawyers, you know, firstly they they offer you a little bit, then they shut up, and then they turn around and pay to massive special dividends.
22:33
Unidentified speaker: So it's like, well You can still unlock value with that.
22:35
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, yeah.
22:36
Unidentified speaker: So so yeah, I mean it doesn't always work that way either, right?
22:39
Unidentified speaker: There's ones where they're just you, you know, you're just straight up wrong, and I've had those as well.
22:43
Unidentified speaker: So I I I do want to like understand the specifics of unlocking value in the case of um DGR a bit more because okay, so so the stock will the stock invests with ASIC who then has to sell it.
22:57
Unidentified speaker: Now, do you see do you see like like what are the ways it can play out from here in order to realize full value, or do you think the the uplift is kind of already happened today effectively?
23:07
Unidentified speaker: No, no, not really.
23:08
Unidentified speaker: I mean, I can't really speculate as to to my own strategy because obviously I you know I think the stock is worth a certain amount and I have a plan to get there, so I have a have a kind of game plan in mind.
23:19
Unidentified speaker: Um I I would just suggest that the orders are as you say, you know, so the the incumbents have a choice, and that is they I mean, and it's actually it's laid out in the orders.
23:27
Unidentified speaker: If you read the orders in detail, you will see there are certain scenarios that are envisaged, such as a takeout either by a third party or by the mother entities.
23:36
Unidentified speaker: In which case he can't actually the the decision has to be voted on by the majority of the minority.
23:41
Unidentified speaker: So so they've essentially written into the rules for the orders that look ASIC's gonna have to sell the 25% in a three to 12 month period, okay?
23:50
Unidentified speaker: The market's gonna have to absorb those.
23:51
Unidentified speaker: However, in the meantime, there might be what's called a relevant bid being a takeover bid for the non-Mather owned shares, and Mather is able to sell those 25% into a relevant bid under certain circumstances.
24:02
Unidentified speaker: That doesn't guarantee there's a bid.
24:04
Unidentified speaker: That doesn't guarantee anyone will make a bid.
24:06
Unidentified speaker: No, maybe no one will make a bid, maybe nothing will happen, maybe you'll have to sell 25% at the price the market will bet.
24:11
Unidentified speaker: If that's the case, so be it.
24:12
Unidentified speaker: And good luck.
24:13
Unidentified speaker: We'll see what happens.
24:14
Unidentified speaker: Um, but if there were to be a bid, then that bid would only be approval under certain circumstances, circumstances I fought for hard, because I obviously wanted to protect my investment and minorities from getting fucked over, which you know you guys can you know read the documents and read the history of the company and come to a judgment as to the likelihood of that happening.
24:32
Unidentified speaker: But essentially, one way to protect the minorities from getting screwed, or or let's say being presented with a with an uh uh uh what's the word for it?
24:41
Unidentified speaker: Being presented with a Hobson's choice.
24:43
Unidentified speaker: Either we take this bid, which is massively desultry and unfair and well below fair value, right?
24:50
Unidentified speaker: Or a quarter of the shares are going to be dumped on the market and great.
24:54
Unidentified speaker: Right?
24:55
Unidentified speaker: So to prevent that outcome, the panel has decided to install gateways into the orders that a majority of the minority shareholders, majority of the unaffected shareholders, will have to approve any bid if it is made.
25:06
Unidentified speaker: So they can't just bid three cents when nav is six to seven cents, right?
25:10
Unidentified speaker: Well he can, but if he doesn't get his, then he's gonna have to sell most of the investment at a massive loss.
25:16
Unidentified speaker: Oh, good.
25:17
Unidentified speaker: Uh I mean, not good, but that that's the rules.
25:19
Unidentified speaker: So, you know, about bloody time kind of thing.
25:21
Unidentified speaker: Got to jump in here, JD, and thank the legends at Titan Recruitment for bringing this episode to your ears, money miners.
25:27
Unidentified speaker: JD, we spent um a few days at iMark, and I'll tell you what, I met a whole host of technical expertise people, like people across the engineering, metallurgical, geological spectrum, people who help bring projects online.
25:41
Unidentified speaker: And you know what?
25:41
Unidentified speaker: When you need those people for whatever purpose, the entire tech services spectrum, you just get in touch with Titan Recruitment.
25:47
Unidentified speaker: Titan recruitment is the only name you need to know in the business.
25:50
Unidentified speaker: Shout out if you are out there, if you are looking for a gig in the space, you have got any of the skills that Trav just mentioned there, go click Titan's name in our show notes, have a look, they'll have heaps of jobs on offer.
26:00
Unidentified speaker: You can find something pretty exciting to make your next step.
26:03
Unidentified speaker: Or if you're a corporate looking to build out, you've got a project on the works, any type of engineering works, or a mine's coming online, something like that, check them out.
26:11
Unidentified speaker: They are the team that can upscale your business, get you set for that next leg of growth.
26:16
Unidentified speaker: So thank you, Titan Recruitment.
26:17
Unidentified speaker: There's like a common theme with a lot of the stuff you've been like like prying out lately, and that's that's these um these these occurrences of of association which um um pop up.
26:28
Unidentified speaker: I don't want to I don't actually want to touch on GWR again just yet, but I want to talk about Terracom.
26:32
Unidentified speaker: Um I know you've posted about this deeply underwater so far, so might be more market related than um the opportunity related, but this is again like like a fascinating example of of get going past the 20% threshold.
26:48
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, in this case, it was the uh an an underwritten entitlements offer the in a distress situation.
26:54
Unidentified speaker: Um talk me through the the sure thesis here and how you think things could play out.
27:03
Unidentified speaker: Should uh you should get your met get your man uh Respector on the phone.
27:06
Unidentified speaker: He's all over him.
27:07
Unidentified speaker: When's he coming on the pod?
27:08
Unidentified speaker: Uh well he promised he he promised me um 18 months ago he'd do it within the next 18 months and that that lapses very soon.
27:16
Unidentified speaker: Sorry, you better hit him up.
27:17
Unidentified speaker: But no, look, terracom's a very kind of the the strokes, the broad strokes of the story are similar to others you would have looked at.
27:23
Unidentified speaker: I mean, Canyon's not that dissimilar, right?
27:26
Unidentified speaker: You have I mean look the difference is they acquired it through a rights issue, um, but then you had all this confluence of other circumstances where if you kind of put your tinfoil hat on, they read a certain way.
27:36
Unidentified speaker: And so Teracom look, it's it's a semi-distressed coal shit go, okay?
27:43
Unidentified speaker: So so let's let's be honest about that.
27:45
Unidentified speaker: That that they don't have they don't have a lot of cash, they're going trying to perform an operational turnaround.
27:50
Unidentified speaker: Um they just took a massive impairment.
27:52
Unidentified speaker: I mean, for everyone, it's important to understand.
27:54
Unidentified speaker: They just took a massive impairment, wrote down the book value of their assets almost to zero.
27:57
Unidentified speaker: A suspicious impairment.
27:58
Unidentified speaker: A suspicious.
27:59
Unidentified speaker: No, no, we'll get we'll get to that, but my point is they did lose 50 million at the eBIT level last year.
28:04
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, yeah.
28:04
Unidentified speaker: Um the backpack story to how they got here is hilarious, though, from the the 22 run-up.
28:09
Unidentified speaker: I actually made money price.
28:10
Unidentified speaker: I actually made money, I made money in 2021 on them.
28:12
Unidentified speaker: I mean, nothing to write home about, but yeah, it yeah, it went from five cents to a dollar or whatever, and now it's back at the divvy.
28:19
Unidentified speaker: Too much of a divvy that they couldn't afford.
28:21
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, yeah.
28:22
Unidentified speaker: So I mean, look, it's it's pretty borderline in terms of quality, and that's being nice to them.
28:26
Unidentified speaker: Uh just objectively, they're you know, they're a relatively small distress company.
28:31
Unidentified speaker: Having said all that, the circumstances around which this Indonesian group acquired central control of the company are strange to put them mild.
28:40
Unidentified speaker: Uh so there was a rights issue January, February?
28:44
Unidentified speaker: Uh you have to look up the date.
28:46
Unidentified speaker: There was a rights issue to to partially recapitalize the company.
28:49
Unidentified speaker: At, I think it was it was either five, was it six cents a share?
28:52
Unidentified speaker: I think it was six cents a share.
28:54
Unidentified speaker: Either five or six.
28:54
Unidentified speaker: I don't remember the exact.
28:55
Unidentified speaker: It was a big discounted rights issue.
28:57
Unidentified speaker: The offer was underwritten by the then major shareholder, an entity called Orbit Marketing.
29:03
Unidentified speaker: Orbit Marketing owned just under, I think it was 20%, 19%.
29:06
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, not below the threshold.
29:08
Unidentified speaker: They they owned just below the takeover threshold.
29:10
Unidentified speaker: They gave uh an undertaking to underwrite the rights offering, and they sit they disclose so okay, so when you do an entitlement offer or a rights offering like this, oftentimes you need shareholder approval if the number of shares raised is above a certain threshold.
29:23
Unidentified speaker: Reason is because again, the control of the company could theoretically pass if enough of those shares go to the larger shareholder.
29:31
Unidentified speaker: And in this case, that you know that was properly disclosed in the docs.
29:34
Unidentified speaker: If if Orbit takes up their maximum entitlement and others renounce their entitlements, a renounceable rights offer, then they could own up to 55% of the company.
29:43
Unidentified speaker: Okay.
29:44
Unidentified speaker: The thing is, that offering document is a legal document, okay?
29:48
Unidentified speaker: And you have to state honestly, or you're meant to state honestly, your intentions with regard to things like the ongoing management of the company, the board of the company.
29:59
Unidentified speaker: Um you're meant to accurately portray what you're going to do during the rights offer.
30:03
Unidentified speaker: You're also meant to give an accurate portrayal of the bidder or the large shareholder, in this case, who would underwrite the shortfall.
30:10
Unidentified speaker: You have to describe their business and their, you know, who they are and what they're all about accurately.
30:15
Unidentified speaker: Or at least that's the, you know, I'm kind of paraphrasing the law, but you know, you have to there's a statement of intention with regard to management of the company.
30:22
Unidentified speaker: So you had this entity, orbit marketing, that was called a strategic investor or an investor with pedigree in coal.
30:29
Unidentified speaker: Okay, the pedigree in the coal markets.
30:31
Unidentified speaker: It was a real estate.
30:32
Unidentified speaker: It was a real estate entity, then it became a Bali, it was a Bali Balinese hotel operator.
30:37
Unidentified speaker: The entity that acquired the 20% stake in Terracom that was funded into orbit was acquired with $10,000 Singapore dollars.
30:45
Unidentified speaker: I'm not sure where they got the 40 million to buy that first 20% or the the more sorry, it was about 10 to 15 million and a 40 million top-up in the rights issue.
30:53
Unidentified speaker: There was no equity capital in that company, which is a Singapore domicile company, so you can actually look up the paid in capital.
30:58
Unidentified speaker: So you can, where did the money come from?
31:00
Unidentified speaker: Someone put the money in and still has not been disclosed.
31:03
Unidentified speaker: So there was that.
31:04
Unidentified speaker: Then there was the the the promise, or not the promise, but the guidance in the offering doc that uh you would be able to be treated pro radar.
31:13
Unidentified speaker: Normal shareholders would be treated pro radar with the main shareholder if there was a shortfall of the rights offer.
31:17
Unidentified speaker: So a lot of people mean that means that a lot of shareholders wanted to exercise their theoretical right to take up more than their entitlement if there was a shortfall.
31:26
Unidentified speaker: Guess what?
31:27
Unidentified speaker: 80%, 90% of the shortfall shares went to the main shareholder.
31:32
Unidentified speaker: But there was a subsequent offering to aggrieved shareholders who felt they'd been shortchanged in their top-up rights, and the only reason you would give a subsequent offering of a couple million bucks is if people felt they were given short shrift.
31:44
Unidentified speaker: Then the whole point is orbit itself, the top-level ownership of orbit, changed hands during the offer period.
31:49
Unidentified speaker: This is key.
31:50
Unidentified speaker: So whilst they were saying this is a coal company, they have pedigree, blah, blah, blah, actually, at that time it was being sold to a hotelier in Bali, a Balinese hotelier.
31:59
Unidentified speaker: Then it came out this Balinese hotel is a listed company after the deal closed, and they're consolidating Terracom in their accounts.
32:06
Unidentified speaker: The legal definition for consolidation is control.
32:09
Unidentified speaker: I mean, that's just straight up accounting 101.
32:11
Unidentified speaker: You consolidate if you have management control.
32:14
Unidentified speaker: So what they're saying is control actually passed without you ever getting approval for control passing.
32:20
Unidentified speaker: Um, then the only independent director on the board left, this guy, Mark Chadwick, he left.
32:25
Unidentified speaker: He also said that um uh he had a disagreement with the strategic direct uh direction risk management of the company, and they replaced two or three of the other directors.
32:36
Unidentified speaker: I in fact, I think they replaced all the incumbent directors during the company.
32:39
Unidentified speaker: The whole board is pretty new.
32:40
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
32:41
Unidentified speaker: And for a time, this company had no defined independent directors, and the independence of the current chair was only asserted later on.
32:49
Unidentified speaker: Whilst the company did not have a chair of the audit committee, meaning this m this Mr.
32:53
Unidentified speaker: Chadwick gentleman, all of a sudden they put out their preliminary financial statements.
32:57
Unidentified speaker: In their preliminary financial statements, they report the loss for the last fiscal year complete.
33:02
Unidentified speaker: They didn't say anything about an impairment, they didn't say anything about a massive write down, they didn't say anything about going concern.
33:07
Unidentified speaker: Then within a few weeks afterwards, all of a sudden, in the lead up to uh a one and a half week suspension that they just came out of, they said, Oh, actually, there's going to be a massive impairment, we're gonna write down the value of our assets.
33:19
Unidentified speaker: They didn't say by what, but there'll be a material impairment, and they ended up writing down their assets by over 100 million and putting a going concern note in their accounts.
33:26
Unidentified speaker: Now, look, I'll have to lean on REST speculators' exp expertise in the sector here, but if you just run what they guided for their current run rate production for this year at current coal prices, less last year's costs, or even last year's costs plus 10% or plus 20%, they're theoretically they should be minting cash.
33:45
Unidentified speaker: They should be minting cash.
33:46
Unidentified speaker: So what they used a very bad now, that doesn't mean they aren't minting cash.
33:50
Unidentified speaker: In fact, I have a feeling they're not minting cash because they're having some geological issues.
33:54
Unidentified speaker: Uh, but nevertheless, the decision to impair was um let's call it interesting because look, again, when you impair assets, you make a huge number of assumptions.
34:08
Unidentified speaker: Where do those assumptions come from?
34:09
Unidentified speaker: How do you base?
34:10
Unidentified speaker: There's a huge amount of judgment involved, but essentially you try to use I mean, look, you can use a 10% discount rate if you want, or you can use a 20% discount rate.
34:18
Unidentified speaker: And the decision between those two means the difference between having 100 million in assets or zero.
34:22
Unidentified speaker: So, of course, they used a 20% pre-tax discount rate.
34:24
Unidentified speaker: Every other coal company in the sector uses 10 to 12 or something.
34:27
Unidentified speaker: Now, look, they're a single asset mine in Queensland, and it's a short-lived mine, so maybe 20% is is correct.
34:33
Unidentified speaker: However, they didn't disclose the discount rate they used the year before.
34:36
Unidentified speaker: They didn't disclose the coal price assumptions they used the year before.
34:39
Unidentified speaker: They actually didn't even disclose the coal assumptions they used at Blair ethole, but they did disclose the coal price assumptions they used at the South African assets.
34:46
Unidentified speaker: Why, in the name of all that is holy, would you disclose the coal price assumptions you use at your discontinued ops, or rather your strategic sale South African ops, but not your meat and potatoes Blair ethole asset, which is the last remaining real asset of the company?
35:01
Unidentified speaker: It just it it asks a lot of questions.
35:03
Unidentified speaker: I mean there's three or four other things in there, but they used four or five or six really conservative assumptions to write down the fast asset value.
35:10
Unidentified speaker: And here's the key.
35:11
Unidentified speaker: Sorry, and then I'll let you go on.
35:13
Unidentified speaker: But when I interact with the company, the chairman originally was very conciliatory.
35:18
Unidentified speaker: So I've had three or four letters with him over the last month, five weeks.
35:21
Unidentified speaker: He offered, in fact, he wanted to meet in person to go over all these things.
35:25
Unidentified speaker: Um I said, sure, let's meet in, you know, late September.
35:28
Unidentified speaker: I'll be out of the country in October.
35:29
Unidentified speaker: Then it got pushed to mid-October.
35:31
Unidentified speaker: Then I asked a few more questions, then the material impairment came out and said, Well, you're impairing, but why?
35:36
Unidentified speaker: Like, you know, and give me an explanation.
35:37
Unidentified speaker: And they said, Well, actually, it was the auditor's decision to impair.
35:40
Unidentified speaker: And I said, No, the auditor makes the decision to impair based on forecasts and numbers given from the management, and I have the right to ask the auditor under the act, so I want all these questions after the auditor at the AGM.
35:51
Unidentified speaker: So I sent them a list of 20 questions to the auditor, which they said they took.
35:54
Unidentified speaker: And after that, they lawyered up and just refused to talk to me and said I'm being annoying.
35:58
Unidentified speaker: So uh that's kind of the status quo.
36:01
Unidentified speaker: So to be clear, there are two competing explanations here, and I do not know which is correct.
36:05
Unidentified speaker: I don't.
36:06
Unidentified speaker: There is an explanation that this is a company in distress, far more distressed than even I believe, or that I understand, that they are running out of funding options, that you know they're searching around looking for anyone to give them money.
36:18
Unidentified speaker: The Indonesians gave them money, but that was money and they took the money to save the company.
36:22
Unidentified speaker: And maybe the current situation is production has been way, way, way below budget, even though they reaffirmed guidance three weeks ago when they did the material impairment, or at least they didn't cut it.
36:31
Unidentified speaker: Uh, and even though coal prices have gone up enough such that even if they cut production 30-40% theoretically, they should still not be burning cash.
36:37
Unidentified speaker: Okay, so so there is a scenario in which I'm just completely wrong, or the fact pattern, the mosaic that I've drawn is um too conspiratorial.
36:45
Unidentified speaker: It's possible.
36:46
Unidentified speaker: There is also the scenario where look, Moreland's JV, which is a new seam that would enable them to use a lot of the stranded infrastructure at the site.
36:55
Unidentified speaker: It's not owned by them, but it's owned by the Chinese.
36:57
Unidentified speaker: But a highly economical JV structure could allow the mine to last another 20 years, not another six years, whatever the current um run rate duration of the mine is.
37:06
Unidentified speaker: And economics improve.
37:08
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, when when when that gets environmental improval, and if that was seems likely, which apparently that was likely as recently as six months ago, um it could really transform the equity value of the company.
37:18
Unidentified speaker: And so therefore you could construct a scenario where it's very similar to what tried to happen at Canyon, uh, and um unfortunately it happens a lot in majority-minority situations like this.
37:28
Unidentified speaker: So when you try to unlock value in a in a situation like like what we see here at at Terracom, you're kind of at the whims of you know potentially getting shafted by coal prices if they move massively against you.
37:39
Unidentified speaker: I don't know how material this position is for you, but how in the in the interim, and I guess it's a broader kind of question for you, are you are you thinking about you know not getting getting railroaded by those sorts of things?
37:49
Unidentified speaker: It's very possible.
37:50
Unidentified speaker: I mean, there's no way around it, just position sizing.
37:52
Unidentified speaker: Tap the sign, position sizing is everything, right?
37:55
Unidentified speaker: Um it always has to be very small just because, like you said, coal prices go down 25-30%, it's game over for this particular equity.
38:02
Unidentified speaker: Um, so so yeah, I mean, look, when you're dealing with a cash box at 50% an av, it's just a completely different ballgame.
38:11
Unidentified speaker: So sizing is always in my view, sizing should always be based not looking up, looking down.
38:18
Unidentified speaker: Like what toolkit do you actually have available to to unlock value here as an activist?
38:24
Unidentified speaker: Like what what um what mechanism do you actually Are we talking pre or post-DGR ruling?
38:30
Unidentified speaker: I yeah.
38:31
Unidentified speaker: I mean just talk me through how you how you how you think about this.
38:33
Unidentified speaker: Because now now there is evidence that the panel is is is willing to have final orders that are actually like really instrumental.
38:41
Unidentified speaker: And terror this is like before the case in Teracom as opposed to some of the other ones we have and I might talk about where I mean look, there's a there's obviously the regulatory pathway you could go down with Terracom.
38:51
Unidentified speaker: I mean this these issues that I've kind of outlined here, they're all in the public domain.
38:56
Unidentified speaker: I I would argue they would they would deserve more full event full of more full ventilation um in the appropriate regulatory outlets.
39:04
Unidentified speaker: Um but but there's also there's also public pressure.
39:09
Unidentified speaker: I mean, look, a not every management team is going to be recalcitrant, and not every management team is gonna want to just fight, fight, fight, fight.
39:15
Unidentified speaker: A lot of you know, I was told some of these new directors actually do care about governance and care about um you know upholding the reputations of the market and doing the right thing for minorities, right?
39:30
Unidentified speaker: So I would hope that you could make some of those messages land.
39:34
Unidentified speaker: You could go to the AGM, you could be in the room in the order to answer those questions.
39:39
Unidentified speaker: Um yeah, I mean some combination of all of the above.
39:43
Unidentified speaker: I I I kind of don't want to be pinned down onto my exact um strategy with this particular name, but but in general, like pointing to some of these other examples, like sure, there's the thermonuclear war option, which is kind of the DGR strategy, or there's the there's the GW GWR strategy, which is maybe a bit more middle, and maybe I kind of misjudge slightly.
40:02
Unidentified speaker: Um, and then there's everything in between.
40:04
Unidentified speaker: So, you know, um we'll have to see what happens.
40:08
Unidentified speaker: I mean, look, I I do want to reiterate Teracom's like on a riskiness scale, far riskier than any of those other bets.
40:12
Unidentified speaker: It's not a bunch of cash.
40:14
Unidentified speaker: They, you know, for all my conspiratorial leanings, like they did just take a massive impairment.
40:20
Unidentified speaker: I tried to make it clear that this is a small bet.
40:22
Unidentified speaker: Like you have to be a conspiracy theorist to.
40:24
Unidentified speaker: I think I think I think I think I have a good record of coming on this podcast and saying this is super interesting and then it blowing up.
40:29
Unidentified speaker: So if you remember a couple of years ago, I still feel bad about that.
40:32
Unidentified speaker: So I just want to be clear of that.
40:34
Unidentified speaker: Um yeah, like you know, this is definitely kind of a lottery tip ticket type sizing.
40:39
Unidentified speaker: Like this is well under 1% of my nav.
40:41
Unidentified speaker: I mean, I find it interesting, and I think I think there should be a value to to highlighting these kind of cases, and I hope the regulators have interest in these kind of things because like they could they would argue in this particular case, the rights offering, okay, they were accurate at the time we were published.
40:57
Unidentified speaker: So what?
40:58
Unidentified speaker: Like, there's an offering period during that offering period, if something material changed, you have to update the docs.
41:02
Unidentified speaker: Everyone who decided to partake or not partake in that rights offering got shafted because they didn't know they were selling out to an Indonesian barley hotel tycoon who never explained where the money came from.
41:11
Unidentified speaker: I mean, like, that's material info that any investor would need to know to make a decision as to whether to put more money in, take their money out, sell their shares, buy more shares.
41:21
Unidentified speaker: I mean, that is the very definition of an uninformed market.
41:23
Unidentified speaker: So I would hope the regulator cares about these kind of things, and you know, to the extent possible, and if I can make money out of it, I'll try to continue to shine a light on these kind of cases.
41:33
Unidentified speaker: Jeremy, you mentioned the you know, this one's far on the fringes of what you're kind of doing.
41:36
Unidentified speaker: So let's kind of get into the the the middle ground of of what you talk about.
41:40
Unidentified speaker: You wrote a wicked note on Alara, which I found um super, super interesting, and I love seeing their their concentrate shipment updates come through every every few weeks, 62, 63.
41:52
Unidentified speaker: But you know, stopped the last week or two.
41:55
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, um Cordley just came out as well, but um I'd I never bothered reading these announcements because I always just thought, what are they doing here?
42:03
Unidentified speaker: It's kind of it's kind of interesting.
42:04
Unidentified speaker: But I mean, if you look at it on a on a multiple batches, cheapest copper name on the ASX, isn't it?
42:09
Unidentified speaker: 100%.
42:10
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, you're in Oman.
42:11
Unidentified speaker: Yeah is a great jurisdiction.
42:14
Unidentified speaker: Are you kidding?
42:15
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, it's definitely better than Yemen.
42:16
Unidentified speaker: Oman's better than Yemen.
42:20
Unidentified speaker: Oman is probably better than I don't know, is Amman better than Queensland?
42:26
Unidentified speaker: I mean I don't know.
42:27
Unidentified speaker: Are you not pure regulatory risk?
42:30
Unidentified speaker: Okay, it's rolling.
42:31
Unidentified speaker: Are they gonna change the rules on me tomorrow?
42:33
Unidentified speaker: Is Amman worse than half a dozen South American countries?
42:37
Unidentified speaker: Probably not.
42:38
Unidentified speaker: It probably falls in the basket of nobody knows.
42:40
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, I mean, look, again, I should probably correct one thing you said there.
42:44
Unidentified speaker: Um this is not really the middle ground of what I do.
42:47
Unidentified speaker: Like, I'll be honest, like, I'm not a resource specialist, so I'm a bit of a punt and not a punt, what's the word for it?
42:53
Unidentified speaker: I'm a dabbler when it comes to resources.
42:55
Unidentified speaker: Like, I'd never in the in the business of taking outright bets on resource prices.
42:59
Unidentified speaker: You'll you'll do some of the parts and it's like obvious value and and if I can underwrite a high batting average swing, like if I can underwrite a pretty good outcome or a solid outcome in various states of the world, you know, which will be copper price down 20%, copper price down 30%, copper, you know, whatever it is, then yeah, that it might line up for me, but I'm not like dude, EVs, like oh my goodness, AI, infrastructure, copper to the moon, bro.
43:23
Unidentified speaker: Like I'm not Robert Fleeland, right?
43:24
Unidentified speaker: So um that's not my thing.
43:27
Unidentified speaker: Like, I'm looking for attractive bets, right?
43:29
Unidentified speaker: Attractive bets, and in the context of sure, I'm not bearish on copper and I can see the bull case, but yeah, copper could fall 30%, and Alara should still be cash flow positive, right?
43:38
Unidentified speaker: Like you look at their unit economics, like they're still close to 50%, like it's still pretty economic.
43:43
Unidentified speaker: Not even even, you know, not you don't need six dollars a pound copper or whatever.
43:47
Unidentified speaker: Um, so what what's the attraction of of Alara?
43:50
Unidentified speaker: Much more uh prosaic kind of attraction, debt to equity pay down in a weird funky structure.
43:56
Unidentified speaker: So you have you have uh you know, a not particularly long mine life, but also not a terribly short mine life um asset that has been through an interesting kind of ownership uh let's call it conversation.
44:09
Unidentified speaker: Again, there's a takeovers panel angle.
44:10
Unidentified speaker: They were found you know guilty of doing some um, let's call it um inappropriate disclosures around a prior rights offering.
44:18
Unidentified speaker: Not not related to that to look, there's takeovers panel cases and there's takeovers panel cases, right?
44:23
Unidentified speaker: Like there's you know, the seventh circle of hell, which is kind of like DGR, like no, speaking generally, and then there's like you know, slap on the wrist type stuff.
44:30
Unidentified speaker: So they're much more towards a slap on the wrist type type situation, so it's not, you know, I'm not trying to have a go at the managers there.
44:36
Unidentified speaker: Um but you know, so what I'm saying is there was some regulatory oversight with regard to the last capital raising they did, uh, or I should say the one before they did at least they did small rights offering subsequent to that, um, that kind of let's put let's call it set the record straight with what they could and couldn't do.
44:52
Unidentified speaker: Um they own 51% of an asset, so often it's it's interesting for me to look at assets where you don't have 100% of them in the listed entity because there's a slight extra layer of complexity that can not confuse people per se, but if you can unpack that, oftentimes there's like some structural discount that is implied.
45:08
Unidentified speaker: So, for example, in this case, because uh you had the takeaways panel issue plus a big working capital movement against them during a period of ramp up in production where they couldn't actually ship the product because of the war and other and other uh teething issues, you had a huge working capital build that that manifested as a huge jump in net debt.
45:26
Unidentified speaker: Mark, it's a microcap stock, the market doesn't understand they only have 51% of that net debt.
45:30
Unidentified speaker: They don't understand that a lot of it is working capital, that as soon as those shipments leave the port, it's gonna be cashed right in the door, that debt's gonna come right down mechanically, which is kind of what happened.
45:39
Unidentified speaker: Um, and then you also have the underlying economics.
45:41
Unidentified speaker: And, you know, I'm not, as I said before, I'm no mining expert, but you know, they're currently mining at a strip ratio six to seven to one, whereas the long-term mine plan has it falling to like three and a half, four to one within two years.
45:52
Unidentified speaker: So that that's not to say that they will achieve that mine plan, but the only point being, you know, we're we're still working through the lowest grade ore, let's say, and they're generating very healthy cash.
46:02
Unidentified speaker: If they can get the copper out of the port, which they've increasingly been able to do, then trades at two times free cash flow.
46:09
Unidentified speaker: So, like I was my write-up was of the view that you know it's trading at one and a half or one times free cash flow, whatever it was, the stocks doubled more or less.
46:17
Unidentified speaker: Um, but this thing should clearly, to my own mind, trade it's something like three times free cash flow with some optionality around a change of control because I do think it's kind of a weird corporate structure.
46:26
Unidentified speaker: It's clearly never going to be valued properly on the ASX as a 51% owner with a bunch of offshore Omani slash Indian rich dudes um kind of controlling it, maybe not controlling it, we don't know.
46:39
Unidentified speaker: It's a single asset producer, it's in as you said, it's in an interesting geography.
46:43
Unidentified speaker: So you add all these up in the blender and spidey sensors tell me two times for cash flow is just the wrong price.
46:48
Unidentified speaker: I mean, so what is the right price?
46:50
Unidentified speaker: That's a much more difficult question, right?
46:52
Unidentified speaker: Like, is this ever gonna trade at 10 times EVIDA?
46:55
Unidentified speaker: No.
46:56
Unidentified speaker: Is it gonna trade at eight times?
46:57
Unidentified speaker: No.
46:57
Unidentified speaker: Is it gonna trade at five times?
46:59
Unidentified speaker: Probably not.
46:59
Unidentified speaker: Is it gonna trade at three times for your cash flow?
47:01
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, sure.
47:02
Unidentified speaker: If they can see that 100 million net debt go down to 50 million net debt, it'd be very hard for that not to be reflected in a better equity rating.
47:09
Unidentified speaker: And sure, you might get some of that cash back via dividend at some point, but it's really more about the market's perception of the asset as it puts runs on the board.
47:17
Unidentified speaker: And in this case, that could mean a tripling in the stock price.
47:19
Unidentified speaker: Or it could have from the level that I was buying it, which was about three and a half cents.
47:23
Unidentified speaker: So I'm I'm way more interested in the canyon conspiracy because I'm I'm stuck on conspiracy theory.
47:28
Unidentified speaker: Sorry.
47:28
Unidentified speaker: I mean I'm sick of couple of things.
47:33
Unidentified speaker: Oh I know, I know, I know.
47:34
Unidentified speaker: Uh yeah, you you are stuck.
47:36
Unidentified speaker: You're you're um you're genuinely bound not to talk to media about things.
47:40
Unidentified speaker: But they've but they've they've already come out with um um uh you we're just waiting on final, final, final orders from the panel, right?
47:47
Unidentified speaker: Well, no, I think they haven't made their declaration.
47:48
Unidentified speaker: Uh unacceptable success.
47:50
Unidentified speaker: They haven't made any declaration yet, so I can't I can't really speculate as to the case.
47:54
Unidentified speaker: Well, but I can you can I can explain why I thought it was interesting.
47:57
Unidentified speaker: I mean, like, how many times will you see I mean you guys went through it on the on a podcast, I believe, in some detail, but you can count literally on one hand, one hand in the last probably five years, the number of times you have a tranche to write a bit down.
48:09
Unidentified speaker: Uh what, sorry?
48:10
Unidentified speaker: You're talking about the trustee.
48:11
Unidentified speaker: No, no, no, no, no.
48:12
Unidentified speaker: That that that's one in one in 50 years, maybe.
48:14
Unidentified speaker: I don't know how that happens.
48:15
Unidentified speaker: No, no, no.
48:16
Unidentified speaker: I'm talking about an extant stock price and then the controlling bid coming in 40% below that price on the day.
48:21
Unidentified speaker: That was that was great.
48:22
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, so so any times you have a controlling shareholder make a bid, oftentimes there's there's always this tension, right?
48:26
Unidentified speaker: I keep going back to this tension between you know a controlling shareholder or a quasi-controlling shareholder and how they treat their minorities.
48:32
Unidentified speaker: And oftentimes in many jurisdictions, not unique to Australia, uh, but in many jurisdictions, there's an opportunity if you can kind of disintermediate that process or understand that process.
48:42
Unidentified speaker: And look, I I've been involved in dozens of these things, but you will probably recall the Stanmore Cole Golden Energy situation in Singapore, which is another similar situation, or hunter dug.
48:52
Unidentified speaker: I mean, outside of mining.
48:53
Unidentified speaker: It look, it happens a lot.
48:54
Unidentified speaker: And so there's various ways that in the context of a in the context of a transaction where the quasi-controller or controller wants to mop up the minorities, um, you know, there's there's a process by which that happens.
49:07
Unidentified speaker: And if they don't quite dot the I's and cross the T's, then there's an opportunity for, you know, someone like me to kind of help the minorities out, let's say, and shine a light on what's going on and kind of fight the bat a little bit and get a better outcome for everyone.
49:20
Unidentified speaker: Um, and look, that that that happens, but within that context, you will never, well not never, because it just happened with Canyon, but you will very, very rarely see an underbid, let alone an underbid at almost half the price of the Eastern stock price, which was itself sold down aggressively in the lead up to that deal.
49:38
Unidentified speaker: It's interesting for so many reasons, but um the I you know I I I I'm speculating, I'm imagining that there's like whatever the the the panel needs to get to the bottom of with the with with the work um is like any any allegations of association, it it's just so it was just so strange that that that tranche two of stock gets voted down by virtue of the the um the the voting from the second largest shareholder.
50:06
Unidentified speaker: You know, the yeah I can't comment on any of those things, sorry.
50:10
Unidentified speaker: It was strange, but yeah.
50:11
Unidentified speaker: I I do have a question on your on your kind of process.
50:13
Unidentified speaker: So you've you've often you know posted socially these sorts of things, had the newsletter for a period, Alara is a is a great example of something on your your platform now that read about became particularly interested in.
50:26
Unidentified speaker: That's part of the process in and alerting other people to it.
50:29
Unidentified speaker: And your evolution now with with what you're gonna do in in future.
50:33
Unidentified speaker: Like, do you see any changes in in your approach going forward?
50:39
Unidentified speaker: Changes in the approach, hopefully not.
50:41
Unidentified speaker: Um it's more capital you're working with.
50:43
Unidentified speaker: So does your strategy scale up?
50:45
Unidentified speaker: I think like I'll tell maybe focus on some of the things I got wrong because I've I've lost money this year, it's in it's been a bad year for me.
50:51
Unidentified speaker: I mean, um had a few decent outcomes, but a couple of really, really bad outcomes.
50:57
Unidentified speaker: And as I said, if you get the sizing wrong and you have a down year, it doesn't take a lot to have a bad year in this business.
51:04
Unidentified speaker: So look, I think I think one of the problems from like the hum situation was not depending on the kindness of strangers per se, but not having a big enough gun at the gunfight kind of thing.
51:15
Unidentified speaker: So, like, if you are you at all familiar with that situation?
51:18
Unidentified speaker: So, in that situation, you had a 30% shareholder that in my view was destroying the value of the company and trying to again trying to expropriate the other 70% at a very insultingly low price, and I and my other co-conveners decided the only way to preserve the value of the company for the minorities was to try to take board control of the company.
51:37
Unidentified speaker: Now, keep in mind at the time that I personally owned five per six percent of the company, five to six percent of the company at my highest, and my other convener owned three, three and a half percent.
51:46
Unidentified speaker: So we owned about 10% between us, so we were about 10% versus 30%.
51:50
Unidentified speaker: Um, with the benefit of hindsight, uh, 10% versus 30%, even in a situation that we thought was a slam dunk, like stock prices down 90% over the last 10 years.
52:03
Unidentified speaker: The guy's cycled through six or seven CEOs, he's been chairman the majority of the time, he's been on the board almost the entire time, absolutely run into the ground, trading at half of book value, no hope of getting you know.
52:15
Unidentified speaker: We had to I had to pull teeth getting the proxy advisors to come around to the idea that this guy is just not in it for creating value for everyone, he's just in it for himself.
52:24
Unidentified speaker: I mean, he literally put a low-ball bid on the table at a moment of max weakness in the stock, uh without funding and yeah, and wouldn't even countenance another bid.
52:38
Unidentified speaker: I mean, all these kinds of things, and then obviously the panel case is public knowledge, but the third-party bid came in at a 30% premium.
52:44
Unidentified speaker: He told them to go away, didn't even give them the benefit of due diligence, even though he's a participating insider because he just stopped his own bid a few weeks before then.
52:52
Unidentified speaker: So this is all on the tape.
52:55
Unidentified speaker: So my my opinion going to the shareholders and the proxy advisors who unfortunately are big participants in in the contested EGM, was just look at the conduct.
53:04
Unidentified speaker: Like he's bidding 53.
53:06
Unidentified speaker: 58.
53:07
Unidentified speaker: He's beating 58 against an X and stock, which was 50.
53:10
Unidentified speaker: Someone comes in and says they want to buy it at 73 or whatever it was, told them to F off.
53:17
Unidentified speaker: Everyone else on the board said okay, like didn't do anything about it.
53:20
Unidentified speaker: And I'm like, these guys are just a bunch of jokers.
53:21
Unidentified speaker: Like, get rid of all of them.
53:22
Unidentified speaker: Like, this is kind of what I'm saying in the back room.
53:25
Unidentified speaker: Like, this is they clearly don't have the best interest of the shareholders.
53:28
Unidentified speaker: Like, seems pretty cut and dry to me, but that was actually not the case.
53:34
Unidentified speaker: Like, the amount of um cajoling I had to go through to to convince, and we eventually did turn around to if not all the proxy advisors, and two or three of them on some of the resolutions, but not enough to get all of the cronies off the board.
53:48
Unidentified speaker: Um, and so part of me was like, this is just it's just literally like getting blood out of a stone, getting these guys to change their minds.
53:55
Unidentified speaker: And you know, we had calls with all these proxy advisors, and they're all freaking hopeless.
54:00
Unidentified speaker: Like, they're just terrible, they're not markets people, they're just they're bureaucratic box checkers, the lot of them.
54:07
Unidentified speaker: I literally don't know why they have their jobs, how they have their jobs or get paid, but look it's this isn't gonna help you uh win them over.
54:13
Unidentified speaker: That's why I'm taking extra money so I can go through them.
54:16
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, just go through these fuckers.
54:18
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, like excuse me, I probably shouldn't say just like just like at the end of the day, you shouldn't depend on these guys thinking that you're right.
54:27
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, yeah.
54:28
Unidentified speaker: I just want to stand over them with a you know, and just read them the right act.
54:32
Unidentified speaker: Just say, look, you can do what you're gonna do, and I got the votes.
54:35
Unidentified speaker: Okay?
54:36
Unidentified speaker: So you do you, I'll do me, and good luck to you.
54:39
Unidentified speaker: So it's not so much about the proxy advisors, that's a feature of the system.
54:42
Unidentified speaker: But if so, for example, if I was at, if he was at 15% of the company or 20% of the company, and I was at 10%, 15% of the company, game over.
54:49
Unidentified speaker: You don't even need to go to the EGM because the balance of the odds is so much closer that you only have to turn such a small portion of the register that he'll come to the table sooner.
54:58
Unidentified speaker: The reason that's important is oftentimes we're dealing with let's call it, I'm not distressed companies, but we're not dealing with Amazon and Facebook.
55:07
Unidentified speaker: Like the chances that value is going up over the time is low.
55:12
Unidentified speaker: So time is time is very important.
55:14
Unidentified speaker: So between the time that we started the project and that we actually got our resolution was like nine months.
55:20
Unidentified speaker: It should have been three months.
55:21
Unidentified speaker: So if you walk up with a bazooka instead of a water pistol, you get them to the table within a few weeks.
55:27
Unidentified speaker: Or not, but it doesn't matter because you have a bazooka, right?
55:30
Unidentified speaker: So you get your meeting within two months.
55:31
Unidentified speaker: If that had happened in this Hum case, credit core would have been live.
55:35
Unidentified speaker: They dropped the bid because the chairman changed their situation, changed, the market changed, the world changed, and it happens.
55:40
Unidentified speaker: So time kills all deals, time kills all activity.
55:45
Unidentified speaker: So with more money, with more bullets, with a bigger gun, you can get you don't have to rely so much on others.
55:51
Unidentified speaker: And there, I mean, the hum case is also interesting because along the way, many Fairweather friends who said they would support the campaign, stock went up a little bit and they sold their shares.
55:59
Unidentified speaker: So it's like, you know, don't have to name names, but like they're not getting a Christmas card from I can't afford to buy them a Christmas card.
56:06
Unidentified speaker: But you know what I'm saying, right?
56:08
Unidentified speaker: Like, if you are show up and you're, you know, you you're holding more than just five percent of the company, if you're holding 10-15% of the company, a different story.
56:16
Unidentified speaker: Jeremy, we so much more we could have talked to you about.
56:18
Unidentified speaker: What time is it?
56:19
Unidentified speaker: We're out of time.
56:21
Unidentified speaker: We're very keen to see you come with a bazooka to the table more often in future.
56:25
Unidentified speaker: And yeah, looking forward to the next time.
56:27
Unidentified speaker: Thanks, guys.
56:28
Unidentified speaker: Been a pleasure.
56:29
Unidentified speaker: As always, a blast with Mr.
56:30
Unidentified speaker: Jeremy Raper.
56:31
Unidentified speaker: He thinks about the world very differently.
56:33
Unidentified speaker: He is engaging to chat with and he hunts down very, very salacious situations.
56:38
Unidentified speaker: So that's what's like Benny's brain, criticism.
56:41
Unidentified speaker: I'll let you enjoy that thought, Trev, while I give a big shout out to our awesome partners, Sand the Ground Support, Titan Recruitment, Focus, the platform by Market Tech, Intralinks, Cross Boundary Energy, and SLR.
56:52
Unidentified speaker: Check them all out.
56:54
Unidentified speaker: Now remember, I'm an idiot, JD's an idiot.
56:57
Unidentified speaker: If you thought any of this was anything other than entertainment, you're an idiot, and you need to read our disclaimer.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-GGUF:UD-Q4_K_XL. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.

More from Money of Mine

Money of Mine

Fooled Man Can't Get Fooled Again, Paladin (Weekly Wrap)

Episode discussion: Paladin raises $575M amid dilution concerns; Langer Heinrich cash flow questioned; Catalyst misses guidance

Speakers’ claims: Paladin announced a $575 million capital raise at $7.80 per share, resulting in 16% dilution, which Speaker 0 questions as potential balance sheet repair rather than growth funding for the PLS project. Langer Heinrich faces scrutiny over its cash flow generation, with only $18 million in operating cash flow against $397 million in revenue, and rising strip ratios threatening future production. Catalyst Metals missed Q3 guidance with a 30% production shortfall and rising costs, drawing criticism for late communication and restricted AGM access. Other updates include scoping studies for Q2 Metals and PMET, and a significant spodumene hit by Brunswick Exploration.

UraniumMining FinanceASX
37 min2 assets16 claims to verify
Money of Mine

We Won't Die Wondering (Alkane's Nic Earner)

Episode discussion: Nic Earner details Alkane's transition to ASX 200 via Mandalay merger and Boda development strategy

Speakers’ claims: Nic Earner outlines Alkane's evolution from a junior explorer to an ASX 200 constituent, driven by the strategic merger with Mandalay and the development of the Boda copper-gold asset. He discusses the operational success of the Tomingley and Costerfield mines, while reflecting on past strategic decisions including the ASM demerger and minority stakes in Genesis and Calidus. Earner emphasizes a perpetual reserve replacement philosophy, leveraging exploration culture inherited from Mandalay to fund growth until Boda's final investment decision in late 2029.

Alkane ResourcesMandalay ResourcesGold Mining
1h 5m2 assets20 claims to verify
All insights