Dr. Bryan Foltice Behavioral Finance Podcast

Speaker contrasts rigid tithing rules with intentional generosity and the psychology of receiving.

25 min Listen to the original
Behavioral FinancePersonal FinancePsychology of MoneyReligious TithingWealth ManagementGenerosityDecision MakingFinancial Planning

Summary

The speaker discusses how financial planning frameworks typically overlook the psychology of giving, treating it as an outlier rather than a core component of wealth wellness. He shares his personal evolution from adhering to a strict 10% tithe driven by authority bias to a more intentional, free-form approach to generosity. The speaker argues that historical religious texts like Malachi 3:10 were intended for priests, not laypeople, and that the New Testament encourages giving proportional to one's means. He introduces the concept of the 'warm glow' effect from James Andreoni, explaining that giving generates happiness but requires letting go of expectations for reciprocity. Finally, he emphasizes that genuine generosity involves viewing money as a two-way current, where learning to receive is as important as giving.

Episode sections

  1. 0:24 – 2:33

    Why Giving Lacks Frameworks

    The speaker notes that financial planning frameworks typically cover earning, saving, and protecting money, but lack guidance on giving. He describes giving as highly personal and difficult to fit into standard prioritization models due to varied backgrounds.

  2. 2:33 – 3:44

    From Tithing to Freedom

    The speaker shares his personal evolution from rule-based tithing to a more intentional, free-form approach to generosity. He aims to help listeners and clients move from obligation to a mindset of genuine generosity, particularly for those facing the 'decumulation paradox'.

  3. 3:44 – 7:39

    Early Church Experiences

    The speaker recounts his early religious experiences, starting with a traditional Protestant church where he learned to avoid services, then moving to a Pentecostal church for basketball, and later attending Christian universities with strict rules.

  4. 7:39 – 9:40

    Tithing Rules in Your 20s

    In his twenties, the speaker adhered to a strict 10% tithe based on authority bias from his church community. He describes giving 10% of net income without question, driven by the expectation of being blessed by God.

  5. 9:40 – 12:34

    Questioning the 10 Percent

    While living in Germany, the speaker researched Malachi 3:10 and realized the tithe was intended for priests, not laypeople. He concluded the New Testament encourages giving according to one's means rather than a fixed percentage, leading to a sense of freedom from obligation.

  6. 12:34 – 14:32

    Giving Without Obligation

    The speaker shifted from obligation to giving cash directly to people, such as paying for meals or groceries. He notes that this approach opened up new layers of life and allowed him to see where his money could have the most immediate impact.

  7. 14:32 – 15:11

    Cash Giving and Warm Glow

    The speaker discusses the 'warm glow' effect of giving, citing James Andreoni. He explains that giving creates a positive feeling, but he had to learn to receive back and let go of expectations of reciprocity to achieve genuine generosity.

  8. 15:11 – 24:36

    Receiving and Letting Go

    The speaker describes the challenge of learning to receive money and favors back after giving. He realized that expecting a return on his generosity was counterproductive, and he needed to view money as a two-way current that must flow through him.

Claims worth verifying

The speaker grew up attending a congregational church in Grand Rapids where services started at 11:00 AM and ended at 10:50 AM for those who avoided them.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·3:56

How to verify: This is a personal anecdote about the speaker's upbringing. It can be verified by checking the speaker's biography or public interviews where he discusses his early life in Grand Rapids, Michigan. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The speaker transferred from public school to a private school in ninth grade to play basketball.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·5:00

How to verify: This is a personal biographical detail. It can be verified by checking the speaker's professional biography or educational background listed on his firm's website or LinkedIn profile. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The private school the speaker attended was affiliated with the First Assemblies of God church.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·5:16

How to verify: This is a specific historical claim about the speaker's education. It can be verified by cross-referencing the speaker's educational history with the history of private Christian schools in his area during that time period. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The speaker attended Calvin College for two years and Cornerstone University for two years.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·6:56

How to verify: This is a verifiable educational fact. It can be confirmed by checking the speaker's LinkedIn profile, university alumni records, or professional biography. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The speaker moved to Jacksonville, Florida, in his twenties and began tithing 10% of his net income.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·7:39

How to verify: This is a personal financial history claim. It can be verified through the speaker's public biographical details or interviews discussing his early career and financial habits. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Malachi 3:10 was written towards the elders and priests of the church, not the general people.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·10:43

How to verify: This is a theological interpretation. It can be verified by consulting biblical commentaries, scholarly articles on the Book of Malachi, or religious texts that analyze the historical context of the verse. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The speaker gave $5,000 checks to his mom and her sisters over Christmas in his grandparents' later years.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·20:02

How to verify: This is a personal anecdote about the speaker's family. It can be verified by checking family records or public interviews where the speaker discusses his grandparents' estate planning or generosity. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The 'warm glow' giving effect was introduced by James Andreoni.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·21:38

How to verify: This is a factual claim about economic research. It can be verified by searching academic databases for James Andreoni's publications on altruism and the 'warm glow' theory, such as his 2026 paper 'Giving with Impure Altruism' in the American Economic Review. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify the definition and application of the 'decumulation paradox' in behavioral finance literature.
  • Research James Andreoni's original papers on the 'warm glow' theory of giving to understand the empirical basis for the happiness-giving link.
  • Review Malachi 3:10 in its historical context to assess the speaker's claim that it was intended for priests rather than laypeople.
  • Compare the speaker's interpretation of New Testament giving principles with standard theological commentaries on proportional vs. fixed giving.
  • Assess personal financial stability to determine if 'giving without obligation' aligns with one's own cash flow and emergency fund requirements.
  • Investigate potential conflicts of interest if the speaker is affiliated with any charitable organizations or financial advisory firms that benefit from client generosity.
  • Look for counter-arguments to the 'warm glow' effect, such as studies showing negative emotional outcomes from excessive or obligatory giving.
  • Check if the speaker's personal experience in Germany and Christian universities provides a representative sample for general financial behavior advice.
Full transcriptexpand

0:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Welcome to the Brian Fultis Behavioral Finance Podcast, where we unravel the mysteries of behavioral finance and unlock the secrets to making smarter, more informed decisions with your money. Now, here's your host, Dr. Brian Foltis.

0:24Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Welcome back, everybody. It's the Brian Fultis. Behavioral Finance Podcast. And today we're gonna be talking about a topic that I feel like is appropriate for the season and also a little bit challenging because there's not a lot of frameworks, and I like to think about things in that way. There's not a lot of framework around our topic today, which is the psychology of giving. And we spend a lot of time trying to understand how we invest money, how we earn money, save it, protect it, but we don't really have a ton of guidance around giving it away. And it doesn't totally fit in someone to into some of the frameworks, whether it's a behavioral finance framework or an overall financial wellness or financial wealth building plan.

1:25And the reason is it's highly personal, and

1:30Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): people

1:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): have all sorts of different backgrounds and experiences around giving, and where does it fit in their order privacy? prioritization is also very personalized. And so I just want to come at it from a perspective of there is a huge benefit from giving and living a generous life that needs to be discussed, how to do it, and see where that conversation goes

2:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): in

2:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): order to bring this critical component into. into our financial planning and our obviously our clients' financial planning as well.

2:10Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

2:10Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): so if there are no universal formulas to use, I wish, mathematically speaking, I wish we could just put it here in our order of prioritization, give this number, and let people execute it. Although that does sound like tithing, if you are affiliated with a religious institution, that's how you, that's how they do it. I'm going to share with you my personal story on how I've come from that tithing mentality into what I believe is way more exciting, way more interesting form of giving and generosity that has really opened. up

2:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a

2:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): whole new world of colors and layers of my life. And that's where sharing this information is hopefully going to help you and help develop your own ideas around giving. Also thinking about clients if you have them, getting your clients to have more of a giving mentality, especially those who have really. saved well and are dealing with what we call that decumulation paradox, where they're struggling to spend it, to see if we can give them some sort of keys to freely giving or freely spending or giving their money.

3:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So

3:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): when we go back to giving, we've got gotta to go all the way back to our first experiences and around that topic. What were your first experiences around giving? Where were you brought up and how did this this work? And so when I think about my first experiences, we go back to the church days, and I grew up in my early years at a congregational church. So it's a very traditional Protestant church and it was in the old church right downtown in Grand Rapids that we went to. And all I really truly remember about that church experience was that church started at eleven o'clock. And if we could somehow deter or not leave or find a way to drag out time. until 1050. That was the cutoff point in which we wouldn't have to go to church. Whether that means avoiding the getting in the car or dragging your feet, eating breakfast, that was the strategy to get us to 1050. So we didn't have to go to

4:42church, which started at 11. Anytime under that, we would make it in time, even if we were a little bit late to the service.

4:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

4:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): we would just basically sit through that for an hour and a half. And that was my church experience. When I was in ninth grade, I actually transferred from the public school to a private school. And the big driver of that was I liked the idea of playing basketball for that program and the coach and the public school that I was in, they would need to pass the ball

5:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): ten

5:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): times before they could shoot a shot, and then they had to get it into the big guys, and I'm just a run and gun small guy who wanted to get out and score in in open spaces, and they scored a lot of points at that program. So I was like, get me over here. What I didn't realize. was this private school was affiliated with the First Assemblies of God church. And that was a very Pentecostal church. And I got to experience the Pentecostal church for the first time. And I'll never forget that first praise gathering where people are waving flags and had their hands there. I was like, I remember gripping the seat. in front of me, and my arms were kind of just shaking because I was kind of nervous. And I realized later that was actually the fruit of the spirit that was actually quite acceptable in this Pentecostal setting to have shaking arms. And that was my pivot from traditional church into Pentecostal. And I really liked a lot of the components. There was that personal relationship with God. that they had. It was a very emotional driven. But when you're young, you're kind of drawn to that as well. So I really liked that. And so my first

6:36years as being what I would having an official personal relationship with God was were those years in my teens. And so that led me to making my college decision, which was add at another private. university. I did two years at Calvin, which was a Christian Reformed church. So a little bit closer to the traditional church that I had been to. And then the last two years were at a Baptist church. And so just again, not Pentecostal, we're dialing it back a little bit, but the Cornerstone University that I went to in my last two years. also in Grand Rapids, was a dry campus, so you d couldn't drink, couldn't do anything. There was just a lot of rules around there and I actually abided by that. I my twenty first birthday, I'd had two basketball practices that day and didn't have a drop of alcohol. I don't think that in

7:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I

7:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): don't even know if that was like the entire year. And I'm making up for it now. And anyway, th this whole thing is leading me up to the expectation of when you're in your twenties and when we moved to Jacksonville, Florida. The first thing we did was we got involved in a non denominational church and we loved it. And we got plugged in and we're starting to make our first paychecks. And the expectation around the income that's coming in. were derived from those religious experiences and the authority figures, which we talk about the authority bias when it's coming from an authority, and you kind of take it as, okay, this is

8:16Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what

8:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I need to do without any question. And that was tithing. That was giving 10%. And that was without question, you give 10%. And that was our the first experiences. So it didn't matter what you were making, didn't matter what other financial obligations you had, 10%, no ifs, ands, or buts. And then the question became: do you give 10% of your top line, or do you give 10% of your gross income? And you don't want to shortchange God. And so you're going gonna to do 10% of your net income. And then of course they would have given. giving programs above and beyond that ten percent. They were trying to get you into that. And so then if you did that, you would get into separate like clubs of growth and different things like that. And so that was what my ex-wife and I did a lot in our twenties.

9:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

9:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): so we did it and we liked it. We loved our church and we got to see and feel like we were participating in what was happening in our church and we were connected through the people and that was just the way we were gonna do it. And we we were always told that you give and you'll be blessed by God and he'll do more with the ninety percent than than you can do with the hundred percent. And it's like, ah that that's I don't know any other difference, so let's yeah, sure. And so what happened was we moved to Germany and basically got to see the church from 5,000 miles away. Um that can sober you up a little bit when you get disconnected from the experiences there, the people there,

10:01Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and they're

10:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): just kind. of moving on, and you're moving on five thousand miles away. And so, nevertheless, with our poultry incomes that we had and trying to raise kids, we were still faithful in giving our ten percent. And it was just one day where I was researching this Malachi 310, and it always says, bring the full tithe into the storehouse. and I'll pour you out a blessing. And so I was really trying to

10:33Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): dig

10:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): into that. And I was like, was that who was that for? And who was Malachi written for? And from my understanding, that was written towards

10:43Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the

10:43Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): elders and the the priests of the church for them to be able to give the full tithe into the storehouse.

10:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

10:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): they were shortchanging God and

10:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but

10:54Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): it was for the priests, not the people

10:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): who

10:58Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): are trying to start family. And I was like, is this real? And so I prayed about it. I was like,

11:03Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): this

11:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): is really messing with me because I thought for sure this was the only way to go. And so what? And so I started just going, Oh no, there's no obligation for 10% tithe. However, there are that's that's a lot of Old Testament stuff. And so

11:20Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the

11:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): New Testament, from my understanding, was you give according to your own means and live a generous life through that. Oh wait, so there's no mention of 10%. It so for somebody that could be 20%, somebody that could be 1%. And so again, we want to get to a mathematical equation, and they're saying we're going to leave this up between you and what you feel called to give. And that was my aha moment. And I was like, I don't have the obligation to do this. And I felt good when I prayed about it. That then I don't have to have that obligation. And so it really made me question. my reasoning for it. So obviously it's past experience, but then there was this obligation that I felt. Also, there was this thought of if I do it, I'll receive something from this in return. And so whether that's blessing or I'm gonna increase my money with

12:23whatever's left over, more there's this thought. of receiving at the same time.

12:29Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

12:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): it really made me change my way of thinking around giving. So naturally, if I'm not in the obligation stage, my first instinct is I'm you're making all of this. And so for a long time it was a a very me us family And I think that's okay because we were just trying to get by. We were trying to get through having a couple of kids and living in a foreign country, being on a meager stipend for my job as a PhD student. And so it seemed like that was a perfect time to hunker down. And once you store it up, then you can give a little bit more. And so this is where

13:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we

13:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): went through that stage. And then as we got older and as we start accumulating some wealth, it starts reversing out, and you start getting nudged into hey, we should start thinking about where we want to give, how we want to give,

13:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): what

13:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): we're gonna do. And now what's really cool is we don't have this obligation to a church to give them the 10%. And all of a sudden, the floodgates open because now all of a sudden we had control of how much, where, why, all the different components. And so when we move from rules. we got to what I feel like is this larger freedom. Now, of course, there wasn't an immediate benefit. There were when I started giving more freely, this would come in different facets, but it could just

14:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it

14:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): wouldn't look would different for different circumstances. And whether it's if it was a organization that we believed in, or if it was literally, I would take out $300 a month in cash, and then I would just give it to people as I saw fit, pay for people's meals, pay for people's groceries, and you just build this awareness and you just wait. for just little prompts like, yep, right there, do it. And just take care of that. And you just every time you walk away, you're just like, Oh, that feels really good. That was awesome. And then when you start doing that kind of stuff, you start noticing things come back to you really quickly. And so one thing I had to struggle with, they're or actually two. things I had to work through when I started giving in that free way, is one, I had to learn how to receive because things would come back to me and people would start doing things for me out of nowhere. And I would always have always felt like, no, I I don't need to receive. But

15:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): as you

15:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): learned, learn about like currency and money as a current, like you have to let it flow through you, but then also give it to a two way street. You have to be able to receive that and let it go through you and be able to give it away. You can't have one or the other. And I was like, okay. So I had to work through that. Work out how to receive and be grateful about receiving it. And then secondly, I had to know that I started building up a expectation of ooh, I give this, guess what's coming back to me. I can't wait to see what's coming. And I I'll never forget I had a moment where I was I had just done something for somebody, and it was like $250 or $300 or something like that. And I was feeling really good. And I was in the car and was coming back from the gym. And I was thinking to myself, it's like, oh, right, or if I gave away $300 just now, I wonder how much is coming back to me. I wonder how it's going to come back to me. And I had

16:46Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): a

16:47Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): really bad feeling in my stomach around that.

16:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

16:50Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I sat with that. the entire car ride. And now everybody has their own gut, right? My gut is always right, knows things that I don't know yet. And it my gut is always on my right side. So if I feel my right side hurting, it's a stop and pay attention. What are you doing? Oftentimes, though, I'm stupid enough to just continue on. when I feel that 100% of the time it bites me in the ass. So anyway, I felt that in my side. I was like, why? I just gave this amount and it came to me that I did that with the full expectation of getting that back, and that is not the point. So I had to go from learning to receive to then learn to not have the expectation. but just to give gratefully and to be that vessel that is able to give and receive and let money throw through me. So I went from obligation to giving with expectations now to hopefully where I'm at with just genuine generosity. Say that again. Genuine generosity. Giving because we want to help, because we're blessed, regardless. of what happens afterwards. Not keeping score, not expecting any sort

18:09of reciprocity, money coming back, or favors coming back. And what I feel like is the awesomeness of life just goes to a whole nother level when you do that. And my challenge now is. how much do you want to push this? Here's what happens when you give X amount. Stretch it a little bit more. Here's how much other things happen. So again, not falling into that obligation, but really trying to challenge yourself so you can truly be that that generous person. And so I think about my experiences with money and I go to that tithing but I just as I was preparing for this I remembered my grandpa Scott so I had grandpa and grandma fultis grandpa and grandma scott and that's my mom's side of the family and my both of my grandparents fought in World War II grandpa Fultis

19:14he was about to get drafted in the MLB, the major league baseball draft, and he got called into service before that draft happened. He was drafted into the w the war draft. So he served as a gunman. And when my grandpa Scott served, he was a a chemist by trade, and he was captured and spent thirty-nine months as a prisoner of war and during the World War II. And his story on how he took oil and rice and fed the concentration camps are nothing short of incredible. And somehow survived thirty-nine months as a prisoner of war in World War II. And when he

20:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): was in

20:03Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): his last years, he and my grandma, I'll never forget this experience, over Christmas, they wrote out checks to my mom and her sisters. And I believe they were like $5,000 each, which probably, if you go back in time, that was probably the maximum gift contribution you can give to any individual. I think it's $18. eighteen thousand dollars now.

20:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

20:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): so that was basically the equivalent of it. But I remember seeing the reactions and he was able to be alive, and my grandma was able to be alive to see that money changing hands, not over their dead bodies when they're going through probate court and trying to get their estate in order. And that really stuck with me. not only so financially, to be able to

20:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be

20:55Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): that blessing, to be able to help people in that way. I got to see what generosity looked like. And so not only was I really reminded of that today, I also I reminded my of my grandpa Scott as being an awesome individual who would always have such. an impact on people and would even like at his funeral, he had like dental assistance coming up, and he just oh, he was so nice, and he just made time, and it's like that's what I want to be like. So anyway, hopefully I'm able to emulate some of that stuff. But psychology of giving, what research tells us,

21:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): there's

21:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): a warm glow giving effect introduced by James Andriani. And so that actually raises the question of if giving makes us feel good, does that make it selfish? And like we tried to disentangle, hopefully, not.

21:56Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): What

21:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): else is there? Giving and in happiness. I think anybody who has given out of generosity can experience. that happiness and that feeling. And so trying to encourage others to do the same thing, even if it's a small amount, just get a hit or get a taste of that feeling, and you will want to come back to them more. And then I think

22:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we'll

22:22Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): leave it alone. We just one of the things though, as you move into this, is don't be surprised when you see things that would be called serendipitous happen to you, when you see coincidences stack up that are improbable to in in conjunction with each other happen. Don't be surprised when those things start coming your way, when things start literally falling into your lap. This is when I said adding this to your life is something that is going to move your whole well-being into a whole different dimension.

23:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And

23:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): so that's where I want to leave you: is do it,

23:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be

23:12Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): grateful when it comes back to you without expectations. And when you see that happen, don't be surprised when all these amazing things start working for you. So anyway, thanks for watching today. Hope you have an awesome holiday season and can embrace some of what we've talked about here today. So thanks for watching again. If you need anything, let me know. Love to hear from you. in the notes. Would love to teach whatever seminars, workshops, whatever's in your world, you know I'm available to teach. It's not just with my butler classroom job. So please understand that and come talk to me on how I might be able to serve you and your employees, your clients, and let's have that conversation. Thanks everybody. Have an awesome day, and we'll see you on the next episode. Bye-bye.

24:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Thank you for tuning in to another episode of the Brian Fultis Behavioral Finance Podcast. We hope you found our exploration into the fascinating world of human behavior and finance, both enlightening and thought-provoking. Be sure to subscribe for future episodes. And until next time, stay curious. and financially savvy.

This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights