Speaker argues NZ tax revenue is below OECD average and warns current work-based system is unsustainable for an aging population.
Summary
The speaker refutes the notion that New Zealanders pay excessive taxes by noting that NZ tax revenue as a share of GDP is slightly below the OECD average. The episode outlines that New Zealand’s tax system relies heavily on individual income tax and GST, lacking wealth, inheritance, or property taxes common in other developed nations. The speaker argues this work-centric design, established post-WWII, is becoming unsustainable due to demographic shifts and a shrinking working-age population. It is predicted that without broadening the tax base to include land and capital, taxes on workers could rise by 50% over the next 50 years. The discussion concludes by criticizing the political focus on tax rates alone, advocating instead for a view of tax as a tool for societal solidarity.
Episode sections
- 0:07 – 1:09
Purpose of Government and Tax
Defines government's role in setting rules and providing public goods, identifying tax as the primary revenue tool distinct from debt.
- 1:09 – 2:39
New Zealand Tax Revenue vs. OECD
Refutes the claim that NZers pay too much tax by comparing NZ tax revenue as a share of GDP to the OECD average.
- 2:39 – 4:39
Structure of New Zealand's Tax System
Describes NZ’s reliance on individual income tax and GST, noting the absence of property, inheritance, or wealth taxes.
- 4:39 – 5:53
Philosophical Design: Work vs. Wealth
Argues the system deliberately taxes work income while exempting asset income, a design established post-WWII.
- 5:53 – 7:14
Government Spending Priorities
Lists spending priorities including health, welfare, NZ Super, and education, arguing tax debates must start with spending.
- 7:14 – 8:56
Tax Principles: Broadness and Progressivity
Outlines principles of broad application and progressivity, noting Australia has a more progressive income tax regime.
- 8:56 – 10:45
Demographic Shifts and Sustainability
Predicts a 50% increase in taxes on workers if the system does not broaden to include land, capital, and wealth due to demographic shifts.
- 10:45 – 12:05
Conclusion: Tax as Solidarity
Concludes that tax is a tool for solidarity and criticizes the current political discourse as 'infantile' for focusing only on tax rates.
Claims worth verifying
New Zealand's tax revenue as a share of GDP is slightly under the OECD average.
Unidentified speaker ·1:16
How to verify: Check OECD Revenue Statistics database for 'Total Tax Revenue (% of GDP)' comparing New Zealand and the OECD average for recent years.
Nearly half of New Zealand's tax revenue comes from taxes imposed on individuals through work.
Unidentified speaker ·2:45
How to verify: Review New Zealand Inland Revenue Department (IRD) or Treasury fiscal statements for the breakdown of tax revenue by source (Income Tax vs. GST vs. others).
GST accounts for nearly about 22% of New Zealand's tax revenue.
Unidentified speaker ·3:06
How to verify: Check New Zealand Treasury or IRD fiscal data for the percentage contribution of Goods and Services Tax to total government revenue.
New Zealand does not have targeted social security contributions, payroll taxes, property transaction taxes, net wealth taxes, estate duties, or inheritance duties.
Unidentified speaker ·4:02
How to verify: Review New Zealand tax legislation and compare with OECD tax policy reports on 'Payroll Taxes', 'Property Taxes', and 'Wealth/Inheritance Taxes'.
Australia has a far more progressive income tax regime than New Zealand, including a tax-free threshold and many more bands.
Unidentified speaker ·8:00
How to verify: Compare the income tax brackets and thresholds of the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) and New Zealand Inland Revenue Department (IRD).
New Zealand's working-age population as a share of the population will be shrinking for the foreseeable future.
Unidentified speaker ·9:25
How to verify: Check New Zealand Department of Statistics (Stats NZ) population projections and median age forecasts.
If the current tax system remains unchanged, taxes paid by working people will have to increase something like 50% over the course of the next 40-50 years.
Unidentified speaker ·10:00
How to verify: This is a speaker's projection/estimate. Verification would require modeling NZ Treasury long-term fiscal sustainability reports against demographic projections to see if a 50% hike in labor tax is required to fund current spending.
Do your own research
- Verify New Zealand’s tax revenue as a percentage of GDP against the latest OECD Tax Revenue Database to confirm the 'below average' claim.
- Review the New Zealand Inland Revenue Department (IRD) annual reports to confirm the breakdown of revenue sources (income tax vs. GST vs. other).
- Compare New Zealand’s income tax brackets and thresholds with the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) data to assess the claim of higher progressivity in Australia.
- Check Stats NZ population projections for the working-age demographic (typically ages 15-64) over the next 50 years to validate the sustainability argument.
- Research New Zealand’s public spending allocations in the annual Budget documents to verify the stated priority order of health, welfare, and superannuation.
- Investigate proposals for land value taxation or wealth taxes in New Zealand policy circles to understand the 'broadening the tax base' alternatives mentioned.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:00
- Unidentified speaker: This is Economy Made Simple with Shamubil Yaku.
- 0:03
- Unidentified speaker: There's a lot going on in the world right now, and I'm here to make sense of it.
- 0:07
- Unidentified speaker: In this episode, I want to talk about tax.
- 0:09
- Unidentified speaker: It's a really big topic, and we see lots of emotions that run high when we talk about tax.
- 0:15
- Unidentified speaker: In an earlier episode, I talked about the purpose of government, and I think that's a good place to start.
- 0:20
- Unidentified speaker: The reason why we have government is because we wanted to set the rules, we wanted to fix market failures, we wanted to provide public services, public goods, we wanted to ensure against big events, and we wanted to be able to share across community today and with future generations.
- 0:37
- Unidentified speaker: So the purpose of government is very big, it's very diverse, and it has some specific financial tools to make it happen.
- 0:44
- Unidentified speaker: And those tools are very much where taxes come in.
- 0:48
- Unidentified speaker: So to deliver our services, this business of government, we need to spend money, and that requires revenue, and that's what tax does.
- 0:56
- Unidentified speaker: We also have other spending in terms of investments and infrastructure that is generally funded with debt.
- 1:02
- Unidentified speaker: So I won't talk about that much today, but it's something that's of course very important as a part of the wider mix of what government does.
- 1:09
- Unidentified speaker: The first thing when we talk about tax, and I hear this a lot, is but we pay so much tax in New Zealand.
- 1:15
- Unidentified speaker: It's actually not true.
- 1:16
- Unidentified speaker: When you look at New Zealand's tax revenue as a share of GDP, we are pretty much on average with the OECD, slightly under.
- 1:24
- Unidentified speaker: But the challenge that we have is the way that we think about the role of government and public services and public goods, we want to have lots of it.
- 1:33
- Unidentified speaker: We want really high quality, we want it to be really easily and widely available, but we want to pay very low taxes.
- 1:40
- Unidentified speaker: Those two things are not compatible.
- 1:43
- Unidentified speaker: If you want more public services, if you want better public services, you have to pay for it.
- 1:48
- Unidentified speaker: And generally the tool for that is tax.
- 1:51
- Unidentified speaker: When I think about the way that we collect tax and who pays tax, both of those things matter.
- 1:56
- Unidentified speaker: But the reason why we collect tax is because it's a way for us to collectivize.
- 2:01
- Unidentified speaker: We bring our contributions together into one place, and then when it's together, we are then able to do things that we would individually not be able to do.
- 2:10
- Unidentified speaker: For example, you and I could not have a health system on our own, but when we pool our resources, we're able to do that.
- 2:16
- Unidentified speaker: But we also know that taxes can be a distortion.
- 2:19
- Unidentified speaker: So the more taxes are levied, the less that incentive might be for us to do an extra bit of work or earn a bit more profit.
- 2:26
- Unidentified speaker: So when we do collect those taxes, it's important for us to have design that makes sure that those distortions are worth it because the tax that we'll spend on things is net net going to be better for New Zealand.
- 2:39
- Unidentified speaker: Now, when I look at New Zealand, it's quite unique in the world in the way that we levy taxes.
- 2:45
- Unidentified speaker: The majority of it, nearly half, is taxes that are imposed on individuals mainly through work.
- 2:52
- Unidentified speaker: So we tax wage very heavily.
- 2:55
- Unidentified speaker: The second big chunk is the taxes we spend on GST.
- 2:59
- Unidentified speaker: So that's essentially the taxes levied on all the goods and services we buy, almost everything, excepting financial services.
- 3:06
- Unidentified speaker: And that's a very big chunk, nearly about 22%.
- 3:10
- Unidentified speaker: And then we have some levies, excise duties, corporate taxes, those kinds of things.
- 3:16
- Unidentified speaker: So that makes up kind of where our taxes come from.
- 3:19
- Unidentified speaker: And so you can see that New Zealand has this system that's very deliberately designed to tax a particular way of doing things, which is about taxing work.
- 3:28
- Unidentified speaker: And New Zealand is very unusual when we compare ourselves to the OECD.
- 3:33
- Unidentified speaker: So our tax on income is very high relative to other places.
- 3:38
- Unidentified speaker: We are also really high when it comes to taxes on things like GSD or contributions to savings.
- 3:45
- Unidentified speaker: So in most other countries, those tend to be much smaller.
- 3:48
- Unidentified speaker: Where we tend to be much lower is we tend to have lower excise duties, so taxes on things like alcohol and tobacco and fuel.
- 3:56
- Unidentified speaker: The things that we don't have at all are things like targeted social security contributions.
- 4:02
- Unidentified speaker: So for example, in most other countries, if you're going to have money in a pension fund or something like New Zealand Super, you would have a separate line item that would take that money from your taxes.
- 4:13
- Unidentified speaker: In New Zealand, we don't have that.
- 4:15
- Unidentified speaker: Many other countries have payroll taxes, they have taxes on property transactions, they have taxes on net wealth, and they have taxes on estate duties, inheritance duties, and sometimes death duties.
- 4:28
- Unidentified speaker: We don't have any of those at all.
- 4:30
- Unidentified speaker: So what we have is a very unusual setup where we just don't tax a whole bunch of different things, but the things we do tax, we tax very heavily.
- 4:39
- Unidentified speaker: There is a philosophical question here in terms of why is it that the income that you earn from work is taxable, but the income that you earn from your money is not.
- 4:51
- Unidentified speaker: And our tax system very deliberately is designed in a way that says that income that's earned through work is taxable, but income that is earned through being wealthy or having assets is not taxable.
- 5:04
- Unidentified speaker: And this all kind of fits back under this wider picture of why do we have the taxes that we have?
- 5:11
- Unidentified speaker: And it was very much a deliberate decision that we had made in New Zealand over a long time ago, really after the Second World War, where we wanted to have a larger government.
- 5:21
- Unidentified speaker: And it became larger over time, gradually, we paid more taxes and we had more provision of public services.
- 5:29
- Unidentified speaker: Over the course of the last 40 years, the conversation has been much more difficult, which has been about is the size of government too big?
- 5:36
- Unidentified speaker: But we don't have that more honest conversation about whether or not the things that we spend money on, those public goods and public services, are they the things that we want and how much are we willing to pay for it?
- 5:48
- Unidentified speaker: And are the right people or the right sources of income or wealth paying for it?
- 5:53
- Unidentified speaker: When we talk about tax, we start with the question of tax rather than the question of spending.
- 5:57
- Unidentified speaker: When I look at where we spend our money, the top is health, followed by other welfare, followed by New Zealand Super, then education, then core government services, then all these other things like housing, infrastructure, justice system, transport, including defense.
- 6:14
- Unidentified speaker: So when we think about the taxes we pay, the question that we need to ask ourselves is what public services do we want, how much of it, and of what quality.
- 6:23
- Unidentified speaker: We cannot have a system where we keep on asking ourselves, is the tax too high or is the tax too low without answering that question of what is the purpose of government and what are those public goods and services that we want for all New Zealanders.
- 6:37
- Unidentified speaker: So tax is a really big topic, but it's also a really simple topic, in the sense that fundamentally tax is about pooling our resources, it's a way for us to practice solidarity.
- 6:48
- Unidentified speaker: When we do that, we are able to provide services that are available to all or most New Zealanders.
- 6:55
- Unidentified speaker: And it's a mechanism for us to be able to coordinate between people who are here today, so we can redistribute from one group to another, should we wish to, or we can make decisions today that are intergenerational so that we are able to make investments and expenditure choices that will last through generations.
- 7:14
- Unidentified speaker: Who pays for it is the question that I think exercises most people's minds.
- 7:18
- Unidentified speaker: There are two principles that are really important when we design taxes.
- 7:22
- Unidentified speaker: It should be broad, so it should apply to everybody.
- 7:25
- Unidentified speaker: And when it comes to New Zealand's tax system, it does that really well.
- 7:29
- Unidentified speaker: So everyone pays income tax.
- 7:31
- Unidentified speaker: Whether you're a beneficiary or somebody who's earning many hundreds of thousands of dollars, all of us will pay income tax.
- 7:37
- Unidentified speaker: When it comes to GST, all of us pay it very broadly.
- 7:40
- Unidentified speaker: It's also the principle of progressivity, that those of us who earn more money pay more tax.
- 7:46
- Unidentified speaker: And we have built that into our system.
- 7:48
- Unidentified speaker: So when you think about our income taxes on work, for example, it's progressive.
- 7:53
- Unidentified speaker: We have bands where you pay lower taxes, so if you're earning less, you tend to pay less tax.
- 7:57
- Unidentified speaker: But if you earn more, you pay more tax.
- 8:00
- Unidentified speaker: Surprisingly, Australia has a far more progressive income tax regime than we do.
- 8:05
- Unidentified speaker: So they have a tax-free threshold right at the bottom, and they have many more bans and much higher rates.
- 8:10
- Unidentified speaker: That means that the more you earn, the more tax you pay on average.
- 8:15
- Unidentified speaker: What's missing in New Zealand is very much those taxes that we don't charge at all.
- 8:20
- Unidentified speaker: We don't charge taxes on capital income, we don't charge taxes on things like inheritance and death and property transactions.
- 8:29
- Unidentified speaker: We don't necessarily have to do those things.
- 8:31
- Unidentified speaker: But when we have that conversation about taxes, we need to ask ourselves, why is it that we have a tax system that is so different from other rich countries around the world?
- 8:40
- Unidentified speaker: What is the deliberate decision that we made to make that happen?
- 8:43
- Unidentified speaker: And is it really fair when we have a shrinking working age population over the course of the next 50 years that we still have a tax system that is so completely out of sync with the future that we can see coming at us?
- 8:56
- Unidentified speaker: When I think about that future shift that needs to happen, it's pretty clear to me that we cannot sustain the tax system that New Zealand has today.
- 9:04
- Unidentified speaker: It is very much designed for a time when we have lots and lots of young people who are in work, who are spending lots of money, who are in the prime of their lives.
- 9:14
- Unidentified speaker: But the reality is that if you look at the projections for New Zealand's future over the course of the next 50 years, we are going to have more people retiring than people entering the workforce.
- 9:25
- Unidentified speaker: Our working age population as a share of the population will be shrinking for the foreseeable future, whether we have immigration or not.
- 9:32
- Unidentified speaker: The reality is that our tax system will have to have a really major and fundamental shift.
- 9:39
- Unidentified speaker: Either that will happen gradually and progressively over time, because we start to do that today, and we start to broaden our tax base to include things like land and capital and wealth.
- 9:51
- Unidentified speaker: The reality is that we must do that because so much of the income potential of New Zealand is going to be held in those places.
- 9:59
- Unidentified speaker: If we stick to the current system of taxing work and spending, then this tax paid by working people will have to increase something like 50% over the course of the next 40-50 years.
- 10:11
- Unidentified speaker: That is simply not sustainable.
- 10:13
- Unidentified speaker: So we are setting ourselves up for this political fight that will either be gradual, progressive change in our spending and tax policy, or it will happen really violently at some point in the future where we're going to see this incredible dislocation where one generation will decide this is no longer working, and those of you who haven't paid enough tax so far will now pay lots of tax, or those services, those public services, public goods that we become used to will no longer be around.
- 10:45
- Unidentified speaker: Tax is fundamentally a tool, but it's a tool that needs to reflect the purpose of government and the will and the values of the people.
- 10:53
- Unidentified speaker: Right now, the conversation on tax in New Zealand is infantile.
- 10:57
- Unidentified speaker: We only talk about whether it should go up or whether we should go down.
- 11:00
- Unidentified speaker: We don't ask why we want to collect those taxes to create a society that is prosperous into the future.
- 11:07
- Unidentified speaker: Some years ago I coined the term that tax is love.
- 11:11
- Unidentified speaker: Some people were very angry about it.
- 11:13
- Unidentified speaker: But the reality is that is the only way, as a very diverse group of people in New Zealand, we can come together to pool our financial resources so we're able to spend and invest on things in New Zealand that makes New Zealand better.
- 11:26
- Unidentified speaker: So next time you pay tax, have a think about the wider purpose of why we do it, how we do it, and how we might change this in the future to make things better and fairer.
- 11:37
- Unidentified speaker: Everything we cover in this session is for general information only.
- 11:41
- Unidentified speaker: We are not tailoring our comments to your financial situation or providing financial advice or recommendations.
- 11:46
- Unidentified speaker: This information and comments we provide are not intended to convey any guarantees as to the future performance of any investment products, asset classes, or capital benefits.
- 11:57
- Unidentified speaker: Past performance is no guarantee of future performance.
- 12:01
- Unidentified speaker: Please refer to our full disclosure statement in the description below.