The Call from ausbiz

Pepe and Riaz debate Australian vs US markets, sell Adore Beauty and NAB, buy NextDC and IGO

56 min Listen to the original Episode page
Australian EquitiesUS EquitiesRetailBankingEnergyDefensive StocksETFsBiotech

Summary

Philip Pepe and Zach Riaz discuss macroeconomic outlooks, with Pepe favoring Australian equities due to lower valuations and Riaz preferring US markets citing RBA rate hike expectations. They advise selling Adore Beauty and NAB, while recommending buys in NextDC and IGO. Defensive stocks like Coles and Telstra are viewed as expensive or neutral, with Suncorp sold by Pepe but held by Riaz. The hosts also cover AGL, Polynovo, and the AQTY ETF, highlighting sector-specific risks and valuation concerns.

Episode sections

  1. 0:23 – 4:10

    Market Overview and Macro Outlook

    Andrew Gagan introduces the show and guests Philip Pepe and Zach Riaz. Philip Pepe suggests the Australian market is relatively advantageous due to lower revenue multiples compared to US tech, though he notes oil price volatility and lagging interest rate impacts. Zach Riaz prefers US markets, citing constraints in the Australian economy and expectations for further RBA rate hikes.

  2. 4:10 – 10:02

    Stock of the Day: Adore Beauty (ABY)

    The host presents Adore Beauty's slashed earnings guidance and stock drop. Philip Pepe advises selling, citing poor timing for brick-and-mortar expansion and weak consumer sentiment. Zach Riaz also advises avoiding the stock, questioning its competitive advantage and value proposition compared to competitors like David Jones.

  3. 10:02 – 15:33

    Coles Group (COL) vs Woolworths (WOW)

    A listener asks about switching from Coles to Woolworths or other defensives. Zach Riaz suggests trimming Coles to buy Woolworths due to better recent like-for-like sales performance, though he views them as similar defensive plays. Philip Pepe agrees Coles is expensive and suggests selling it, potentially for a higher-yielding defensive like SALT, while noting Woolworths is also expensive.

  4. 15:33 – 19:43

    Telstra Group (TLS)

    Philip Pepe calls Telstra a hold, citing its strong competitive position and high dividend yield despite being expensive. Zach Riaz also calls it a hold/neutral, acknowledging near-term stability but warning of long-term erosion of Telstra's premium due to Starlink competition and capital intensity.

  5. 19:43 – 23:31

    VanEck MSCI Australian Quality Plus ETF (AQTY)

    The hosts discuss the AQTY ETF. Zach Riaz views it as a valid allocation for diversification in the concentrated Australian market but warns of potential underperformance relative to the broader market. Philip Pepe calls it a hold, noting its recent outperformance is likely due to heavy bank weighting, but suggests passive index funds as a cheaper alternative.

  6. 23:31 – 28:09

    Lovisa (LOV)

    Philip Pepe advises selling Lovisa ahead of its AGM, citing risks from consumer spending slowdowns and the dangers of store expansion in a tough environment. Zach Riaz is neutral, suggesting taking profits due to the tough market environment and potential negative operating leverage, though he is less negative than Pepe on the business mechanics.

  7. 28:09 – 33:25

    Suncorp Group (SUN)

    Zach Riaz holds Suncorp, viewing it as a diversifier from banks with a benign insurance environment. Philip Pepe sells Suncorp, arguing that reinsurance rates are softening, property values are impacting insurance growth, and consumers are becoming more price-sensitive due to interest rate impacts.

  8. 33:25 – 38:23

    NextDC: Buy vs Hold Debate

    Philip Pepe recommends buying NextDC, citing political pushback and power supply issues as overdone fears that created a buying opportunity. Zach Riaz maintains a hold/neutral stance, expressing caution due to the company's high leverage and balance sheet risks despite owning a small position.

  9. 38:23 – 41:45

    AGL Energy: Valuation and Transition

    Zach Riaz views AGL as a fair-value trading stock with a decent yield, noting risks from capital expenditure and coal asset retirement. Philip Pepe agrees it is cheap and calls it a buy, arguing that coal-fired stations will remain operational longer than expected, supporting the energy transition narrative.

  10. 41:45 – 45:04

    Polynovo: Speculative Biotech Risks

    Philip Pepe recommends selling Polynovo, arguing that despite good business fundamentals, the stock is priced for perfection in a rising rate environment unsuitable for speculative biotechs. Zach Riaz holds a neutral view, acknowledging positive net income but avoiding the sector due to binary outcome risks.

  11. 45:04 – 49:59

    NAB Bank: Sector Headwinds

    Zach Riaz holds NAB as a relative core holding but remains underweight banks due to top valuations and macro risks to the SME market. Philip Pepe recommends selling NAB, citing a poor environment for banks with rising defaults and suggesting ANZ and CBA as superior alternatives.

  12. 49:59 – 56:10

    IGO Limited: Lithium Volatility

    Philip Pepe recommends buying IGO as a medium-term play on electrification, accepting the volatility associated with lithium prices. Zach Riaz holds a neutral stance, warning of further consensus downgrades and disappointing EV growth rates, though he acknowledges IGO as a key pick in the space.

Assets discussed

AssetKindStanceContext
NVIDIANVDAequityneutraluh last week really dominated by NVIDIA. This week's gonna going to be anthropic, but um look, I guess we're obviously talking more local stock. stocks.

“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.

Claims worth verifying

Oil supply is growing faster than demand, and this is driving the Australian market.

Philip Pepe ·1:38

How to verify: Check recent reports from the International Energy Agency (IEA) or OPEC on global oil supply and demand forecasts for late 2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

US consensus expects three further rate hikes over the next four months.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·3:16

How to verify: Review CME FedWatch Tool or Federal Reserve meeting minutes/press conferences from November 2026 for market-implied rate expectations. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Adore Beauty slashed FY26 earnings guidance to $4-6.5 million from $9-13 million.

Andrew Gagan ·4:30

How to verify: Check Adore Beauty's ASX announcements or quarterly reports for FY26 earnings guidance updates. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Adore Beauty revenue fell 8% over the first 20 weeks of the new financial year.

Andrew Gagan ·4:30

How to verify: Check Adore Beauty's interim trading updates or annual reports for revenue performance data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Adore Beauty stock is down 96% over the last five years.

Philip Pepe ·6:13

How to verify: Calculate the percentage change in Adore Beauty's share price from November 2026 to November 2026 using historical price data from Yahoo Finance or ASX. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Coles and Woolworths alternate leadership in like-for-like sales growth.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·11:54

How to verify: Compare quarterly like-for-like sales data for Coles Group and Woolworths Group from their respective investor relations pages. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Coles owns liquor stores which face headwinds from younger demographics and GLP-1 drugs.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·13:51

How to verify: Check Coles Group's annual report for segment revenue breakdown (liquor) and review market research on alcohol consumption trends among younger demographics and GLP-1 usage. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Telstra has a 6% fully franked dividend yield.

Philip Pepe ·15:14

How to verify: Check Telstra's dividend announcements and current share price to calculate the yield, or review ASX announcements for dividend history. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Lovisa is trading at 29 times PE.

Philip Pepe ·24:46

How to verify: Calculate Lovisa's Price-to-Earnings ratio using its current share price and trailing twelve-month earnings per share from financial data providers. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Suncorp has a $250 million share buyback underway.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·28:26

How to verify: Check Suncorp Group's ASX announcements for details on the share buyback program. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

General insurers face a more challenging next 12 months than the last three years, a risk not in current share prices.

Philip Pepe ·30:47

How to verify: Review Suncorp Group (SUN) and other insurer share price movements and analyst consensus forecasts for 2026-2026; check insurer earnings reports for guidance changes. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Coles and Woolworths trade places in market share essentially one up, one down.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·31:14

How to verify: Check quarterly market share data from NielsenIQ or company annual reports for Coles Group (COL) and Woolworths Group (WOW). For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

NextDC downgraded its EBITDA by approximately 30% after its energy provider paused an approved site due to political backlash.

Philip Pepe ·34:43

How to verify: Search NextDC Limited (NXT) ASX announcements and annual reports for the specific earnings update and EBITDA revision linked to the Melbourne data center power supply issue. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

NextDC's net debt to EBITDA is expected to remain at ten times for the next three to four years.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·36:54

How to verify: Review NextDC Limited (NXT) financial statements and investor presentations for leverage ratios and forward guidance. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

AGL has been served with a federal court class action regarding misleading or deceptive conduct over carbon neutral products.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·38:47

How to verify: Search Australian Federal Court records or AGL Energy Limited (AGL) ASX announcements for class action filings related to carbon neutral products. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Polynovo trades at 40 times PE.

Philip Pepe ·42:44

How to verify: Calculate Polynovo Limited (PNV) Price-to-Earnings ratio using its current share price and trailing twelve-month earnings from financial data providers like Bloomberg or Refinitiv. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

NAB's credit impairment charges jumped 86% in recent results.

Andrew Gagan ·45:23

How to verify: Review National Australia Bank Limited (NAB) latest quarterly or half-year financial report for credit impairment charge figures. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

NAB trades at 16 times PE with a 4.4% dividend yield.

Philip Pepe ·49:28

How to verify: Check current valuation metrics and dividend yield for NAB on financial data platforms; compare with ANZ's reported 15x PE and yield. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

IGO divested its Cosmos nickel project to Gorilla Mines.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·50:13

How to verify: Search IGO Limited (IGO) ASX announcements for the divestment of the Cosmos nickel project to Gorilla Mines. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

EV growth rate expectations are being adjusted from 30-40% per annum to 15-20% or 10-15%.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_2) ·53:21

How to verify: Review industry reports from sources like BloombergNEF or IEA on global electric vehicle adoption forecasts and growth rate revisions. For recent events, verify 2026-08-16 through 2026-11-16. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify Adore Beauty's FY26 earnings guidance and revenue figures in the company's official ASX announcements.
  • Check the latest RBA minutes and market-implied interest rate probabilities for Australia versus the US Federal Reserve.
  • Review NextDC's latest financial report for net debt to EBITDA ratios and balance sheet details.
  • Assess AGL's class action lawsuit details and carbon neutral product claims via Federal Court records.
  • Compare NAB and ANZ valuation multiples (P/E) and dividend yields using current market data.
  • Analyze Polynovo's P/E ratio and speculative risk profile in the context of current interest rate environments.
  • Verify Coles and Woolworths' latest like-for-like sales data from their quarterly reports.
Full transcriptexpand
0:23
Andrew Gagan: G'day and welcome to the Call Ten 10 Socks stocks picked by you two experts when One uh hour. It is Monday, the 16th of November. I'm Andrew Gagan. Thanks for joining us. Also joining us for the show today. Philip Pepe from Shur Partners and Zach Riaz from Banantry Investment Management. Gentlemen, welcome to both. As we uh enter another week, of course,
0:43
Andrew Gagan: uh last week really dominated by NVIDIA. This week's gonna going to be anthropic, but um look, I guess we're obviously talking more local stock. stocks. Um, Phil, what do you what are you watching for at the moment? Because we were talking about more recently as the Australian market wasn't a bad place to hide because we were seeing that tech turmoil.
1:02
Philip Pepe: Yeah.
1:02
Andrew Gagan: Um, do you feel as though perhaps we we're going to be in an advantageous position at the moment or not?
1:08
Philip Pepe: Relatively, yes. We didn't have the high, ridiculous revenue multiples some of the other companies did. We're still through AGMC. AGM season in Australia, still two weeks to go.
1:18
Philip Pepe: We had a shocker of an AGM update today, which we'll we'll talk about soon. But generally speaking, they've been okay because we're we're kind of waiting for interest rates haven't had the bite that they're supposed to have. It's starting to. I think the worst is yet to come. Uh the banks are certainly flagging that, but our share market's holding up okay. The oil
1:38
Philip Pepe: price. is driving our market at the moment, and with the having a falling recently, and you know, I think I saw an article this morning saying supply is growing faster than demand, first time in a while. People are looking, and it's great, people are looking beyond the next 12 months to when oil normalizes, when the war ends, when interest rates starts to fall again. And that's great, but they're
1:58
Philip Pepe: sometimes forgetting that it might get worse before it gets better. So Australia's got some great investment. investments that were probably overlooked because people will focus on the Mag 7 and and the massive infrastructure spend that is data centers. I don't think that's slowed by the way. Um we're debating at the moment. Yeah.
2:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
2:14
Philip Pepe: don't think that comes to an end. Um, but it just reminds you you need to have a diversified portfolio. Um, don't ignore good Aussie stocks are producing cash flow because you're chasing the sexy sexiest shiny thing. This is the latest uh age.
2:30
Andrew Gagan: Zach, you've always got your eye on Wall Street. Which market do you want to be in at the
2:34
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): moment?
2:36
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I'd still prefer um overseas, I still prefer US. Um there's there's and and that doesn't come without any flaws or risks, of course. Um I I just think um like Philip uh described, I think there's there plenty of constraints to the domestic economy in Australia and I think it
2:56
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): does probably get worse uh in the Middle East. Uh I think you need to watch out for that. Um it it may be a temporary spike, but it it could be very brutal. Um and our expectations are still for interest rates to go higher. Um and and I don't think that's um uh gener j that's not even out of consensus cause because I can in the US a further three rate
3:16
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): hikes is expected over the next four months, um, from what we can see. So uh I I think there's still a lot of moving parts. I think you've got to be very selective. I I think you've got to be selected diversified but quick. And what I mean by that is if you think a buy and hold strategy would just work its magic, uh, which we generally have
3:35
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): been uh subscribers of, um, I I think now when something's worked for you, I think you've got to be with the view of taking some profits because markets tend to flip very quickly. Um and and we've seen that with a few stocks. Um but yeah more for more focused domestically um the trading updates are still very
3:55
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): lackluster um and and
3:58
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we
3:58
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): still expect the RBA to go higher which means uh your biggest asset your house housing, uh house and house prices likely to run under pressure and therefore um you know sentiment negative.
4:10
Andrew Gagan: Well, speaking of lake laster updates, let's get to our stock of the day. It is a door beauty, it has slashed its four-year earnings guidance by roughly half one of the warehouse disruptions and cost of living learning pressures of weight on sales for full underlying uh core earnings there now, forecast between four and six and a half million dollars down from previous guidance of between nine and
4:30
Andrew Gagan: thirteen million. Revenue falling eight percent over the first twenty weeks of the new financial year due to warehouse stock shortages. The company also withholding revenue guidance, citing market uncertainty and confirming ongoing talks with its bank over debt covenant compliance. And
4:46
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): well,
4:47
Andrew Gagan: there you can see the market reaction to that losing. a third of its value in this morning's trade.
4:54
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well
4:54
Andrew Gagan: let's get um a view from our experts then. Uh Phil, let's start with you. We know retail is under pressure at the moment.
5:02
Andrew Gagan: Should we have expected this from Adul?
5:04
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
5:05
Philip Pepe: think we should have partially expected it. Um I mean the I think they did flag they were expecting some disruptions from the new distribution center centre rollout. This is worse than expected. so some surbulence a lot more. Um, but the the weaker environment we we've seen similar stories from other retailers in terms of margin
5:24
Philip Pepe: pressure, consumer tightening the belt. The the unfortunately, we have a blunt policy in Australia called um
5:33
Philip Pepe: You
5:33
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
5:33
Philip Pepe: Reserve Bank using official interest rates to try and move the needle. There is a two two-speed speed economy uh by hiking. up rates the way they've been doing, my opinion, they're not addressing the causes of inflation. They're punishing the battler, the battler shops at Ador Beauty. So we've got ongoing uh cost of living pressure. You've got increased competition amongst Ador Beauty's competitors. For some
5:53
Philip Pepe: reason, they're rolling out bricks and mortar stores in an environment where you look at David Jones going, you know, chapter 11, closing down stores. This is not their environment. Um, whether that was in the share price, it's it's never priced in until you get the sticker shock. We should have seen some of this coming and being cautious. This is probably worse than people had expected. Uh I mean
6:13
Philip Pepe: the stocks on the look at that, it says it all down 96% uh over the last five years. This photo is an online retailer uh for memory, and and they're now moving into into in bricks and mortar. Um probably not the right time for this. type of strategy. I I would just avoid it. Uh it's not too late to sell. It's the when they pulled their own guidance,
6:33
Philip Pepe: they can't see too far ahead.
6:36
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
6:36
Philip Pepe: there's no reason to be in this sector, so it's a sell for me.
6:39
Andrew Gagan: Certainly is an intriguing
6:40
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
6:41
Andrew Gagan: strategy, isn't it, to go to bricks and mortar. Um Zach, what do you
6:46
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): think?
6:47
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
6:47
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I think that BRICSO bricks and mortar MONERS strategy is just to get sellsay sell side analysts excited because it's very easy to build out a ten year um DCF with certain amounts of store rollouts with certain amount of capex and uplifting um you know in and top down revenue. So uh you can get a very easily a nice financial model that
7:07
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): tells you a very nice price target or or evaluation. But the reality is very different and look, you know, I I've s having haven't been covering covering um you know uh retail stocks in Australia for a long time now and and I uh always feel like there's a there's a sort of a um you know uh a pothole that investors can fall into with that. Now I've been
7:27
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): I mean I've traveled a lot uh in the last sort of 12 months or so I can tell you beauty stores around Asia and absolutely bustling um absolutely killing it and I'm not talking about um you know I've seen my own family, my own wife go in there and spend two three hundred dollars on three, four different items very quickly. I I don't understand. So, my my question with
7:47
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): David Jones, my question with all of these guys is what
7:52
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): value proposition do you actually have with the product and services that you're selling? And I I think we kind kinda of ignore that in this whole macro, which is absolutely playing a factor as well. So uh we've never looked at Adore Beauty before. We we don't really think they have a competitive advantage. Um and and I and I wonder whether the macro issues
8:12
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): are kind of being used to what may be a uh a uh competitive positioning or product positioning issue because from what I can see um when I travel and even in Australia, uh beauty products are absolutely uh you know running off the shelf. So um I would avoid it. We've never looked at it. Uh and
8:32
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): yeah,
8:32
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
8:33
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): just rolling out stores makes absolutely no sense. So um, you know, the share price is down by a quarter or whatever it is, but the actual uh eBay guidance being cut by almost half. Um so you know, yeah, I'd I I'd avoid that. But I would say again with David Jones as well, David Jones has lost his value proposition.
8:53
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): It lost his value proposition about ten years ago. Uh and it fa basically David Jones and my a lot of these guys fell in this middle wasteland. You're not high end where guys and consumers buy because no one has it. And at the end, you're not value like Kmart and Tyler, where guys like us, you know, f fairly aspirational um professional who sa say
9:13
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): who sometimes go, Well, family budget's a bit tight. I think you know what's being sold at Kmart and Target is pretty good value, and I want to tighten up. And we have no loyalty to buying $300 bet sheets from David Jones.
9:25
Andrew Gagan: Yeah.
9:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
9:26
Andrew Gagan: yeah, I only have to look at my local shopping center. The the top floors are those premium brands, the bottom floors are the Kmart's and targets. Where where does David Jones and Maya Meyer fit in? Um, all right, so uh that is a an avoid from both. Or if you've ridden it this far, I am sorry for your loss, but um, I guess to Phil's point, it's never too late to sell. It is a double
9:46
Andrew Gagan: sell then for our stock of the day, a door.
9:49
Andrew Gagan: Alright, let's uh turn to the first five stocks as chosen by you. We're gonna take a look at Coles, Telstra, uh, Van X Misky Australian quality uh ETF, La Visa, and Suncorp. Alright, so
10:02
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): we've
10:02
Andrew Gagan: done. done uh consumer discretionary in the form of a duel. Let's move to the staple in the form of coals. That is our first stock. And in fact, some news today is investigating a cyber incident. It says it's found no evidence so far of customer, staff, or supplier data has been compromised or removed. It's working with cybersecurity experts and the Australian Cybersecurity
10:22
Andrew Gagan: Centre Center to contain the incident, and that it says stores and online operations continue. as normal. Now, a question from Dale. Dale, thanks for the question. Are you saying my wife has a small holding in Kohl's which she's thinking of selling and putting it into either West Farmers or Sol Pats for a bottom drawer? Just wondering your thoughts on which might be best or
10:42
Andrew Gagan: something better. Saying I love the show and listening to all the different points of view. Thanks for the um question, Dale. Uh Bearing in mind, of course, this is not a advice, purely information only. Zach, what are you thinking of Kohl's at the moment?
10:57
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, purely on an information basis. Uh, I think all those three stocks are pretty much in the same genre as defensive quality. I think sole patz is a great worry where we're run business. Um, you know, I think coals is very run business, and same with West Farmers. But within um um obviously Sol Pats
11:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): is
11:14
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): a more diversified. Uh West Farmers gives you a different exposure to um, you know, obviously bunnings and and and uh and the discretion of Kmart and Target. Um so slightly different but I I would buck bucket them in in defensives, Australian defensives. Um with coals specifically I think we own coals uh it i is a
11:34
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): core position holding we don't really get too cute with it. Where we do tend to get a bit cute with it is um, you know, Coles and Woolworths have a history of basically um sharing the limelight in terms of like for life sales growth. Um meaning uh when one tends to lead the other for a period of time, the the other realizes
11:54
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): that they need to invest in consumer proposition, pricing, and then they start to outperform um relative to the other. Because the two have very strong positions position and pretty much divide um the key corridors of uh uh of Australian consumers. So um Coles for a extended period of time up until recently was leading
12:13
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Woolworths, and that's why coal share price outperformed Woolworths. Most recent update you saw was Coles basically uh not provide a particularly damning or ca catastrophic um trading update, but it was well below Woolworths. because Woolworths latest I think that it's the US that they've come out with has seen a much better reaction from
12:33
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): consumers and the like for like sales looks like Woolworths is picking up. And I think there'll be a period of time where Woolworths outperforms Coles. But from a uh absolute perspective, um whether you sell Coles coals and move it into salt pats, um West Farmers, I think you're largely getting similar sort of um defensive characteristics and that means the
12:53
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): kind of valuation multiple the broader market will put on them. Um but from a from a I think right now it wouldn't make i if you don't have Woolworths, it wouldn't be the worst of our ideas of putting a little bit in Woolworths by setting down a bit of coals because I think Woolworths is going to do a little bit better on like for like sales, which likely sees its
13:13
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): share price do better.
13:14
Andrew Gagan: So what a trim for coals then
13:17
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): get
13:17
Andrew Gagan: into Woolys.
13:18
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, uh look new we're neutral, neutral, but if you wanted to uh transact um the way this gentleman's suggesting, I would trim coals and buy Woolworths.
13:27
Andrew Gagan: All right. But overall I call that a hold. Um Phil?
13:31
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yes.
13:31
Philip Pepe: Look, I I don't disagree. Great. It's an expensive defensive, in my opinion, twenty twenty-two two and a half times PE. It's fair value if you believe analysts. analyst price targets, negligible dividend yield three and a half percent. Absolutely correct in what was said earlier that Coles and Woolies tend to overtake each other. One does better than the other one plays catch up. Coles is in reinvestment phase, so whether it's Ushis
13:51
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): or
13:51
Philip Pepe: better better investment by Woolies in promotions, Coles has got to play catch up. Coles has the disadvantage that owns liquor stores. Uh you know, the the young kids don't drink, the old people are on GLP ones. So that's that's that's a tough sector to be in. Uh so they've got some additional headwinds um that Woolworths doesn't given the current multiple, there's
14:11
Philip Pepe: no need to be in Kohl's. Let them let them fight it out. Uh I agree Woolies will probably win some market share in the near term, and maybe you revisit Kohl's in six, twelve months' time. Um I won't suggest what to switch into till we get to the next stock because I think need to be careful about switching out of one expensive defensive into
14:31
Philip Pepe: another. West farms has got similar challenges. Bunnings are slowing, so yeah, you're just swapping um, you know, uh one form of uh call it consumer staple slowing and switching into another one. West farmers almost has issues that it's a lot more housing market uh exposed. So I don't know if switching into West Farms is the right thing. Salt Pats is more diversified, is now the right
14:51
Philip Pepe: time to buy a farm manager? Possibly.
14:54
Philip Pepe: But maybe we'll talk about the next stop. Uh I'll come back to this point. But I would I would sell coals um and if you wanted to maintain a defensive position, focus on a stock that pays a decent fully frank dividend yield as a head start. Because I think in this market, um particularly with with what's happened with the tax changes, if you can get a five and a half-six percent fully frank dividend
15:14
Philip Pepe: yield. that is a stock worth looking at. And then you look at is you
15:17
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know
15:18
Philip Pepe: is it expensive, is it cheap, what do the near terms uh earnings outlook look like? So yeah, it's a sell from Kohl's, uh, and I wouldn't necessarily uh buy any of the other two stocks listed. And uh unfortunately I think Woolworths is also expensive defensive as well. So I wouldn't trade light for like a fifth stage.
15:33
Andrew Gagan: Right, uh so a hole and a and a sell then for uh coals. coal. So, Phil, to that point, then would you? buy the next stock which is Telstra? And well it's actually um it's got this one million dollar on market share buyback underway, it's um up to about four hundred and seventy million of that.
15:49
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
15:49
Philip Pepe: Telstra is not cheap. It's also twenty-two times it has an almost six percent fully frank dividend yield. Historically, people have considered Telstra tele five point seven um a a cash proxy. Um for those who cannot hold cash. in their portfolio, don't choose to, well you can g get a cash like return uh through a near six percent fully frank dividend
16:09
Philip Pepe: yield and I think it's fully frank and they're doing the share buyback so that'll support the share price so hopefully it doesn't tank. They got a a massive call it free kick of good management with the Optus um outages uh in recent history that's you know, they're not the most expensive uh cheapest product in the market. They don't pretend to be. They they the biggest network um compete on service
16:29
Philip Pepe: and they've won that battle. Uh there's threats of Starlink um you know cutting their lunch and you know offering a service that you no longer needs, uh you you no longer need Telstra. I think that's overplayed. But I think they're in a strong position structurally, um, best of what they do, they're just not cheap. So I'm I'm gonna call it a hold because it is
16:49
Philip Pepe: expensive, but I I see compared to some of the others, minimal near term risk, um you're not gonna cut off your telecommunications. You're not. If you're spending more time at home because you're not going out as much, you'd probably use the internet more. Most people have or you can eat these days anyway. You may trim your mobile phone bill if you haven't already done so, but more and more people are using that for business. So um
17:09
Philip Pepe: you'd think in the near term their earnings are a little more defensible than a Coles or a or um or a Door Beauty, but they're priced accordingly. So I can't call it a buy at the current multiple, but it pays a good and good dividend yield. So I would happily hold it. And if you wanted to switch out of uh Coles into this, sure. Uh but not a big position, just a comparable position because of the
17:29
Philip Pepe: decent dividend yield and their strong competitive position.
17:33
Andrew Gagan: Zach, what would you do with
17:34
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it?
17:35
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
17:36
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): look, I'm a neutral at um we own it. I I I think uh we own it because the Australian market is so used to using it as a dividend play and there's a natural support to it. Um at twenty-two times P low low earnings growth, it's hardly worth twenty-two times, but that's the nature of the Australian market. Um I I think the Starlink uh Starlink
17:56
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): issue um is probably overplayed in the very near new term, but long term I think it's definitely a risk. I I think the pre premium that Tulsa charges because of its infrastructure and its coverage is um obviously something it's enjoyed um and continues to enjoy, but it will get eroded away. Um look at Starlink's market share in New Zealand's um, you know,
18:16
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): regional space, uh regional area. I think it's up to like twenty, thirty percent. So there is a clear case of it approving proving its um uh value proposition. And I think long term there's gonna be some serious shifts. I think the guys with the strong infrastructure like Telstra still has a room to play, absolutely, um especially in terms of buildings and whatnot, where
18:36
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Starlink cannot um uh uh the coverage cannot reach as uh as strongly as something like Telstra. So I think there's gonna be a a healthy medium, um, but I think the the value proposition and the premium that um Telstra charges. on its product, which it should, because it's invested a lot. We calculated, I think it's about a
18:55
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): billion or uh thereabouts. I think that gets starts to get eroded away. Um and then don't forget, these are pretty capital-intensive businesses, and you've got a very nimble and an aggressive, uh outspoken competitor coming through. So um, you know, uh we use parts of uh our analysts
19:15
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): use Starlink when we're traveling around the world. Uh really can't fault some of the coverage. And so um it's not a near term issue for Telstra, but I think on a three to five year view, I think that premium gets straight away. In the mean meantime, Australian investors just cannot get past the dividend yield or continue to buy it. So for that reason, neutral.
19:35
Andrew Gagan: Hold. Double hold for Telstra. Hold the phone.
19:40
Andrew Gagan: All right. Let's move to an ETF. We're going to take a look
19:43
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): at
19:43
Andrew Gagan: Van Eckh MSCI Australian Quality Plus. Essentially does what it says on the tin tracks, the Misky Australian Quality Plus Index. Now, Bernan, bringing this to our attention. Thanks to the question saying, I'm starting to think that smart finance people working every day on finance are probably in a better position to choose stocks wisely than I am. Uh we've all come to that conclusion.
20:03
Andrew Gagan: Uh so he says I've sold off some shares to cash up ready for smart buyers. Would you consider the AQTY ETF a goodbye at $21 to buy into quality Aussie stocks?
20:16
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
20:16
Andrew Gagan: once again, bearing in mind this is not advice. Zach, what do you
20:19
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): think?
20:21
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Um,
20:22
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): yeah,
20:22
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): look, no, I I I think if you if you're uh um yeah, uh in a world diversified portfolio, I think uh an allocation to smart beta ETFs like this is uh valid, um and and uh probably a prudent strategy. And and so especially in the Australian market which is so concentrated, frankly, um, you know,
20:42
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): it's very difficult to uh add alpha because there's a lot of other issues driving it besides fundamental value. Um so but the only thing I would caution uh against is some of the smart beta can have extended periods of underperformance as well relative to the broader market. Um so I'd be very careful and and quality, it all you really need to dig into
21:02
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): what these guys see as quality. I mean the typical quality, low leverage, high ROE, high margin. There's a moat mote um which obviously i is up for debate. And so in in in definitional terms. yeah, absolutely, these are the kind of companies you want to own. I just had a quick
21:19
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): um look at their top holdings and it's all the banks. I mean the AS X three hundred is all the banks. I think their largest position is um ANZ and so they're obviously right now they're playing that relative core between these um large caps, predominantly AS ASX X one hundred stocks anyway. So yeah, look, I I think something of this nature can't go to too wrong. Um but
21:39
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): yeah my only caveat is sometimes these quality na uh quality smart beater ETFs can lag the broader market. And then I think that's got to do in part because of their definition of quality, but also because the the concentrated nature of our uh market. So yeah I I I'd be neutral on
21:58
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.
21:59
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Phil? Look
22:00
Philip Pepe: I don't d I don't disagree. Uh it's an interesting instrument. Uh I've got it on a five point six percent dividend yield, so that's a good place to start. Um its performance it seems to have outperformed recently by about two percent. So that's probably a sign that they're holding the banks. A lot of uh a lot of active managers have been underweight banks because they've been perceived as expensive, but if you start to
22:20
Philip Pepe: think about, well, are they quality businesses, yes they are. That then pushes you to own more of them rather than less of them. So it's probably been um the right product uh for the recent environment. Again, is that always gonna be the case? No, I wouldn't put all my eggs on this basket. But for those who wanted to outsource um uh investing and not
22:40
Philip Pepe: appoint a separate fund manager uh but through a an exchange trader fund which is becoming more and more popular, it seems to be a reasonable product. I I would call it a hold. It's not for everyone because ultimately um you know you could just buy a I can't believe I'm using those a passive fund and just ride the market up and down without any investment decisions to get the cheapest exposure to the Aussie equity
23:00
Philip Pepe: market. But yeah it seems to be a reasonable product. It's done very well recently
23:05
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): as
23:06
Philip Pepe: as point made earlier the definition of quality can change. There's certainly companies that even 12 months ago would have been regarded as high quality now there's a question mark on the more them more so because of behavior internally rather than externally, or what AI has done to their business model. So that can change, but presumably they will um pull those levers as they need to. Looks like an okay
23:26
Philip Pepe: product. I'll I'll I'll call it a hold.
23:28
Andrew Gagan: Double hold then for the uh Van Eck Misky
23:31
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
23:31
Andrew Gagan: sorry quality plus CTF AQTY. Now let's head back into consumer to discretionary square sharing in the form of Levi. La Visa. And it is that um fast uh fast fashion, essentially. And
23:47
Andrew Gagan: uh it um
23:49
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it's
23:50
Andrew Gagan: got a CGM coming up uh week after next, in fact. Uh now Andy has written in for ask us about this one saying we've about got a small stake in La Visa or as I see the retailer as bulletproof, he says. Fast fashion. Australian jewelry store that's expanding globally. Share price, he says, has dropped since I bought it. I feel I should buy more to price
24:09
Andrew Gagan: average from my $28 entry price. What do you think? Phil?
24:15
Philip Pepe: It's an interesting one. I wouldn't call it bulletproof. They sell cheap and cheerful accessories, $15, $20 twenty dollars is it's you wear it once you buy the next one. Um What's
24:24
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): those
24:24
Andrew Gagan: it's tween girls is isn't it?
24:25
Philip Pepe: Tween. So
24:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
24:26
Philip Pepe: targets a a younger or their customers are younger, they they don't have home loans, they don't have school fees, their parents are funding it. So it's believed to be defensive for that reason. It's on twenty nine times PE. Um fair value for Billy of Analysts, circa four percent dividend yield. My concern is we're seeing now that
24:46
Philip Pepe: what was once perceived as bulletproof isn't w where uh West Farmers Bunnings is uh slowing, Cochlea um has had some issues. So, again, definition of quality, the definition of bulletproof in what we've seen in what five rate rises now. Uh grossly generalizing. If this is funded by their parents, their parents' parents are struggling, they're
25:06
Philip Pepe: passing fewer to your teenage daughters to buy more though adults clearly buy by this product as well. My concern is they are two rolling out stores, targeting over 2,000 global. globally, currently just over a thousand. Is this the market to be backing someone to do store rollouts? I think the share price gives them the benefit of the doubt that they will succeed.
25:27
Philip Pepe: Not that it's an adore beauty, but we saw just today what happens when a strategy is dislodged Dislodge just temporarily, what the share price ration could be. So I think the risk is to the downside, should they have a hiccup rather. than to the upside. So I wouldn't be buying more. I would be waiting for the AGM. I'd be selling today ahead of uh I'm just cautious. Anything consumer
25:47
Philip Pepe: facing, discretionary or non-discretionary. I'm I if it's fully valued, risk is to the downside. I I would take the profits um and sit in cash.
25:56
Andrew Gagan: Zach, are you as equally as wary?
26:00
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Um yeah, look, w when the Louise Lavisa initially crashed to about twenty dollars, we saw it as a buying opportunity. Um, and but I think it's since bounced back to where it is twenty seven dollars. So I think um you probably wanna be taking profits here because of the broader market, uh, as was suggested, i is pretty tough. Slightly a few different
26:20
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): things about La Visa. Um, you know, your average buy price is ten to twenty dollars, uh it's knickknacks. Um the store rollouts aren't, you know, hanging um bed sheets and big um, you know, expensive uh fixtures. It can be a little hole in the wall, in and out, um, where, you
26:40
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): know, probably uh revenue per square meter is actually pretty high. Um that doesn't, you know, um necessarily mean this is not uh a risk, uh it is expansion without risk. Um and and they've obviously got a great lot um international growth uh um growth story which has its own risk. The only other yeah so I'd be neutral. The only other
26:59
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): issue I would just call out and so I'm I'm not as negative on Ludiza. Um and that's why we we you know we thought there was a short term price uh uh advantage to be taken off um but that seems to be close. The other thing is they do have debt on their balance sheet. Um and and while it's not catastrophic, um it only takes earnings,
27:19
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): EV uh you know, your net debt to EBITA to move if EBITA moves up a little bit, and most of it is top line growth. So it does show forward growth of top double digit top line growth and double digit bottom line growth, but that can change very easily 'cause easily because the margin themselves aren't moving too much. So you can very easily get negative operating leverage. So yeah, look, I'm
27:39
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): not as negative on LaVisa and because some of the mechanics that I understand of the business and and its growth prospects, but yeah, just a broader environment. I'd be very careful. And and when you're rolling out so many stores, sure, you're rolling it out another two, two, two to three thousand stores, but there are other competitors within that landscape as well, and where they fit in terms
27:59
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): of where your stores are coming up, needs to be you need to be mindful of. as well. So yeah, I I'd be taking some profits definitely. Um but yeah, I'd be neutral on
28:08
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it. Oh,
28:09
Andrew Gagan: okay. We'll call it a hold, but maybe just trim then. Whereas um Phil is selling it. All right, let's uh now turn to an insurer in the form of Suncorp Lias came out. This one, um it also um is um has a uh shared
28:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
28:26
Andrew Gagan: buyback underway to the tune of two hundred and fifty million. Um Zach, the insurers, do you want to be
28:34
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): there?
28:35
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah, look uh w we are there. Um and you know we're we're happy to hold them, get the dividend yield. It's not overly thumping the table sort of dividend yield. I mean we have been very long Suncor Suncore for a long period of time when the whole bank transaction was going on. and the subsequent potential capital management potential, and that all is now playing
28:55
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): around. The overall um sort of uh insurance environment is pretty um benign as well. Uh and so look, we we own it, we like it, we think it's uh it's a little bit of a diversifier away from um obviously the banks, which have other issues as well. Um, so yeah, we are neutral. on it
29:15
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): and and we do own um Suncorp as uh one of our holdings in our dividend um strategy. So yeah, for us it's a neutral.
29:23
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
29:23
Andrew Gagan: you're holding it, Phil. What are you doing at this?
29:25
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yeah we're holding.
29:26
Philip Pepe: It's a sell for me at this price. I think um people I mean look at the share prices. It's done very well. Um It's perceived to have some pricing power given it's largely an oligopoly in in this country. But the consumers battling, we've seen reinsurance rates soften, so that'll impact their commercial rates. We should start to see top line
29:46
Philip Pepe: slow because of the link to property values. Um, property values going down. Um, not that your sum insured goes down, but if people aren't moving into new houses like they used to, they're not buying the new furniture, they're not reassessing their sum insured, uh, may not grow, or they might look to reduce it by increasing. deductibles or just saying, Hey, we don't need to insure, it will we
30:06
Philip Pepe: will self-insure.
30:08
Philip Pepe: My guess is you'll start to see people shop around more, uh, that'll put pressure on the top line, and you'll find that uh you've got if uh inflation hitting them, cost of repairs is going up. Uh, I'm not convinced I'd don't necessarily be able to pass them through into the um premium rates they've gotten through in recent years. I think people may be. extrapolating the
30:28
Philip Pepe: fantastic results the sector's put out for the last three years and not really impact, not really thinking about the impact the five interest rate rises is happening in what is all forms of spending, including um including insurance. It is hitting your your hip pocket. So it's it's an area where people can make a few phone calls and decide where can I save some money? If I can alter my insurance or
30:47
Philip Pepe: or change providers, I think they will. And I think the the next 12 months is probably more challenging for the general insurers than the last three years have been, and that's not in the current share price. So at the current levels, I'd say the future's a little um more pessimistic than what consensus is forecasting. So I'm a seller.
31:07
Andrew Gagan: Let's wrap up the first half of the show. Then uh beginning with Coles, um
31:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
31:14
Andrew Gagan: we'll for Phil it's uh that uh expensive defensive um but you know not bad for a dividend nonetheless given where it's been and we see um its battle with Woolets Woolworths. Um they trade places essentially one up, one down. Uh Phil would be selling it whereas Zach um would be trimming it, so it's a hold
31:34
Andrew Gagan: essentially, he would be prepared to buy Woolies. Telstra, uh the defensive stock also it is a hold from Phil. Um, not cheap, uh, but safe good dividend, he says. Uh, Zach owns it. Um, potentially there is that challenge there from um Starlink
31:48
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
31:49
Andrew Gagan: in terms of uh communication, so it is a hold from both. The Vanimisky Australia Quality plus ETF.
31:56
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It
31:56
Andrew Gagan: is a hold from both. Um Zach's saying it's not a a it's fairly prudent strategy, um, not a bad yield, says. uh Phil. Uh La Visa
32:05
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
32:05
Andrew Gagan: back into that uh consumer discretionary space. So it is a sell from Phil is saying the question was: is it bulletproof? No, he doesn't think it is. Uh also it's engaging in a store rollout, too. There's a bit of risk there. Um Zach would be trimming, but essentially it's a hold from him. And finally, their son caught the insurer a hold from Zach, whereas Phil is
32:25
Andrew Gagan: selling it. Alright. let's catch up with our own high conviction fund picked by the investment committee. Now, the latest episode is live for you to watch. Going into November, the panel sold out of Mayfield Group while increasing the holding in Lion Town. Why? Well, if you head to the drop-down menu at ospiz.com.au and look for the investment committee, uh, you'll
32:45
Andrew Gagan: find out the reasoning why they made those decisions. So, of course, this is all based on your decisions. and your questions, your stocks that you send in. So, keep doing
32:54
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that.
32:58
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
32:58
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): shopper in me though does foresee potentially some bargains out there.
33:03
Andrew Gagan: Investors will have a bit more cash to
33:05
Philip Pepe: deploy.
33:06
Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Live Wek days from 4 pm Eastern. Watch on demand or catch up with the newsletter or podcast. The COB is brought to you by Long. Longview, a new way for investors to access Australian residential property. Visit longview.com.au
33:25
Andrew Gagan: Second half, we're going to take a look at NextDC. AGL, Polynovo, NAB, and IGO. So let's get into data centers with NextDC. Next DC. Oh, my goodness. Um of course we um
33:37
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh I'm
33:38
Andrew Gagan: sure you're across the news as to what's happened to this stock uh over the past month or so.
33:44
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um, in
33:45
Andrew Gagan: terms of its uh build out, particularly it's a data center in Melbourne. You're getting community pushback. This is happening globally, of course. Um, so let's um
33:54
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
33:55
Andrew Gagan: if and of course the the share price dropped precipitously, and that was a buying opportunity for some of its his competitors, in particular. Goodman group fill. Phil, how do you look at
34:03
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it?
34:04
Philip Pepe: I think it's a buy. Um I find what's been happening quite amusing. Um there's been political pushback for quite a while on data centers in terms of how how they're going to um use how much power they're gonna use, where they're gonna be located. Okay, This isn't new. Uh we we've seen picketing in
34:24
Philip Pepe: Tasmania, we've seen um North Sydney, um, the council saying we don't want you in our backyard. We've seen South Australia do the same. But we still want them. So there was an issue uh where their energy provider in uh in in Melbourne uh said, Hey, there's a lot of political backlash at the moment, we're just gonna pause what was already an approved
34:43
Philip Pepe: site, um, which caused Next C CC C to update its earnings, take those numbers out, effectively downgrading their EBITDA. by I think it was 30%. And then two other um data centers bought 10% of the company saying, hey, this has been overdone and up it goes. My my personal view is that we still want data centers. We need to
35:03
Philip Pepe: think more carefully about how they're going to be powered. Um don't just rely on the grid, don't just assume the councils will supply the power. and probably think more about where they're going to be located. The data center manufacturers want them close to close to home base because if you need to roll a truck at three in the morning, you
35:23
Philip Pepe: want to be 10 minutes to the location, not two hours, right? You want to fix a problem if there's a problem pretty quick. But if you have to move them further out, you move them further out. I think that's where we're headed. Um and what's happening recently is now the conversation regarding about how do you power these things. um
35:39
Philip Pepe: becomes more relevant. So personally I think we go down the Western Australia model, which is um solar powered battery storage. Those have lobbied, uh continue lobbying Australia for nuclear. We might not get that anytime soon, but that that's a potential solution. But it just brings forward the argument or the discussion about how do you power them. We still want them, we just don't want them across the road, we don't want
35:59
Philip Pepe: them to be ugly, we don't want um poles, um, you know, twenty 20 30 metre poles outside.
36:04
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well, that's a classic
36:04
Andrew Gagan: NIMBY, isn't it?
36:05
Philip Pepe: Yeah. So so we want them. Um, and I think it was uh fear that pushed the share price down. Great buying opportunity for those who genuinely think longer term. I am a believer in the longer term play that remains data centers and all the picks and shovels operators that support them. So I think given the uncertainty at the moment, it is a good buying opportunity. And within three to five years, we'll look back at this moment and
36:25
Philip Pepe: say
36:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): there's
36:26
Philip Pepe: there was a solution. We just had to find
36:29
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.
36:29
Andrew Gagan: That's our first buy of the day. Zach, do you agree?
36:34
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Um no, I don't. Um we do own own Next DC. We have a small position in it. Um I I I mean, I'm not going to cover the the bull case. I think that's that's pretty well summarized. summarize. Um I I I guess for us, um, the issue issues is around the leverage, uh, net debt to eBit. EBITDA is expected to stay ten times
36:54
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): uh until um for the next three or four years. So there's a lot of leverage here. Um get the demand story and and you know that could wobble around obviously regulatory issue. I think you got you gotta like it was stated, I think you gotta find a healthy medium. I think we need this as part of the transition. Um But the the point really is how um balance
37:14
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): sheets are used and how earnings uh eventually materialize. Um I don't think that it's necessarily just a story about demand and what the importance of these structures play. Uh and so that's what concerns us. And like I said, we've got exposure there. Uh we think I think uh at six dollars it probably was a great buying opportunity, but it
37:33
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): shows you how quickly when a very, very over leveraged balance sheet when the s growth story gets a wit bit of a wobble, how quickly the market derates it. It's got nothing to do about, you know, demand and all of that. And the market will just see the balance sheet and the leverage and and and and whatnot. So um for us, um, that is the only
37:53
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): reason that keeps us a lot more cautious on it. Um but like I said, So we've got a small skin in the game. Do we need to have five, six percent of our portfolio in data centers because of the potential growth? I I think just from a risk management perspective, and for what we see, leverage being built up is something we weren't willing to do. So yeah, for us it's a neutral. Um the bounce that was a great
38:13
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): buying opportunity, but where it's sitting today, uh, I think you find that it probably trades sideways for a while. Um so yeah, neutral or a hold for us.
38:23
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right
38:23
Andrew Gagan: up uh buying buy and a hold for next DC. Let's now turn to the Gentile under the form of AGL and um
38:30
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): more
38:30
Andrew Gagan: recently reaffirming its um its guidance
38:36
Andrew Gagan: uh uh also uh has run into a bit of a regulatory issue. It's um been served with a federal court class action regarding to misleading or deceptive conduct over some of its carbon neutral products.
38:47
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
38:47
Andrew Gagan: Zach,
38:48
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): how
38:48
Andrew Gagan: are you viewing AGL?
38:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
38:50
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): look, uh, it's a neutral for us. Um there was a there was this uh thematic of getting excited about it with with obviously again the the the use uh the increasing proliferation of data centers and someone's something's got to power that right um so you know integrated uh retailer uh like and um AGL
39:10
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): energy and obviously its transition um to uh a you know more diversified local low emissions energy platform was all playing into that thematic. But it is a tough business. There's there's capex to be had um you know to get that transition, which is not going to be even. Um that's gonna impact free cash flow, and that's what you use to value a
39:30
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): company. So, you know, at current levels, it's probably looking fair value to us. It does give you a half decent yield um for your troubles, um, but it tends to for us, it's become a bit of a trading um stock to be honest. Anytime it drops below $8 or thereabouts, it's normally a pretty good trade. But anything when it gets to that $10, $9, $10,
39:50
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): it starts to, you know, look a little bit troubling given where wholesale prices tend to push around, where the the CapEx execution risk comes in. You've still got the cold coal assets uh which need to be retarded. retired and how that all plays out. Uh and so yeah, it becomes a bit of a bit more of a messy um story. So it's a
40:10
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): neutral for us. Um and yeah, it's got a half decent yield. So that keeps us interested as well.
40:16
Andrew Gagan: Phil?
40:17
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah
40:17
Andrew Gagan: look I
40:17
Philip Pepe: don't disagree. I'm on the border of neutral slash buy. It It's a little bit cheap and it pays a decent dividend yield if you add the two together. It's about a ten percent return in it. which is flirting on a buy, so I'll call it a buy. Uh 'cause I I do think this is part of the energy transition play. I mean, ideally I'd like it below nine bucks, uh, but it it's close enough so I'll call it
40:37
Philip Pepe: a buy. I think um
40:40
Philip Pepe: we're kidding ourselves that we're gonna shut down coal fired power stations anytime soon. Right? Look at the cost of doing everything, cost of electricity, consumers battling. Yes, we need to clothe them. close them. Uh we seem to have not stepped away but softened our tone regarding uh carbon neutral by 2050 or whatever the latest update is. Uh I think the reality is
41:00
Philip Pepe: we'll need to have the coal-fired power stations uh open for longer if we can. But when we do shut them down, they have um you know um uh alternative solutions in terms of battery storage, etc. Uh, I do think this is a good way to play the energy transition and to support what I think is a medium term growth in data centers. I do that like it a bit
41:20
Philip Pepe: cheaper. It is a it is a great trading stock. Um but I just think um it got oversold, so I'll call it a buy. This is a you know it's not an expensive defensive, it's a relatively cheap ish defensive
41:33
Philip Pepe: And and probably reasonably sensitive to it, less sensitive to any further rate rises than some of the other stocks would. we've discussed. So I'll call it a buy on that basis.
41:42
Andrew Gagan: Buy and a hold for AGL.
41:45
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Next
41:45
Andrew Gagan: up, Polynovo, I did ask him about this. Um thanks for the suggestion. So it um recently um completed its um manufacturing facility in Melbourne, uh preparing for its commercial launch of its um Novo Sorb uh product into the US hospitals alongside its
42:05
Andrew Gagan: um what it's seeing this rapid adoption essentially of um of the product um saw commercial sales jump um around 90% in FY26. In fact, Phil, um biotech, we know the uh binary outcomes of to these. Um
42:22
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): where's
42:23
Andrew Gagan: Polynovo Polynovar sit?
42:24
Philip Pepe: Look, This one seems to be one of the better ones. but its share price has still been sliding uh if you look at that. Uh I think it's just a similar pattern if you go longer. So it should be doing better. Uh I just think the reason why it's slid is because expectations were high. Analysts think it's cheap. I don't necessarily share their view. Analysts analysts think it's a
42:44
Philip Pepe: screaming buy but it's on 40 times PE so they really need to deliver and what that chart tells me is that it just hasn't good business, but just hasn't caught up with expectations. This is not the market for biotechs. We've seen some some famous blow-ups, um, and in a rising interest rate environment, you don't want to be long duration um highly
43:04
Philip Pepe: speculative stocks, and unfortunately, it's not the right market for them. So, although the company seems to be doing well, their that main product is um uh wound wound uh uh management management products product, as mine. is my understanding. It's got some growth, but I just think this is not the right time for a speculative biotech. Nothing wrong with the business, just not the right time. So I'll just call it a
43:24
Philip Pepe: sell. I think it'll it's priced for good results. Uh risk is to the downside, so it's a sell for
43:30
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): me.
43:31
Andrew Gagan: Zach, do you play in the space or not?
43:35
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Um, very, very, very rarely because as you say, we we don't really gravitate towards binary outcomes. Um but you know they can make you a lot of money or they can lose you a lot of money. Um this is a stock that has come on our radar um but we've never done any work on it. We never really looked at it uh again for just that
43:55
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): high level uh um you know approach to the sector um I I think the the only sort of saving grace for this stock is a little bit does have uh a bit of net income and so it's positive. Um the revenue is growing. I think there's a catlist coming for it. So um for those that do want to take that binary um play in this space, um,
44:15
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): you know, maybe uh I think they're looking to get their um pre market approval for the US market, which is where everyone gravitates towards. Um and I think that gives them a a lot more um you know avenues to drive commercial revenue. So again, what happens from that is anybody's guess. But yeah, there is a bit of a catlass coming. But yeah,
44:35
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): for me, it's it's a neutral at best. I'm only putting on a neutral because it does have a positive uh net pat uh and forecasts of positive net pat. That But um any more than that, uh it's purely speculative. M More broadly, we do. think that um the biotech sector is gonna probably pick up a little bit more pace in
44:55
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): MA activity, but this is more globally. So I think there's probably more opportunities uh globally than in the domestic market. But hold for us.
45:04
Andrew Gagan: All right. Uh sum that up as being both pretty lukewarm, particularly in relation to biotechs. All Alright, right, let's get into the big banks in the form of NAB. stock we're looking at. And of course, they've all recently updated the market over the past couple of weeks. Um cash earnings um down 13%,
45:23
Andrew Gagan: um, but it pretty much flat when you exclude the notable items such as software capitalization change there. Uh credit impairment charges, they jumped 86%.
45:35
Andrew Gagan: Um, and the chief executive Andrew Irvine uh warning that uh tough economic conditions for borrowers remain. Zach, uh the banks. So look, you know, the share price uh continue to to push high. A and Z, in fact. Um, that's uh you know topped out as well. Um, where does NAB fit? Do
45:55
Andrew Gagan: you hold any of the banks?
45:56
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Yes, we do. So look, at the end of the day, uh we we don't spend a lot of time analysing the banks. Uh it's a big part of the market to be honest. We play the relative core. Right now we are under underweight banks, uh, because of our view on the market. Um, but uh look from from our perspective, um being completely out of the banks is not
46:16
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): very prudent portfolio construction or portfolio management or for Australian equity manager. Um, because every day you wake up and all you think about is what the banks have done and you completely figure miss out on other alpha opportunities. Um I think there's it's just a relative core. Um so we are obviously our biggest underweight is CBA. It's the most expensive, but it's the best, best uh run
46:36
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): bank out there. I think um more specifically the NAB, it does have a much bigger exposure to the SME market, um, the small to medium median businesses market. So if you really have a sort of a um you know lackluster view on the economic growth. of Australia, you'd expect a you know bit of pressure in the SME market. Um your everyday
46:56
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): mums and dad running both businesses. So uh it is a high margin business where the other guys uh are starting to come in as well. Uh West Baxton making some rural inroads in there, CBA wants to move in there because of high margin and same with A and Z. So it's becoming a very more uh a contested market uh which is one of the key
47:16
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): differentiation from our understanding of NAB. So yeah, overall, um not too overly um you know uh excited about even the dividend yields when you when you take the dividend yields before franking relative to the risk free rate, they are not even giving you well they're actually giving you a negative premium. Um so you
47:36
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): could actually put your money in cash. But b with obviously with franking and and all of that, you get a bit of a premium. So the valuations are looking pretty toppy. Um the macro's not looking overly good. Um provisions and you know, Dow debts are probably likely to rise. And with NAB more specifically, that that's SME um book um likely to see a
47:56
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): little bit more stress if the economy continues to come under pressure from higher and elevated interest rates. So yeah, um uh we'll hold it, but we'd be underweight the banks.
48:05
Andrew Gagan: Yeah. Bill?
48:07
Philip Pepe: This is not the environment for banks. You don't want to be new, but this is the wrong environment. Rising interest rates, slowing consumer credit growth, rising defaults. Typically if if you were index unaware, you just wouldn't own any banks, but it's hard to be index unaware given how large they are. NAB was hoping to be the saviour because of their lower exposure to home loans. more business
48:27
Philip Pepe: banking, but SMEs are the worst part of the market. We've seen them battle. We've heard the whinging about the credit card, justifiable whinging about the credit card surcharge being removed, so they can't pay their tax bill. Their part of the market's struggling, and hence NAB's revision was quite material. With another interest rate rise expected, loans will continue to slow, investor loans will
48:47
Philip Pepe: continue to go backwards, mortgage will be focused on refinancing. So condition isn't looking looking very good. I would continue to play banks twofold quality and value. NAB is neither relative. The best one in the market is CBA. CBA is not going to $135, like analysts have been calling for two years. It's just
49:07
Philip Pepe: not.
49:08
Philip Pepe: So you can own a combination for CBA. The cheapest one is ANZ. Uh It's about a PE point cheaper than. NAB and a percent in dividend yield above NAB. So NAB's on 16 times, C ANZ's on 15, NAB pays 4.4% dividend yield added percent, and you get ANZ. So if you
49:28
Philip Pepe: want, you need to have some bags, you would buy the cheapest one, which is ANZ. I think it's been one of the better performers, relatively. And you need some exposure to CBA C B A because it is quality and we've seen C B A gap up ten percent of the month because people rush back to equities. You're rushing back to equities, you buy C BA. So the environment for banks remains
49:47
Philip Pepe: challenged.
49:48
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
49:48
Philip Pepe: cannot renew banks, own the best one, own the cheapest one and you don't need to own any others um in any way, shape or form, in my opinion.
49:56
Andrew Gagan: So is that a cell?
49:57
Philip Pepe: It's a cell.
49:57
Andrew Gagan: Yep. Yeah. Okay.
49:59
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well
50:00
Andrew Gagan: let's uh finish by um uh wading into um the resources sector, get digging there with IGO and it recently divested its uh Cosmos nickel project to Gorilla Mines.
50:13
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
50:13
Andrew Gagan: this is part of its uh strategy of pivoting away from nickel towards lithium and copper. Do you like that strategy, Phil?
50:21
Philip Pepe: Medium term, yes. Bullish copper because of electrification, um similar for lithium as well. The problem is trying to predict the lithium price and the supply-demand curve with any uh level of accuracy. Um, you know, we think lithium is in oversupply, uh, then the Chinese or someone mothballs their mine, lithium price spikes,
50:41
Philip Pepe: lithium producers run, and then hey, we're now profitable, so supply comes back on. So people overestimate um the shortage that there is no shortage. of lithium. People turn it on and off. And I think people people do two things. They overestimate how much lithium there is in the world, and they overestimate how quickly the demand for electric vehicles
51:01
Philip Pepe: and electrification will occur. It will happen, it's just sometimes if you look at the share price of 2022, a lot slower than people are anticipating. So whether this stock is a buy, hold or sell depends on where the lithium price is at the moment. At the moment, I would say the outlook for lithium is neutral to slightly negative because
51:21
Philip Pepe: suppliers come back on. That can and will change. So at the current share price,
51:27
Philip Pepe: it is at only on 10 times PE and analysts, you know, well below analyst price target. That could change tomorrow. Um, But if you take a medium-term medium term view and can tolerate the volatility that is investing in the lithium stock as as we've discovered, I think it is a good medium-term buy. It could drop tomorrow if the
51:47
Philip Pepe: lithium price drops. Um, but as an entry point, if you didn't own it, I think that the current share price with some volatility is a good long-term play on electrification. But you need to be able to stomach the volatility that is buying the lithium stock.
52:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Is
52:00
Andrew Gagan: that something you'll uh you're willing to do, Zach?
52:03
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
52:04
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): we we we like the stock. Um you know, I I'm I'm ha almost close to saying it's a buy, but yeah, look, I think there's probably a few more downgrades to come in the lithium uh in consensus lithium headline prices. And at the end of the day, these
52:20
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): these uh resources uh materials companies are pretty much effectively driven by um the commodity itself. And uh and I think um obviously this year went through a great over investment phase, then it came down and they were starting to turn back again. And I think people thought there was a a balance of sorts happening in the supply demand. But there was just so much investor that gone on
52:40
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): prior to in the prior bull um that they are ready to sort of, you know, um monetize that as soon as they get any opportunity. So I'm just a little bit worried about there's a few more um guys who may be a little bit more bullish um to push through their downgrades. It probably is a better time through this process um to start picking up or look at these stocks.
53:01
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): But I think the whole uh energy storage systems are disappointing in terms of the growth in there. I I think the EV growth rate is also disappointing. Not because we're not we're not moving to more EVs. I just think the the expectations are of 30-40% 30, 40% per hour. annum is now being adjusted to 15, 20 percent or 15, 10 to 15%, which is still a great growth rate.
53:21
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): It's just not what it was expected in forecast prior. So I think there's a few adjustments happening with some of the Macro drivers and and that's playing out along with obviously there's still supply around and the supplier waiting on the sidelines waiting to exit. And and so yeah, um I I've got a neutral on it. um of right here,
53:40
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): right now. But I think um let this sort of um you know current downturn in lithium prices play out, and it you may find a better opportunity. But I don't think the stocks get too much cheaper. I think IGO is one of our key picks within the space. Um, but yeah, Yet neutral. neutral, But but you yeah, know, if someone wanted were to start to take nibbles
54:01
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): out at these levels, we wouldn't be opposed. to it.
54:03
Andrew Gagan: Alright. Okay, let's sum up the second half then. Beginning in data centers with next DC, uh, given the extreme volatility we've seen there. Uh Phil is willing to buy it, and uh particularly given where that that price fell to, uh still demand for these data centers despite the community uh pushback. Uh Zach
54:23
Andrew Gagan: owns it, but um he was he would be more happy to hold. these levels. There is concern about its debt levels too. AGL, it is a hold from
54:32
Andrew Gagan: Zach.
54:35
Andrew Gagan: Once again, you've got to power those data centers. So that's potentially where AGL comes in seeing it as fair value on a trading stock. Phil's saying it's looking cheapish. So and once again that energy transition plays. play. So he's willing to buy it. Polynovo, uh, those binary outcomes with these buyer. uh biotechs, um, Phil would be selling it. Um,
54:55
Andrew Gagan: whereas Zach um sees it it is pretty specky, he would more likely hold it. NAB, as far as the banks are concerned, uh Zach is holding it. Um Phil saying, look, it is it is a poor environment for banks at the moment, he would sell it. So both would prefer CBA and finally IGO. It is a buy from Phil and a hold from Zach.
55:16
Andrew Gagan: Thank you to our guests for getting across all those stocks. Zach, thanks for joining us, Banitary Investment Management.
55:23
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Thanks,
55:23
Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): Andrew. I appreciate that.
55:24
Andrew Gagan: Good stuff. And Phil, as always, thanks for joining from Shore and Park.
55:28
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Thanks for
55:28
Andrew Gagan: you.
55:28
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Cheers.
55:29
Andrew Gagan: And thanks to you, of course, for watching and sending in your stock ideas. Keep those coming in. And just a reminder, there is, of course, a lot of investing information out there, but good decisions require more. than noise osbys plus gives you the experts plus intelligence you can get your free seven day trial at
55:45
Philip Pepe: osbisplus.com
55:47
Andrew Gagan: dot au
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.

More from The Call from ausbiz

The Call from ausbiz

the call: Friday 13 November

Episode discussion: Guests discuss NVIDIA CEO resignation, retail sector weakness, and select stock trades across tech, resources, and consumer sectors.

Speakers’ claims: Adam Dawes and Jun Bei Liu analyze market reactions to NVIDIA's CEO resignation, with both viewing the stock as a buy despite long-term founder risk. They contrast views on Lynas Rare Earths and Macquarie Group, citing geopolitical pricing power and compliance fixes respectively. The conversation shifts to consumer discretionary, where both sell Accent Group and Flight Centre due to weak spending and structural threats, while recommending James Hardie for its resilience. Medibank and Bega Cheese are debated based on defensive value versus technical overvaluation.

NVIDIARare EarthsMacquarie Group
52 min1 assets20 claims to verify
The Call from ausbiz

the call: Thursday 12 November

Episode discussion: Wulff and Coleman debate AI volatility, coal exposure, and bank valuations across multiple ASX stocks

Speakers’ claims: Grady Wulff and Howard Coleman discuss market sentiment amid AI trade volatility and a two-speed Australian economy. They analyze specific equities including Wagner's, Whitehaven Coal, and HUB24, with divergent views on valuation and growth prospects. The hosts also cover JB Hi-Fi's resilience, Guzman y Gomez's profitability concerns, and the Cleanaway takeover. Megaport and Macquarie Group round out the discussion, highlighting debates over capital expenditure efficiency and long-term shareholder returns.

AI VolatilityCoal & MiningBanking
54 min1 assets19 claims to verify
All insights