Ready For Retirement

Retirement spending analysis challenges 4% rule with 2.1% actual withdrawal data

14 min Listen to the original
Retirement PlanningWithdrawal RatesBill BengenPortfolio RiskInflationSpending Patterns

Summary

Speaker_0 argues that retirees with over $2 million face the risk of outliving their savings rather than running out of money. They cite a statistic that typical retired couples withdraw only 2.1% of their portfolio annually, which is less than half of the sustainable rate. The speaker references Bill Bengen's research to suggest a 4.7% withdrawal rate ensures a 100% probability of success over 30 years. However, they caution that targeting 100% certainty often results in unspent wealth and lower lifestyle enjoyment. The episode highlights the 'retirement spending smile,' where spending peaks early and tapers off, allowing for higher initial withdrawals. The speaker advises balancing financial security with life quality to avoid missing out on experiences due to excessive deferral.

Key takeaways

  1. 1
    The typical retired couple in America only withdraws about 2.1% of their portfolio balance, which is less than half of what you could sustainably spend throughout your retirement.

    Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) · 0:00

Episode sections

  1. 0:00 – 0:36

    Retirement Spending Risks and the 2.1% Statistic

    Speaker_0 states that for individuals with $2 million or more, the primary risk is running out of life before spending savings. They cite that typical retired couples withdraw only 2.1% of their portfolio annually, which is less than half of what is sustainably spendable.

  2. 0:36 – 3:12

    The 4.7% Withdrawal Rate and Bill Bengen's Research

    Speaker_0 introduces a $94,000 annual spend (4.7% of a $2 million portfolio) as a sustainable rate based on Bill Bengen's research. This rate ensures a 100% probability of success over a 30-year period using nearly a century of market data, including worst-case scenarios.

  3. 3:12 – 4:51

    The Cost of 100% Probability of Success

    The speaker argues that targeting a 100% probability of success often leaves millions unspent. They illustrate this with a client who wanted to raise their Monte Carlo score from 97% to 100%, suggesting that higher certainty often means lower lifestyle enjoyment.

  4. 4:51 – 7:48

    Trade-offs Between Spending and Portfolio Survival

    Using a $2 million portfolio example, the speaker shows that increasing the withdrawal rate from 4.7% to 6% ($10,000/month) reduces the ending portfolio balance but increases the quality of life during retirement. The speaker emphasizes balancing probability of success with actual lifestyle enjoyment.

  5. 7:48 – 11:27

    The 'Retirement Spending Smile' vs. Inflation Adjustment

    Speaker_0 shares an anecdote about a client who deferred spending to build a buffer, only to face health declines. They explain that most retirees do not increase spending with inflation; instead, spending peaks early and tapers off (the 'spending smile'), allowing for higher initial withdrawals without jeopardizing the portfolio.

  6. 11:27 – 13:43

    Conclusion: Balancing Financial Security and Life Quality

    The speaker concludes that retirees face two risks: running out of money and running out of life. They urge listeners to consider what they would do with higher withdrawals (e.g., travel, gifts) and to avoid deferring spending so much that they miss out on life experiences.

Claims worth verifying

The typical retired couple in America withdraws about 2.1% of their portfolio balance annually.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·0:00

How to verify: Search for academic or industry studies on 'average retirement withdrawal rates' or 'safe withdrawal rate studies' comparing actual withdrawal behavior to theoretical safe rates, such as those published by the Federal Reserve or academic journals like the Journal of Financial Planning. For recent events, verify 2026-08-07 through 2026-11-07. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

A $2 million portfolio can sustainably spend $94,000 per year (4.7% withdrawal rate) for 30 years based on Bill Bengen's research.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·0:56

How to verify: Verify Bill Bengen's '4% Rule' updates by searching for his published papers or interviews where he discusses the 4.7% figure, specifically referencing his analysis of historical market data (2026-2026 or similar periods) and inflation adjustments. For recent events, verify 2026-08-07 through 2026-11-07. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Bill Bengen's original research established the 4% rule, which he later updated to 4.7% for a 30-year retirement horizon.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·2:52

How to verify: Search for Bill Bengen's seminal article 'Withdraw Safely, or Die Trying' (2026) and subsequent updates or interviews where he discusses the evolution of the safe withdrawal rate, noting any changes in assumptions regarding bond yields or equity returns. For recent events, verify 2026-08-07 through 2026-11-07. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

A client with a 97% Monte Carlo score requested to increase it to 100%.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·4:11

How to verify: This is an anecdotal claim. It cannot be independently verified as it refers to a specific, unnamed client interaction. It serves as an illustrative example rather than a factual assertion about market data. For recent events, verify 2026-08-07 through 2026-11-07. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

In the speaker's example, a $2 million portfolio with a 4.7% withdrawal rate projects an ending balance of $5.7 million after 30 years.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·5:35

How to verify: This is a hypothetical projection based on specific assumptions (market returns, inflation, withdrawal rate). It can be verified by replicating the calculation using a Monte Carlo simulator or historical backtesting with the stated parameters, noting that the result depends entirely on the assumed market return distribution. For recent events, verify 2026-08-07 through 2026-11-07. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Studies show that average retiree spending increases by about 2% per year, while inflation increases by 3% per year.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·10:07

How to verify: Search for longitudinal studies on 'retirement consumption patterns' or 'retirement spending profiles,' such as those from the Employee Benefit Research Institute (EBRI) or academic papers analyzing the 'spending smile' in retirement, to confirm the 2% vs 3% figures. For recent events, verify 2026-08-07 through 2026-11-07. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The speaker's firm is Root Financial Partners, LLC.

Unidentified speaker (speaker_0) ·4:11

How to verify: Verify the firm's name and SEC registration status by searching the SEC's Investment Adviser Public Disclosure (IAPD) website for 'Root Financial Partners, LLC'. For recent events, verify 2026-08-07 through 2026-11-07. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Do your own research

  • Verify Bill Bengen's original research on the 4% rule and its assumptions regarding asset allocation and market conditions.
  • Check the latest Social Security Administration life expectancy tables to assess the 'running out of life' risk for specific demographics.
  • Review personal portfolio allocation to determine if a 4.7% or 6% withdrawal rate is sustainable given historical volatility.
  • Analyze personal spending habits to identify if they follow the 'spending smile' pattern or increase with inflation.
  • Research Monte Carlo simulation tools to understand how changing withdrawal rates affects the probability of portfolio survival.
  • Consider tax implications of higher early withdrawals versus leaving assets to heirs.
  • Evaluate health insurance and long-term care costs as potential factors that could disrupt the 'spending smile' model.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Most people think the biggest risk in retirement is running out of money. That's not necessarily wrong, but it is incomplete. For a lot of people, $2 million or more, the bigger risk is actually the opposite running out of life before you ever actually spend the money you've worked so hard to save. The typical retired couple in America only withdraws about 2.1% of their portfolio
0:20
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): balance, which is less than half of what you could sustainably spend throughout your retirement. So in this video, I'm going gonna to show you how much you can actually. spend from your portfolio without running out of money, and then I'm gonna show you how you can spend even more, still without jeopardizing your retirement. Let's get into
0:34
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.
0:36
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
0:36
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): here's the thing: there is a specific number that I could give you if you were to ask me how much can I spend and not run out of money in retirement? If you have, let's say, a two $2 million dollar portfolio. Now I know your actual portfolio is gonna going to be smaller or larger. but it's the framework that I want you to pay attention to. If you said, James, how much can I spend with this portfolio? I would tell
0:56
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you a number, and that number is $94,000 per year. Now, I'm making some assumptions here. Where does that come from? That comes from the assumption that you need that money to last for 30 years. That comes from an assumption that you are diversifying that money and that portfolio properly. That comes from an assumption. that you're gonna spend that
1:16
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): amount and increase it with inflation over time. Well, what happens is you end up leaving, and this is not an exaggeration, millions of dollars on the table over the course of your retirement, and you're not gonna realize it until it's too late. Let me explain where that number comes from. That $94,000 per year is 4.7% of a $2 million
1:36
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): portfolio. Again, think less of the specific portfolio. balances and think more of the framework here. But 4.7% is based upon real research that Bill Bangin did. He took nearly a century of data and wanted to answer this question. If I'm trying to support a 30-year retirement, I know that going into
1:56
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): retirement, I have no idea if we're going to get strong markets, poor markets, choppy markets, high inflation, low. inflation, we have no way of knowing. So what can we do? We can test several different periods of time. Yes, of course, there are good times that happened, but we're not concerned about those for testing. We want to know about the bad times, the years where there were back
2:16
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): to back to back, negative years in the market, the years where there is persistent hyperinflation and we had to continue to increase the cost of everything that we were purchasing, the years where the market would drop by 30, 40 plus percent at a single time. Can we survive in those markets? Is the answer he was trying to get to. And what he wanted to know is what's the highest
2:36
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): amount you could spend in that first year of retirement such that you could adjust it for inflation over time. And even if you retired into one of those years, one of those time periods, you would still have that money last for 30 years. His answer was four. 4.7%.
2:52
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So if you've ever heard of the 4% rule, this is the same exact author. His name is Bill Bang and 4% rule was his original research 30 plus years ago. He has since updated it. And his finding is that 4.7%. So if you wanted to know, James, how much can I spend? The answer is that. But here's the thing: that spending
3:12
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): amount means in none of those instances, over the past nearly 100 years did you ever run out of money. Now, on the one hand, great, that's good to know that we're not running out of money. But on the other hand, consider this. In most cases, the amount of money you would have had left at the end of retirement compared to the beginning of retirement is substantially larger.
3:32
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So, yes, you didn't run out of money, but did you run out of life before you could potentially spend on all that money? Because this is the nuance people fail to take into account. When I say you can spend 4.7% per year of your portfolio balance, that's purely if you take that amount and you don't make any adjustments for the next 30 plus years. And that's
3:51
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): understanding that we have no idea what's going to actually happen in the market. That means that for this data set that Bill Bang Bangin looked at, there was a 100% probability of success. Is that what we should? be targeting? I would say, and I would say this pretty emphatically, no, that is not what we should be targeting. We had someone who reached out to us. We have
4:11
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): dozens of people every single week who reach out to our firm, Root Financial, to get help with their saving and investing and retirement planning decisions, just like this. And when someone reaches out, they put a little comment of what are you reaching out for? What are you hoping to solve? And one individual just last week put something. My current Monte Carlo score is at 97%. I want to see what you can do to get it to 100.
4:31
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And it made me smile. So I'm very excited for us to be able to talk to this individual because we could very clearly show him what to do to get that to 100%. But the more fun question is is it already high enough to fund what you want to do? And could you actually spend more or retire earlier? Let me explain. So what we're looking at
4:51
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): here, this is a projection. And this is looking at a simulated example of someone who has exactly $2 million in their portfolio, who is spending exactly $94,000 per year, which represents exactly a 4.7% withdrawal rate. What you can see right here are those numbers. This individual is 60. We're planning for a 30-year year retirement. I am excluding Social
5:11
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Security. So we're purely looking at the portfolio here, and he is spending $7. 7,833 per month, which comes out to 94,000 per year. So in this example, I could tell this individual, based upon the last hundred years of data, you have a 100% probability of success that you will be able to retire and maintain this spending. Now that's no
5:30
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): guarantee that the future is the exact same, but it's a pretty good starting point.
5:34
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Here's
5:35
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): what I would show them him next. You did this, but you retire with 2 million and you're projected to pass away with $5.7 million. Now, you might look at that as a success if your goal is to pass more to your family, to your children, to whoever. But some of you want to know, how can I spend a little bit more? Yes, maybe I do want to pass
5:54
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): some to my children or some to my heirs, but do I want to pass uh nearly three times as much then as I actually have today in my portfolio balance? The answer is you don't need to. But this is what a 100% probability of success translates to. A giant stack of money that's likely to be sitting there at the end of your lifetime. Now, if that's your
6:14
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): goal, no problem. But again, that's not everyone's goal. What would this look like, for example, if you changed the spending amount from, let's say, 4.7% as an initial withdrawal? rate to 5%. So $100,000 now based on a $2 million portfolio, what you can start to see is there's less
6:34
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and less money left at the end of the day, but there's more and more life being lived along the way. So imagine a lever. And on the one side, the lower your spending, the lower your initial withdrawal rate, the higher your probability of success. But is that worth lower spending? Is that worth saying
6:54
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): no to things you might want to say yes to? As you start to raise your spending,
7:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): or
7:01
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): in other words, raise your lifestyle, there's a corresponding decline in terms of your Monte Carlo score. So when we look at that, if we go all the way up to, let's just say, 10,000 per month, which now represents 120,000 per year. which represents a 6% withdrawal rate, what we can see is there's more of a trade-off there.
7:21
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): The Monte Carlo scores, the probability of success of you being able to do this drops, but you live more along the way. So what's the right balance? Well, the right balance comes down to you and your plan and your strategy. But I want to share a couple of things that should reframe the way you think about this. One is a mindset. thing, and one is actually a very
7:40
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): practical thing that in some ways allows you to have your cake and eat it too. The first is a mindset thing. And let me illustrate this with a story.
7:48
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): A
7:48
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): lot of clients have seen this. A lot of clients have gone through this and they see the numbers, they get it, but they tell themselves, you know what, if I just build a little bit of buffer early in retirement, then I'll feel more confident to spend later in retirement. And there's one particular client I'm thinking of. where they did that. They knew they could spend more, but they didn't want to. They refused to spend more because they would feel a bit more
8:08
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): comfortable building more of a cushion early on. And then they felt that would give them more confidence to spend. Then the knees stopped working so great. Then the lower back went out. Then the health started to seriously decline. And now all of a sudden they have that buffer. They had the portfolio already, but now it's even larger. If they were good then, they're better now. financially, but they no longer
8:28
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): have the means of enjoying that from a health standpoint. They're not in the position to actually use what they've saved. And so I don't want us to get so focused on looking at the portfolio balance, and the bigger it is, the better, and the bigger it is, the more we'll feel comfortable spending this in the future. The future isn't promised. Whether it's our health, our life, the time of those around us,
8:48
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): we need to think very critically about how do we. want to do this. Now that actually ties in directly to the second point that I want to make here. Let's go back to the screen right here. You can see this. And yes, this individual, they went from spending 4.7% of their portfolio, or right about $7,800 per month, up to 6% of their portfolio or
9:08
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): 10,000 per month. And that cuts into what their portfolio might look like at the end of the day. But, and this is a serious but that if you take one thing away from this video, I want you to make sure you understand this. This is assuming this individual is going to spend $10,000 day one of retirement per month and increase health
9:27
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): inflation. Studies show that's not how the actual retiree tends to spend. The average retiree is going to spend a lot more early on in retirement. And when I mean a lot more, I just mean keeping up with an inflation. You're taking the trips, you're active, you're doing the things. Fast forward five years, 10 years, 15 years. Are you still taking the same trips that you're taking
9:47
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): today? Does a week in the life of you look the same 15 years from now as it does today? My guess is it probably doesn't. What tends to happen though is you don't all of a sudden stop spending money. You just gradually taper off. And what the research shows is if inflation increases by 3% per year, the average retiree spending
10:07
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): increases by about 2% per year. Meaning you're still giving yourself raises, but it's almost not even noticeable that you start spending less because it's just tiny incremental changes that just don't quite keep up with inflation year after year. So if I go back to this same exact planning scenario and if I change the retirement spending projection from what's called inflation adjustment, adjusted,
10:27
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): meaning take that 10,000 per month and increase it by 3% year over year, because that's what we're assuming for inflation, and instead change that to the retirement spending smile. Look what happens when I refresh this. The spending doesn't get back all the way to where it was at the beginning, but look at that difference. The
10:47
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): difference in assets left over at the end of your lifetime significantly. higher. Here's why that matters. This matters because this individual now can spend more up front. But instead of looking at a retirement projection and assuming logically but incorrectly that that spending keeps up with inflation over time, if
11:07
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): you follow the general approach that most retirees fall into of spending more in the first few years, doing more, traveling more, being more active, and that gradually tapers off, that actually has a significant impact on your ending wealth. Now, real quick, if you want to see how we actually do this and how we approach this, check out the video link in the description below. It's in the
11:27
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): pinned comment where I walk you through how we approach this. But this is so important to realize that if you want to know how much can you spend without running out of money, you have to understand there are two risks. One, is the risk of running out of money. If you want to minimize that, we already looked at that. Spend less. 4.7% is what Bill
11:46
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Bang and research shows over a 30-year retirement that you're going to have your money last using the last hundred years as a data set. But the second risk is running out of life. You have all the money, but you never actually get around to spending it because that identity you have created for yourself. as someone who builds and saves and invests and grows and
12:06
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): defers. It's very difficult to take that identity and switch it off and start spending this. I want you to ask yourself, what would you do if you had to? If you had to take five percent per year of your portfolio, if you had to take six percent per year of your portfolio, what would that enable? Trips with your family, trips with your friends, giving to causes you care about, spending freely on things
12:26
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that would add quality to your life or buy back some of your time. What would those things be? What would that transform about the way that you live? And if you fast forward to the end of your life now, what's the risk of you not doing those things? It's not the risk that you run out of money, it's the risk that the quality of life you could have had, the fullness of life you could have had in retirement, maybe you didn't quite get
12:46
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): around to. This is not saying money is a thing that unlocks quality of life in retirement. But the things you spend money on, the trip with your granddaughter, helping to send kids through college, gifting money to people or causes who can need it. Those are the things that will enrich your life. So keep that in mind. As you're looking at your portfolio, yes,
13:06
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): ask the question how much can I spend without running out of money? But also make sure you're not keeping it so low that you run out of life. Now, by the way, none of this take took into account tax. taxes, other income sources, different expenses that are staggered at different times. If you want to see how to bring all those pieces together, check out the video link in the description below and in the top pinned
13:25
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): comment, I walk you through how our Sequoia system does that for hundreds of families across the country to ensure that this part of your strategy is coordinated with all other aspects of your financial life. And if you like this video, I really think you're gonna like this next one. It's every retirement withdrawal strategy ranked from worst to best.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.

More from Ready For Retirement

All insights