Ground Rules: Behind the Scenes of Real Estate Law & Industry Leaders

NY landlord-tenant attorney Martin Meltzer details litigation delays, HSTPA impacts, and economic realities of housing court

1h 11m Listen to the original
Real Estate LawLandlord-TenantHousing PolicyLitigationNew York City

Summary

Martin Meltzer of Valkenberg Burton Goldman discusses the severe impact of the 2019 Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act (HSTPA) on New York landlords, particularly the elimination of the rent deposit law which extends case timelines. He argues that right-to-counsel intake procedures and inconsistent Good Cause Eviction rulings create significant financial burdens for small property owners. Meltzer highlights cases of tenant fraud, forged documents, and excessive legal fees that often exceed the debt owed. He notes that while eviction timelines have lengthened, landlords still pursue actions to maintain regulatory compliance with HPD and mortgage covenants.

Episode sections

  1. 0:04 – 5:01

    Introduction and Guest Background

    Host introduces Marty Meltzer of Valkenberg Burton Goldman, highlighting his 36-year career in New York landlord-tenant litigation and his unconventional path to law school.

  2. 5:01 – 9:29

    Early Legal Career and Housing Court Dynamics

    Meltzer describes handling up to 100 cases a day early in his career and the need for zealous advocacy in the high-pressure environment of Housing Court.

  3. 9:29 – 12:24

    Legislative Shifts: 2017-2019

    Meltzer identifies 2017 right to counsel and the 2019 HSTPA as a 'tsunami' of anti-landlord legislation that drastically altered the legal landscape.

  4. 12:24 – 17:43

    Procedural Changes: RPAPL Section 745

    Discussion on HSTPA's elimination of the rent deposit law, which previously allowed landlords to strike a tenant's answer for non-payment, now adding at least a month to proceedings.

  5. 17:43 – 22:27

    Tenant Screening and Fraud

    Meltzer argues that new laws prohibiting the use of prior landlord-tenant history for screening is 'criminal' and enables organized fraud rings.

  6. 22:27 – 26:47

    Good Cause Eviction and Legal Strategy

    Meltzer explains the ambiguity of Good Cause Eviction laws and strategies to use accrued rent for non-renewal, though many judges do not accept this linkage.

  7. 26:47 – 31:12

    Litigation Timelines and Financial Impact

    Meltzer details the 10+ month timeline for non-payment cases, allowing tenants to accumulate 1.5 years of rent debt, devastating small property owners.

  8. 31:12 – 32:09

    Client Education and Billing Transparency

    An anecdote about a Boston-based asset manager understanding the firm's billing structure after witnessing procedural delays in housing court.

  9. 32:09 – 33:07

    Temperament for Housing Court

    Meltzer describes the stress of housing court and the need for internal fortitude, noting that case law changes frequently.

  10. 33:07 – 36:52

    Commercial Insurance Fraud Case

    Meltzer recounts a case where a commercial tenant committed insurance fraud, leading to a default judgment that was later vacated due to judicial bias.

  11. 36:52 – 39:45

    Criminal Conviction and Recovery Failure

    The tenant's principal was convicted of fraud but acquitted of filing a false instrument; the landlord recovered no money due to hidden assets.

  12. 39:45 – 44:08

    Forged Court Order Case

    A tenant forged a judge's signature to stop eviction; Meltzer identified the forgery, leading to indictment, but restitution was vacated on appeal.

  13. 44:08 – 51:16

    Rent Stabilized Tenant and Guardian Fees

    Meltzer handled a case where a guardian incurred $186,000 in fees; the client was awarded $146,000 in attorney fees, collected a decade later.

  14. 51:16 – 1:10:42

    Right to Counsel and Intake Delays

    Meltzer explains that automatic adjournments for right-to-counsel intake harm low-income tenants who lose wages, though some judges allow settlements to proceed.

Claims worth verifying

Marty Meltzer spent 36 years practicing landlord-tenant law in New York.

Unidentified speaker ·1:21

How to verify: Check Marty Meltzer's professional biography on the Valkenberg Burton Goldman website or LinkedIn profile.

New York State was the first state to implement right to counsel in housing court in April 2017.

Unidentified speaker ·9:50

How to verify: Search for 'New York Right to Counsel Housing Court 2017' in legal news archives or state legislative records.

The Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act (HSTPA) came into effect in June 2019.

Unidentified speaker ·10:08

How to verify: Review the official text of the HSTPA or New York State legislative history for its enactment date.

HSTPA eliminated the ability to strike a tenant's answer for non-payment of rent under RPAPL Section 745.

Unidentified speaker ·12:49

How to verify: Compare pre- and post-HSTPA versions of RPAPL Section 745 in legal databases like Westlaw or LexisNexis.

Meltzer handled up to 100 cases a day within his first week of practice.

Unidentified speaker ·7:25

How to verify: This is a personal anecdote; verification would require contemporaneous court dockets or firm records from the early 1990s.

A tenant delayed a case for almost two years and walked away with over $150,000.

Unidentified speaker ·15:54

How to verify: This is a specific anecdote; verification would require finding the specific court case involving 'sovereign citizens' and the financial outcome.

Trial dates in July 2026 were being scheduled for November.

Unidentified speaker ·27:48

How to verify: Check New York City Housing Court scheduling announcements or court calendars for July and November 2026.

The statute requires the court to give a court date no less than three and no more than eight days from the date the tenant files the answer.

Unidentified speaker ·29:15

How to verify: Review the specific provisions of the Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law (RPAPL) regarding scheduling timelines.

Meltzer's older brother, Philip, clerked for a federal judge in Brooklyn.

Unidentified speaker ·5:44

How to verify: Check federal court clerkship records or Philip Meltzer's professional biography.

Good Cause Eviction laws exist in other jurisdictions and states.

Unidentified speaker ·22:42

How to verify: Search for 'Good Cause Eviction' laws in other US states or municipalities to verify their existence.

The tenant in the commercial case owed rent and committed insurance fraud by soaking electronics to claim damages.

Unidentified speaker ·

How to verify: Court records from the New York State Unified Court System for the specific commercial landlord-tenant case involving insurance fraud allegations; news archives from the early 2000s regarding electronics store fraud in NYC.

The tenant's principal was arrested by the NYPD while leaving the elevator to go to court.

Unidentified speaker ·

How to verify: NYPD arrest records or court dockets from the relevant New York County Supreme Court or Civil Court session on the date of the arrest.

The judge vacated the default judgment because Meltzer worked with law enforcement to have the principal arrested.

Unidentified speaker ·

How to verify: Transcripts or orders from the specific court hearing where the injunction was granted and the default judgment vacated, available via PACER or NY State Court Records.

The tenant's principal was convicted of two counts of insurance fraud and acquitted of filing a false instrument.

Unidentified speaker ·

How to verify: Criminal court records (NY County Criminal Court) showing the verdict for the specific defendant charged with insurance fraud and filing false instruments.

The tenant in the forgery case had a prior conviction for forgery.

Unidentified speaker ·

How to verify: New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services (DCJS) criminal history records or court dockets for the tenant involved in the forged order to show cause case.

The former judge appointed as guardian incurred $186,000 in legal fees over the course of the case.

Unidentified speaker ·

How to verify: Court orders awarding attorney's fees in the specific landlord-tenant case involving the elderly tenant and the former judge guardian, available via NY State Court Records.

The court awarded $146,000 in legal fees to Meltzer's client in the guardian case.

Unidentified speaker ·

How to verify: The final judgment or order in the landlord-tenant case detailing the award of attorney's fees, accessible through NY State Court Records.

Bruce Bailey, a tenant advocate, was murdered and dismembered in the late 1980s or early 1990s.

Unidentified speaker ·

How to verify: New York Times archives or NYPD homicide case files from the late 1980s/early 1990s regarding the murder of Bruce Bailey.

The 'Right to Counsel' intake process requires tenants to appear in court even if a settlement is ready, causing lost wages.

Unidentified speaker ·

How to verify: New York City Housing Court rules and regulations regarding 'Intake Day' and Right to Counsel eligibility verification procedures.

Permission from NYCHA may be required to sue tenants for nonpayment of rent in NYCHA housing.

Unidentified speaker ·

How to verify: NYCHA tenant lease agreements and NYCHA policies regarding legal actions against tenants for nonpayment of rent.

HPD-governed housing evictions follow the same RPAPL notice provisions as standard tenancies, with potential extra notice layers depending on the program.

Unidentified speaker ·1:04:55

How to verify: Review New York Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law (RPAPL) statutes and HPD guidelines for affordable housing eviction procedures.

In Section 8 housing, the tenant's share of rent is typically small ($100-$200) while the government pays the majority (e.g., $3,800 total).

Unidentified speaker ·1:05:53

How to verify: Check Section 8 payment standards and tenant contribution rules (typically 30% of adjusted income) via HUD guidelines or HPD program documents.

Eviction processes for tenants in affordable programs take approximately double the length of standard cases.

Unidentified speaker ·1:06:45

How to verify: Analyze median time-to-eviction statistics from New York State Unified Court System or HPD reports comparing standard vs. affordable housing cases.

Landlords sue for small arrears to avoid violating regulatory agreements with HPD or mortgage covenants.

Unidentified speaker ·1:06:31

How to verify: Review sample HPD Regulatory Agreements and commercial mortgage loan documents for clauses requiring active rent collection and eviction of non-paying tenants.

The speaker joined the firm in 1992.

Unidentified speaker ·1:08:06

How to verify: Verify Martin Meltzer's professional biography on the BBG LLP website or LinkedIn profile.

Do your own research

  • Verify the text of the Housing Stability and Tenant Protection Act (HSTPA) of 2019, specifically amendments to RPAPL Section 745.
  • Review NYC Housing Court statistics on average time to resolution for non-payment cases pre- and post-2019.
  • Check HPD regulatory agreements for affordable housing properties to understand compliance requirements for rent collection.
  • Research the definition of 'Good Cause' for eviction in New York City and how it varies by borough or judge.
  • Investigate the implementation timeline and impact of the Right to Counsel law in New York housing court.
  • Examine case law regarding the enforceability of tenant screening criteria that exclude prior non-payment judgments.
  • Review mortgage covenants for rental properties to identify clauses requiring active pursuit of rent arrears.
Full transcriptexpand
0:04
Unidentified speaker: Welcome everybody to another episode of Ground Rules, where today we had the man, the myth, the legend himself, and the person also who is right next door to me and hears me speak very loudly about it.
0:14
Unidentified speaker: That is never true.
0:16
Unidentified speaker: Marty Meltzer, uh Belvin Burton Goldman.
0:19
Unidentified speaker: He talks about his early beginnings and trials that he went through as a litigator.
0:24
Unidentified speaker: I know some of the past episodes we've not necessarily been focusing on litigation.
0:28
Unidentified speaker: A lot of it's been real estate or brokerage or things that are surrounded either existing assets or assets that are being developed.
0:34
Unidentified speaker: This one you're going to be talking about when the asset's in place, yet you have to be making money and you have tenants.
0:40
Unidentified speaker: These are human beings.
0:41
Unidentified speaker: How do we play here?
0:42
Unidentified speaker: How do we make our money?
0:43
Unidentified speaker: How do we evict tenants?
0:44
Unidentified speaker: And how do we behave as human beings to make sure that we're compassionate?
0:47
Unidentified speaker: And he went through all that stuff.
0:48
Unidentified speaker: He taught us a lot on how the litigation process works.
0:52
Unidentified speaker: And unfortunately, that's part of the deal.
0:54
Unidentified speaker: In the real estate business, litigation is a given.
0:57
Unidentified speaker: All I can say is if I had the litigation, I wanted Marty on my back.
1:00
Unidentified speaker: Oh, yeah.
1:01
Unidentified speaker: Not even a question.
1:01
Unidentified speaker: The guy knows exactly what he's talking about.
1:03
Unidentified speaker: And without further ado, Marty Meltzer of Valkenberg calls me.
1:08
Unidentified speaker: Woo.
1:14
Unidentified speaker: Welcome to another episode of Ground Rules.
1:17
Unidentified speaker: Today we have an excellent guest, a partner with the firm by the name of Marty Meltzer.
1:21
Unidentified speaker: He spent 36 years on one of the most contested relationships in New York, and one that's really in the eyes of everyone today, landlord and tenant.
1:31
Unidentified speaker: And he spent it in the courtroom where that fight actually happens.
1:35
Unidentified speaker: This episode is about what you learn about housing when you spend three decades in the room where it breaks down, and why the people who do it the longest, just like Marty, are usually the least ideological about it.
1:46
Unidentified speaker: So, Marty, I want to welcome you to Ground Rules.
1:51
Unidentified speaker: We're really excited to talk to you because it's a different perspective, which we always love.
1:56
Unidentified speaker: It's still housing, it still talks about rent, but it's what happens when things go wrong and what things can go wrong.
2:02
Unidentified speaker: And this is very much in the limelight right now.
2:05
Unidentified speaker: But before we turn to all of that, your career obviously has spent many decades.
2:10
Unidentified speaker: You're one of the most tenured people at Balkan Burton.
2:14
Unidentified speaker: And if you could just give an overview, how did you get involved in law and how did you end up spending so much time at BBG and not looking elsewhere?
2:22
Unidentified speaker: So my career was started with my father's suggestion.
2:26
Unidentified speaker: I went to undergraduate school and I had a degree in psychology and two minors, one in business law and one in Holocaust studies.
2:34
Unidentified speaker: I also was very good in photography, and I thought I'd pursue photography as a career.
2:40
Unidentified speaker: That didn't happen.
2:42
Unidentified speaker: I took a job at Little Caesars making pizzas.
2:46
Unidentified speaker: Pizza pizza.
2:48
Unidentified speaker: Pizza pizza.
2:49
Unidentified speaker: And after about three months of me wasting my life away making pizza at Little Caesars, my father invited me to come back to New York from Florida and join him in the construction and restaurant business.
3:03
Unidentified speaker: My dad was an entrepreneur.
3:05
Unidentified speaker: After World War II, he got into the lunchonette business, the pipe and tobacco business, and other retail stores.
3:12
Unidentified speaker: He was a salesman.
3:13
Unidentified speaker: And then when he was selling real estate, he met this fellow named Lorenzo directly off the boat from Sicily, who worked under my father at this real estate company.
3:25
Unidentified speaker: And Renzo wanted to open up a pizzeria.
3:28
Unidentified speaker: So you're like, well, my resume says little Caesars, so I must now.
3:35
Unidentified speaker: Well, I didn't get involved with that one.
3:36
Unidentified speaker: I was a young teenager at the time.
3:38
Unidentified speaker: I did serve slices behind the counter, but I think that sparked my interest because I always wanted to make a pizza after that the right way.
3:46
Unidentified speaker: So anyway, fast forward to after college, 1982-83, I started helping my dad in the construction and restaurants business, where I learn all aspects of construction, help with those aspects, and then learn how to make pizza and eventually wind up running three restaurants at the same time.
4:08
Unidentified speaker: Wow.
4:09
Unidentified speaker: So you have a restaurant and construction, which I guess maybe they go together, but how's that work?
4:15
Unidentified speaker: So your dad's in real estate and also in the restaurant.
4:18
Unidentified speaker: Is he building these restaurants for himself for others, both?
4:22
Unidentified speaker: So what we did, we would spot locations.
4:24
Unidentified speaker: They were usually in shopping centers, and we would take over either an existing store, either a pizzeria or a deli, and modify it or reconstruct it and then open up.
4:35
Unidentified speaker: And thank goodness he had an eye for picking locations and everyone was successful.
4:40
Unidentified speaker: And where were these all in the boroughs or were they all over the place?
4:44
Unidentified speaker: The three that I was involved with were in Long Island, Westbury, Beth Page, and Farmingdale, basically within 20 minutes of each other.
4:52
Unidentified speaker: They have a lot of those strip moles over there, if you're if anybody's familiar with Long Island that's listening.
4:58
Unidentified speaker: So you eventually pivoted to law school.
5:01
Unidentified speaker: What were you thinking about when you get out of law school?
5:04
Unidentified speaker: What's the goal?
5:04
Unidentified speaker: Is it just, well, I want to survive and I'll figure it out?
5:06
Unidentified speaker: Or you know where you're headed?
5:08
Unidentified speaker: Well, no, I never had the thought about going to law school.
5:12
Unidentified speaker: For those three years I worked with my dad, every day, without exception, he would implore me to apply to law school.
5:21
Unidentified speaker: And it got so contentious after the three years.
5:24
Unidentified speaker: I took my entry exams, got accepted, and went.
5:27
Unidentified speaker: I just couldn't handle him nudging me anymore.
5:31
Unidentified speaker: Well, why isn't that he thought that this was such an important thing for you to do?
5:36
Unidentified speaker: My older brother Philip went to law school and begrudgingly, more so than I.
5:41
Unidentified speaker: He was more artsy and into music.
5:44
Unidentified speaker: He became a very successful lawyer, clerk for a federal judge in Brooklyn, worked for an incredibly successful real estate litigation firm in New York City.
5:54
Unidentified speaker: And my father had this grand idea that my brother Philip and I would be law partners one day.
6:00
Unidentified speaker: We talked to each other three times a year.
6:04
Unidentified speaker: So uh Philip, if if you're if you're listening, obviously, uh give him a call.
6:08
Unidentified speaker: But it never ended up happening.
6:09
Unidentified speaker: But was litigation because to me, when I went to law school, that's sort of what I thought it was.
6:14
Unidentified speaker: I didn't really know all the different types of things that you can actually do in terms of the transactional and and so on.
6:21
Unidentified speaker: So was litigation really just well, that's kind of what lawyers do.
6:24
Unidentified speaker: That's what I see on TV.
6:25
Unidentified speaker: That's what I know.
6:27
Unidentified speaker: I had no idea what to expect.
6:28
Unidentified speaker: So while in law school, I was on the moot court board.
6:32
Unidentified speaker: So basically appellate arguments.
6:35
Unidentified speaker: I was the competition editor for one year on the moot court society.
6:39
Unidentified speaker: I also took externship programs where I volunteered for the Legal Aid Society, criminal division, learning the ins and outs of criminal practice.
6:49
Unidentified speaker: I decided criminal law wasn't for me at that time.
6:53
Unidentified speaker: Or now.
6:54
Unidentified speaker: Really?
6:54
Unidentified speaker: Correct.
6:55
Unidentified speaker: I would never do that.
6:57
Unidentified speaker: And I sort of liked the activity involved, but I still had no real concept about what an attorney in court does.
7:08
Unidentified speaker: So I wound up taking my first job at another firm.
7:13
Unidentified speaker: And basically the day I was hired, they would say you're going to court, and between a group of five to six or seven attorneys, we handled up to a hundred cases a day.
7:25
Unidentified speaker: So, in other words, we got our feet wet really fast.
7:29
Unidentified speaker: Within a week, I was doing trials.
7:33
Unidentified speaker: Right.
7:33
Unidentified speaker: You either swim or drown.
7:36
Unidentified speaker: And so I've been to Housing Fort a couple of times, and I'm lucky enough not to have to go anymore.
7:40
Unidentified speaker: And to me, the rules are people yell things out, and there's some roll call and there's some things that are sort of unsaid.
7:48
Unidentified speaker: What was that like you first going in there?
7:50
Unidentified speaker: And did they give you any sort of training?
7:52
Unidentified speaker: Or you literally you were just like, let me see what other people are doing.
7:55
Unidentified speaker: I'll ask questions, I'll figure it out.
7:57
Unidentified speaker: The only training we had we shadowed a more senior attorney who may have had six more weeks of experience.
8:04
Unidentified speaker: But that six months is six years, and it's like dog ears at that moment.
8:08
Unidentified speaker: Well, it it's valuable.
8:10
Unidentified speaker: You basically go in, you listen, you have to be an incredible listener, you have to be incredibly patient, and you have to be intuitive.
8:19
Unidentified speaker: Meaning you have to read the judges, you have to read the tenant if they're unrepresented.
8:26
Unidentified speaker: If they're represented, you have to understand who their attorney is, whether they're from some form of legal services, what their background is, whether they're private counsel, what type of firm they come from.
8:37
Unidentified speaker: And those are just some of the aspects of what we need to digest in order to deal with the other side to get this result, because the key thing that we're hired to do is zealously advocate for our clients.
8:55
Unidentified speaker: And that's one of the first canons of ethics and law is zealous advocacy.
9:00
Unidentified speaker: Your client is number one.
9:02
Unidentified speaker: Taking all those factors, we have to figure out real quickly in housing court, where each judge might have 50 to 70 cases a day, how to get an incredibly good result in a matter of a few minutes.
9:17
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, it's a lot of pressure.
9:19
Unidentified speaker: If you can recall uh the evolution of the housing courts from when you started to when you came here to as you progress to today, are the differences stark?
9:29
Unidentified speaker: Have things changed much, or is it sort of the same beast as it was when you started?
9:34
Unidentified speaker: So it's a very interesting question, David.
9:37
Unidentified speaker: Now, well, since 2017, that was really a trigger point, in my viewpoint, of drastic changes in housing court.
9:50
Unidentified speaker: In 2017, I believe it was April, New York State was the first state to have, let's call it, right to counsel in housing court.
9:59
Unidentified speaker: And whether it's a good thing or a bad thing, that's a topic for another day.
10:03
Unidentified speaker: But it was supposed to level the playing field between litigants.
10:08
Unidentified speaker: Then in June 2019, the HSTPA, the Housing Stability Tenant and Protection Act, came into effect, and that changed a significant part of the landlord tenant practice, basically changing the real property actions and proceedings law, which is the statutory body that governs how things work in court.
10:32
Unidentified speaker: And then, of course, recently the Good Cause Eviction Law was passed, which further changed the landscape of housing.
10:41
Unidentified speaker: So, with those three major things, it wasn't like a pendulum that gradually moved.
10:48
Unidentified speaker: This was like a tidal wave or a tsunami.
10:52
Unidentified speaker: It starts real slow.
10:54
Unidentified speaker: The pendulum may have, prior to 2017, depending who the mayor was or the city council was or who was on the rent guidelines board, for example, the pendulum may have moved a little bit one way in favor of tenants or one way in favor of landlords.
11:11
Unidentified speaker: But in 2017, in my viewpoint, that was sort of the tsunami of what is now this drastic change of, in my opinion, anti-landlord that harm property owners, small, medium, and large.
11:30
Unidentified speaker: And so it's interesting to hear that because when I look at those laws, and I would love for you to t tell us a little bit more about that.
11:36
Unidentified speaker: When we look at those laws, we view them from there are certain restrictions, there's certain limits on operating income as a result, vacancy increases, all those things that affect the bottom line of the landlord.
11:49
Unidentified speaker: But in my mind, I don't necessarily think right away that it affects things in housing court.
11:53
Unidentified speaker: So how have the procedures changed as a result of that sentiment?
11:58
Unidentified speaker: And in addition, given who the mayor is and what's happened recently with the rent stabilized board and them not passing any increases, which I think is terribly wrong given how operating expenses are going and how difficult landlords are having it, including landlords who have rent stabilized housing and others who have stock like that.
12:16
Unidentified speaker: How has it really impacted the procedures versus just the bottom line of landlords and how they function in operating these buildings?
12:22
Unidentified speaker: It's a fantastic question, David.
12:24
Unidentified speaker: We could talk about the laws and what happens in court for many hours to come, but I'd like to focus on one aspect of the real property actions and precedings law that drastically affects property owners.
12:39
Unidentified speaker: And in my view, was a terrible change in the law.
12:43
Unidentified speaker: So that occurred during the HSTPA's enactment again in June 2019.
12:49
Unidentified speaker: RPAPL Section 745, also known as the rent deposit law, was an important procedural tool for property owners.
13:00
Unidentified speaker: Before the HSTPA, basically, if a tenant asked for two adjournments in a court proceeding, the landlord's attorney can ask the judge to trigger the rent deposit law, and we would walk away with a court order that said something like the tenant has to pay all the rent that accrued since the filing of the case, and that period of time could have been a couple of months, and ongoing rent throughout the proceeding.
13:30
Unidentified speaker: And if the tenant missed any one of those payments, the court was empowered to strike the tenant's answer, basically meaning the tenant hasn't appeared, and entered judgment for the landlord, and landlords would win the case that way.
13:46
Unidentified speaker: So let's fast forward.
13:48
Unidentified speaker: The HSTPA basically obliterated that procedure.
13:54
Unidentified speaker: And although the statute still exists, there's no more striking of the answer.
13:59
Unidentified speaker: The request to the court has to be done in writing through what's called a motion.
14:04
Unidentified speaker: That adds at least a month on to the procedure, whereas prior to the HSTPA, we could ask the court verbally, and the court would accept that for the most part.
14:15
Unidentified speaker: So let me take an aside.
14:18
Unidentified speaker: A landlord's goal as a business owner is to collect rent.
14:22
Unidentified speaker: It's not to throw people out of their apartments.
14:26
Unidentified speaker: So when a tenant comes to court owing money, and we're talking about most cases are non-payment cases.
14:33
Unidentified speaker: The holdovers we could talk about another time.
14:36
Unidentified speaker: Many people have legitimate reasons for not paying rent.
14:39
Unidentified speaker: They had to pay for a medical expense, they had a car repair, they got laid off from work, and they're trying to figure out a way to pay.
14:48
Unidentified speaker: And for the most part, most people who come to court who have that problem are decent working New Yorkers who have had a hiccup in their life.
14:58
Unidentified speaker: And we as counsel should recognize that.
15:02
Unidentified speaker: And I think I do a pretty good job at that, as well as my colleagues.
15:06
Unidentified speaker: I think the other side of the bar, the tenant representation and judges think that landlords want to displace tenants from their homes.
15:17
Unidentified speaker: It's a fallacy.
15:19
Unidentified speaker: Okay.
15:20
Unidentified speaker: I think our local government, the mayor, the council, they also look at this as an adversarial event in life and are looking for reasons to change laws with this fiction that landlords want to create homelessness.
15:38
Unidentified speaker: That's not the case.
15:41
Unidentified speaker: Now, just let's flip the coin a second.
15:43
Unidentified speaker: Many cases that I do deal with tenants who are gaming the system.
15:49
Unidentified speaker: I've had recently tenants who claim they're sovereign citizens.
15:54
Unidentified speaker: One delayed the case for almost two years, walking away with over $150,000.
16:00
Unidentified speaker: Now, if the rent deposit law was still in effect, that financial harm to our client would never have happened.
16:08
Unidentified speaker: But fast forward, that case occurred about five, six, seven years ago.
16:12
Unidentified speaker: We obtained over a hundred thousand dollar judgment.
16:15
Unidentified speaker: I just located a piece of investment property this person has in upstate New York.
16:19
Unidentified speaker: Oh, wow.
16:20
Unidentified speaker: And the client is deciding whether we should go ahead and attach it and foreclose on the home.
16:25
Unidentified speaker: The only problem is the home is only worth about $100,000, and the legal expenses to do that legal work will probably be half or close to that amount of money.
16:38
Unidentified speaker: So the client has to decide whether it's worth spending money on BBG to do that work or just forego and wait for that judgment to expire in 20 years.
16:50
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
16:50
Unidentified speaker: And so I think a lot of the cases they just you end up not collecting.
16:55
Unidentified speaker: Maybe you'll get the tenant out.
16:56
Unidentified speaker: And so you can bring in a new tenant and take away some of that pain, the monetary pain.
17:00
Unidentified speaker: But like I said, it's a business.
17:02
Unidentified speaker: They have to pay their mortgage, they have to pay their expenses, they have to pay for insurance, and not having that income come to the building is a big hit.
17:10
Unidentified speaker: Are landlords hedging against that or doing anything to try to protect themselves given this huge wave?
17:17
Unidentified speaker: If you're talking about are landlords doing anything to try to collect rent in a manner?
17:22
Unidentified speaker: In any way to try to prevent it from happening before it happens, namely changing their strategy given this entire wave of what's happening, perhaps vetting tenants a little bit more.
17:35
Unidentified speaker: What are clients doing, or what can you advise clients that could help subvert some of this, or maybe there's nothing that that really can they can do?
17:43
Unidentified speaker: Aaron Ross Powell, there are things that can be done, but if you recall, I just said there's been a change in the law.
17:50
Unidentified speaker: One of the most recent changes, and which to me is devastating to our clients, is the inability to vet or screen tenants in a proper manner.
18:03
Unidentified speaker: So you may say, what does that mean?
18:05
Unidentified speaker: So now, under this new law, a landlord cannot use prior landlord tenant history to determine whether they will rent to a tenant.
18:18
Unidentified speaker: So for example, if there were a judgment against a tenant for nonpayment of rent, and let me say a legitimate judgment for nonpayment of rent, that piece of information cannot be used to deny a rental applicant.
18:35
Unidentified speaker: It's ridiculous.
18:36
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
18:36
Unidentified speaker: So as Camilla said uh quietly, it's ridiculous.
18:40
Unidentified speaker: I think it's not ridiculous.
18:42
Unidentified speaker: I think it's criminal that the government would prohibit a property owner to handcuff them to decide who they rent to or not.
18:54
Unidentified speaker: There are so many protections for tenants, anti-discrimination, income-based discrimination, the protected classes.
19:03
Unidentified speaker: Those are wonderful, but for somebody who's been involved in the legal proceeding world, a landlord should have the right, the unbridled right, to look at and use that as a point of information.
19:18
Unidentified speaker: So another thing about screening, one thing that is crucial, and I have this discussion with clients often, to always review the application that a tenant submits.
19:32
Unidentified speaker: I've had many cases over the years, well after the person has been made a tenant and they're in housing court, and I look at the application, and there's information missing, like a partial Social Security number.
19:47
Unidentified speaker: The references are scribbled, the phone numbers that are given are inaccurate, the references, the family members.
19:57
Unidentified speaker: So many years ago, I had handled cases which it was a family or people with the same last name, and they would go from building to building to building using similar information or false information, defrauding landlords, and they would get into an apartment, and then they would load the apartment up with their family members.
20:21
Unidentified speaker: It would take me almost a year to get them out, and they would sometimes trash the apartment by damaging it significantly, using it as a place of business, and then once the marshal was heading to the door, they would go apply somewhere else.
20:38
Unidentified speaker: I haven't had many of those recently, but it was a wave of over a course of three or four years where that happened.
20:46
Unidentified speaker: So if a landlord's allowed to screen where they train their leasing agents the right way, those things can be discovered and handled in a lawful manner, such as, for example, Camilla, if you were to apply to me for an apartment and I saw an incomplete application, I would say something like, Hey Camilla, I'd like to review this and submit this for application, but there's many points of information missing.
21:13
Unidentified speaker: Here it is, please fill it out.
21:15
Unidentified speaker: But I think that's a general problem.
21:17
Unidentified speaker: We review a lot of leases every day, and the management companies don't tend to review applications.
21:23
Unidentified speaker: We get leases or forms that are pre-filled and they're always missing information.
21:27
Unidentified speaker: And unless we flag it, they don't go after that.
21:30
Unidentified speaker: So even flagging it, it's already happened.
21:32
Unidentified speaker: It's after the fact.
21:34
Unidentified speaker: So in today's world, some of the buildings, especially the institutional clients who own multiple properties in New York City, in the different boroughs, and even in other cities across the country, they have pretty sound training programs internally.
21:52
Unidentified speaker: And then when things come up, they reach out to me or people in the firm and they ask, What would you do?
21:58
Unidentified speaker: Do you have any suggestions?
22:00
Unidentified speaker: And we hope with that teamwork it helps the clients be able to screen and vet tenants better and under the guise of the current laws.
22:10
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
22:11
Unidentified speaker: And so one of the things that actually surprised me, we were just talking about this with another guest, which is we'd spoken to this guest three years before on a different show, and we thought that good cause eviction was just something that there were rumplings, it wasn't really going to happen.
22:27
Unidentified speaker: Obviously, it happened.
22:28
Unidentified speaker: Have you felt any of these cases and what was that experience like if you have?
22:32
Unidentified speaker: So I have not litigated any cases.
22:34
Unidentified speaker: I know other partners and attorneys have in the office, but good cause eviction shouldn't be a surprise to anybody in New York.
22:42
Unidentified speaker: It existed in other jurisdictions in other states.
22:46
Unidentified speaker: It was just a matter of time before it happened here.
22:49
Unidentified speaker: And the stars were aligned, meaning the legislature and the mayor, and it happened.
22:55
Unidentified speaker: There's exceptions to the good cause eviction, but the there's various aspects of the law that are not worded precisely.
23:05
Unidentified speaker: So if a case is challenged by a tenant in court, there's judges in different boroughs who view the law differently than each other.
23:17
Unidentified speaker: So we have a myriad of decisions from judges, say Brooklyn, Queens, Manhattan, who rule differently on the same issue.
23:26
Unidentified speaker: Then when a decision comes down from housing court, another lawyer will use that in a different borough, even though it's not controlling law.
23:37
Unidentified speaker: Housing court is basically a trial court at the lowest level.
23:42
Unidentified speaker: Unless there's an appellate case, housing court law is really informational in my mind.
23:49
Unidentified speaker: Though a decision may be worded very artfully and thoroughly and well written, it doesn't mean it's controlling law.
23:58
Unidentified speaker: So this is developing now, the decisions on good cause eviction.
24:02
Unidentified speaker: So for example, one of the grounds to be able to sue a tenant who is covered by good cause eviction is for nonpayment of rent.
24:12
Unidentified speaker: Well, what does that mean?
24:14
Unidentified speaker: You can bring a non-payment proceeding, but does it mean you can terminate the tenancy under the good cause eviction?
24:21
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
24:22
Unidentified speaker: So what do you do as an attorney?
24:25
Unidentified speaker: What do you do as a client?
24:28
Unidentified speaker: Do you serve a rent case and then bring the lease termination case based on the nonpayment?
24:39
Unidentified speaker: It always that always seemed very odd to me because you had that choice.
24:42
Unidentified speaker: You're seeking nonpayment, but you're not seeking to terminate.
24:44
Unidentified speaker: You just want to get back what you're owed, and then you have to kind of update that information as time goes on, right?
24:50
Unidentified speaker: Because the money owed continues to increase as the time goes on, but you can't do both at the same time.
24:56
Unidentified speaker: So you have to remember a non-payment case, even though the end result, if the tenant doesn't pay after a judgment is obtained, is an eviction, possession.
25:05
Unidentified speaker: But it's really about money.
25:06
Unidentified speaker: The holdover for termination is about possession, even though there's an ancillary monetary claim to the case, right?
25:15
Unidentified speaker: Trevor Burrus, Jr.
25:15
Unidentified speaker: But you want to get paid for what he's using when he's not entitled to it, right?
25:18
Unidentified speaker: She So under good cause eviction, nonpayment is an exception not to renew a lease.
25:26
Unidentified speaker: Right?
25:27
Unidentified speaker: But how do you prove that in court?
25:29
Unidentified speaker: How do you satisfy the judges who are also new to the law?
25:33
Unidentified speaker: It's only a year, year and a half since it happened.
25:36
Unidentified speaker: So one of the things that I do is I bring the nonpayment, and then I use that same rent and anything that has accrued since as a basis to bring the non-renewal.
25:48
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
25:48
Unidentified speaker: So this this way you have something to back it up, and there's not really a question that that's it's proof that the money is owed and that a case had to be started to compel the payment.
25:59
Unidentified speaker: So it's one more notch in the belt, if you will, to support the case for non-renewal.
26:08
Unidentified speaker: Many judges don't accept that.
26:10
Unidentified speaker: But we had remember the zealous advocacy part?
26:14
Unidentified speaker: If we don't do that, the question is, are we zealously advocating?
26:18
Unidentified speaker: Are we trying to help our client the best way possible with the tools that we have under the structure of the law that we have to get the result?
26:27
Unidentified speaker: Either payment in full or get that tenant out.
26:30
Unidentified speaker: Because remember, with the non-payment, you're likely not to get the tenant out anytime soon.
26:37
Unidentified speaker: That's another topic we should talk about timing of court cases.
26:41
Unidentified speaker: How long does it take to get a tenant out for non-payment taxes?
26:44
Unidentified speaker: Oh, exactly.
26:45
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, I think I got to tell us that.
26:47
Unidentified speaker: So the boroughs are different between Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, and there's the Bronx, but I might as well focus on the three main boroughs that we deal with.
26:59
Unidentified speaker: Before you even get a trial date, there's several months of delay at the first level.
27:05
Unidentified speaker: That's called the resolution part, meaning a judge who won't try the case but is designed to try to get people to settle.
27:12
Unidentified speaker: If you can't settle within that first two to three months, the case gets referred to the trial part.
27:20
Unidentified speaker: The procedure there can take six to seven months.
27:24
Unidentified speaker: So now we're looking at 10 months minimum before you have a trial.
27:31
Unidentified speaker: So in the trial part, you get a pretrial conference, that takes 30 days, then it gets adjourned for trial.
27:38
Unidentified speaker: Today, in July of 2026, if I get sent to a trial judge, trial dates are being given in November.
27:48
Unidentified speaker: So wait a minute, just to step back for a while.
27:49
Unidentified speaker: That first phase that you said where you go to housing court, it's a general housing court judge, you get called, they can adjourn it, right?
27:57
Unidentified speaker: They have rights of representation, so there's some of that delay there.
28:01
Unidentified speaker: And then the judge talks to you, and then you say, Well, judge, they owe my client this money and they're just not gonna What do you mean settle?
28:07
Unidentified speaker: They owe the money, right?
28:08
Unidentified speaker: They haven't paid.
28:09
Unidentified speaker: Do they have do they say, oh well, this thing was broken or that thing was broken, or there was a nuisance, or how does that go over there?
28:15
Unidentified speaker: Why is there so much delay there?
28:17
Unidentified speaker: And then once you go to the trial, there's not really a lot of discovery, right?
28:20
Unidentified speaker: So shouldn't things move a little faster?
28:22
Unidentified speaker: And I know I'm playing a little devil's advocate because I know it doesn't, but I want you to tell me why it doesn't.
28:26
Unidentified speaker: Well, if you recall, I mentioned the RPAPL, right?
28:30
Unidentified speaker: That's the statutory body.
28:32
Unidentified speaker: These are called summary proceedings.
28:35
Unidentified speaker: For the 37 years that I've practiced law, nothing has been summary about this.
28:40
Unidentified speaker: It's a detailed summary.
28:42
Unidentified speaker: I hope my lifespan is as summary as this proceedings.
28:45
Unidentified speaker: I may well live into my hundreds if they're associated in any way.
28:50
Unidentified speaker: So the procedure is when the case is served, the tenant has 10 days to respond.
28:57
Unidentified speaker: So let's assume the tenant responds, then the court assigns a court date.
29:03
Unidentified speaker: The statute under the RPAPL requires the court to give a court date no less than three and no more than eight days from the date the tenant files the answer.
29:15
Unidentified speaker: Sometimes, not so much today in 2026, but last year, we were getting court dates sometimes several months after that.
29:24
Unidentified speaker: There were lawsuits filed against the court administration about that, and the the higher court basically said, we don't get involved with the administration of procedure.
29:35
Unidentified speaker: Um so now realize now if you're getting a court date that's two or three months after the tenant answers, the tenant already owes a few months' worth of rent minimum.
29:46
Unidentified speaker: Now we're looking at a half a year's worth of rent, and then a year later, there's a year and a half worth of rent owed.
29:54
Unidentified speaker: That tenant, unless they get rental assistance from some government source, usually it's the Human Resources Administration, part of the welfare system.
30:04
Unidentified speaker: That tenant is walking, owing that kind of money.
30:07
Unidentified speaker: Either it's before a judgment or after a judgment.
30:11
Unidentified speaker: That's also devastating to a property owner, especially a small property owner who owns 10 or less units, who usually live in their building and who have worked their whole lives to buy this building many decades ago, and now they're on the cusp or in their retirement.
30:29
Unidentified speaker: And now when a tenant leaves owing a year and a half worth of rent, and their water expenses are going up, their property insurance is going up, their real estate taxes are going up, their Social Security payments may be going down, they have difficulty paying for those expenses.
30:50
Unidentified speaker: Is that a plan by the government to foreclose on small property owners and take those properties back in order to provide affordable housing for people?
30:59
Unidentified speaker: I don't know.
30:59
Unidentified speaker: Food for thought.
31:00
Unidentified speaker: I think we're going to do a hashtag for that, uh a conspiracy theory hashtag.
31:04
Unidentified speaker: You and I talked a ton about these war stories that you've amassed over the last 35, 37 years.
31:12
Unidentified speaker: I would love to get a flavor of the types of things that you handle.
31:15
Unidentified speaker: A lot of people do not understand how housing core works, and so giving an example, I think is the best way to demonstrate that.
31:23
Unidentified speaker: I think I could remember a few.
31:25
Unidentified speaker: But before I get to that, for example, we have a client whose headquarters are based in Boston, Massachusetts, and their asset manager wanted to understand how we do our billing because he's the one who was reviewing our invoices, authorizing payment, and he couldn't understand why a particular tenant's account was being billed over the course of months, if not a year.
31:48
Unidentified speaker: I invited him to New York to come with me to court.
31:52
Unidentified speaker: To shadow you.
31:53
Unidentified speaker: Yes.
31:54
Unidentified speaker: So he can see exactly what those bills.
31:57
Unidentified speaker: He takes the train from Boston, we meet in court, and I brought him to two or three courtrooms, and it wasn't very busy that particular day.
32:06
Unidentified speaker: And he looked at me and he said, Thank you.
32:09
Unidentified speaker: Never invite me again.
32:11
Unidentified speaker: The few times I've been to housing court, I did not want to return.
32:14
Unidentified speaker: It is not for the faint of heart.
32:15
Unidentified speaker: Right.
32:16
Unidentified speaker: So you have to have a certain temperament as an attorney to go to court day in and day out, especially for the decades that I have done it and some of my colleagues here have done it.
32:29
Unidentified speaker: You have to have great internal fortitude.
32:33
Unidentified speaker: You have to have a certain knack for dealing with people, dealing with negativity and pushback from the other side.
32:41
Unidentified speaker: So you have to be a pretty forceful person.
32:44
Unidentified speaker: I don't mean loud, but forceful in a sense, sticking up for your clients' rights, advocating, knowing the case law, knowing the law that changes from week to week, month to month, and using all those tools to help shorten that process of what we have now become accustomed to.
33:07
Unidentified speaker: So having said that, I'd like to talk about a case that came to mind this morning, it was a commercial case that I did years ago.
33:15
Unidentified speaker: And the tenant was a corporation that rented a small space in the financial district electronics store, laptops, cameras, video recording.
33:30
Unidentified speaker: So the tenant owed some rent.
33:32
Unidentified speaker: We brought him to court, and I get a call from an insurance investigator, and they were asking me some questions about why we're in court, and I told them what's going on.
33:47
Unidentified speaker: And I said, Well, why are you calling me?
33:49
Unidentified speaker: It's unusual that an insurance investigator calls me.
33:52
Unidentified speaker: He says, Well, um, this particular owner takes old equipment from customers, he puts it in the back in a box and he soaks it with water, and he makes insurance claims for damaged electronics, and he's been paid out on claims.
34:14
Unidentified speaker: So I said, Well, what does that have to do with me?
34:16
Unidentified speaker: And he says, Well, he's claiming that the sprinkler system in the place is causing the leak, and it's not him.
34:24
Unidentified speaker: So I confirm that there's nothing wrong with the sprinkler system for this 30-story building where there's multiple commercial tenants.
34:34
Unidentified speaker: They continue with the investigation.
34:38
Unidentified speaker: So when the tenant's principal was coming to court, the NYPD and the detectives were out to get him.
34:47
Unidentified speaker: So they called me and they said, Do you know if the person's coming to court?
34:51
Unidentified speaker: I said, I have no idea.
34:52
Unidentified speaker: He has a lawyer, it's a corporation, but the court date is at this time on this particular date.
34:58
Unidentified speaker: They arrested the principal coming off the elevator to go to court.
35:03
Unidentified speaker: Okay.
35:04
Unidentified speaker: It would have been better if actually he was in front of the judge and they took a that would have really helped her case, I think.
35:08
Unidentified speaker: Well, I don't know about that because the next part of the story is even more interesting.
35:12
Unidentified speaker: Probably.
35:13
Unidentified speaker: So um the lawyer didn't show up that day for court, and the judge calls the case, and I go in front of the judge, and the judge says, What do you want to do, Mr.
35:25
Unidentified speaker: Meltzer?
35:26
Unidentified speaker: And I said, I want a default judgment.
35:28
Unidentified speaker: Said, but I want to let you know that the tenant has a lawyer, but his principal was just arrested stepping off the elevator for alleged insurance fraud.
35:38
Unidentified speaker: The judge grants me a default, and we get a, I think it was like a $32,000 judgment, if my memory serves me right.
35:47
Unidentified speaker: So what I do is I take that judgment, I file it in the county clerk's office, and then I do an asset search, and I find that this man has a brokerage account at Schwab, and I freeze the account, and I'm about to take the money.
36:04
Unidentified speaker: His lawyer brings what's called an order to show cause.
36:07
Unidentified speaker: And for those who may not know what that is, it's a written request to the court to stop what's happening, an injunction.
36:14
Unidentified speaker: The judge signs that, we go to court and we argue against the injunction, and the judge blames me personally for working with law enforcement to have the principal attendant arrested, and she vacates this day, and he was able to get his money.
36:30
Unidentified speaker: No way.
36:31
Unidentified speaker: Yes.
36:32
Unidentified speaker: That's unbelievable.
36:33
Unidentified speaker: Wait a minute, so but what does one have to do with the other?
36:37
Unidentified speaker: What that seems like completely irrelevant to.
36:39
Unidentified speaker: It doesn't.
36:40
Unidentified speaker: So that judge and I had very heated discussions outside the courtroom when we went to social events.
36:46
Unidentified speaker: That judge still thinks he or she did the right thing, and I don't.
36:52
Unidentified speaker: But there's a third part to the story, and that is the criminal proceeding.
36:57
Unidentified speaker: I testified in court against the defendant tenant's principal for the district attorney's office because the tenant filed an affidavit in the landlord tenant proceeding, claiming that the reason why he was withholding rent was because of the water leaks.
37:18
Unidentified speaker: So the district attorney, in order to prove a criminal offense of filing a false instrument, needed me to testify about what the financial harm was to the client, which I did.
37:31
Unidentified speaker: It was a little nerve-wracking being a witness, even though I appear in court, had the jurors look right next to me, and the tenant's principal was looking at me, and his wife was in the courtroom, and his two little girls were in the courtroom.
37:44
Unidentified speaker: They were a few years old at the time.
37:47
Unidentified speaker: So he's being charged with three counts: two counts of insurance fraud, one count of filing a false instrument.
37:54
Unidentified speaker: All three are felonies.
37:56
Unidentified speaker: If he got convicted of three felony counts, he would have served a pretty long time in prison, New York State prison, and he wouldn't have seen his little girls grow up.
38:08
Unidentified speaker: So here's the end of the story.
38:11
Unidentified speaker: The jury comes back and convicts the defendant of two counts of insurance fraud and acquits him on the filing of a false instrument.
38:21
Unidentified speaker: Why did they do that, you might wonder?
38:23
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
38:23
Unidentified speaker: Because we had him dead to rights on that.
38:25
Unidentified speaker: The DA had him dead to rights on the filing of the false instrument.
38:28
Unidentified speaker: If he got convicted on the three counts, he would have served probably a minimum to three to five years in prison.
38:35
Unidentified speaker: But being convicted on two counts, maybe he would have gotten probation or a year or two.
38:40
Unidentified speaker: So the jury felt sympathetic or empathetic, I should say, and didn't want to deprive his two little girls of seeing the father for such a long period of time.
38:50
Unidentified speaker: That's what I was told.
38:52
Unidentified speaker: That's why I bring my kids to any of these important events to make sure they have sympathy points.
38:56
Unidentified speaker: So that was one.
39:00
Unidentified speaker: Well, did did they got so when we got convicted though?
39:03
Unidentified speaker: What happened with the money?
39:04
Unidentified speaker: Did they uh you get evicted?
39:06
Unidentified speaker: Did any of that stuff the tenant was evicted, but my client saw no money.
39:11
Unidentified speaker: He wound up grabbing his money and hiding it and declining to spend any more.
39:15
Unidentified speaker: It's only $32,000 to go after that kind of money would have cost that amount of money.
39:21
Unidentified speaker: So the only reason to do that is for principle.
39:25
Unidentified speaker: And we know how much principle costs too much money.
39:27
Unidentified speaker: And if you're in a business, you don't you generally don't live on principle, right?
39:31
Unidentified speaker: Right.
39:31
Unidentified speaker: So another case I'd like to talk about too, which stands out in my mind, is another case where it was another criminal proceeding that I got involved with, not by my asking or doing, but just because of the circumstance I was in.
39:45
Unidentified speaker: We had a residential case, and the eviction is about to occur.
39:51
Unidentified speaker: A person takes out an order to show cause, again, an injunction to try to stop the eviction, and I get a call from the marshal's office saying that there's an order to show cause, the eviction is going to be called off.
40:08
Unidentified speaker: I happen to see the order to show cause, and then I recognize.
40:13
Unidentified speaker: So at the bottom of the piece of paper that is the order, the judge's name is usually printed, and this particular judge, she had a very recognizable signature.
40:25
Unidentified speaker: You didn't have to be a handwriting analyst to know whether it was hers or not.
40:30
Unidentified speaker: So the tenant forged the judge's signature.
40:33
Unidentified speaker: Well, how did you know?
40:34
Unidentified speaker: Did you know at the time that you saw it, or is this the I did immediately?
40:37
Unidentified speaker: I the minute I saw that, because the goal is zealous advocacy, get the tenant evicted.
40:43
Unidentified speaker: I'm on the phone calling the court to speak to the judge.
40:46
Unidentified speaker: She's calling me on another line at the same time, and she told me, I know it's a forgery.
40:52
Unidentified speaker: The court called the marshal, they told him it's an invalid order, the eviction went through.
40:58
Unidentified speaker: Shortly after that, I get a call from the district attorney's office, and they asked me to testify at the grand jury.
41:05
Unidentified speaker: And the judge testified at the grand jury, and as a result of our testimony, the person was indicted for forgery.
41:13
Unidentified speaker: He did this once before, but not with a judge forging a check.
41:18
Unidentified speaker: So he was already a convict for forgery.
41:22
Unidentified speaker: He was tried, he was found guilty, he was serving time, and then now, fast forward after a couple years of imprisonment, they want to do some type of plea deal with him.
41:32
Unidentified speaker: So the district attorney calls me, because I followed up with him during the couple of years to see what's going on, and I said, Well, I don't know if you could do this, but my client was harmed, tens of thousands of dollars in rent.
41:51
Unidentified speaker: I'm asking the DA to make a condition of his release, restitution.
41:58
Unidentified speaker: I didn't even know you could do that.
42:00
Unidentified speaker: I thought of it on the flood.
42:01
Unidentified speaker: Remember, I said I practice in the criminal law in the in the externship program.
42:07
Unidentified speaker: I saw all sorts of deals being made for a bail application.
42:10
Unidentified speaker: So I kind of equated it to well, if somebody's going to get out of prison that could be similar to bail, let me ask the DA.
42:18
Unidentified speaker: People who listen to this podcast may think I'm making this stuff up because it sounds too much like a movie.
42:26
Unidentified speaker: It's not.
42:27
Unidentified speaker: So the DA says, let me see what I could do for you.
42:31
Unidentified speaker: And part of the plea deal was he had to pay back the money that the client lost.
42:38
Unidentified speaker: He was paying back $500 a month to pay back about $30,000.
42:44
Unidentified speaker: And he did so for a couple of years.
42:48
Unidentified speaker: Well, I read in the Law Journal, which is the what used to be the paper that let us know about cases being published every day in the criminal section, and I see the tenant's name there.
43:02
Unidentified speaker: And the Legal Aid Society appealed the parole deal, saying that because his client wasn't present, he wasn't afforded his constitutional rights, and therefore the parole deal should be set aside.
43:19
Unidentified speaker: The court vacated the parole deal, right?
43:23
Unidentified speaker: So the money my client collected was fine, but now they were going to be at another $15,000.
43:29
Unidentified speaker: So I get on the phone with the assistant district attorney and I said, Well, can't you do another parole deal and give, you know?
43:36
Unidentified speaker: He says, No, that would be double jeopardy.
43:39
Unidentified speaker: So once again, full circle, a landlord is deprived of a source of income that a person voluntarily agreed to pay back, but was undermined by this thing called constitutional rights.
43:54
Unidentified speaker: Those silly things that are constantly getting in the way.
43:58
Unidentified speaker: We won't do the hashtag conspiracy theory thing, but you know, there's a theme here, right?
44:03
Unidentified speaker: And I guess there's one other I could talk about if we have the time.
44:07
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, of course.
44:08
Unidentified speaker: So this was a residential case where there was rent stabilized tenant, long-term tenancy.
44:15
Unidentified speaker: The woman was in a beautiful co-op on the Upper East Side, but because she was rent stabilized, she was protected by the rent stabilization law fine.
44:27
Unidentified speaker: She owed about $20,000 in rent.
44:29
Unidentified speaker: Her rent at the time was about $900 a month.
44:34
Unidentified speaker: Okay.
44:35
Unidentified speaker: I don't know the reason why she withheld rent, but I think it had something to do with her age and her mental capacity, or perhaps mental incapacity.
44:44
Unidentified speaker: She was in her 80s at the time.
44:47
Unidentified speaker: And one of the things that was happening, she was overflowing her sink in one of the bathrooms intentionally.
44:54
Unidentified speaker: She was stuffing up the drain with clothing and overflowing.
44:59
Unidentified speaker: The unit owner below was getting flooded frequently.
45:04
Unidentified speaker: But that wasn't part of the case.
45:05
Unidentified speaker: But that led us to believe that the tenant needed help.
45:08
Unidentified speaker: So we told the court what's going on to see if we can get a guardian appointed for her or legal representation.
45:16
Unidentified speaker: Now, this was before the 2017 right to counsel law.
45:22
Unidentified speaker: So the tenant, she came to court, she refused assistance from counsel, Adult Protective Services, which is another division of the Human Resources Administration, interviewed her.
45:35
Unidentified speaker: I forget the reason why they didn't get involved, but I think it was because they couldn't work with her.
45:39
Unidentified speaker: There was some pushback, and they won't subject their caseworkers to that type of behavior.
45:48
Unidentified speaker: So, anyway, the case is dragging along in court all because of the obligation of an attorney to let the court know.
45:59
Unidentified speaker: Even if it's the landlord's attorney, we have an ethical obligation to let the court know if we believe a tenant is in need of some type of adult protective services.
46:09
Unidentified speaker: Once we notify the court, it's up to the court to put that wheels in motion.
46:15
Unidentified speaker: That process takes months and months, depending on the cooperativeness of the tenant and the availability of the caseworker that's appointed.
46:26
Unidentified speaker: So this case is dragging along.
46:28
Unidentified speaker: The legal fees are amassing.
46:30
Unidentified speaker: So at some point, the tenant winds up getting counsel.
46:34
Unidentified speaker: Up to that point, the legal fees were about $30,000.
46:38
Unidentified speaker: This is over about a year and a half period of time.
46:42
Unidentified speaker: The attorney who took on the case happened to be a former judge of the civil court where we're practicing.
46:51
Unidentified speaker: I'm not going to mention the former judge's name.
46:56
Unidentified speaker: From the period of time he took over the case to the time we concluded the trial, the legal fees were about $186,000.
47:06
Unidentified speaker: Oh wow.
47:07
Unidentified speaker: He would not show up for court appearances.
47:10
Unidentified speaker: He would tell the judge that he's engaged in Supreme Court in the Bronx.
47:14
Unidentified speaker: The judge would call, knowing that this lawyer, former judge, may not have been telling the truth from past experiences that was rumored to have occurred throughout the courthouse.
47:27
Unidentified speaker: He would call that judge and ask if this attorney had a court appearance, and the answer was absolutely not.
47:34
Unidentified speaker: I've asked for sanctions against that attorney.
47:37
Unidentified speaker: I've asked for the case to proceed without his presence.
47:40
Unidentified speaker: I've asked him to be reported to the disciplinary committee.
47:44
Unidentified speaker: None of that stuff happened.
47:46
Unidentified speaker: And he would do this frequently throughout the case, which resulted in me sitting around court, billing my client at the hourly rate.
47:56
Unidentified speaker: So fast forward, we finally do the trial.
48:07
Unidentified speaker: But where did the payment come from?
48:10
Unidentified speaker: It came from that lawyer's office.
48:13
Unidentified speaker: And I'm like, why is he paying the rent?
48:17
Unidentified speaker: You know, so anyway, he wound up becoming the tenant's guardian after the case and was controlling her assets.
48:25
Unidentified speaker: After the case?
48:26
Unidentified speaker: Yes.
48:28
Unidentified speaker: So as a result of that case, the tenant paying the judgment.
48:32
Unidentified speaker: She retained the apartment, and rightfully so.
48:36
Unidentified speaker: But now there was this claim for attorney's fees of $186,000 or so.
48:42
Unidentified speaker: I asked the client if they would like me to ask the court for an award of attorney's fees.
48:47
Unidentified speaker: And they said yes.
48:48
Unidentified speaker: So I do the hearing.
48:49
Unidentified speaker: The trial judge awarded about, and this is all from memory, so it's about $146,000 in legal fees.
48:55
Unidentified speaker: That's a pretty sizable amount.
48:57
Unidentified speaker: So and there was a decent cut.
49:00
Unidentified speaker: And the client then says to me, Well, how are we going to collect it?
49:04
Unidentified speaker: I said, share some information with me.
49:07
Unidentified speaker: So we found out that this person has a trust.
49:11
Unidentified speaker: So fast forward, with some good lawyering from one of my colleagues in the office, we located a brokerage account that had ample money to satisfy this judgment.
49:22
Unidentified speaker: So about a decade later, we wound up collecting the entire amount of the legal fees.
49:28
Unidentified speaker: I hope you got interest.
49:29
Unidentified speaker: I don't recall if we got interest.
49:32
Unidentified speaker: Do they look at, given how significant the fees are, especially compared to how much the outstanding rent was of like $20,000?
49:40
Unidentified speaker: Are they looking at that?
49:41
Unidentified speaker: Or did you say, hey, this guy wasted all this time?
49:44
Unidentified speaker: How are they weighing it?
49:45
Unidentified speaker: How do you argue for that?
49:46
Unidentified speaker: Okay, so it's a great question.
49:48
Unidentified speaker: So whenever an application or request for fees is made to the court, there are certain factors the court looks at, and there's plenty of case law in this, the experience of the attorney, the number of years, whether the issues in the case are novel or routine.
50:06
Unidentified speaker: Could somebody else at a lower billing rate have handled the case with the same efficiency and expertise and results?
50:15
Unidentified speaker: Whether the other side is delaying, whether we delayed in any way?
50:20
Unidentified speaker: Did we make any request to the court that shouldn't have been made?
50:23
Unidentified speaker: So there's a host of factors.
50:26
Unidentified speaker: So the thing that you said, David, about the delay of this lawyer, that was the lion's share of the work, sitting around court for eight hours with this lawyer was saying I was engaged in this case.
50:38
Unidentified speaker: One of the excuses that he gave for not showing up in court for multiple hours and only showing up after the lunch recess, which was about 2:30, because on the Upper West Side, his car, which was parked on the street, was blocked in by a garbage truck.
50:57
Unidentified speaker: And that was the reason why he couldn't get to court.
51:02
Unidentified speaker: It's interesting how you obviously there's not all the cases that you handle, but the three that you showed were you're dealing with some sketchy characters, the criminal cases, the forgery, the delay by a former like those are outstanding for examples, first of all, of the things that that happen.
51:16
Unidentified speaker: When a normal action occurs, one one that's not extraordinary like this, how quickly do you generally go about it?
51:24
Unidentified speaker: So for the regular case, the run-of-the-mill case where somebody owes a few months' worth of rent, automatically the case gets adjourned for the right to counsel.
51:34
Unidentified speaker: It's called intake day.
51:36
Unidentified speaker: So regardless if that tenant wants to settle the case and sign a written agreement to pay back the money, most judges will say, sorry, you have to go through this process.
51:47
Unidentified speaker: In a few instances where I know that the person won't qualify for the free legal services, meaning they're substantial wage earners and they'll be rejected, judges have allowed settlements to go through.
52:00
Unidentified speaker: What is the standard there for in terms of need-based?
52:03
Unidentified speaker: I don't know the income level, but you have to be a marginal wage earner, you know, barely making it.
52:09
Unidentified speaker: It could be in the 20,000, 30,000 range, if I'm not mistaken.
52:14
Unidentified speaker: So we had a case in the last couple of years where it was somebody who would have qualified, and the judge was insisting that she has to go through intake.
52:25
Unidentified speaker: And our attorney said to the judge, and the tenant said to the judge, we had the case settled.
52:30
Unidentified speaker: The tenant's getting a six-month payment plan.
52:34
Unidentified speaker: The tenant doesn't want to come back because if they have to come back, that's going to be two days of misswork, and that's income out of her pocket.
52:42
Unidentified speaker: And it took a lot of strenuous advocating and the tenant sticking up for herself saying, This is what I want to do, judge.
52:50
Unidentified speaker: And that judge let that settlement through without going through intake.
52:54
Unidentified speaker: Because they have to make a living themselves.
52:56
Unidentified speaker: It's odd that they would even not let them proceed with that just because it's a requirement.
53:02
Unidentified speaker: Well, you think every day a tenant who is an hourly income earner misses work that's money out of their pocket.
53:11
Unidentified speaker: You could be in housing court four, five, six, seven times.
53:16
Unidentified speaker: Can you imagine if a person misses a week's worth of work, that could be a third of their rent.
53:22
Unidentified speaker: And it harms the tenant.
53:24
Unidentified speaker: So many people, some judges included, are myopic about this.
53:30
Unidentified speaker: A rule, if it's not going to help the landlord enforce the rule, right?
53:36
Unidentified speaker: But they sometimes forget the harm that it causes the tenant or the repercussions that occur from these what have become accepted practices in housing court.
53:49
Unidentified speaker: Now I'd like to go back in history a little bit.
53:52
Unidentified speaker: I think it was 19 in the 1990s, early 1990s.
53:56
Unidentified speaker: The practice of law was a lot different, especially in the upper Manhattan.
54:02
Unidentified speaker: There were a lot of bad landlords at the time, people who forcibly harassed tenants to make them vacate, paid them money, filled their buildings.
54:13
Unidentified speaker: I wasn't at this firm at the time, and those weren't the firm's clients, nor were they clients of my first firm either.
54:20
Unidentified speaker: But they certainly made the newspaper.
54:23
Unidentified speaker: Some of those landlords were brought to the HP courtroom, which is one that deals only with housing violations issued by HPD.
54:32
Unidentified speaker: Some of those landlords went to jail.
54:35
Unidentified speaker: So during this time, the late 80s, early 90s, it was very contentious between tenant advocates, landlords, and the courts.
54:50
Unidentified speaker: There was a man who was a tenant advocate, his name was Bruce Bailey.
54:54
Unidentified speaker: I had encountered him a couple times because what he would do, he would go to buildings in Upper Manhattan, organize the tenants to tenants association to fight for rights that they weren't being given, like heat in the winter, the panes of glass were broken in the windows, so cold air was getting in, boilers were being shut off.
55:19
Unidentified speaker: So the essential requirements of water, heat, hot water, and glass in your windows were being deprived.
55:28
Unidentified speaker: So he was trying to help those tenants, and in my opinion, rightfully so.
55:33
Unidentified speaker: And he was a feature in New York housing court.
55:37
Unidentified speaker: Lovely man.
55:38
Unidentified speaker: I think he was doing good work.
55:41
Unidentified speaker: Well, one day I noticed that he wasn't around anymore.
55:45
Unidentified speaker: And as time went on, he wasn't around.
55:47
Unidentified speaker: So I asked around what happened.
55:49
Unidentified speaker: Nobody knew.
55:50
Unidentified speaker: Well, anyway, he was murdered and he was dismembered and he was placed in black trash bags throughout the city.
56:00
Unidentified speaker: So that's a type of contentiousness that occurred back then.
56:06
Unidentified speaker: We don't have any of that now.
56:08
Unidentified speaker: The contentiousness comes from the legislature and the mayor.
56:12
Unidentified speaker: So it's financial contentiousness, not physical or criminal.
56:17
Unidentified speaker: Okay.
56:18
Unidentified speaker: So I thought it would be important to talk about that, especially for some of our listeners who weren't around during those times, or maybe younger attorneys who listened to this, they're lucky that they weren't exposed to that sort of thing.
56:36
Unidentified speaker: Talking about contentiousness, I had two cases where my life was threatened by tenants or family members of tenants.
56:44
Unidentified speaker: One case was a simple case.
56:46
Unidentified speaker: It was second chair at the first room I was at.
56:49
Unidentified speaker: We won the case.
56:51
Unidentified speaker: And then the week later, this young woman who was the tenant who was subject to the judgment jumps up behind myself and my colleague at the time around us and says, I'm gonna come back here and kill you too.
57:06
Unidentified speaker: We laughed it off.
57:08
Unidentified speaker: We were both young and stupid.
57:09
Unidentified speaker: We never reported, nothing ever happened, obviously.
57:13
Unidentified speaker: Right?
57:14
Unidentified speaker: Another case I did, which was here at this firm, was one of the first cases I got.
57:20
Unidentified speaker: It was a small landlord who owned a small building in Chinatown, or on the fringe of Chinatown, and it was a non-primary residence case.
57:31
Unidentified speaker: I was able to prove that the tenant was living in Queens somewhere and not using the Chinatown apartment as her primary residence.
57:44
Unidentified speaker: I was able to prove that she used the apartment once a week to play Mahjong with her friends.
57:52
Unidentified speaker: Her son happened to be in the Chinese mafia.
57:57
Unidentified speaker: I can't mention the name.
57:59
Unidentified speaker: And this was actually an interesting case because there were three dialects of the Chinese language: Cantonese, Mandarin, and Fujinese, if I'm saying that correctly.
58:10
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, I didn't know about the third one.
58:12
Unidentified speaker: And doing a trial with one interpreter is difficult enough because you have to ask the question, the translator translates, then it has to be translated back.
58:24
Unidentified speaker: I had three different languages.
58:27
Unidentified speaker: Every question took 15, 20 minutes, and every answer took the same.
58:33
Unidentified speaker: So I win the case, and I had noticed that there was this young man sitting in the gallery watching the case.
58:40
Unidentified speaker: It turns out that was the son of the tenant.
58:44
Unidentified speaker: So I'm wrapping up my papers for the case.
58:47
Unidentified speaker: And back in those days, the judges often gave decisions from the bench.
58:51
Unidentified speaker: They would just handwrite them or give a verbal.
58:54
Unidentified speaker: I've learned subsequently it's probably not a good thing, especially if you're the recipient of the bad news.
59:00
Unidentified speaker: So the judge gave her decision, ordered that the tenant leave.
59:05
Unidentified speaker: And the son came up to me and said, basically, the minute you step out this door, there's going to be a bullet in your head.
59:13
Unidentified speaker: So I went and reported it to the judge because I took that threat seriously, told the court officers, and they basically escorted me to the front of the building, opened the door, and said, There you go.
59:26
Unidentified speaker: They escorted out of the building.
59:28
Unidentified speaker: You don't need the help inside the building.
59:31
Unidentified speaker: I asked to be escorted at least to the subway, just you know.
59:34
Unidentified speaker: You took the subway afterwards.
59:36
Unidentified speaker: Well, and I happened to survive that one too, obviously.
59:40
Unidentified speaker: But those are that those are the type of contentious things that happened back there in the last 15 years, and I have experienced nothing compared to that.
59:51
Unidentified speaker: That's good.
59:51
Unidentified speaker: People have yelled at me, people's tempers have flared, but no death threats or anything like that.
59:57
Unidentified speaker: I think housing is putting some of the commercial stuff aside, it's important too.
1:00:01
Unidentified speaker: But the housing in general, it's a personal, it's you're saying it's not criminal.
1:00:05
Unidentified speaker: Criminal is very personal.
1:00:06
Unidentified speaker: Housing is also personal.
1:00:08
Unidentified speaker: It's something that's a real need.
1:00:09
Unidentified speaker: You taking it away from someone is a big deal.
1:00:12
Unidentified speaker: It's food and shelter, right?
1:00:14
Unidentified speaker: Those are the some of the main things.
1:00:15
Unidentified speaker: And I think that turns me to my next and probably final question I have, which is in terms of this not-for-profit, which I think, and I don't know too much about it, but it it's helping um tenants.
1:00:28
Unidentified speaker: So the name of the company is Housing and Services Inc.
1:00:32
Unidentified speaker: They provide not just affordable housing, but supportive housing.
1:00:38
Unidentified speaker: So you may say, what is supportive housing?
1:00:40
Unidentified speaker: It's not just the shelter, social services, mental health, job placement, career training.
1:00:47
Unidentified speaker: The goal is to get people who have been on the streets or coming from the shelter system back into society, functioning people.
1:00:58
Unidentified speaker: The organization is run primarily by two amazing people, James Dill and Molly Mattimore.
1:01:04
Unidentified speaker: They're so devoted to providing the supportive housing and they dedicated their careers.
1:01:09
Unidentified speaker: They do incredible work.
1:01:11
Unidentified speaker: The way I got involved was through a friend of mine in a networking group who thought I could contribute to this organization.
1:01:20
Unidentified speaker: When she asked me, I just said, sure, count me in.
1:01:23
Unidentified speaker: It's about 10 years now since I volunteer my time.
1:01:27
Unidentified speaker: And the board, who consists of volunteers, professionals in the law, architect, real estate, you name it, who want to help society volunteer their time, and we offer our expertise in certain areas.
1:01:43
Unidentified speaker: And that's the long and the short of it.
1:01:45
Unidentified speaker: Now, this is not the only not-for-profit who provides housing to the formerly homeless.
1:01:51
Unidentified speaker: There's many companies that do that throughout the city.
1:01:53
Unidentified speaker: We're not the biggest one.
1:01:56
Unidentified speaker: It's incredible what they do and how many thousands of New Yorkers make use of these services.
1:02:04
Unidentified speaker: So if we have a few more minutes, there's a couple things I'd like to talk about.
1:02:08
Unidentified speaker: So you talked about eviction and being a devastating thing.
1:02:12
Unidentified speaker: It's not just devastating, it's life-changing.
1:02:14
Unidentified speaker: There's studies done, and there's this very informative book called Eviction.
1:02:20
Unidentified speaker: It's what it's called, eviction.
1:02:22
Unidentified speaker: Yeah, I've heard of it.
1:02:23
Unidentified speaker: And I I believe, if I'm not mistaken, it talks about the eviction process and its effects in Michi.
1:02:29
Unidentified speaker: I think it was Michigan, if I'm not mistaken, or maybe Chicago.
1:02:32
Unidentified speaker: I forget, somewhere in the Midwest.
1:02:34
Unidentified speaker: And you talk about cycles.
1:02:37
Unidentified speaker: So I think everybody can agree, whether it's the tenant side, the judiciary side, the legislature side, or the owner side, that eviction is a horrific life event, no doubt.
1:02:53
Unidentified speaker: So when judges think that we, the landlord's uh attorneys, are coming to court to displace somebody, I want to say if any judge is listening to this, you're 100% wrong.
1:03:06
Unidentified speaker: Our mission is not to displace people from the homes.
1:03:09
Unidentified speaker: We understand as human beings, as ethical attorneys, that throwing somebody out of the home because of their fault not being able to pay the rent, or not their fault, life circumstances.
1:03:24
Unidentified speaker: That's not the goal.
1:03:25
Unidentified speaker: The goal of property owners is to collect rent.
1:03:28
Unidentified speaker: That's their business.
1:03:30
Unidentified speaker: When they collect rent, they're making money, or at least not losing money.
1:03:37
Unidentified speaker: So please realize that when we come to court and advocate for a settlement or to get paid or to get reimbursed for attorney's fees, the goal is not to throw somebody out of their home.
1:03:52
Unidentified speaker: That's not it.
1:03:54
Unidentified speaker: We do with a lot of HPD programs and affordable housing, affordable tenants.
1:03:59
Unidentified speaker: And you mentioned some of the tenants that you had situations with the non-rent payment, they were low-income tenants.
1:04:06
Unidentified speaker: Have you ever had to deal with a tenant that fell within the HPD affordable tenant pool and you had to deal with a regulatory agreement or a restrictive declaration while dealing with the non-rent payment or an eviction payment?
1:04:22
Unidentified speaker: So the answer is yes.
1:04:23
Unidentified speaker: We have many clients who participate in those programs.
1:04:27
Unidentified speaker: For example, it depends on the financing of the building.
1:04:30
Unidentified speaker: If it's under one of the 421A programs, there's a regulatory agreement, as you probably know, Camilla, right?
1:04:36
Unidentified speaker: But the landlord tenant procedure is the same for them as a non-covered person.
1:04:43
Unidentified speaker: There may be certain notice requirements that are required.
1:04:46
Unidentified speaker: For example, if it's a tenant who's subject to city NYCHA, we might have to ask for permission to sue for nonpayment to rent.
1:04:55
Unidentified speaker: Or if it's an HPD-governed housing, we might have to notify HPD that we're terminating the tenancy.
1:05:04
Unidentified speaker: But the procedures under the RPAPL remain the same with notice provisions.
1:05:09
Unidentified speaker: And we get to ask that very, very often.
1:05:12
Unidentified speaker: Well, they're affordable.
1:05:13
Unidentified speaker: Can we uh if they're not paying rent, the procedure is pretty much like you said, the the same, and people do can confuse about that, which is why I think Camilla's question was good.
1:05:23
Unidentified speaker: There's no sort of added layers.
1:05:25
Unidentified speaker: It's more just like you you you go with it the tenant just like you would with any other, but there are some there could be some layers of extra notice or whatnot, depending on what program they're participating in.
1:05:36
Unidentified speaker: So if you think about it, let's say you have one of these covered low-income, low-rent tenants.
1:05:43
Unidentified speaker: The lion's share of the rent comes from HPD or the Section 8, the federal government.
1:05:48
Unidentified speaker: The tenant share is usually a small portion of that.
1:05:52
Unidentified speaker: I have a few of these now.
1:05:53
Unidentified speaker: The rent is, let's say, $3,800 a month.
1:05:57
Unidentified speaker: Most of that money comes from Section 8.
1:06:00
Unidentified speaker: The tenant share may be $100 or $200 a month.
1:06:03
Unidentified speaker: Section 8 continues to pay, the tenant stops paying.
1:06:06
Unidentified speaker: So the question isn't really, can I go to court to enforce the landlord's rights?
1:06:13
Unidentified speaker: The question is, does it make economic sense to?
1:06:16
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
1:06:17
Unidentified speaker: So if a tenant owes, let's say, $100 a month for three months, are you going to start a case for $300?
1:06:23
Unidentified speaker: Yeah.
1:06:24
Unidentified speaker: Um it also raises the question if I don't go to court for the $300, what message am I sending?
1:06:31
Unidentified speaker: Am I in violation of the regulatory agreement?
1:06:34
Unidentified speaker: Am I in violation of my mortgage for not collecting the rent?
1:06:38
Unidentified speaker: So most of our clients do bring the cases in court and spend the money because they have to.
1:06:45
Unidentified speaker: But then remember, this process, this year-long process, it's probably double the length of time for a tenant who's in one of these affordable programs because the judges know, and we know, and the clients know, that they will be evicted because they don't have the hundred or two hundred or four hundred dollars.
1:07:04
Unidentified speaker: What they do with their money, nobody knows.
1:07:07
Unidentified speaker: We can't inquire about what a tenant does with the money they have, but there's a reason why they're not paying their share of the rent.
1:07:16
Unidentified speaker: And this sort of goes back to if you remember the case I told you about with the $20,000 and the lawyer ex-judge who represented.
1:07:25
Unidentified speaker: I told that client early on in the case, once that lawyer came, I said, your legal fees will be magnified.
1:07:33
Unidentified speaker: It pays for you to let that rent free for the rest of her life.
1:07:37
Unidentified speaker: I said, You're gonna spend multiples in legal fees because I know who that lawyer is.
1:07:43
Unidentified speaker: And at the end of the case, the client said to me, I can't believe you let me do this.
1:07:48
Unidentified speaker: Hopefully you sent a letter explaining it again.
1:07:51
Unidentified speaker: I said I reminded the client that those reminders are hard because they remember it differently, and uh you're just trying to explain to them that you had given them that information and they just didn't.
1:07:59
Unidentified speaker: Well, but remember ten years later, we collected the money.
1:08:02
Unidentified speaker: I made the call and I said, Got the money for you.
1:08:06
Unidentified speaker: I guess the last thing I want to talk about is I came to the firm in 1992, and at that time there were four founding partners.
1:08:13
Unidentified speaker: Now we have three: Sherwin Belkin, Jeff Goldman, and Joe Burden passed away a few years ago.
1:08:20
Unidentified speaker: So Sherwin and Jeff are the two remaining founding partners.
1:08:24
Unidentified speaker: Jeff co-manages a firm with Dan Altman.
1:08:28
Unidentified speaker: And over the 37, 34 and a half years I've been here, I've been lucky enough to work with these colleagues.
1:08:37
Unidentified speaker: They're incredible attorneys, they're dedicated to the legal profession.
1:08:42
Unidentified speaker: Being at this firm for this amount of time, I could never have envisioned.
1:08:46
Unidentified speaker: In fact, I told Jeff in passing, sometime this year, that I gave myself five years to be here, and then I was going back into construction and wrestling.
1:08:57
Unidentified speaker: Because of their stewardship, I decided to stay.
1:09:00
Unidentified speaker: I realized when you surround yourself with talented, smart people who have a vision, you're in good hands.
1:09:08
Unidentified speaker: Being a lawyer and being at this firm has opened up incredible opportunities for me, not just in the profession.
1:09:17
Unidentified speaker: I was a campaign manager for a judicial candidate about 16 years ago.
1:09:22
Unidentified speaker: She won the election.
1:09:23
Unidentified speaker: I got to see the election process work on the ground.
1:09:26
Unidentified speaker: Just like I'm in housing court, dealt with politicians.
1:09:29
Unidentified speaker: I dealt with all the Democratic clubs throughout the city.
1:09:33
Unidentified speaker: I met tons of judges that were involved in the process or who were trying to get elected.
1:09:39
Unidentified speaker: I've had entree into certain areas of real estate, of business.
1:09:44
Unidentified speaker: So coming full circle, it's been a pleasure being here 34 years.
1:09:49
Unidentified speaker: I envision myself being here well into my 90s.
1:09:54
Unidentified speaker: You said an extra loud.
1:09:56
Unidentified speaker: Just for your sake, I hope I hope not.
1:09:59
Unidentified speaker: So anyway, kudos to Sherwin, Jeff, and Joe, rest your soul, and Joe Burden.
1:10:06
Unidentified speaker: We appreciate all the knowledge and all the wisdom that you've implored on us.
1:10:09
Unidentified speaker: Well, thank you, David and Camilla.
1:10:11
Unidentified speaker: And for any people who are listening in the audience, it's been a pleasure and hopefully come out of this with something useful.
1:10:17
Unidentified speaker: Yep.
1:10:17
Unidentified speaker: You should check out Site Page, and you can certainly contact him if you have any questions or you'll have a case or wanted to ask him about landlord tenant law or something like that.
1:10:25
Unidentified speaker: But no complaints.
1:10:26
Unidentified speaker: Thank you very much, Martin.
1:10:28
Unidentified speaker: Appreciate it.
1:10:28
Unidentified speaker: Thank you.
1:10:29
Unidentified speaker: Thanks for listening to Ground Rules.
1:10:31
Unidentified speaker: To make sure you stay in the loop on all new episodes, please make sure to subscribe wherever you get your podcasts.
1:10:36
Unidentified speaker: For more on the show and BBG, make sure to visit BBGLLP.com.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-GGUF:UD-Q4_K_XL. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights