Defaqto's Fraser Donaldson discusses MPS market growth drivers and upcoming FCA review implications for advisers.
Summary
Fraser Donaldson of Defaqto joins the IFA Talk podcast to discuss the Managed Portfolio Services (MPS) market, citing regulatory catalysts like RDR and MiFID II as key growth drivers. He notes the market has reached approximately £250 billion on platforms, nearing the size of multi-asset funds. Donaldson outlines the FCA's upcoming review, which will scrutinize fair value assessments, performance benchmarking, and AI usage. He advises advisers to enhance due diligence by demanding greater transparency on fees and conflicts of interest. Finally, he highlights Defaqto's launch of new MPS-specific benchmarks to enable more accurate performance comparisons.
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 2:15
Introduction and Guest Background
Meg Bratley and Jenny Hunter introduce the episode topic: the Managed Portfolio Services (MPS) market and the FCA review. Fraser Donaldson, an investment consultant at Defaqto, joins to discuss findings from the MPS Insights report. Donaldson notes his 40-year industry tenure and specialization in discretionary management since around 2010.
- 2:15 – 6:27
Drivers of MPS Growth
Donaldson attributes MPS growth to regulatory nudges like the Retail Distribution Review (RDR), which encouraged outsourcing of portfolio management. He cites the 2012 FSA Assessing Suitability paper, Pension Freedoms (2015), MiFID II (2015), and Consumer Duty as key catalysts that increased transparency and cost awareness.
- 6:27 – 8:45
Market Size and FCA Review Context
Donaldson estimates MPS investment on platforms at around £250 billion, compared to £375 billion for multi-asset funds, noting MPS started from near zero in the early 2000s. He explains the FCA review is timely due to the market's rapid expansion, the influx of new firms, and the need to ensure Consumer Duty is applied correctly.
- 8:45 – 11:21
FCA Review Focus Areas and Fair Value Assessments
The FCA sent a 32-question questionnaire to discretionary firms in March. Key review areas include portfolio construction, risk management, conflicts of interest, and costs. Donaldson highlights recent FCA criticism of fair value assessments for lacking evidence and relying on assumptions, suggesting this will be a focus of the review.
- 11:21 – 14:52
Performance Benchmarking Challenges
The FCA questionnaire asks how firms assess performance and select benchmarks. Donaldson notes that Defaqto previously used proxy indices (like IA sectors) but launched five new benchmarks in 2020 based on actual MPS portfolio performance to allow 'like-for-like' comparisons across defensive, cautious, and active styles.
- 14:52 – 17:17
Advisor Due Diligence and Transparency
Donaldson advises advisors to incorporate FCA review outcomes into their due diligence processes, particularly regarding disclosure and transparency. He criticizes fact sheets that require clients to call for more information, advocating for readily available data on fees, internal fund usage, and conflicts of interest.
- 17:17 – 19:16
AI and Future Trends
The FCA questionnaire includes questions about the use of AI in research, construction, and monitoring of MPS. Donaldson speculates that AI adoption may be driven by efficiency gains that could lead to reduced costs for clients, though he awaits the final review findings.
Claims worth verifying
Fraser Donaldson has been in the industry for 40 years and has specialized in discretionary management since around 2010.
Fraser Donaldson ·1:23
How to verify: Check Fraser Donaldson's LinkedIn profile or Defaqto staff biography for employment history and tenure dates. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Retail Distribution Review (RDR) created a regulatory hint towards outsourcing portfolio management to discretionary managers.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·2:47
How to verify: Review the FCA's final guidance on the Retail Distribution Review (2026-2026) for statements on advisor roles and product distribution. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The FSA published an 'Assessing Suitability' paper in 2012 that mentioned MPS and bespoke management.
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·4:54
How to verify: Search the FCA historical archive or FSA publications for the 2026 'Assessing Suitability' guidance document. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
MiFID II came into effect in 2015, changing fee disclosure from headline fees to actual costs.
Fraser Donaldson ·5:34
How to verify: Verify the implementation date of MiFID II (January 3, 2018) and its cost transparency requirements via the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) or FCA website; note the speaker may be conflating MiFID II with earlier cost transparency initiatives or national implementations. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
MPS investment on platforms is estimated at around £250 billion.
Fraser Donaldson ·6:14
How to verify: Check the 'MPS Insights Report' published by IFA Magazine and WealthDFM for the specific data source and methodology behind this estimate. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Multi-asset funds have approximately £375 billion in investment.
Fraser Donaldson ·6:14
How to verify: Cross-reference with industry data from the Investment Association (IA) or Defaqto's multi-asset fund data reports. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The FCA sent a 32-question questionnaire to discretionary firms in March regarding the MPS review.
Fraser Donaldson ·8:58
How to verify: Search the FCA website for 'MPS review' or 'discretionary portfolio management' consultation documents or letters sent to firms in March of the relevant year. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceAlison and Walters published fair value assessment examples on November 2nd criticizing lack of evidence.
Fraser Donaldson ·9:59
How to verify: Search the FCA website for press releases or articles published on November 2nd, 2026 (or the relevant year) mentioning 'Alison and Walters' and 'fair value assessments'. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Defaqto launched five benchmarks calculated using actual MPS performance, covering defensive, cautious, and active styles.
Fraser Donaldson ·13:33
How to verify: Visit the Defaqto website and search for 'MPS benchmarks' or 'managed portfolio services benchmarks' to confirm the launch and composition of these indices. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Defaqto has been collecting and publishing MPS performance data for approximately ten years.
Fraser Donaldson ·11:58
How to verify: Review Defaqto's historical data releases or press announcements regarding the launch of their MPS performance data service. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Review the FCA's 32-question questionnaire sent to discretionary firms in March to understand specific review criteria.
- Check Defaqto's MPS Insights report for detailed market size data and growth trends.
- Verify the methodology behind Defaqto's five new MPS benchmarks launched in 2020 to ensure they reflect actual portfolio performance.
- Assess current fair value assessments for evidence quality and assumption transparency, noting FCA criticism of excessive assumptions.
- Evaluate advisor due diligence processes for gaps in disclosure regarding fees, internal fund usage, and conflicts of interest.
- Investigate how AI is currently being used in MPS research, construction, and monitoring within your firm.
- Compare MPS costs against multi-asset funds using actual cost data rather than headline fees, per MiFID II requirements.
- Review the 2012 FSA 'Assessing Suitability' paper and 2015 MiFID II implementation details for historical context on market shifts.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You're
0:01Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): listening to IFA Talk, IFA Magazine's weekly podcast. IFA Talk is for financial professionals only. Thank
0:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you.
0:08Meg Bratley: Thanks for joining us for another episode of IFA Talk, the weekly podcast for financial advisors, brought to you by IFA Magazine. I'm Meg Bratley, social media and content editor here at IFA Magazine. And joining me on the podcast this week is our Deputy Editor, Jenny Hunter.
0:24Jenny Hunter: Yes, thank you, Meg, and welcome everyone. Thank you. so much for tuning in to another episode of IFA Talk. This week we're looking at Managed Portfolio Services Market, or better known as MPS, which is also the focus of our recently published annual MPS Insights Report from IFA magazine and Wealth DFM. So the publication kicks off with an analysis of the latest MPS market trends, which was written by Fraser Donaldson, an investment. consultant at de facto. So you won't be surprised to hear that today we've invited Fraser onto the podcast to talk us through some of those findings. We'll be taking a look at what's driving the market's pretty dramatic growth in recent years, especially amongst advisors, and also to discuss the FCA's forthcoming MPS review, which will also be no surprise to hear that we're still waiting on. So, Fraser, welcome to IFA Talk. Thanks so much for all your input into our MPS Insights publication and for joining us today. To get us started, could you tell us a little bit about you and your role at de facto?
1:23Fraser Donaldson: Uh yes, of course. Thanks, Jenny. I am an insight consultant at de facto. In terms of background, I've been around for in the industry for 40 years, I suppose. Plus,
1:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
1:38Fraser Donaldson: more important importantly, I've been looking at and specialising in discretionary management probably since around 2010. And the team that looks after this area is pretty much still intact from that, from that time, which is which is really important in terms of establishing uh good relationships with the discretionary managers and advisors for that matter. So, yes, still working on the MPS.
2:06Jenny Hunter: Perfect. 40 years. Congratulations. That is a long time to be in the NPS.
2:10Fraser Donaldson: Is congratulations the right word? Oh,
2:12Jenny Hunter: yeah, I'm not sure actually. Let's think of another word.
2:15Meg Bratley: Welcome, Fraser, and thanks again for taking the time to join us today. So let's kick things off with our first question. We've obviously seen the MPS market take over over the last half. a dozen years or so, especially within advisors. Why do you think that is?
2:31Fraser Donaldson: That's a big question. I've already mentioned I've been working in this particular area since about 2010 looking at discretionary management. This was kind of in the early days, the discussion periods around the retail distribution review.
2:47Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
2:48Fraser Donaldson: it was pretty clear from that that. one of the things the regulators wanted people to do or wanted advisors to do was not to manage individual client portfolios,
2:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh,
3:00Fraser Donaldson: but to get on with financial planning and that side of things. So there was uh a very big hint of an outsourcing theme coming. There were already multi-asset Multi asset funds, they've been established for probably a couple of decades by then. But we saw we saw that managed portfolio services and the wider discretionary industry, there was a good chance that that might well take off. So we started doing what we do, collecting data. When we started, there was it's clear there were some hurdles we had to overcome. For instance, when we questioned discretionary managers, they were genuinely surprised. that we were asking for the costs. They couldn't understand why anyone would want to know what the costs were. Equally, they were surprised we were looking for performance. Pretty standard evidence required when you're recommending an investment. They're surprised about that. There was no real broker support in place. Probably worse still, they were mortified at the thought of giving their assets. under administration to platforms, and it was pretty clear by then that platforms is where advisors do business. From the advisor side, there was some nervousness about discretionary managers poaching clients. It's a bit of a red herring, that one, in fairness,
4:19because if one firm did it once or twice, they'd be kind of blacklisted, were guess gets around. But nonetheless, there were hurdles to overcome. But we stuck with it, the discretionary managers stuck with it, and every few years there have been big and small catalysts that have helped grow the market. The first one is basically time. Companies like us put the names out there, and it's a case of getting to know the market. There was such a lot of companies you you've probably never heard. of. So you need to get used to that.
4:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): There
4:54Fraser Donaldson: was an assessing suitability paper from the then FSA in 2012, which is is a bit nerdy, but it's my favorite regulatory paper. Everyone read it. That was in 2012, and it actually mentioned MPS and bespoke as part of a kind of plan, depending on how much you've got to invest. Pension Freedoms 2015 widened the market considerably. MiFID 2 costs over probably um originated in Europe, but thank God for that. That came in 2015. So you could actually judge how much something cost rather than the fees that are, you know, the headline fees, which bear no resemblance whatsoever to what things actually cost. Then you had assessment of value in 2018. And of course, most recently you've got the consumer duty as well. So every element of that over the years is a little nudge to advisors, adding to the transparency, a little
5:54focus on costs. Somewhere down the line, it's become well established as a kind of viable alternative to multi-asseth. multi-asset funds, to the point where now we're seeing about or an estimate of around 250 billion in MPS investment on platforms, and an estimate of the multi-asset funds, which if you remember has been around for decades longer, is about 375 five billion. So sort of 6040 sixty forty in favour of funds. But really impressive. considering that multi asset funds have been established for decades and MPS portfolio started pretty much from zero in the early noughties. So that's a snapshot of things that have happened over the last ten, fifteen years and why it has grown. Obviously it's grown considerably over the last half.
6:48Jenny Hunter: That sounds really dramatic in terms of growth. I don't think anybody has ever admitted to having a favourite regulatory paper before. So that I think is
6:57Fraser Donaldson: compulsory reading. It's brilliant.
6:59Jenny Hunter: You um you mentioned some pretty strong regulation, obviously, um uh a minute ago, in particular fair value assessment and obviously the consumer duty. So we know there is an FCA MPS review coming soon. Why do you think it is an And what do you think the key elements of the review will contain?
7:18Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
7:18Fraser Donaldson: first of all, kind of why now, I suppose. Kind of obvious it really. It's all of a sudden, over the last half a dozen years, as you've mentioned, there's a big market, 250 billion plus. It's particularly taken off over the last five or six years. There's been an avalanche of portfolio launches over the last ten years. 10 Loads of new firms entering the market.
7:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
7:43Fraser Donaldson: lots of those expanding from the private client end of the market.
7:48Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh,
7:48Fraser Donaldson: lots of unfamiliar names. So so I guess it it's kind of about time that the FCA get a granular understanding of the way the market operates. Multi-asset Multi asset funds, for instance, are kind of legal entities. with very strict rules. Discretionary portfolios are not quite as solid in terms of the rules, so that there was regulation required to tighten things up, and the more things are tightened up, the more the advisor market trusts it, the more transparent it becomes, and so on. The review itself is really kind of taking. stock, I think, where we are now. In particular, it's to ensure that the regulation and guidance they have put in place over recent years, in particular consumer duty, is being followed correctly and applied properly. So that's that's why. Had What will the key elements be? Well, we've had we've had a a pretty big clue in as much as the they sent out a questionnaire to discretionary firms back in March with a lot of questions, 32 of
8:57Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): them,
8:58Fraser Donaldson: and supplementaries. They got, you know, 32 A, B, and C, that kind of thing. Uh, and they suggested in particular the review will cover portfolio construction, adherence to mandate, risk management and oversight, identification. management of conflicts of interest, cost and charges. In other words, pretty much everything to assess how firms apply the consumer duty, how they're operating, and what they're going to be doing going forward. I think it's going to be a really important paper.
9:34Jenny Hunter: Sounds
9:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): like
9:35Jenny Hunter: 32
9:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): questions. Yeah,
9:36Fraser Donaldson: it's gonna be
9:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): quite
9:37Jenny Hunter: 32 questions, haven't they?
9:39Fraser Donaldson: Yeah. And uh uh uh we already know that the FCI FCA are a little bit unhappy with what with the application of one or two bits of their guidance. Um for instance, we've had Alison And Walters on the 2nd of November, which as we're recording is yesterday, publish publishing the fact that they're not happy with some of the fair value assessments. There isn't much evidence in them as to why they've come to whatever conclusion they've come to. There's a lot of assumptions. This is across the board. This is not just MPS, this is all fair value assessments, but it still applies.
10:23Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
10:23Fraser Donaldson: And this this is something
10:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that
10:26Fraser Donaldson: we're we had de facto had noticed some years ago, because when they started as data collectors, we looked at some of them and thought, well, there's actually nothing in them. There's no um, for instance, cost data comparing to performance, and that's kind of what they're all about is about whether clients are getting what they pay for. So that I would have expected. to come into the MPS review. So whether they're particularly irked at what the fair value assessments are giving and felt they needed to get this out there quickly, I'm not sure. I I suspect it'll become part of the review anyway.
11:06Meg Bratley: And thanks Fraser. And it does sound as though there are quite a few areas for firms to consider as the review does progress. So moving on now. from your perspective, what does stand out to you that we should be looking out for the most in this review?
11:21Fraser Donaldson: Well, as I said, it it covers so much, but as data collectors or data providers to the industry, there are certain areas that kind of um do stand out. In particular, we mentioned the fair value assessments, that would have been one. And it's been
11:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): useful.
11:38Fraser Donaldson: usurped by uh the publication yesterday. Some examples. There are a number of questions on performance and benchmarks. One of the questions: how does the firm assess performance of its MPS? That's only a bit of the question. Um, but we've a d de facto we've been collecting and publishing performance of actual MPS portfolios for pretty much ten years now. Um but they're they're probably talking about whether there's any synthetic performance in there, whether it's on a gross or a net basis, that kind of thing. They ask what time horizons are considered, if benchmarks are considered, if the firm assesses the model portfolio performance or the underlying client portfolio performance and so on. and so forth. The next question says: Does the firm compare performance of MPS to one or more benchmarks or indices? You start to wonder why they've asked that, because on all fact sheets you'll see a graph and it will have an it'll have the portfolio and it'll have a benchmark of some description. And it goes on to ask how they select those benchmarks or indices to use. for an MPS.
12:53Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Now,
12:53Fraser Donaldson: this is uh quite interesting to us because this is a question we asked ourselves probably five years ago, and we noted that when we were doing comparative performance, we were probably using proxy indices, things like the IA sectors, maybe the ARC aren't private client. sectors, uh that kind of thing. And it kind of struck to struck us with consumer duty that it probably wasn't quite good enough. And of course we've been collecting and calculating performance quite a number of years. So what we did is we uh we worked on and launched Launch some benchmarks which were calculated using actual MPS performance. There are five five benchmarks and sub-benchmarks, um as you would expect, defensive, cautious, active, and each one of those contains performance of sort of 400 odd portfolios. And what it means is you can actually compare like with like. So it's MPS NPS portfolio, portfolio um averages. averages with whatever MPS portfolio you want to look at.
14:07And that goes for the costs as well. This is all based on risk adjusted returns.
14:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): But
14:14Fraser Donaldson: it's really important, I think, that the performance side of things is right. And comparing like for like is a pretty good way of starting.
14:25Jenny Hunter: Yeah. No, that's that's really insightful. Thank you for sharing those with us. Um obviously we our our listeners um may or may not have have seen that, so that's that does give good context.
14:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You're
14:37Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): tuned in to IFA Talk, IFA magazine's weekly podcast. Subscribe to us on Spotify and Apple Podcasts to make sure you never miss a new episode. And follow us over on X and LinkedIn for regular content from the world of financial services.
14:52Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
14:52Jenny Hunter: FCA's review is clearly primarily aimed at discretionary managers. So is there a reason why do you think that advisors should be equally as interested in the outcome of the review as the discretionary managers?
15:05Fraser Donaldson: It's it's um interesting. The the discretionary managers have obviously got to up their game in terms of disclosure. transparency, and certain pieces of information. It follows that a lot of this information ought to be looked at by advisors as part of their due diligence. They might not know what they don't know at the moment, but it should should become part of their uh part of their due diligence process. because the DFMs are being asked to disclose a lot more about their offerings and how they work. Um and it it simply means that advisors ought to be autofactoring this in their due diligence. Not all of it, but uh quite a lot of it. And there is quite a bit about disclosure and transparency in the questions sent, which we find which we find particularly important. If you want to find out something, it should be easy to find it out. Um, for instance, yeah, simple thing like fact sheets. Um, we all we all know fact sheets, whether it's funds or portfolios, and there is nothing worse than going onto a website and say and finding a message saying, please ring us for more
16:23information. No one's got time for that. And
16:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
16:26Fraser Donaldson: know you've you're probably gonna get sold too.
16:30Jenny Hunter: Even
16:31Fraser Donaldson: just subtly. And the and in this questionnaire they ask what links there are that DFMs can provide where consumers can see more information, which is great. So so hopefully something will come out of that. Uh other little bits, some portfolios as we know include their own internal funds or other funds in the group, or you know, completely fettered uh all their own internal funds. And it's important that this is disclosed fairly obviously somewhere within any literature that the client gets and or advisor gets if they're
17:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
17:13Fraser Donaldson: working on behalf of the client. And w one of the one of the questions in there revolves around AI, artificial intelligence. And I've been I've been having quite good fun as to working out why they've asked the question. Obviously if a firm uses AI in you know in the they specify research, construction and monitoring of its MPSs, ask what tools it use. and it it's it's as I said, it's a little bit difficult to speculate on what's behind the question. I'd like to think that because AI is generally a tool that makes things more efficient and speeds up certain tasks, it is potentially a pointer to another reason to reducing costs.
18:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): We'll
18:00Fraser Donaldson: wait and see what the review says on that one.
18:03Jenny Hunter: Sadly, that's all we've got time for today, Fraser. But um thank you so much for joining us and sharing your insights and experience all 40 years of it. And of course for supporting our annual MPS Insights publication. And we'll be interested to see what happens when the review comes out.
18:21Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Be
18:22Meg Bratley: sure to follow or subscribe to IFE IFA Talk wherever you get your podcasts so you never miss an episode. You can find us on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and Amazon as well as in the podcast section on our website. If you haven't done it already, please go download your copy of the MPS Insights report, including the full version of all of Fraser's analysis. We hope you'll join us again next week for another great conversation here on IFA Talk. Thanks for listening.
18:48Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): IFA Talk is for financial professionals only. All material has been carefully checked for accuracy, but no responsibility can be accepted for inaccuracies. Wherever appropriate, independent research and whatever necessary legal advice should be sought before acting on any information contained in this podcast. The value of investments and income goes go down as well as up, so you may not get back the amount you originally invested.