Wharton and Stanford professors defend business schools against claims they erode idealism and harm wages.
Summary
Jules Van Binsbergen and Jonathan Burke respond to a New York Times op-ed by Chris Marquis that argues for abolishing business schools. The hosts refute claims that MBA-led firms cut wages to boost profits, arguing instead that such decisions reflect efficient resource allocation in competitive markets. They challenge the notion that business schools lack a public good foundation, noting that pharmaceutical R&D relies on similar profit-driven structures. The speakers also criticize the teaching of stakeholder capitalism as a win-win scenario, emphasizing that trade-offs are inevitable and often ignored in favor of political compromise.
Key takeaways
- 1 Van Binsbergen identifies survivorship bias in case studies, where students learn from success stories without distinguishing between luck and decision-making quality.
Jules Van Binsbergen · 10:43
- 2 Van Binsbergen argues that stakeholder capitalism is often presented disingenuously as a win-win, ignoring the fundamental economic reality that trade-offs always exist.
Jules Van Binsbergen · 16:05
Episode sections
- 0:05 – 0:31
Introduction and Hosts
Jules Van Binsbergen and Jonathan Burke introduce themselves as finance professors at UPenn Wharton and Stanford GSB, respectively, and welcome listeners to the All Else Equal podcast.
- 0:31 – 2:16
Critique of Marquis Op-Ed: Erosion of Idealism and Wage Share
The hosts introduce a New York Times op-ed by Chris Marquis arguing for abolishing business schools. They discuss the claim that business schools turn idealistic students into transactional consultants/finance workers and that MBA-led firms cut wages to boost profits.
- 2:16 – 5:12
Efficiency, Profit, and Systemic Critique
Burke argues that replacing labor with lower-cost providers is efficient and moral in a competitive system. Van Binsbergen adds that maximizing labor share is irrelevant; the goal is efficient resource allocation. Burke contrasts capitalism with communism, arguing the latter failed due to lack of productivity incentives.
- 5:12 – 10:03
Public Good Foundation and R&D
The hosts refute the claim that business schools lack a public good foundation compared to medicine or law. Van Binsbergen notes that pharmaceutical R&D relies on profitable, managed organizations. Burke points out that the US pays for most medical R&D via the profit-maximizing system, leading to high drug prices.
- 10:03 – 15:01
Case Method and Survivorship Bias
The hosts agree that case studies often suffer from survivorship bias, focusing only on successful leaders and ignoring failures. Burke argues cases are useful as examples but must be paired with generalizable theory and data. Van Binsbergen notes he rarely uses cases in finance, preferring logical frameworks.
- 15:01 – 20:42
Stakeholder Capitalism vs. Trade-offs
The hosts criticize the presentation of stakeholder capitalism as a win-win, arguing it ignores necessary trade-offs. Burke claims business schools are politicized for failing to teach that maximizing profits is the limit of efficiency unless trade-offs are explicitly acknowledged. Van Binsbergen agrees that treating stakeholder concerns as a 'veneer' is disingenuous.
- 20:42 – 25:34
Corporatization of Universities
The hosts reject the claim that business schools caused university corporatization. Burke argues universities charge high tuition and should be transparent about economic value. Van Binsbergen notes that universities without business schools (e.g., some in the US) operate similarly, suggesting no causal link.
- 25:34 – 32:13
Faculty Incentives and Tenure
The hosts dispute the claim that faculty are rewarded for 'big ideas' rather than rigor. Van Binsbergen states tenure is based almost exclusively on published research. Burke agrees, noting the opposite problem: lack of reward for practical influence, though he suggests this should change.
Claims worth verifying
The op-ed 'I Teach at a Business School. It’s Time to Shut Them Down.' was written by Chris Marquis and published in The New York Times.
Jules Van Binsbergen ·0:31
How to verify: Search The New York Times archives for the article title and author Chris Marquis. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Daron Acemoglu claims that when business degree majors become CEOs, the wage share of the firm is cut.
Jules Van Binsbergen ·1:49
How to verify: Check Daron Acemoglu's published works or interviews for this specific claim regarding wage share and CEO backgrounds. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Communism was a system where wages were not related to productivity, resulting in an economy where nobody had anything.
Jonathan Burke ·4:31
How to verify: Review historical economic data and literature on communist planned economies (e.g., USSR) regarding wage determination and output levels. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Most R&D in medicine occurs in the United States because the US pays for most medical R&D in the world.
Jonathan Burke ·6:28
How to verify: Check OECD or NIH data on national R&D spending in pharmaceuticals and medical devices. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Jules Van Binsbergen started teaching in 2008.
Jules Van Binsbergen ·13:35
How to verify: Check Jules Van Binsbergen's CV or UPenn Wharton faculty profile for employment start date. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The University of Austin is an example of a new university created to reform higher education.
Jonathan Burke ·28:19
How to verify: Check the University of Austin's website or press releases regarding its founding and mission. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Tenure at Stanford GSB is based almost exclusively on published research, not practical influence.
Jonathan Burke ·26:20
How to verify: Review Stanford GSB faculty tenure and promotion guidelines. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The Lauder Institute at UPenn integrates international relations, geopolitics, and geoeconomics into the MBA curriculum.
Jules Van Binsbergen ·29:59
How to verify: Check the Lauder Institute curriculum or program description. For recent events, verify 2026-08-19 through 2026-11-19. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Read the original New York Times op-ed by Chris Marquis to understand the specific criticisms being rebutted.
- Review Wharton and Stanford GSB faculty publications on labor economics to verify claims about wage share efficiency.
- Analyze pharmaceutical R&D funding sources to assess the claim that profit-driven models are essential for medical innovation.
- Examine case study curricula at top business schools to identify potential survivorship bias in teaching materials.
- Compare tuition costs and revenue models of universities with and without business schools to test the corporatization claim.
- Review tenure and promotion guidelines at Wharton and Stanford GSB to verify claims about faculty incentive structures.
- Search for empirical studies on the impact of MBA-led management on employee wages and firm profitability.
- Investigate the definition and implementation of 'stakeholder capitalism' in corporate charters to evaluate the trade-off argument.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:05
- Jules Van Binsbergen: Welcome to the Lauder Institute at the University of Pennsylvania. I'm Jules Van Binsbergen, Director of the Institute and a finance professor at the Wharton School.
- 0:14
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 0:14
- Jonathan Burke: I'm Jonathan Burke, a finance professor at the Graduate School of Business at Stanford University. This is the All Else Equal podcast.
- 0:31
- Jules Van Binsbergen: Welcome back, everybody! Today we're going to be talking about a New York Times opinion piece by a professor called Christopher Marquis. And in this article, he argues that it's probably best for business schools to be abolished, or at a minimum, to be very thoroughly reformed.
- 0:50
- Jules Van Binsbergen: And there are a number of arguments, Jonathan, in this article that are made. And I have to tell you, I read each of them in amazement in what I think is one of the longest opinion pieces I've read in the New York Times that just keeps going on and on. But I do think that it is important for the two of us to talk through the main arguments in the
- 1:10
- Jules Van Binsbergen: article and see what we think about them and to what extent we agree with those arguments. and to what extent we disagree. So the first argument that is made in the piece is that business schools really erode the better intentions that students have. So there's this claim that
- 1:29
- Jules Van Binsbergen: quite idealistic students come into the business school that really want to change the world for the better, and the output of the business school would be students. that only want to do consulting and finance, that come out with a transactional mindset that even spreads into politics and management. And there's also this article quoted
- 1:49
- Jules Van Binsbergen: by Daron Asamoglu that claims that or argues that when business degree majors become CEOs of firms, it's that's really the wage share of the firm that's cut. So lower wages are being paid. And that's for some reason viewed as a bad thing because the firm doesn't grow otherwise. It is just that the firm
- 2:09
- Jules Van Binsbergen: becomes more profitable and therefore investors get a larger return. So what do you think about that, Jonathan?
- 2:16
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You
- 2:16
- Jonathan Burke: know, predictively, I'm sure you know what I think about that. I mean, look, let's just start with the following observation that if I have somebody providing me with a service, let's say I have somebody cleaning my house. house and somebody else arrives and offers to do the identical job at a lower price,
- 2:33
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 2:34
- Jonathan Burke: don't think anybody would argue that it was perfectly moral for me to replace the worker with somebody with a lower price, just like we're going to any store. So again, I don't really understand this idea that if the new management comes in and can produce the same productivity at a lower wage.
- 2:51
- Jonathan Burke: I would argue that that's the system we work in and that's what they should be doing. So I don't see this as a negative.
- 2:59
- Jules Van Binsbergen: No, I agree with you. Uh furthermore, it seems to me that if the activities that the firm does are more profitable and therefore more money is returned to investors, can't those investors then do other things with the money that has been returned to them? So if we see the economy. economy as a resource allocating mechanism where we
- 3:19
- Jules Van Binsbergen: want to do as many things as we can, isn't it better that the firm operates and does the same things more efficiently? Jordan, I think it comes back to a thing that we've discussed many times, right? Which is are we willing to face the world the way it is, which is a competitive place and a system that we've always
- 3:38
- Jules Van Binsbergen: all together put up that leads to and has proven to lead to more output and to a better life for everybody? Or do we again want to go for the things that sound good and that we wish were true? To start with, the idea that maximizing the labor share of a firm should be an
- 3:58
- Jules Van Binsbergen: objective. I do not understand where that ever came from. Who said that it's a good thing? I mean, I'm not saying that you should minimize the labor share either. I think that the labor share is an entirely irrelevant decision-making criterion when you do firm decision making. I think the decision criterion should be that allocation of resources is done as
- 4:18
- Jules Van Binsbergen: well as possible, leading to the most output given the inputs that we're using. And so, indeed, as you she said earlier, if you can produce exactly the same thing with fewer inputs, I just don't understand what is wrong with
- 4:30
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): that.
- 4:31
- Jonathan Burke: Yeah, and I get the system is unfair. I get that what happens is exposed some people make more money than other people. But there isn't a better system out there. We tried it. That's what communism is. that Communism was a place where people's wages weren't related to their productivity.
- 4:50
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 4:51
- Jonathan Burke: the net result was an economy where nobody had anything. And so unquestionably, this country is successful precisely because nobody is embarrassed to do what is efficient.
- 5:07
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
- 5:07
- Jonathan Burke: that I think is a crucial part of what makes this economy successful.
- 5:12
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All
- 5:12
- Jules Van Binsbergen: right. Second claim, Jonathan. Business school schools lack
- 5:14
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): of the economy.
- 5:15
- Jules Van Binsbergen: a public good foundation. So the article claims that professions or schools like medicine and law serve health and justice, but business schools are organized just around private profit and therefore does not have the same moral justification that these other two fields have. Tap. And again, I think that that
- 5:35
- Jules Van Binsbergen: claim is so built on a misunderstanding of what any of these fields really do. I mean, let's start with medicine. How do you think most pharmaceutical drugs actually make it to the marketplace and actually lead to people's health improving? Do you think that it's not done through
- 5:54
- Jules Van Binsbergen: organization that are managed and need to be managed, where again, resources need to be allocated efficiently and profits that are made can be used for research and development for the next medicine. So the idea that medicine has this justification without having to do anything else, right? It doesn't have to prove that it's effective or anything. It's just that the
- 6:14
- Jules Van Binsbergen: intention apparently of being in favor of health and being in favor of law is just enough. Whereas business doesn't Don't have that leg lack to stand on and therefore it's suspicious from the get get-go. go. I find that argument very strange.
- 6:28
- Jonathan Burke: It's ironic, I think. I mean, most of the RD in medicine occurs in the United States for a reason that I don't fully understand. We pay for most medical RD in the world. Okay. And so this idea that everybody else says, oh, we're just in it for the good, but then they use all the benefits of the profit
- 6:47
- Jonathan Burke: maximizing system that led to that RD. And then, of course, that leads to patents, which leads to very high drug prices. So we individuals have to pay for that. You know, they ignore the thing. I mean, it's but you say the two worlds. There's a world that we would like to be, which is the world where people
- 7:07
- Jonathan Burke: don't have private needs and they're not selfish. Everybody works for the public good. Okay. And I agree, it's a much fairer. world and we'd all be happy in such a world. But that isn't the real world. That's the world we would like. But the world we would like doesn't exist. People are selfish. They do make decisions in their
- 7:26
- Jonathan Burke: self-interests. And the great thing about capitalism and what we teach in business schools is that we can harness that self-interest to make everybody better off. We don't have to tell people stop being self-interested because we know it's not going to work. Instead, we say, fine, be self-interested,
- 7:47
- Jonathan Burke: and we'll teach you how to be self-interested and let everybody do that. And then it leads to a lot of wealth.
- 7:54
- Jules Van Binsbergen: And I think that the communist systems has proven that to make people act against that self-interest and to try to, between quotations, quotation marks, act in the public good in those societies has led to such levels of coercion that the entire society collapsed. Because trying to force people to live
- 8:13
- Jules Van Binsbergen: according to this other value system is so against human nature that it's only possible to push it in that direction through coercion, which is then so self-defeating that in the end you do not get anything done.
- 8:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
- 8:26
- Jonathan Burke: but you'll Jules, let me just finally add, it's easy for somebody listening to us to look at us and say, boy, we have no caring for anybody. And I think that is a huge mistake. Both you and I care a lot about other people, and we just realize the constraint, right?
- 8:46
- Jonathan Burke: You don't care for somebody by pretending people aren't selfish.
- 8:51
- Jonathan Burke: You care for people by recognizing that people are selfish and figuring out a way how to take that selfishness to make everybody better off.
- 9:01
- Jules Van Binsbergen: And another example of this, Jonathan, is that I think every parent that's listening on this podcast understands that there are times where pushing your children to be better and work harder is the loving thing to do. The caring thing is not to automatically take the incentive away and
- 9:21
- Jules Van Binsbergen: say to people, you shouldn't be ambitious, you shouldn't push, you shouldn't work for yourself. The caring thing to do is that people have agency and that they achieve things on their own and that they're able to function together in a society that indeed the only rules that make the society as a whole. work are the ones where people that want to
- 9:41
- Jules Van Binsbergen: put in the effort are rewarded for it. And not the ones that everybody's taking care of no matter how much effort you put in. And so this trade-off that we've now so many times tried to do, which is the trade-off between incentives and insurance, of course, insurance is a nice thing, but perfect insurance means that nobody has an incentive to do anything and
- 10:01
- Jules Van Binsbergen: it just doesn't work.
- 10:03
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All
- 10:03
- Jules Van Binsbergen: right, so next. And I think here, Jonathan, is a claim that you and I at least are partially agreeing with, which is the question of is the case method in an effective way of teaching? Does it potentially distort learning? Because of course, the students in the case method That are asked to put themselves in the
- 10:23
- Jules Van Binsbergen: position of one particular decision maker who is faced with one particular set of circumstances. Often the cases, although I'm not sure how often, but it's definitely has happened that cases are company approved because company data is being used. Obviously, there's some simplification necessary to do the education. And we
- 10:43
- Jules Van Binsbergen: may even argue that the case studies These are generally biased towards winners. There is a survivorship bias, meaning that a lot of the guests. guest speakers that people have in classes and a lot of cases that we use are generally success stories. And if you don't properly distinguish between whether these success stories were luck or good decision making, that indeed
- 11:03
- Jules Van Binsbergen: could lead to a distortion.
- 11:04
- Jonathan Burke: Yeah, and I would go further and make the argument even stronger that it's not just the case method, that many business schools, and we are certainly guilty of this. teach by bringing in successful industry leaders who then tell students how to be successful, which is obviously a bias sample. We
- 11:24
- Jonathan Burke: don't have leaders coming in talking about the mistakes they made because those people, you know, nobody cares about. We only have the successes. And a lot of success is luck. And so basically what we're doing is having people come in, suppose supposed that experts, telling us essentially how lucky they were. So I think that criticism is
- 11:44
- Jonathan Burke: also valid. Now, having said that, let's just talk about the case method. It doesn't mean the case method is useless. The right way of teaching cases is to use them as an example. The thing about learning, the one thing you learn as a professor, is that students do not learn from theory.
- 12:03
- Jonathan Burke: Students learn from examples and anecdotes that can stick in their mind. And it's crucial as an educator to understand that. And so the case method can be very useful in focusing students on a specific example. But if that's all you do, you're failing as a professor. You have to both do that
- 12:23
- Jonathan Burke: and show students that you're not just picking an example out of thin air, that this example you're doing is backed by a lot of evidence that it's a more general phenomenon. And that's certainly the way I use cases.
- 12:37
- Jules Van Binsbergen: Jardel, I couldn't agree with you more. I think that people will also remember anecdotes way better than data. And so it's definitely possible to tell people anecdotes that aren't representative of the larger data. But if you teach by telling anecdotes that are representative of the overall data, you get the best of both worlds. They and learn the insight, they learn the data,
- 12:57
- Jules Van Binsbergen: and they learn something that's representative. It is still important indeed to teach people how to then think outside of the context of, say, the mean of the data, because the data doesn't just have a mean, a representative data point, it also has variation around it. And teaching people how to think about that, I think, is really
- 13:14
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): important.
- 13:16
- Jules Van Binsbergen: But let's also be clear, we have to start somewhere. If students don't know anything yet, we first have to start with a representative data point and get them interested and get them going on the material and start thinking that through. So now that said, Jonathan, I have to tell you that in the how many years has it now been? I started teaching in
- 13:35
- Jules Van Binsbergen: 2008, so that is 18 years. I have not used many cases in teaching finance. And I've always wondered whether it's even possible to teach finance in a case study only method. I think I would have a very hard time with it. Of course, I never specialized in teaching it through cases only, but it seems difficult to me. I think
- 13:55
- Jules Van Binsbergen: that finance is a logical framework that hangs together by teaching people the general principles underneath, and it does seem important to me to start there. And so even if you wanted to use cases, it seems to me that for a core finance class, I don't think I would use cases at least until halfway through the semester.
- 14:13
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well
- 14:13
- Jonathan Burke: I don't think you can teach a class with only cases, because then you're failing. You're just giving examples and you're not showing how they generalize. I certainly think you can use the cases as exemplars, no problem. But that means you have to have a lot of other material besides the case in the classroom. And
- 14:33
- Jonathan Burke: so yes, I think there may be cases of people abusing the case method by just doing cases. And that's something where maybe the article is correct about and maybe we should be doing a better job as business schools on are that. met.
- 14:46
- Jules Van Binsbergen: Yeah. Now just for the record, I think that the use of cases at book both our schools is rather limited. I think both Stanford and Morton sparingly use it where it is appropriate. And so I think that that's the way to go about it.
- 15:01
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All
- 15:01
- Jules Van Binsbergen: right, the next one, Jonathan, is also a point that I think even though we're clearly coming at the whole problem very differently than the author of the New York Times article, I do think that we have some agreement with it for a completely different reason. And that is this presenting stakeholder capital as this
- 15:20
- Jules Van Binsbergen: win-win ideology where if you just do all the things that are good for all the stakeholders, then the firm will become so much more profitable that that also happens to be in the interest of the shareholders, and therefore everybody is better off. And what I've always had against this. way of presenting it is
- 15:40
- Jules Van Binsbergen: that if it was good for the shareholders to begin with,
- 15:44
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): then
- 15:45
- Jules Van Binsbergen: according to the shareholder model, you were supposed to be doing it all along. That has absolutely nothing to do with the stakeholder model. And therefore, this stakeholder model doesn't add anything to the equation. And so the only way in which the stakeholder model, and by the way, we've discussed the stakeholder model on multiple of our partners. podcast episodes, the only way in which
- 16:05
- Jules Van Binsbergen: it has bytes is there's a meaningful trade-off, meaning that you prioritize the interest of a different stakeholder than the shareholders over that of the shareholders. And so indeed, pretending that we can have all of it as if the trade-offs don't exist, is one against the basic philosophy of what economics
- 16:25
- Jules Van Binsbergen: of the field is built on, which is everything. is a trade-off. And indeed, I think it's disingenuous to present it that way.
- 16:32
- Jonathan Burke: Jules, I would say this is a problem in business schools, but not the way the writer identified. Unfortunately, business schools, like most universities, have become politicized. What do I mean by this? Look, if profits have been maximized at the firm. what that
- 16:52
- Jonathan Burke: means is you can't do better. So if you're telling me that we can maximize for stakeholders, then either the profit maximization model delivers that, or if it doesn't deliver that, then it must lead to lower profits. So there
- 17:12
- Jonathan Burke: must be a trade-off. And so where I agree is that argument I made, it seems to me blaringly obvious. And the fact that it's not made in business schools, to me, is an indication of the politalization of business schools, that you can have it all without the rigor you need
- 17:32
- Jonathan Burke: to explain why that isn't actually possible.
- 17:36
- Jules Van Binsbergen: What the New York Times author is trying to argue, but maybe it's the same thing as what you're saying, is that essentially business schools just put a very thin veneer of socially acceptable language around the curriculum by pretending to care about these other stakeholders while in fact just continuing what
- 17:56
- Jules Van Binsbergen: they were doing before. And he's arguing that, you know, if you just have a curriculum, you keep the whole curriculum the same, but you just have one extra curriculum. class on stakeholder management or ESG, and then you pretend that everything is fine otherwise. That's what he's objecting to. And I think that the argument also that you just made is I think it is exactly the
- 18:15
- Jules Van Binsbergen: movement and the fact that business schools feel the need to address these topics is exactly a reason to dive into the trade-offs and the true problems that the world is facing and how we should. go about them. So using it as a rounding error and a layer of veneer may indeed be exactly the wrong way to go about it. I think that if we really
- 18:35
- Jules Van Binsbergen: want to achieve other objectives other than shareholder maximization, I think we need to be absolutely clear and upfront about what that's going to cost. It's It's not not gonna going to come for free.
- 18:47
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
- 18:47
- Jonathan Burke: Jules, I may mean may the way to say it is we are in agreement. but maybe what the author had in mind to fix it is very different to our fix. What we're saying is: look, the theory is pretty clear on this: that you can't have it all. There must be a trade-off. And so if there must be a trade-off, as we
- 19:06
- Jonathan Burke: started out this podcast, everybody's better off with more efficient firms. So if you take that as the working hypothesis, then what we're teaching is the right thing. But if the world's politicized and nobody wants to admit that, well, that's what we're teaching, so we put up a veneer. And I agree that we shouldn't be doing that.
- 19:27
- Jonathan Burke: So I think the solution to this is go back to basics and teach the economics that we're pretty certain is correct. I think maybe the author wanted us to give up on the economics, and I don't know what we would teach, but anyway.
- 19:39
- Jules Van Binsbergen: I think what you just described is exactly the issue. So are we willing to defend, and are business schools willing to defend about what it is that we do teach students? And I think that teaching students to deal with the world as it is in a competitive environment and in that environment make And the best resource allocation
- 19:58
- Jules Van Binsbergen: decisions, that is what we've been good at. And that's just why the podcast is called All Else Equal. What the field of economics has brought to the table is the ability to think about that system and its wider applications. Meaning you cannot just change small things in this dynamic system and pretend you know what's going to happen. It's a very complicated
- 20:18
- Jules Van Binsbergen: dynamic system that requires a lot of thought. And I think teaching students that is the main thing that we add value in. And you know, I don't know about you, I think I do know about you. I'm not at all ashamed of this. I mean, this is what it is, and this is what we stand for. And I think it's important to defend that. And doing away with the economics, I think would be a
- 20:38
- Jules Van Binsbergen: disaster for business schools.
- 20:39
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All
- 20:40
- Jonathan Burke: right. What's number five, Jules?
- 20:42
- Jules Van Binsbergen: Number five is another curious one, in my opinion. I I don't think we're going gonna to agree with this one. That the fact that universities have become corporatized.
- 20:51
- Jules Van Binsbergen: is really due to the fact that business school logic have seeped through the organization. And again, I think, you know, well, maybe I'll let you talk first, Jonathan. What do you think of this? Is it business school's fault that rankings and donors and students as customers, all of this focus on the monetary
- 21:11
- Jules Van Binsbergen: flows, all of this focus on reputation management. rather than, and again it's a bit of a utopian vision, but this center of curiosity and learning where students can explore anything and they can explore the humanities regardless of what say the job market consequences are of studying those
- 21:31
- Jules Van Binsbergen: things. And I do think that universities are not these the centers of utopian learning that don't have a lot of relationship with the real world. But the question is, have business schools contributed to universities becoming this way?
- 21:44
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
- 21:45
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_2): first want
- 21:45
- Jonathan Burke: to go to that central question of the role of a university. You know, what's interesting to me is it's assumed that in fact a university is not supposed to prepare you for the world, but it's just a place where you get to consume knowledge. Nobody talks about the misrepresentation that occurs, which is universities charge
- 22:05
- Jonathan Burke: a large amount of money, give people degrees, and then people with those degrees find out there's no economic value for those degrees. I mean, if you want to be this utopian view of a center of learning, do not sell the product as, okay, well, you spend this money, you're going to get a return on the money. Be very clear that that consumption
- 22:25
- Jonathan Burke: and learning and everything. may not translate into skills in the labor market. In some parts of the university, it will translate, in other parts, it won't. So I think there's some duplicitous behavior behind that notion. Now, having said that, I'm not sure I agree that that's the role of university. I mean, my view is: why do you need to go
- 22:45
- Jonathan Burke: to university just to enjoy knowledge? It seems to me there is some role of the university in preparing people to be productive in the economy. And so, in that sense, then I think there is some responsibility of the university to consider the people that they're educating and how well those people are able to be
- 23:05
- Jonathan Burke: productive in society.
- 23:07
- Jules Van Binsbergen: No, for sure. So there is the question if you have to pay for an education, and maybe this is what the author of the article means. If you have to pay for an education, you have to pay two or three or four hundred thousand dollars for it, then obviously there is a financial calculus that can come with that too. Is that a
- 23:27
- Jules Van Binsbergen: good investment or is it not a good investment? Now we can incorporate in the fact of whether it's a good investment or not, that you become a richer person, that you become a happier person, that you've you feel more fulfilled from a knowledge point of view, perhaps even that you've made friends for life. We can take all of those things into account. But
- 23:47
- Jules Van Binsbergen: in the end, it would be foolish to not take into account that there are economic consequences to the education as well, and that therefore you will earn a different salary in the marketplace, depending on what you chose to study and what you learned and what skills you acquired. And, you know, particularly I think for a business school, and if we
- 24:07
- Jules Van Binsbergen: talk about MBAs, I don't know about you, Jonathan, but I never thought of the MBA degree of all degrees indeed as a place where you come just to acquire the knowledge without any eye for the consequences that that degree might have. Now, maybe the criticism is that that thinking of, hey,
- 24:27
- Jules Van Binsbergen: is my investment worth it? Is it that something particular that business schools spread around the rest of the campus? But I have a hard time tying those together. And I think that we have very simple examples of this, Jonathan. There are several universities in the United States that explicitly have chosen not to have business schools. They have
- 24:46
- Jules Van Binsbergen: explicitly chosen to stay away from all practical schools. And from where I'm sitting, those universities operate exactly the same way today as the ones that do have business schools. So it doesn't seem to me that blaming the business school for making the institution as a whole more corporatized, I don't think
- 25:06
- Jules Van Binsbergen: that that causal effect is proven at all.
- 25:10
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
- 25:10
- Jonathan Burke: Jules, I actually would go a stage further and say the only effect they we have had is to emphasize the importance of making trade-offs, of making optimal decisions, of figuring out what the objective is. And the extent to which we have educated society, we've also educated university of the same thing. So in fact, I think it's
- 25:30
- Jonathan Burke: a good thing that universities think carefully about how they spend their money.
- 25:34
- Jules Van Binsbergen: Last point. Are the incentives of faculty according to the author, the incentives are sell some big ideas, write some books, write some cases, get a lot of attention. And it isn't about the rigor that the author would like to see. But Jonathan, in my experience, if I look at
- 25:54
- Jules Van Binsbergen: the way that people at the business school get tenure, I don't think anybody that I can remember has gotten tenure for selling big. ideas in TED talks or in books or in newspaper articles. Generally, the tenure cases are almost to a fault about the published research only,
- 26:14
- Jules Van Binsbergen: and almost no other characteristics or performance metrics are taken into account.
- 26:20
- Jonathan Burke: Yeah, I agree with you. I mean, certainly as in Stanford, Danford, that's the only thing we care about in a published research. You know, if somebody's going to criticism. criticize us, I think they criticize us for the opposite, that we do not take into account in our tenure review process whether or not the ideas have been practically influential.
- 26:39
- Jules Van Binsbergen: Yes. The
- 26:40
- Jonathan Burke: question is how influential has it been in academia? Not how influential has it been in the practice of business. In our case, the practice of finance. And I think there one could argue that we should be taking that into account more. But I don't think we do at all. And so I think that that
- 27:00
- Jonathan Burke: criticism of business schools is completely off the mark.
- 27:03
- Jules Van Binsbergen: Yeah. And so therefore, academic knowledge generation, I think that is only a public good.
- 27:10
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
- 27:10
- Jules Van Binsbergen: mean, to the extent that it's not implemented in practice and leads to private. profit, isn't that the definition of a public good? Knowledge generation? So isn't it then the case that business schools in general, also in their research, is predominantly driven as a non-profit by the public good?
- 27:28
- Jonathan Burke: Yeah, absolutely. The only thing I would say is we should reward faculty if somebody can demonstrate that the ideas which were put into the public domain were actually picked up in the practice of business. And sometimes they are. There's no question about it. But we don't use that as a criteria. And I think we should probably
- 27:48
- Jonathan Burke: use that more. And that might make it more clear to people how useful business schools are.
- 27:53
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
- 27:54
- Jules Van Binsbergen: should we abolish the business school? Should we replace the business school or should we reform the business school?
- 27:59
- Jonathan Burke: Look, Jules, on this podcast, we have extensively discussed the problems universities have. And, you know, the University of Austin is an example of people saying these places can never be reformed. My view is you gotta take the constraints as given. The idea of starting new universities seems to me a
- 28:19
- Jonathan Burke: non starter. So really the only choice is to reform from within. You know, I don't think business schools are. as broken as the person who wrote the article. So I don't think it's as much effort to reform, but I think there is definitely some work to be done. If you were to ask me, I think the article missed the single
- 28:38
- Jonathan Burke: biggest problem in modern MBA education. If you ask me what the single biggest problem is, it's we do not deliver enough content. That back in the 50s fifties and the 60s sixties and the 70s, seventies, when the MBA education was essentially invented, there was content in that classroom you could get nowhere else. We have been unable to
- 28:58
- Jonathan Burke: provide new content, not because that new content doesn't exist, but because I think schools as a whole, the incentive structure to reinvent the school is set up so that people are risk risk-averse, averse, they don't want to make big changes. And In anyway, any way, it requires a lot of effort. So if you would ask me in what area would I reform, I would reform
- 29:18
- Jonathan Burke: on the content. Make sure we deliver content that is really only available if you do an MBA.
- 29:26
- Jules Van Binsbergen: I agree with that completely. But I do think that the reform that you're proposing is orthogonal, if not going in the opposite direction as what the author is proposing. Now, the most generous reading of what the author is proposing.
- 29:39
- Jules Van Binsbergen: which is something that I do like, is that I do think it's possible to integrate parts of the campus into the business school education. I am sure that there are insights from other parts of campus like political science or history or other places that could be integrated further into the curriculum. And I think that, for example, the Lauder
- 29:59
- Jules Van Binsbergen: Institute is a place where that exactly happens. It is the cooperation between the business school and many other places in campus and international relations and geopolitics and geoeconomics, I think, are very important developments that should be incorporated in the MBA curriculum. But I'm not sure that's going to fit your definition, Jonathan, which is we should find
- 30:19
- Jules Van Binsbergen: content that only the business school can deliver and nobody else will. Or nobody else can, potentially.
- 30:25
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well
- 30:26
- Jonathan Burke: Jules, it's interesting to me how much attention that New York Times update got, given what I think are pretty weak arguments.
- 30:34
- Jules Van Binsbergen: Yeah. To be fair, I think there are a few things that are touched upon that I think deserve clearer inspection also for ourselves what it is that we want to do. But yeah, I also think there are a couple arguments that completely missed the mark as far as I'm concerned. Even the ones that do address important issues, I think you and I definitely
- 30:54
- Jules Van Binsbergen: comment those issues from a completely different angle. There's still the question of why did this article resonate so well at this moment? I'm not so much interested in what the motivation of the author is, because the author should do whatever they want to do, but the fact that it got as much attention as it did does tell you something
- 31:14
- Jules Van Binsbergen: about what the times are like. I think that if that article had been written twenty years ago, I don't think it would nearly have gotten as much attention as it did today.
- 31:22
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I think
- 31:23
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): you're
- 31:23
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): right,
- 31:23
- Jonathan Burke: Jules, and it's a good note to close the podcast
- 31:26
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): on
- 31:28
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): Thanks for listening to All Else Equal Podcast. Please leave us a review at Apple Podcasts. We'd We love to hear from our listeners. And be sure to catch our next episode. by subscribing or following the show wherever you listen to your podcasts. For more information and episodes, visit all else equal podcast.com
- 31:49
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): or follow us on LinkedIn.
- 31:51
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
- 31:51
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_3): All Else Equal Podcast is a joint production of the Norder Institute at the University Universal of Pennsylvania and the Graduate School of Business at Stanford University, and is produced by University FM