Tim Baldwin discusses rising tenant lawsuits, arbitration challenges, and documentation strategies for landlords.
Summary
Tim Baldwin explains that tenant lawsuits are increasing, with class actions demanding high payouts and litigation timelines varying significantly by court level. He highlights arbitration as a potential but imperfect alternative to litigation, noting difficulties in finding specialized real estate arbiters. The speakers emphasize that unmet move-in expectations and mold claims are primary drivers of disputes, recommending thorough inspections and honest marketing to align expectations. They also discuss the use of monitoring technology, occupancy enforcement, and the legal distinctions between named tenants and approved occupants under fair housing laws.
Key takeaways
- 1 to disclose these things and that the tenant actually agrees that they're uh that they can be used, uh, so long as they're not, of course, violating some statute that may apply. For example, I can't record what you're saying in your house, I can't record the uh you know the audio recording of your what you're saying, but I can I can record the decibel level.
Tim Baldwin · 31:47
Episode sections
- 0:00 – 6:24
Litigation Surge and Court Timelines
Tim Baldwin notes a rise in tenant lawsuits against landlords, including class actions with high financial demands. He explains that in Florida, small claims and county court cases (up to $50,000) reach mediation quickly, while circuit court cases can take over a year to reach mediation.
- 6:24 – 13:01
Arbitration Clauses and Enforcement
Baldwin describes arbitration as a less formal, often cheaper alternative to litigation decided by a licensed arbiter. He notes challenges in finding arbiters with real estate expertise and explains that enforcing arbitration requires court intervention if a party refuses.
- 13:01 – 21:09
Property Inspections and Expectations
Baldwin identifies property conditions and unmet move-in expectations as primary drivers of tenant disputes. He recommends thorough inspections and honest marketing to align tenant expectations with the actual property condition.
- 21:09 – 29:48
Mold Claims and Prevention Strategies
Mold claims are increasingly prevalent, often used by tenants to exit leases. Prevention involves documenting property conditions, managing humidity with dehumidifiers, and using smart AC systems to monitor usage and prevent mold growth caused by tenant behavior.
- 29:48 – 33:53
Monitoring Technology and Lease Disclosures
The speakers discuss using noise, humidity, and smoke detectors for rental properties. Baldwin advises including these monitoring tools in lease agreements to ensure legal compliance and enforceability, noting that courts have ordered such installations in litigation.
- 33:53 – 35:26
Monitoring Technology and Occupancy Enforcement
Tim Baldwin and the host discuss using electronic locks and external cameras to enforce occupancy limits, particularly for short-term rentals. They note that while monitoring can reduce liability, it must be balanced with lease terms and local regulations.
- 35:26 – 38:38
Fair Housing and Occupant Disclosure
Tim Baldwin explains that leases distinguish between named tenants and approved occupants. He clarifies that fair housing laws prevent denying residency to families with children, except in designated 55+ or 62+ communities. Landlords have a legitimate interest in knowing who is in the unit for safety reasons.
- 38:38 – 41:02
Occupancy Standards and Wear and Tear
The speakers discuss HUD standards of two persons per bedroom. Baldwin notes that landlords cannot charge extra rent for a family with children, but can offset wear and tear risks through security deposits rather than higher base rent.
- 41:02 – 47:45
Security Deposits vs. Insurance Fees
The host shares an experience with a property management insurance program in Idaho where tenants paid monthly fees that did not accumulate like a savings account. Baldwin explains that Florida law allows tenants to convert fee-in-lieu-of-deposit arrangements into traditional security deposits at any time.
- 47:45 – 51:00
Legal Counsel and Documentation
Tim Baldwin advises landlords to document everything, use experienced legal counsel, and treat property management as a high-risk business requiring front-end work. The host recommends having leases reviewed by lawyers, even if using services like LegalZoom, to ensure legal soundness.
Claims worth verifying
Tim Baldwin is an attorney in Florida specializing in representing landlords and property owners.
Tim Baldwin ·1:23
How to verify: Check Florida Bar Association attorney directory for Tim Baldwin and his practice area. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Tim Baldwin has over 20 years of experience representing landlords, property owners, and management companies.
Tim Baldwin ·33:53
How to verify: LinkedIn profile for Tim Baldwin, Property Management Law Solutions; or his website PM Law Solutions.com. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
In Florida, small claims and county court cases up to $50,000 typically reach mediation faster than circuit court cases, which can take a year or more.
Tim Baldwin ·33:53
How to verify: Florida Statutes Chapter 713 or local Florida court rules regarding mediation timelines for small claims vs. circuit court. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Fair housing laws do not allow denying residency to a family with children, except in 55+ or 62+ communities.
Tim Baldwin ·35:55
How to verify: Fair Housing Act (42 U.S.C. § 3604) and HUD guidelines on familial status discrimination. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
HUD standards suggest two persons per bedroom.
Tim Baldwin ·39:53
How to verify: HUD Housing Quality Standards or local building codes referencing HUD occupancy guidelines. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Florida statute allows tenants to convert a fee-in-lieu-of-security-deposit arrangement into a traditional security deposit at any time during tenancy.
Tim Baldwin ·44:58
How to verify: Florida Statutes Chapter 83, Part II, specifically sections governing security deposits and alternative arrangements. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The host has a cluster of properties in Idaho and used a property management insurance program where tenants paid monthly fees that did not accumulate.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·43:07
How to verify: Podcast transcript self-reporting; no external verification possible for specific private contract terms. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
LegalZoom and LegalShield offer legal review services for property documentation.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·49:20
How to verify: LegalZoom.com or LegalShield.com product pages for legal services. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Tim Baldwin can be contacted via PM Law Solutions.com or LinkedIn.
Tim Baldwin ·50:01
How to verify: Visit PM Law Solutions.com or search LinkedIn for 'Tim Baldwin' associated with Property Management Law Solutions. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Review Florida court rules regarding mediation timelines for small claims vs. circuit court cases.
- Verify local and federal fair housing laws regarding occupancy limits and charges for families with children.
- Check state-specific statutes on security deposits versus insurance fee-in-lieu arrangements.
- Audit lease agreements for explicit clauses regarding monitoring devices and arbitration enforcement.
- Research the availability and cost of arbiters with real estate expertise in your jurisdiction.
- Confirm HUD standards for occupancy and how they interact with local housing codes.
- Investigate the enforceability of external cameras and electronic locks in short-term rentals.
- Consult with legal counsel to review lease templates for privacy statute compliance.
Full transcriptexpand
0:00Tim Baldwin: But what and this is what I mentioned to you, and it's what's very notable to me is that there's just increasingly more and more lawsuits that tenants are filing against landlords, uh, against property management companies, and and the actions are not small. I mean, we're we're talking about some of them class action lawsuits, um actions demanding uh lots of money
0:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): and
0:26Tim Baldwin: it's really starting uh to really put pressure on our clients.
0:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Hello and welcome back to the ideal investors show. Everybody, you guys know that we always bring great guests and we most of the time have new guests, but every once in a while we have a great opportunity to bring back a great guest. And this is a very opportune time because I just learned before we went live that there's more loose lawsuits than ever in the space that we are in. So welcome back to the show, Tim Borgwin
1:05Tim Baldwin: Thank you, Dr. Bayerhoffers great to be here.
1:08Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, thank you for coming back and uh thanks for sharing that with me. Uh just for those who haven't gone back to the previous time that you were with us, can you just like in a very brief quick intro tell the audience who you are and what you do?
1:23Tim Baldwin: Yeah. So I am uh Tim Baldwin. I'm an attorney in Florida. Uh our our law practice uh specializes in representing uh landlords, property owners who have investment in real estate and other uh property uh issues. and matters such as um you know, some civil litigation, uh possession actions and and these sorts of things. So we're we're one hundred percent vested in this real estate world. Um and we're statewide, so we represent a lot of uh variety of clients, including large companies and apartments and property management companies.
1:59Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, very good. Thank you. And I mean, thank you again for having me on your show and and talking a little bit about property management and some of the things that I have learned and where we might be going with our, you know, like Optimus robots taking care of all our properties and stuff. Um one thing before we maybe dive in, um since you are in the market and and even though you're focusing on the legal side, what would you say, what do you see in the Florida market right now? or have you seen this year so far?
2:31Tim Baldwin: Well, we uh my clients um of course bring us in with with legal issues and and these sorts of things. So we you know, we're not really keeping our our finger on the pulse of um, you know, market trends uh per se. But what what and this is what I mentioned to you and it's what's very notable to me um is that there's just increasingly more and more lawsuits that tenants are filing against landlords, uh against property management companies. And and the actions are not small. I mean, we're we're talking about some of them class action lawsuits, um actions demanding uh lots of money, and it's really starting uh to really put pressure on our clients in a variety of ways. And so, you know, I entered this world in in landlord tenant law back in two thousand six. You know, this is twenty twenty years ago. And the the landscape at that time was just very, very different. Um and so I think it's something that we're having to navigate and in it's is and it's really can be challenging.
3:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah
3:38Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): absolutely. So, I mean, I'm definitely not a legal scholar or anything like that as you are. Um, but I mean I I took a few classes and what I was told, and maybe this is still from even before 2006 and and not applicable anymore, but I wanna want to say it and then you tell
4:00Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): me,
4:00Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): hey Axel, you're full of it, and this is totally different now. But what I was told is the the intention from a from a court's perspective would be to say, is there a way to do mediation between the parties? If the answer to that is no, is there a way to settle between the parties? And only if the answer is no to that, well then we obviously have to bring it actually to the court and have actual you know eviden evidence discovery and have a real court case and you know have witnesses and that kind of stuff. Is that still true or is that like aching me and telling the audience that I'm old?
4:44Tim Baldwin: Well it's true um that especially the what you'd call you know small claims case cases um or even um lower value county court cases, uh I'm talking about Florida, 'cause Florida we have uh small claims is the lowest, county courts the next, up to fifty thousand dollars in damages, and then anything above fifty thousand is circuit court. If you get into circuit court, you're not gonna Going see to a mediation uh in in in many instances uh until at least a year into litigation. Uh that now with county court cases and small claims cases, that you're probably gonna see uh mediation maybe, maybe fairly quickly. But I can tell you that in my experience, um a lot of the attendants just simply don't want to settle. I mean, I'm it's true, they don't want to settle. They believe that they're gonna get more value out of the case by hanging on. And um so while it may be uh nice, if you will, to be able to settle some some dispute that uh you know may or may not have any merit at all, I'm I'm seeing these cases just go forward. And uh that's troublesome.
5:56Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, absolutely. I hear you. Um well it's obviously well, I would assume clocking up the the quad. courts as well. Now, the other thing I wanted to ask before we go into some examples is I've seen, and I don't remember if this was for Florida or if this was for some of my properties in different states, that in a lot of the contracts and agreements there are so-called so called arbitration clauses in there. Can you describe what that is, how that's different from what we discussed? so far and if this is useful or if this is basically just written in and doesn't do anything?
6:35Tim Baldwin: Yeah, I mean arbitration clauses uh I mean I see them uh somewhat frequently. Uh in in arbitration is simply having your case decided by uh a licensed arbiter. Uh many times those are just attorneys. who are licensed arbiters. And they hear the case, they hear the evidence, and they make a decision. It's a lot less formal. I was going to say it's more informal. And many times it doesn't cost as much as it would in litigation. Um, However, there, I mean, there are some downsides to. that because there may not be the stringent rules that you would actually want to enforce uh so that you can keep certain things out of the case that really have no bearing on the issues. But those arbitration clause can be helpful to reduce costs. I can tell you one of the things that sometimes also is a problem um is actually finding an arbitration. arbitr an arbiter who has sufficient knowledge for the kind of case you're dealing with because
7:45there's just not a lot of arbiters out there uh which can be a problem if you're if you're needing the judge you know to have the experience and expertise in the issues you're dealing with. So it you know it could be a good idea for you but it uh it's not always a good idea to have an arbitration goal. clause.
8:04Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Okay, and um just in general, for me and our fellow non-legal experts, can eat both or either side refuse arbitration even though it was in the documents, or or is this kind of like a step that has to be taken?
8:22Tim Baldwin: Sometimes you do see refusal for arbitration, and then what ends up happening is if you are wanting to force that arbitration, then you have to ask the court to and you may have to follow uh a uh an injunction or or some sort of relief in the court to get them to arbitrate. Um or if a action has already been filed, you may have to get the court to put a stay on that case until such time as you're able to arbitrate. the case. I mean there so there are enforcement mechanisms that you can uh impose so on the other side. Um and and there could be reasons that arbitration doesn't apply. So for example, if there arbitration only applies to certain uh dis dys certain kinds of disputes, then that might be a reason why you reject. a uh demand for arbitration. Um so you know that that sort of thing. So um it it may just kind of depend on on what's going on in your situation.
9:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, thank you for that Tim. Um I'm asking all of these questions because I've only been sued once and the judge
9:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): before we
9:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): ever Never really ever got into any kind of nitty nitty-gritty gritty details asked us all those things. Have you considered or done any mediation? Have you had arbitration? Is it in your contracts? Why are we actually here? Why do we need to have this? Is there a chance to settle? Right? Like he even it was kind of
9:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
9:51Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): guess fortuitous for from his perspective. Our case was called at like something like eleven 11 30 thirty in the morning or so, and then you know, everybody got settled and he asked. some questions, and we had to introduce you ourselves and stuff, and the lawyers and what have you. And then it came up to closer and closer, it was like 12 15 or so, and he said, You know what, guys? I think you should try one more time. Let's make take a lunch break for an hour and a half, and then you come back and you tell me if you found a way or not. I And
10:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
10:26Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): approached the tenant and they said they were absolutely set in believing that they were right. Well, and so then we came back at I think one thirty or something like that, told the judge, Okay, no no settlement possible and then we went through the whole rigmaroo and ultimately he decided, luckily for me so So because they really had no case but you know they tried anyway. Yeah. So with that being
10:54Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): said,
10:54Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): maybe you yeah, go ahead, Tim.
10:56Tim Baldwin: No, I was gonna say um that that's that's a typical story, but um a lot nowadays that you're seeing tenants get attorneys a lot more readily.
11:05Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, I mean the thing I had that too. Um
11:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): she
11:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): didn't come along with me because she felt that wasn't necessary. What she did I felt, was very and it was mainly to keep the cost down. I mean, she could have come, but then it would have cost me like 500 bucks an hour or something like that. Um but the point was we sat down and she had me explain all the evidentiary material that I had put together. I had literally a binder with It's like 40 forty taps in
11:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it.
11:35Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): And she said, if if you get the judge to accept to take a look. at it, you're home free. And that's exactly what ultimately happened. He asked the tenants to make their case, so to speak, with their lawyer, and they made me sound like I'm slumlord. Yeah. And then the judge said, So what do you have to say for yourself? And said, Well, is it possible that I can give you this binder of evidence? And in it's like sequential order, everything they talked about and if you're willing to look at it, then he I don't know what that's officially called, but he said, Okay, let's take a quick break and told us we can stay, and he went like in a back door, I don't know, fifteen minutes or something like that, and came back and said, Okay, I looked through everything and then asked some questions to the tenants based on the stuff that I gave
12:24Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): him.
12:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): And they agreed. that all the people, all the documents, all the receipts, everything was true. And he said, well then sorry, you have no case, right? So um now m nowadays this is six years ago, this may not work today anymore. Um what I kind of wonder if you want to start maybe either top down or bottom up on what are the things that you see. regularly where you would say, well, either the tenant or the owner could have done a better job not to let it get that far.
13:01Tim Baldwin: Yeah, that well, I think prop the property conditions are are probably one of the most um contentious parts of a relationship between landlord and tenant. Uh the issues about mold, uh, you know, cleanliness, the functionality of uh amenities, um utilities, all these sorts of things. Because it seems to be that when the tenant moves in, if there are uh expectations that are not met, then right right away there's like this this tension. And almost like the tenants looking at the landlord through the lens of uh scrutiny and distrust. And from then on out it seems like that's what um sort of drives uh the relationship from then on. So I think that for landlords really it's look it's having good and thorough um ins in inspection processes to make sure the house is not just
14:08habitable, but it meets what you you've advertised it to be. And that's the big thing is that landlords will advertise their the the property as being one way but then the tenants move in is it's really not that way. And so so that's that's a lot of the contention that you get. And and so it's meeting expectations. I think again is a big one. Or, you know, lowering the expectation, really. If if the if the apartment's not luxury, don't say it's luxury, right? I mean, if if the the apartment hasn't been painted in 10 years, don't say it's got a fresh coat of paint, right? It's it's these types of things that if the landlord Or were just really honest about it, I think that you there would be less um there would be less. problems.
14:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, let me ask you something about that because I've been wondering about it, and I realized most of the time I've been, I guess, very lucky because w I'm talking about my own portfolio. What we typically have been doing is either we were lucky and had long-term tenants that didn't move out, and I think the longer a tenant is in your property. the less likely it is that they start complaining suddenly out of out of nowhere. Um, but then the other thing is if somebody was in the property for a while, we typically do like what we call a refresh. It's not really a renovation, but a refresh. Would but I've been wondering if it would actually be worth spending a few hundred dollars to get it inspected again, just like you do before you buy.
15:40Tim Baldwin: Yeah, I I I think so. I mean I I do. Um one is you want to see if the tenants are causing any problems with the property. So you need an inspection periodically. Um, because if the tenants are not caring for the property the way they need to, now you may have um either one a claim against them, or two, you may not want to rent from them again. Uh but if everything looks good from that standpoint and you do an inspection uh to make sure that you know the the the the main the the main functions of the home are working properly, uh that there's not going to be a disaster lurking around the corner, sure. I I I think those kinds of preventative maintenance types of of inspections are very helpful.
16:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
16:27Tim Baldwin: they
16:27Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): do cost money,
16:28Tim Baldwin: obviously.
16:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Well, yes and no, and I I believe at least in my portfolio there are two different kinds of inspections. The one that I have my property managers write into the lease agreement, where we basically say whenever we come to switch the um the filters for the air conditioning and and any kind of air filter. filters and stuff like that. We will also do um minor inspection, is what we're calling it. And the the tenant is at the time of signing the lease agreement agreeing to that twice a year. So that's basically somebody from property management not just doing that task, but also having permission basically based on the lease agreement to walk through the house and and uh or how half of the house or whatever duplex and stuff it is to see kind of like the condition. What I was referring to is more the full on inspection that you would do before you buy. Um when you have a turnover. So the small ones I for anybody listening and and not doing this, my strong and I hope you agree Tim, my strong recommendation is you should have somebody from property management in the house literally walking through twice a year at least, if not more often. But then the turnover, let's say somebody was in the house for three years and you do your refresh. Um, just for
17:50this point of I'm basically renting or selling what I'm saying, and I have a third party that is not property management, it's is not the owner that has actually inspected the house and has all the pictures and and all that stuff.
18:05Tim Baldwin: Yeah, well I'd first of all I'd definitely agree on the number of inspections from property management at least twice a year. Sure. Yes. That's that's that's definitely a a good rule. You know, I in the property management agreements that I draft for for clients, um, you know, what you know one of the things that we we see we draft, you know, help them draft language for is having these service options for the property owners. And one of them is what you're talking about is having a uh a more thorough, even licensed home inspectors to go through and do their assessments uh for for anything that may need to be addressed. And they do that periodically. It could be once a year, it may be once every two years. or maybe at the turnover, or whatever. But that way, you know, the property manager has an agreement with the home inspector. They may have some sort of, you know, mutually beneficial agreement with each other. Uh, and it's done more on a volume basis, and the and then the property owners may get a benefit from a lower price, uh, and but but this routine service plan. So I yes, I think that's a really good idea.
19:18Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, and I mean this also goes with what I always say, and I don't know if your landlords that you are representing do the same, but I'm a big fan of building clusters. I l if you say, Okay, I wanna invest in Tampa, for example, don't just buy one house and then buy the next one in Fort Lauderdale and another one in Fort Myers and stuff like that, but build a cluster. because that then actually gives that opportunity, right? If you buy every time you buy, you have a full official home inspection. And I know, like I have this for my cluster in Ohio. We have inspectors, and a reinspection is 150 bucks because they have the file, they have all the original stuff already. It takes them maybe an hour and then all the updates. They don't make another 85 page full thing, they just make a comparative to the original inspection or the last inspection they had. And if they know okay, you do this on a regular basis for five or six properties, and you know, and you have a turnover at least one or two of them each year, right? So they don't even have to worry. And if they charge a full fee every time, then you might not actually want to. do it. Right. So um now you mentioned a few of the things. Where would you say, I mean, I can understand if if people try to offer a property
20:38that is not like it was, you know, the tenant moves in and finds out, hey, this is all not really like I was told. Are there other things where you would say, okay, that conflict or this lawsuit could have been prevented prevented? Um not by kind of in a sense it sounded a little bit if you cheat your tenants, then you can't be surprised to get a lawsuit. But are there other things that that you see being put in front of the courts more and more that that could be avoided?
21:09Tim Baldwin: Well, I think I think um whether they could be avoided or not maybe may be a difficult question to ask, but um um but the one that that is just increasing increasingly um prevalent is is mold claims.
21:24Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Okay.
21:24Tim Baldwin: Uh you probably have dealt with that. Maybe I as pr I presume as as an investor you've dealt with this issue, but um you know, there are lawyers out there who their only job, their only uh market, if you will, is to find people and prime primarily tenants who have mold claims against the landlord. And so you get these demands, and some of these demands are outlandish. Uh many times what's happening too is the tenants the tenants are simply looking for a way out of the lease. And there could be different reasons for that, but they want won out. And so what better way to to m to move out it than to just make this um you know, this exaggerated claim of mold. Um and it and it's becoming a political issue. I mean, not to point out any particular political candidates, but we just had elections and one of the one of the um candidates who won um who got elected used this um this this very thing. in his acceptance speech.
22:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And
22:32Tim Baldwin: so it's a big, it's it's becoming just a more and more uh prevalent thing. Um fair housing, uh emotional support animals, also a pretty big deal. We see a lot of these uh these types of planes, and they're getting uh they're becoming more and more prevalent as well. Um if you talk about prevention and just to go to that real quick, a big part of prevention is having your documentation in order. Documenting the condition of the property before they move in, while they're there, after they move out. So you can point to a place in time to say, no, we didn't cause this. And maybe the tenant did. Or if and since air conditioning systems is a big part of mold, like how does this interact with the mold claim? Um, one of the things not to mention, it's many times very difficult to prove what even caused the mold to begin with. This this is one of the biggest problems.
23:32Um, what we see uh not uncommonly is whenever a tenant is gone for an extended period of time of time. And um by the way, is my connection still good over there with you, Dr. Meyerhoffer?
23:45Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): It's kind of in and out, but it's okay, fundamentally okay, yes.
23:50Tim Baldwin: I'm sorry.
23:51Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
23:52Tim Baldwin: just want to make sure I'm I it I it said that I was we had a weak connection here. Um
23:58Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): but
23:58Tim Baldwin: you know, the way the tenants run the AC system,
24:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): do
24:02Tim Baldwin: they do they have it at the right temperature? Or are they leaving doors open? Are they leaving windows open? That have they taken the two week vacation during the summer and turned the AC up to 82? Right? All of all of these different factors. Um, and and you may not know the answer to these questions right away, but it's these types of things that are relevant to uh preventing the types of claims. flames. So in your lead. lease, you know, making sure if you're gone for an extended period of time, make sure the AC is properly set to and you give them parameters. Uh, even the humidity levels, of course, be being in the southeast here, the humidity is high. If some houses have a bigger problem with humidity levels, then you might need to get a dehumidifier, you know, to help um help that problem. It's those those. types of things. Um so that that's just an example, uh Dr. Meyerhoff
24:55Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): for Dan
24:56Tim Baldwin: Prevention.
24:57Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, I think that's great, and thank you for mentioning this. One thing that I would like to mention, and and if you hadn't said it, I mean I have actually literally for some of my houses bought the dehumidifier and get it get gave it to the uh tenants. The one thing that's really good about that is the slightly better than cheapest ones, let's put it that way. Um they come with basically, I would call it like a usage counter. They basically say how many hours they're actually running. Right? And if you are in a in a facility in in a house that may have at least a propensity of mold, even if there isn't any detectable at the moment. And you provide them, I spent like $150 or $200 to provide a dehumidifier. While if you look at the hours counter, and that's one of those things that you can't easily fake, you know, like it's it's built into the machine and they barely ever run it, that would be one thing to say, hey, you know, you have to play a little bit your side of the game too. You can't just say it's my fault, and then I give you a two.
26:02tool from the get-go and you're not using it. But the other thing I I believe that that points out, and I wonder what you would say, Tim. I think what we as owners should look more at, and maybe in with support from property management, is to look at equipment that takes advantage of modern technology. And I know that some people might find this kind of like overly controlling, but I personally really honestly don't see anything wrong if, for example, to see okay, property management can see what the settings and how often air conditioning systems are running. The systems have actually that capability, you know, to to report that to an app. And whatever the setting is, is not so much the point, but is it running at a reasonable amount of time? Now the other thing I would say is if you are in a location that is prone for high humidity, like you pointed out, Tim, I oftentimes wonder why when you go, and I can only speak about renovations or new build. Right? I I never bought anything that that's is just sitting there. But I really have to say when you do a renovation I
27:15tell my contractors, you know, I don't want to have bathrooms without tire. Right and if you have a properly tired bathroom, you might if you ever even get any more then it would be on the surface and it can easily remedy it. But these things where they basically put in these plastic inserts and then paint the bathroom and then have not even a a fan, no de-umit. dehumidifier, no window, and then you're surprised. I mean it kinda in some sense it feels like they're asking for it.
27:47Tim Baldwin: Yeah. Yeah. W well yeah, you're you're yeah. It's just it's like a steam room in a closet. You know, I mean like it's it's just it's like you're yeah, you're you're gonna get mold, right? I mean you're gonna get mold. And then and then to make matters worse, the tenants don't don't open the door. They they
28:04Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): You know,
28:04Tim Baldwin: so it becomes a petri dish of of mold growth. Yeah, we we've seen all kinds of things. But I mean, yeah, a lot of that stuff, you're right. The from the construction standpoint, uh, that helps a lot. The uh AC set having smart AC systems uh is a great idea if you you know if you can if you can put that money into it, that that investment. We've had some clients who own you know they own build for rent communities and uh so they you know there's hundreds of houses in these in these uh neighborhoods and all of them are equipped with all this this smart technology that you're talking about. So yeah you can see what they're running the AC and and so on and so forth. If they're if they have a lockout situation they can remotely you know open the door. Uh if they have an emergency situation where they got to get a vendor in the in house. They can unlock it remotely. All those types of things, it's yeah, it's very handy. Of course, you got to make sure the privacy and the security measures are in place because that can pose other liability risks as well. But yeah, there's a lot of tools out there. And someone who's listening to you on a regular basis, I'm sure they can s hear you say this on on a regular a basis. because I know that I hear you say it a lot, but using the right tools and the right technology is a critical part nowadays, I think, of um keeping your
29:24um reducing your liability risks.
29:28Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, and I mean one thing I wanted to ask you maybe as we're coming to a close for today is and I know this from a few friends who actually run their properties as an Airbnb, that they have a number of, I would kind of call them gadgets. Like one of them you just plug in a power outlet and that is measuring the noise level. Another one you you stick in a uh in a power outlet and you can have it in multiple rooms individually, is measuring humidity. Um
29:59Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): then
29:59Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): there's one that um my friend Bernie told me about. that is not really like a smoke detector in like fire smoke, but if somebody's actually smoking in the house when they're renting the house as a smoke-free house. So I mean like cigarette smoke, cigar, or like these vape thingies and so forth. But I've been wondering because I think it's a great idea to basically if you're running a property like a hotel, quote unquote. that you wanna obviously try to keep it pristine and you can make everybody aware that these things are there. Obviously, like noise complaints could be a a real problem um in a neighbourhood and stuff.
30:39Tim Baldwin: Yeah.
30:39Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): But I wonder is are those things, even though they're technically available, are they uh suitable and usable for regular long term rentals? And and what would you as a lawyer say property management would have to do? You know, is it enough to just disclose that these systems exist and are being monitored, or is there anything else that that we would need to look for?
31:03Tim Baldwin: Yeah, in well in the lease that I've prepared, and it's an ever changing um or it's an ever improving document I because mean, of just how much I see in this business. But yes, I I put in certain certain uh provisions about um audible audible readers, noise readers, um, other, you know, like if you have a smart system, it has the following features, you know, you can send to the, you know, you know, these types of things. Um, the smoke this the smoke detectors that you mentioned are uh another great tool because many times it's difficult to actually prove, you know, did you smoke in here or not? You can say, Well, I smell something. I think well, that wasn't me, right? I mean, like all these issues. So, yes. Um, have I would put them in the lease to disclose these things and that the tenant actually agrees that they're uh that they can be used, uh, so long as they're not, of course, violating some statute that may apply. For example, I can't record what you're saying in your house, I can't record the uh you know the audio recording of your what you're saying, but I can I can record the decibel level.
32:07Yeah,
32:07Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): exactly.
32:07Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): The
32:08Tim Baldwin: decibel levels.
32:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah. Uh
32:09Tim Baldwin: so that way when there is a noise complaint and we get police out there, that's one of the most difficult things to prove is noise. Um and so having the decibel reader uh is one way of doing that.
32:21Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, my friend actually he has it actually set at a at a level where he basically gets a warning on his phone and then just calls the guest and s without even having anything from a neighbor to say and I don't know if this is ethically great, but he tells me he's calling them and say, Hey, a neighbor just called me and said it's a little loud, can you can you turn it down? Which doesn't involve the police or an actual living neighbor, but when I think his thing is I don't know, 75 seventy does five decibel or something like that. Um that is just under the point where you would say, okay, you know, they're having a massive party outs or something. He gets actually notified rather than the police or the security agency or anything like that.
33:06Tim Baldwin: Well I mean it's it's it is smart. I mean yeah you could call them and say hey I it was reported to me and it was reported to you by the
33:13Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): app.
33:13Tim Baldwin: But again it i it you know having the rules like if you if it's Airbnb type of thing, you know, you're gonna have your guest rules and you're gonna provide that to them uh whenever they book book the room or upon um upon um occupancy of of the place. Uh if it's a long term it's in the lease or some addenda that you may have that sp specifies these things. Um, you know, You know I've even seen case uh court cases where the court courts ordered some of these monitoring systems um to be installed whenever there was these issues uh in in in in litigation, which is very interesting. So uh it yeah these things can be done. Um I think it's smart to do that. I mean you have to look at what the um investment is because obviously it's gonna cost you money to do this, but I think as far as preventative maintenance and and liability reduction and all these types of other costs that are uh just looming over your head, I think it's a great way of of eliminating those types of or at least reducing those types of risks.
34:15Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, exactly. Well and I mean if you say, okay, what's my time horizon? And let's say I would love for having an average, let's I'm just picking it, between twenty-four and thirty-six months of a lease. per tenant. Right. And then you you figure out okay, how much would that actually increase the rent on a 30-year 30 month term? You will find out it's like really just maybe not even a handful of dollars when you add all these little gadgets together. Um, by the way, just for the audience, uh my Airbnb friend also told me and he said this has become a standard, is they have these electronic locks where you need a code to get in, and they now install cameras above the door on the outside to see if you basically booking for three people, but you're showing up with three people and six kids. You
35:09Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know,
35:09Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): But you mentioned occupancy. Is there actually I I'm I'm shocked to ask that, but if it feels to me at this moment that I never asked if somebody leases a house from me even if it's long term and they say okay, it's like me, my husband and the dog, is that really then the limit? Do I do I have any any kind of recourse if they suddenly have five kids that I didn't know about?
35:35Tim Baldwin: Yeah. Yeah, you do, because it's a con it's a contract. Uh the contract will s will determine who who's permitted to be there. Uh now with long term, you know, uh in your lease agreement, like with my lease, but it's with all pretty much any lease I've ever seen, is you have your your your stated tenants, um named tenants, and then you have your occup your approved occupants. So many times in a family situation that's children. Now there's fair housing, right? So fair housing does not pr uh allow you to uh deny uh residency for a family with children. So if you say, Well, we don't permit children, you can't do that, of course, unless it's a um it's a it's a um fifty five or sixty five year old uh plus community. Okay, you you
36:22Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): know there's an
36:23Tim Baldwin: exception for eight a for that.
36:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah,
36:25Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): I was
36:25Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): actually more so if
36:27Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): sorry, keep going.
36:29Tim Baldwin: No, go ahead. Go ahead.
36:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): If that is the case, wouldn't then the tenants also have to notify property management if they had a baby.
36:42Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Well,
36:42Tim Baldwin: if I mean they you may have to notify um you may have to give notification because the landlord has an interest in knowing who's there.
36:49Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right. So
36:50Tim Baldwin: if you if you
36:50Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): don't decide. disclose
36:51Tim Baldwin: who's
36:52Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): it might be a small occupant, but it's an additional occupant.
36:56Tim Baldwin: Yeah, it's an additional occupant. I mean, but that but just disclose, hey, we we have to know who's there, that that's a legitimate landlord interest, right? That that's not a problem. Um, so if they fail to do that and you learn that they fail to do that, well, it's curable, right? So you say, Okay, well give me give me the information. Who who do we have here? Um, you know, and I hate to say it, this sounds weird. Well, um, I've seen cases where we've had uh human trafficking scenarios, right?
37:30Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, and that's
37:31Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): probably a little extreme. I
37:32Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): think it it I think I I my first thought was a little bit less extreme, even though it's still extreme, is if there's like a fire or some kind of other emergency to at least have an idea who are the people that are supposed to be or actually associated with that unit.
37:48Tim Baldwin: Right. Right. Well yeah, and that's just another uh another good reason. But yeah. Yeah, but even with uh Airbnb or short term uh vacation type, yes, uh it's it's based on the agreement. So they say you're booking a room for three people. Uh now it th that I'm not sure that matters sometimes because if it's a six bedroom uh you know uh condo and they say three people and then they show up and there's only uh and there's six people I guess the question is was you know is the is the uh rental amount higher you know because if it's higher then obviously you know that that they would owe more and so for that you yes. But if it's if if it's um does it increase the price, maybe it doesn't matter, except that you cannot have too many people there because there's occupancy limits.
38:38Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah, a lot of people. I mean I look at
38:41Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): yeah, I I don't you're the lawyer. I I look at it through the same lens like I look at when a potential tenant asks me if a pet is allowed. Right. And I mean I'm not saying a child is a pet, don't get me wrong, but I'm saying okay, we are then nobody has an issue to say okay if you want to have a pet and the landlord allows it, it costs you X amount extra. Um the wear and tear, this is basically my my view, is the more people are using you something, the higher the wear and tear is. right? Like um, so from that perspective, it would be surprising if you kept the rent at the same level. Uh now if you have a property that is, I don't know, like a four-bedroom, two-bath, and there's two people that want to rent it, and you would rent it for the same price for four or five people, okay. I can I can see that, right? If the number of people is way smaller than the space allows. But if you have like let's say a two t or one bedroom apartment or studio or stuff like that and they want to stay there with three people, uh, you know, I I would say well that's questionable if even allowed, you know.
39:53Tim Baldwin: Yeah. Well, again, there's there's there's occupancy limitations. I mean, uh HUD will you know, they put out these standards for for HUD, you know. two persons per bedroom, right? That's that's been the standard for a long time. Um but but you know you first of all you cannot charge more for a family right you can't say well because you have two children I'm charging you more. You can't do that.
40:17Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um
40:18Tim Baldwin: if there's a if there's a legitimate in uh if there's a legitimate interest in uh wear and tear then theoretically the way that the landlord offsets that risk is through a security deposit, not not risk.
40:32Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Right,
40:32Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): right, yeah, yeah. That's true.
40:34Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): So
40:34Tim Baldwin: so that's that's sort of how you offset that um that situation. But um you do have to go by you do have to go by um oxy occupancy standards of your of your um local government, because there are likely occupancy standards. So that's the first thing to look at. Looking at fair housing, you know, and then also, you know, as I said, offsetting risk by um getting a security deposit that could be adequate for you.
41:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Right, yeah, absolutely. And thanks for correcting that. I mean, the thing about the security deposit is a little bit of a more and more sore Or a wound for me, because it used to be that if you got a month worth of security deposit, that if the if the tenant treated your property reasonably well, that was fine. But when I look at how much prices have increased, right, for everything you you need a plumber, you need an electrician, you need a carpenter, you need any kind of whatever, and you When think about okay, I have a property that gets like, let's say seventeen $1,700 hundred dollars rent, so I get seventeen $1,700. When when the tenants move out, even with relatively limited wear that is tenant cost and not normal wear and tear, a one month most of the time is not even coming close. But then on the flip side, we're getting back into To that affordability issue. that If you say I need two or three months, they just don't have it.
42:03Tim Baldwin: Yeah. Yeah, absolutely. That's that that is one that's the million-dollar question to to answer because um because you know, we we file lawsuits against tenants many times based on the situation you just described. They caused damage, uh the pro the uh deposit did not cover the expense, and so we sue them. You know, we sue them for the excess. A lot of landlords don't want to do that. because they're basically you're, you know, if you're going to use good money to chase after bad money, that's not a good decision. Uh any o too, they have these insurance programs now that are actually designed for the very thing you're talking about too. Um there's a variety of them out there, but they will they they will provide a certain amount of coverage for certain types of property damage, uh as well as back rent that was owed. and unpaid at when they left. So I think the insurance aspect of this is becoming more relevant because of what you described for the high the the cost of repairs going up considerably.
43:03Um, you know, so I I think landlords have to be smarter about it.
43:07Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, and I do this actually in in my Idaho uh cluster of properties. I have that insurance or basically offered through property management. One little thing for the audience I want to mention, because I always feel we want to have a fair relationship with our tenants, not a contested relationship. And what I don't like, and I think this is a matter of really checking the insurance policy, is there should be an agreed upon total amount that you're insured for. Because I had one situation in that cluster where a tenant has been in one of my houses for I think now three and a half years, and they have been paying for this insurance. But the insurance wanted to keep charging, even though they never missed a rent and they had barely any kind of repairs and stuff like that. And so the amount of money that basically went into the insurance got to like six m w rents. worth or something like that. And that is something I think
44:07tenants should be aware of that, you know, when when something like this insurance versus security deposit issue is offered, that you put a limit on it because I ultimately said, Okay, well, let's um terminate the insurance because it's really starting to harm the tenant. Um, you know, I I couldn't see any case where they would be ten thousand dollars in in the rears or need to have that much repair so stuff like that. You know, so there is there is a
44:35Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): little bit of a risk on
44:36Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): that end
44:38Tim Baldwin: well the in Florida the statute that was passed um allowing or not allowing it was already it was already allowed but of it, governing and regulating um fee in lieu of security deposit which is basically a way for the landlord or the tenant to purchase insurance, is that the tenant could convert the agreement into a traditional security deposit at any time during the tenancy. So like the situation you're describing is one that or the tenant may may be saying, you know what, I I don't um I don't need to keep paying this fee or the insurance costs because I'm a good tenant. I'm you know so on and so forth. I'm going to convert this now into a traditional deposit. So they have to notify the landlord. The amount of the security deposit has to be uh predetermined. Uh and so typically it's a one month deposit. So that's what they end up doing. And yeah, you're right. That could actually end up helping the tenant.
45:31Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, exactly. But the thing that people oftentimes um forget is this insurance policy, at least the one that they're probably that property management company had negotiated, was not like a whole life insurance policy where you basically say, Okay, I have a certain part for if I die and the other part is accumulating, kinda like a savings account. It was literally just charging a fee. So they had been paying something like a hundred dollars for three and a half years, and when they finally said, We don't think this is fair anymore, we want to do what you just suggested, all that money that they paid went basically disappeared. Right? Because the insurance company kept their money. They never put part of the payment aside for actual cases or any issues or so forth. So they had paid and paid and paid every month and and didn't really accumulate a deposit. And that was the misunderstanding and they were reasonably okay with it. I mean, they were somewhat angry, but not at me or not at our property management, more at the insurance company. But I think for the audience it's something to know if you go for these insurance things to really study in detail what it means. And for the tenant, because most of the time they're not insurance experts to tell them, okay, if this policy works this way, be aware. you know
46:51month after month after month you pay in and it's not accumulating it's just giving you a policy kind of like your car insurance right like if you don't have an accident then just money gone.
47:04Tim Baldwin: The insurance doesn't really give you a refund on that does it do they?
47:07Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Well and like I said I mean a lot of people think it's like whole life where you have a part that accumulates and a part that is for life insurance so to speak. And in these rental insurance policies it's not like that. It's literally just you have a policy that kicks in when there is a case, but if you never have a case, then the money is gone. Right.
47:31Tim Baldwin: Yeah. Yeah, that's right.
47:33Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Okay, well um as we're closing, Tim, one last thing, one one last suggestion or recommendation that you have for landlords or property managers in this context.
47:45Tim Baldwin: Yeah, well, I mean it's um document, document, document, getting uh good contracts in place, uh speaking with people who have experience, uh learning learning from other people's mistakes, watching the pitfalls, you know, having legal counsel, having CP. CPA, having property. I mean, all these things. It's the being in the landlord business is a it really is a high risk venture. Um and I don't not to scare people, but like, you know, it there's risk involved. Um, so you you really just need to treat it like you would any other business. Uh that for success, you've got to have certain things in place. So I would encourage listeners to do that. Find the right connections, find the people you like to work with. to and trust. Um, it can be set up um to where a lot of it is automated and it becomes seamless at some point. But um there's a lot of f sort of front end work to do it, uh uh front end work, but it's I think it's worth it.
48:40Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, absolutely. And I mean my piece of advice in the same context would be I mean, if you're in Florida, contact him and and let him review your your lease agreements and other contracts. But if not, I still feel and I do this all the time, even though I have been doing the the business for a long time, is if there's a document, have it checked by somebody who is a lawyer or a legal scholar or stuff like that, just to make sure that what you actually for yourself signing and then the other side is signing is actually legally sound or what the property management organization is putting out. because in a way they're putting it out for for you on your behalf, right? Um yes, they have certain obligations, but if it comes to like things like you mentioned, it's ultimately the owner's um height, so to speak, that people go after. Um one thing that I actually like in this context is to consider if you do something like legal zoom, legal shield, on something where you have property. proper legal review of
49:40documentation before you ever get to have to basically go to court. But from all the good things that you mentioned, and I mean obviously you have amazing contracts that you have developed and keep developing over the years. How can people get in touch if they say, Wow, this Tim guy knows this stuff? How can I tap into that?
50:01Tim Baldwin: Uh I think the best way we really is to go to our website, which is PM Law Solutions.com. Um, you can find me on LinkedIn, Tim Baldwin. Um, I'm I'm there too. So those are probably the two easiest ways actually uh to get a hold of me.
50:16Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Absolutely, yeah. And then we obviously put all of that in the show notes and the recording will actually show up on YouTube. So I have to do the old spiel, but if you're not a subscriber, please subscribe. thumbs up, um, shout out and comment and all the good things. But you also find in the notes all the information so that you can get in touch with Tim. So, Tim, thank you so much for being on the show again. Every something every time there's a little bit of new stuff to learn for all of us and for myself. So I'm very grateful.
50:48Tim Baldwin: Thank you. It's good to be on your show again.