Contractors misclassified as employees face payroll tax liabilities regardless of contract labels
Summary
Lee Woodward and Mai Harris discuss the risks of misclassifying contractors as employees, particularly regarding payroll tax liabilities triggered when group wages exceed jurisdictional thresholds. They explain that tax authorities like the ATO look at the substance of the relationship, such as control over hours and equipment, rather than the label 'independent contractor' in the agreement. The speakers propose a service agreement model where agents operate as independent businesses paying for facility use, mirroring GP practices to avoid employment classification. They cite the Thomas and Nez case where medical centers were liable for millions in payroll tax because revenue offices deemed doctors to be employees. The recommended structure involves agents signing client contracts under their own ABN and the agency invoicing for services, ensuring the agent is GST registered to claim expenses.
Key takeaways
- 1 The ATO looks at the substance of the relationship (control, uniform, equipment) rather than the label 'independent contractor' in the contract to determine employment status.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) · 2:19
- 2 'Internal conjunction arrangements' in real estate can cause agencies to pay payroll tax on agents' earnings even if those agents are paid purely on commission and do not receive wages.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) · 4:25
- 3 To prove independence, agents should hold their own ABN and sign client contracts (e.g., listing agreements) in their own entity name, rather than the agency's name.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) · 5:44
- 4 worth worth of of commission commission pool. pool, for example, and you provide the sales agent with $70,000, the business retained 30%, which is $30,000, but the you are actually not getting the full $30 because you still have to pay for rent, admin costs, marketing for the brand, and then technology costs, compliance costs, insurance, and training. On top of that, because they part of it's like a employment type arrangement, you still have to think that, okay, that commission that you pay them, they still attract 12% super. And what about payroll tax? And then on top of that, what about workers comp? So really you're not gonna be left with the full 30. And you just gotta be really careful that you need to get to the break even point.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) · 8:25
- 5 So it is important for the practitioner or the agent to be registered for GST.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) · 17:06
Episode sections
- 0:01 – 2:19
Introduction and Payroll Tax Thresholds
Lee Woodward and Mai Harris discuss the risks of misclassifying contractors as employees, specifically regarding payroll tax liabilities. They note that payroll tax is triggered when group wages exceed a threshold of $1.2 million, with a rate of 5.45% on the excess.
- 2:19 – 6:43
ATO Definition of Employees and Internal Conjunction
Mai Harris explains that the ATO has widened the definition of 'deemed employees,' meaning independent contractor agreements may be disregarded if the agency exerts full control (hours, uniforms, equipment). She highlights 'internal conjunction arrangements' in real estate, where commission-only agents can still trigger payroll tax liabilities for the agency.
- 6:43 – 11:45
Service Agreement Model vs. Commission Splits
The speakers propose a service agreement model where the agency provides facilities, admin, and brand, charging the agent a service fee rather than taking a commission split. This mirrors GP practices where doctors operate as independent businesses paying for facility use, thereby avoiding employment classification.
- 11:45 – 14:12
Case Study: Thomas and Nez and Medical Centers
Harris cites the 'Thomas and Nez' case where three medical centers were liable for millions in payroll tax because Revenue NSW deemed the doctors to be employees. This illustrates that written contracts do not override the substance of the working relationship in the eyes of tax authorities.
- 14:12 – 20:05
Implementation of Service Fees and GST
The recommended structure involves the agent signing client contracts under their own ABN. Funds flow through trust/clearing accounts, and the agency invoices the agent for services (e.g., 35% fee). The agent claims this as a business expense and must be GST registered to claim GST credits.
Claims worth verifying
Payroll tax is payable when group wages reach $1.2 million, at a rate of 5.45% on the amount exceeding that threshold.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·1:30
How to verify: Check the payroll tax threshold and rate for the relevant Australian state revenue office (e.g., NSW Revenue, SRO Victoria) for the relevant financial year. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The ATO has widened the definition of 'deemed employees' to include contractors who work under full control (specific hours, uniforms, equipment).
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·2:19
How to verify: Review ATO guidelines on 'Contractors and subcontractors' and 'Working with contractors' on ato.gov.au, specifically regarding 'employee advocacy' and 'sham contracting'. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceInternal conjunction arrangements in real estate can trigger payroll tax liabilities for agencies even if agents are commission-only.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·4:25
How to verify: Search for 'internal conjunction arrangements payroll tax' in state revenue office rulings (e.g., NSW Revenue, SRO Victoria) or ATO determinations. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Agents should sign sales contracts under their own ABN to prove they are not working for the agency.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·5:25
How to verify: Review standard real estate agency agreements and contract law principles regarding independent contractors and ABN usage in Australia. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The 'Thomas and Nez' case involved three medical centers liable for millions in payroll tax because Revenue NSW deemed doctors to be employees.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·11:45
How to verify: Search for 'Thomas and Nez' and 'payroll tax' in NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT) decisions or NSW Revenue case studies. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
In the proposed service model, the agency invoices the agent for services, and the agent claims this as an expense and GST credit.
Unidentified speaker (speaker_1) ·17:06
How to verify: Review ATO guidelines on 'GST for contractors' and 'Business structure' to confirm GST registration requirements and input tax credits for service fees. For recent events, verify 2026-08-18 through 2026-11-18. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceDo your own research
- Verify current payroll tax thresholds and rates with the specific state revenue office (e.g., Revenue NSW, SRO Victoria) as the $1.2 million threshold and 5.45% rate may be outdated or jurisdiction-specific.
- Review the ATO's 'Worker vs Contractor' guidelines and recent case law to understand how 'substance over form' is applied in employment status determinations.
- Examine the details of the 'Thomas and Nez' case study to understand the specific facts that led to the payroll tax liability for medical centers.
- Consult with a tax advisor to evaluate whether a service agreement model is appropriate for your business structure and to ensure compliance with GST registration requirements.
- Audit current commission splits against actual operating costs (rent, admin, marketing, compliance, super, payroll tax, workers comp) to assess financial viability.
- Check if 'internal conjunction arrangements' apply to your real estate agency model and trigger payroll tax liabilities on commission-only agents.
- Review existing contractor agreements to identify clauses that imply control (hours, uniforms, equipment) which could lead to reclassification as employees.
- Verify GST registration status for all contractors to ensure they can claim input tax credits on service fees, reinforcing their independent business status.
Full transcriptexpand
- 0:01
- Lee Woodward: Hello and welcome back to My Accounting Advantage. My name's Lee Woodward, your coach and host. And joining me today is the star of our podcast, My Harris. Mai, welcome back. Thank
- 0:13
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): you, Lee.
- 0:14
- Lee Woodward: Now I've been nervous to do today's podcast as I've had a career of train wrecks watching this happen happened in the real estate industry. So let's get straight into it. The contractor contract to cost costs nobody nobody budgeted for. What can we expect out of today's podcast?
- 0:30
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Okay. Today's podcast, we're going to be talking about it's like contractors versus employees. What are the differences? What are you really liable for when you have contractors working for your business? And I'm actually deliberately avoiding use the word employed here for contractors and
- 0:50
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): subcontractors. because you may think that you, you know, they're just working for the business and contract on like ad hoc basis, but that's not how the ATO sees it. And often you also liable for payroll tax for these people. Well,
- 1:07
- Lee Woodward: that's the elephant in the room, isn't it? Payroll tax. I remember being twenty twenty-four, four, twenty-five, working for my little real estate agency. and another couple of people joined, and another couple of people joined. And I remember the day that my principal said, Lee, I've just had a call from my accountant and we've got to pay payroll tax. Yeah. Because when we're under
- 1:26
- Lee Woodward: it, and what is that number when payroll tax must be paid?
- 1:30
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Well, it's 1.2 million. So if the overall Your group wages reaches that amount, that's when you pay 5.45% on what what's over it. That you get a threshold of 1.2, and then you need to pay 5.45% of payroll tax on the amount in excess of that threshold.
- 1:49
- Lee Woodward: Clarity.
- 1:57
- Lee Woodward: To pay payroll tax. But they didn't do it correctly because some massive fines right around the country.
- 2:03
- Lee Woodward: the biggest agency names we know, have been paying the fine because the contractor arrangement was not correct. Maya, you've been doing some amazing research on this and you've got come up with the solution at the same time. Where did they go wrong with the contractors?
- 2:19
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Well, with the contractors, they don't realise Realize that the HO ATO has widened the definition of DEM employees. So now these days, just having the independent subcontractor agreements or contractor agreements, that doesn't protect you. And the ATO can say, no, that's um not worth the
- 2:39
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): paper it's written on. Because you know, the arrangement that you have with that contractor, it looks like employer arrangement, it smells like one as well, and you have four. full control of that person. And that person has to, you know, come to work at specific hours. And they're wearing your
- 2:59
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): uniform. They're using your equipment. And you're saying that they're subcontractors? I don't think so. And in the past, you know, we seem to get away with it because it's not very clear. But now it's a very clear definition of what gets caught under the employee arrangement.
- 3:19
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): And also, if you unfortunately have disgruntled employees as well or subcontractors, and they may have been subcontracting for you in the past and you haven't been paying them super, and if they report you and they say, Look, you know, these business, this business has hasn't
- 3:39
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): paid me any em um employee super for the past four years, you could get an audit and you have to pay that back. That could really since the business.
- 3:50
- Lee Woodward: People have just pulled over their car right now, Mai. They're gonna listen to this intently. Another thing that popped up when all this was going on, the fines were going on, um the accountants missed it. Not you, but in the cases that I was in. involved in, it was like, how did this happen? And we're talking big fines, over a million dollars in
- 4:09
- Lee Woodward: fines for a business that is thinks it's got all these subcontractors and they're not. And as you just articulated, the ATO said, Don't care about your paperwork. This is what they're doing. The real estate industry said, Well, we'll make it a conjunction. But the conjunction take us into that.
- 4:25
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Well, with the like there's a specific ruling for this for their real estate world, and it is called internal conjunction arrangements. So it's actually arrangement that gets you caught um paying payroll tax. So you might thinking that you have an
- 4:45
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): arrangement where the independent salesperson work for your agency. but they're not. You know, they're actually getting their own clients, they're, you know, getting their own commission. They're not actually getting pay any wages. It's um they're just getting commission only. But the whole arrangements still get caught under
- 5:05
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): the internal conjunction arrangements, which means that the agency will be stuck paying the payroll tax for the all the agents that. that's on the books or just working within that agency.
- 5:19
- Lee Woodward: Is it true that you cannot have 80% of your income from one source?
- 5:25
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): That's correct. It's like a PSI rule. However, what you need to actually establish and prove is that your income is not actually from one source, it's from multiple listings. listing. But you need to be able to prove that and you need to be able to show that. So, you know, your sales contract, for
- 5:44
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): example, needs to be under your own entity, your own ABN, in order to prove that you're not working for that agency.
- 5:54
- Lee Woodward: Can both agents bear conjunction, meaning my ABN, the brand's ABN, and we're working on that one house together and the vendor pays both of us?
- 6:03
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, that actually thinking that's a gray area. So to me, having a separation, you know, that the agent is actually not working for the agency. They have their own listing and they have their own contract with the clients, that's much clearer. And that will
- 6:23
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): provide a definite proof that you're running your own business. but you're operating under the agency's umbrella and that's where I want to talk about the service arrangement where the agency provides the facility, the brand, the reputation, the marketing campaign, trust account,
- 6:43
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): etc. for the agent themselves. It's like you you're going into a GP practice, right? You're going You go in there, the GP themselves actually they're running their own individual mini business, and they go into a medical center as a facility. You know, they use the
- 7:03
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): medical center as a place for business. So they pay for the for the facility for the service of you know the receptionist, admin, paperwork, processing, and the doctor's rooms, etc. They it's like rent, but also plus service so that they can operate
- 7:23
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): the business. They don't have to worry about, you know, set up their own team. They just go into a place, they operate the business, and they earn money. And for the privilege Privilege and that them using the services for uh of the practice, the practice take a percentage. of their income and then the practice invoice them for
- 7:42
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): that service.
- 7:43
- Lee Woodward: My this is such an interesting moment because if we look at the traditional thinking, and I'm just gonna use seventy thirty as an example. But an agent thinks, you know, I sold the house and I gave away thirty percent and I get to keep seventy. Even that thinking's wrong because for the business owner, explain. out of that
- 8:03
- Lee Woodward: thirty percent it's not real.
- 8:05
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah. Well, especially if you actually the agency owner and, you know, you you're taking thirty percent cut out of a hundred and provide your sales agent with seventy. But really you're not getting the full Full thirty 30%. percent. So So just just imagine imagine there's there's a $100,000 hundred thousand dollars
- 8:25
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): worth worth of of commission commission pool. pool, for example, and you provide the sales agent with $70,000, the business retained 30%, which is $30,000, but the you are actually not getting the full $30 because you still have to pay for rent, admin costs, marketing for the brand,
- 8:45
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): and then technology costs, compliance costs, insurance, and training. On top of that, because they part of it's like a employment type arrangement, you still have to think that, okay, that commission that you pay them, they still attract 12% super. And what about payroll tax?
- 9:05
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): And then on top of that, what about workers comp? So really you're not gonna be left with the full 30. And you just gotta be really careful that you need to get to the break even point.
- 9:16
- Lee Woodward: Give us an example from one of our little example stories of agency A. Agency A operates as a real estate business using independent sales agents. Take us into this.
- 9:27
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yes. So I have been speaking to an agency owner and they're just wondering, you know, it doesn't look like we're making that much money. And why is that? Maybe you need to actually have a look at your commission split because really it looks like a lot of the operating costs, such
- 9:47
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): as what I mentioned before, hasn't been built in into that 30% or whatever, like 25. And it depends on what the arrangement that you have with your sales agent. And so it's the realization. that, you know, you need to work backwards at what profit do you
- 10:07
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): actually need to make. And then whether or not that split makes sense. Because what has been set before may not really be the right ratio that you need to charge the salesperson. sales person
- 10:23
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Because, as you know, the operating costs are increased. increasing each year and the percentage still stay the same. The sp percentage spit split. So that doesn't make sense.
- 10:35
- Lee Woodward: And the agents are demanding more and certain agencies that haven't listened to this audio are providing it and no one's gonna win out of that. Because when you look at office facilities, admin marketing technology, CRM training, compliance support, transaction administration. trust account details.
- 10:52
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): AML, there's more.
- 10:53
- Lee Woodward: AML. There is so much to keep that going. This isn't just a real estate problem. Many businesses or practices, and practices is a good word, yeah. Are set up in that way.
- 11:05
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, it's it's really is because you know, a lot of practice owners, especially in the medical space, like I've been working with psychologists, VCO, and they provide the rooms and the admin team for the physicians. And then they're saying, Look, it doesn't
- 11:25
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): even look like we are making enough money to cover the operating costs. And then on top of that, they actually have to be careful that, you know, the em well, I keep saying employment arrangement, but it should not be an employment arrangement. But the contractors agreement and the arrangement that they have may
- 11:45
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): even got caught in the you know the payroll. In recent case, it's called Thomas and Nez case, where there were three where there were three medical centers centres that got caught under payroll tax and had to pay. back millions in payroll
- 12:05
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): liabilities. Why? It's because the way they offer, you know, this their services to the doctors and the Service New South Wales, Revenue New South Wales, sorry, actually deem them to have employed the doctors under the payroll tax rule. You can imagine
- 12:25
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): doctors are getting paid a lot of money. So which means that the medical center group themselves had to pay millions in payroll tax.
- 12:34
- Lee Woodward: How frightening. And yet everyone would have said we've got an agreement, we've got a contract, we've written not worth the paper it's written on. Because the ATO said no. You've employed doctors, they're sitting in this building and the super's gonna have to be paid.
- 12:47
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah well that's that's the problem right because it's they their interpretation, your interpretation. So you need to make sure that you can prove that the arrangement is definitely not an employee employer arrangement. And the contract needs to be clear. The way the payments are
- 13:07
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): split needs also be clear. And that's why the service model really, to me, bypassed those laws.
- 13:15
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): because that's how it should be. That the practice themselves provide the facility for the doctors to operate from. So the doctors pay for the services and the facility, and there's invoice between the two parties. There's clear definition on the arrangement so
- 13:35
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): that the ATO and Revenue New South Wales can. really see that the doctors or the sales agent actually operating their own independent businesses.
- 13:46
- Lee Woodward: Well, let's go back to this proposed solution for the real estate industry. And everyone's definitely pulled their car over now to go, how do we do it? And not have to pay these payroll tax because we do want to have a real agreement and we want the agent. agents to have the benefits of running their own business because there is
- 14:06
- Lee Woodward: tax advantages there. But we're all going to come together under the one brand. Take us into the proposed solution.
- 14:12
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, so the proposed solution that I would like to recommend for you know people who offered the facility to, you know, sales agents or medical practitioners to consider provide them provide the the contractors with a service agreement. Basically, the service agreement
- 14:32
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): identify clearly what um product and services you are providing to them. Number one is the facility and your administration side, which is your receptionist, you know, your bookkeeper, and like your trust account is being looked up. after and reconciled,
- 14:52
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): audited, etc. And so there's a business unit that you pay to provide you with the right facility to operate your business. And then you actually operate under that brand. That's okay because you're leveraging from the brand reputation and goodwill. And then
- 15:12
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): you also remunerate them by paying the service fee for using those things. So for example, you when you also, if you're a real estate agent and um you sign a sales agreement, you need to have your own separate entity that signed the sales agreement with your clients under your own entity.
- 15:32
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): And that really displays that you are performing an independent service and you're not working for the agency itself. And then you will also maybe even employ your own team, etc. But if you don't want to have that administration, you need some sort of arrangement
- 15:52
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): for someone to do the admin for you, that's fine too. So you operating your own units. But what that does is actually detach the agency from employee your arrangement and then on top of that the benefit here is the relationship is clear and we can
- 16:11
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): identify the separation and you'll be able to prove that you don't even need to pay for payroll tax super and workers comp. So that can be a big deal for an agency.
- 16:25
- Lee Woodward: Emile Emma, you've done great research into this and actually doing this right now, you've drawn up the legal agreements, you've gone deep into the problem. But let's just go for an example. I've just sold a house and I work under your brand. The money's gone into the trust account, which is and the property is now settled. Yeah. The money would then come out of the trust
- 16:45
- Lee Woodward: account into a clearing account.
- 16:46
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yes, and to we it the money will go into a business account. And then the admin person would just work out, you know, the service fee percentage that you agreed with the contractor. And then, you know, they will deduct that that percentage out being the service fee. And then they will issue an invoice,
- 17:06
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): like a you know, like a service fee invoice. It could be weekly, could be monthly, and then you know the agent will just claim that as an expense and also claim GST on it as well. So it is important for the practitioner or the agent to be registered for GST.
- 17:26
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): And then you you operating your own business unit then because it's all separated.
- 17:33
- Lee Woodward: So we've got the client, we've got the income coming in, the business independence has happened. We have a service agreement. It's not a commission split. It's a service agreement of what I'm paying. And I think that's a defining moment. Traditionally, the agency, I've sold it, I'm giving away a bit. Versus, no, I I I pay a service fee. And
- 17:52
- Lee Woodward: it can be per deal or it could be a monthly retainer and then there's a a balance that is adjusted. Yeah. Is that possible?
- 17:59
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): Yeah, it is possible. So it depends on how the say for a real estate agent, how the agent uses the facility. You know, sometimes you can you just briefly w use the facility for a short period of time or you actually want to be in that agency group. So that creates flexibility as well. So if the agent
- 18:19
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): wants to sort of hop around for a little bit, that creates f fre flexibility. And that's the same as my medical practitioners. They might be the physio or the psychologist. They can hop around medical practices because of that arrangement, the clear service arrangements. So if they come in and they use the
- 18:39
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): facility, they use the room, they just, you know, pay the facility fee of X amount, say 35%, and they could be there for two days. But that depends on how much they earn. And and then they'll go to another practice and do the same thing. So that creates flexibility for the agency owner, the
- 18:59
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): practice owner to earn more income that way. And also, you know, the clear flexibility for the agency and the practitioners. So I think that's a win-win.
- 19:09
- Lee Woodward: My everything's been very well explained. Give us your final words.
- 19:13
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): My
- 19:14
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): final word here.
- 19:15
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): is if you are paying contractors a commission or percentage, don't just look at the percentage. Look at the true cost of the arrangement. And if you actually like the idea of the service fee and you want to know how to structure that together, you can get in touch with us at my accounting advantage.
- 19:35
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): And uh and I'll be happy to just, you know. um guide you through that but the important thing is you need to have the arrangement in mind how you want it to work and also we need to put together a legal document that reflects that arrangement. My
- 19:52
- Lee Woodward: Harris a very very important podcast today and thank you for all your research and documentation and I look forward to next week.
- 20:00
- Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Thank
- 20:00
- Unidentified speaker (speaker_1): you Lee I'll be here