Podcast discusses asset allocation principles, historical performance data, and rebalancing strategies.
Summary
Paul Moffitt and Jordan define asset allocation as the division of investments among stocks, bonds, and cash, emphasizing that no single allocation fits all investors. They present historical data from 2000 to 2025 showing that a 100% stock portfolio yielded 10.08% annual returns with a 38% worst-year loss, while a 60/40 portfolio returned 7.57% with a 23% loss, and a 100% bond portfolio returned 3.79% with a 5.18% loss. The speakers argue that while bonds reduce volatility, their returns may barely outpace the 2.5% historical inflation rate, creating longevity risk. They assert that allocation should be determined by individual factors like retirement dates and income sources rather than age alone. Finally, they highlight the importance of rebalancing portfolios to manage drift caused by market movements.
Key takeaways
- 1 generally provides a longer-term growth potential. And bonds generally provide income and help prov reduce against portfolio volatility.
Jordan · 1:45
Episode sections
- 0:28 – 3:15
Introduction and Definition of Asset Allocation
Paul Moffitt and Jordan introduce asset allocation as the division of investments among stocks, bonds, and cash, noting that individual goals and risk tolerance dictate the mix.
- 3:15 – 5:47
Historical Performance of Hypothetical Allocations
Jordan presents 2000-2025 data showing 100% stocks returned 10.08% (38% worst loss), 60/40 returned 7.57% (23% worst loss), and 100% bonds returned 3.79% (5.18% worst loss).
- 5:47 – 7:15
Inflation, Longevity, and Risk Trade-offs
The speakers discuss how bond returns may barely exceed the 2.5% inflation rate, creating longevity risk where portfolios fail to preserve purchasing power.
- 7:15 – 8:49
Factors Determining Allocation Beyond Age
Jordan explains that retirement dates, income sources, and financial position determine risk capacity, making age an insufficient sole determinant for allocation.
- 8:49 – 10:01
Rebalancing and Portfolio Drift
The hosts conclude by explaining how market movements cause portfolio drift and stress the importance of rebalancing while considering taxes and costs.
Claims worth verifying
Asset allocation is defined as how investments are divided among stocks, bonds, and cash.
Jordan ·1:25
How to verify: General financial planning definitions; no specific filing required, but consistent with standard industry terminology. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Primary sourceA 100% stock portfolio had an average annual calendar year return of 10.08% from 2000 to 2025.
Jordan ·3:35
How to verify: Calculate the compound annual growth rate (CAGR) of a total stock market index (e.g., CRSP US Total Market) using data from Dimensional Fund Advisors or CRSP for the period 2026-2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The worst year for a 100% stock portfolio was a loss of 38% during the financial crisis.
Jordan ·3:55
How to verify: Check the annual return of a broad US stock market index for 2026, which saw a decline of approximately 37-38%. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
A 60/40 stock-bond portfolio had an average annual return of 7.57% and a worst-year loss of 23% during the financial crisis.
Jordan ·4:34
How to verify: Calculate the CAGR and worst-year return for a portfolio weighted 60% in a US stock index and 40% in a US aggregate bond index over the specified period. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
A 100% bond portfolio had an average annualized return of 3.79% and a worst-year loss of 5.18%.
Jordan ·4:54
How to verify: Calculate the CAGR and worst-year return for a US aggregate bond index (e.g., Bloomberg US Aggregate Bond) for the period 2026-2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
The historical annual inflation rate is about 2.5%.
Jordan ·6:04
How to verify: Calculate the average annual inflation rate using the US Bureau of Labor Statistics Consumer Price Index (CPI) data for the period 2026-2026. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Age alone is not a determinant for investment allocation.
Jordan ·7:22
How to verify: This is a philosophical/strategic claim made by the speaker; it is not a verifiable fact but a stated principle of their financial planning approach. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Market performance can cause a portfolio to drift from its intended mix.
Jordan ·8:54
How to verify: Mathematical fact: if one asset class outperforms another, its weight in the portfolio increases relative to the target allocation without rebalancing. For recent events, verify 2026-08-20 through 2026-11-20. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.
Do your own research
- Verify Dimensional Fund Advisors data for the 2000-2025 performance metrics cited.
- Check current inflation rates against the cited 2.5% historical average.
- Review personal retirement timeline and income sources to assess true risk capacity.
- Calculate potential tax implications and transaction costs before rebalancing.
- Compare personal asset allocation against the hypothetical 100/60/40/0 models presented.
- Assess whether current portfolio drift aligns with stated investment goals.
- Research specific bond yields relative to current inflation expectations.
- Confirm that the speakers' definitions of 'longevity risk' match personal financial planning assumptions.
Full transcriptexpand
0:02Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Hello and welcome to the AristaWealth Podcast, where we focus on your finances, wellness, and lifestyle. So you can focus on living your dreams. We'll help you navigate through important topics so that you can elevate your life and financial health.
0:17Paul Moffitt: Hello, welcome to AristaWealth Podcast. This is episode 117. This is Paul Moffitt, your host, and I'm joined today with Director of Financial Planner Jordan. Jordan, good to have you. Welcome.
0:26Jordan: Excited to be here for this episode, Paul.
0:28Paul Moffitt: Good to have you. And uh always fun to jump into uh financial topics that are near and dear to our heart. And uh in today's episode, we would like to come back to what we discussed um in prior podcasts, which is what are the ingredients of a portfolio? And today let's look at that stock and bond mix, the two largest assets. in the world, uh, and discuss what asset allocation is best and going to enable uh our investors and prospective investors to be able to sleep at night. So, Jordan, what is the mix inside of a portfolio?
1:05Jordan: Yeah, that's a uh interesting question, Paul. And you know, we're talking about one of the most important decisions when it comes to investing and how much of your portfolio should be invested in bonds and stocks. And the answer is there's not a one size fits all. Uh, everyone has different goals and risk tolerances and time horizons. And so uh we're going to look how different allocations have performed historically in the trade-offs between risk and return and why choosing the right mix is an important financial planning. And so when we think of allocation, uh, that's just a fancy way of saying how are investments divided amongst stocks, bonds, and cash, generally speaking. And so uh for our newer listeners, uh, the idea of stocks is it generally provides a longer-term growth potential. And bonds generally provide income and help prov reduce against portfolio volatility. And so the allocation is one of the biggest drivers to uh uh a portfolio's risk in and return.
2:00Paul Moffitt: Yeah, so well put. So well put. And um whether you're uh a college student or you're receiving an inheritance or you're looking to retire and enjoy you know the fruit of your labor, we're really big in saying, you know, generate income, keep your income, and then enjoy the income and or you know make the money, keep the money and then maintain the money, it that where you are then determines on what allocation you have from a risk portfolio of ten point oh out of ten or zero risk out of ten. And sometimes that's a greater risk than um a three or four because you've got so much in bonds that are susceptible to the economic ups and downs. But it uh does determine and it is based upon, you know, your outlook, your comfort level, your cash, your earning potential, and so many other things.
3:03Walk us through um, you know, hypothetical six different uh allocations from two thousand to two thousand and twenty five.
3:11Jordan: Yeah. Jordan? Memory lane and when we uh take an inventory of some of the largest uh fund managers out there. In this particular case we'll utilize dimensional funds. We really uh uh have high esteem for uh for this fund family. They uh they utilize an approach that's near and dear to our heart of long-term uh a disciplined investment approach. And so we'll take a look at the past twenty 25 five and twenty 26 six years. And so um, when we look at a hundred percent stock portfolio, the average rate of return has just been slightly over 10%, about 10.08% has been the annual uh annual calendar year return. Uh, but that comes with a caveat of one of the worst years. Uh, the portfolio is down 38%. And uh many are of our investors can remember the financial. crisis, and it was not a pretty time to be in the stock market. There was a lot of uncertainty and anxiety. Uh, we've been through very similar crisis of the COVID pandemic and Brexit. Um, uh, but that
4:14was one of the worst ones where the portfolio was down close to 40%. Now, um, as investors feel like, okay, maybe 100% stock portfolio is a bit too much risk, uh, we hear a lot in the news. about the 60-40. So 60% of your portfolio is offensive and the other 40% is defensive. So think of stocks as offense and bonds as defense. Your average rate of return is now about 7.57%. However, the worst year was still during uh the financial crisis, but instead of down close to 40%, it's only down 23%. Uh and then in contrast to an all-stock portfolio, a hundred percent bond portfolio, your average rate of return annualized is 3.79%. And the worst year was only negative 5.18%. And so these are all hypothetical all hypothetical allocations. And so Uh there's no guarantee for future returns, but the uh general um understanding. is the the higher returns, uh uh you have to be uh
5:19accepting a greater amount of risk.
5:22Paul Moffitt: Yeah. 100%. And the importance of um every portfolio is customized and built around the needs of every client and every investor that we work with. There is no, you know. co uh cookie cutter or one size fits all. But um walk us through the smaller loss was still a loss.
5:47Jordan: Yeah. Yeah. It definitely was, Paul. And another way for our uh listeners to think about this is we're talking about returns in a vacuum, but what about inflation? Yeah. So when we think of a bond returning uh an average three 3.79%, the historical annual inflation rate has been about two and a half percent. So when you take a look at your real return, uh it's not much better than just treading water in a portfolio. And so for many of our clients, we can't accept just an all-star all bond portfolio because uh we need to position them for some level of returns because what we've seen and with the advances of medicine, is uh longevity is definitely a concern. And inflation is a real thing. Just take a look at your grocery bill from 10 years ago.
6:37Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Uh
6:37Jordan: and when you go to the grocery store today, $100 does not get you nearly as much as uh as it did a number of years ago. So when we think of, okay, maybe I don't want to take on a bunch of risk, but I would argue that may transform your. risk to longevity risk. So when it comes to creating a portfolio, there is, uh to your point, Paul, not a one size fits all.
6:57Paul Moffitt: That's right. That's right. And time horizon, capacity for loss,
7:02Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh,
7:02Paul Moffitt: expectation of losses, and how long those losses uh are extended and the duration of them is really that stress test, or as we call it, the boat drill,
7:12Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh,
7:12Paul Moffitt: just talking reality. Um and question, Jordan, is could two people the same age uh expect different allocations?
7:22Jordan: The the answer is yes, Paul. Uh and it comes it comes from many different angles. And so age alone isn't a determinant for investment allocation. We have many awesome clients who are you know in their eighties 80s or even nineties and they have portfolio allocations that we would deem are relatively aggressive, but uh based off of their financial position, we're comfortable uh with with a bit more stock risk. And so age alone is not a determinant investment allocation. There you there are rules of thumbs, generally speaking. Um, but uh uh folks have different uh retirement dates, income sources, spending needs. Uh someone with a pension may have more flexibility. for investment risk. Someone relying heavily on the portfolio may need greater sustainability. So uh there's not a one size fits all. Just like when you go to the dentist, uh, you know, your teeth are not the same as the other uh the the same patient who's the same age as you they may have a uh different circumstances and it's very similar to the portfolio.
8:26Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Yeah.
8:26Paul Moffitt: And different treatment plans.
8:27Jordan: And different treatment
8:28Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): plans, exactly.
8:30Paul Moffitt: And or battle plans, as we say. Yeah. So wonderful. And um uh final question, Jordan, is you know, comparing the current mix with the intended mix, uh, walk us through how important it is to then provide an update and check in on these different portfolios and the allocations that we have to. match and to meet the expectations.
8:54Jordan: It's extremely important, Paul. And comparing your current allocation versus your targeted allocation is a process at Arista that we follow uh very stringently. And so market performance can cause your portfolio to drift from its intended mix. As an example, if the market's doing extremely well, you're gonna going have to stock drift and vice versa. if the market is not doing well, uh, you may have a a drift towards bonds because the representation of stocks is diminished. And so there are opportunities to rebalancing and to maintain your desired level of risk. And so uh our listeners and investors and clients need to think through taxes, transaction costs, account types before making any changes and review the allocation as financial. goal and review your allocations as financial goals and circumstance changes. So uh uh an audit of the portfolio is it is definitely needed.
9:50Paul Moffitt: Thank you for joining us. Visit AristaWelp.com and don't forget to like, subscribe and share. And until next time, AristaWelp Arista Welp is here to help you live a life of significance.