First Trust ROI Podcast

Dennis Hammond discusses faith-based investing, AI ethics, and performance screening at the Vatican

34 min Listen to the original
Faith-Based InvestingArtificial IntelligenceESGVaticanEthical ScreeningPerformance Analysis

Summary

Dennis Hammond of First Trust’s Faith Solutions Group discusses the intersection of faith-based investing and artificial intelligence. He recounts presenting research at the Vatican on Pope Leo XIV's encyclical 'Magnifica Humanitas,' which draws parallels between the Industrial Revolution and AI's threat to human dignity. Hammond explains that faith-based portfolios use commercial databases like MSCI to screen out companies violating specific religious guidelines, contrasting this with secular ESG approaches. He cites a 10-year study showing that excluded 'bad actors' significantly underperformed benchmarks, suggesting faith-based screens can maintain performance while adhering to ethical standards.

Episode sections

  1. 0:12 – 4:01

    Introduction and Vatican Presentation

    The host introduces Dennis Hammond from First Trust’s Faith Solutions Group to discuss faith-based investing and AI alignment. Hammond recounts how he unexpectedly presented his paper on Catholic investing at the Vatican after the original presenter handed it off to him.

  2. 4:01 – 5:35

    Pope Leo XIV's Encyclical and AI Ethics

    Hammond discusses Pope Leo XIV's encyclical 'Magnifica Humanitas,' issued 135 years after 'Rerum Novarum.' He contrasts the Industrial Revolution's threat to jobs with AI's threat to human dignity and the rise of transhumanism, emphasizing the need to align AI with humanity's well-being.

  3. 5:35 – 24:00

    Faith-Based Screening Methodology

    Hammond explains how faith-based portfolios differ from standard benchmarks like the S&P 500 by excluding companies that violate specific religious guidelines. He notes that screens are sourced from commercial databases (MSCI, Invest with Purpose, Bright Light) and applied based on specific faith guidelines like the USCCB or Vatican standards.

  4. 24:00 – 26:37

    ESG vs. Faith-Based Investing

    The speakers compare ESG to faith-based investing, noting that ESG has fallen out of favor due to political associations, whereas faith-based investing is customizable to specific religious doctrines. Hammond emphasizes that faith-based screens are not secular and allow for nuanced prioritization of sins or ethical concerns.

  5. 26:37 – 33:34

    Performance Impact of Screening

    Hammond addresses the cost of screening, stating that tracking error is typically 60-80 basis points for Catholic portfolios and 40-50 for Protestant ones. He cites a 10-year study showing that excluding 'bad actors' resulted in those excluded stocks significantly underperforming benchmarks, allowing optimized faith-based portfolios to match benchmark performance.

Assets discussed

AssetKindStanceContext
S&P 500indexneutralUm just for uh to sort of set the stage for us, can you describe what that actually looks like? How does that how does that differ from just buying the S P 500?

“Stance” is how the speakers talked about the asset, not a recommendation.

Claims worth verifying

Dennis Hammond wrote a paper on Catholic investing using USCCB guidelines and presented it at the Vatican.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·1:50

How to verify: Search for papers by Dennis Hammond or First Trust Faith Solutions Group presented at the Vatican or related to USCCB guidelines. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Pope Leo XIV issued the encyclical 'Magnifica Humanitas' 135 years after Pope Leo XIII issued 'Rerum Novarum'.

Dennis Hammond ·4:16

How to verify: Check the publication date of 'Magnifica Humanitas' and 'Rerum Novarum' via Vatican.va or Catholic news archives. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

First Trust licenses screening databases from MSCI, Invest with Purpose, and Bright Light.

Dennis Hammond ·7:47

How to verify: Review First Trust's methodology documents or investor presentations regarding their faith-based screening data sources. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Tracking error for Catholic portfolios is typically 60 to 80 basis points, while Protestant portfolios are 40 to 50 basis points.

Dennis Hammond ·27:27

How to verify: Review First Trust's faith-based fund prospectuses or performance reports for tracking error statistics. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

A 10-year study (40 quarters) of USCCB-screened S&P 500, MSCI World, and ACWI ex-US portfolios showed the screened-out stocks underperformed the benchmarks.

Dennis Hammond ·28:27

How to verify: Locate the specific paper by Dennis Hammond on First Trust's website or SEC filings if published as a prospectus supplement. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Primary source

Optimized faith-based portfolios were within 20 basis points of the benchmark performance in the study.

Dennis Hammond ·29:53

How to verify: Refer to the performance results section of the aforementioned study paper. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Pope Leo XIV is the current Pope who issued 'Magnifica Humanitas'.

Dennis Hammond ·4:16

How to verify: Verify the current Pope's name and recent encyclicals via Vatican.va (Note: As of 2026, Pope Francis is the Pope; this claim may reflect a future scenario or ASR error for Pope Francis or a hypothetical context in the transcript's release date of 2026). For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Anthropic's chief alignment officer agreed with a former employee's concern about a 10% chance of ASI destroying humanity.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·16:10

How to verify: Search for news reports regarding an Anthropic employee resignation and statements from Anthropic's leadership on AI risk. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

The USCCB has Socially Responsible Investing Guidelines.

Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN) ·1:50

How to verify: Access the USCCB website to view their Socially Responsible Investing Guidelines. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Vatican has a group called 'Mensrum Bonum' (Latin for good measure from Luke 6:38).

Dennis Hammond ·8:46

How to verify: Search for Vatican documents or groups named 'Mensuram Bonam' or similar related to investment guidelines. For recent events, verify 2026-08-12 through 2026-11-12. Use another period only when the speaker explicitly names it.

Do your own research

  • Verify the existence and text of Pope Leo XIV's encyclical 'Magnifica Humanitas' and its specific teachings on AI.
  • Check the current USCCB Socially Responsible Investing Guidelines to understand the specific exclusion criteria used in the cited study.
  • Review First Trust's faith-based fund prospectuses to confirm the use of MSCI, Invest with Purpose, and Bright Light databases for screening.
  • Analyze the methodology of the 10-year study cited by Hammond to ensure the 'bad actor' underperformance is statistically significant and not due to sector concentration.
  • Research the definition and current status of Artificial Superintelligence (ASI) and the claims made by Anthropic regarding alignment risks.
  • Compare the tracking error figures (60-80 bps for Catholic, 40-50 bps for Protestant) against current faith-based ETF performance data.
  • Investigate the political and secular associations of ESG that Hammond claims have caused it to fall out of favor, using recent market data.
  • Look for conflicts of interest regarding First Trust's licensing of screening databases and their impact on fund construction.
Full transcriptexpand
0:12
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): As society grapples with the issues surrounding the development of advanced AI models, one of the questions at hand is whose values and whose core beliefs do those models reflect? In other words, questions of alignment. This is also an issue for many investors in institutions as they consider their portfolios. How do those
0:32
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): portfolios reflect their views and their beliefs? Joining me today is Dennis Hammond from the First Trust Faith Solutions Group to discuss these issues and to talk a little bit about a paper that he recently presented at the Vatican on Catholic investing. We're also going to take a little bit closer look at how faith leaders like the Pope are
0:52
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): interacting with issues like artificial intelligence and the development of those models. And we're going to talk about how what the implications are for investors that are screening for faith-based screens. Thanks for joining us on this episode of the First Trust ROI podcast. Thank you for agreeing to come on the podcast. It's uh
1:11
Dennis Hammond: thank you, Ryan, for inviting me. That's
1:12
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): awfully
1:13
Dennis Hammond: kind of you.
1:13
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): It's
1:13
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): it's been kind of a long time coming. We've talked about um trying to figure out a time where you and I would be in the same place where we could have this this conversation. So I'm glad we were able to work it out. Um and I just heard something somewhat recently uh about you and and I think that's a good way to start a conversation. Um you were recently at the
1:33
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Vatican and ended up presenting a paper there related to um Facebook faith-based investing, Catholic faith-based investing. So uh take us through that. How how how in the world did you end up presenting a paper at the Vatican?
1:47
Dennis Hammond: So I had written a paper on
1:50
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
1:50
Dennis Hammond: Catholic investing using what they call the USCCB, uh United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, Socially Responsible Investing Guidelines. I wrote it earlier this year. We looked at 10 years worth of uh data on three major indices. At any rate, I was asked to go to the
2:10
Dennis Hammond: Vatican, but not to speak, not to talk about the paper, just to be there.
2:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): For
2:14
Dennis Hammond: a mensorum bonum conference. So I got on the bus. We're riding up to the top of the hill, which is where Galileo, by the way, presented his uh thesis that the sun. actually does not revolve around the earth and was thrown out for that uh that wild heretical notion. But at any
2:34
Dennis Hammond: rate,
2:35
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
2:35
Dennis Hammond: got on the bus and introduced myself to the guy beside me. And uh I said, So what are you doing here? And he said, Well, I'm presenting a paper. Well, he says, Who are you? What are you doing? All right, I'm Dennis Hammond, I'm with First Trust. I'm doing, I'm just here to listen. I said, What are you presenting? He said, Oh, I'm presenting a paper
2:55
Dennis Hammond: on Catholic performance with the USCCB. I said, That's so unusual. I wrote a paper on that earlier this year. He said, Hold it. Who'd you say you were with? I said, First Trust. He said, That that's the paper I'm presenting. I'm presenting your paper. He said, Would you mind? instead of me
3:15
Dennis Hammond: doing it, would you mind doing it? I said, Well, sure. Happy to do it. So we walked in, as it turned out, he handed it off to me and I I ended up having the opportunity to make the presentation at the Vatican. So it was kind of an unusual series of events, but we I
3:35
Dennis Hammond: enjoyed it.
3:36
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): And uh so how long was the standing ovation? from the Pope after you presented that? Was it
3:41
Dennis Hammond: No, I don't think so, but but what did what was important wasn't the trip so much as as the fact that uh getting to see how faith based performance screening was meaningful and material to uh the people there led me to think that maybe I should
4:01
Dennis Hammond: expand this to faith-based screening in AI. As you know, the day before, maybe two days before Pope Leo the 14th had just
4:16
Dennis Hammond: 135 years after Pope Leo XIII issued Rerum Rayum Nobarum, Pope Leo XIV issued Magnifica Humanicas, the humanic. Humanitas on artificial intelligence. And um
4:32
Dennis Hammond: so this trip
4:34
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
4:34
Dennis Hammond: the Vatican convinced me that this is something that we need to study. This is something that we're all going to be involved in. And the question is: how does it impact our institutional investment management? What should we be thinking about? What are the pitfalls? Should we try to avoid any company that has
4:53
Dennis Hammond: AI?
4:55
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Of
4:55
Dennis Hammond: course, the answer to that is it's impossible. You
4:59
Dennis Hammond: can't do it. You can't buy today a company that doesn't use AI. So the better question is: can you differentiate among those companies that use AI and those companies that use AI in a way that will harm humanity. It's this latter crowd
5:19
Dennis Hammond: that we want to focus on when it comes to screening our portfolios. If there is harm to humanity in some way, we want to avoid that. We certainly don't want to fund it or finance it. So um
5:33
Dennis Hammond: that's what came out of this for me.
5:35
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Okay, so let's let's take a step back. Um your day job is um you know you you're you're working for the uh Faith Solutions group at First Trust, where um creating portfolios, they're screened based on the the the beliefs and the values of certain faith, certain groups
5:54
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): of people. Um just for uh to sort of set the stage for us, can you describe what that actually looks like? How does that how does that differ from just buying the S P 500? How do you get to a portfolio that's screened?
6:08
Dennis Hammond: It's a great question. When you invest in the S P 500, you own all the companies that are in that benchmark, same with any of the other benchmarks. Those benchmarks don't always include companies that um
6:23
Dennis Hammond: comply with your faith. So if you are a Catholic, for instance, uh those benchmarks will include companies that provide abortion or that use stem cell, that do stem cell research that uses fetal tissue or embryonic tissue. If you're a Protestant, uh uh a Protestant conservative,
6:43
Dennis Hammond: it'll include companies that produce alcohol, tobacco, uh that run gambling, or produce pornography. If you're a um progressive Protestant, it will include companies that are antagonistic to your faith for other reasons, such as environmental or social justice. So the notion
7:03
Dennis Hammond: is always
7:05
Dennis Hammond: what companies in this benchmark, I want to get exposure to the benchmark. My my asset allocation suggests that I should have exposure exposures to large cap stocks, mid-cap stocks, so forth. And I want to get those exposures, but not at the cost of owning a company
7:24
Dennis Hammond: antagonistic to my faith.
7:28
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Where do the sorts of screens for each of those groups come from? You know, for example, uh where do the Catholic screens come from relative to the
7:38
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Catholic?
7:39
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Protestant screens? Or um, you know, if you were to rope in um maybe some of the other faiths, where are those screens coming from?
7:46
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): All
7:47
Dennis Hammond: right, that's great. Let's sort this into two questions. We have the source of the screens and the source of the guidelines to use the screens. So the screen sources are commercial databases. MSCI has one, Invest with Perse. Purpose, Bright Light. We license all three of
8:06
Dennis Hammond: those. So we have hundreds of screens available to us. The guidelines are the application of the screens to your particular portfolio. So if you were a an evangelical or if you were a Lutheran or if you were a Methodist, whatever, your group would have a statement of investment um
8:27
Dennis Hammond: policies or a statement of responsible investing. And you could go to those guidelines and it would help you articulate your faith metrics. The USCCB has the socially responsible investing guidelines. And the Vatican has a separate group
8:46
Dennis Hammond: called Mensrum Bonum, which is Latin for good measure from Luke. 6, 38. So the notion here is we start with a robust group of three databases that provide us hundreds of screens, and then we narrow it down to your
9:06
Dennis Hammond: particular guidelines, uh, whatever faith those are, and then we customize that to your particular guidelines. institution. So not every Protestant conservative uh follows the exact same guidelines. Not every Catholic follows the exact same
9:26
Dennis Hammond: guidelines, even though they have the US C C B guidelines to follow, they don't all follow them. So we try to customize this to uh to your particular faith needs. Mm-hmm.
9:39
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Okay, so you were talking um about the
9:44
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): development of AI and the paper, the encyclical that the Pope just published, and um I I do want to talk a little bit about that because everyone is there's a lot of uh questions that are swirling about in society about what the implications are of this uh development of this new technology, data centers. uh which you know
10:04
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): people are concerned about for the physical infrastructure, for raising costs of utilities potentially, and you know um how much water use it's going to require and and there's uh concerns that are expressed about what that means for uh income inequality for for you know for those that think that it's gonna be worse for
10:24
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): for the poor. Um And so the the Pope wrote this encyclical um and discussed some of those issues. Let's let's talk about that a bit. Um I I know that um you have uh read that piece uh it took took a little while probably to get through and uh
10:43
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): um I I uh you know probably didn't read it as as carefully as you but I did take the opportunity to read it because I was uh it was a topic 'cause I was interested in. But what's what are some of the takeaways? Um and and then I want to talk about how that would it then potentially apply to someone if they're investing. But at at a high level, what were your takeaways in kind
11:03
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): of going through that?
11:04
Dennis Hammond: The what what we're seeing is the difference between Pope Leo's Rerum Novarum, which was new things.
11:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): He was
11:14
Dennis Hammond: talking
11:15
Dennis Hammond: about the new things being the Industrial Revolution and the concern that the Industrial Revolution would take jobs away from people. The notion in Catholic faith, Catholic social teaching is uh each human has a certain intrinsic human dignity, and that comes from work, comes from the ability to
11:35
Dennis Hammond: earn a living and to earn a a decent living to enable him to ha or her to have a job, I mean to have a a house, a family, and so forth. With Magnifica Humanitas, the concern was a different new things. That's why we signed exactly 135 years to the day. The new thing here is the
11:55
Dennis Hammond: new thing of artificial intelligence or the digital revolution, which again is a concern that machines will take away the livelihood of human beings. We've already seen uh the factory floors, uh the concern that robots will take over factory floors, but
12:15
Dennis Hammond: now we're also seeing the concern that robots will take over medicine, radiology, ideology, law, um, any number of white white-collar collar jobs that can be that can be done with uh with intelligence and with that kind of skill, these large language models
12:35
Dennis Hammond: can uh can outperform us across a variety of of of um metrics. So what Pope Leo XIV said was we have to guard the dignity of the human being. We have to ensure that the human being is not seen as just a
12:55
Dennis Hammond: step in the process, a clog in the wheel. The bigger concern with Ray Rum Novarum was that machines were going to take over people's jobs. With Magnifica Humanitas, the concern is people will become machines. This is the transhumanism, the post.
13:14
Dennis Hammond: post-humanism concerns.
13:23
Dennis Hammond: But um but it is something that is perceivable on the horizon. So back to what is he what did he want to do? If Pope Leo the XIV Fourteenth wanted to ensure that we think about um
13:39
Dennis Hammond: this AI in terms of does it help humanity? Are we simply building a tower of Babel to God and trying to exalt ourselves to be like God to get smarter and smarter? Or are we trying to build something that the walls of Jerusalem where we all are constructing
13:58
Dennis Hammond: our part to do a to build a better humanity? And that's his key question. Which are we trying to do? If it's the self-will, self-love, uh, Saint Augustine says that's that's the opposite of the love of God from City of God. So
14:18
Dennis Hammond: um that's where we're that's what we're struggling with. GD.
14:22
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, and one of the issues that as is these conversations about what the ultimate goal is of artificial intelligence and alignment is one of the terms that you hear over and over again. And it it just begs the question what are we aligning AI with? What is the source of ultimate goal
14:42
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that you're trying to achieve? What are you trying to avoid? Um, it does have some analogies to what you're trying to do in the in investment. space and aligning someone's portfolio to their their um to their beliefs and their values. But um I I think if you're aligning the whole system of artificial
15:02
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): intelligence to uh somebody who has one set of beliefs, it might not line up with what someone else's beliefs will be. And that is
15:12
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): perhaps concerning.
15:14
Dennis Hammond: It is concerning.
15:18
Dennis Hammond: Is that these machines, this artificial intelligence, at the end of the day, has to be aligned with preserving humanity and enhancing humanity. Um
15:30
Dennis Hammond: that's why they call their safety officer the chief alignment officer. So over the weekend you you saw this one guy quit. uh anthropic saying that we're going to reach artificial uh general intelligence or artificial superintelligence in a relatively short period of time and there was a ten percent
15:50
Dennis Hammond: chance that when we get to s artificial superintelligence, these machines will destroy us. And so the media said, What a goof. And they called his boss. the chief alignment officer at Anthropic and said, This is what this guy said who just quit. What do you think? He said, Well, I agree with
16:10
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): him.
16:11
Dennis Hammond: So the the alignment people uh are trying to make sure that we don't let this get out of control. It doesn't move faster than we can control it. You saw the paper over the weekend by uh Darien, who wrote on the pace
16:31
Dennis Hammond: of this technology and trying to slow it down because once we get to so we have artificial intelligence now, and the machines are a lot smarter than I am. When we get to artificial general intelligence, they're smarter than most everybody.
16:49
Dennis Hammond: And we have recurrent. recursive learning. At that point, the machines build their build their next generation themselves. So recursive learning means AGI is building ASI, artificial superintelligence. The way Musk explains it, artificial superintelligence is
17:08
Dennis Hammond: AI that's smarter than the combination of all people on the planet.
17:14
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): And the
17:15
Dennis Hammond: the question is, back to your point, well, when we get to that point, what is this a ASI cat gonna want to do? What if he decides that he that
17:28
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
17:28
Dennis Hammond: know he really wants a better ecology and human beings are Things kind of in the way? What if he has no ulterior motive? He's not irritated by
17:38
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the head.
17:39
Dennis Hammond: with mankind. It's just he doesn't care about it. He's just like, you know, we we might not we're more concerned about keeping our garden than the squirrels. So we'll get rid of them or the rabbits. We're we'll try to keep our garden. If he decides that artificial superintelligence that we're the squirrels and
17:58
Dennis Hammond: rabbits that are getting into his cabbage, he might take steps. that we wouldn't like. So that's the notion. Uh and
18:08
Dennis Hammond: I I find Pope Leo's paper just to be um
18:13
Dennis Hammond: really uh it it's surprisingly timely, isn't it?
18:19
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah, I I
18:21
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I think personally I'm kind of of two minds when it comes to all of those issues. On the one hand
18:27
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): I just am always skeptical when we're heading into an election season that this is all just uh, you know, a lot of it is driven by politics. Um, and and um I I I believe that that is probably to some degree the case here. But the other side of it is, you know, to the to the point of alignment, and when you're creating an artificial
18:47
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): intelligence model and you're determining uh and you're tuning the model for truth, what you tune it is going to be a reflection of the people that are doing the tuning. And so if you're creating what's super intelligence, it's going to be a magnification of the people that told it what was the right answer. And and so that's
19:07
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that is the like that's the part where I'm you know, I said I'm of two minds. Yes, it's political, but this is also something that I think is uh rightly criticized and it uh I'm glad that uh you know the Pope
19:19
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
19:19
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): called out the sort of magnification of the transhumanists as sort of is is this are we really trying to get past humans? 'Cause if that's the case, that could be a problem.
19:30
Dennis Hammond: It could be a terrible problem. Um, especially with post posthumanism, humanism, which blurs or dissolves the the lines between humans and machines. Um that sounds so much like science fiction, but when you think about it, this all sounds like science fiction. You know, I
19:49
Dennis Hammond: remember years ago, I don't even know how long it is, uh, when we were talking about this new thing that was gonna come into place called the internet. There was a lot of concern about that, which turned out to not be a big deal. Now there's a lot of concern about AI. And to your point, it is it is
20:08
Dennis Hammond: um
20:10
Dennis Hammond: concerning that the three main owners of these systems are talking about how they should work together to slow this down. Uh and they sound pretty fearful, which is in
20:24
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
20:25
Dennis Hammond: know infusing a lot of fear into the system. And one wonders why they would want to do that. These are smart guys. Um at the same and so that's why Mr. Trump said, Would you cut it out, please? We don't need any more doom and gloom about all this.
20:41
Dennis Hammond: His concern is China, because China is not slowing down, and he does not want China to create the first ASI because one once once that happens uh the game's over uh it to s to a certain extent. So back to the paper. What we tried to do in the paper
21:01
Dennis Hammond: was was take what what Poplio has said and create uh a map to the US C C B guidelines and to the Minstrom Bonum guidelines, the Vatican screening guidelines and come up with what new screens should we be thinking about? What new corporate engagement should we be
21:21
Dennis Hammond: thinking about?
21:22
Dennis Hammond: And that I think is the real takeaway from the paper. It's easy to read the paper and get the gist of it. It's more difficult to read the paper and say, okay, what does it mean means in the sense of what should we be screening now? As you've already said, we can't screen out every company that uses AI because there'd be nothing left to invest in except
21:42
Dennis Hammond: Carmel's and um the ice cream folks, and they probably use it somewhere.
21:48
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Are they the ones that have Fudgy the Whale? Remember Fudgy the Whale?
21:52
Dennis Hammond: I don't know. We my granddaughter and I stopped there after school often. But um the uh
21:58
Dennis Hammond: the notion here is we've gotta we've gotta figure out what screens are different. Yeah, I'll give you a good example. Uh one of the things that can s that concerns the Pope and people that are thoughtful about this is the elimination of jobs. Um whether alg algorithmically, uh, you know, just an an
22:18
Dennis Hammond: algorithm running the HR department, which decides who's gonna get hired or decides what credit you're gonna get or decides whether you're gonna get a home. loan or not. And there's not a person involved, it's a machine. We already have this to some extent. I'm sure your Experian credit score is done by a machine. It's that you know,
22:38
Dennis Hammond: Bob is not sitting down in the basement somewhere thinking, Well, gee, whiz, you know, Ryan did buy this car. No, I don't think so. It's it's all being done, but at scale, this becomes a bigger and bigger problem. Uh similarly, we we don't want to get to the point where we're just all of us are
22:58
Dennis Hammond: are losing our our jobs. And I I hear that from Mr. Musk. You know, you hear from Mr. Musk there's no reason to go to college. There's no reason to go to the most elite colleges. Why not? Because I don't care how small. smart you are, you won't be smart enough.
23:18
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): But
23:18
Dennis Hammond: that's his notion. And I don't care how much education you have, you won't have enough. Uh those are really concerning notions.
23:28
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Yeah. Yeah.
23:29
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um yeah,
23:30
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): that's the they're all really complicated issues, and
23:35
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you
23:35
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): could see how it would
23:37
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): be
23:37
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): issues that would impact.
23:39
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): people who are investing in different ways. In other words, what someone says is, I don't want to invest in this company. Another person might say, No, I'm okay with that. I want to invest in, but I don't want to invest in this company, and and have these different values that they want to customize. And and um
23:57
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): it
23:57
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): it it sounds similar in some ways to
24:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): you know
24:00
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): the the the trend from a few years ago that everyone
24:10
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): So am I right in in kind of making the analogy with faith-based screens? Is is it similar to that? And in in what ways might be uh might it be different?
24:19
Dennis Hammond: Well ESG was environmental, social, and governance. And that was essentially a secular approach to determine determining that
24:26
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): the event is a very important thing.
24:27
Dennis Hammond: who you wanted to invest with and who you didn't.
24:31
Dennis Hammond: Faith-based has some overlap with ESG, but primarily it is faith-based and not secular in nature. So we wouldn't think of uh faith-based investing in the same way that you might think of ESG. ESG has become associated with woke and over the last several
24:51
Dennis Hammond: years has fallen out of favor for the most part. Although governance is still important and the environment is still important. But the the S part, the social part, was often used in ways that that were was really harmful to the company. And we're trying not to do that. So you you mentioned a a key
25:10
Dennis Hammond: word, customize. No one's people's faiths are not. all the same. Institutions don't see it exactly the same. So the the important point is to help them articulate what is important to you. Is it is it important to you to i uh is gambling as important as
25:30
Dennis Hammond: pornography? Is um in vitro fertilization as important to you as contraceptives?
25:37
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Interesting. Now you you uh I asked you about ESG, and part of my reason for asking about that and and the fact that that has faded in popularity is my theory anyway. Part of the reason that it became popular and part of the reason that it's faded is because um it became popular because a lot of the
25:57
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): timing surrounded when we we went through a period of time of underperformance of many of the companies. that were screened. Energy companies in particular went through a period of of pretty steep underperformance. And it was easy to to say for an ESG company that, you know, for example, you want to get out of fossil fuels, and it it actually improves
26:17
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): your performance because these, you know, and these companies didn't do well. But then subsequent to that, energy companies performed much better. And those same mandates actually cause some underperformance. And I'm I'm oversimplifying. But I guess my question for you is when we have this sort of
26:37
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): trade-off of excluding companies, um, what what is the cost that people should expect in performance? Does it cause underperformance? Performance? Does it cause a lot of tracking error? And how do you solve for both both of those things?
26:49
Dennis Hammond: That's a great question. And I think it's a question that is keeping a lot of faith-based institutions from embracing this as they should.
26:59
Dennis Hammond: Let's break it into two parts. Does it create a tracking error and does it create underperformance? Because the answers are different. Anytime you take a group or an industry or a sector out of a benchmark, you're going to have a tracking error. It's going to behave differently. So the question isn't whether you're
27:19
Dennis Hammond: going to have a tracking error. It's whether the tracking error is going to be too high and whether it's going to lead to underperformance.
27:27
Dennis Hammond: It's not going to be too high. Typically we find tracking error for Catholic portfolios, for instance, to be 60 to 80 basis points plus or minus. But we expect that to be that could be either positive or negative. And over time, we expect it to wash out. Uh Protestant portfolios are about
27:47
Dennis Hammond: half that. They do not have the same number of screens generally. And so you might see 40 or 50 basis points. But again, uh, we expect it to wash out. Now, with respect to this performance issue. we actually undertook a study. I mentioned that at the top of the uh
28:07
Dennis Hammond: of the hour. Uh we undertook a study in the last 10 years. And we said, well, what if we actually used all the USCCB Catholic guidelines for the S P 500, the MSCI world, and ACUI XUS, those three major benchmarks. And
28:27
Dennis Hammond: we applied these the way you would. We applied them beginning um 40 quarters ago and excluded certain stocks, and then we rolled the uh performance forward one quarter and we redid the screening and excluded stocks and rolled it forward. In other words, an iterative process.
28:47
Dennis Hammond: So we came up with a real 40-quarter screen of um, and we determined what the performance of those screen portfolios was relative to the benchmarks. Interestingly, over that period, the basket of companies that were screened
29:07
Dennis Hammond: out did worse than the benchmarks. I didn't expect that. I mean, why would they? But they did over that particular period. They did actually substantially worse. I think they were like a third below the unscreened benchmarks as a basket of stocks.
29:33
Dennis Hammond: Uh, if you screened out those bad actors and then just market cap weighted your portfolios, and we calculated if you screened out the bad actors and instead of market cap weighting, you optimized them to lower the tracking error. In this particular period, market cap weighting outperformed the benchmarks. Um, I think
29:53
Dennis Hammond: it's because you are excluding some folks other than the mag seven and you're adding back their excluded weighting
30:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): to
30:00
Dennis Hammond: among others the mag seven who didn't did wonderfully well over this period. In the optimized portfolios, the performance was within twenty basis points of the pitch mark. So the the conclusion that we came up with was you uh in this particular period, a Catholic could have followed their
30:20
Dennis Hammond: faith and had no material impairment of their performance. And we believe that will carry forward.
30:27
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): If
30:27
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): someone wanted to read that paper, is it publicly available somewhere?
30:31
Dennis Hammond: Yeah, it's on our website. And we hope the Magnifica Humanitas will be on the website uh uh soon as well. We've got, I think, um got five papers uh that we've written and published now on investment management, and the um the AI papers are six.
30:49
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Okay. All right. Final question. for you, Dennis.
30:52
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): Um,
30:52
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): and this is a curveball that I didn't tell you was coming, so uh it's always fun to throw a curveball at the end. Um
31:00
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): one
31:00
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): of the things that I've gotten the habit of doing when I have uh a new guest on the podcast in particular is I'm always looking for new books to read. And so I'm gonna ask you, as you kind of think back to something that you've read over the last year or two, or maybe something that you're considering reading. give us a book recommendation for viewers of the podcast. And again, it doesn't have to be related to what we've
31:20
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): been talking about today, just something interesting that you've come across.
31:24
Dennis Hammond: That's a fascinating question. Um
31:28
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I'm actually writing a
31:29
Dennis Hammond: book right now called Where Your Treasure Is. And as a result of that, I've got some 22 books that I've got on my bookcase that I have not gotten through. through. Um
31:41
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
31:41
Dennis Hammond: will tell you the book that I read the most
31:44
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): uh
31:45
Dennis Hammond: because I think they are the most important, and they are the gospels. I've read them over and over and over uh because I've trying to I've taken the position that
31:57
Unidentified speaker (UNKNOWN): I
31:58
Dennis Hammond: want to either be in this thing or not be in this thing. And if I'm gonna going to be in it, I better know what the requirements are. I better know what's expected of me. And so I started with, you know, as everybody does, the Gospels, Mark written first, probably
32:17
Dennis Hammond: written by John Mark, but as dictated by Peter and then Matthew, 10 or 15 years later. And 10 or 15 years after that, you have the Luke version who also wrote Acts, the only uh non-Jew who wrote books of the Bible, and finally a totally different book
32:37
Dennis Hammond: written by this guy, John, who just came at it from a totally different perspective. Uh those four books are fascinating, and they contain
32:51
Dennis Hammond: the elements of life. Uh you read those and you find
32:58
Dennis Hammond: you'll find answers to questions you didn't know were questions, and you'll find answers to questions you can't find anywhere else. So
33:07
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): well, that seems like a good place to uh leave our conversation. Dennis Hammond, thank you for joining us uh on this episode of the podcast. It's been a really interesting conversation. Thanks for the book recommendation. Um, and for all of you who have joined us for this episode of the First Trust RI podcast. Thank you for spending some time with us. We look forward to seeing you again next time.
33:26
Unidentified speaker (speaker_0): Take care, everyone.
This page was produced automatically: the audio was transcribed with nvidia/parakeet-tdt-0.6b-v3+sortformer-v2.1 and interpreted by Qwen3.6-35B-A3B-UD-IQ3_S.gguf. Transcription and interpretation can contain errors; always confirm against the original episode. Nothing here is investment advice.
All insights